Edward Guthmann
Select another critic »For 526 reviews, this critic has graded:
-
52% higher than the average critic
-
3% same as the average critic
-
45% lower than the average critic
On average, this critic grades 1 point higher than other critics.
(0-100 point scale)
Edward Guthmann's Scores
- Movies
- TV
| Average review score: | 67 | |
|---|---|---|
| Highest review score: | Thieves | |
| Lowest review score: | Book of Shadows: Blair Witch 2 | |
Score distribution:
-
Positive: 317 out of 526
-
Mixed: 155 out of 526
-
Negative: 54 out of 526
526
movie
reviews
-
- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- Edward Guthmann
It's a classy but downbeat spin on the most familiar of TV-movie formulas.- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- Edward Guthmann
The Olsens' precociousness and sitcom-style mugging grate at first, but I found myself warming to their movie in its last half - thanks mostly to Alley, a crackerjack physical comic who's incapable of a flat or colorless note.- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- Edward Guthmann
The Distinguished Gentleman isn't much of a movie - it's a mess, in fact. [04 Dec 1992]- San Francisco Chronicle
-
- Edward Guthmann
The film's aim -- to dazzle and inspire -- is sapped by Cruise's vein-popping, running-the-marathon performance.- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- Edward Guthmann
Takes a long time getting started and doesn't hit its stride until Danny starts coaching a team of fellow cons -- think "Bad News Bears," just nastier.- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- Edward Guthmann
Girl 6 is glossy, technically proficient and a glib waste of time. Lee and his screenwriter goof around with phone-sex rhetoric ("I wanna service your juicy kielbasa''), but that gets tired quickly.- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- Edward Guthmann
This is the downside of Roberts' giant success and her dazzling ability to charm: Every time she goes plain, as she did in the little-seen "Mary Reilly" and "Michael Collins," our princess simply fizzles.- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- Edward Guthmann
Larger Than Life isn't as bad as it sounds, mostly because Murray is so likable and fundamentally incapable of not being funny.- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- Edward Guthmann
A conspiracy tale of high-tech chicanery, Chain Reaction has better acting, better writing, more spectacular chase sequences and more genuine drama than all of this summer's blockbusters. It's also got Morgan Freeman, as good an actor as we have today, which easily qualifies it as the one action film you should see this summer if you see no other.- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- Edward Guthmann
They try to make Beverly adorable, and the movie comes off strained and dishonest as a result.- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- Edward Guthmann
Dredges up every cliche about druggy, obnoxious dreamers on the fringes of Hollywood and assumes that said cliches have the power to shock and surprise.- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- Edward Guthmann
It's a bitter pill to swallow, featuring a quartet of unsympathetic characters and an unrelenting air of misanthropy.- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- Edward Guthmann
Harmless enough, and its team of actors so frisky and enthusiastic that it manages to deliver a modicum of laughs despite itself.- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- Edward Guthmann
Unfortunately, Raising Cain is largely a retread of De Palma's vintage thrillers from the '70s -- an extended self-homage that makes you wonder if his imagination got frozen in 1980.- San Francisco Chronicle
-
- Edward Guthmann
What's lacking is an explanation for the relationship, and some insight into the origins of Rimbaud's art. The other big problem, aside from DiCaprio's twang, is his lack of chemistry with Thewlis. These are two fine actors, working in vastly different styles, who might as well be walking through different movies. At the end of the handsome, frustrating Total Eclipse, you'll be wondering who these two men were.- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- Edward Guthmann
If your tolerance for Branagh's shtick and Woody's narrowness of focus is as low as mine, you can take solace in the director's joke on himself.- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- Edward Guthmann
Plays like the cinematic equivalent of a paperback bodice- ripper with embossed type.- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- Edward Guthmann
Instead of defining and spoofing its period, its attitude and its social barometer, Leave It to Beaver just stumbles about in a bland, irony-deprived suburbia that denies the movie any juice or bite and renders the Cleaver family even duller than it was.- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- Edward Guthmann
Nasty to women, cruel to old people and tosses in a cardboard gay couple for gratuitous laughs. It's also got one of those annoying soundtracks that lays rock music right over the dialogue -- as if it wanted to distract us from it.- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- Edward Guthmann
It's beautifully shot by first-time feature director Antoine Fuqua, whose eye for sensual surfaces, deft camera moves and elegant framing was refined with commercials and music videos- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- Edward Guthmann
It sets up two or three dozen satirical targets, hits the mark occasionally, but has trouble maintaining an even satirical tone or satisfying pace. Dawber, too, is unappealing in the female lead -- definitely outclassed by Ritter. I'd wager Stay Tuned will die an early death at the box office and find its real life, appropriately enough, in home video. [15 Aug 1992, p.C3]- San Francisco Chronicle
-
- Edward Guthmann
The movie was written by Scott Yagemann, who taught seven years in the Los Angeles public- school system, and you can feel the rancor and bitterness he still carries.- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- Edward Guthmann
Too bad the plotting is jumbled, and the characters too numerous and undifferentiated.- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- Edward Guthmann
In a movie as hackneyed and as dull as Evolution, the small favors of Duchovny's performance stand out.- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- Edward Guthmann
An earnest, ponderous epic that tries desperately to say Something Important about disenfranchised blacks and their Afrikaans oppressors, but never does. [27 March 1992, p.D7]- San Francisco Chronicle
-
- Edward Guthmann
Consenting Adults is well-made, preposterous junk -- the kind of modestly effective thriller that delivers a modicum of thrills but insults its audience, over and over, to achieve that effect. [16 Oct 1992, p.C1]- San Francisco Chronicle
