Netflix | Release Date: November 17, 2021
6.5
USER SCORE
Generally favorable reviews based on 394 Ratings
USER RATING DISTRIBUTION
Positive:
241
Mixed:
76
Negative:
77
Watch Now
Stream On
Review this movie
VOTE NOW
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Check box if your review contains spoilers 0 characters (5000 max)
0
bnbianchiMar 19, 2022
This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. i hated this movie!... i was waiting for it to get interesting considering the reviews...it's slow, couldn't connect w/ the characters, didnt give a damn abt Cumberbunch's homosexuality... the acting was "meh" at best... sigh... it will win the Academy Award for Everything!... movie, director, writing, acting, location, on and on... i guess im not sophisticated enough... i give it a -0... if u want to c a great film abt the west watch "First Cow"... absolutely the best! Expand
2 of 2 users found this helpful20
All this user's reviews
0
DrLAVMar 20, 2022
I'm with Sam Elliott--what a POS! Like so many, this film just drug along, and I kept waiting for it to get better, but, well....that's 2+ hours of my life I'll never get back.
2 of 2 users found this helpful20
All this user's reviews
0
EsotericEricFeb 14, 2022
This movie tells you its more important than it is, and the critics believed it.

Absolutely nothing happens, just grunting and nodding while the score makes you believe something epic is moments away. Spoiler: It isn't.
8 of 9 users found this helpful81
All this user's reviews
2
RoisinMJan 17, 2022
Tries to be subtle but ends up boring and confusing. The entire plot is just hints and subtext, with hardly any dialogue. Music and cinematography make it seem like something tense is brewing, but no plot developments happen until the last 10Tries to be subtle but ends up boring and confusing. The entire plot is just hints and subtext, with hardly any dialogue. Music and cinematography make it seem like something tense is brewing, but no plot developments happen until the last 10 minutes. The only female character (though well acted by Dunst) is so undeveloped she is just a wilting flower - we're led to believe she is so weak that her brother in law playing mandolin a bit loudly and not coming to her dinner party was enough to torment her into alcoholism, despite the fact she apparently already survived one husband's suicide and ran her own business just fine. We are given no insight into the inner worlds of any characters and are instead left guessing at the meaning of it all. Expand
7 of 8 users found this helpful71
All this user's reviews
0
Dsnuts209Jan 27, 2022
Very very slow and boring. I kept thinking something was going to happen to make the movie interesting but it didn’t. Now I’m disappointed two hours later.
7 of 8 users found this helpful71
All this user's reviews
2
vgreenwevFeb 11, 2022
This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Power of the dog was not Oscar worthy. First of all, its filmed in New Zealand that is very clear, the two brothers are still sleeping in their childhood room, but their mother and father have moved out of the house (why) never explained. The movie moves from the marriage, to being a drunk to her son in medical school in 10 minutes. Phil went to Yale really since he was having an affair with Brono Bill when did he have time to do this? And how did her son know that he would find a cow dead from Anthrax lucky find. There were HUGE holes in the story line, and I could not figure out why this movie would get any nods. If you want to watch a great western in the early 1900's watch Legend of the Falls so much better. Expand
7 of 8 users found this helpful71
All this user's reviews
0
mgrandellFeb 14, 2022
I found it to be abusive to animals and stopped watching at 32 minutes when Benedict, the fake vegan, started swatting the horse in the face repeatedly while shouting **** at it. Seeing the fear in that horse's eyes was heartbreaking. II found it to be abusive to animals and stopped watching at 32 minutes when Benedict, the fake vegan, started swatting the horse in the face repeatedly while shouting **** at it. Seeing the fear in that horse's eyes was heartbreaking. I researched the animal abuse, and it is real. Further along in the movie, I read that Benedict also castrates a bull. Why is this abuse necessary and tolerated? I will no longer watch a movie with Benedict Cumberbatch or a movie directed by Jane Campion. Expand
7 of 8 users found this helpful71
All this user's reviews
0
EgrobinsFeb 16, 2022
This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. This movie was really bad from start to finish. I kept waiting for the movie to get better. Don't waste your time. Expand
6 of 7 users found this helpful61
All this user's reviews
3
ElarturFeb 23, 2022
This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. This movie is really boring, it tries to generate moments of tension but it doesn't make it, the events doesn't mean anything and the end is anticlimactic as no other Expand
6 of 7 users found this helpful61
All this user's reviews
0
bartsniderMar 3, 2022
Boring is about the best thing that can be said for this movie. It reminded me of the old saying, "As exciting as watching chrome rust" or "watching grass grow." The good reviews of this film must have been done by Hollywood elitists whoBoring is about the best thing that can be said for this movie. It reminded me of the old saying, "As exciting as watching chrome rust" or "watching grass grow." The good reviews of this film must have been done by Hollywood elitists who think they know more about what's good than the rest of us. Giving it an Oscar would be a major disservice to moviegoers and the film industry. Much better for everyone to rename the film "Hair of the Dog" and just let it go off and be forgotten. Expand
5 of 6 users found this helpful51
All this user's reviews
2
FATMANGOBOOMJan 28, 2022
One of the worst movies I have ever seen… no one acts likes this and it is just bad… you find yourself waiting and waiting for it to get better but it does not it just gets worst…

