Buy Now
| Buy on |
|
- Critic score
- Publication
- By date
-
Record CollectorJul 14, 2025A joyous release that's as eclectic as the vinyl selections in a first-rate junkshop, anchored by long serving ex-R.E.M. sideman McCaughey's exuberant yelp. [Aug 2025, p.105]
-
Classic Rock MagazineJun 23, 2025The most motley of crews manage to bring out the best in McCaughey's songs and he's on peak form here. [Summer 2025, p.72]
-
MojoJun 23, 2025This is college rock meant to be blasted over the radio, a record as vigorous as it is joyous. [Jul 2025, p.87]
-
Jun 23, 2025Oar On, Penelope! is the sort of spontaneously joyous record that reminds us it's a great thing he's still with us and making music. He more than gets by with a little help from his friends.
-
UncutJun 23, 2025The musicians' off-the-cuff interaction animates cartoonish songs like the boisterous "Burgundy Suit" and the woozy "Sharktooth", but Mccaughey's flights of fancy occasionally tumble into relatable coherence. [Jun 2025, p.35]