Read User Reviews and Submit your own for Roma - Page 2

10

VirgonoShakaJan 7, 2019

Well damn Cuaron, you did it again. Roma is not only a movie, it is an art exposition. Every shot, every moment is so well handled and filmed that a lot of the times I was thinking more about the how they did it than what was happening in theWell damn Cuaron, you did it again. Roma is not only a movie, it is an art exposition. Every shot, every moment is so well handled and filmed that a lot of the times I was thinking more about the how they did it than what was happening in the screen. Thankfully, I had a masterpiece of storytelling, with great performances and a humanity that is often missing in movies, to the point that I really felt I was a watching a real place in real time, with every person on screen (even the Extras) having a story, and at many times, stories that I wanted to see. I can't recommend enough, and it is my best movie of 2018 without a doubt.… Expand

0 of 4 users found this helpful04

All this user's reviews

10

ThatFilmGuy20Jan 7, 2019

Cuaron's Roma is undoubtedly one of the best realistic films throughout history, I say this because you'll find yourself lost in Roma, so immersed with how things are happening in a tedious way, much like life itself, that aspect of realismCuaron's Roma is undoubtedly one of the best realistic films throughout history, I say this because you'll find yourself lost in Roma, so immersed with how things are happening in a tedious way, much like life itself, that aspect of realism is fully captured by Cuaron as he presents us with an insight so vivid and so clear and raw you could swear that you're watching a real-life events happening in front of you, it gives you the chance to observe and asses and more importantly feel and relate to strong emotions from pain to love and in a manner that is very genuine, in all honesty, Roma is something really special, I can't start to describe how into it I was, I loved how Cuaron chose his camera angels, to provide the maximum presence, it just flows naturally, again at times it feels all too real, and that right there is near impossible to capture in such manner, it takes and lot to make something so simple.

The acting is spectacular, almost half the film we're presented with articulate shots that speaks volumes and doesn't need any dialogue to explain it, an also, Cuaron's attention to the background which is a story in and of itself.

What I'm trying to say here is Roma is as pure as they come, it's like an untouched part of nature so beautiful and so wild, it demands admiration, so ultimately, Roma is a fine piece of craft and an extremely rare gem, I absolutely, completely, utterly, fully enjoyed and loved this film, the power of film doesn't get stronger than this.… Expand

2 of 6 users found this helpful24

All this user's reviews

3

DarrylTanJan 6, 2019

Roma is quite underwhelming. Its not for everyone, those in the comments below who raves about this movie probably saw something in it that i couldn't see. If we are going sentimental, there are better movies out there that portrays thatRoma is quite underwhelming. Its not for everyone, those in the comments below who raves about this movie probably saw something in it that i couldn't see. If we are going sentimental, there are better movies out there that portrays that emotion. This one doesn't seem to give it enough... impact. It could be the black and white scheme it went for, it could be something else. Just my opinion. Im don't watch many of these types of films, but some that i do watch has etched an impression on me. This doesn't seem to have. Good cinematography but bland protagonist and a story ive definitely seen or heard before a hundred times.… Expand

10 of 14 users found this helpful104

All this user's reviews

2

ProteusJan 5, 2019

Character. Writing. Photography. Acting. These things make critics swoon. I prefer entertainment, excitement, originality, imagination, intensity, emotion, drama and comedy. Roma has none of those things.

If you are quite young, or naive, orCharacter. Writing. Photography. Acting. These things make critics swoon. I prefer entertainment, excitement, originality, imagination, intensity, emotion, drama and comedy. Roma has none of those things.

If you are quite young, or naive, or a film critic who goes gaga on the story of a normal sensitive young women you may like this film. If you want entertainment go elsewhere. Boring movie.… Expand

4 of 8 users found this helpful44

All this user's reviews

9

Iky009Jan 4, 2019

Cuáron cria personagens profundos dos quais simpatizamos, odiamos, e muitas vezes torcemos por eles, e esperando que no fim, tudo de certo. Roma é um retrato sensível, as vezes cru e realista de uma década turbulenta, uma obra-prima que passaCuáron cria personagens profundos dos quais simpatizamos, odiamos, e muitas vezes torcemos por eles, e esperando que no fim, tudo de certo. Roma é um retrato sensível, as vezes cru e realista de uma década turbulenta, uma obra-prima que passa uma mensagem de uma época da qual, ainda se reflete nos dias atuais.… Expand

0 of 4 users found this helpful04

All this user's reviews

3

czesiarudaJan 4, 2019

Bored AF. Boring,boring,boring and boring. There's raelly NOTHING going on. Only one scene in this movie is worth watching. ONE!And it's 135 minutes long!

9 of 12 users found this helpful93

All this user's reviews

2

Jkc3Jan 3, 2019

I'm Mexican I know all the movie talks about and all the places, and as much as I tried to like the movie it just doesn't. One thing good about this movie tho; the photography, really beautiful shot.
Now.... The actual history behind theI'm Mexican I know all the movie talks about and all the places, and as much as I tried to like the movie it just doesn't. One thing good about this movie tho; the photography, really beautiful shot.
Now.... The actual history behind the movie is predictable, boring and poorly written. I never got to connect with any character, thanks to a very lack of emotions from them they are just cast into a one dimensional role, and they never get out of it. If he tried to portrait the maid as they are in Mexico (I mean very submissive and so desperate that they accept any circumstances) then all the other characters should have a large array of emotions so there's contrast. But there's just no contrast they're all superficial stereotype persons.
A lot of scenes could have also been removed and we could have ended up with a much shorter and less tedious movie instead we have a very long, predictable with a lot of useless scenes movie, might it repeat again there are some beautiful shots tho. I hope it doesn't get the Oscar because there are just so many better narrated and well shot movies out there.
I will end my review doing this comparison;
Roma is like a picture of some delicious food that you see it and it looks just so good, but then cut the picture and realize it was nothing but emptiness and regret to ever tried… Expand

11 of 15 users found this helpful114

All this user's reviews

4

abdiespinozaJan 3, 2019

México no es así del todo, solo un sector, nos hace ver a todos como unos mestizos con vida muy pobre y noooo, México tiene muchas caras

0 of 7 users found this helpful07

All this user's reviews

3

NavyBeanJan 1, 2019

I guess it depends why you go to the movies. I like movies that have a story. Apparently critics and the self-important art-house crowd only care how a film is shot. I even read one review that called it a "masterpiece" but also said it hadI guess it depends why you go to the movies. I like movies that have a story. Apparently critics and the self-important art-house crowd only care how a film is shot. I even read one review that called it a "masterpiece" but also said it had "not much of a story." Another, which was one of the lower rated, said something to the effect of "no one would care about this as much if it was done by another director." I shrugged my shoulders after the credits came on and will likely never independently think of this film again.… Expand

13 of 16 users found this helpful133

All this user's reviews

9

MattBrady99Dec 31, 2018

“I like being dead.”

