Critic Reviews
- Critic score
- Publication
- By date
-
The series’ measured tone allows the richness of the characters and the dialogue to shine, even though much of the narrative is laden with medical jargon.
-
It’s not a comedy, but in a way it is — second chances and all. And Parker, who shines a light all over the show, is particularly delightful and moving in her reborn persona. “Doc” can be a little corny, a little too obviously like television, when it comes to the cases, but is all in all quite entertaining.
-
Doc ultimately doesn’t break a lot of new ground, but it doesn’t need to. .... Parker’s nuanced lead performance — and the fact the writing doesn’t let Amy off the hook for her attitude or smooth down her rough edges — makes the show worth a watch and distinguishes it from similar fare.
-
A loaded plate of melodramatic angst. ... And yet Parker so deftly defines the pre- and post-accident Amy that we can't help but root for the reformed and humbled (though still gifted) doc. [20 Jan - 9 Feb 2025, p.6]
-
It’s an intriguing start to the series but the beats that follow flow predictably from the show’s premise.
-
It’s a painless watch, brisk enough to keep from being boring and slick enough to never become too frustrating. But it’s also rarely bold or exciting enough to leave a lasting impression. Aimed right down the middle, it hits its target perhaps too well.
-
The series can't decide if it cares more about Amy's amnesia and personal relationships or the case-of-the-week medical drama. Each episode is heavily unbalanced and poorly paced.
-
Doc doesn’t fail because it’s full of medical show cliches. It fails because its central premise feels like a house of cards, and there won’t be much to watch when it collapses.