The 4400

The most impressive quality "The 4400" boasts is the fact that, after tonight's episode, there are any number of directions the drama could head. There hasn't been anything this wide-open unpredictable on TV in years, and for that reason alone, it's worth overlooking the premise's flaws and following this wherever it may head. [11 July 2004]

Spooky and intriguing and almost everything that a science fiction series should be.

If the concept is captivating, the execution, at least in the pilot, leaves something to be desired. [12 July 2004, p.e37]

a promising, unprepossessing five-week series about the flip side of alien abduction. [9 July 2004]

If we have to spend yet another summer in the twilight zone of alien abduction, it might as well have the intriguing twist of The 4400.

What distinguishes The 4400 is its representation of the sense of alienation that pervades post-9/11 America.

There is -- so far -- nothing remarkable about the miniseries, which is full of things you have seen before, sometimes tweaked and sometimes not. (There is nothing new under the sci-fi sun.) It’s fairly corny and way too serious, given the manifold opportunities it offers for humor. It plays strictly by the rules, so that one completely understands what one should feel about these characters without necessarily actually feeling it. But if you’re in a charitable mood, or indeed are an active connoisseur of B-grade science fiction, that may be enough. And there may be surprises ahead -- some revelation beyond expectation. I’m willing, even hoping, to be surprised.

[Its] tepid execution and uneven performances don't exactly master its possibilities.