Put it this way, I would rather piss on an electric fence
One of the worst movies I have ever seen… no one acts likes this and it is just bad… you find yourself waiting and waiting for it to get better but it does not it just gets worst…

Put it this way, I would rather piss on an electric fence then suffer watching this movie again…
Expand
9 of 11 users found this helpful92
All this user's reviews
1
aaronmasserFeb 7, 2022
This movie seems to be intentionally irritating and the big ending was not that surprising or interesting. It is boring.
8 of 10 users found this helpful82
All this user's reviews
1
twpolkFeb 8, 2022
Badly acted, boring, slow, in love with itself.

But it’s beautiful to look at.
7 of 9 users found this helpful72
All this user's reviews
0
robomartionDec 21, 2021
Rubbish, worthless junk. Totally boring nothingness. Will be buried and forgotten along with the growing graveyard of Netflix originals in a few weeks. Don't watch.
9 of 12 users found this helpful93
All this user's reviews
1
InMyDayFeb 24, 2022
OMG soooo boring. The first two times I tried to watch it I fell asleep. Had to drink a Red Bull on the third attempt just to stay awake. If a movie is just about pretty cinematography we don't need directors. The cinematography is great, andOMG soooo boring. The first two times I tried to watch it I fell asleep. Had to drink a Red Bull on the third attempt just to stay awake. If a movie is just about pretty cinematography we don't need directors. The cinematography is great, and it makes for a good trailer, but there is nothing here. And Benedict Cumberbatch is so miscast. He looks like he only weighs 110lbs soaking wet. Not a very ominous threatening figure at all. The plot drags on like a broken cart being pushed uphill. Jane Campion hasn't directed a good movie since 1993's The Piano. Who keeps hiring her? I have no idea what the Oscars was thinking with all the nominations. Expand
3 of 4 users found this helpful31
All this user's reviews
3
TomMondayDec 27, 2021
Power of the yaaaaawn. Nothing happens for a looooooong time. Cumberbatch is totally miscast as a roughneck American. Portentous music telegraphs tension that the film totally lacks. Pass!
10 of 14 users found this helpful104
All this user's reviews
0
LephtyDec 2, 2021
I had high hopes for this film being that I am somewhat familiar with the director and wanted to see a female take on the western genre. I read the book it’s based on more than twenty years ago but I have to say the film was a disappointment.I had high hopes for this film being that I am somewhat familiar with the director and wanted to see a female take on the western genre. I read the book it’s based on more than twenty years ago but I have to say the film was a disappointment. It all starts with cowboy rancher Phil not taking off his chaps or hat indoors which no self respecting cowboy would do, he wears spurs all day everyday and speaks with a horrible American accent. I could forgive this since Benedict was pretty good but the whole movie is a There Will Be Blood ripoff. From the cinematography to the soundtrack to the shots it seems to be a film students take on the source material who hasn’t found her own voice. I am appalled at the critical acclaim and the fact that no “professional” critics noticed the similarities with There Will Be Blood. I guess as long as you’re a woman making a gay cowboy movie your lack of originality can be overlooked. Expand
12 of 17 users found this helpful125
All this user's reviews
1
LsarDec 1, 2021
This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Look, in short this movie has a queer coded and violent antagonist who is killed by a neurodivergent young adult. Even if you excuse these blatant and outdated tropes, this movies legit sucks. It is not tense, it is boring. The cinematography is ruined by the horrible script and one note acting by Jesse Plemons and Kirsten Dunst (I’m sorry Queen I think you can do better). If you need to rely on queer coded villains in the year 2021 well then you’re just a horrible writer. Get off your Hays code era bs and write some actual drama. This movie was lifeless and dull. Beyond relying on horrible tropes, this movie just has no inspiration. You want the fall of the Wild West personified? Go play Red Dead Redemption 2. Go read All The Pretty Horses. Go drink half a bottle of Makers and slam your head against a wall. You will gain a greater understanding of the west by doing any of these compared to watching this slow rotting corpse. Legit 0/10 I will scream about how bad this movie is I cannot believe it is a Metacritic must see. Expand
9 of 13 users found this helpful94
All this user's reviews
1
PisoFeb 21, 2022
