Star Trek: Discovery

:

Season 1
Season #: 5, 4, 3, 2, 1
User Score
4.5

Mixed or average reviews- based on 1324 Ratings

User score distribution:
  1. Positive: 527 out of 1324
  2. Mixed: 158 out of 1324
  3. Negative: 639 out of 1324
Watch Now

Where To Watch

Stream On
Stream On

Review this tv show

  1. Your Score
    0 out of 10
    Rate this:
    • 10
    • 9
    • 8
    • 7
    • 6
    • 5
    • 4
    • 3
    • 2
    • 1
    • 0
    • 0
  1. Submit
  2. Check Spelling

User Reviews

view
per page
  1. lynannouilh
    Feb 10, 2018
    10
    It's a good show, I'll wait the end of the season to be more thorough with my review, but I can't say the show is bad. It's a different flavour of Star Trek, and this is what I like. The trekkies which reviewed this show with a 0 note are extremists and are missing the point in the Roddenberry philosophy.

    Edit : Now that I have completed the show, I can say for sure, it's one of the    It's a good show, I'll wait the end of the season to be more thorough with my review, but I can't say the show is bad. It's a different flavour of Star Trek, and this is what I like. The trekkies which reviewed this show with a 0 note are extremists and are missing the point in the Roddenberry philosophy.

    Edit : Now that I have completed the show, I can say for sure, it's one of the most innovative and modern take on star trek yet. Shame on the movies.    … Expand
  2. MrPositive
    Mar 18, 2018
    10
    I think it's extremely well done, especially after the first couple of episodes which honestly are a bit slow. It's sad people giving this bad reviews and saying they quit after 1 episode. You are lame and don't deserve something this well done. I seriously feel people are trashing this because they can't handle a woman lead in their precious Star Trek. Total sadness.
  3. Korkenzieher
    Sep 26, 2017
    10
    WOW - like it. Special effects, music and casting are great! Old Star Trek had more depth but the new show is a good compromise between the old series and the style of the new time line. AND the visuals in this TV series are one of the best you will currently see! If you watch Discovery shortly after STNG you my think THIS IS NEXT GENERATION TELEVISION.
  4. the_nephilim71
    Oct 22, 2017
    10
    I love this show. I've been a fan of Trek for around 40 years and was thrilled when I heard they were making a new show because I've been waiting for a new show for a long time. The actors and characters are great and the stories are interesting. Star Trek: Discovery is like a mixture of Next Generation, Battlestar Galactica and Star Trek (2009) I highly recommend it! 10/10
  5. Cometer
    Sep 26, 2017
    10
    I'm an old time fan of Star Trek. When people think of Star Trek they think about exploration. Going into space and finding new life forms, new challenges. And you know what? Star Trek Discovery is no different from past Star Trek series. Those giving this show a low score only after the first two episodes have short memories and are grabbing to a 10 year old nostalgic view of the oldI'm an old time fan of Star Trek. When people think of Star Trek they think about exploration. Going into space and finding new life forms, new challenges. And you know what? Star Trek Discovery is no different from past Star Trek series. Those giving this show a low score only after the first two episodes have short memories and are grabbing to a 10 year old nostalgic view of the old series. But all those old series had a common trait. They all add antagonists.
    Go ahead and watch some of the first episodes of the older series. Khan, the Q, the Borg queen, Klingons and so on. The very first episode of the TNG introduced the Q.
    I'm giving Discovery a 10 because it is the best start of a Star Trek series. The main characters are strong. Discovery gives the best introduction to Klingons. Their tribal nature. The new look reflects it. And the use of Klingon language makes it more credible when compared to previous series where Klingons for some reason always spoke perfect English.
    If you want to stick to the past keep this in mind. The original series was created in the 60's. The computer consoles had buttons instead of touch displays because that's the best they could do
    at the time. We now have iPads and **** and what we expect from the future is not a star ship with buttons. If Star Trek does not evolve visually it will die along side a generation. I dont't want that. I want Star Trek to continue to inspire future generations.
    No Star Trek Discovery is not like TOS. But it is Star Trek. Fans praised the fan created Axanar. That focused on the battle of Axanar. Star Trek Discovery is truly leaps ahead what was possible in older shows. I'm looking forward to see what will happen.    … Expand
  6. Darkrayne
    Sep 26, 2017
    10
    This show is clearly getting review bombed on two fronts. First, by the people upset about the viewing method in the US. Second, by hardcore Star Trek fans who refuse to accept change. I wouldn't be surprised if Star Trek fan groups have posted to their forums requesting that all members help with review bombing. They are even hanging around here to up vote all the negative reviews andThis show is clearly getting review bombed on two fronts. First, by the people upset about the viewing method in the US. Second, by hardcore Star Trek fans who refuse to accept change. I wouldn't be surprised if Star Trek fan groups have posted to their forums requesting that all members help with review bombing. They are even hanging around here to up vote all the negative reviews and down vote the positive ones.

    Here's the deal: Star Trek, all the older series, are OLD. We love them, but they are old. Not just chronologically old, but also old fashioned. New things need to be NEW.

    Star Trek Discovery is an excellent example of how to modernise an old franchise. It gets rid of the occasional cheesyness and frequent geekyness the series is known for and replaces it with narrative, extremely high production values and more action. So far, every episode will make you believe you're watching a high budget movie. It follows a single character closely, instead of focusing on the entire officer crew.

    If Battlestar and Star Trek had a baby and that baby was raised by Mass Effect, this is what you would get. I'm personally enjoying it a lot more than the rebooted movies, which are still pretty good in thier own way.

    The Klingons look different, fans don't like that because they aren't used to the look and find it distracting, I understand that. However, the new design is far superior, aesthetically. They look more warrior-like and more imposing. If this had been the only version of what a Klingon looked like from the start of Star Trek, the fans would love it. The complaints have nothing to do with the way they look, it's purely because they look different.

    Fans also don't like that the technology looks way more advanced than the Original Series, even though Discovery is set before it. It's not the 60's anymore, we don't make things look old and rubbish just to follow suit. If they could have made ST:TOS look better, they would have. This problem stems from the archaic limitations of the time period the original was made, not in the design of the new series.

    Normal viewers: Dive in and enjoy some high quality Star Trek. There's a lot to like here, especially for newcomers.

    Hardcore Star Trek Fans: Keep going the way you're going and you're going to completely destroy this franchise. I get it, you don't want change.. but lets admit that this is better than nothing, even for you. If this series isn't a success it's not likely anyone will ever make a Star Trek series again.    … Expand
  7. Fred12
    Sep 26, 2017
    10
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. For my part, I'm a big fan since the TOS series, and I think this is the best franchise since ST Voyager. The visual effects are on cinema movie level, and they present the ST Universe with refreshing characters in their own (new) way.
    I simply cannot understand some critics from users that pointed out here that TOS played in a universe with CRT monitors and it was after this series... Would you prefer old fashioned CRT monitors, and staff behind the screen who are pulling the doors and technicals / visuals from 30 years ago? that would be ridiculous. Updated technology is the key here as well as the overall fitting of the Star Trek Philosophy into the action. The klingons play their cultural aggressive stereotype that you love and the action is cinema movie level. Series start was really furious and I hope they can maintain that level.    … Expand
  8. high90
    Jan 18, 2018
    10
    Just watched episode 11 and this show has really hit its stride. Strong performances by the leads a diverse cast and high production values make this one of the only programs on tv worth tuning in to see what happens next. How about everyone who gave this a bad review after one episode shut the f up and give it a chance to breath. Well worth your time if your a sci fi fan.
  9. nanokiwi
    Sep 25, 2017
    10
    I'm probably not the biggest Star Trek fan since my wife is watching all the old stuff and I give most of it a miss. But to me this is a big step up with thrilling writing and stunning set and costume design. As for the haters they have The Orville as an alternative but in my opinion that show is shockingly bad. Depends what you are after but modern TV has evolved to be more cinematic, andI'm probably not the biggest Star Trek fan since my wife is watching all the old stuff and I give most of it a miss. But to me this is a big step up with thrilling writing and stunning set and costume design. As for the haters they have The Orville as an alternative but in my opinion that show is shockingly bad. Depends what you are after but modern TV has evolved to be more cinematic, and yes, darker on average - I prefer it this way.… Expand
  10. redspark
    Feb 9, 2018
    10
    Great to see Star Trek back on our screens ,remember time for us in movie production has moved on so much since the first series and remember each episode was a story on its own .Discovery is a on going saga i would say it is different be cause of turns and twists , but i am enjoying watching it,take it as something new ,movies have moved on from simple tales and so must Star Trek to survive!
  11. Alphastrike
    Feb 7, 2018
    10
    Story and characters are well thought out and progressing well. Engaging and can't wait for more, an amazing addition to the Star Trek series.
  12. damocles1974
    Oct 9, 2017
    10
    The negative reviews just seem to have spoken their verdicts even before the show even really started. The first 2 "real" episodes showed that Discovery is very well written and a really good addition to the universe because it dares to be new.
  13. GodOne
    Oct 6, 2017
    10
    I've never been so happy since TNG, this is the first series with a different atmosphere, more realistic, with a lot of blood, good acting and cinematographic post production levels.
    I have never given 10 to something, this is the first time in my life, there are only 3 episodes for now but they are great.
    People unhappy about this series must have serious mental problems or maybe just    I've never been so happy since TNG, this is the first series with a different atmosphere, more realistic, with a lot of blood, good acting and cinematographic post production levels.
    I have never given 10 to something, this is the first time in my life, there are only 3 episodes for now but they are great.
    People unhappy about this series must have serious mental problems or maybe just trolls trying to sabotate this show.    … Expand
  14. ignore78
    Nov 19, 2017
    10
    i hate the star trek series and LOVE the movies. This is even better than the movies. Dont miss this!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
  15. Geekcrux
    Apr 21, 2019
    10
    Another great show being review-bombed. Many of the 0 reviews I have read obviously aren't even watching. They did so much to bring season 2 back in line with cannon and explain how everything recovered from the events that took place on Discovery.