‘Roma’ is poetic film making at its finest. One of the beautiful and unique movies of 2018. Such an experience that after it was over, I struggled to utter a word. A masterful portrayal of joy, loss, betrayal, birth and“I like being dead.”

‘Roma’ is poetic film making at its finest. One of the beautiful and unique movies of 2018. Such an experience that after it was over, I struggled to utter a word. A masterful portrayal of joy, loss, betrayal, birth and heartbreak.

I’m honestly flawed by this. I cherish these type of movies.

I love the long tracking shots that lets the audience soak in the environment and scan every corner of the frame. The cinematography is so stunning and evocative, it implanted a image forever stuck in my mindset. Every frame is so carefully precise, I could make a picture frame out of them and hang up on a wall.

None of it felt fake, just real and raw. Same thing with the performances from everyone. Yalitza Aparicio is absolutely fantastic in this movie. However, what surprised me is finding out that this is her first big role, because I, not for one second would have never guessed that. If you thought that was impressive, Aparicio was told at the last minute by Cuaron about the birth scene and how that escalates (without spoiling anything). This being her first role and given such a tricky task, which she effortlessly pulls off - it makes me question if there’s any point of going to drama school. Simply amazing.

Alfonso Cuaron is a gift to cinema. The forest fire and beach scenes proves he’s the Tarkovsky of this generation.

I won’t say no more. See it for yourself if you’re interested.

Happy New Year everyone!… Expand

1 of 6 users found this helpful15

All this user's reviews

10

AlfonsoAVDec 30, 2018

Just can't explain how much I liked this movie. MUST see if you're into good camera handling and good shots. Quite slow movie but that makes you enjoy it more. 10/10 for me, absolutely.

2 of 7 users found this helpful25

All this user's reviews

9

AndremaxDec 30, 2018

Roma is visually beautiful, absolutely touching and emotional and mixes these points to a precise Cuaron's direction, maintaining rhythm all over picture always holding watcher. Maybe 2018 year's movie.

1 of 6 users found this helpful15

All this user's reviews

0

FrostyGammaDec 30, 2018

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. What makes Roma an incredibly boring film? It is not for lack of plot; a lot happens to Cleo and the family for which she works. It is a misplaced focus. There is an enormous amount of screen time given to bands marching down the street and to street musicians, with whom the characters show no notice. There are numerous long shots of the courtyard, where you are left with counting how many piles of dog poop are there today. Only in a couple of scenes does anyone interact with the poop. There are numerous scenes of being careful not to let the dog out or to run after it, but in only one scene does anyone interact with the dog. There are scenes of the children playing and fighting that have nothing to do with the plot. When something dramatic does happen, all the emotion is drained out of the scene. It's like watching staged figurines covered in bubble wrap. It takes a skill to film scenes like a deadly riot, a stillbirth and a near drowning and leave the audience unmoved. Cleo manages to deliver the line about not wanting the baby to be born as if she's reading a news report. Was she ashamed, relieved, guilty? We'll never know. It's one thing to portray a stoic character, but that's not what is going on here. She seems robotic at the most dramatic times; she could show some emotion on her face and the director could capture that.

Frankly, part of me was hoping Cleo would drown saving the kids as I was so incredibly tired of watching her character and it might bring the film to a close sooner.

I kept watching the film to the end, hoping it would improve, but it never did. It is a self-indulgent bore and a waste of over two hours.… Expand

3 of 15 users found this helpful312

All this user's reviews

9

goncalocoutoDec 27, 2018

"Roma" tem um início (primeiros 30 minutos) lento, no entanto, a segunda parte do filme é simplesmente fenomenal. Em geral, o filme é belo, intenso e emocionante.
9/10

1 of 6 users found this helpful15

All this user's reviews

10

DaniLoudDec 28, 2018

Roma is a masterpiece that works with a very quiet cinematography with touches of B&W that loves this Cuarón´s masterpiece. It's A tale to him family and a love letter to him women, it's fantastic.

2 of 9 users found this helpful27

All this user's reviews

1

writergal9825Dec 28, 2018

Baffled by the positive reviews. This was one of the MOST BORING films I've ever seen! The main character shows almost no emotion throughout the movie. In one scene where she is rejected you think she'll FINALLY show some emotion but theBaffled by the positive reviews. This was one of the MOST BORING films I've ever seen! The main character shows almost no emotion throughout the movie. In one scene where she is rejected you think she'll FINALLY show some emotion but the camera does not show her reaction! Unbelievably tedious and boring and I kept wanting the movie to end, as I'll never get back the time I wasted watching it.… Expand

19 of 24 users found this helpful195

All this user's reviews

7

TrevorsViewDec 27, 2018

It’s a delicate perspective that teaches the value of letting the mind drive the body, much like Roberto Benigni’s Life is Beautiful. Except now, it’s told through the eyes of a woman with minimal outward emotion expressed. Although it’sIt’s a delicate perspective that teaches the value of letting the mind drive the body, much like Roberto Benigni’s Life is Beautiful. Except now, it’s told through the eyes of a woman with minimal outward emotion expressed. Although it’s first important to know that this otherwise tremendous film in fact has a pretty bad screenplay; Roma is simply not personal enough with what it’s like for a single mother, considering nothing really happens to her, the grandmother, or the kids. They’re all emotionally distanced enigmas who pretty much just stand there as plot devices, not human beings.

Rather, the focus remains on the house maid, Cleo, whose mental state is shown to be crucial to success. Watching this production through her memory of serving this family has very intelligent establishments, even focusing in on a faucet dripping that connects back to Cleo’s shallow yet stern boyfriend using a shower rod for martial arts while he’s naked. Throughout these memories of a woman who only remembers the harsh, colorless moments as a maid, the creation of 1970’s Mexican culture is valuable for everyone to see. Inside the family’s walls, the television sets and cinema are both critical influences within this narrative. Outside the family’s walls, hail falls after a critical scene to pelt Cleo’s head until it melts into beads of sweat as she glistens during a stressful scene of labor.

It will be easy to remember these seemingly unimportant moments because director Alfonso Cuarón (Children of Men, Gravity) knows personally how crucial the brain is, so immediately during the opening credits, he commands total control within the screen by lingering on floor tile that becomes flooded with soapy water, which reflects an airplane in the sky. It’s a unique, provocative image specifically designed to be remembered, especially since that floor tile in the narrow driveway becomes a character that gives Cleo enough reason to enjoy being dead… truly amazing how Cuarón can do that. In the narrow driveway, Cleo first sees the father of the family, as introduced by his car before any face is revealed. While it consequently means nobody in the film is easy to connect with like a new close friendship, the soul breaks through to spark the memory of how several young women would see their father during dark trials.

