- Network: Freeform
- Series Premiere Date: Apr 16, 2025
Critic Reviews
- Critic score
- Publication
- By date
-
It doesn't do anything that new, but what it does do it does well, thanks to some sharp writing, some effective rug pulls and an absolutely stellar cast, clearly invested in the material.
-
By the end your credulity will have been sorely tested. But it is a gripping ride and you’ll definitely be saying no to sleepovers for a while.
-
Coming in at just five 45-ish-minute episodes, it doesn’t stick around long enough to become a slog. It will be easy for such a miniseries to get lost in the streaming shuffle, but for those looking for a fleet, twisty distraction, The Stolen Girl won’t leave anyone feeling robbed.
-
The Stolen Girl is off to a decent start, and I'll admit I'm more invested than I thought I would be.
-
While the first episode of The Stolen Girl is a bit too predictable, there does seem to be a really twisty story underneath the predictable premiere.
-
The Stolen Girl is totally absurd and strangely moreish.
-
The tension in The Stolen Girl – and whatever else it is, it grips like duct tape – comes as much from these performances as from the plot. If only they could give the actors a little more to work with.
-
It won’t linger in your mind for a second after you finish it, but you will have had five hours of a pretty good time.
-
It’s a forgettable – if gorgeous-looking – thriller that never surprises past its initial set-up.