    On top of that, the budget has been increased to create 3 Star Trek shows. Something tells me that Discovery is a big success. Producers are    Another great show being review-bombed. Many of the 0 reviews I have read obviously aren't even watching. They did so much to bring season 2 back in line with cannon and explain how everything recovered from the events that took place on Discovery.

    On top of that, the budget has been increased to create 3 Star Trek shows. Something tells me that Discovery is a big success. Producers are just throwing money at them.

    Picard Series
    Pike Series
    Discovery Series.    … Expand
  16. gozu
    Oct 2, 2017
    10
    I was hooked right away and I'm loving all the plot twists. I am enjoying this much more than TNG, which is the only other Star Trek series I've watched in its entirety.

    I have we get 6 or 7 more seasons!

    Making the show streaming-only and 10 dollars a month the only way to watch it is terrible news for the show and its cast and crew.
  17. shinitaru
    Sep 25, 2017
    10
    I wouldn't have given this show a 10 if it weren't for all that haters that clearly want a decent show to fail. True score: 7.5-8. Don't listen to the haters, this show is pretty good
  18. Roagie
    Sep 25, 2017
    10
    First, let it be known that I am a "true" Trek fan. I grew up with re-runs in the 70s as a kid. I was into TNG, DS9, and yes, even Voyager. I can appreciate thoughtful scifi. And this new show IS thoughtful sci-fi. Yes it is more along the lines of the Trek reboot movies, but that's not a bad thing at all. I loved the reboots, so this show sits well with me. So far, this show is definitelyFirst, let it be known that I am a "true" Trek fan. I grew up with re-runs in the 70s as a kid. I was into TNG, DS9, and yes, even Voyager. I can appreciate thoughtful scifi. And this new show IS thoughtful sci-fi. Yes it is more along the lines of the Trek reboot movies, but that's not a bad thing at all. I loved the reboots, so this show sits well with me. So far, this show is definitely more action-centric, but it also has some interesting character development with the lead, as well as a distinct Klingon character I believe they are going to develop/follow in parallel as the show continues. The story also appears it will take a twist after the first two eps. I can see where they're going with it, and I'm intrigued. This show is a vast departure from previous Trek formulas, and that's a good thing!
    The series has angered so-called "true" Trek fans because it does not appear to be ship-centric, and the main character is not a captain. Well people, it's time to BOLDLY GO WHERE NO ONE HAS GONE BEFORE. Grow up and give the show a chance... jeez.
    As for the show itself, it's great. Production costs must be off the chart... sets, characters, makeup, costumes, etc are all absolute top-notch & movie quality. Pretty amazing for a TV show. The episodes had me gripped on the edge of my seat all the way through, never a dull moment. I found the writing to be excellent, on par with newer more mature shows like The Expanse and Battlestar Galactica. Same holds true for the acting. If you like Trek, or scifi, or action, or just good shows... you should check this one out.    … Expand
  19. Boxtears
    Sep 25, 2017
    10
    A lot better than I expected especially after the internet tried to convince me I should hate it before seeing even a single episode. But of course there's a mass campaign to get as many people to hate this as possible regardless of the actual quality of the show. Even after posting this, I guarantee you I'm going to get a ton of downvotes just for daring to think outside the echoA lot better than I expected especially after the internet tried to convince me I should hate it before seeing even a single episode. But of course there's a mass campaign to get as many people to hate this as possible regardless of the actual quality of the show. Even after posting this, I guarantee you I'm going to get a ton of downvotes just for daring to think outside the echo chamber of haters. That's fine, haters gonna hate.… Expand
  20. ernie76
    Oct 1, 2017
    10
    This is Trek at its best. Greates Problem for most haters seems to be that the "Massage" isent delivert on a silver plater like in TNG where Picard hold a long Monolog at the end of many episodes.
    The look of the Klingons and thair Ships is a bit strange but it isent the 90s anymore and so i can live with that.
    As the Trek Creed say i am open for "New and Strange" things and so i git    This is Trek at its best. Greates Problem for most haters seems to be that the "Massage" isent delivert on a silver plater like in TNG where Picard hold a long Monolog at the end of many episodes.
    The look of the Klingons and thair Ships is a bit strange but it isent the 90s anymore and so i can live with that.
    As the Trek Creed say i am open for "New and Strange" things and so i git this a chance!    … Expand
  21. cinemabon
    Apr 8, 2018
    10
    Fan Clubs have flooded this website with "bad" reviews in the hopes it will bring down the favorable rating. However, anyone with a brain and some Sci-Fi background knows good science fiction when they see it. Star Trek Discovery is made up of great fans, devoted to the series. They've accomplished what few could - take a dying series and breathe new life into it. So many sour grapes whenFan Clubs have flooded this website with "bad" reviews in the hopes it will bring down the favorable rating. However, anyone with a brain and some Sci-Fi background knows good science fiction when they see it. Star Trek Discovery is made up of great fans, devoted to the series. They've accomplished what few could - take a dying series and breathe new life into it. So many sour grapes when those who have tried to trash this show and say how "brilliant" the Orville is must disappointed to see their ratings are the exact opposite of what they hoped. The true Star Trek fan LOVES this show and the post show, both well done.… Expand
  22. Chickensun
    Feb 27, 2018
    10
    Literally every negative review is about how the show is not like old Star Trek. Ignore them it's a good show. Starts slowly and gets better.
  23. Tallrothen
    Oct 6, 2017
    10
    The next step in the natural evolution of Star Trek.
    A few shady performances from a couple of characters but nothing that takes away from the overall experience. Don't miss it!
  24. Shaka_Igloo
    Oct 1, 2017
    10
    Loved it. A show where the action and plot comes first instead of jumping straight into being yet another sci-fi soap opera. So sick of these crews full of self doubting whining babies and their personal problems that end up taking center stage instead of adventures in space.
  25. jmason86
    Oct 30, 2017
    10
    I grew up on Star Trek TNG, DS9, and Voyager. They inspired me, especially TNG, to pursue a career in science and engineering. I'm now writing this review from my office at NASA. Discovery so far is just as good as any of those earlier series.

    It's way too early to crap on Discovery. The first season of TNG was terrible but it became absolutely iconic and, for me, epitomized Star Trek.    I grew up on Star Trek TNG, DS9, and Voyager. They inspired me, especially TNG, to pursue a career in science and engineering. I'm now writing this review from my office at NASA. Discovery so far is just as good as any of those earlier series.

    It's way too early to crap on Discovery. The first season of TNG was terrible but it became absolutely iconic and, for me, epitomized Star Trek.

    While Enterprise was on the air, I boycotted most of the episodes, including the finale, because of the theme song. Years later I watched the series all the way through, and then regretted not supporting the show while it was on. I vocally denounced it with many others. And it got cancelled. Now we've been more than a decade with no Star Trek series. I won't make that mistake again.

    But the paywall is absurd. I'm paying for it to give them support, but they really should broaden the distribution so that it is more accessible. If not broadcasting it, then also let Netflix stream it. If not that, then also make it available for purchase on Amazon like HBO is or the Mars series was. I grew up in the lower middle class and my parents would not have been able to pay for CBS All Access (we didn't even have cable) so I would not have been exposed to and inspired by Star Trek.    … Expand
  26. Badben
    Sep 25, 2017
    10
    This is exactly what the Star Trek franchise needs. Willing to let go of the TNG era, and move into modern television. Wonderfully acted, gripping story so far, and already hinting at addressing modern issues like culture vs race, I believe this will be the first show to out do The Next Generation.
  27. MMBosch
    Sep 25, 2017
    10
    A Star Trek story for a new generation, a generation open to change. Critics are right, its a solid entrance in the dying franchise, brought to life with incredible atention to details.
  28. Yco
    Oct 30, 2017
    10
    Interesting, flashy and well made show that I'm looking forward to getting in to.

