Alan Scherstuhl
Select another critic »For 727 reviews, this critic has graded:
-
59% higher than the average critic
-
3% same as the average critic
-
38% lower than the average critic
On average, this critic grades 3 points higher than other critics.
(0-100 point scale)
Alan Scherstuhl's Scores
- Movies
- TV
| Average review score: | 69 | |
|---|---|---|
| Highest review score: | A Bread Factory Part Two: Walk With Me a While | |
| Lowest review score: | Saving Lincoln | |
Score distribution:
-
Positive: 447 out of 727
-
Mixed: 233 out of 727
-
Negative: 47 out of 727
727
movie
reviews
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
The mayhem is hypnotic, scabrous, scarifying, unpredictable, astonishing, dispiriting, repetitious, clearly both amoral and immoral, and by the end, a little dull. Even over the short running time, you can feel your humanity’s diminishment.- Village Voice
- Posted Jan 18, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Liquid Sky has always been caught smack between delirious curio, avant-garde put-on, exploitation cheapie, and naive masterpiece.- Village Voice
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
It's smart in surprising ways, daring in a few minor ones, moving in the right ones.- Village Voice
- Posted Nov 24, 2015
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Sure, all the studios offer anymore are big, dumb adventure spectacles, but that's not a knock against the achievement of this one, which at least parades wonders before us, not the least being the greatest dragon in the history of movies.- Village Voice
- Posted Dec 9, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
The Widers opt for much footage of the still-empty house itself, inside and out, shot by gently gliding cameras. This conveys an appropriate lonely stillness, a sense of a soul wandering a static world, especially in early scenes, but by the end the footage seems repetitious – yes, we’ve nosed around this sad doorway before.- Village Voice
- Posted Mar 29, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Even in this glossy pulp fictionalization, Marshall is filled above all else with truths that still demand telling.- Village Voice
- Posted Oct 12, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Village Voice
- Posted Aug 19, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Deadpool might even stand as one of the strongest and most inventive films of the high-early-late superhero baroque — if we could just turn off its built-in commentary track.- Village Voice
- Posted Feb 7, 2016
- Read full review
-
- Village Voice
- Posted May 14, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Since it’s hard to buy the character, it’s hard to buy the story, no matter how good Macdonald is.- Village Voice
- Posted Jul 26, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
The directors plant a camera in front of Roth and get him talking. To smooth over edits, they show us book covers and old photos—Roth was dashing, charming, a little dangerous, one of his college friends tells us, but she doesn't need to say it. It's manifest, and it's still true. The film is especially recommended to anyone who thinks they hate him.- Village Voice
- Posted Mar 12, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
There’s no way around it: The whole, here, is a mess. Even with the extra minutes, the film seems unfinished, the connections among its disparate scenarios vague and arbitrary. But outside of the espionage-movie and poor-lonely-director-dude-can’t-stop-getting-laid interludes, many of those scenarios unsettle, provoke (intentional) laughter, or prove engrossing, especially in their doublings and mysteries.- Village Voice
- Posted Mar 22, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Like The Conjuring and the many immersive spook-house thrillers inspired by it, Origin of Evil demands and rewards attentiveness, inviting scrutiny of its frames, study of its negative space.- Village Voice
- Posted Oct 22, 2016
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Ultimately, the film's wearying qualities pay off both as verisimilitude — you do feel like you've been through something — and as awe-inspiring history, making visceral art out of a global migration.- Village Voice
- Posted Sep 15, 2015
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
This lit-doc travelogue gains in power, insight, and urgency as it journeys.- Village Voice
- Posted Oct 27, 2016
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Cutter Hodierne's gorgeous, harrowing debut feature, Fishing Without Nets, doesn't just ask you to feel a bit for Somali pirates, as Captain Phillips did -- Hodierne puts you in their shoes.- Village Voice
- Posted Sep 23, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
The Visitor is a mess, but a revelatory one, both a ripe, bizarre thriller and a fascinating example of how filmmakers first responded to the interstellar millions stirred up by Spielberg and George Lucas: by thieving the good bits.- Village Voice
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
It's not news, of course, that it's a terrible thing to extinguish a life, but it's a relief, when the shoot-'em-ups of Summer Movie Season are bearing down on us, to see a film that regards killing with pained awe. Wladyka's hands are clean.- Village Voice
