Read Mixed User Reviews for Wing Commander: Space Will Never Be the Same

6

SamMay 6, 2006

I'm not surprised the movie was critically panned. But that doesn't mean I didn't enjoy myself.

1 of 1 users found this helpful

6

JB.Aug 11, 2006

It really saddens me to see this film here. Let me break it down: the settings and scenery and especially the Kilrathi (cat-people) costumes were clearly produced on a low budget. That's the bad part. The good part? The acting, which It really saddens me to see this film here. Let me break it down: the settings and scenery and especially the Kilrathi (cat-people) costumes were clearly produced on a low budget. That's the bad part. The good part? The acting, which was solid the entire way through. It's really not that bad a film, but perhaps one needs to see really bad films to realize that.… Expand

1 of 1 users found this helpful

5

KadeemluvmusicJan 31, 2017

I haven't seen it, but Wing Commander does have a reputation of being one of the worst video game movies Hollywood has crapped on. However, I have to lay low for a minute because I think it's a awfully but decently good bad movie. WingI haven't seen it, but Wing Commander does have a reputation of being one of the worst video game movies Hollywood has crapped on. However, I have to lay low for a minute because I think it's a awfully but decently good bad movie. Wing Commander was everything full of awful in this so-called science fiction movie. The special effects are barely hard to watch, the pacing of the film just completely off the ground up, and although both Freddie Prinze Jr. And Matthew Lillard (both from Scooby-Doo) tried everything they can to make this movie more or less like a autopilot rerun of Battlestar Galactica. But still the acting is bad and the movie is completely forgotten, but as a fan of terrible b-movies of the 90's, maybe I'll give it a shot by renting this dumbload.… Expand

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

6

Kai82Mar 5, 2021

The enjoyment of this movie depends on 3 things. Firstly how much you like B movies, secondly how much (over)use of tropes, stereotypes and cliches you like or can endure and thirdly if you are a fan of the Wing Commander video games. For meThe enjoyment of this movie depends on 3 things. Firstly how much you like B movies, secondly how much (over)use of tropes, stereotypes and cliches you like or can endure and thirdly if you are a fan of the Wing Commander video games. For me it is a bit dividing. I like the B movie charm of this movie and find it enjoyable. I can mostly endure the tropes, stereotypes and cliches but freely admit that if you do a drinking game with a sip for them you will die of alcohol poisoning long before the movie ends;-). For the games: I know the games and have a small bit of experience with them. They were amazing at their time but the franchise is long dormant or even dead (The difference is actually hard to distinguish). For fans this is a nightmarish adaptation. It just uses some names, themes and visuals from the game to tell its own story. The fans even say that this has noting to do with the games and today there is the phrase “In name only adaptation” which was not used back then (or I just did not knew back then). Even if I am not a hardcore fan and my experiences with the franchise are limited compared to them I agree that they at least have a point. Because I have complained for other movies like Avatar the last Airbender which is a rape of the source material I cant give a free pass here as it would be hypocritical. Back to the movie: In the amazing intro which won me over the set up for the Human / Kilrathi conflict is explained. The Kilrathi are a warrior race and at conflict with humanity as they have no interested in diplomatic relations or coexistence (Already a few tropes). At the start of the movie the war is already ongoing for a while. The Kilrathi landed at critical coup as they managed to destroy an important outpost but archived to get an even more valuable price. They got a navigational computer which gives them the keys to the kingdom or to be more specific all routes and locations of the Terran Confederation. Earth itself is in danger as the Earth fleets are to far away to respond (Do you see what I mean? Even more tropes). A good set up for the story and should easily hook up B movie fans. However I hate the Star Trek inspired trope of incompetent defenses (= No ship or fleet is near the most important world / worlds). This is insanity and only left the question how could they survive this long if they did not even manage the basics of warfare. In real life do you think an enemy could march from far away to Washington, Peking or Moscow and they could not stop them or put up a solid defense? Look for fictional examples at Mass Effect, Halo, Babylon 5 or Star Wars how they defend their important worlds. You could attack and even conquer them but only with a huge fleet and for a harsh price of countless causalities. In total I already explained it. The story is entertaining but uses a lot of tropes. Now for the actors lets start with a harming comparison. Do you know that the (later) games had an impressing cast of actors with the most prominent being Mark Hamill (Yes the Luke Skywalker one), John Rhys Davies, Malcom McDowell and Tom Willson (Back to the Future) atop of lesser know but good actors / actresses? Now try to tell me you wouldn't love to see these in the movie. We got instead Freddie Prince Jr., Saffron Burrows, Matthew Lillard, Jürgen Prochnow, Ginny Holder and Tcheky Karyo atop others. Don't get me wrong. These are all competent actors / actresses. It is more some underperformance and to a far lesser degree overacting in some scenes. As B movie fan this is not that much disturbing as I expected something like this. In total it is a weaker but not garbage performance which is still entertaining. I will praise however Tcheky Karyo as I still remembered his good performance. The special effects were good for its time and I see no missteps to complain. The Kilrathi however look strange and a bit unconvincing (Nothing like the games were they were catlike aliens). The star fighters were also nothing like in the games and I read that they used real fighter jets as models if I remember correctly. Overall this is not a good movie and cemented the videogame movie adaptations are always bad movie cliche. It has B movie charm and so bad it is good appeal for some including me (But not 100%). I enjoyed it somehow but still find the flaws outweighing the so good its bad appeal to give a higher rating. Cant recommend it for you expect you have even more of a soft spot for B movies like this.… Expand