    Sad that it's being review-bombed by trolls that don't know how to be open minded.
  29. jamestran84
    Nov 13, 2017
    10
    To be honest I was hoping this show would fail miserably but holy cow I was blown away. After the first two prologue episodes you are taken for a ride! The CGI and tech are great and its very realistic while keeping to the star trek theme. I LOVE IT. I got it on Netflix so it's a big win. It's quite obvious they have not kept the tech strictly to canon but seriously I would be sooo boredTo be honest I was hoping this show would fail miserably but holy cow I was blown away. After the first two prologue episodes you are taken for a ride! The CGI and tech are great and its very realistic while keeping to the star trek theme. I LOVE IT. I got it on Netflix so it's a big win. It's quite obvious they have not kept the tech strictly to canon but seriously I would be sooo bored if they did!!!… Expand
  30. kralizeh
    Jan 22, 2018
    10
    Best Star Trek since TNG, different but refreshing plot takes time to develop but does so nicely, I was a bit circumspect about the characters but good character building gets you hooked after a couple of episodes.
  31. MadChiller85
    Sep 25, 2017
    10
    The most intriguing Star Trek series since Voyager. At first it feels a bit like a fan film, but the production value is much higher and there's a lot of depth here that I didn't expect. Yeah, the Klingons look strange, but overall this is definitely a show to keep your eye on.
  32. Vengar1965
    Sep 25, 2017
    10
    Excellent tv series, about time we got another star trek show!!! Acting, story, graphics superb. The show will look completely different from the originals due to we are in 2017 technology advanced.
  33. Groen
    Oct 2, 2017
    10
    I watch the first two episodes and loved it! i do remember the first episodes of TNG and was horrible. The first season of Voyager was ok, later it became the best next to STO. Discovery began very strong. SFX was fantastic, good characters and lots of actions. Hope they can keep up this level of tension and urgency. For all you haters (0 points really?) get a life :)
  34. woollyshaft
    Oct 30, 2017
    10
    This series exceeded my expectations. It brings Star Trek into the 21st century, where we realize that even in the 24th century, humans are still going to have human emotions, desires, and flaws. The characters have more than one dimension (don't always do what's right), the special effects are 10x better than previous star trek series, and most importantly, the writing isn't campy starThis series exceeded my expectations. It brings Star Trek into the 21st century, where we realize that even in the 24th century, humans are still going to have human emotions, desires, and flaws. The characters have more than one dimension (don't always do what's right), the special effects are 10x better than previous star trek series, and most importantly, the writing isn't campy star trek of old. This is definitely alternative Star Trek, which is why so many Trekkies are giving it negative scores...well that and the dumb CBS app.… Expand
  35. solfireuk
    Jan 21, 2019
    10
    I know there has been way too many negatives about this show. As a Star Trek fan it is great to me, but I love all Star Trek, everything full stop. This for me is the best of the bunch, it is of its time just like the others were but it adds a richness and depth to the universe for me. Dark and full of wonderful characters, intelligence and meaningful interactions. 10/10 especiallyI know there has been way too many negatives about this show. As a Star Trek fan it is great to me, but I love all Star Trek, everything full stop. This for me is the best of the bunch, it is of its time just like the others were but it adds a richness and depth to the universe for me. Dark and full of wonderful characters, intelligence and meaningful interactions. 10/10 especially starting the new season 2, just simply brilliant.… Expand
  36. Starcryst
    Sep 24, 2017
    10
    Don't listen to the idiots giving ST Discovery 0 Ratings. It's brilliant. The production values are amazing, the acting is top notch, the dialog is well written and believable and most importantly, the characters are complex and interesting.

    As a fan of the original series and an avid consumer of every TV series and movie since, I was afraid the series would be hi-jacked by producers    Don't listen to the idiots giving ST Discovery 0 Ratings. It's brilliant. The production values are amazing, the acting is top notch, the dialog is well written and believable and most importantly, the characters are complex and interesting.

    As a fan of the original series and an avid consumer of every TV series and movie since, I was afraid the series would be hi-jacked by producers and writers who valued Brand over Lore. I'm excited to report the show included a constant stream of excellent fan service with subtle historical details that are accurate for the time and place that the story takes place. For example, there is a point where the Klingon leader disgustingly references both Tellarites and Andorans (2 of the first 4 members of the Federation) even though none appear in the episode. ST:D (yes its an unfortunate abbreviation) has clearly been crafted by Star Trek fans with loving attention to the details of the source material..

    The most impressive part of the first 2 episodes in my opinion is the focus on creating a truly compelling culture for the Klingons that explains their xenophobic aggression towards other races. No longer are they simply 2 dimensional, evil props to be used as a foil to the Federations ethical and moral codes. We see glmpses of a fascinating racial history that provides logical context for their behavior and why the Federation failed so badly in early attempts to understand Klingons and how this inevitably led to conflict.

    For the first time in years, I'm excited to see what comes next in a Star Trek series. CBS looks to have a huge hit on their hands if they keep up this level of quality throughout the show run.    … Expand
  37. Sirr_Hann
    Sep 24, 2017
    10
    Haters, haters all over the place... I'm so tired of them. The two episodes were good even if (because of the trailers) almost everything was predictable. It is a start, a valid one. The real good news is that, from the next week, we are about to see something really new and unpredictable. I can't wait!
    Star Trek Discovery is a much darker and mature place and I love it, even if the    Haters, haters all over the place... I'm so tired of them. The two episodes were good even if (because of the trailers) almost everything was predictable. It is a start, a valid one. The real good news is that, from the next week, we are about to see something really new and unpredictable. I can't wait!
    Star Trek Discovery is a much darker and mature place and I love it, even if the Klingons looks pretty bad, but I really don't care about that. I never liked them anyway.    … Expand
  38. shayneosu
    Sep 25, 2017
    10
    Star Trek is back (on TV)! And I'm excited for it!

    It's hard to judge from just a few episodes, but I liked what I saw so far. It's exciting, futuristic and really well-produced. I can't wait to see where it goes. If you like scifi, you should definitely check this out. And if you're a Trek fan: (Very slight info ahead, but nothing I'd call a 'spoiler.' Still, if you're    Star Trek is back (on TV)! And I'm excited for it!

    It's hard to judge from just a few episodes, but I liked what I saw so far. It's exciting, futuristic and really well-produced. I can't wait to see where it goes. If you like scifi, you should definitely check this out.

    And if you're a Trek fan:

    (Very slight info ahead, but nothing I'd call a 'spoiler.' Still, if you're sensitive, watch the episode before reading.)

    This is the first time I've found the Klingons to be interesting. They've got an actual back-story and culture presented, rather than just being a mindless, battle-obsessed biker gang in space. (This is an old beef of mine, and I'm glad they're already addressing it.)

    The Vulcan-raised crew member is interesting. She's like the opposite of Spock. You sometimes saw glimpses of emotion through his wall of logic. With Michael, logic serves to rein in her emotions during stressful moments as she remembers her Vulcan training, and you see it in her face and mannerisms here.

    The ship and settings are great. They're JJ-verse inspired, and I'm alright with that. We can't have another TOS-looking ship in 2017. This looks like the future of our time, just like TOS did for the 60s.

