Watchmen
Warner Bros. Pictures | Release Date: March 6, 2009
8.1
USER SCORE
Universal acclaim based on 2504 Ratings
USER RATING DISTRIBUTION
Positive:
2,057
Mixed:
186
Negative:
261
Watch Now
Stream On
Buy on
Stream On
Stream On
Stream On
Stream On
Expand
Review this movie
VOTE NOW
 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Check box if your review contains spoilers 0 characters (5000 max)

User Reviews

User scoreBy dateMost helpful
10
buzznjackallastnameApr 4, 2009
Excellent comic book to movie translation. Visual effects were stunning, acting and plot were very good. I believe that people that didn't enjoy the film was for two major factors. 1. They didn't read the comic book and Excellent comic book to movie translation. Visual effects were stunning, acting and plot were very good. I believe that people that didn't enjoy the film was for two major factors. 1. They didn't read the comic book and couldn't follow the complex story involving multiple protagonist. 2. They read the comic and expected every single detail to be included in a two hour 40 minute movie, which of course would require the movie to have been over 6 hours judging by the motion comics.… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
8
BobBApr 5, 2009
Never read the graphic novel till after seeing this film. Info: I'm a huge film buff. Love independent and foriegn films due to philosophical content typically expressed. This film, though not perfect, was fascinating. If you pay Never read the graphic novel till after seeing this film. Info: I'm a huge film buff. Love independent and foriegn films due to philosophical content typically expressed. This film, though not perfect, was fascinating. If you pay attention to politics and the worldwide push for globalization and a NWO, this film is haunting. I went and read the graphic novel afterwards. It is, of course, better. Why make an exact copy in cinematic form? If you want an honest representation, read the novel. As a film, Watchmen was great. It was also fairly close to the novel and dead-on in many aspects. If you have the mental ability to fill in certain shoddy sections of the film, as one does when viewing/reading a comic, then it is pretty damn good. Use your brain, connect the dots, and see this. It is different, haunting, and different. Good stuff.… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
8
SamMJul 10, 2009
Knew nothing about the comic book, and i really enjoyed it not your average comic book film.
0 of 0 users found this helpful
9
EverettM.Jul 20, 2009
I won't say anything other than that this is one of the best movies I have ever seen. The fact that it is based on a graphic novel is irrelevant (I have never read it.) All that matters is that it explores real issues like hopelessness, I won't say anything other than that this is one of the best movies I have ever seen. The fact that it is based on a graphic novel is irrelevant (I have never read it.) All that matters is that it explores real issues like hopelessness, despair, loneliness and sense of self-worth more than almost any Oscar-caliber drama ever has. Much of the story deserves to be compared far more with Death of a Salesman than with Batman. Wonderful!!!… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
4
KPJul 2, 2009
I love superheroes. But this movie was a disappointment. I found it long winded and meandering. The graphic novel was great. But as movies go, I'd rather watch almost any comic book based movie than this one. (except maybe Ghost Rider I love superheroes. But this movie was a disappointment. I found it long winded and meandering. The graphic novel was great. But as movies go, I'd rather watch almost any comic book based movie than this one. (except maybe Ghost Rider lol) It just missed the mark it almost every way. And I hated hearing Hendrix in the soundtrack...I love Jimi, but what horrible placement.… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
10
wayneyJul 23, 2009
I have not read the graphic novel, and don't intend to. This film suffices as a wonderful testimony on all our dreams, faults and self delusions. The world we seek to dreate is the world we have and it is really ugly and dark. There are I have not read the graphic novel, and don't intend to. This film suffices as a wonderful testimony on all our dreams, faults and self delusions. The world we seek to dreate is the world we have and it is really ugly and dark. There are so many references here to religion, politics, relationships, greed, hope etc. and I found it literally amazing. It brought me back to the dyas I sneaked inot see Clockwork Orange and was never the same again. It is a superhero movie as a vehicle only to shatter our smugness and should not really be in the Spiderman and Batman argument (despite Heaths brilliant part coming close to the same mayhem in us all) but I think in Watchmen we have a much grander canvas and a more unsettling image. Beyond all the technical brilliance it has a real story to tell, and you wont feel the same way again. I bought the soundrack and each song now has new meaning.… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
7
EvinCAug 12, 2009
Cool but I think it could only be watched like twice and then every couple of years. Dean Morgan and Earle Haley are good.
0 of 0 users found this helpful
10
JonathanS.Aug 1, 2009
Well I'm a type of person love to watch every type of movie and enjoy the movie i analyze the movie and i think watchmen is a great movie with amazing and the other that surprise me is the movie explained the origins and why the heroes Well I'm a type of person love to watch every type of movie and enjoy the movie i analyze the movie and i think watchmen is a great movie with amazing and the other that surprise me is the movie explained the origins and why the heroes take the path they take this is a good point but other movies don't explain very well the origins this movie is long but is a great movie i like the longest movies because if a pid for a blue ray or i go to theater i want to enjoy and stay for a long time this is great and i hate people don't appreciate and analyze the movies!!… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
9
SeanFJan 10, 2010
An excellent film that I believe should certainly enter into the lists of best films of all time. Having no previous knowledge of the watchmen as I had never read the graphic novels I cannot compare the two media, however, I suspect that to An excellent film that I believe should certainly enter into the lists of best films of all time. Having no previous knowledge of the watchmen as I had never read the graphic novels I cannot compare the two media, however, I suspect that to do so would be a disservice to the film. Having spent years and years in development hell I can… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
9
TLOct 8, 2009
I tried watching this movie about a month ago and literally fell asleep 30 minutes in. I guess it wasn't what I expected. Still, I knew it had 'something'. I revisited it last night... with an open and focused mind. It really I tried watching this movie about a month ago and literally fell asleep 30 minutes in. I guess it wasn't what I expected. Still, I knew it had 'something'. I revisited it last night... with an open and focused mind. It really is quite brilliant.… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
8
JohnHMar 11, 2009
I read Watchmen this past summer after seeing the preview of the film version before The Dark Knight. Needless to say I became an instant fan and have been anticipating this film for quite some time. I recently saw Watchmen and was very I read Watchmen this past summer after seeing the preview of the film version before The Dark Knight. Needless to say I became an instant fan and have been anticipating this film for quite some time. I recently saw Watchmen and was very pleased with how much attention was given to detail by Zach Snyder. A few element of the story were left out, but the main elements were flawlessly portrayed throughout the entire film. I can see how someone could get lost in the film if they had not read the novel. However, anyone who enjoyed the film, will very much enjoy the graphic novel. GO READ WATCHMEN… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
10
kcMar 10, 2009
I rate this movie two blue dongs down. The fanboys' perfect ratings are seriously misleading to the average movie-goer. The movie was boring, cliched, and devoid of sympathetic characters. By the end, i was rooting for the nukes.