Then Cuarón goes right from here to give information about the family through the young boys playing with guns, which seems like nothing at first, but carefully doses some foreshadowing toward an eventual street riot. Even when things get chaotic, Cuarón keeps quiet spectacle going louder than any James Bond movie, to the point when even the performances shine when the camera lingers on the details of the home. He doesn’t need all these closeups, but naturally keeps his actors on the same page as they make art out of the problematic script.

The tone remains quiet as the camera very slowly pans through Cleo turning off all the lights downstairs before bed, which makes a powerful ocean moment near the very end permanently impressionable. Many scenes, especially that one, are all in one long take that allows the lush black and white imagery to test your eyes. In the end, the imagery goes beyond just being mere pixels on a screen—but the memories shared in the same way somebody in Cleo’s predicament would remember it, making you and her one in body and spirit. That doesn’t mean this movie is for everybody. In fact, if you’re looking for something relatable in the instantly approachable sense, then the screenplay written by Alfonso Cuarón will not help. Unlike what the final moments of the film suggest, the idea never gets across that Cleo was ever a real sincere part of the family she serves. While it’s verbally communicated satisfactorily, it has much more potential than the final product. There are no real personal moments between Cleo and each of the family members to give you a clear sense of what their individual relationships are like, nor are there real personal moments between the sons and daughter, like this film pretends are there. It ultimately results in an incorrect message that humanity just exists without an end goal, that people might as well be passive since nothing we do really matters.

That henceforth categorizes Roma as a, “you either love it or you don’t” type of movie. That’s much what many of the old classics from the 1950s is like. For myself, after watching Roman Holiday, despite everyone calling it one of the greatest romantic comedies in history, I basically just went, “meh, now I can at least say I’ve seen it.” But there’s still an audience for it, as I know of an author in the UK who loves that movie! That’s how it will be for this film: If it doesn’t sound appealing, then you can look elsewhere for other experimental films that satisfy your taste buds.… Expand

0 of 4 users found this helpful04

All this user's reviews

7

KeithDowDec 27, 2018

There are a few undeniable things about 'Roma.' It's amongst the most gorgeously shot black and white films on record, which is all the more impressive considering Alfonso Cuarón serves as the film's writer, director, AND cinematographer.There are a few undeniable things about 'Roma.' It's amongst the most gorgeously shot black and white films on record, which is all the more impressive considering Alfonso Cuarón serves as the film's writer, director, AND cinematographer. There's also no distinguishing between fiction and reality. In particular, the actors in the movie make this slice-of-life film feel like it's a biography. And finally, if 'Roma' indeed goes on to win the Oscar for Best Picture--right now it's certainly a contender--it'll eventually be saddled with the reputation of being undeserving of the honor, much like 'Crash' or 'Shakespeare In Love.'

The bottom line is that no matter how vividly shot a picture may be (*cough cough* Terrence Malick), without an engaging plot, everything else is just cinematic masturbation. Lastly, a point of privilege: one reviewer fawned over Alfonso Cuarón's camerawork, setting expectations rather high. However, while a number of sequences are indeed wonderfully shot, basic left-to-right or right-to-left pans aren't exactly innovative. For comparison, watch 'Shoplifters' while paying special attention to camera placement and movement. It's nothing short of extraordinary and likely the best camera work of any film this year.… Expand

4 of 8 users found this helpful44

All this user's reviews

6

JLuis_001Dec 26, 2018

The technical and visual aspects are just impeccable. Nothing bad to say about that at all.
But and the story...?
Any mexican people could tell me that this was the story of any Mexican soup opera and I would believe it with absoluteThe technical and visual aspects are just impeccable. Nothing bad to say about that at all.
But and the story...?

Any mexican people could tell me that this was the story of any Mexican soup opera and I would believe it with absolute certainty and that's devastatingly alarming coming from Alfonso Cuarón.

I'm not really disappointed because my expectations about this film were not into that side, but to call this film a masterpiece, is simply a scandal.… Expand

9 of 12 users found this helpful93

All this user's reviews

8

migdalorguyDec 26, 2018

This film is a masterpiece. I say this even though the film did not connect with me as deeply as it has for some. It is beautifully written, filmed, and acted. It doesn't fully connect for me precisely because it is yet another film writtenThis film is a masterpiece. I say this even though the film did not connect with me as deeply as it has for some. It is beautifully written, filmed, and acted. It doesn't fully connect for me precisely because it is yet another film written as a valentine by someone who grew up in relative comfort to the lower class nanny/au pere who raised them. As such, gritty as it can be, it is still the rich man's perspective on how the lower class lives and experiences life, and throughout watching the film I couldn't escape that feeling. I was watching another man's shockingly honest yet at the same time still rose-colored dream perspective of not only his own reality but that of those of a lower social class who helped raise him. All that being said, Cuaron can't help being who he is. This film is deserving of every accolade and award that it gets.… Expand

1 of 8 users found this helpful17

All this user's reviews

3

WillCraigDec 23, 2018

My wife and I see a lot of movies every year -- over 100. Usually the critics are helpful in finding the good ones. They blew it on this one. Collectively! Some good photography, but usually not interesting material. No characterMy wife and I see a lot of movies every year -- over 100. Usually the critics are helpful in finding the good ones. They blew it on this one. Collectively! Some good photography, but usually not interesting material. No character insights. A waste of time.… Expand

11 of 17 users found this helpful116

All this user's reviews

0

mikebakuninDec 23, 2018

Every now and then a movie comes along that reviewers who want to appear sophisticated and "in the know" feel compelled to heap all kinds of praise upon. This is one of those movies. Boring, slow, tedious, and lame don't begin to describe it.Every now and then a movie comes along that reviewers who want to appear sophisticated and "in the know" feel compelled to heap all kinds of praise upon. This is one of those movies. Boring, slow, tedious, and lame don't begin to describe it. Hate is a strong word, but it is the only appropriate one to describe my feeling towards this waste of film. I honestly don't see how any real human being could like or enjoy this movie, and I suspect that very few actually did, despite their phony reviews.… Expand

11 of 21 users found this helpful1110

All this user's reviews

7

BrianMcCriticDec 22, 2018

Roma is undoubtedly one of the best looking movies of the year and does a remarkable job at conveying a message through long shots of the world going on around our main characters. The thing that holds me back is I never could become investedRoma is undoubtedly one of the best looking movies of the year and does a remarkable job at conveying a message through long shots of the world going on around our main characters. The thing that holds me back is I never could become invested in the lead character and towards the end when the emotional pull of the film hits I still felt somewhat hollow. Overall a high to middle 7 a B+.… Expand

1 of 5 users found this helpful14

All this user's reviews

10

josecaioDec 21, 2018

Um filme no qual Cuarón tem a liberdade de dirigir, escrever e fazer a fotografia da própria obra, atingindo o seu ápice artístico entregando uma simples embora lindíssima história contada numa narrativa paciente, calma e poderosa.