    Overall, I'm really looking forward to seeing where this goes. Most Trek series start out a bit weak and build from there. I want to see this series grow to become one of the best in this historic franchise. And so far, I'm optimistic about its chances!    … Expand
  39. Discoverspace
    Sep 24, 2017
    10
    Star Trek Discovery is the Sci-fi we've all been waiting for since Enterprise. Many of times, tv shows will come on trying to innovate the idea of adventure, exploration, drama, and discovery, but they often times fail at meeting what the average users want. Disicovery not only meets those innovations, but exceeds it greatly.
  40. AlexMuld
    Sep 25, 2017
    10
    Well, this was something different.. As a die-hard Star Trek fan, I welcome the change of pace from invincible goody-two-shoes characters to something new. Finally. Keep it up.
  41. corky_
    Sep 25, 2017
    10
    great show and far better than the old boring star trek. If you want a show that resembles previous star trek go watch the hot pile Orville; Discovery is a show adapted to modern television and is actually entertaining.
  42. rixmadpor
    Sep 26, 2017
    10
    I've been a trekkie for almost 30 years. My first contact, with the Star Trek universe, was the Motion Picture, Wrath of Khan and then the series ST: The Next Generation. Back then I was impressed how one universe could encompass such a wide variety of subjects. From doing a 2001 Space Odyssey type of movie to an action movie like Wrath Of Khan. And then there was a TV series like TNG,I've been a trekkie for almost 30 years. My first contact, with the Star Trek universe, was the Motion Picture, Wrath of Khan and then the series ST: The Next Generation. Back then I was impressed how one universe could encompass such a wide variety of subjects. From doing a 2001 Space Odyssey type of movie to an action movie like Wrath Of Khan. And then there was a TV series like TNG, which I didn't expect that could be that good. Even the special effects were, for me, even better than the movies back then. And now... They've done it again. They re-invented Star Trek. They took a big risk but it was worth it. It's a whole new level. Not even the rebooted movies were this good. Cast, effects, story. Everything. They've done a great job hiding the story until the premiere. I never saw this coming. It's the best Star Trek TV pilot ever. This could be a movie. Congrats to everyone involved on the show. Thank you so very much. Live long and prosper!… Expand
  43. Sugarhorse
    Sep 27, 2017
    10
    Really surprised at how good this show is, having followed the news of its troubled development and seeing the new "Klingons" made me expect very little of this show, but iv'e never been so happy to be wrong. Awesome effects and great characters, as well as an interesting story so far, can't wait to see how it shapes up. All the 1/0 star reviews seems to be trek fans of old complainingReally surprised at how good this show is, having followed the news of its troubled development and seeing the new "Klingons" made me expect very little of this show, but iv'e never been so happy to be wrong. Awesome effects and great characters, as well as an interesting story so far, can't wait to see how it shapes up. All the 1/0 star reviews seems to be trek fans of old complaining about how its all action and doesn't "feel like star trek" and other vague complaints without any specific criticism, the show is great and you should defiantly have a watch if your a trek fan or not.… Expand
  44. Brigitte63
    Sep 27, 2017
    10
    LOVED the new series and I've been a fan since TOS! Expected the usual whining from fans who are stuck in the past and can't open their minds! I'm lucky to be able to watch in Canada on SPACE channel. My only criticism is that it is offered only on the CBS ALL Access service which makes it inaccessible to many potential fans and also I found having to read the Klingon subtitles veryLOVED the new series and I've been a fan since TOS! Expected the usual whining from fans who are stuck in the past and can't open their minds! I'm lucky to be able to watch in Canada on SPACE channel. My only criticism is that it is offered only on the CBS ALL Access service which makes it inaccessible to many potential fans and also I found having to read the Klingon subtitles very tedious and I hope they have them speaking in English soon. It always takes a new show a while for character development and I expect this will get better as time goes on. I do love the dark cinematic feel of it. Not everything has to be the light fluffy TNG!… Expand
  45. Discovery
    Sep 28, 2017
    10
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. excellent series, quite good addition in the Universe of Star Trek, As the fan of Star Trek I isn't happy only with design of klingon ( they are awful )… Expand
  46. wolffandy3
    Oct 2, 2017
    10
    Loved it! Pitch perfect! Thrilling, mysterious, funny, and bold! Top notch acting, Sonequa Martin-Green is captivating and charming -- a perfect Trek lead. Writing is clever and deep, weaving a tapestry of intrigue, making the most of it's serialized structure. Fantastic direction, SFX, music -- the sets are incredible. I dig the big budget, love seeing Trek this way. Very epic. Star TrekLoved it! Pitch perfect! Thrilling, mysterious, funny, and bold! Top notch acting, Sonequa Martin-Green is captivating and charming -- a perfect Trek lead. Writing is clever and deep, weaving a tapestry of intrigue, making the most of it's serialized structure. Fantastic direction, SFX, music -- the sets are incredible. I dig the big budget, love seeing Trek this way. Very epic. Star Trek meets Game of Thrones, in the best way.
    This is Star Trek at it's finest!    … Expand
  47. cbeckman
    Oct 2, 2017
    10
    I've love Trek since the TOS and love all incarnations, except the JJ Abrams version (which is terrible). But, I do not get the hate for this version. It's great. The characters are great. The story is fun and exciting. It features both believable science and politics.

    This is certainly different than all other incarnations, but true to the heart of trek. This is the only show I'm    I've love Trek since the TOS and love all incarnations, except the JJ Abrams version (which is terrible). But, I do not get the hate for this version. It's great. The characters are great. The story is fun and exciting. It features both believable science and politics.

    This is certainly different than all other incarnations, but true to the heart of trek. This is the only show I'm at all interested in and actually the best thing I've seen in years!    … Expand
  48. FunInTheSun1
    Oct 4, 2017
    10
    Okay, so there seems to be some review bombing going on with this show, thus the 10/10. Honestly though, as someone whose earliest childhood memory is watching the TNG episode "Shades of Grey" (season 2, episode 22) --not a great one--this series is pretty good, likely the most interesting thing to happen to Star Trek in over a decade.

    Also if you are going to criticize any sort of    Okay, so there seems to be some review bombing going on with this show, thus the 10/10. Honestly though, as someone whose earliest childhood memory is watching the TNG episode "Shades of Grey" (season 2, episode 22) --not a great one--this series is pretty good, likely the most interesting thing to happen to Star Trek in over a decade.

    Also if you are going to criticize any sort of media for "bad writing" you really need to clarify what you mean. Such epithets are vague to the point of meaninglessness unless qualified.    … Expand
  49. jcastlouis
    Oct 4, 2017
    10
    After three episodes I have to say this show is amazing. I felt compelled to write this review because so many others here are merely 0s with the same things copied and pasted. Would you honestly believe a rating of 0? Just like you wouldn't believe a 10. -- Overall the show is a modern telling of the classic Star Trek tales. Everything has been updated so the Star Trek franchise canAfter three episodes I have to say this show is amazing. I felt compelled to write this review because so many others here are merely 0s with the same things copied and pasted. Would you honestly believe a rating of 0? Just like you wouldn't believe a 10. -- Overall the show is a modern telling of the classic Star Trek tales. Everything has been updated so the Star Trek franchise can attract a whole new generation of fan. And the classic Trek substance is there too, if viewers will look. The first episode was somewhat stuff. Think of all of the beautiful television we'd miss if the first hour didn't do it for us and we dipped out. Episode 2 was masterful. It laid the foundation for the serialized story to move forward in a brilliant manner. Dialogue was crisp and believable. Effects were amazing. And the overall scope of the production was vast - similar in style and cinematography to a film. ST is a show steeped in canon. And the producers have said this show will adhere to canon if you are patient enough. Which means by the end of the 15 episodes of this season any "canonical conflicts" will have been explained. Many don't seem capable of giving it more than 42 minutes before making up their mind. If you're concerned about canon, I advise you to chillax going in. I have an it has led to an utter enjoyment of the show. And my son, who has never been a fan of any other incarnation, is hooked. Discovery is worth a look and I know you'll find the same jewel of science fiction that has endured for 51 years.… Expand
  50. Fallguy
    Oct 9, 2017
    10
    This is not your daddy’s Star Trek., but it is Star Trek. Just a different version for a different time. It’s compelling, exciting and, yes, dark. Darker than Trek has ever been.But it oozes the hope for those times we know and we all have seen to come after this prequel. Don’t believe the trolls: It’s absolutely epic! LLAP
  51. blainiebobainie
    Oct 14, 2017
    10
    I have sincerely enjoyed the building tension on the show. I am enjoying the serialized story-line. I look forward to many more seasons with new and interesting story-lines and deepened character development. The production values is fantastic. I feel like I am watching a movie in my living room every week! I like the characters and the actors playing them. I am honestly excited and beyondI have sincerely enjoyed the building tension on the show. I am enjoying the serialized story-line. I look forward to many more seasons with new and interesting story-lines and deepened character development. The production values is fantastic. I feel like I am watching a movie in my living room every week! I like the characters and the actors playing them. I am honestly excited and beyond thrilled to have Star Trek back on television!!!… Expand
  52. GiantWomanOpal
    Oct 21, 2017
    10
    This show is AMAZING! It breathes new life into a franchise that was long growing stale. The recent movies were boring, and few new fans were being created. This is a Star Trek that shows that values are hard to stand by, and it takes struggle to do so. Don't listen to the haters who are just mad that the universe doesn't revolve around White dudes. This is Trek worth watching.
  53. Olamax
    Jan 29, 2018
    10
    I love this show! I’m not sure why people think it isn’t Star Trek; we can’t have every show being exactly the same, can we. It is fun and engaging and it is Star Trek!
  54. Chrisma55
    Nov 11, 2017
    10
    Calm down people of earth. Star Trek can evolve, it's not religion... Just joined the metacritics to set things strait vs professional critics and The Orville and now it's Discovery's turn but vs. Trekkers and Trekkies. Keep calm and appreciate. Filming is beautiful, high quality. The sound and soundtrack, the ambiance, colours, the casting and dialogues it's all good and I´m noCalm down people of earth. Star Trek can evolve, it's not religion... Just joined the metacritics to set things strait vs professional critics and The Orville and now it's Discovery's turn but vs. Trekkers and Trekkies. Keep calm and appreciate. Filming is beautiful, high quality. The sound and soundtrack, the ambiance, colours, the casting and dialogues it's all good and I´m no fanboy. I understand all the fuss is about in regards to Star Trek lore, about what should or shouldn't be, about the respect of the cannon stuff... And those of you who bring up front the Klingon appearance as a major bug well switch channel you are not worthy (and those who bring up the "Michael is not a ladies name" I don't want those waste good typing time on you) . Enjoy what CBS took a chance on, put in the hands of very competent people who do a great creative job and put on your old dvd's of S-T, next g, voyager, enterprise and even deep 9 and be joyful to have big corps putting money in good sci-fi shows we can all enjoy with a light hearted reconnaissance and honesty. All hands, brace for impact...… Expand
  55. Brian_Brodrick
    Nov 26, 2017
    10
    Star Trek is back! Finally after 12 long years we get a new series, not movies that we have to wait years in between for each one. The pilot episodes were rocky, and you had to watch the rest behind a paywall, but that is trivial compared to the overall quality of Discovery's 1st season which delivers movie-quality SPFX, costumes, props, and sets, but also quality acting and direction asStar Trek is back! Finally after 12 long years we get a new series, not movies that we have to wait years in between for each one. The pilot episodes were rocky, and you had to watch the rest behind a paywall, but that is trivial compared to the overall quality of Discovery's 1st season which delivers movie-quality SPFX, costumes, props, and sets, but also quality acting and direction as well as storytelling. A totally new thing for Trek is the serial instead of episodic format, and the story so far, with small exceptions, is well put together.… Expand
  56. waahaa
    Jan 15, 2018
    10
    star trek discovery.. this show is great, although you have to stick with it as the first 4 episodes kinda feel like nothing new. but i'm now on episode 11 and they are getting into dark territory. id say its the most enjoyable series of any star trek so far. i get the feeling they will kill off a host of characters. there are a few back round characters that will probably step forward instar trek discovery.. this show is great, although you have to stick with it as the first 4 episodes kinda feel like nothing new. but i'm now on episode 11 and they are getting into dark territory. id say its the most enjoyable series of any star trek so far. i get the feeling they will kill off a host of characters. there are a few back round characters that will probably step forward in season 2 i'm guessing. but please stick with this show don't give up too soon. VERY MUCH THE DARKEST TREK SERIES TO DATE.… Expand
  57. xortim
    Feb 20, 2019
    10
    A lot of users are rating it poorly after just one episode or by the fact that CBS is charging money for a clearly high budget show.

