• Network: Netflix
  • Series Premiere Date: Mar 17, 2017
Season #: 2, 1
User Score
6.1

Generally favorable reviews- based on 1318 Ratings

User score distribution:
Watch Now

Where To Watch

Buy on
Stream On
Stream On

Review this tv show

  1. Your Score
    0 out of 10
    Rate this:
    • 10
    • 9
    • 8
    • 7
    • 6
    • 5
    • 4
    • 3
    • 2
    • 1
    • 0
    • 0
  1. Submit
  2. Check Spelling

User Reviews

  1. Aug 5, 2021
    0
    I really can’t find anything positive to say about Iron Fist season 1. This season is evidence that while Marvel has had a lot of success with both movies and TV shows in recent years, they can still be hit or miss. IF is a huge miss, and it’s disappointing that it’s a miss since the story behind this show could’ve been really engaging and interesting had everything else not been executedI really can’t find anything positive to say about Iron Fist season 1. This season is evidence that while Marvel has had a lot of success with both movies and TV shows in recent years, they can still be hit or miss. IF is a huge miss, and it’s disappointing that it’s a miss since the story behind this show could’ve been really engaging and interesting had everything else not been executed so poorly. The writing, directing, action and acting are all nowhere near as good as they are in other Marvel Netflix shows and all should’ve been done differently. The scenes are awkward and don’t flow very well, and the chemistry between the actors isn’t great either, which makes so many moments in the show feel like a drag. The action and martial arts scenes are ok at best and if you’re looking for some really good fight sequences I’d recommend you go look at Daredevil, which has top notch fight choreography. There are also some plainly stupid moments and plot points in the season that just make it ridiculous. There are things that shouldn’t have been included in the season and areas that should’ve gotten a lot more focus. The acting doesn’t help much either; Finn Jones wasn’t the greatest casting choice for Danny Rand and doesn’t play the part the way it deserves to be played. Jessica Henwick does a decent job of portraying Colleen Wing but she isn’t enough to keep the season afloat. There are some moments in the show that have promise, but they don’t generate enough momentum to really get the show going and make it exciting. My best advice with this show is to binge watch it and get it over with as quickly as possible so it doesn’t feel like a joyless slog or to not watch it at all to save yourself the boredom. IF s1 is a big disappointment and I hope the character is able to earn redemption someday, hopefully in the MCU. Expand
  2. Sep 19, 2018
    1
    What's the opposite of "Marvel?" ... Annoying, dragging, indecisive. A lengthy melodrama that has some good technical points and stand-out actors, but fails overall to engage under the orchestration of a dull, dragging, unnecessary script! Predictable and what's not predictable doesn't add to any excitement. This series is the definition of Mental Garbage.
  3. Jun 14, 2018
    0
    Things I would rather do than watch this awful actor play an awful character with awful dialogue in an awful plot line: anything else!

    This is by far the most horrendous Marvel production yet made. Baaaaaaad.
  4. Jan 16, 2018
    2
    Iron Fist more like Iron Complete Bollocks Ass.

    If Iron Fist was a show consisting only of the actually interesting stuff, it would be three to four episodes max instead of 13 goddamn episodes. Danny Rand/Iron Fist and Colleen Wing are the only good things about this thing. When they're on-screen, the show is alright, sometimes even quite cute. I liked their chemistry and every time
    Iron Fist more like Iron Complete Bollocks Ass.

    If Iron Fist was a show consisting only of the actually interesting stuff, it would be three to four episodes max instead of 13 goddamn episodes. Danny Rand/Iron Fist and Colleen Wing are the only good things about this thing. When they're on-screen, the show is alright, sometimes even quite cute. I liked their chemistry and every time they were in the show something was actually happening.

    But about 60-70% of the show is dedicated to a storyline focusing on Rand Enterprises and its staff, and it's one of the most lifeless, annoying, frustrating, stupid and repetitive storylines I've seen so far. Seriously, that storyline is absolute bollocks. Complete tosh. Dreadful. It is so obviously filler and so out of place that there wasn't a single moment I was enjoying it. The characters Ward and Joy are terrible. They're completely empty and lifelessly acted. Even after just a couple scenes of that business stuff that repeats itself over and over again I was hoping for anything else. The badly edited action scenes that happened probably once every two episodes felt like heaven after watching Ward and Joy talk about stuff over and over again. At one point in the show Ward's dad, Harold, becomes a bigger character and he joins the stupid conversations too, and he was at times even more annoying than Ward. The show never shows, it just tells and it's awfully uninteresting.