0 of 0 users found this helpful
5
GVBMar 10, 2009
I saw this movie at the midnight showing at the local theater. At around 3 in the morning, I walked out of the theater and thought, "It was.. OK." This is to all the people who say that "if you read the comic, you'll love the movie." I I saw this movie at the midnight showing at the local theater. At around 3 in the morning, I walked out of the theater and thought, "It was.. OK." This is to all the people who say that "if you read the comic, you'll love the movie." I say that it's almost the complete opposite. Fans of Alan Moore's masterpiece will be disappointed by the changes and by some of the casting. Speaking for myself, I really came into the theater with high hopes. I had read the comic only twice (a small number compared to the many other Watchmen fanatics), and had been psyched ever since the trailer first came out. Needless to say, I left the movie criticizing the film, even though I would never call it "bad." It just seems like the people who haven't read the comic are going to see it to gain respect points from people, or are going expecting another movie like Batman. This is not Batman; this is Watchmen, where superheroes don't exist. Real people exist, a concept that was left out of the movie adaption. Everyone's running around and doing all these superhuman things, the point gets lost that these are just ordinary people that don masks to fight crime for their own reasons. Another thing to the people that praise the soundtrack: What movie were you watching?? The soundtrack, by itself, is probably fine for any hipster's iPod. But the music in the film just felt disjointed and unnecessary (excluding Dylan's "The Times They Are a-Changin' "). I mean, "99 Luftballons"? That was laughable. And playing "Hallelujah" during one of the most awkward parts of the movie pulled a giggle out of the whole audience. I know that these were the songs quoted in the novel.. but numerous times, people have brought up what works in a comic doesn't always work in a movie. The soundtrack was one of those things. Please stop calling Snyder "visionary." He's made three movies, calm down. Looks like he traded story for heavy-handed punches and ludicrous fighting scenes, via slow-mo. This could've been a really good movie; the only thing that I count as a plus is that, hopefully, the film will get people to read the original comic. I won't say it's a bad movie, but it sure wasn't good.… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
7
gkMar 10, 2009
It wasn't bad. It wasn't amazing. It goes to show you that even if you recreated a masterpiece piece by piece it's not always going to be the same. The watchmen came out in the 80s and was unlike anything written before (that It wasn't bad. It wasn't amazing. It goes to show you that even if you recreated a masterpiece piece by piece it's not always going to be the same. The watchmen came out in the 80s and was unlike anything written before (that was over 20 years ago). Good attempt but it wasn't epic.… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
1
BestMar 11, 2009
I have never seen a movie that is as full of itself as this one. Arrogant, boring movie. I was also angered and saddened that the music from the brilliant film, Koyaanisqatsi, was used as a cheap dramatic boost in this movie. This movie I have never seen a movie that is as full of itself as this one. Arrogant, boring movie. I was also angered and saddened that the music from the brilliant film, Koyaanisqatsi, was used as a cheap dramatic boost in this movie. This movie claims to be original, but it's all glitz, no substance.… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
8
WesleyWMar 10, 2009
As a fan of the original source material I have to say I love the bits they included from the graphic novel, sadly they left some bits out too.
0 of 0 users found this helpful
10
SeansMar 12, 2009
I thought this movie was great very true to the book which is pretty hard to say for most books turned into movies.
0 of 0 users found this helpful
9
AstridIMar 10, 2009
I went in the theatre having never read the graphic novel and emerged impressed with Snyder's portrayal of Watchmen, vowing to get my hands on the book. The sound and graphics were fantastic, and Rorschach was portrayed brilliantly by I went in the theatre having never read the graphic novel and emerged impressed with Snyder's portrayal of Watchmen, vowing to get my hands on the book. The sound and graphics were fantastic, and Rorschach was portrayed brilliantly by Jackie Earle Haley. Haley was perfect casting and made the film - certain dull scenes could have been the downfall of the movie if it were not for him.… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
10
JulianRMar 12, 2009
The first thing you have to learn about this movie is: if you never read the book it's not for you. I read the graphic novel and therefore understand the subtleties in the film. There was absolutley no way anyone could put the entire The first thing you have to learn about this movie is: if you never read the book it's not for you. I read the graphic novel and therefore understand the subtleties in the film. There was absolutley no way anyone could put the entire novel in and keep a reasonable time limit.… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
9
SimonDMar 13, 2009
I'm a fan of the graphic novel (but I don't weep over how good it is like some) and I thought the film was great. Was true to the novel (obviously they had to omit quite a bit) but overall it was just a condensed version of the I'm a fan of the graphic novel (but I don't weep over how good it is like some) and I thought the film was great. Was true to the novel (obviously they had to omit quite a bit) but overall it was just a condensed version of the book. Rorschach is perfectly cast and Dr Manhattan has a fat schlong. What more could you ask for?… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
9
JAMar 10, 2009
When watching those "official" reviews, you could actually just cut the lower half away, and then you'd get somewhat more realistic average. Naturally, when trying to turn a great graphic novel into a movie, it won't be as good as When watching those "official" reviews, you could actually just cut the lower half away, and then you'd get somewhat more realistic average. Naturally, when trying to turn a great graphic novel into a movie, it won't be as good as the original was, but Watchmen really does get close. Some things have been changed, but then again, some things really had to be changed in a movie version. In the end, it still is almost as worthy movie version the book could possibly get. About those reviews, I have no idea what kind of movies some of those "critics" usually watch and give good ratings, but they just might be in a wrong business.… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
8
HyperSMar 13, 2009
A bit long and was a let down from the epic movie trailer(s) that raised expectations to an unachievable level. That aside, the plot of the movie was fine [Dark and gritty in a Sin City-esque way].... nothing mind blowing and actually mostly A bit long and was a let down from the epic movie trailer(s) that raised expectations to an unachievable level. That aside, the plot of the movie was fine [Dark and gritty in a Sin City-esque way].... nothing mind blowing and actually mostly took a back seat to the individual characters themselves... but at least the story remained unpredictable to the end so that's good. Really for me the star of this movie isn't the plot, but rather two characters (even if at times they are overdone): Dr. Manhattan (his presence alone on camera commands God-like "oohs" and "ahhs") and the psycho that was Warshack, both of whom who could have warranted a movie of their own. The other masked "heroes" unfortunately were just bleh and really didn't carry the same character complexities to warrant much deep thought or attention. Definitely recommend at least one viewing... two on the other hand? That's debatable.… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
9
KarlLMar 13, 2009
Why are the ratings for this movie all over the place? Fanboys of course. Most people enjoyed the movie but the smallest compromise sends fanboys into an uncontrollable fit of downvoting. Its a good movie.