    This is a different Star Trek because this is a different decade than when the others aired. The way we tell stories now is entirely different than how we told stories in the early aughts, 90s and 60s. Some common critiques: The Klingons looks    A lot of users are rating it poorly after just one episode or by the fact that CBS is charging money for a clearly high budget show.

    This is a different Star Trek because this is a different decade than when the others aired. The way we tell stories now is entirely different than how we told stories in the early aughts, 90s and 60s.

    Some common critiques:
    The Klingons looks different - yup, they also didn't have any prosthetics in TOS
    The technology looks too advanced for it to take place before TOS - I really don't want to watch actors push radio shack buttons glued onto cardboard in a show produced this side of of the millennium.
    Not everyone is an altruistic blowhard, Gene Roddenberry would not approve! - meh, the main character is annoyingly moral and so is the first Captain we encounter.
    It's too politically charged- have you watched any Star Trek, ever? People lost their **** over Dax having the first broadcast "lesbian" kiss, or how about a black bridge officer, let alone a woman Captain. The show has always pushed progressive politics in one way or another, and there's always been someone to object and fold their arms saying "that just ain't right"

    Some genuine criticism are things like:
    Too much or inconsistent camera movement
    Some characters can be annoying at times (true of any show)

    Plus, Tilly is amazing and everyone should watch it for that reason alone.    … Expand
  58. CuckooTheCuckoo
    Feb 6, 2018
    10
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. I just can't understand all the negative reviews for STD.

    I had extremely low expectations after a string of clones of the fantastic Start Trek the Next Generation. I was preparing for yet more sanctimonious 2D characters, badly acted and rehashing tired old story-lines. But STD has taking it in an entirely new direction, adding richness to the Klingons, and showing that The Federation isn't always squeaky clean.

    Rather than being all nauseatingly perfect, the cast of STD have as many characters flaws as they have talents. The exposition is done well without being a series of explainers, and the characters all feel rich and well developed as a result.

    I can't understand the complaint that Star Trek should be about exploration only. They go to another fricking universe! The plot twists are clever enough to actually catch you off your guard, and they sitll find time to add a sense of wonder to what's happening.

    The acting is just superb and I really don't understand the complaints about the acting as it is top notch. There is a great sense of humour attached, and plenty of scenes that bring about real sense of emotion.

    Star Trek badly needed a new sense of direction, and STD has provided much needed vigour and charm. The sci-fi is credible and believable, drawing on current theories (like the multiverse theory), but finding interesting ways to project it. It can be surreal at times, intriguing, raunchy, heat-breaking, and elating.

    I really don't understand the haters.    … Expand
  59. Emmit
    Jan 11, 2018
    10
    This is a very high quality show with great production value and sincere acting performances. I am shocked that there are so many negative views but after reading them its become clear that they are almost entirely written by bitter trolls who would hate anything of real artistic value. I grew up on Star Trek: The Next Generation and this show takes the old Star Trek to an entirely new level.
  60. marsm1
    Feb 5, 2018
    10
    Fantastic Trek. Started off a bit rough but has really come into it's own! Would recommend a watch.
  61. RMillward
    Feb 6, 2018
    10
    Star Trek Discovery is a bold new vision in the Star Trek Universe, one that has unsettled and even disappointed older fans. Younger, more imaginative viewers, whose experience includes liking Star Trek Enterprise on TV, with its non-episodic story arcs, and the up-to-date trilogy of Star Trek films starring Chris Pine and Zachary Quinto, will appreciate Star Trek Discovery's incredibleStar Trek Discovery is a bold new vision in the Star Trek Universe, one that has unsettled and even disappointed older fans. Younger, more imaginative viewers, whose experience includes liking Star Trek Enterprise on TV, with its non-episodic story arcs, and the up-to-date trilogy of Star Trek films starring Chris Pine and Zachary Quinto, will appreciate Star Trek Discovery's incredible production values and out-of-the-box storytelling. Yes, a lot of very vocal people seem not to care for Star Trek Discovery, but as a lifelong fan of Star Trek (52 years and still counting!), I can tell you this show is among the best the Star Trek franchise has to offer and you owe yourself a look.… Expand
  62. drew314159
    Feb 6, 2018
    10
    I have been a life long fan of Star Trek since the 70s also, and I love this show. It is great and flows lovely from all the series before eit.
  63. slimshadi
    Feb 7, 2018
    10
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Great show, times have moved on and this is great modern trek. Hope Lorca comes back.… Expand
  64. Malthazor
    Feb 7, 2018
    10
    I suppose hard-core Star Trek fans are going to bemoan the fast pacing and the moral complexity, as well as the absence of tedious sermonising about the greater good and the Prime Directive. The rest of us can find plenty to enjoy in the first season's well structured story arc and the fine performances by the likes of Michelle Yeoh and Jason Isaacs.
  65. eightyfish
    Feb 20, 2018
    10
    You'll notice most of the early reviews for this series are bad, and most of the later ones are good. Ignore anyone who reviews a series of anything after 2 or 3 episodes. Yes, this is different to previous Trek, but if you try to imagine what Trek would look like if it was written in the modern TV universe - a universe with Breaking Bad, Game of Thrones, The Wire, Peaky Blinders and allYou'll notice most of the early reviews for this series are bad, and most of the later ones are good. Ignore anyone who reviews a series of anything after 2 or 3 episodes. Yes, this is different to previous Trek, but if you try to imagine what Trek would look like if it was written in the modern TV universe - a universe with Breaking Bad, Game of Thrones, The Wire, Peaky Blinders and all the rest - this is it. Yes, it has some issues with pacing at the beginning, and the new Klingons take a little getting used to (I think I would have preferred them as they were in TNG), but this is solid Trek with a moral backbone, good characters and an intriguing story arc. It really comes together by the end. Don't forget TNG took almost three years to find its feet. Can't wait for series 2.… Expand
  66. SvenLorenz
    Mar 9, 2019
    10
    I never expected there to be another great Star Trek show after DS9 ended, but they managed to maybe even surpass it. It's like they took all the good things from DS9, added a lot of the Battlestar Galactica reboot and the look and feel (but not the silly plots) of the Abrams' Star Trek movies. If you think that TNG with its simplistic morality tales and everybody loves everybody crew isI never expected there to be another great Star Trek show after DS9 ended, but they managed to maybe even surpass it. It's like they took all the good things from DS9, added a lot of the Battlestar Galactica reboot and the look and feel (but not the silly plots) of the Abrams' Star Trek movies. If you think that TNG with its simplistic morality tales and everybody loves everybody crew is what Star Trek should be, then you're going to have a bad time with Discovery. If you loved the adult take on Star Trek that DS9 presented, you're going to love Discovery.… Expand
  67. Dinglebuddy
    Jan 30, 2019
    10
    The people complaining about "Another show goes PC" are the same people who would have complained about an interracial couple in TOS. Star Trek has always been a progressive show, that shows hope for humanity and displays a world more tolerant and just than the one we live in today. These people probably complained about a female captain in voyager. Probably didn't like DS9 due to theThe people complaining about "Another show goes PC" are the same people who would have complained about an interracial couple in TOS. Star Trek has always been a progressive show, that shows hope for humanity and displays a world more tolerant and just than the one we live in today. These people probably complained about a female captain in voyager. Probably didn't like DS9 due to the progressive themes in that.