- Posted Mar 31, 2015
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
The finely realized Annette Bening performance at the center of Paul McGuigan’s Film Stars Don’t Die in Liverpool doesn’t power the movie. Bening is subject to its rhythms rather than vice versa, and her blood seems to pump faster than McGuigan’s, whose film is listless and thinly conceived.- Village Voice
- Posted Dec 31, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
It's all shocking, of course, but it also often looks staged and performed rather than merely observed.- Village Voice
- Posted May 18, 2016
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Sutton's Memphis framed in fascinating layers -- leaves and tree limbs, wig shops and overgrown gravel roads. It's a movie of a place and a character rather than about them.- Village Voice
- Posted Sep 2, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
It's no news that a filmmaker's debut is mostly 90 minutes of a couple kids gabbing on the streets of Brooklyn. But writer/director Jay Dockendorf's buoyant, tragic, richly textured walking-and-talking job Naz & Maalik exhibits none of the shambling narcissism that so often characterizes such projects.- Village Voice
- Posted Jan 24, 2016
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
The clock, Cogsworth, serves as a perfect metaphor for the production itself: The movie’s just as poky and lumbering as he is while huffing up the staircase to escort Belle to her bedroom.- Village Voice
- Posted Mar 11, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
The movie's not just good but moving, funny and true to the way people actually live in hard-times America.- Village Voice
- Posted Mar 17, 2016
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Monsters University feels not like the work of artists eager to express something but like that of likable pros whose existence depends on getting a rise out the kids. It's like the scares Sully and Mike spring on those sleeping tykes: technically impressive but a job un-anchored to anything more meaningful.- Village Voice
- Posted Jun 18, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Village Voice
- Posted Jun 15, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Well observed and sometimes hilarious, Punching Henry stands as a better film than The Comedian, but many fewer people will see it. That might be its truest punch line.- Village Voice
- Posted Feb 22, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Informative and workmanlike, Antarctic Edge is more a bad-news rundown than one of the meditative masterpieces of the genre- Village Voice
- Posted Apr 14, 2015
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
The film is most illuminating on the prehistory of Land Art.- Village Voice
- Posted Jan 5, 2016
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
We Are Mari Pepa is a sweaty, urgent, beautifully honest bliss out.- Village Voice
- Posted Aug 12, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
The film is novel-rich, so bristling with life that you might not notice how familiar it is in its contours.- Village Voice
- Posted Sep 8, 2015
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Thorpe offers charming, intimate glimpses of his life, including memorable chats with friends and experts, and he's adept at drawing winning quotes from interview subjects — one of the most moving moments comes from George Takei.- Village Voice
- Posted Jul 7, 2015
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
The film is brisk and fascinating, ultimately moving, but also less rich than it might have been.- Village Voice
- Posted Sep 21, 2016
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Matthew VanDyke, Point and Shoot's hero/subject, can't forget the mediated, imitative nature of his adventures even when he has dedicated himself to a grand cause.- Village Voice
- Posted Oct 28, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Disconnect might play better a decade from now, when it's more clearly a compendium of contemporary fears rather than some dire expression of them.- Village Voice
- Posted Apr 9, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
The film is handsomely mounted, traditional in its scenecraft, superbly acted, and much less ham-handed than you might expect from a historical drama about a great man’s great moment.- Village Voice
- Posted Sep 21, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Dark Touch, like much of the best horror, works the fears that connect to real life.- Village Voice
- Posted Sep 21, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
The old footage — newsreels, scraps of home movies — is entrancing, and even those familiar details eventually accrete with the fresh ones into something grand and stirring, especially near the conclusion.- Village Voice
- Posted Mar 11, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
The more typical approach transforms the material, and not for the better—rather than a revelation about how it feels to live her life, this feels like a document of what that life might look like as a conventional, often pokey movie.- Village Voice
- Posted Aug 13, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
