Zeitgeist Films | Release Date: February 17, 2006
8.2
USER SCORE
Universal acclaim based on 53 Ratings
USER RATING DISTRIBUTION
Positive:
45
Mixed:
6
Negative:
2
Watch Now
Stream On
Buy on
Stream On
Stream On
Expand
Review this movie
VOTE NOW
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Check box if your review contains spoilers 0 characters (5000 max)
9
KenG.Apr 3, 2006
Poignant, inspiring story that sends the important message that going to war for your country, or supporting your country isn't the only way to be a patriot. Sometimes a patriot is the person who stands up to their country and saids Poignant, inspiring story that sends the important message that going to war for your country, or supporting your country isn't the only way to be a patriot. Sometimes a patriot is the person who stands up to their country and saids "NO!", when their country is doing wrong. And no, the United States today is no where close to what Nazi Germany was. But if we wait to we are close, or have gone too far down that road before we say no, then it will be too late. The idea is to speak out when we are just starting down that road. Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
10
PhilipP.Jan 10, 2007
A human drama without any added film dramatizations and all the more chilling because of it. This could happen today in any country unless the people are aware.
0 of 0 users found this helpful
9
LK.Jun 22, 2007
A great gift for the kid going to college. Question everything. Know what you believe---and WHY. Then, you, like Sophie Scholl, will know when you must stand up against injustice.
0 of 0 users found this helpful
9
VK.Jun 7, 2007
This woman (only 21-22) is one of the most admired persons in Germany. The best part is when she verbally faces off against an experienced Gestapo interrogator!
0 of 0 users found this helpful
10
JoanM.Feb 28, 2006
Julia Jentsch gives a powerful performance, authentic Oscar worthy. The films deserves the Oscar.
0 of 0 users found this helpful
7
JustinS.Mar 24, 2006
interesting and timely. certainly poses some valid questions. Still, I didn't like the acting that much. Lots of tears and some screaming, but not much emotion otherwise. Too many speeches and it seemed like a hagiography far too often. interesting and timely. certainly poses some valid questions. Still, I didn't like the acting that much. Lots of tears and some screaming, but not much emotion otherwise. Too many speeches and it seemed like a hagiography far too often. Also, the judges lines and actions bordered on farcical at times. Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
10
ButteredPopcornDec 3, 2006
Engrossing and captivating. Uplifting and resolute throughout, this movie is about the triumph of principles and ideals over politics and circumstance. The scenes involving the interrogation of Sophie are so masterfully crafted that you come Engrossing and captivating. Uplifting and resolute throughout, this movie is about the triumph of principles and ideals over politics and circumstance. The scenes involving the interrogation of Sophie are so masterfully crafted that you come to realize that in fact, the balance of power has tipped to Sophie's advantage through the shear strength of her resoluteness and integrity. And not enough can be said for the exquisite attention to nuance and detail, giving the movie a taut sense of precison and purpose. A rare treat, wonderfully told, marvellously understated, and just brimming with meaning. Like one of the previous reviewers - this is my favorite movie of the year as well. Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
9
ArnoldP.Feb 24, 2006
Powerful and frightening and above all still relevant both for Americans today who must defend their freedoms and for Germans to see that good people can flourish against all odds. Amust see history lesson to all the youth. Dramatically Powerful and frightening and above all still relevant both for Americans today who must defend their freedoms and for Germans to see that good people can flourish against all odds. Amust see history lesson to all the youth. Dramatically gripping to know these were real people. Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful
10
LyleM.Jun 11, 2006
Excellent movie. Wonderful "conflict" scenes. So far, my "best movie" of the year.
0 of 0 users found this helpful
6
MarcK.Nov 24, 2006
Very talky, with not much else going on. I'm sure it's very faithful to what actually occurred, but I wasn't entertained.
0 of 0 users found this helpful
10
GaryP.Feb 24, 2006
Harrowing and superb!
0 of 0 users found this helpful
10
HelenA.Feb 24, 2006
Excellent performace; what a tragedy it hits your heart.
0 of 0 users found this helpful
10
FrancesS.Feb 28, 2006
Brilliant and moving. Performances like these are rare.
0 of 0 users found this helpful
7
ERG1008Aug 24, 2010
Anti-war protesters get caught delivering flyers in a University. Get arrested, interrogated, then on trial.
Quite intense dialogue throughout but very well acted & shot. Every film I've seen Julia Jentsch she has been brilliant & this is no
Anti-war protesters get caught delivering flyers in a University. Get arrested, interrogated, then on trial.
Quite intense dialogue throughout but very well acted & shot. Every film I've seen Julia Jentsch she has been brilliant & this is no exception. A mention too for Alexander Held as the cold yet angry Mohr.
You sort of expect what's going to happen but does leave you feeling empty at the end.
Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful00
All this user's reviews
8
FilipeNetoApr 15, 2020
A remarkable film that strives for authenticity and credibility.