    Luckily the show somewhat improves in the later episodes. We start to get more of Danny and Colleen and a lot more happens than just constant talking. Some of the dojo scenes were pretty fun and had some cool soundtrack choices and in episode 12 we get a lot more action too even though it's still pretty badly shot and there isn't really a feeling of weight in it. Sometimes Danny looks like he only has to dodge and everyone flies to a wall and sometimes he struggles against one freaking guy. It's definitely better than any of the Rand Enterprises stuff but not exactly something I'd care to watch again.

    Even if the final few episodes were better, they came far too late and still had some of the terrible stuff in them too and by the end I was just glad for the show to be over. All in all, Iron Fist is bollocks. Not recommended.
    Expand
  5. Dec 25, 2017
    3
    I was looking forward to the series as it was something more magical in marvel tv, it started off great but about half way through it got stupid and ridiculous, Finn Jones is a terrible actor and he's like a crying baby throughout the series, Jessica Henwick stole the show and her acting was fantastic, she held the series together with an interesting character and a strong performance.
  6. Nov 28, 2017
    0
    Well, i think that the Iron Fist have so many problems that one could really see in the show, that it is a failure for Marvel + Netflix, i dindt enjoy at all, all i want was that the Iron Fist's Girl die or give something more to the drama and that didnt happend... all the history of The Hand we all know it i dont know why they tell us again, and The Iron Fist looks like a Kid with aWell, i think that the Iron Fist have so many problems that one could really see in the show, that it is a failure for Marvel + Netflix, i dindt enjoy at all, all i want was that the Iron Fist's Girl die or give something more to the drama and that didnt happend... all the history of The Hand we all know it i dont know why they tell us again, and The Iron Fist looks like a Kid with a Power, always saying " I am The Inmortal Iron Fist" and doing nothing. Poor Show. Expand
  7. Nov 4, 2017
    0
    Straight Garbage. How Marvel lets someone like Scott Buck make a hot mess out of a character like Iron Fist?
    Finn Jones is miscast, the villains are decent, the action scenes don't feel "Iron-Fisty". Even the CGI looks bad.
    It's disappointing that Netflix's Marvel came from great quality of Daredevil to this. The only good thing about this show was Jessica Henwick, who i cared more
    Straight Garbage. How Marvel lets someone like Scott Buck make a hot mess out of a character like Iron Fist?
    Finn Jones is miscast, the villains are decent, the action scenes don't feel "Iron-Fisty". Even the CGI looks bad.
    It's disappointing that Netflix's Marvel came from great quality of Daredevil to this.
    The only good thing about this show was Jessica Henwick, who i cared more about than the Iron Fist himself.
    Expand
  8. Oct 16, 2017
    3
    It's a real pain to watch. The plot doesn't seem to go anywhere, the characters look all empty and there's nothing interesting about them. Totally boring
  9. Oct 2, 2017
    2
    Sooo boring, i watched the 13 episodes in around 5-6 hours, kept hitting fast forward just to stay awake. The fight scenes are super lame, and the characters are stupid, especially iron fist. i just wanted to punch him in the face and tell him "wake up ****
  10. Aug 29, 2017
    3
    It sure is a show. The character Jones portrays is obnoxious and difficult to relate to, unlike the other "Defenders". The Meechums came off as flip floppy and odd. Fight scenes became tiresome and repetitive, how many nameless ninjas can we throw in? I believe Jones tried his best, but you can't fake something like martial arts mastery. They can tell us this guy is the most badass fighterIt sure is a show. The character Jones portrays is obnoxious and difficult to relate to, unlike the other "Defenders". The Meechums came off as flip floppy and odd. Fight scenes became tiresome and repetitive, how many nameless ninjas can we throw in? I believe Jones tried his best, but you can't fake something like martial arts mastery. They can tell us this guy is the most badass fighter in all of heavenly Kun Lun, but his struggles with even basic enemies and controlling his chi make me think wonder "why can't we have Daredevil take up this quest?" Iron Fist brings nothing new to the table. Even worse, The Defenders hinges on plot laid by Iron Fist. Risky move that didn't pan out. Expand
  11. May 20, 2017
    3
    Metacritic said I needed 150 characters to review this. So I'm adding filler to the point where I could write what I'd intended to at . TURN BACK NOW
  12. May 16, 2017
    3
    No me gusta dejar ninguna serie a la mitad, y esa es la razon por la que voy mirando actualmente el cap. 11 y he de decir que mi sentimiento de decepción era tal que salir por toda internet a buscar donde expresar mi total decepción por este "DISPARATE",

