The Atlantic's Scores
- Movies
- TV
For 593 reviews, this publication has graded:
-
56% higher than the average critic
-
2% same as the average critic
-
42% lower than the average critic
On average, this publication grades 4.8 points higher than other critics.
(0-100 point scale)
Average Movie review score: 70
| Highest review score: | Clouds of Sils Maria | |
|---|---|---|
| Lowest review score: | Melania |
Score distribution:
-
Positive: 420 out of 593
-
Mixed: 117 out of 593
-
Negative: 56 out of 593
593
movie
reviews
- By Date
- By Critic Score
-
-
Reviewed by
David Sims
That The Rip is such a bland venue for its charismatic stars’ reunion is a terrible shame.- The Atlantic
- Posted Jan 21, 2026
- Read full review
-
Reviewed by
-
-
Reviewed by
David Sims
For all its powerful elements, though, Hamnet rings a bit hollow at its core. Perhaps the grand tragedies are just too overwhelming for some viewers to see beyond. I cried, yes, but in the end, I felt no closer to the mysterious bard—let alone to the people he loved, all those hundreds of years ago.- The Atlantic
- Posted Dec 1, 2025
- Read full review
-
Reviewed by
-
-
Reviewed by
David Sims
The best I can say about For Good is that its two stars, Cynthia Erivo (as the green-skinned witch Elphaba) and Ariana Grande (her sickeningly sweet friend Glinda), are strong-enough performers to make the most bizarre turns feel functional. But even they can’t keep the film from collapsing under the lightest scrutiny.- The Atlantic
- Posted Nov 24, 2025
- Read full review
-
Reviewed by
-
-
Reviewed by
David Sims
For Frankenstein, Netflix handed him a massive budget to play with, and the money is all up on the big screen, if you can catch the movie on one. But just like del Toro’s previous reverent adaptations, all of that sumptuousness is hamstrung by his apparent desire to remain faithful to the original tale.- The Atlantic
- Posted Nov 13, 2025
- Read full review
-
Reviewed by
-
-
Reviewed by
David Sims
It’s another superficial, techno-futuristic tale that emphasizes its glossy look over its heady concept.- The Atlantic
- Posted Oct 16, 2025
- Read full review
-
Reviewed by
-
-
Reviewed by
David Sims
In Caught Stealing, Aronofsky drops the viewer into an older New York as another artistic exercise, but renders it as a playground for bloody and one-dimensional silliness. His skill as a cinematic storyteller is on display—I just missed the narrative depth and danger that used to come with the elegant shots.- The Atlantic
- Posted Aug 30, 2025
- Read full review
-
Reviewed by
-
-
Reviewed by
David Sims
As an effort to breathe new life into a particularly moribund title—there have been four prior takes on these characters, all of them bad—First Steps is essentially successful. What it somehow can’t manage to do is have much of a good time in the process.- The Atlantic
- Posted Jul 25, 2025
- Read full review
-
Reviewed by
-
-
Reviewed by
David Sims
Yes, visual-effects technology is up to the task of re-creating a cartoon on a larger scale and dotted with real actors, and yes, these redos tend to turn a profit for their makers. These shouldn’t be the only reasons for art to exist.- The Atlantic
- Posted Jun 13, 2025
- Read full review
-
Reviewed by
-
-
Reviewed by
David Sims
Ballerina ultimately succeeds as a piece of junky fun, however, because it attempts to expand the Wick canon rather than deepen its titular protagonist.- The Atlantic
- Posted Jun 11, 2025
- Read full review
-
Reviewed by
-
-
Reviewed by
David Sims
Bring Her Back is far more confident in its portrayal of Laura’s own story, building to a devastating and intense conclusion about the extent of her loss and her inability to deal with it. Hawkins is up to the challenge, and the rest of the ensemble is strong enough to keep pace. But many of those story beats feel perfunctory; the film comes to life in the nastier, grislier set pieces.- The Atlantic
- Posted May 30, 2025
- Read full review
-
Reviewed by
-
-
Reviewed by
Shirley Li
The Electric State is so transparently eager to satisfy as many demographics of viewers as possible that it proves its own message: that a world dependent on business interests and technological optimization dulls artistic potential and human ingenuity. All that’s left is a wasteland of half-baked ideas searching for a home.- The Atlantic
- Posted Mar 31, 2025
- Read full review
-
Reviewed by
-
-
Reviewed by
David Sims
Companion is at best a mean little confection, no matter how much you know going into it: amusing, occasionally thrilling, but not something with the capability to linger.- The Atlantic
- Posted Feb 5, 2025
- Read full review
-
Reviewed by
-
-
Reviewed by
Shirley Li
A generic and plodding revenge thriller that’s nowhere near bold enough to justify the franchise’s resurrection.- The Atlantic
- Posted Aug 27, 2024
- Read full review
-
Reviewed by
-
-
Reviewed by
David Sims