1 of 5 users found this helpful14

All this user's reviews

6

IzagoDec 21, 2018

Roma em minha opinião é parecido com o filme boyhood e lady bird que mostra a vida do protagonista e termina finalizando uma parte de sua história de uma forma lenta, sem chamar atenção, sem deixar você curioso, motivados, ou qualquer outraRoma em minha opinião é parecido com o filme boyhood e lady bird que mostra a vida do protagonista e termina finalizando uma parte de sua história de uma forma lenta, sem chamar atenção, sem deixar você curioso, motivados, ou qualquer outra emoção, o filme segue essa linha. Fotografia e as câmeras ficaram muito bons, me agrada muito se filmam de um ângulo ou jeito diferente e nesse ele mantém o mesmo jeito. Trilha sonora? Não tem, e eu acho que isso poderia deixar algumas cenas mais tensas e deixa las mais excitantes. Talvez para quem viveu no Mexico nessa época ou fez parte de alguma história próxima tenha se emocionado mais, pois para mim foi somente mais um filme.… Expand

0 of 4 users found this helpful04

All this user's reviews

7

AndrewBurgeDec 21, 2018

Alfonso Cuarón was always great at mixing visual proficiency with human emotions, often presenting the world (or outer space, in "Gravity") in a lush, pristine manned and making it interact with its characters.

So, in comes 'Roma', hisAlfonso Cuarón was always great at mixing visual proficiency with human emotions, often presenting the world (or outer space, in "Gravity") in a lush, pristine manned and making it interact with its characters.

So, in comes 'Roma', his latest release. Its premise its simple. It focuses on a middle-class family in Mexico City during the early 1970's. Yet for all its bitter-sweet humanity, the film feels slightly disconnected by having the potential of nearly every single scene absorbed by this prism of technical and visual marvel. Sure, it looks good, the atmosphere is present, but this mask, as nice as it might be, its too thick and often the film feels like a family slideshow. Its beautiful, but you do not really want to sit through it.

Alright, maybe not that bad. There are many scenes containing true emotional weight. The one in which the chaos on the streets breaks free, but more than that, the scene in which Cleo (Yalitza Aparicio) gives birth to her firstborn. That scene is presented with a personal purity which could have been this film's mark to greatness. The camera stays fixated, there is a sense of suppressed emergency and for the first time in nearly two hours, I felt truly connected. Not soon enough though, the film goes back to its habits.

Fortunately, this still is one of the most beautiful films I have ever seen. The Mexican new-wave directors really have a gift for presentation and an unmatched skill of polish when it comes to cinematography and editing. I also feel like mentioning Aparicio, who is a first-time actress at this point. She managed to hold her own as the lonely, troubled but loving maid.

In the end, I believe 'Roma' is more of a personal vision and nostalgic release for Cuarón rather than a traditional film. All this production, art-decoration, cinematography and editing is stunning to behold, too bad its such a thick emotional filter.… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

10

VincentNov 24, 2018

Simply the movie of the year. A new renaissance of emotional film-making. There is one unnecessary scene that threatens to ruin the beauty of the rest of the movie, but I can forgive it because the rest of the movie is that good. OutstandingSimply the movie of the year. A new renaissance of emotional film-making. There is one unnecessary scene that threatens to ruin the beauty of the rest of the movie, but I can forgive it because the rest of the movie is that good. Outstanding film!

Update: Post-Netflix, the theater experience is superior to the television experience sadly. The sound is flat where in the theater it was immersive and 3D (such as the laundry scene and the hill scene with the animals), and the size and scale of the set really is not given its full due on a television screen. I can understand why people who saw this on their television might not get the hype, but it is so much more transporting when the sound/screen is done right. Still a great movie, but it is sad to see and understand why people are not getting the hype/why people are so fascinated and impressed with this film.… Expand

8 of 21 users found this helpful813

All this user's reviews

6

BHBarryDec 18, 2018

“Roma” is a film written and directed by Alfonso Cuaron and is his attempt to pay homage and acknowledge his childhood in the Roma section of Mexico City as well as the housekeepers that cared for him and his siblings. Filmed in black and“Roma” is a film written and directed by Alfonso Cuaron and is his attempt to pay homage and acknowledge his childhood in the Roma section of Mexico City as well as the housekeepers that cared for him and his siblings. Filmed in black and white this film has become the choice of so many critics and award entities so I find myself again at odds with the so called pros for this film, as good as it is, is not great, nor in my opinion is it worthy of the accolades being heaped upon it. This is the story of a family, a marriage and those who kept house for them…..and that is where it all really begins and ends.
So, like a fly on a wall, we watch the residents and servants interact in a really not too exciting series of mundane events as they go about their assigned chores and fulfill their designated roles. I give the film a 6 rating as I continue to wonder what the excitement regarding it is all about..Perhaps the highest award should go to the distributor’s PR firm for being able to generate such unwarranted hype and activity..… Expand

8 of 15 users found this helpful87

All this user's reviews

10

MetawalkerACDec 18, 2018

Understated and subdued, especially compared to hollywood blockbusters or typical award-far, but technically brilliant and full of wonderful moments that dazzle the senses.

1 of 7 users found this helpful16

All this user's reviews

10

FlawlessasurnotDec 17, 2018

Esta película marca un hito definitivo en la carrera cinematográfica de Cuarón, poniéndolo entre los mejores hasta ahora. Viendo su buena producción, fotografía, sonido y la simultaneidad y casi perfección de cada acción, marca esta películaEsta película marca un hito definitivo en la carrera cinematográfica de Cuarón, poniéndolo entre los mejores hasta ahora. Viendo su buena producción, fotografía, sonido y la simultaneidad y casi perfección de cada acción, marca esta película como la mejor de este año y, quizás, de todos los tiempos.… Expand

1 of 6 users found this helpful15

All this user's reviews

9

WaelDec 17, 2018

"Roma" is both a visual and a sentimental masterpiece. The direction is outstanding (Kudos to you, Alfonso Cuaron), and the characters are very lovable. I felt like I lived with them in that house for two hours. The film encapsulates so much"Roma" is both a visual and a sentimental masterpiece. The direction is outstanding (Kudos to you, Alfonso Cuaron), and the characters are very lovable. I felt like I lived with them in that house for two hours. The film encapsulates so much emotion, and delivers a strong near-to-ending sequence. One of the best films I've seen this year. 9/10.… Expand

1 of 7 users found this helpful16

All this user's reviews

9

ahmedaiman1999Dec 16, 2018

I admire movies of this kind; movies that feel simple and spontaneous, and have unrestrained plot. But I prepare myself before watching a movie of this kind; simply because I usually don't find myself connected emotionally with these movies.I admire movies of this kind; movies that feel simple and spontaneous, and have unrestrained plot. But I prepare myself before watching a movie of this kind; simply because I usually don't find myself connected emotionally with these movies. And I was ready to watch one of these art-house movies that I appreciate from the artistic and technical standpoint more than truly enjoying them. But Roma really took me off guard. Because I found out that Cuarón took this artistic approach in making this movie just to tie the somewhat loose plot of an ordinary story into an emphatic and heart-wrenching force.

