Buy Now
| Buy on |
|
- Critic score
- Publication
- By date
-
UncutOct 10, 202511 raw but gorgeously melodic songs. .... One of the least cliched [breakup] records you're ever likely to hear. [Nov 2025, p.31]
-
Record CollectorDec 2, 2025Fans of Joni Mitchell and early PJ Harvey will relate to Fatal Optimist on a visceral level. [Christmas 2025, p.133]
-
Oct 17, 2025‘Fatal Optimist’ is, despite the content matter, enticing on first listen and a record that yields further dividends with repeated ones. Here her voice has space to breathe in a way does not always on her preceding albums.
-
Oct 10, 2025Throughout its first ten tracks, Fatal Optimist offers occasional philosophical gems, like "Sometimes a good thing can break you/Sometimes a bad thing can save you" from "Good Lair," a song that also wonders, "Is it really that bad to cover up the sad?"
-
Oct 21, 2025For the majority of the record, she sings alone, accompanied only by her acoustic guitar. This elemental soundscape pushes Diaz’s finely crafted melodies and brutal lyrical observations to the forefront more bluntly than ever.
-
Oct 13, 2025The tracks skirt the edges of alternative country but can also lean into it, as on “Good Liar”. Not until the closing title track does Diaz infuse much energy. On that number, she proves how she is on the level of a musician like Lucy Dacus but has chosen to wallow in more melancholy moods.
-
Oct 10, 2025These are gnarly, inward-focused songs, but if you listen carefully, you can hear how a different sort of delivery—big voice, big drums, slashing guitars—could turn them into a female-centric version of emo-rock. Even if you appreciate the way the music works here, you might still wonder what that larger scale version would sound like.
-
Oct 10, 2025Largely eschews the more robust instrumentation of 2024’s Weird Faith in favor of stripped-down recordings that thrust her lyrics to the forefront.