    This show is fantastic, and such a breath of fresh air after the dumpster fire that was Star Trek: Enterprise. It is well rounded, with original and creative plot devices. They managed to pay homage to the old, while still creating something new. Every Star Trek after TOS had weak 1st seasons. The characters grow and develop, Sarek's depiction is fantastic. This show's only downfall is that it's on CBS all access. It's wonderful. And by the way, Johnathan Frakes (Commander Riker) directs the second episode of the second season, and I feel like this show is only going to get better. So long as review bombing nay-sayers don't ruin it for the rest of us.

    These nay-sayers are just mad there is a gay couple in it and that the main character isn't a captain... They're angry because it isn't the same recycled material over and over again. They only wish to feed their own nostalgia. It's preposterous, and they're probably the same people who think the cliche, recycled (or literally stolen from star trek TNG) story lines, tired tropes and cheap humor in Orville are points of genius. You can watch Orville, that's fine. You don't see anyone review bombing it... Why? Because they don't care. Why are you so offended by it that you've got to spread hate for the sake of it?    … Expand
  68. GrantC84
    Jan 31, 2019
    10
    Gave a 10 to combat all the trolls who cant get past the old Trek Days.
    I am an avid star trek fan and have watched every episode of every ST series at least 2-3 times.
    STD is a good show and deserves support even from the old guard. All you "0" raters are pathetic!
  69. Thorus84
    Feb 24, 2019
    10
    I am a Star Trek Fan since 1990. I must admit that DSC is not my favorite Star Trek show (that would be TNG) but it is quite well. And the second season is really awesome.
  70. Baron236
    Mar 2, 2019
    10
    For all the nerd rage people seem to forget that Star Trek has always been a show if it's time, changing and pushing boundaries whenever a new series surfaces. As a casual fan I find this series very enjoyable. It does seem to have more in common with the recent cinematic universe than any of the previous series. It is overall a deeper, slightly grittier program that I feel holds true toFor all the nerd rage people seem to forget that Star Trek has always been a show if it's time, changing and pushing boundaries whenever a new series surfaces. As a casual fan I find this series very enjoyable. It does seem to have more in common with the recent cinematic universe than any of the previous series. It is overall a deeper, slightly grittier program that I feel holds true to the original series but offers a fresh perspective.… Expand
  71. ScottNAtlanta1
    Mar 8, 2019
    10
    This season is miles ahead better than the first season and I am really enjoying how they are paying homage to the original series.
  72. subrinaw
    Mar 14, 2019
    10
    Simply the best Star Trek in a long time. I love the look of the show, the flawed characters, the seasonal arcs with multiple plots. The costumes and special effects are A-1. It is the only weekly show that I watch live everything else I tape and watch even convenient. Star Trek Discovery is "must see tv" for me. I am jumping out of my seat everyweek. The only time it losing its footingSimply the best Star Trek in a long time. I love the look of the show, the flawed characters, the seasonal arcs with multiple plots. The costumes and special effects are A-1. It is the only weekly show that I watch live everything else I tape and watch even convenient. Star Trek Discovery is "must see tv" for me. I am jumping out of my seat everyweek. The only time it losing its footing when they try to appease the old-timers, of which I technically am one (bringing back the gold uniforms, giving the Klingons hair again...oh whatever). It's faster, deeper, smarter than we were 50 years ago and I LOVE IT.… Expand
  73. peregrin5
    Mar 24, 2019
    10
    If you are a gate-keeping Star Trek fan, there's no doubt you'll hate this show because it's not the same exact show that you grew up with.

    That said, that's what makes this show so brilliant. Too many Star Trek reboots have tried to play on ToS or TNG success and created cookie-cutter series with almost identical plot lines and characters. Thank GOD Discovery changed the way it did.    If you are a gate-keeping Star Trek fan, there's no doubt you'll hate this show because it's not the same exact show that you grew up with.

    That said, that's what makes this show so brilliant. Too many Star Trek reboots have tried to play on ToS or TNG success and created cookie-cutter series with almost identical plot lines and characters. Thank GOD Discovery changed the way it did.

    While some of the pseudo-science sounds hokey, in the larger Star Trek canon, it's really not that bad.

    The characters are deep, flawed, vulnerable, well-developed, and evolve throughout the series. The writing is incredible, and every time you think you've got one up on the writers and that they might be going in a predictable route, they turn the entire thing on its head and disrupt your expectations entirely!

    The show doesn't shy away from its dark plots, but it also doesn't paint a dreary depressing galaxy like many of the semi-recent sci-fi successes (i.e. Battlestar Galactica, Stargate Atlantis). Hope and adventure are always right around the corner and every episode you're left at the edge of your seat eagerly waiting to find out what happens next.

    Again, if what you like is the shallow, feel-good, low energy writing of past Star Trek series, you're going to hate this. If you hate the fact that the only straight white male character on this show is essentially a side character even though he's the captain because you HATE representation and diversity, you will hate this show (and you're a piece of crap human being). If you feel like no one has any right to EVER change or update any media from your childhood memories (OMG MAH KLINGONS!) you'll hate this show. But if you're actually open to what is a BRILLIANTLY written show with amazing characters, writing, and acting, you will NOT be disappointed. This is one of the best sci-fi shows out there right now, right along with The Expanse.    … Expand
  74. Daddyoh
    Apr 11, 2019
    10
    I'm half way through the second season and I love this show. It has amazing twists and turns and keeps you guessing. Science Fiction at it's best. Great CGI, great stories and deep complicated characters.

    Is there a problem? Only if you are a gate-keeping die hard ST fan because the look and feel of the series strays from Roddenberry's creation. That said there are enough intertwining    I'm half way through the second season and I love this show. It has amazing twists and turns and keeps you guessing. Science Fiction at it's best. Great CGI, great stories and deep complicated characters.

    Is there a problem? Only if you are a gate-keeping die hard ST fan because the look and feel of the series strays from Roddenberry's creation. That said there are enough intertwining story arcs from the original series (Captain Pike, Talos 4) to keep ST connoisseurs entertained.

    I am a big ST fan - love the original ST, loved TNG - so-so on DS9 - loved Voyager and Enterprise. Although not 100% Star Trek it is a great Sci-fi series. Well done!    … Expand
  75. MrShmoove
    Sep 25, 2017
    9
    Saw both episodes off the CBS All Access app on the PS4. I've noticed some people complaining due to continuity issues in other review. Don't they realize that THIS series is OBVIOUSLY done in the JJ Abrams style so the continuity would be from THAT timeline?!?!! O.o

    Anyways to the show itself **some spoilers**. The title sequence sucks. I much prefer the outer space scenes of    Saw both episodes off the CBS All Access app on the PS4. I've noticed some people complaining due to continuity issues in other review. Don't they realize that THIS series is OBVIOUSLY done in the JJ Abrams style so the continuity would be from THAT timeline?!?!! O.o

    Anyways to the show itself **some spoilers**.

    The title sequence sucks. I much prefer the outer space scenes of previous series that have come before it. The set design is like the JJ Abrams movies style. Even has the lens flare! The cast seemed really small at first with only really 3 characters standing out, BUT we found out why in the second episode why they didn't focus on the different characters of the bridge crew.

    Michelle Yeoh was good as the Captain and Sonequa Martin Greene was great as her #1. The green eyed alien was a little hard to get to like cause he's such a wuss but he may grow on you as the series progresses. I LOVE the fact that we are finally getting to see the war between the Federation and the Klingons that has been talked about on previous shows like TNG. BUT the Klingons didn't look right. Their skin color was off (too dark) and they looked more reptilian than any of the previous shows. Wish they would have stuck to the old makeups.

    First episode was the setup while episode two brought the action...and OHHH did they bring it! Two fleets in a massive battle with well over 10,000 combined casualties between the two sides (8100+ just for the Federation). I am sad to see that Michelle Yeoh was killed off in episode two though. Would have liked to have seen her stay as Captain. Will see how the new guy does that they showed is coming up next week.