Cuarón's audiovisual motifs find their way across the film, not for the sake of showing his masterful skills, but to represent metaphorically, or sometimes literally, the characters' feelings, characteristics, nature, express their relationships to each other, and to mark major turning points in the story. When he doesn't use metaphors, Caurón plays, literally, with the contrast between background and foreground, and therefore allowing us to witness the currently unfocused on characters. This give me an opportunity to experience what all characters feel at every moment, and not loosing touch with any one of them at all. Furthermore, this gave the movie some kind of vividness that elevated the experience of watching it even more.

By doing so, Cuarón didn't just give us a phenomenal piece of cinema, but he also subverted the art-house film genre, and proved that films can be as technically flawless and outstanding as they are thoroughly accessible and absorbing.

The first act is a combination of simplicity and innovative visual storytelling.
The third act showcases Cuarón at the top of his visual craft, and that's when his signature long takes were prevalent, and each was as masterful as the last. But there's one in particular that sent chills down my spine, and kept me on the edge of my seat.
The second act, however, is more artistically enthralling than emotionally. Flawless from the narrative and technical, of course, aspects, but it's more "Arthouse" and meditative than anything else. It has some of the most beautiful shots, and moments, of the movie, though. And I really can't say that the movie lost me even for a split second.

The story isn't the most original thing you'll ever encounter. Actually, the characters arcs are quite familiar, but that doesn't take away even the slightest hint of greatness from this masterwork due to the completely unorthodox and refreshing ways the film narrated, structured, shot, and edited in. That said, I couldn't help notice the stereotypical character arc of Sra. Sofía (Marina de Tavira's character) at the end of the movie. Cleo, on the other hand, has enough genuine nuances and twists in her character arc that breathed new life into the character, let alone Yalitza Aparicio's spellbinding performance. Nevertheless, Marina de Tavira's committed performance is nothing short of stellar.

I hope Roma will jump start a career for Yalitza Aparicio. I already knew that many critics praised her performance in this movie, claiming that she gave one of the best performances of the year, but I really didn't expect that her performance will fascinate me like it did. For as much as I admired Hamilton Morris's performance in Sweet Country, or Brady Jandreau's in The Rider, I appreciated them for their naturalism and authenticity more than anything else. But as for Yalitza Aparicio, I really can't make up my mind whether her performance or Emily Blunt's in A Quiet Place is the best performance by an actress I've seen this year so far. And the same goes with these two movies they starred in as well.

Alfonso Cuarón doesn't go with the flow neither by giving priority to politics over anything else, nor by squandering his creative vision for the sake of making Hollywood cash-grab blockbusters. He stays true to his idiosyncratic vision, and faithful to his jaw-dropping trademarks. And here he is making yet another masterpiece that is captivating, poignant, personal and subversive all at once. And easily one of the most accessible art-house films ever made! Roma is a daring simple film.

(9/10)… Expand

1 of 7 users found this helpful16

All this user's reviews

10

movieducationDec 16, 2018

After bringing wonder and making me like a child - stunned - in Gravity, Alfonso Cuaron brings back the same ambition - to capture every frame beautifully, to transport, ROMA is worth every tears I’ve shed but this time I could not smell hisAfter bringing wonder and making me like a child - stunned - in Gravity, Alfonso Cuaron brings back the same ambition - to capture every frame beautifully, to transport, ROMA is worth every tears I’ve shed but this time I could not smell his ambition and that’s the highest feat.… Expand

1 of 8 users found this helpful17

All this user's reviews

8

Creeper3455Dec 16, 2018

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. SPOILERS for Roma,so please check the movie out before reading the review!

Alfonso Cuaron is an interesting filmmaker to discuss. Children Of Men was a “Story Setup Simmer” in a depressing future (until the 3rd Act),and Gravity taught me that the best experiences often don’t really need a story. Now with Roma (the new Netflix movie) he tackled something I wouldn’t expect (aside the technical aspect,but that’s for later): He made a movie that a director like Steve McQueen (Widows,Shame) would be proud.
In fact,the screenplay takes a bit too much time to set up a situation,for example,and get away with it really fast,and the presentation of this family feels like a metropolis at home,especially for the main character we’re following throughout the whole picture,Cleo (played by Yalitza Aparicio). And the screenplay sets her up to be a presence...Until the last half of the 2nd Act,where,aside from her presence,the screenplay dumps everything onto the garbage bin (for example,her best friend ignores her only to go in a more menacing road,the baby of hers was born dead...I mean,it goes deep in a heartbeat),only for that to be an excuse so that the family she works for loves her (and,in context,it makes sense,given that this family got separated from their father,who was basically an imbecile during its screen-time). I mean,what I said feels like another A+ Steve McQueen movie: slow buildup to a situation,the fact we follow this person for the whole movie,the fact that sometimes it feels like a short.
But that didn’t mean I was disappointed with the screenplay (as a whole),as the movie can be a great example of “Character Study”,since it sets Cleo up pretty fast instead of waiting 15-30 Minutes for a new character root. And it has a pretty emotional weight to it whenever it tries to take a break and let some characters breathe (when Cleo’s baby was considered dead,I was clenching my fists scared in the seat).
Alright,now for the technical aspect… This may be the best use of Dolby Atmos+Vision in a movie this year. The use of Dolby Vision was perfect in every frame,as this is bound to be one of the few inspirations for my comicbook drawings (since I’m trying to approach a style almost like that),and also because it definitely feels like a fantastic Throwback Thursday to the golden days of Black and White Movies. And sound mix in Dolby Atmos is flawless in every detail. Sound always flows in every speaker,and it manages to get really intense without having one of those bass-thumping moments. This may be the closest thing to a true 360° Sound Field (what Atmos is made for). Also,pay attention,because sometimes the mix will drop an important piece of story when you’ll be looking at the fantastic cinematography.
Look,I’m not saying Roma is bad or horrible as an Alfonso Cuaron movie,because there are some damn good things about it (and some inspirational ones,at times). Problem was just the fact that the screenplay was disappointing,because I didn’t expect such a grandiose screenplay that just feels like it’s in the wrong movie. Still,watch the movie. You’ll probably enjoy it better than me.
But ending just like “Children Of Men” with a “Shantih Shantih Shantih” was an awesome touch to the end credits.… Expand