    Diálogos pobres, conversaciones sin sentido y escenas muy previsibles. Tenemos a un Iron Fist que puede usar su puño todo poderoso en
    No me gusta dejar ninguna serie a la mitad, y esa es la razon por la que voy mirando actualmente el cap. 11 y he de decir que mi sentimiento de decepción era tal que salir por toda internet a buscar donde expresar mi total decepción por este "DISPARATE",

    Diálogos pobres, conversaciones sin sentido y escenas muy previsibles. Tenemos a un Iron Fist que puede usar su puño todo poderoso en cualquier momento, pero miro constantemente afanarse con dos o tres enemigos y al parecer olvidarse de que tiene un estúpido puño de hierro. Si ya se todo el tema de que necesita usar su CHI y bla bla bla, pero seamos honestos...

    Las peores escenas de karate, kunfu, taekwondo, yoga o lo que sea que que halla aprendido en el susodicho templo donde aprendió a pelear, son mediocres, poco reales, lentas, sosas. A veces pienso que estoy viendo una escena de los míticos Power Rangers en sus inicios.

    Seré honesto, voy a terminar de ver esta temporada completa, pero con cada capitulo la voy disfrutando menos.
    Expand
  13. May 3, 2017
    3
    I liked it well enough to watch the first season,: this show is about a boy who, after a tragedy grows up in a monetary and learns a powerful ability.

    I find it to be the weakest of the Netflix hero series, but the show stands alone on it own merits; namely, good characters, decent acting, interesting setting, and a budget to support it.

    I will also say, that it is somewhat pretentious.
  14. Apr 13, 2017
    1
    This show is terrible period. This superhero backstory of some white guy who owns a billion dollar company is getting old. Iron fist is a rip off of Batman and the Arrow. It represents the asian culture poorly and filled with just old stereotypes. This show has no break throughs was poorly written and plain boring. I don't recommend this show, the writers and the director need to make someThis show is terrible period. This superhero backstory of some white guy who owns a billion dollar company is getting old. Iron fist is a rip off of Batman and the Arrow. It represents the asian culture poorly and filled with just old stereotypes. This show has no break throughs was poorly written and plain boring. I don't recommend this show, the writers and the director need to make some major changes to make the show feel fresh. I feel like I've seen movies like this too many times, Asian Villain White hero who is suffering from yellow fever. Its 2017 lets change it up a little. Expand
  15. Apr 12, 2017
    3
    Iron Fist starts promising, gets boring and near the end it's just unbearable. The Danny rand character is so hateable, half the time he acts like a 10-year-old kid with personality issues and the other half, like a 14 year-old girl on her period, the only bearable character is Ward, at least most of the time. Simply a waste of time.
  16. Apr 12, 2017
    3
    Its boring. Its Batman with no brain and even dumber villains. "The Hand" is just like the League of Assassins from Batman. The samurai chic is basically a less dark Catwoman. I really dont mind that it is copying another comic book, what I do mind is how bad the story telling and character development is. The characters are simply stupid, though I suppose that is an accurate portrayal ofIts boring. Its Batman with no brain and even dumber villains. "The Hand" is just like the League of Assassins from Batman. The samurai chic is basically a less dark Catwoman. I really dont mind that it is copying another comic book, what I do mind is how bad the story telling and character development is. The characters are simply stupid, though I suppose that is an accurate portrayal of modern day executives and political leaders... but it does not make for good television. When I see politicians do boneheaded things, I dont get interested, I get frustrated and in many ways I felt the same while watching this. I just could not understand any of the decisions made, and certainly everyone in the show deserved to die a painful horrible death for being such lousy thinkers.