This stellar, incisive slice-of-life doc centers on the kind of crowd-pleasing competition story that lures in audiences and then lays bare heartsick truths about small-town America today.- Village Voice
- Posted Nov 5, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Sorrentino, as always, invests his scenarios with a feeling and beauty that transcends the dreary specifics- Village Voice
- Posted Dec 4, 2015
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Demme has crafted yet another superb document of musicians at work, one as much about creation—and the sources of inspiration—as it is about performance. A wonderful film, as in, it's full of wonders.- Village Voice
- Posted Oct 15, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Will Allen's sunny gut-punch cult exposé Holy Hell plays like a thriller, all right, with a darkness edging slowly over its swimsuit revelry, but Allen never cheats in the interest of suspense.- Village Voice
- Posted May 24, 2016
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
What are the concerns of coherent storytelling or in-depth documentation when all of these good boys and girls — yes they are! — are leaping and licking and tail-wagging and just being the best?- Village Voice
- Posted Aug 28, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
The film’s lead is far and away its least interesting character, and Damon dials back every watt of his charisma or wit.- Village Voice
- Posted Dec 20, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Cheadle's tender eyes and scraped-raw whisper prove reason enough for Davis fans to give Miles Ahead a go: Just often enough, I thought, "Holy shit, this is what a day with Miles might feel like."- Village Voice
- Posted Mar 30, 2016
- Read full review
-
- Village Voice
- Posted Jul 9, 2015
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Serge Bozon's smart, surprising, marvelously realized French crime-and-sex police drama/comedy distinguishes itself with trenchant plotting, inspired framing, and performances that honor true human feeling even as they lunge into the screwball.- Village Voice
- Posted Dec 9, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Village Voice
- Posted Oct 7, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Even in its longueurs Young Bodies yields beauty and surprise, and there are inklings of some grand conception, even among scenes that feel haphazardly chosen.- Village Voice
- Posted Feb 24, 2015
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Gere jabbers amusingly, and there's something touching in his Norman's persistence.- Village Voice
- Posted Apr 13, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Once it gets going, it's fine, a somewhat scattered précis of the life and accomplishment of one of the 20th century's towering musicians, activists, and curiosities.- Village Voice
- Posted Jul 29, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
The filmmakers observe rather than interview or investigate, and much of the film is footage of actual church-sanctioned exorcisms.- Village Voice
- Posted Oct 19, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
The movie is fascinating in its approach to legal arguments, forensic evidence, and the uses and abuses of history — but, like the courtroom at its center, it doesn't have much feel for the feels.- Village Voice
- Posted Sep 29, 2016
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Katz stages the contests with infectious energy... Too bad the last half hour feels like Katz is rubbing our face in the several turds he shows us, reminding us that people are awful. Of course they are. What else do you have to tell us?- Village Voice
- Posted Mar 18, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
That Guy Dick Miller is a cheery and likable film, one that bops along the surface of its story with lots of interviews, too-quick film clips, and spazzy-quirky-tootling music meant to let us know how fun all this is.- Village Voice
- Posted Mar 31, 2015
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
The biggest suspense: As everything gets worse for everyone, will this consummate director's outraged worldview afford anyone any pity? At first you'll seethe — then your heart will ache.- Village Voice
- Posted Jan 13, 2015
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Davis holds forth memorably on the histories of country, blues, and rock 'n' roll. (He played with Chuck Berry.) But neither he nor Accidental Courtesy has much time to consider the scene with the BLM activists, who, in the film's schematic presentation, get depicted as something like a Klan equivalent — just less friendly.- Village Voice
- Posted Jan 5, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
The film — which is nowhere near as interesting as LaBeouf’s performance — is hopelessly reductive about its subjects’ psychology even as it mocks the press of 1980 for being reductive about its subjects’ psychology.- Village Voice
- Posted Apr 12, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Field can't make it all make sense, but she does make it diverting, even pleasurable.- Village Voice
- Posted Mar 9, 2016
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