-
- Edward Guthmann
Down Periscope makes a surprisingly successful launch, with plenty of brisk one-liners and a promising set-up. But after that auspicious opening, it sinks.- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- Edward Guthmann
Sister Act 2 doesn't challenge Goldberg, but it's a marvelous showcase, nonetheless, for one of the screen's most likable personalities. [10 Dec 1993, p.C1]- San Francisco Chronicle
-
- Edward Guthmann
Handsome and sincere but slightly awkward in its combination of entertainment and evangelical boosterism.- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- Edward Guthmann
It's a perfect fit for Williams -- a hunk of slapstick, a dose of schmaltz -- and yet he can't save the film, which is overproduced, mechanical and resoundingly unfunny.- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- Edward Guthmann
Boyle isn't the first British or European filmmaker to make his obligatory zesty American road movie (apparently it's a dream for anyone raised on American cinema), but knowing that doesn't make A Life Less Ordinary any less tiring or its numerous pilferings any less obvious or annoying.- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- Edward Guthmann
As haunted-house thrillers go, Cold Creek Manor is more ludicrous than the average but at the same time more handsomely produced.- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- Edward Guthmann
It's a sad sight when two big- name stars sink this low, especially when their demoralization and embarrassment are right up on the screen. [24 Aug 1991, p.C3]- San Francisco Chronicle
-
- Edward Guthmann
An uneasy mixture of tragedy, satire, monster yarn and David Cronenberg creepiness, No Such Thing can't decide what it wants to be or how it needs to get there.- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- Edward Guthmann
The best scenes are the ones that Fox shares with Tamala Jones, Wendy Raquel Robinson and the full-figured Monique as her sassy girlfriends. There's a ripe, crackling spontaneity when these women get together.- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- Edward Guthmann
It's a bizarre hybrid: one part feminist screed, one part French art film and one part skin flick.- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- Edward Guthmann
Jingle wants to warm our hearts and establish Schwarzenegger as a family man -- but devotes so much time to goony violence and broad physical comedy that the last-reel schmaltz feels hollow and tacked-on.- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- Edward Guthmann
Pryce is very good, but Very Annie Mary is a bit too eager to please.- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- Edward Guthmann
Despite its posh trimmings, and Fiorentino's feline presence, Jade never rises above its limitations and never cloaks the fact that Eszterhas' dialogue and script are basically pulp -- minus the trashy fun that we've come to expect from the genre.- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- Edward Guthmann
Despite its technical defects and negligent production values, The Flip Side will probably appeal to a Filipino-American audience.- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- Edward Guthmann
It may smell awful from a distance, especially if you have low tolerance for lowbrow humor, but up close this yarn about an unlikely golf star is fairly painless.- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- Edward Guthmann
A white-trash burlesque that springs from the notion that people chasing each other in cars and doing stupid things in motels are inherently funny.- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- Edward Guthmann
Neutralizes these characters, makes them cute and one-dimensional like fluffy dolls.- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- Edward Guthmann
Granted, you don't expect much from a movie like this: azure seas and honey-dripped sunsets, perhaps, a little titillation and a few wicked laughs. But Robert Steadman's photography lacks the imagination of Almendros' work on The Blue Lagoon, and the rare erotic moments are no match for the dumbness of Leslie Stevens' script. [03 Aug 1991, p.C3]- San Francisco Chronicle
-
- Edward Guthmann
Campbell and Edwards work wonders with the rocky, wide-open Oregon landscape, but none of their periwinkle-blue skies and sparkling shots of whooping cranes in flight can compensate for a film that aims high, means well, and ultimately fails its audience. [20 May 1994]- San Francisco Chronicle
-
- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- Edward Guthmann
It's tremendously entertaining, and probably worthy of repeat viewings.- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- Edward Guthmann
Cynical to an extreme, it doesn't illustrate its points but blasts them at us -- in italics, boldface and capital letters.- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- Edward Guthmann
Might be a blast of ridiculous fun -- the way truly bad movies tend to be -- if it weren't so noxious and reprehensible.- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- Edward Guthmann
It isn't simple bad taste that Formula 51 deals in, but a total vacuum of feeling.- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- Edward Guthmann
A mean-spirited comedy...that steals the rampaging-psycho-chick formula from ``Fatal Attraction'' and tries to make it funny.- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- Edward Guthmann
Knows its audience and doesn't stint on the flatulence jokes, poop jokes, leg-humping dogs and moments of homo-panic.- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- Edward Guthmann
What we have here isn't a disaster, exactly, but a very handsomely produced let-down.- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- Edward Guthmann
It's an interesting technique -- the blurring of reality and "movies" -- but Korine's objective is so narrow and mean, and his viewpoint so colored by smug, adolescent condescension, that Gummo comes off like a mean-spirited prank.- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- Edward Guthmann
A schlocky thriller that might appeal to less discriminating members of the mall crowd.- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- Edward Guthmann
This is a sloppy hash of a movie, poorly directed and plotted in a way that looks as if it were improvised on the spot.- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- Edward Guthmann
Big, opulent and frequently wretched, Pinocchio is so bad that its American distributor, Miramax, opened it on Christmas Day with scant advertising and no advance press screening.- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review
-
- Edward Guthmann
It's impossible to imagine why Lions Gate, the indie distributor that released "Monster's Ball," would bother with this garbage.- San Francisco Chronicle
- Read full review