    No potential here... and please fire the writers.
    Expand
  17. Apr 10, 2017
    3
    Had high hopes for this show, but was quite disappointed. First off, the dialogue was unimaginative, character development was forced and clunky, and the script was just bad. Finn Jones's Danny Rand comes off as whiny and unlikable. Finn Jones was just not believable in the role. He was just so awkward when he fought or did anything with physical movement that it ruined the scene for me.Had high hopes for this show, but was quite disappointed. First off, the dialogue was unimaginative, character development was forced and clunky, and the script was just bad. Finn Jones's Danny Rand comes off as whiny and unlikable. Finn Jones was just not believable in the role. He was just so awkward when he fought or did anything with physical movement that it ruined the scene for me. Maybe most egregious, the fight scenes were almost hard to watch. There were multiple times where you could see no contact being made, illogical choices during confrontations, and just overly choreographed conflicts. Colleen Wing's character had better, more believable fight scenes than the main character did and she did a commendable job with the character pretty poor material. The Meachum family delivered pretty compelling portrayals of their characters and were one of the few positive of this series. Another problem with this series was the way the Hand was portrayed. In Daredevil, the Hand was a menacing, dangerous legion of mystical ninjas. In Iron Fist, they were a bunch of children and random dudes who took a few self defense classes at the local YMCA. Rosario Dawson was solid as usual, but even she couldn't help elevate the show with its poor writing. I disagree with a lot of users here who think politics played into the critics' reviews of the show. The show was just bad. However, I do think if any other actor with more of an on screen presence and the ability to make us believe he was a actually a master of kung fu were cast, then it would have made a huge difference. Expand
  18. Apr 9, 2017
    3
    This show is too much Tarzan not enough Bruce lee. The incompetent clueless guy excels at everything because of who he was born. There is a strong Martial Arts presence but all the Asian guys are defeated in droves by non Asian guys. All the white guys are bosses,rich, and are only misguided because they put family first. The lead artist is obviously not a martial artist.

    This show
    This show is too much Tarzan not enough Bruce lee. The incompetent clueless guy excels at everything because of who he was born. There is a strong Martial Arts presence but all the Asian guys are defeated in droves by non Asian guys. All the white guys are bosses,rich, and are only misguided because they put family first. The lead artist is obviously not a martial artist.

    This show should be called "Tarzan Fist"

    Some of the fight scenes are good but mostly tainted with Rand pretending to know the arts.
    Expand
  19. Apr 4, 2017
    1
    Iron Fist is shockingly bad -- it's incomprehensible how awfully they've managed to mangle a property that could have been lots of fun. Finn Jones is grating as a whiny, incompetent Danny Rand. David Wenham chews scenery as a wholly unnecessary villain; the Meachum family burns up screen time, engulfing the series as secondary leads that are subpar in all ways. Even the few bright spots --Iron Fist is shockingly bad -- it's incomprehensible how awfully they've managed to mangle a property that could have been lots of fun. Finn Jones is grating as a whiny, incompetent Danny Rand. David Wenham chews scenery as a wholly unnecessary villain; the Meachum family burns up screen time, engulfing the series as secondary leads that are subpar in all ways. Even the few bright spots -- Marvel/Netflix frequent flier Rosario Dawson and Jessica Henwick -- are mistreated by abysmal writing. Skip this, and let's hope Defenders is a much better series. Expand
  20. Apr 2, 2017
    3
    I got half-way through Iron Fist on my way across the country, and after the first episode, I thought "hey, this isn't nearly as bad as I was led to believe. It's not great, but it has some real promise."

    Unfortunately, with each episode, the show gets a little worse, not better. What happened, Netflix? Your other Marvel-based shows has been so, but this one just has crappy writing and
    I got half-way through Iron Fist on my way across the country, and after the first episode, I thought "hey, this isn't nearly as bad as I was led to believe. It's not great, but it has some real promise."

    Unfortunately, with each episode, the show gets a little worse, not better. What happened, Netflix? Your other Marvel-based shows has been so, but this one just has crappy writing and slow pacing. The "corporate evil vs. kind heart" scenarios are presented with a first grade level of nuance. The martial arts aren't very good and are remarkably inconsistent (Danny keeps teaching Colleen how to be a better fighter, yet he keeps getting nearly beaten up by lone thugs without much skill). The pseudo-profundities Danny keeps uttering are cringeworthy, both because they're terribly cheesy AND because they're delivered with an amateurishness that make him sound like a beginner attempting to sound like he thinks "a master" should sound. Colleen's classes are terribly cliched, both in how she teaches and how her students act. The pre-fight (and mid-fight!) poses that Danny adopts are right out of the worst 80s Americanized martial arts movies. I can normally laugh at silly martial arts stereotypes, but these just make me cringe. As I said, the pacing is way off, too. There might be 4 episodes worth of story here, but it takes 13 episodes to tell.