Feige’s mainstream instincts are easy to detect here. The prior Deadpool films were scuzzy and cobbled together, even as the budget grew; the cameos from other Marvel characters felt half-hearted and perfunctory, inclusions for Deadpool to roll his eyes at, not for fans to cheer over. Deadpool & Wolverine, on the other hand, has that bland MCU sheen that makes all of its movies look expensive but nonthreatening, happily accepting of mediocrity rather than attempting something artsy or daring.- The Atlantic
- Posted Jul 23, 2024
- Read full review
-
Reviewed by
-
-
Reviewed by
David Sims
Although it’s often charming and relatable, it’s a letdown when you consider the heights such a project could reach.- The Atlantic
- Posted Jun 13, 2024
- Read full review
-
Reviewed by
-
-
Reviewed by
David Sims
The result is a functional if unspectacular film that makes no outsize effort to speak to cultural conversations around the movie.- The Atlantic
- Posted Apr 4, 2024
- Read full review
-
Reviewed by
-
- The Atlantic
- Posted Feb 2, 2024
- Read full review
-
-
Reviewed by
David Sims
By making Nyad a narrative film, the movie succumbs to a lot of boring biopic-storytelling shorthand; Nyad sometimes states her goals and fears aloud in the middle of conversation. Much of the thuddingly expositional dialogue cannot escape the sense that it sprouted from an expanded Wikipedia page.- The Atlantic
- Posted Nov 10, 2023
- Read full review
-
Reviewed by
-
-
Reviewed by
David Sims
Dream Scenario morphs from a Charlie Kaufman–esque cringe comedy into a simmering nightmare thriller, staging some genuinely unsettling hallucinations but failing to knit them into any larger narrative.- The Atlantic
- Posted Nov 9, 2023
- Read full review
-
Reviewed by
-
-
Reviewed by
Shirley Li
Fair Play positions itself as a psychosexual thriller, but it’s neither truly provocative nor all that sexy.- The Atlantic
- Posted Oct 26, 2023
- Read full review
-
Reviewed by
-
-
Reviewed by
David Sims
It’s fun, in a depraved way, to see him trotted out for one more ride, but Jigsaw won’t be around to play games with us forever. Enjoy it while it lasts.- The Atlantic
- Posted Oct 6, 2023
- Read full review
-
Reviewed by
-
-
Reviewed by
David Sims
It seems some cheap frights were slipped into a narrative otherwise aiming for deeper emotional distress. That’s where everything gets a bit convoluted, and less enjoyable.- The Atlantic
- Posted Jul 13, 2023
- Read full review
-
Reviewed by
-
-
Reviewed by
David Sims
Though Ford invests his performance with as much longing and nuance as he can, underlining Indiana’s increasing disconnection from the modern world, the movie is too busy to really plumb those themes, instead zipping along to the next action sequence lest anyone get bored.- The Atlantic
- Posted Jun 29, 2023
- Read full review
-
Reviewed by
-
-
Reviewed by
David Sims
Although Elemental has moments of imaginative joy—watching a living cloud talk to an aquatic being, for one—the viewer is mostly subjected to a very mundane, clichéd domestic dramedy, not the kind of tale that can truly transport younger audiences.- The Atlantic
- Posted Jun 22, 2023
- Read full review
-
Reviewed by
-
-
Reviewed by
Shirley Li
Like a frustrated player speeding up the falling blocks to end the game, the film haphazardly stacks ideas atop one another until, well, it’s a relief when it’s over.- The Atlantic
- Posted Apr 11, 2023
- Read full review
-
Reviewed by
-
-
Reviewed by
David Sims
The intellectual property has become intimidating, too profitable to warrant risk-taking—so instead, audiences are served an appetizing confection. But kids do love candy, and I’m sure that around the world, they’ll have just one command for their ticket-buying parents: “Let’s-a go!”- The Atlantic
- Posted Apr 4, 2023
- Read full review
-
Reviewed by
-
-
Reviewed by
David Sims
This project does not skimp on its main attraction, but it does seem unsure of what to put around it, throwing a variety of hapless characters in the mix and arming them mostly with indifferent comedy in the face of some truly gnarly violence.- The Atlantic
- Posted Feb 23, 2023
- Read full review
-
Reviewed by
-
-
Reviewed by
David Sims
Anytime Quantumania allows itself to get a little silly, it’s in much better shape.- The Atlantic
- Posted Feb 15, 2023
- Read full review
-
Reviewed by
-
-
Reviewed by
David Sims
Yes, Gerard Johnstone’s M3GAN is pulled from January’s bucket of mostly low-budget pablum, but it’s cheeky and knowing enough to stand out from the slop.- The Atlantic
- Posted Jan 12, 2023
- Read full review
-
Reviewed by
-
-
Reviewed by
Shirley Li
Despite a committed cast and often stunning cinematography, the film’s script is too blunt and the direction too ham-fisted to make Emancipation anything more than another rote—albeit expensive—entry in the slavery-movie genre.- The Atlantic
- Posted Jan 6, 2023
- Read full review
-
Reviewed by