1 of 6 users found this helpful15

All this user's reviews

9

everettDec 16, 2018

I'm amazed that few, if any, critics have been talking about the great divide in this beautiful, poignant film: The disparity between men and women. It is a tribute to women - Cleo, the protagonist, but also all who prominently appear: TheI'm amazed that few, if any, critics have been talking about the great divide in this beautiful, poignant film: The disparity between men and women. It is a tribute to women - Cleo, the protagonist, but also all who prominently appear: The other housekeeper, Adela, as well as the two patrician women in the household (though they are flawed, they are kind and loving overall), right down to the female obstetrician. On the other hand, we have the men who abandon them and their families; the shooters; the posers like Fermin who show off to a point that becomes downright ridiculous (you will remember that scene); the ones in military bands who march through the streets for no apparent reason at all ... and who of course are flying the planes that intersect the sky throughout. In the big martial arts demonstration in the field, who among them is able to execute the pose demonstrated by the teacher? The martial arts students are all falling over, while (did I see this wrong? The movie begs repeat viewings) isn't it Cleo, among the women on the sidelines watching all this, who pulls it off? Is there one likable male character here at all?

The ultimate message I got was that it is women who know how to love, while men are absorbed in themselves, to the point of disruption, and the most profound effect of this disparity is on the children. Women save and nurture while men work against them. The betrayed and abandoned wife says bluntly that women are always alone. Here, they are in one sense - that men disrespect them and/or fail to even stick around; but the women actually aren't alone. It's love that binds them to each other, and to the children who could not thrive without them. What an homage to the women who made Cuaron such a sensitive director, and an exception to his gender (as he sees it) in doing so.… Expand

6 of 13 users found this helpful67

All this user's reviews

10

alejandro970Dec 16, 2018

17 años después de Y tu mamá también Alfonso Cuarón a México con una más personalizada e introspectiva, apoyado en un estupendo trabajo de fotografía y personajes absorbentes: la madre de familia y la empleada domesticada que deben17 años después de Y tu mamá también Alfonso Cuarón a México con una más personalizada e introspectiva, apoyado en un estupendo trabajo de fotografía y personajes absorbentes: la madre de familia y la empleada domesticada que deben sobrellevar, cada una a su modo, el abandono de un padre cobarde y desnaturalizado. Narrado en un bien reproducido ambiente de época entre el vintage y el retro, es una de las películas de 2018 que dejarán huella indeleble. Sin falta.… Expand

1 of 6 users found this helpful15

All this user's reviews

10

carldamnitDec 15, 2018

Beautiful. I'm going to watch it ten more times before I decide whether or not I like the implications of the classist propaganda of the movie but it's so beautiful and so nuanced, I don't think it takes away from it being a great movie.

1 of 8 users found this helpful17

All this user's reviews

3

OlivierPielDec 15, 2018

Critics fall over themselves for another slick foamy soapy film from Cuaron, with very simple cinematographic tricks. It is obviously copying Zerkalo (The Mirror) by Tarkovsky but with far less ingenuity, creativity and poetry. WhereasCritics fall over themselves for another slick foamy soapy film from Cuaron, with very simple cinematographic tricks. It is obviously copying Zerkalo (The Mirror) by Tarkovsky but with far less ingenuity, creativity and poetry. Whereas Tarkovsky makes his life and his memories interesting by cleverly destroying time and space, blurring the lines between reality and dream, and making us think, think, think about our own memories, Cuaron serves a linear, egotistical, boring diaporama of his own life that didn't touch me at all. All this of course with a heavy dose of sentimentality and "humanism" that can't go wrong with middle-class critics.
But what about the cinematography?
The initial slow constant circular movement of the camera is obviously designed to clash with the perpetual zig-zagging of the little bee worker, create this extra tension and the rest is just like that. The scene of the fire is completely in line with his work in "children of men" with camera shifting from different points of foci in the same frame. All this is probably well crafted, and different from Hollywood, but doesn't inspire any beauty or even elicit any form of intellectual reflection.
It's better than Gravity, but that doesn't say much!… Expand

14 of 27 users found this helpful1413

All this user's reviews

10

katezoeDec 15, 2018

Masterpiece! One of the best films of all time. Direction and fluid camera work is breath taking. Brilliant cinematography. The acting is flawless. Magical story of a family and their maid. Oscars for Alfonso Cuaron best film, director,Masterpiece! One of the best films of all time. Direction and fluid camera work is breath taking. Brilliant cinematography. The acting is flawless. Magical story of a family and their maid. Oscars for Alfonso Cuaron best film, director, screenplay, cinematography.… Expand

2 of 10 users found this helpful28

All this user's reviews

8

moviemitch96Dec 15, 2018

This admittedly simple and straightforward, yet beautifully shot film follows a year in the life of a middle-class Mexican family in the 1970s. Directed by Alfonso Cuaron (director of films such as Children of Men, Gravity, and even the thirdThis admittedly simple and straightforward, yet beautifully shot film follows a year in the life of a middle-class Mexican family in the 1970s. Directed by Alfonso Cuaron (director of films such as Children of Men, Gravity, and even the third Harry Potter film), the film has such a natural eye and attention to detail and aesthetics throughout, and the portrayal of this family simply trying to live the best life they possibly can is tender and emotionally impactful. Overall, it does have moments where not much is happening, but the gorgeous black and white cinematography captures so many beautiful shots and easily makes up for those moments, and the film's simple yet completely natural approach to an average everyday family just trying to get by little by little proves surprisingly compelling and emotionally investing for the most part. And despite this being a Netflix film, I wouldn't at all be surprised if this film ends up in several major categories at the Oscars (even best picture!)… Expand

2 of 9 users found this helpful27

All this user's reviews

10

avr50Dec 14, 2018

¿Porqué no hay cineastas como Cuarón trabajando actualmente en México? Roma es una belleza de película desde principio a fin. La mejor película del año porque hace lo que muy pocas películas hacen, mostrarnos la belleza y la tristeza del día¿Porqué no hay cineastas como Cuarón trabajando actualmente en México? Roma es una belleza de película desde principio a fin. La mejor película del año porque hace lo que muy pocas películas hacen, mostrarnos la belleza y la tristeza del día a día.… Expand

2 of 9 users found this helpful27

All this user's reviews

1

riordanpettDec 14, 2018

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Nothing short of groundbreaking! Quality cinema. And no wonder it’s taken every award for Best Cinematography - so many beautiful shots, from the smashed mug on the floor to waves on the beach, to Cleo literally brushing up dog ****
Great acting, a good pacing, that can sometimes feel like a slow-burn but it all just comes together!

