Critic Reviews
- Critic score
- Publication
- By date
-
Wednesday season two is an absolute delight… though she’d kill us if she heard us say it.
-
Mystery-wise, the show offers the same kind of thrills that made season 1 so watchable. .... After finishing episode 4, I immediately wanted to learn what would happen in Part 2, which will have to deal with a major cliffhanger and a lot of blood spilled.
-
Based on Part 1, “Wednesday” has found its stride and loosened its grip on boxing itself into the mold (or in some cases, coffin) of YA television, with the help of strong performances and more spooky, delectable production design.
-
In addition to breaking from teen drama stereotypes, leaving out a bothersome love triangle also makes room for more interesting character dynamics to flourish and deepen. Season 2 of Wednesday zeroes in on two other complicated relationships that were merely skirted around earlier.
-
Wednesday continues to be a funny, scary delight because of Ortega’s performance and because Burton has gone all in with the nightmarish imagery written by Gough, Millar and the show’s writers.
-
A hugely elaborate and wildly entertaining thing that happens very quickly and at great budgetary expense only to be promptly buried under the demands of a more immediately pressing plot strand.
-
This show is mayhem in the best way possible, finally living up to the unparalleled popularity that season 1 (perhaps unfairly) earned.
-
Wednesday’s zingers aren’t as wickedly sharp as they once were. And because we know she’s going to be annoyed by her classmates, such as perky werewolf roommate Enid (Emma Myers), the dynamic is not as morbidly charming. The bond between Addams family members, however, is more deeply explored and their dysfunctional interactions add a new layer of contemptuous humor to the mix.
-
Full of zing and depth, the season remains just as thrilling as the first.
-
Sure, it's possible that the remaining four episodes of the season could lose the plot (or become consumed by it), but given what a strong start this first batch is, I think the only one who'll be full of woe by the end of "Wednesday" is Wednesday herself.
-
A near three-year delay would have killed off a lesser show, but Wednesday’s murderously enjoyable second season proves worth the wait.
-
It’s obvious that series creators Alfred Gough and Miles Millar, and their writers, are having fun with the introduction of new characters and settings.
-
There's an urgency and verve to the series that wasn't there in the almost lackadaisically paced first season, which seemed to going for a paint-by-numbers approach to plotting and stakes. Everything has been tightened and sharpened this time around, and the series is so much the better for it.
-
While I still have my hangups about how well the Addams Family fits into this kind of murder-mystery milieu, season 2 seems to have righted the ship and given Netflix’s latest mascot a more delicious meal to chew on…. so far.
-
The diminutive actress’s remarkable stage presence imbues the prickly teenager with enough humanity — and intelligence and chilly, real concern — to anchor and sometimes justify the show’s horror and clichés and patchy, not-quite-persuasive lore.
-
There are still strong “Chilling Adventures of Sabrina” vibes — fine by me, because I liked that show a lot. But “Wednesday” works best when it leans most heavily into its history, a strange family happy in the misery they bring onto themselves and to others. To each their own.
-
Wednesday's two-part season break ultimately weakens the story, cutting things off at the knees just as the plot is ramping up into a good place. Although this means that Part 2 will almost certainly be a wild ride, it means that Part 1 resembles more of an appetizer rather than a full meal.
-
Wednesday herself seems less striking this season — she’s not any less unusual, but she is less distinct from her surroundings. Her classmates have embraced her, despite her objections, and her visits to the outside world are increasingly fleeting. Something is lost when there’s no culture clash in an Addams Family story. And yet in plenty of superficial ways, Wednesday has become a more entertaining show.
-
Really, there’s a lot of promise here, despite the season split that, instead of enhancing the story, ends up curbing the show’s momentum.
-
Ultimately, this is still an enjoyable show that has enough off-kilter humor and twisted moments that it works for what it is. But it has soured a bit with too many cooks in the kitchen.
-
Wednesday continues to be passably entertaining mainly thanks to its visuals and its casting, particularly Jenna Ortega in the central role. But even with a couple of trouble spots from Season 1 improved upon, Season 2 still struggles with a wildly uneven tone and comedic moments that too often falter.
-
Wednesday goes big in a second season that bites off a little more brains than it can chew. Still, it’s a fun ride — worth it just to watch Steve Buscemi groove to ‘Dancing In The Dark’.
-
Soap opera machinations drive the plot exactly where you think, when you think. What seems on the surface shiny and new is really a Frankenstein’s monster of countless teen hits: Emily in Paris meets X-Men meets Veronica Mars meets Riverdale, all stitched up in style.
-
“Wednesday’s” dry, morbid humor is, at best, noticeable, but too often forgettable and sometimes actively lazy.
-
Oozing with plot and attitude but dreadfully short on inspiration, it continues to feel like a training-wheels Burton rehash that’s only fit for viewers under the age of 13.
-
Most of Season 2’s first half — even the Burton-directed first episode — is generically dark, with effects beyond The Thing resembling standard-issue CGI in a million other shows. Overall, it looks like a follow-up made with half the budget of Season 1. That is, until the fourth episode.
-
It’s not just the supporting stars who are dulled in the new episodes, which are equally split by directors Tim Burton (who also serves as executive producer) and Paco Cabezas (The Appeared, Mr. Right). Ortega is an interesting performer whose goth-girl charms are reminiscent of Winona Ryder and Christina Ricci in the late ’80s and early ’90s, but season two’s Wednesday Addams isn’t just deadpan: She’s damn near soulless, all clipped deliveries and unblinking stares.
-
The hit Netflix series has turned the morbidly deadpan character created by cartoonist Charles Addams into the central figure in a generic supernatural teen drama, seeping away most of what makes her such an enduring presence. That process continues in the second season of “Wednesday.”
-
Jenna Ortega returns for a new season as the acerbic Addams daughter, which is great, but the character’s misanthropic self is supported by an overload of the repulsive, the gruesome, the homicidal and the disgusting—or am I, like the series, being redundant? There’s also a negative side, which is the lack of much storytelling craft in a production that seems to be making stuff up as it goes along.
-
I can’t think of any more damning criticism for these four new episodes of Wednesday that, just two days after watching them, I legitimately can’t remember anything that Wednesday is trying to accomplish this season, nor any single withering line of dialogue.
-
“Wednesday” Season 2 lacks spark or direction. Bogged down by a meandering plot, distracted writing, unnecessary additions, and a misunderstanding of what made the premiere season winsome despite its many flaws, not even Ortega is enough to lift this one out of its depressive state. For all of the mischief the protagonist seeks, there’s not a whiff of playfulness or sense of fun. And it suffers because of it.