0 of 0 users found this helpful
0
SimonSMar 13, 2009
Are you kidding me? This movie is an absolute joke. One of the worst films to come out in the last ten years, do not waste your time on this pretentious, bloated, say nothing piece of ****. It is rubbish.
0 of 0 users found this helpful
10
YonatanJMar 13, 2009
Perfectly captures the brilliant graphic novel.
0 of 0 users found this helpful
1
DragOMar 13, 2009
Almost 3 wasted hours of my life that i will never get back.
0 of 0 users found this helpful
10
IsaacNMar 15, 2009
Ok, I know some people might hate me but. I don't think the technology was right for this movie still. I still think It's almost an unfilmable movie. It was great amazing. It didn't catch me but it was good for what it was Ok, I know some people might hate me but. I don't think the technology was right for this movie still. I still think It's almost an unfilmable movie. It was great amazing. It didn't catch me but it was good for what it was supposed to be.… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
9
MattMar 15, 2009
Well acted and possibly the best comic adaptation of recent years. At times however it feels like Snyder overused action sequences and gore too much. The overall message from the graphic novel was there, middle aged vigilantism, and at timesWell acted and possibly the best comic adaptation of recent years. At times however it feels like Snyder overused action sequences and gore too much. The overall message from the graphic novel was there, middle aged vigilantism, and at times kept the same brooding nature. Some scenes were altered for continuity and to make the story line look like it happened in a a matter of days.
Changing the ending, though it may appear as heresy to the fans of the graphic novel, made the Watchmen acessable to a new audience while allowing for the Film to be shorter,
The music adds to the moment and some of the montages are fantastic.
The Film ignored many of the sub-plots and tiny relationships built up in Moore's work however if you look the relationships are there; they are just not as explicitly pointed out.
All in all a very good translation only stopped from being truly fantastic by the insistence of fight sequences and gore that adds nothing to the plot and seem to be there just so those who wish to see violence do not get bored.… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
10
R.LMar 10, 2009
Over hyped? No. A beautiful piece of movie making? Most definitely, the Watchmen is one of the best Anti-hero series ever made. I've had the innate pleasure of reading the graphic novel and I've just seen the movie and let me tell Over hyped? No. A beautiful piece of movie making? Most definitely, the Watchmen is one of the best Anti-hero series ever made. I've had the innate pleasure of reading the graphic novel and I've just seen the movie and let me tell you it was exceptional, the movie had almost captured the graphic novel and completely put it no film, I had never been thus impressed in my entire life by a comic book adaption. The Watchmen tells the story of a group of not so heroic heroes, and as the film states one of them is killed and now the rest have to find out why. The Watchmen is an amazing visual feat that no comic book adaption has ever come even close to before it has the same feel, the same style that the watchmen graphic novel did and I promise you, fans of the graphic novel will not be disappointed at all by this magnificent film, it's a treat for the eyes and the senses; and will keep you going all the way till the shocking end.… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
9
DallasPMar 16, 2009
Don't believe they negative review. Movie was excellent and a nice translation of the comic books.
0 of 0 users found this helpful
9
ChrisMMar 10, 2009
I seriously don't understand the harsh critiscism radiating from the users and a select few critics. I thought the movie, although long, was brilliant. It was deep in moments, and had a great plot. What really annoys me is the whinning I seriously don't understand the harsh critiscism radiating from the users and a select few critics. I thought the movie, although long, was brilliant. It was deep in moments, and had a great plot. What really annoys me is the whinning 13 year olds complaining about mr. manhattan's full frontal nudity. Just grow up, he's nude, get over it.… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
10
JoshWMar 16, 2009
I had never heard of Watchmen until recently so I decided to but the graphic novel before seeing the film. I know the hardcore fanboys are getting ridiculously distraught over what has been changed etc but in my opinion Zack Snyder has taken I had never heard of Watchmen until recently so I decided to but the graphic novel before seeing the film. I know the hardcore fanboys are getting ridiculously distraught over what has been changed etc but in my opinion Zack Snyder has taken a good book that in places was boring and downright stupid (squid anyone?) and made it into a brilliant film that stays faithful to the novel whilst also improving many scenes and especially improving the end (especially between Nite Owl and Ozzy). Well made, well acted (nixon looked idiotic though with THAT nose) and I cannot wait for the blu ray edition.… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
6
THATMOVIEGUYMar 16, 2009
B- for effort. However, if you guys want to see an actual 10 out of 10, stunning visual representation of the Watchmen comic... Get the Watchmen 6 hour Animated Comic. It's a totally new medium of art that going overlooked, and one of B- for effort. However, if you guys want to see an actual 10 out of 10, stunning visual representation of the Watchmen comic... Get the Watchmen 6 hour Animated Comic. It's a totally new medium of art that going overlooked, and one of the greatest films you could watch right now! Why? Because it's a frame for frame (not recreation with "decent" actors and an action/horror director) COMIC with GREAT VOICE ACTING and subtle not over the top animation of the actual comic, WATCHMEN. Go see it, after you leave this "alright" film, please. And if you like it, tell more people!… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
3
JustinSMar 10, 2009
The first half hour of the movie is amazing, it rivals the Dark Knight but then the movie meanders through a familiar road: a dramatic Hollywood soap opera. The movie tries to fit in too many things without describing others. The movie The first half hour of the movie is amazing, it rivals the Dark Knight but then the movie meanders through a familiar road: a dramatic Hollywood soap opera. The movie tries to fit in too many things without describing others. The movie should have been two maybe even three parts. Oh and the acting is horrid (except the comedien and masked guy). Many of the scenes were laugable...pple kept shaking their heads in the theater.… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
1
NickMMar 17, 2009
Between the unrealistic and unneccesarily graphic fight scenes, and the bizzare and outlandish plot that barely makes sense, this movie trys to make a moral/philosophic point, but it is completely lost in a mess of absurdity. The only reason Between the unrealistic and unneccesarily graphic fight scenes, and the bizzare and outlandish plot that barely makes sense, this movie trys to make a moral/philosophic point, but it is completely lost in a mess of absurdity. The only reason i even gave it a one is because it was so stupid that it gave me something to laugh at, even though that that wasn't the movie's intention.… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
10
KewlkatMar 10, 2009
Not since The Dark Knight have comic book movies felt so real. And now, not since the Watchmen has that premise been so built upon.