Jane Campion is no Christian. Anyone who knows the first thing about Psalm 22 knows it's a prophecy foretelling Jesus's suffering on the cross. The interpretation in which Cumberbatch is the "dog" and Dunst is the "darling" is anti-textualJane Campion is no Christian. Anyone who knows the first thing about Psalm 22 knows it's a prophecy foretelling Jesus's suffering on the cross. The interpretation in which Cumberbatch is the "dog" and Dunst is the "darling" is anti-textual nonsense. Also, the movie is boring, passive-aggressive drivel. The whole plot hinges on some nonsense about burning piles of extremely valuable cured animal hides, which no one would ever do. If you think this is a film about cowboys doing cowboy things, it's not. If you think it's about characters making logical choices based on competing interests, it's not. If you think it's Jane Campion jumping in a time machine to complain about how awful she thinks our great-grandfathers were, taking whinging pot shots at "toxic masculinity" through a post-modern lens but with cowboy hats on, you're right on the money. Expand
2 of 3 users found this helpful21
All this user's reviews
0
DashingDexterMar 13, 2022
Too bad I chose to watch this mess... satisfaction may have brought the cat back...but in this case...
2 of 3 users found this helpful21
All this user's reviews
1
KeepzepackDec 9, 2021
Slow, tedious, boring movie, where the camera lingers on flat earth and the movie lingers on long, long silences between grunts by the actors. As if this weren't bad enough, there is Director Jane Campion's fixation with pianos, ever sinceSlow, tedious, boring movie, where the camera lingers on flat earth and the movie lingers on long, long silences between grunts by the actors. As if this weren't bad enough, there is Director Jane Campion's fixation with pianos, ever since she won sone underserved award for her previous film, The Piano. In this film, she has dusty cowboys dragging a grand piano onto the Wyoming deserts for unimaginable reasons. I could only take 45 minutes of this awful film, then turned it off. Expand
7 of 11 users found this helpful74
All this user's reviews
2
RobhussleJan 13, 2022
I’ve never been less entertained my a movie. The story line is the equivalent to eating cardboard. It’s just nothingness.
3 of 5 users found this helpful32
All this user's reviews
1
Seth937Jan 1, 2022
Benedict’s acting is top notch. There’s some really beautiful shots in this movie, but at the end of the end this movie sucks. Like a lot. The “music” which is just a three year old playing the piano really poorly, is really bad and annoying.Benedict’s acting is top notch. There’s some really beautiful shots in this movie, but at the end of the end this movie sucks. Like a lot. The “music” which is just a three year old playing the piano really poorly, is really bad and annoying. There’s no real development of the story telling you who is who and what is going on. You’re almost all the way through the movie before you finally see what you think they’ve been trying to tell you only for it to leave you going what the F was that? Save your two hours and thank me later. Expand
4 of 7 users found this helpful43
All this user's reviews
1
ishurikDec 10, 2021
I barely finished watching to the middle. It is one of the most boring movies I've seen in my life.
5 of 9 users found this helpful54
All this user's reviews
3
DavoZedDec 10, 2021
This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. This is a dreadful movie. I couldn't sit through it to the end.

Cumberbatch has 2 speeds- getting dirtier (by bathing in mud, for example) and glowering. That's it. He's charismatic? How?

Jesse Plemens role could have been played by a store mannequin, that's the level of the character's physicality and emotion. Kirsten Dunst is ditzy squared but it gets tiring pretty quick. Her Pee Wee Herman wannabe son is laughable and wouldn't have survived in 1920's Montana for 10 minutes. If you need a list of a hundred movies released this year, to see ahead of this one, drop a me line and I will send it to you.
Expand
5 of 9 users found this helpful54
All this user's reviews
1
MoutamineDec 5, 2021
Worst movie I watched all year. I want my 2-hours back. The movie is filmed like an horror movie (constant tension) and yet nothing ever happens. It's absolute garbage.
7 of 13 users found this helpful76
All this user's reviews
0
AriesrainMar 22, 2022
One of the most boring movies. Not a true western. You can tell it is not Montana. Not anything I would recommend.
1 of 2 users found this helpful11
All this user's reviews
3
KvncvsMar 23, 2022
Really underwhelming, uninteresting story and difficult to empathize with. Lame experience and I don’t understand why it is being acclaimed as excellent.
1 of 2 users found this helpful11
All this user's reviews
2
JudgeSmailsNov 28, 2021
The best thing about the movie was the style of it- sort of a There Will Be Blood atmosphere to it. However, it digressed into some heavy handed messaging and overwrought acting that was hard to take seriously.
7 of 15 users found this helpful78
All this user's reviews
0
Sqarni13Dec 2, 2021
worst movie ever made there is nothing interesting about this movie I didn’t enjoy watching it
7 of 15 users found this helpful78
All this user's reviews
0
Riles2000Dec 14, 2021
Boring and pathetic storyline and script. The story development was lazy. Some cinematography was great
7 of 15 users found this helpful78
All this user's reviews
3
MetacriticOnurDec 2, 2021
bad
[ bad ]