McAvoy is impressive as he switches personalities, but never scary or moving; the script gives him many chances to exhibit virtuosity but too few for soulfulness.- Village Voice
- Posted Jan 17, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
The comic scenes arc into bleakness, and the bleak ones often collapse back into comedy.- Village Voice
- Posted Oct 8, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
This minute-by-minute rundown is priceless history, alive with the anxious textures of American life right then, a film that in twenty years will reward attentive viewing. It’s also, for many of us alive in the now, probably too much too soon, the tearing open of wounds that only are just starting to scab over.- Village Voice
- Posted Nov 1, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
There’s something dazzling in the audacity of applying the most conventional and conservative techniques to the portrayal of radical thinkers and thoughts. That frisson keeps the movie interesting without quite jolting it to life.- Village Voice
- Posted Feb 22, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Howard stamps the material in some welcome ways: The scruffy breeziness of his early comedies (Night Shift, Splash, Gung Ho) suits the hit-and-miss script, by Lawrence and Jonathan Kasdan. Here’s a Star Wars that’s more appealing when its characters are chatting than when they’re pew-pewing.- Village Voice
- Posted May 16, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
The filmmakers aren't arguing that mass-media tech leads to fascism, but they suggest, with some lightness, that our interconnectedness certainly facilitates it. But Dreams Rewired is no polemic, and it never mocks the past.- Village Voice
- Posted Dec 17, 2015
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
The movie sugars up Robinson's story, and like too many period pieces it summons some vague idea of a warmer, simpler past by bathing everything in thick amber light, as if each scene is one of those preserved mosquitoes that begat the monsters of Jurassic Park.- Village Voice
- Posted Apr 9, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
The horror's a long time coming, but Goldthwait and company make the waiting worth it.- Village Voice
- Posted Jun 3, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
All that prickly inner conflict Ruffalo is so adept at suggesting? Cheery Begin Again wants none of it, offering instead lots of scenes of two characters we don't believe could ever exist arguing about authenticity in pop music.- Village Voice
- Posted Jun 24, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
For all its familiarity and rote nastiness, the film's sharply crafted and quite promising.- Village Voice
- Posted Nov 11, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
It's part caper comedy, part revenge tale, and part glorious whopper.- Village Voice
- Posted May 27, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Far from a film about sharks sharking and love not working out, this About Last Night revels in friendship, fidelity, and something too rarely seen in the movies today: the idea that being young and black in Los Angeles can be glorious.- Village Voice
- Posted Feb 14, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
It's to the film's credit that truth-telling here looks as hard as it does noble, and that the Holocaust is not treated just as a suspense story's macguffin.- Village Voice
- Posted Sep 29, 2015
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Rubble Kings, an impassioned examination of New York's gang culture of the late 1970s, isn't just a fascinating piece of urban history. It's also a challenge to common assumptions about that culture, and a testament to the power of organization within a community.- Village Voice
- Posted Jun 16, 2015
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
With high spirits and great tenderness, Dalio and his actors stir up what might be the greatest of youthful feelings: that as you get to know someone new, someone whose thinking rhymes with yours, you're also becoming ever more yourself.- Village Voice
- Posted Feb 9, 2016
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
That patience of Reichardt's, and her dedication to showing us exclusively the things that we must see, makes the scenes of preparation — boat parking, fertilizer buying — hypnotic and suspenseful and practical all at once.- Village Voice
- Posted May 27, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Any cheapjack action movie can get a crowd to cheer at its shock kills. It’s the best ones that persuade us that there’s a clear chain-of-events physical logic at play — that find suspense in one action leading inevitably to another.- Village Voice
- Posted Jan 31, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Lea Thompson’s first film as a director — a brisk, breezy, sharp-elbowed, sexually frank, occasionally shout-y, often hilarious comedy — stars the performer’s own daughters and plays like both a raucous family party and an urgently necessary corrective.- Village Voice
- Posted Jun 14, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Like first sex, writer-director Maggie Carey's debut feature, The To Do List, is quick and messy, fitfully pleasurable, full of promise but not quite adept at getting everyone off.- Village Voice