0 of 0 users found this helpful
9
AaronSMar 10, 2009
Easily the best superhero film to date, but more importantly Snyder actually manages to pull off the impossible: a more plausible and foreshadowed ending that still manages to convey Moore's core thesis that vigilantism is a slippery Easily the best superhero film to date, but more importantly Snyder actually manages to pull off the impossible: a more plausible and foreshadowed ending that still manages to convey Moore's core thesis that vigilantism is a slippery slope, and one which, even given the best of intentions, even when successful, has a terrible moral and human price. The down side: Moore's story is not one which all audiences will appreciate and Snyder's sensibilities with respect to violence enhance the already graphic nature of the story.… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
0
JGMar 10, 2009
Ugh. Long. Boring. Laughable script. Laughable sex scene. I hated every character.
0 of 0 users found this helpful
0
TFMar 10, 2009
I admit I never liked the original comic series, and this was forced on me by a group of friends the other night. I still think it's ridiculous, and seeing Dr Manhattan onscreen only increased that sentiment.
0 of 0 users found this helpful
9
KeaganAMar 19, 2009
A truly great movie. In my opinion sets a standard in cinematography that 'hero' movies of the future will struggle to meet. Its great to see a movie that doesn't glamorize the 'superhero' scene and parodies all that A truly great movie. In my opinion sets a standard in cinematography that 'hero' movies of the future will struggle to meet. Its great to see a movie that doesn't glamorize the 'superhero' scene and parodies all that came before it.… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
10
KellyO'O.Mar 20, 2009
Brilliant, just brilliant. Snyder did the impossible and made a credible film version of the greatest comic ever written. I hated 300, but this is way more intellectual, super hero movies cannot be the same after this, it's on another level.
0 of 0 users found this helpful
10
DerekHMar 23, 2009
This was a very faithful translation of the book. It shed only the unnecessary parts and kept the theme. The soundtrack and effects were well chosen.
0 of 0 users found this helpful
10
TimLMar 23, 2009
A fantastic adaptation to a novel considered unfilmable. This movie certainly won't appease the fanboys (but what actualy does?). The most drastic change in the plot between novel and movie was probably necessary to keep the movie under A fantastic adaptation to a novel considered unfilmable. This movie certainly won't appease the fanboys (but what actualy does?). The most drastic change in the plot between novel and movie was probably necessary to keep the movie under 3 hours long. The pacing of the various stories does well in keeping the overall movie moving. The use of The Times They Are A-Changin to tell the tale of the Minutemen is an ingenious way to give a background to the history of masked vigilanties. Having read the novel before seeing the movie, I have to say that people who expected every page to be present in the movie are dreaming. The screenplay holds onto Moore's ideas of a lost society and anyone who is angry Moore didn't take part in this adaptation have to realize he wouldn't have taken part in any retelling of his novel. The actors do an excellent job of portraying these beloved masked crusaders and I personally think every actor was perfect for their role. If this film was released later in the year we could easily be seeing James Earl Haley nominated for a Best Supporting Actor nomination. People have to go see this movie for what it is, an adaptation to what Time magazine called one of the 100 best novels of the past 80 years.… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
10
donmMar 24, 2009
I knew nothing of the book or tghe characters. I found the movie experience thrilling from the first moment. It aimed high and had serious themes under the story. A great movie going experience and arresting visuals - fresh and yet satisfying.
0 of 0 users found this helpful
8
RonFMar 25, 2009
Ok, if you have gotten this far in the Watchmen reviews, then you know that this film is about the dark side of being a superhero. So, I won't belabour that perspective. Here's the important part of the flick you might have missed: Ok, if you have gotten this far in the Watchmen reviews, then you know that this film is about the dark side of being a superhero. So, I won't belabour that perspective. Here's the important part of the flick you might have missed: a nerd has an office place accident which leaves him with a barrel chest, washboard abs and a large penis. Wow! I want to know which office that guy works in! Ok, he's a little short on tan, well, in fact, he is blue but, hey, I'm a nerd and I want to have an office place accident which will leave me with a physique which even Laurie Juspeczyk gawks at. This mishap near the water cooler is the quintessential superhero fodder: the nerd is, after all, Superman. Perhaps we like this because it makes us, the powerless, feel empowered. How many CEO's with a gaggle of concubines and a wad of millions in their wallets go to see superhero movies? These movies are for us, the powerless, to feel better. Only, this movie does not quite do that. If superheroes existed in the real world, then this is how it would be: we ordinary humans are, as Dr. M said, little more than termites to a superbeing. Deep stuff. If there had been less blood in this film, I would have given it a 10. The blood detracted unnecessarily from what was originally a good tale by Alan Moore et al.… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
1
ChadYMar 26, 2009
One of the worst movies I've seen in the past 5 years. To me this is a prime example of how the movie industry has lost its way.