    Overall great start. Not perfect but beats the HELL out of The Orville!    … Expand
  76. Denis_IRL
    Mar 4, 2018
    9
    Loved it. Seems harsh some of the negativity. Agree the characters lack emotional depth but other than that the storyline is fantastic, it keeps pushing and pushing, wonderfully creative. Why do people review something after only 2 episodes?
  77. Skeletor71
    Sep 25, 2017
    9
    Just as I thought. The Orville is more Star Trek than this. But... I really enjoyed it. I watched it on Dutch Netflix and I was VERY disappointed when I found out I had to wait another week for a new episode.
  78. sanitariusz
    Sep 26, 2017
    9
    Really good start. As a ST fan from more then 30 years I can say that new show is unexpectedly good. Anyway I'm not able understand all these bad comments because new trek is different then treks before. New Klingons are excellent!
  79. Datzman290
    Jan 5, 2018
    9
    There have really been only 3 Star Trek shows on television that I have REALLY enjoyed. The original series with it's eternally beloved characters, Enterprise which I believe tried to lose the pseudo-science and get back to its action roots, and now Discovery. It has been one of the few shows in recent memory where I couldn't wait for the next episode. Was it perfect? No. Did I HATE theThere have really been only 3 Star Trek shows on television that I have REALLY enjoyed. The original series with it's eternally beloved characters, Enterprise which I believe tried to lose the pseudo-science and get back to its action roots, and now Discovery. It has been one of the few shows in recent memory where I couldn't wait for the next episode. Was it perfect? No. Did I HATE the CBS pay per view scheme? Absolutely! However, did I love the show which chose to be different in so many ways? Yes I did! Honestly, I 'm astounded (while writing a review 4 months after the initial premiere) how many bad reviews I see! Looking forward to not only watching it again, but also sincerely hoping another season takes place (though once again NOT with the pay-to-watch scheme)… Expand
  80. Ittiaces
    Feb 5, 2018
    9
    This new venture into the Star Trek universe is set about ten years before the events of the original series and centres around a troubled yet brilliant federation officer called Michael Burnham. I loved this first season, and as a long time, Trekkie have to admit I haven't enjoyed a version of this world so much since The Next Generation. Plotlines were dramatic and well thought out andThis new venture into the Star Trek universe is set about ten years before the events of the original series and centres around a troubled yet brilliant federation officer called Michael Burnham. I loved this first season, and as a long time, Trekkie have to admit I haven't enjoyed a version of this world so much since The Next Generation. Plotlines were dramatic and well thought out and the main characters particularly well developed. Sonequa Martin-Green as Burnham is terrific and skilfully portrays a strong, intelligent if somewhat vulnerable woman, guilt-ridden from a poor decision which destroyed her promising career. The cast, on the whole, is very watchable as an ensemble with some great scenes from Jason Issacs and Anthony Rapp. Shazad Latif is particularly charming as Burnham's unpredictable love interest, and Michelle Yeoh is just brilliant as her mentor. I would have loved a more substantial role for Yeoh; it was great casting to have her as a Captain and one of the main reasons I wanted to see the show.

    The VFX are excellent, and clearly, a large budget was allocated to produce some quality work. It certainly paid off and transported us to many different and exciting locations throughout each episode.

    I do not doubt that a lot of die-hard fans will find fault with this incarnation, it can never be the original or TNG, but it doesn't have to be. It can certainly stand on its own while paying tribute to the trek legacy. I hope season 2 will be as engaging.    … Expand
  81. PandaFromHell05
    Sep 24, 2017
    9
    As a subscriber to CBS All Access, I was able to watch the first 2 episodes of Star Trek Discovery. The first 2 episodes seemed like a 2-part episode, and will be as infamous as all the other 2-part episodes in the Star Trek franchise. My reaction..I enjoyed it!
    I will say, this show takes a little bit out of every Star Trek iteration that has been released so far. First, this show takes    As a subscriber to CBS All Access, I was able to watch the first 2 episodes of Star Trek Discovery. The first 2 episodes seemed like a 2-part episode, and will be as infamous as all the other 2-part episodes in the Star Trek franchise. My reaction..I enjoyed it!
    I will say, this show takes a little bit out of every Star Trek iteration that has been released so far. First, this show takes place 10 years before the original Star Trek series. Like Enterprise, it just seems too advanced for that timeline; however, who is going to watch a series that looks like its from the 1960's? However, I liken it to the J.J. Abram's iterations of Star Trek. This show basically feels like a TV show form of those movies. This form of storytelling also reminds me fondly of Star Trek: Deep Space Nine, which ditches optimism for a grittier story.
    This show, however, is unlike any other Star Trek before it. It takes from the same type of story telling as we've seen in shows like Game of Thrones and Orange is the New Black, using dramatic storytelling and flashback scenes.
    My advice...do the CBS All Access free trial. If you have a Roku or PS4, you can download CBS All Access for free. Watch the first two episodes. This is one of those shows that every Star Trek fan has to watch, and they will either like it (as I do), or they won't. I'm willing to accept that it's different from the other shows and give it a shot. Will you?

    I'm excited to see Episode 3 next week.    … Expand
  82. brentwshelton1
    Oct 2, 2017
    9
    I'm rating this show as a "9" as any TV show generally has some flaws - and Discovery hasn't been immune to that. However, I have to commend it for bringing us a different type of Trek. I'm in my fifties and have been a fan of the original show, TNG, and Voyager. For me the fact that this show portrays Star Fleet officers as flawed is important. If one truly thinks of the "Trek time"I'm rating this show as a "9" as any TV show generally has some flaws - and Discovery hasn't been immune to that. However, I have to commend it for bringing us a different type of Trek. I'm in my fifties and have been a fan of the original show, TNG, and Voyager. For me the fact that this show portrays Star Fleet officers as flawed is important. If one truly thinks of the "Trek time" line - Picard and Janeway were centuries after Lorca. It is totally realistic for Star fleet officers to be darker in nature and fuzzier on ethical grounds than what is achieved in the future. Quite honestly, most of the negative reviews seem to harp on (1) Having to pay (by the way - only if you want to see it right away - I'm sure it will be available on other streaming services or broadcast - after the season ends) and (B) that it isn't exactly the same ( as TNG, etc. Like I said - I'm glad it is a different type of Trek and really excited for the rest of the season! Thnik the cast and writers are doing awesome!… Expand
  83. giovanniremo
    Nov 3, 2017
    9
    Escludendo i primi due episodi, posticci e senza capo ne coda, Discovery è una bella serie che reinterpreta e rinnova lo 'stile Star Trek', ma facendo passi avanti, superando il concetto di 'una avventura alla settimana', introducendo personaggi più complessi che si svelano poco a poco, e avendo finalmente a disposizione i soldi necessari per fare ottima fantascienza. Spero che prosegua a lungo.
  84. YuryVidal
    Sep 27, 2017
    9
    Gostei muito da serie possui a protagonista possui o espirito dos verdadeiros capitães anteriores, muito bem feita com episódios dignos de um filme.
  85. Wexford_C
    Oct 28, 2017
    9
    I have watched the fist 6 episodes so far and have really liked it and the new characters. The characters have all a vulnerability that makes them interesting and the action has been good. It is as good a Star Trek since the best of TNG. Can't wait to seen the rest.
  86. Prosmooth
    Sep 25, 2017
    9
    Based on the first 2 episodes it's very good Trek. Production value is actually higher than usual for a Trek show and the acting was top notch. Haven't met the whole cast yet, because the first 2 eps are kind of a prologue to what the main story will be. The Trump/Nazi crowd hates it because it has a female person of color in the lead role. That is the basis for all these hateful reviews.Based on the first 2 episodes it's very good Trek. Production value is actually higher than usual for a Trek show and the acting was top notch. Haven't met the whole cast yet, because the first 2 eps are kind of a prologue to what the main story will be. The Trump/Nazi crowd hates it because it has a female person of color in the lead role. That is the basis for all these hateful reviews. Sad world we live in.… Expand
  87. electronicoffee
    Oct 27, 2017
    9
    I absolutely love it when a show can take classic style and mesh it with futuristic graphics. This is why as fun as the star wars universe is- I've preferred the star trek universe visually. I love that throwback style, even when touches of deep future scifi aesthetic are added (ds9, voyager), moreso I've preferred the star trek universe because at it's heart star wars is another genreI absolutely love it when a show can take classic style and mesh it with futuristic graphics. This is why as fun as the star wars universe is- I've preferred the star trek universe visually. I love that throwback style, even when touches of deep future scifi aesthetic are added (ds9, voyager), moreso I've preferred the star trek universe because at it's heart star wars is another genre (some say space opera, drama/romance, etc.) with scifi as it's setting rather than it's focus while star trek, due to it's inherent nature (being 'mission' or 'protocol' based) assigns the plot / events in most episodes or story arcs from a certain mindset and this does that very well although the crew in this is tossed together due more to events and outcomes. The enemies are redesigned with a gothic feel, showing the series is learning from it's adversary (the SW universe) learning to slide a little extra into the 'feel' of an enemy and of the show, sometimes a little flash does a LOT for a show like this leaving it feeling more like a science / adventuring show with elements of war and the flash and payoff of game of thrones. Few could do a better job doing a prequel and balancing the level of depth (such as the Mycelium Drive and it's issues/story) with the sizzle and level of visual delight we've come to expect from AA and AAA shows. Give it a few episodes, as many characters and the cast change about swiftly.… Expand
  88. alejandro970
    Dec 3, 2017
    9
    It keeps fidelity to the spirit of original series with great work in special effects and a multiethnic cast. The final chapter develops curiosity for what will happen next season.
  89. JorgeLestre
    Nov 23, 2017
    9
    It is visually engaging and Sonequa Martin-Green is definitely a very good and interesting lead. Although it stumbles a bit in the story, Star Trek Discovery is a very dense and dark space opera.
  90. chrispezza
    Sep 25, 2017
    9
    Fan reviews here are way too harsh. This is a great evolution of the franchise, with above-average acting featuring strong female leads, good production value (which is more than can be said of most Star Trek TV), and a good story to kick things off.