    The cast is pretty good, but the writers should cut their teeth on some low-budget, low-stakes shows to get some practice before tackling ANY network's flagship show, especially for a network that sets a bar as high as Netflix does.

    If you're a big fan of the Netflix Marvel sub-universe, Iron Fist is worth watching to follow the ongoing plot lines that'll weave together in The Defenders, but while it's not exactly a slog to get through, it's not a good show by any stretch of the imagination.
    Expand
  21. Apr 1, 2017
    0
    I don't want to give it a 0 but I feel inclined so that In some way I can balance out the people giving it 10s and 9s that admit it's not a good show. You can't really admit something is bad, and then give it a perfect score. Is it a 0/10? Nah. Is it a 5/10? Yeah, somewhere along those lines. The writing is atrocious, the plot drags on, none of the characters aside from one is remotelyI don't want to give it a 0 but I feel inclined so that In some way I can balance out the people giving it 10s and 9s that admit it's not a good show. You can't really admit something is bad, and then give it a perfect score. Is it a 0/10? Nah. Is it a 5/10? Yeah, somewhere along those lines. The writing is atrocious, the plot drags on, none of the characters aside from one is remotely interesting, the fighting scenes are bad, and the show as a whole lacks originality and any semblance of inspiration. Not all of the performances are bad, most of them are pretty solid honestly. But the show as whole just isn't good. A friend recommended this to me and it made me think less of him. I wouldn't recommend this to anyone who isn't a big fan of the MCU. That's the only enjoyable part, that somehow this all ties into something larger than itself. Expand
  22. Mar 31, 2017
    0
    Plodding, whispered, shadowy. Shows the problem of expanding a 2.5 hour movie to 13 hours. He really doesn't come across as innocent or naive. He comes across as stupid.
  23. Mar 30, 2017
    0
    Does he really have to be so "White Boy" about it? When you think of kung fu warriors who have mastered their craft, and have been "chosen" on top of that, many characteristics come to mind. To name a few: Discipline, dedication, focus, maturity, loyalty to his masters, and wisdom. Everything that billionaire kid Danny Rand has NOT; despite spending 15 years training in a monastery withDoes he really have to be so "White Boy" about it? When you think of kung fu warriors who have mastered their craft, and have been "chosen" on top of that, many characteristics come to mind. To name a few: Discipline, dedication, focus, maturity, loyalty to his masters, and wisdom. Everything that billionaire kid Danny Rand has NOT; despite spending 15 years training in a monastery with monk warriors, and no outside western influence. He fails, and fails, and is quite simply an idiot. Hes way too gullible, or as i like to say A SUCKER. What ancient way of life , and organizations of skilled warriors would give this kid the Iron Fist? He doesn't know who he is, deserted his post, and totally failed in the end. To get it right next time Netflix and Marvel must envision "Kung Warrior". "But rich white kids chosen..." No look at me WARRIOR. "But mix privileged white kid with monk..." NO! WAR RI OR!. Goodness gracious white people, you cant white wash everything. Lets all respect realistic boundaries, please. And if anyone thinks this is racist. No, In an attempt to make worlds collide, Iron Fist waters down kung fu in a way that is quite disrespectful and can be looked at as the oh so common need for white people to hijack a culture , and make themselves appear as the dominant ones. You may continue to watch it, but you will be annoyed by every minute of it. Expand
  24. Mar 30, 2017
    0
    Glad I didn't listen to the critics, I watched 7 episodes in one day and can't wait to watch the rest today. Characters, story and action keep everything moving briskly. This show is like eating potato chips, after 1 or 2 you have to eat some more.
  25. Mar 30, 2017
    1
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. This is mind numbingly awful. I can't believe I hung in for 8 hours! The characters are completely unlikable. (there's your 150) Spoiler... Everything is fine. The Hand is for jerkin a Rand. Expand
  26. Mar 29, 2017
    3
    Premise was great, acting was good or OK, but the story line killed it. So many predictable things.
    I expected a lot more rationality from the main character who spent 15 years in monk training.
    His total naiveness, his stupidity in tricky situations, his gullibility, his lack of control over his emotions.... was just SO SO SO cringe worthy. I felt like slapping the lead character at
    Premise was great, acting was good or OK, but the story line killed it. So many predictable things.
    I expected a lot more rationality from the main character who spent 15 years in monk training.
    His total naiveness, his stupidity in tricky situations, his gullibility, his lack of control over his emotions.... was just SO SO SO cringe worthy. I felt like slapping the lead character at times.
    Story writers and directors just ruined a great great premise.
    So sad.
    Expand
  27. Mar 27, 2017
    0
    The main problem of this show is the main character. He so stupid and naive. Actor is totaly misscasting! He looks like a weak and unprepared. Just a pretty boy, not the strongest fighter in MCU. Fighting and story is also bad
  28. Mar 27, 2017
    2
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Besides the excellent cast (Tony Pelphrey has just too good acting and Jessica Henwick astounds in every aspect), Iron Fist sucks. I'm so sorry to come up here and say it but there isn't any other words to put it clearly.