0 of 0 users found this helpful
9
AlecBMar 20, 2009
Watchmen is easily the best film of 2009. Far better then Taken or Friday the 13th. It has everything a good action film should have. You care about some of the characters, a good plot, and lots of action. Im tired of people fucking Watchmen is easily the best film of 2009. Far better then Taken or Friday the 13th. It has everything a good action film should have. You care about some of the characters, a good plot, and lots of action. Im tired of people fucking complaining about it was too gorey or there was too much sex in the movie. Who cares the movie is rated R for a reason. Its not a pussy PG-13 superhero movie so for parents bringing there 4 year old kid to go see it, then complaning about the movie and how violent it is need to shut up and realize its their own fault for bringing the kid in the first place. Yes, the movie is extremely long but why are people complaning about it. If you could handle the dark Knight then you can handle this. ohh yea and to the kid who said the music sucks? its supposed to be set in like 1985 of course its going to have that kind of music. Sorry that the film didnt have your faggot 50 cent black music going on.… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
8
MikeN.Mar 6, 2009
Overall I liked it. Cast and crew obviously tried to get it right. Every book to movie adaptation leaves things out and makes changes, deal with it. Jackie Earl Harley was phenomenal as Rorschach. I think this was a very hard movie to make, Overall I liked it. Cast and crew obviously tried to get it right. Every book to movie adaptation leaves things out and makes changes, deal with it. Jackie Earl Harley was phenomenal as Rorschach. I think this was a very hard movie to make, but they did the comic justice. People who haven't read the comic might be a little lost.… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
7
JimmyJ.Mar 6, 2009
Watchmen starts out as a 10/10 from the original graphic novel. This gets: -1 for unnecessary gore -1 for unnecessary sex -2 for laughable insertion of the soundtrack (I know they were the songs in the end-of-chapter quotes, but the Watchmen starts out as a 10/10 from the original graphic novel. This gets: -1 for unnecessary gore -1 for unnecessary sex -2 for laughable insertion of the soundtrack (I know they were the songs in the end-of-chapter quotes, but the incorporation was absurdly awkward) +1 for making the entire thing really pretty. A highly faithful adaptation that sometimes stylizes the original TOO much, but is overall a compelling film.… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
7
EdmundW.Mar 6, 2009
Zack Snyder is a 13 year old nerd who finds no passion for subtlety or elegance. The beginning half of the film was grand. Dr. Manhattan's Mars monologue was fantastic (along with the opening credit montage), but after that, it just Zack Snyder is a 13 year old nerd who finds no passion for subtlety or elegance. The beginning half of the film was grand. Dr. Manhattan's Mars monologue was fantastic (along with the opening credit montage), but after that, it just goes downhill. The violence is definitely gratuitous, but almost pointless at times. This isn't 300 you arrogant prick, learn to make a good film. Also, the sex scenes look like something out of a prepubescent wet dream. Terrible scoring (sans Philip Glass) and a lack of honesty to the actual plot and intention of the graphic novel make this film a bit lackluster. For fans of the novel, it's a must see, despite the deranged notion that the novel was about Dr. Manhattan's genitalia. For everyone else - if you enjoy superhero movies, see it. If you enjoy thrilling adaptations of thought-provoking tales of corruption and anti-heroism, this is not the movie for you. Teens will love the violence and sex, fans will love the characters, any mature being will only enjoy the very faint look at humanities ideals.… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
0
MattM.Mar 6, 2009
This film is abysmal. Horrible pace, pointless plot, awkward acting and stilted uncomfortable action. And its long. Very long. I saw this at an Imax preview in Perth, WA. About 30 people walked out... enough said. Avoid at all costs.
0 of 0 users found this helpful
10
GiovanniC.Mar 6, 2009
Zack Snyder's Watchmen is an amazing movie. Zack Snyder does a fantastic job delivering Alan Moore's novel onto the big screen. Zack sets that mood in the world that Alan sets in the novel the world is exactly like ours just with Zack Snyder's Watchmen is an amazing movie. Zack Snyder does a fantastic job delivering Alan Moore's novel onto the big screen. Zack sets that mood in the world that Alan sets in the novel the world is exactly like ours just with these costume characters in the middle. The acting is top notch especially with Dr. Manhattan from being a wimpy little scientist to never feeling fear for the rest of his days. The soundtrack was simply epic! Every scene has a tune that sets the mood so perfectly, especially the opening credits with the Bob Dylan song. The action is brutal and non-stop never ceasing to keep the audience up in their seats. Watchmen is surely a movie you can't miss.… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
10
ChrisV.Mar 6, 2009
Those looking for a story like Spiderman, or Iron Man will leave disappointed, however I don't think we've ever seen a deeper comic book based movie. Without reading the graphic novel prior, I really enjoyed the movie and found it Those looking for a story like Spiderman, or Iron Man will leave disappointed, however I don't think we've ever seen a deeper comic book based movie. Without reading the graphic novel prior, I really enjoyed the movie and found it very easy to jump right into an alternate 1985...… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
10
JasonR.Mar 6, 2009
Just WOW! Don't remember the last time, that a movie impressed me that much. Actually I have no idea why so many review sites don't like Watchmen at all. It has nearly everything a movie should have and what I like the most that it Just WOW! Don't remember the last time, that a movie impressed me that much. Actually I have no idea why so many review sites don't like Watchmen at all. It has nearly everything a movie should have and what I like the most that it is so different. The style, the setting, the humour: I likes it all. I have never read a Watchmen comic, but I could follow the whole (awesome) plot, even though it's sometimes not easy. And...I think I will buy some of those Watchmen comic books....… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
6
MichaelM.Mar 6, 2009
Not having read the graphic novel this was an enjoyable fantasy if a little long & ponderous in parts
0 of 0 users found this helpful
9
JustinN.Mar 6, 2009
The Watchmen is a very good movie and its not your typical comic book movie, which might disappoint some people. The graphic novel is still better then the movie, but you have to give it up to Zack Snyder for doing an exceptional job of The Watchmen is a very good movie and its not your typical comic book movie, which might disappoint some people. The graphic novel is still better then the movie, but you have to give it up to Zack Snyder for doing an exceptional job of making this movie on of the best comic book movies every made.… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
10
MerryJ.Mar 6, 2009
Very visual, dark, and great to see more than once. one of the best of the year despite a lot of no name critics giving it a low rating.
0 of 0 users found this helpful
10
TimN.Mar 6, 2009
I'm starting to think you have to be a fan of the book to love this movie. Otherwise, it's just too much to process in one viewing.