    The 2 episode premiere was better produced than all Star Trek television series aside from the Original (which is impossible to beat due    Fan reviews here are way too harsh. This is a great evolution of the franchise, with above-average acting featuring strong female leads, good production value (which is more than can be said of most Star Trek TV), and a good story to kick things off.

    The 2 episode premiere was better produced than all Star Trek television series aside from the Original (which is impossible to beat due to it's legacy), and Star Trek TNG, which doesn't really get going til Season 3, and is philosophically brilliant + features Patrick Stewart, who like the Original, is hard to beat.

    All in all this was a fun watch with great production value and good kickoff story to set up for the season. I'm excited to see where it heads next.    … Expand
  91. Method__Man
    Jan 22, 2019
    9
    Don't believe the haters! Firstly, I am not a fan of the klingon redesign, but literally all else of the show is great. It actually starts off rather quick (almost too quick), then properly settles back in pace before escalating again. I have watched and been a fan of star trek for 33 years. This shows has the feel, the charm, and the lore of a modern star trek.

    Of course you will get    Don't believe the haters! Firstly, I am not a fan of the klingon redesign, but literally all else of the show is great. It actually starts off rather quick (almost too quick), then properly settles back in pace before escalating again. I have watched and been a fan of star trek for 33 years. This shows has the feel, the charm, and the lore of a modern star trek.

    Of course you will get the butthurt "trekkies" who will be unhappy no matter what happens, but this was a VERY solid attempt at star trek after so long. I cannot wait for more.    … Expand
  92. Santakrooz
    Oct 9, 2017
    9
    Huge ST and TNG fan. I like it - a lot. I also like the theatrical reboots fwiw. I just disagree with the negative reviews on here. We loved it from the pilot and are up to episode 4. I think the acting is good, the characters are interesting, and it's an interesting and action oriented Star Trek story that follows the Star Trek philosophy and general storyline, but not necessarilyHuge ST and TNG fan. I like it - a lot. I also like the theatrical reboots fwiw. I just disagree with the negative reviews on here. We loved it from the pilot and are up to episode 4. I think the acting is good, the characters are interesting, and it's an interesting and action oriented Star Trek story that follows the Star Trek philosophy and general storyline, but not necessarily the canon perfectly, which is fine with me. TNG didn't follow perfectly either, and neither did the original movies. The characters are different, which I think rubs some people the wrong way, they're looking for another Picard or Janeway or Kirk, and these are different characters - and they're interesting, flawed, mysterious. We're digging it. We also like the whole Klingon reboot - and backstory. The FX are amazing, but we're addicted to the storyline and the action. Great series.… Expand
  93. ShannonS
    Sep 25, 2017
    9
    This is the Star Trek I have wanted for decades. The FX is blockbuster grade, the casting is great, I loved the interaction between characters and loved the unexpected twist there.That being said, I do not think this should have been split as it was, the Vulcan Hello" does not stand on its own well, it needed the second part and viewers only seeing the first are really missing key parts.This is the Star Trek I have wanted for decades. The FX is blockbuster grade, the casting is great, I loved the interaction between characters and loved the unexpected twist there.That being said, I do not think this should have been split as it was, the Vulcan Hello" does not stand on its own well, it needed the second part and viewers only seeing the first are really missing key parts. I think CBS screwed up by hiding the needed 2nd half online.… Expand
  94. Esterling
    Sep 25, 2017
    9
    Strongly character driven, which much to be revealed. Makes you want to keep watching. It is a good starting point for a new series even if I hate the timeframe. If nothing else it keeps people interested and continues to boldly go forward. He's hoping it spawns a future series after Voyager. Give it a chance people!
  95. arkton
    Sep 25, 2017
    9
    I enjoyed watching the first two episodes of the new show. And yes, I'm grateful and happy that Star Trek lives and received another show after such a long time. You can't expect that the show does the same things in the same way they did 20 years back. It's a modern Star Trek, playing in the prime timeline (what a relief), has stunning visuals and a good feel to it. It's not only actionI enjoyed watching the first two episodes of the new show. And yes, I'm grateful and happy that Star Trek lives and received another show after such a long time. You can't expect that the show does the same things in the same way they did 20 years back. It's a modern Star Trek, playing in the prime timeline (what a relief), has stunning visuals and a good feel to it. It's not only action like the trailer suggests, it is a good mix between action, dialog and exploration.

    I look forward seeing how the story progresses and how the characters evolve. It has been a good setup so far. Klingons are different, but not so much that you can't make a connection to how they are later in the timeline.

    Be flexible in thought, open to new, and enjoy this Star Trek. I sure do and hope this lives long and prospers.    … Expand
  96. Gerd76
    Nov 6, 2017
    9
    as a long time fan of star trek i can say that this is a fresh start and i love the little nuances that are there from the older series and films. Some may hate that this is not in the same concept of TNG etc, but more of the same is not always good for a series. My mother, me and my brother are all star trek fans, and we all agree that this is a good series
  97. KILLyrIDOLS1
    Oct 2, 2017
    9
    So many other reviews have completely missed the point or applied a standard that every other Star Trek series would also fail to meet. The first several episodes were great and a real return to form for the franchise after several movies that really seemed to, like so many users on this site, miss the whole point of what star trek is supposed to be about.
  98. Brittany123
    Oct 3, 2017
    9
    Very Impressed.
    I am really glad that Metacritic takes into consideration the user and critic reviews because I really enjoyed this show. If you just read the user reviews you would probably never watch this series because of how terribly it is scored. I cannot speak to how different it is from the previous Star Treks and that seems to be a sore point with some users. However, a lot of    Very Impressed.
    I am really glad that Metacritic takes into consideration the user and critic reviews because I really enjoyed this show. If you just read the user reviews you would probably never watch this series because of how terribly it is scored. I cannot speak to how different it is from the previous Star Treks and that seems to be a sore point with some users. However, a lot of the negative reviews seem to be focusing on the fact that the two highest ranking officers on the show are both female minorities.
    Don't let the internet trollers prevent you from watching it.
    Great story
    Insightful characters
    Excited to see whats to come!    … Expand
  99. yiannis23
    Oct 5, 2017
    9
    To be honest, I don't understand all the negative user reviews. Probably they come from Star Wars fans who are just jealous :-) I've been a Star Trek fan all my life, I've also been to a couple of conventions In Vegas so I think I am entitled to have an opinion on to whether Discovery is Star trek material or not. The answer is simple, YES IT IS. It focuses on the character, it adheresTo be honest, I don't understand all the negative user reviews. Probably they come from Star Wars fans who are just jealous :-) I've been a Star Trek fan all my life, I've also been to a couple of conventions In Vegas so I think I am entitled to have an opinion on to whether Discovery is Star trek material or not. The answer is simple, YES IT IS. It focuses on the character, it adheres with the Federation Directives, it brings out the Star Trek culture as we the fans know it. If I could compare it with one of the oder series, I would say that it is a mix between TOS and ENT. Actually I find it much more Star Trek than the recent Chris Pine movies. We need to give DIS a chance to reveal its true potential. Don't forget how awful the first season of DS9 was; at least in DIS we see a lot of action and story. Let's hope it will bring CBS the numbers otherwise I don't think we will be around for the next Star Trek TV series :-)… Expand
  100. pleitch
    Apr 13, 2019
    9
    Totally rewriting and rerating my review after the end of season 1 and season 2.
    In short - the beginning of Season 1 was a misstep that has been more than corrected for. I've gone from a detractor to a fan. Well done for turning this around.
prev
Page:

Awards & Rankings

80
#80 Best TV Season of 2017
1
#1 Most Discussed TV Season of 2017
9
#9 Most Shared TV Season of 2017

Critic Reviews

All reviews »
Metascore
72

Generally favorable reviews - based on 20 Critic Reviews

Critic score distribution:
  1. Positive: 15 out of 20
  2. Mixed: 5 out of 20
  3. Negative: 0 out of 20
  1. The New York Times
    Reviewed by: James Poniewozik
    Oct 19, 2017
    50
    Discovery feels like it’s adrift between the adventure-of-the-week format of its network-TV predecessors and the kind of complex serial favored by cable and streaming.
    Read full review
  2. The Oregonian
    Reviewed by: Kristi Turnquist
    Sep 26, 2017
    60
    Star Trek: Discovery feels like it's just finding its footing. On the promising side, Doug Jones is already a standout as Science Officer Lt. Saru, who's from an alien race called Kelpiens. And James Frain is perfectly cast as Sarek, the Vulcan who veteran "Trek" fans know as the father of Spock. The relationship between Burnham and Sarek is one of the more intriguing aspects of Star Trek: Discovery.
    Read full review
  3. Salon
    Reviewed by: Melanie McFarland
    Sep 26, 2017
    80
    Happily Star Trek: Discovery strikes a balance between what diehard Trekkies love about Roddenberry’s universe and what J.J. Abrams injected into its theatrical resurrection. Ethical dilemmas and a clash between cultures and traditions comprise the fore of the narrative, but the hours don’t skimp on phaser blasts and broadcast-appropriate carnage.
    Read full review
See all critic reviews »