I saw this film recently, very much under the influence of my girlfriend, who is a distant relative of Sophie Scholl. I had heard of this historical character but I confess
A remarkable film that strives for authenticity and credibility.

I saw this film recently, very much under the influence of my girlfriend, who is a distant relative of Sophie Scholl. I had heard of this historical character but I confess that I deepened my knowledge of it. It was worth watching this film and rediscovering this figure, remarkable for the anti-Nazi resistance.

The film is heavily based on historical documents and reports from people who lived with Sophie Scholl. This is enough to give this film a credible basis for greater realism, which has been fully achieved. The film never sounded false, imaginative or invented. The whole plot is centered on the arrest of Sophie Scholl and her brother Hans, and on the process, interrogation and trial of the two, to which a third conspirator joins. The film is not brutal and they are not subjected to torture or anything ... but the interrogations are harsh and do not spare the young woman questions in which she ends up contradicting herself and confessing. A precious moment in the film happens when Sophie debates with the police officer who interrogates her. The ideological debate between the two characters shows the ambiguity and fragility of the logic of the Nazi doctrine, and attests to the firm conviction of the young prisoner. The trial scene, in turn, reveals the way in which justice was applied: no matter the truth, the sentence was decided, it is important to give a show and make the three students an example so that other young people, who want to think for themselves, know what can happen to them.

I am not a specialist in German cinema, so it is not surprising that I do not know any of the actors involved. Julia Jentsch seemed to me to be a good choice for her physical resemblance to the real Sophie Scholl and it seems to me that she did a good job overall. Alexander Held was very good in that he gave the interrogator an unexpected humanity for someone so faithful to Nazi doctrine. His character, more than once, reveals feeling compassion for the young Sophie, even though she dislikes her idais. Perhaps this is an interesting fact for us: even among the most faithful Nazis there would be, as it is likely, good-natured people who only later realized the size of their mistake. Fabian Hinrichs and Florian Stetter were competent like Hans and Probst, but both had little to do and little time on the scene. André Hennicke was truly the face of Nazi cruelty and hypocrisy. Jörg Hube and Petra Kelling were good additions.

Technically, I don't see any major flaws. I tend to be very attentive to issues of historical correctness in period films, but I didn't see much that could possibly be incorrect. Only, perhaps, the choice of American jazz to be played on the radio in the opening scenes ... I don't know if the Nazis would allow this type of music, even the most popular, to be played on the radio, with the III Reich at war with the USA. But that was just a note and does not interfere with the credibility of the film. I also observed some caution and restraint in using the word "Fuhrer" and ostensibly Nazi symbols, such as the flag, but I do not know if this is an influence of current politics in Germany, which condemns its public appearance. Other than that, the film has good sets and costumes, it is very restrained in the effects, it seems to me that it has been very well edited and edited, and it has a very interesting soundtrack, dominated by jazz.

Nominated for the Oscar for Best Foreign Language Film, it is undoubtedly an interesting film and to some extent even educational, as it presents a relevant historical figure, in a relatively mild film in terms of brutality. It is not a film for children but I think that teenagers and young people can see it without problems.
Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful00
All this user's reviews
8
hamidgoodarziOct 4, 2022
I like the movie, it's the kind of movie that you can feel with your skin and bones. And the film has been a great success in international festivals. The movie is mostly shot indoors and has a good direction, and you can't ignore the actingI like the movie, it's the kind of movie that you can feel with your skin and bones. And the film has been a great success in international festivals. The movie is mostly shot indoors and has a good direction, and you can't ignore the acting of Sophie, she is wonderful. Expand
0 of 0 users found this helpful00
All this user's reviews