0 of 0 users found this helpful
10
MarkW.Mar 6, 2009
An astounding adaptation to the big screen. Pitch perfect, accessible, entertaining, thought provoking. I just hate to say this but... I liked it better than the graphic novel. People will make noise and cry about it's departures from An astounding adaptation to the big screen. Pitch perfect, accessible, entertaining, thought provoking. I just hate to say this but... I liked it better than the graphic novel. People will make noise and cry about it's departures from the graphic novel but it's a movie. Hard choices needed to be made and the director et al made them well. Low points were the actress who played Jupiter (she looked 25 not 40) and Ozymandius. A couple of times the exposition was a little preachy. Overall, this movie is art for the masses.… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
6
AnnE.Mar 6, 2009
The movie lost one of the key points of the comic: these "superheroes" aren't super at all--they are normal human beings (with the exception of Dr. Manhattan). Even Ozymandias, as intelligent as he is, is still just a normal human The movie lost one of the key points of the comic: these "superheroes" aren't super at all--they are normal human beings (with the exception of Dr. Manhattan). Even Ozymandias, as intelligent as he is, is still just a normal human being. But the film is full of gore and violence that normal humans shouldn't really be capable of. Many of the fight scenes were a bit ridiculous because of this. They shouldn't be able to fight THAT well, or inflict THAT much damage. Also, the complexity of the ending was almost completely lost. I knew before hand that the main part of Ozymandias's plan had been altered in the movie, though I knew not how. But after watching it, I don't quite understand WHY that part was changed. The constant change in time was also severely simplified towards the end, as well, which made the entire ending lose a lot of its richness. All that being said, the movie is not bad. I enjoyed it, and I'll probably watch the Director's Cut with the scenes from the pirate comic and Under the Hood woven in. But unfortunately, it's not quite as good as it could have been, or should have been.… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
7
PaulR.Mar 6, 2009
Watchmen is Smart, Bloody, Soft Core Comic Book Porn with a Twisty 80's Soundtrack! Zac Snyder has given us a world in which costumed heroes are real and ugly and most assuredly human. He has done for the comic book movie what Alan Watchmen is Smart, Bloody, Soft Core Comic Book Porn with a Twisty 80's Soundtrack! Zac Snyder has given us a world in which costumed heroes are real and ugly and most assuredly human. He has done for the comic book movie what Alan Moore did for comics. If there is a flaw it is that Watchmen is just a little too real. It will be rejected by audiences accustomed to shiny happy heroes or those masked vigilantes that do their dark deeds in the shadows where we don't have to actually see the blood. The blood of Watchmen jets and flows, the bones break and crumble, flesh burns and the camera never looks away. These wounds don't miraculously heal leaving the heroes and the hero worshipers to deal with the mess.… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
10
ChrisM.Mar 6, 2009
I am a long time and huge fan of the book and I was very happy with the film
0 of 0 users found this helpful
10
JasonMar 6, 2009
There really is one of best movies ever made. Regardless of whether you've read the comic or not you will enjoy this film. Great action , beautiful cinematography(imax even better) , a complex and engaging story (streamlined from the There really is one of best movies ever made. Regardless of whether you've read the comic or not you will enjoy this film. Great action , beautiful cinematography(imax even better) , a complex and engaging story (streamlined from the comic but they had to , the movie would be 10 hours long if they hadn't) I really feel that the director picked the best scene and the strongest moments to translate into film. Even the acting was perfect, particularly Rorschach. It really a movie you must see to believe.… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
5
MitchellO.Mar 6, 2009
Can't tell you how much I loved the graphic novel. I can see the Director's love for the source material. I can see the shots, the reference, the mood. The only thing I don't get is any real connection to the characters and Can't tell you how much I loved the graphic novel. I can see the Director's love for the source material. I can see the shots, the reference, the mood. The only thing I don't get is any real connection to the characters and their stories. Their dialogue comes across as made-up and wooden. Maybe my hopes were just too high going in.… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
10
ToddB.Mar 6, 2009
This movie was fantastic. Best comic to film adaptation ever, and I enjoyed more than The Dark Knight. Visuals are inspired, music is fantastic, and great story. I can't wait to see it again. Kudos, Zack.
0 of 0 users found this helpful
9
ColinH.Mar 6, 2009
The Watchmen was visually beautiful, stunning almost throughout. Though I was annoyed at the few parts that were too long and odd flashback style (It annoyed me in the graphic novel as well), it had an amazing cast, great interpretation of The Watchmen was visually beautiful, stunning almost throughout. Though I was annoyed at the few parts that were too long and odd flashback style (It annoyed me in the graphic novel as well), it had an amazing cast, great interpretation of the novel and, most importantly, it weaved a story that left me thinking. I would recommend it to almost anyone who enjoys action movies, and those who enjoy superhero movies should see it twice.… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
7
WilliamN.Mar 6, 2009
It was very entertaining if long, and unfortunately I knew going in that it would be long. Thank goodness I didn't have a lot of coffee going in...and ate well in advance...I've never actually read this book and I for the most part It was very entertaining if long, and unfortunately I knew going in that it would be long. Thank goodness I didn't have a lot of coffee going in...and ate well in advance...I've never actually read this book and I for the most part did care about it and the stories going on, all along the way...for the most part it worked...a few things I didn't so much care for, some story elements, where this person or that was from or whatever, but, a very well made film, you know, you can see it. From the Kubrick Strangelove War Room to all the music and stuff inbetween, tight, very righteous. Well done...but not all there...it did feel long. It is a credit however, now, I want to get a copy of the book and check it out...so, how good is that?… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
9
ColeR.Mar 6, 2009
I am no comic nerd. I do like a good comic though and I thought this embodied the spirit and emotion of the original. I believed the characterizations and the acting without expending energy to suspend my disbelief. I am sure many will not I am no comic nerd. I do like a good comic though and I thought this embodied the spirit and emotion of the original. I believed the characterizations and the acting without expending energy to suspend my disbelief. I am sure many will not understand or cope well with the story's moral and ethical ambiguity. It may be this alone that could cause a poor rating in spite of it being a grade A comic conversion.… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
10
AlexV.Mar 6, 2009
Unbelievable imagery and vision. Action pack sequences with romance in between. A true Masterpiece. The graphic novel will never be topped, but the movie gives a unique demonstration of Snyder's vivid imagination. Kudos to all cast and Unbelievable imagery and vision. Action pack sequences with romance in between. A true Masterpiece. The graphic novel will never be topped, but the movie gives a unique demonstration of Snyder's vivid imagination. Kudos to all cast and crew that developed an ultimate classic into an explosion of beauty phenomenon in 2 hours and 35 minutes. p.s. great job Tyler Bates with an INCREDIBLE soundtrack… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
3
PhilipDuncanMar 6, 2009
A story that doesn't draw you in. Watchmen is flashy and has it's enjoyable fight scenes, but outside of that the plot moves at a stagnant pace.
0 of 0 users found this helpful
9
AtticusM.Mar 6, 2009
So visually compelling it was mind blowing. And Rorschach was perfect.