Now, my removal of 3 points may bare unpopular opinion, but I honestly felt like not a lot happened. It was a great film, with a pensive portrayal of the life of a beloved maid in 70s Mexico. Definitely one of the best films I’ve seen in ages, but I couldn’t tell what the climax was - the baby arriving or the kids drowning. While not every film needs a “climax” to sum up a great story, I just felt this was a slightly less enjoyable watch than A Star Is Born or even The Favorite. Roma is a film with a meticulously curated series of shots that cleverly cover a thin story. A film which the critics love but the audience may struggle to enjoy. I enjoyed it... It can take every Best Cinematography award, it’s unmatched this year, but Best Picture? Not too sure.… Expand

5 of 9 users found this helpful54

All this user's reviews

9

amheretojudgeDec 14, 2018

To Practice For Perfection.

Roma Cuaron's jaunting stay is frankly too practical to handle. Mumbling the mundane lifestyle of a maid in a mellow vocab, Cuaron has made his best film to date. First thing's first, the notable and yes loudTo Practice For Perfection.

Roma

Cuaron's jaunting stay is frankly too practical to handle. Mumbling the mundane lifestyle of a maid in a mellow vocab, Cuaron has made his best film to date. First thing's first, the notable and yes loud cinematography of his is hauntingly beautiful. No one ever points out the facts that goes behind the camera on screen like such and even though it eerily resonates with Anderson's symmetric camera work, it is a testament of its own for he himself was never able to speak effervescently like such. Speaking of it, there barely resides a stable conversation in here, the bickerings, the murmurings, the gossip, every bit of narration is piled under such pragmatic state of environment. Cuaron speaks through body language and physical sequences, to a point where they themselves become a character.

The sequence of a car being parked is so absorbing to encounter it on screen, which then enfolds into another layer of perspective to its intention and then another and then another. Cuaron keeps giving you reason- nay- he challenges you to get disengaged from this humble imbalanced world. And the host that he has selected to narrate this saga is a pure delight on terms of character development. Surprisingly, to write such a character is a daunting task. For its persistency ought to be justified and he does it in here as a mere distraction; kudos to him.

Each time the protagonist is helping the younger ones or her employers, Cuaron subconsciously maps out another milestone in your mind. The stillness of a scene staged in a room puts you right there on the spot among the actors, where you have to work your way through to concentrate the gossip or sort out the primary activity in a frame. Amongst many steps that constructs this ingenious behemoth monument called drama, personally that speaks to you is the sort-of-training-camp where Cuaron speaks honestly of his theme without any strings attached.

The cast has done a fabulous work, from the lead Aparicio as a humble supporter of this family and Tavira as the real supporter of Aparicio, along with the young cast which may resemble to the younger cast of Malick's The Tree Of Life. But Cuaron's dish is not spiced up with plethora of ingredients like Malick's, his sweetness is competent enough to tick for its course. Cuaron's span spent upon screen is a mesmerizing poem weaved out to clean and scrub a house properly.

And boy what a poem it is, dipped into a metaphorical tone, it soars just like those planes hovering around in the background. For the most part of it, Cuaron keeps the frame under the shades, teasing us to seek for the action going on and similar to it the storytelling too feeds on our imagination that is at brisk all the time, especially the last act that scares you with the closure that you are trying to achieve. Roma narrows down cinema to a better quality, Cuaron makes sure it isn't compromised for any reason whatsoever, not even for him.… Expand

3 of 12 users found this helpful39

All this user's reviews

10

petearellanoDec 14, 2018

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Unfortunately, although the premise is universal and criticizes disparity in society, Roma is a film that can only be fully understood by a middle-class Mexican. That forgotten class that exists and struggles inside the Latin American country. Only a Mexican will identify the nostalgia of playing with hail during the rainy season or the stress posed by an incoming earthquake. Only a Mexican will remember the authoritarian rule of the PRI and the student repression ordered by the government. With long and depressing shots -such as everydayness- Cuarón portrays wonderfully the life of the domestic service in Mexico. Moreover, he plays with the nostalgia of daily life in Mexico City before the overpopulation of the incoming decades. A time long yearned by the old citizens of the largest metropolis in the Western Hemisphere. Peculiarly, most criticism to Roma is drawn by people who do not understand the dynamic of Mexican life. Cuarón's family is not a wealthy one, they can afford domestic service because one of the tragedies of the Latin American country is precisely the wages of this cruel benefit. Moreover, most of the people engaged in this servitude comes precisely from the largely marginalized indigenous communities of Southern Mexico. Roma is a must-see. Not only to appreciate another facet of the neighbor to the south but to understand that injustice is present in every social stratum.… Expand

2 of 10 users found this helpful28

All this user's reviews

4

foxgroveDec 14, 2018

This Critics darling will find its nemesis with the general public. I mean, really , what is their to love. It's long, slow and largely uneventful. The baby scene and the swimming scene, which come towards the end of the film is as good asThis Critics darling will find its nemesis with the general public. I mean, really , what is their to love. It's long, slow and largely uneventful. The baby scene and the swimming scene, which come towards the end of the film is as good as the drama gets. The most over rated film of this year which underlines how pretentious a lot of film critics are. Come back Bohemian Rhapsody their was nothing to forgive!… Expand

10 of 20 users found this helpful1010

All this user's reviews

9

netflicDec 10, 2018

"Roma" is the latest movie by a famous Mexican director Alfonso Cuaron.

Cuaron is not only the director of this movie but also the writer and cinematographer. The movie is a recollection of Cuaron's childhood years so it is to some degree"Roma" is the latest movie by a famous Mexican director Alfonso Cuaron.

Cuaron is not only the director of this movie but also the writer and cinematographer.

The movie is a recollection of Cuaron's childhood years so it is to some degree autobiographical.

The main character of the movie is a live-in made Cleo who lives with a family of four kids, in a big house in Roma, an affluent neighborhood in Mexico City.

The movie is long and very artsy, made with lots of taste and style.

It is deliberately slow in the beginning showing a slice of life
of a family in a big city. The story develops and becomes more and more dramatic without phony pathos or flashy Hollywood tricks.