adjective, worse, worst;(Slang) bad·der, bad·dest for 36.
not good in any manner or degree.
5 of 11 users found this helpful56
All this user's reviews
0
Jacko16Nov 20, 2021
This is my #1 worst movie of all time, some movies are so bad they become funny how bad they are like "The Room", this is sitting at the perfect level where it's just terrible. It thinks it's so much smarter than it is, trying to be aThis is my #1 worst movie of all time, some movies are so bad they become funny how bad they are like "The Room", this is sitting at the perfect level where it's just terrible. It thinks it's so much smarter than it is, trying to be a masterpiece like "There Will Be Blood" or "No Country For Old Men" but with zero substance, resulting in a self-important pile of garbage. Benedict Cumberbatch overacts and puts on a terrible American accent, it looks like some tacky theatre performance. Nothing to say that's positive for this whole mess, I watched it for the high review score which is very suspect because it's literally the worst film I've ever seen. Expand
11 of 31 users found this helpful1120
All this user's reviews
1
FarnoodJSep 4, 2022
This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Well, one doesn't know where to start. The film has a potential to be great, but constantly falls short. The characters and their motivations are not convincing at all. For instance, i dont believe that anyone's issues with in-laws or their stepfamily can amount to their killing each other silently.
Phil's motives are not well-established for us to believe his actions toward Rose, Rose is not well established to become a drinker, Peter's motives not clear to become a murderer for the sake of his mom. I understand he is capable of killing a rabbit, but it's not enough.
Some lazy symbolism too, like carrot, as phallus or under the tree as a place of subconscious . Much less than convincing
Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful00
All this user's reviews
3
fwmurnauApr 5, 2022
If you look at the few 10 star reviews, they all sound like the same person wrote them,like a publicist for the film or studio. Definitely looks like they were planted in a desperate effort to raise the viewer score, which would be extremelyIf you look at the few 10 star reviews, they all sound like the same person wrote them,like a publicist for the film or studio. Definitely looks like they were planted in a desperate effort to raise the viewer score, which would be extremely low without them. I mean seriously: what ordinary moviegoer writes like this? "Stunning. Raw. Complex. Challenging. Heartbreaking. Iconoclastic. Innovative. Reverential. Sensual. I could go on foerver. Favorite movie of the year. Dunst and Cumberbatch are supreme. Jane Campion has done it again!" Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful00
All this user's reviews
3
ProfAmateurMar 4, 2023
If you liked Nomadland you will probably also like this movie. If no, not. Just random scenes from a cowboy range in 1925.
0 of 0 users found this helpful00
All this user's reviews
0
Tobias89Mar 28, 2022
This movie was so boring it ruined Christmas. It is a 2 hour long constant crescendo of unparalleled boringness.
0 of 0 users found this helpful00
All this user's reviews
1
MiralunaMar 25, 2022
Dreadful "slow burn" of tired gay cowboy sterotypes we've seen SO many times before. This film is not powerful or progressive. Cumberbatch is miscast and obnoxious with his phony western accent, ridiculous chap fetish and one-dimensionalDreadful "slow burn" of tired gay cowboy sterotypes we've seen SO many times before. This film is not powerful or progressive. Cumberbatch is miscast and obnoxious with his phony western accent, ridiculous chap fetish and one-dimensional meanness. Campion is a narcissist who can't even accept an award without cluelessly dismissing the accomplishments of greater black women who had to overcome so much more than a critic's darling like Campion can even imagine. Sam Elliott is not a homophobe for calling this a POS but Campion might just be the worst opportunist "ally" of gay people ever. Truly wonderful actors wasted on cardboard characters with overly predictable and manipulatively depressing motivations. A gay cowboy pinup calendar has more substance than this dog of an "art film." Cinematography is beautiful but this movie is ugly, mean, small-minded and ultimately just boring. It does not work as a critique of "toxic masculinity" because real people aren't so one-dimensional and easy to despise. It probably does qualify as toxic, self-important "artistry." Is there not room in the world for men who embrace traditional manliness with eyes wide open, gay or straight? Are you a true feminist if you're so hung up on paper-thin gender roles (see Kirsten Dundst's Rose)? Shame on professional critics for their self-serving overly laudatory take on an at best mediocre "PC approved" effort. Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful00
All this user's reviews
1
VedderAdderMar 25, 2022
Boring, idiotic, new age crap. My wife and I couldn’t make it half way through.
0 of 0 users found this helpful00
All this user's reviews
0
ko805Mar 26, 2022
My wife and I suffered through this movie and concluded it was probably the worst movie ever (I disagreed, I thought Jaws 15 was far worse). It's amazing anybody agreed to fund another boring Jane Campion movie - what is her obsession withMy wife and I suffered through this movie and concluded it was probably the worst movie ever (I disagreed, I thought Jaws 15 was far worse). It's amazing anybody agreed to fund another boring Jane Campion movie - what is her obsession with pianos!? Everybody overacted except "Bronco Henry", a too-friendly uncle represented by a shrine featuring his saddle. The plot was unintentionally funny because it was so absurd. The music score sounded like a bunch of novice musicians all playing different songs. However, these are the kind of movies that "critics" love because it checks all their PC boxes. I suspect the vast majority of 5-star "audience" ratings came from those who funded or worked on the movie. You can always tell rating manipulations when there is an overwhelming number of truthful 1-star reviews. Rating sites need to do a better job filtering out these economically biased ratings. Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful00
All this user's reviews
1
durstlawMar 27, 2022
This is one of the absolute worst movies I've ever seen. How people nominated it for an Academy Award baffles me beyond baffling. I suppose reviewers like it because its a gay cowboy movie. Jesse. So boring, so bland, goes nowhere andThis is one of the absolute worst movies I've ever seen. How people nominated it for an Academy Award baffles me beyond baffling. I suppose reviewers like it because its a gay cowboy movie. Jesse. So boring, so bland, goes nowhere and keeps going nowhere. Torture to watch, minute by minute boringness. Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful00
All this user's reviews
0
Nr42397Mar 27, 2022
I signed up to MetaCritic just to comment on the madness:

This movie, aside ratings/ nominations, is one of the worst ever. It is incomplete, in clarity of message, lacks innovation, is incomprehensible, and miscasts. It has interesting
I signed up to MetaCritic just to comment on the madness:

This movie, aside ratings/ nominations, is one of the worst ever.
It is incomplete, in clarity of message, lacks innovation, is incomprehensible, and miscasts. It has interesting ideas, and if the flow were clearer, I’d just pass it as one I didn’t see as worthwhile, but this isn’t there.
It must be the high end actors and high quality team, production, etc, with an attempt at a message; I appreciate that it has given a base to compare critics (and the acadamys) ability to critique (though good choice with CODA).
Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful00
All this user's reviews
3
GaryRJApr 1, 2022
Three words, dull, dull, dull. Netflix and you are not alone, please stop making expensive movies to please the critics and ignore your paying audience. Competent acting, great scenery but zero impact as a story.
0 of 0 users found this helpful00
All this user's reviews
2
BraynlessApr 3, 2022
Ok - My fault - This is what happens when you watch the Academy Awards and get suckered into believing critics. Cumberbatch is convincingly good, Kirsten Dunst hasn't gotten over spiderman and still calls for "Peter", there is less dialogueOk - My fault - This is what happens when you watch the Academy Awards and get suckered into believing critics. Cumberbatch is convincingly good, Kirsten Dunst hasn't gotten over spiderman and still calls for "Peter", there is less dialogue than an early Schwarzenegger movie, and it moves ...... at ...... the .........pace .......... of ........ a ........ g l a c i e r. Better suited to the politically correct academic elite who drink bubbly vinegar (champagne) eat raw fish guts (caviar) and buy Jackson Pollock paintings (drop sheets).
2 hours of your life that can be put to better use.
Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful00
All this user's reviews
1
MaddsTheHatterJun 17, 2022
Besides a few amazingly beautiful shots in this film, it is not worth your time at all. An hour in and nothing of a plot has been established. One of the most boring movies I have ever seen, turned at off an hour and a half in. Would not recommend.
0 of 0 users found this helpful00
All this user's reviews