0 of 0 users found this helpful
0
hnMar 6, 2009
Worst comic/graphic novel movie ever! So many long pointless scenes. Cliche after cliche. The blue guy might as well have been the silver surfer. Action scenes were pointless. I think the only people who liked this movie were the fanboys of Worst comic/graphic novel movie ever! So many long pointless scenes. Cliche after cliche. The blue guy might as well have been the silver surfer. Action scenes were pointless. I think the only people who liked this movie were the fanboys of the comic.… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
8
TorinH.Mar 6, 2009
Incredible fidelity to the source material, and yet an experience unto itself. This film is an absolute must-see for any fan of the comic-hero genre.
0 of 0 users found this helpful
9
GTMar 6, 2009
Best.Superhero.Movie.Ever Not perfect, but still as good as anything in the genre. God to great acting, excellent special effects, the best opening credits I've ever seen in a movie that flew along despite a relatively long screen time. Best.Superhero.Movie.Ever Not perfect, but still as good as anything in the genre. God to great acting, excellent special effects, the best opening credits I've ever seen in a movie that flew along despite a relatively long screen time. Well done to Snyder and crew.… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
10
DenebMar 6, 2009
With Watchman, the superhero genre in film has taken another couple steps forward and set the bar much higher than it was before. The emotional impact towards the film and initial impression is simply that it is amazing. Every detail within With Watchman, the superhero genre in film has taken another couple steps forward and set the bar much higher than it was before. The emotional impact towards the film and initial impression is simply that it is amazing. Every detail within the film, from the script, setting, atmosphere, special effects, character development, and narrative the film is superb. The director and writers should be given credit for understanding that material throughout.… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
9
ShamusM.Mar 6, 2009
i think this was on of the best adaptions of a comic book to movies i have ever seen some things are changed and dropped from the comic but in the end they weren't necessary and it makes the plot and the overall message a lot clearer i think this was on of the best adaptions of a comic book to movies i have ever seen some things are changed and dropped from the comic but in the end they weren't necessary and it makes the plot and the overall message a lot clearer and a really good soundtrack… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
10
DaveW.Mar 6, 2009
It could be better, but after all it´s a great history and a great film!
0 of 0 users found this helpful
9
PrestonEverettJ.Mar 6, 2009
Great adaptation of a slightly dated but well written graphic novel. Changes to the original story added relevance and made the ending much more believable and less silly. Brutally violent, well staged and shot, well adapted, could have used Great adaptation of a slightly dated but well written graphic novel. Changes to the original story added relevance and made the ending much more believable and less silly. Brutally violent, well staged and shot, well adapted, could have used a stronger hand in the cutting room floor (some backstory a little unnecessary even if it was in the graphic novel), but highly entertaining and still highly relevant in our fear dominated political scene.… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
10
JuanF.Mar 6, 2009
Sets the new standard in adaptation while preserving the intent and spirit of the original comic.
0 of 0 users found this helpful
8
RickE.Mar 6, 2009
I think it's fair to judge a film for what it is I can't say that I have been disappointed. For anyone who feels that something was missing, there was. Pages and Pages of exposition in written form that Snyder tried to incorporate I think it's fair to judge a film for what it is I can't say that I have been disappointed. For anyone who feels that something was missing, there was. Pages and Pages of exposition in written form that Snyder tried to incorporate somewhere into the movie. His attention to detail should be applauded.… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
9
DaveWhiteMar 6, 2009
If you haven't read the novel then you are most likely NOT going to enjoy the movie that much. It drags on and on. But being a fan of the original graphic and knowing the characters and plot already, I thought it was an excellentIf you haven't read the novel then you are most likely NOT going to enjoy the movie that much. It drags on and on. But being a fan of the original graphic and knowing the characters and plot already, I thought it was an excellent adaptation. Minus one gratuitous sex scene it was dead one what I hoped it would be.… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
9
MarioV.Mar 6, 2009
The film was a great adaptation. I really enjoyed it visually. The story was well structured from what is a huge story. I really enjoyed it.
0 of 0 users found this helpful
9
WadeO.Mar 6, 2009
To anyone complaining about the change to the minor deus ex machina of the film, grow up. Realize that the squid is simply there as a catalyst and changing that catalyst does not effect the importance of the moment. I was worried by all of To anyone complaining about the change to the minor deus ex machina of the film, grow up. Realize that the squid is simply there as a catalyst and changing that catalyst does not effect the importance of the moment. I was worried by all of the nay saying around this film until I was utterly astonished by the faithful wonder of it all. No punches were pulled and there is nothing left out that I felt was absolutely necessary. Here's to anticipation of the directors cut.… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
8
DanielMar 6, 2009
The movie stayed very faithful to the comic book. Though it was less dense, and less detailed, the final product was visually stunning, and overall a very enjoyable movie. If you liked the book, you will like the movie, as it is essentially The movie stayed very faithful to the comic book. Though it was less dense, and less detailed, the final product was visually stunning, and overall a very enjoyable movie. If you liked the book, you will like the movie, as it is essentially the book on screen.… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
9
MattB.Mar 7, 2009
I enjoyed this movie very much, and everyone I know who read the book says that it followed it well, but with a changed end that worked very well still.
0 of 0 users found this helpful
10
ObieS.Mar 7, 2009
I thought is was great. it follows the comic pretty close. but for the non reader its just as entertaining.
0 of 0 users found this helpful
8
MattA.Mar 7, 2009
As a fan of the GN(although not a fanboy) I was skeptical about this film upon it's release. I just watched it today, and I was, surprisingly, satisfied. I never thought it would be as good as it was. The action was thrilling, if not a As a fan of the GN(although not a fanboy) I was skeptical about this film upon it's release. I just watched it today, and I was, surprisingly, satisfied. I never thought it would be as good as it was. The action was thrilling, if not a bit over done. The violence made me giddy with joy. The story holds up on its own, and includes the better parts of the Original source, however, anybody who has read it will surely miss at least one or two of their favorite moments. I can't wait for the Unrated version, or directors cut to come out. Then this may go up another point. Otherwise, i was thoroughly entertained by this adaptation.… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
10
TylerM.Mar 7, 2009
Unlike anything I've ever seen, original and very very deep
0 of 0 users found this helpful
0
LisaS.Mar 7, 2009
Boring, pretentious, cruel, fascistic crap. Total waste of money and time. This movie sucked blue Wang.
0 of 0 users found this helpful
6
TimN.Mar 7, 2009
VERY underwhelming compared to the book.

On its own, it's solid. But compared to the book...ech. Nearly all of the themes and messages were either diluted or totally wiped out, too many important scenes cut out, too rushed (I'dVERY underwhelming compared to the book.