    You don't know who the fact is the villain, if there's really a villain in this story. I know it could be mature if it worked correctly but in this storyline, where everything is about what is wrong and right, it just doesn't work. This series could use some great villain, with some badness, ugliness and power.

    Madame Gao is a good villain, but her plotline is unconclusive. She jokes everyone, she is immortal, she is a drug dealer and she can use the chi (better than Danny). SHE IS A **** BOSS. But then she is just aprisioned by the Hand (a organization where she has some kind of leadership) in a room and isn't abble to be rescued by the Hand (HER Hand) and she also isn't abble to kick the door off with her power.

    The Hand itself doesn't work well. It's just a bunch of teenagers trying to be sucessful in life: what is wrong with you, Danny??

    Daredevil kicks drug dealers asses, Luke Cage tanks a lot of bullets (specially from the police) and Jessica Jones drinks a lot and still have the time to save the city from a freaking crazy mastermind controller son of a **** (Luv U Killgrave). Danny can't do anything like that. Coleen is the real deal here. She kills the leader of the High School "the Hand" Musical. She is the one who has a katana and DOENS'T LOSE A FIGHT. WHAT A BOSS, I say.

    The other villain, the last villain, the main villain. Harald Meachum. What can I say? He is the worst villain from the Netflix superhero series. And any other superhero from Netflix (AKA Jessica, Luke or Matt) would beat the **** out of him, without being hit by a shot.

    Not even the fighting scenes are really cool. They're just generic. The kind of thing you can see in Arrow or Agents of Shield. It would be nice to see some chinese coreographys and mistic things from chi and Kun-Lun, but in the end I kept caged in business bull**** and familiar tragedy 80% of the time.

    Disappointed. Just disappointed.
    Expand
  29. Mar 27, 2017
    0
    I tried to give it a chance but it is unbearably bad on all levels. what a disappointment! Firstly the lead is terribly miscast. Awful fight scenes. Terrible wooden dialogue.
  30. Mar 24, 2017
    3
    After a few episodes in, I could not stand the boring 'he said, she did blah blah' conversations any more.
    Because of respect to the actors, I finished the show but with a twisted arm
Metascore
37

Generally unfavorable reviews - based on 21 Critic Reviews

Critic score distribution:
  1. Positive: 0 out of 21
  2. Negative: 11 out of 21
  1. Reviewed by: Jonathan L. Fischer
    Mar 20, 2017
    30
    Unfortunately, the trouble with Iron Fist doesn’t end once you start actually watching the show, which like its character, is occasionally sweet, frequently maddening, and ultimately kind of lost in Marvel’s New York.
  2. Reviewed by: Alex Abad-Santos
    Mar 20, 2017
    30
    The clunky dialogue often creates the sense that the show doesn’t trust its audience. ... Everyone fights the same, and no one looks interesting doing it.
  3. TV Guide Magazine
    Reviewed by: Matt Roush
    Mar 17, 2017
    60
    If Iron Fist pulls it punches in the originality department, it excels in thrilling martial arts action. [20 Mar - 2 Apr 2017, p.19]