- Posted Jul 22, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
The filmmakers have gotten extraordinary access to Mohamed and ravaged Somalia... But it's disappointing that they did not capture more scenes of Mohamed's wife and her family, who in the end are the ones who make the most momentous decision.- Village Voice
- Posted Sep 30, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Simply put, the clockwork heist that Ocean’s 8 promises (and, by its end, dazzles with) limits the film’s ability to offer what you might actually want from it: the chance to relish this cast.- Village Voice
- Posted Jun 5, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
El Angel is a crime spree as improvised reverie, one with a subject who is as quick to give away his loot as the director is to make the subtext explicit.- L.A. Weekly
- Posted Nov 8, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Everyone involved at last seems to understand that the mode here is comic. Previous entries suffered from self-important glumness that gummed up the fun whenever the cars weren’t racing.- Village Voice
- Posted May 17, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
If you somehow manage to stay dry-eyed through the concert numbers, the end should set you bawling.- Village Voice
- Posted Jun 27, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
The film itself is more a record than a narrative: proof to the future that, yeah, we knew.- Village Voice
- Posted Jan 19, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Those more devoted to the genre can debate whether Matthew Vaughn's Kingsman is the best comic-book movie of the last few years. What's beyond argument, however, is that Vaughn has whipped up the most interesting one, the only to make ferocious, unsettling art out of the great contradiction of superheroic fantasy: jolly do-goodism and its brutalizing sadism.- Village Voice
- Posted Feb 10, 2015
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
The movie — based on Les Standiford’s novel — is pleasantly simpleminded, often assembled from parts of other movies.- Village Voice
- Posted Nov 21, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
At first the stakes are as light yet rich as Sentaro's pancakes; then come marvelous cine-essays on bean-soaking and paste-prepping, plus — in the film's tragedy-tinged final third — a change-of-seasons montage for the ages.- Village Voice
- Posted Mar 17, 2016
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
The movie — at first scrappy and strange but an increasingly tough sit as it goes — never fixes its gaze on any singularly compelling idea.- Village Voice
- Posted Dec 8, 2016
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
From moment to moment, this Last Five Years is a robust entertainment, often stirring, sad, and funny.- Village Voice
- Posted Feb 10, 2015
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Newell's film doesn't supplant Lean's, of course. The yearning is more vague, the gloom less consummate. But it's the best since, rich in feeling and dark beauty, alive with the superior scenecraft, chatter, and imagination of the most beloved of novelists.- Village Voice
- Posted Nov 5, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Firth is all panicked reserve in the role of Crowhurst, and Rachel Weisz invests the familiar stay-at-home role with antsy, agonized spirit as the wife of the doomed man, facing the truth that her family’s lives will never be what they once were.- L.A. Weekly
- Posted Nov 29, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
It works, kind of, despite its broadness, its obviousness, and its howlingly awful opening.- Village Voice
- Posted Feb 17, 2015
- Read full review
-
- Village Voice
- Posted Feb 2, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Especially in its superior first hour, Goosebumps has a loose comic rhythm at odds with what we see in effects-heavy would-be blockbuster junk like Pan.- Village Voice
- Posted Oct 13, 2015
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
That relaxed joyfulness is balanced by the challenges of the states: weight gain, being stereotyped, the emphasis on fun with friends rather than preparation for all the life ahead. You can see, over the school year Wang documents, the kids’ certainties about what matters most eroding.- Village Voice
- Posted Mar 15, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Village Voice
- Posted Jun 21, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
It's a sweet, sympathetic film, based on wise and memorable material and featuring inspired performances from its teen cast, but it simply collapses.- Village Voice
- Posted Apr 7, 2015
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
The comedy's too broad to take the characters seriously, and the vibe is breezily aimless, a mistake in a story about anxious waiting.- Village Voice
- Posted Aug 27, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
It's all sickeningly accomplished, with incidents so tense and audacious that you might not have the headspace to wonder until afterwards, "Hey, wait, what was the point in grinding us through so many terrifying minutes of that?"- Village Voice
- Posted Aug 9, 2016
- Read full review