On its own, it's solid. But compared to the book...ech. Nearly all of the themes and messages were either diluted or totally wiped out, too many important scenes cut out, too rushed (I'd probably be somewhat confused midway without reading the book beforehand), parts of the narrative changed for no reason , too much emphasis on slo-mo Hollywood action which WASN'T the book's emphasis, too much gratuitous gore and sex compared to the book (its isolated moments of emphasis in the book made it stand out when it needed to), etc.

Of course, I shouldn't be surprised. The amount of content in the book is way too much for 2h40m (still pretty lengthy for contemporary films), and its narrative structure is much too complex to translate to the screen...it's true, though: Watchmen is unfilmable, both in the amount of content to show and the way in which the narrative is constructed. Unless you make it 6 hours long, you will NOT end up with Watchmen. Actually, scratch that--you'll never equal the original, no matter what.

Oh well. Snyder made a good effort.… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
10
EricGMar 7, 2009
I loved it. It is the most entertaining film I have seen since the LOTR trilogy.
0 of 0 users found this helpful
8
JBMar 7, 2009
Not perfect but brilliant in certain places.
0 of 0 users found this helpful
10
ddsdssddsdMar 7, 2009
Ignore the bad reviews, if you read them youll find theyre extremely badly written. if you look on IMDB the film has an 8.5 which is very good for the site. Its a great film, im a huge fan of the novel and found they seem to compliment eachIgnore the bad reviews, if you read them youll find theyre extremely badly written. if you look on IMDB the film has an 8.5 which is very good for the site. Its a great film, im a huge fan of the novel and found they seem to compliment each other, seeing rorschach and manhattan in motion is amazing. Remember this is also Zack snyders ADAPTATION of the book, not an exact replica.… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
10
VittorioR.Mar 7, 2009
If you're a fan of the comic books, please go see this movie. Only you can see the hard work that Warner Brothers has put into including all the suttle nuances. Those who have not read the Graphic novel, will likely feel overwhelmed, If you're a fan of the comic books, please go see this movie. Only you can see the hard work that Warner Brothers has put into including all the suttle nuances. Those who have not read the Graphic novel, will likely feel overwhelmed, this was intended purposely. If you look a majority of these reviews both user and critic you will see those who have read the graphic novel, adored it, and those who didn't found it average. It's because you pick up the allegorical, and biblical references if you've read the novel. If you haven't they will fly past your head because you're not prepared. It's a deep movie on several layers, although sill not as deep as the book. Overall fantastic movie, don't let the ninth grade reviews who don't know what allegory or symbolism to change your opinion of this movie.… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
10
CharlesL.Mar 7, 2009
amazing movie. loved every second of it
0 of 0 users found this helpful
10
BillH.Mar 7, 2009
This was a great movie, the pacing is done in a manner which directly mimics Dr. Manhattan's removed perception of events and reality, reviewers are really missing the point of this, I don't get what they are all banging it up for, This was a great movie, the pacing is done in a manner which directly mimics Dr. Manhattan's removed perception of events and reality, reviewers are really missing the point of this, I don't get what they are all banging it up for, yes it's a little long, but there's so much to pack into one film, I could see how the director's cut might actually improve the viewing experience!… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
9
LiahT.Mar 7, 2009
This movie is incredibly faithful to the graphic novel, which I guess some found disconcerting. It seems to me that the critics can't make up their minds when it comes to adaptations: they pan an adaptation if it isn't faithful This movie is incredibly faithful to the graphic novel, which I guess some found disconcerting. It seems to me that the critics can't make up their minds when it comes to adaptations: they pan an adaptation if it isn't faithful enough, they pan an adaptation if its too faithful. Make up your minds, people! Right now you all sound incredibly unfair.… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
9
MichaelK.Mar 7, 2009
A very good movie, very faithful to the original comic. It definitely isnt the comic, there was absolutely no way they could reproduce that in movie form. The trick to seeing a movie like this is knowing that its not gonna surpass the source A very good movie, very faithful to the original comic. It definitely isnt the comic, there was absolutely no way they could reproduce that in movie form. The trick to seeing a movie like this is knowing that its not gonna surpass the source material and that's what made it so awesome for me. the acting was great (especially Rorschach's) and the action was amazing and incredibly gory... and really please stop dissing Dr. Manhattan. Ive read too many people that said he was just like the silver surfer. i don't think those people have any idea that this was an adaptation of a comic book… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
9
MarkG.Mar 7, 2009
First, take note of all the reviewers who gave this film a 5 or less, and ignore them from now on. They can't be trusted. Second, any person who is surprised to be disappointed by a film adaptation of a book needs to stay out of the First, take note of all the reviewers who gave this film a 5 or less, and ignore them from now on. They can't be trusted. Second, any person who is surprised to be disappointed by a film adaptation of a book needs to stay out of the theater if he or she has read the book first. Guess what. Books and films, apples and oranges. It's your fault if you can't make the transition. To those offended by sex and violence, if a movie is based on a graphic novel (which is not the same as a comic book), avoid it. You will always be offended. And finally, anyone wanting to see an action film should choose something else. This is not a turn-off-your-brain-and-enjoy-the-ride kind of romp. There's a lot to think about and the average movie goer will not want to do the mental work needed to get it. That's not to say most people are stupid, just that most won't want to work out the many philosophical puzzles presented in this film. Bottom line: not everyone's cup of tea, obviously. As for me, Lisa H., a Tarantino/X-Men baby is a mighty fine addition to the family. Great idea. Hope Quentin considers it.… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
9
SongMar 7, 2009
The action, story and characters are great. Some of the song choices were bad. The film shows a bit too much of Dr.Manhattan's enlarged(from the comic) member. Not a good film to bring kids or even a date if you don't want to them The action, story and characters are great. Some of the song choices were bad. The film shows a bit too much of Dr.Manhattan's enlarged(from the comic) member. Not a good film to bring kids or even a date if you don't want to them seeing lots of gore, sex, and private parts.… Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
Page:
More From This Movie

56 Critic Reviews

8.1 User Reviews

Details & Credits|Trailers

Current Movie Releases
By MetascoreBy User Score
1 81 28 Years Later: The Bone Temple
2 77 Project Hail Mary
3 75 Send Help
4 73 Hoppers
5 72 The Sheep Detectives
SEE ALL
Essential Links
New on Amazon Prime Video
New on Netflix
Coming Soon to DVD/Blu-ray
SEE ALL