Overall, it is an incredibly good film, definitely Oscar material.
Shot in black-and-white.… Expand

3 of 12 users found this helpful39

All this user's reviews

10

LamontRaymondDec 9, 2018

At this point, it's either #1 or #2 on my movie-of-the-year list. There were a couple of moments in this film when the woman sitting next to me looked over because I unconsciously let out gasps. Incredibly emotional and beautifully shot.At this point, it's either #1 or #2 on my movie-of-the-year list. There were a couple of moments in this film when the woman sitting next to me looked over because I unconsciously let out gasps. Incredibly emotional and beautifully shot. Yalitza Aparicio as Cleo is incredibly good in the role. The hospital sequence and the beach sequence were two of the best scenes committed to film in recent years. I knew going in it had to be good when Joe Morgenstern called it the best movie he's ever seen (though I was a bit skeptical of that for a time - felt like hyperbole), and it absolutely lived up to the hype. This is a film that demands that you see it on the big screen with other people around you. It's a human film that requires your not seeing it along.… Expand

5 of 15 users found this helpful510

All this user's reviews

3

Brent_MarchantDec 7, 2018

OK, I'll say it -- when it comes to this film, the emperor is indeed naked. I'll admit that the film's stunning black-and-white cinematography is exquisite and that the scenes introducing the picture's final act are emotionally mesmerizingOK, I'll say it -- when it comes to this film, the emperor is indeed naked. I'll admit that the film's stunning black-and-white cinematography is exquisite and that the scenes introducing the picture's final act are emotionally mesmerizing (or maybe it's just that I was glad that something interesting was finally happening on the screen). Unfortunately, those are about the only redeeming qualities this release has to offer. The rest is a big, bloated, underdeveloped bore that tries the patience of even the most tolerant cinephile. It's obvious this was a heartfelt project for director Alfonso Cuaron, and his personal passion is written all over it. But, given that he's dealing with uninteresting characters in largely unexplained circumstances in a time frame for which little to no context or back story is provided, he's not giving the audience much to work with other than a glib implication that essentially says "This is authentic -- just trust me on this." Also, the picture's anemic attempts at incorporating philosophical and metaphysical themes show the filmmaker's got some brushing up to do in terms of effectively conveying his meaning in a comprehensible way. If you're willing to risk the time watching this, be sure to pack a pillow and a lunch.… Expand

14 of 28 users found this helpful1414

All this user's reviews

10

BeastJ18Dec 3, 2018

One of the best films of the 21st century and DEFINITELY the best film of 2018. This is a level of masterpiece that doesn't come around often. It is beautifully, emotionally and dauntingly shot, one of the most daring film scripts of recentOne of the best films of the 21st century and DEFINITELY the best film of 2018. This is a level of masterpiece that doesn't come around often. It is beautifully, emotionally and dauntingly shot, one of the most daring film scripts of recent times, completed by excellent performances. The direction of Cuarón balances subtle emotion and powerful sentiment in a rarely perfect manner, for any art form. It deserves to take home the majority of major Oscars this year, in; Best Picture, Best Director, Best Lead Actress, Best Original Screenplay, Best Cinematography and many more.… Expand

6 of 16 users found this helpful610

All this user's reviews

8

hoobokenkenDec 3, 2018

Very well done cinematically. Beautiful story but not terribly original. Entirely subtitled and therefore I assume it will be a Foreign Language contestant at the Oscars and not Best Picture.

3 of 10 users found this helpful37

All this user's reviews

8

CMCDec 1, 2018

The good: Lack of Hollywood superficiality and trite conventions. This is a film not a movie. There are many situations and moments inserted that are a bit strange and memorable.
The unfortunate: There is almost no character development, andThe good: Lack of Hollywood superficiality and trite conventions. This is a film not a movie. There are many situations and moments inserted that are a bit strange and memorable.
The unfortunate: There is almost no character development, and no certainly no arc to the story. As the film advances the story of the wife becomes important, but she oddly is left as a peripheral character. You come away without any insight into the main character, she is almost always an onlooker with little revealed.
The bad: For a film shot in black and white, it was flat- no deep blacks, and an overly warm grey palette. The cinematography was usually wide angle, which means no close-ups of faces and eyes, contributing to the visual lack of character development. It felt like the Director had a check-list of scenes drawn from mostly Italian and Italian Neo-Realism films. So while the film did not seem superficial, the effort was in the end more of a style exercise than emotional storytelling. I give it an 8 because movies today are so dreadful. This film is worth watching and discussing, but does not rise to be considered a truly great film.… Expand

3 of 10 users found this helpful37

All this user's reviews

10

ALEXJARAMILLONov 26, 2018

Beautiful, touching. Amazing cinematography.
A very smooth plot that makes the movie look like a short film how good is it.

6 of 18 users found this helpful612

All this user's reviews

10

ag6889Nov 21, 2018

Sublime, engrossing work. If you can't see it in theaters, lose yourself to a dark room, two hours on your laptop and a great pair of headphones.

8 of 21 users found this helpful813

All this user's reviews

9

sps179Nov 21, 2018

Intellectualise all you wish about the black and white, the nostalgia, the sentiment, the script, or whatever. I challenge you not to be moved by the human force of this movie. Ace production design, and Cuaron himself as cinematographerIntellectualise all you wish about the black and white, the nostalgia, the sentiment, the script, or whatever. I challenge you not to be moved by the human force of this movie. Ace production design, and Cuaron himself as cinematographer getting great shot after great shot, this is one of the movies of the century. Loved the opening sequence, which is simply the maid sluicing the ceramic tiles - with the totally Cuaron exception of a tiny airplane reflection in the gleaming water. He's put his best soul into this, and will never equal it.… Expand

5 of 17 users found this helpful512

All this user's reviews

10

pomattovichNov 21, 2018

The best film I've seen this year, last year, probably the year before that, and probably next year too. The kind of masterpiece most auteur filmmakers have seemingly forgot how to make these days. Incredibly powerful and dramatic. NostalgicThe best film I've seen this year, last year, probably the year before that, and probably next year too. The kind of masterpiece most auteur filmmakers have seemingly forgot how to make these days. Incredibly powerful and dramatic. Nostalgic without being overly sentimental. Just as stunning on a technical level as Gravity was, without being nearly as showy. Simply flawless.… Expand

27 of 45 users found this helpful2718

All this user's reviews

10

QLA92Nov 21, 2018

Roma is an astonishingly beautiful film filled to the brim with emotionally devastating and uplifting moments. Yalitza Aparicio and Marina de Tavira deliver Oscar-worthy performances, however the star of this spectacle is director, writer,Roma is an astonishingly beautiful film filled to the brim with emotionally devastating and uplifting moments. Yalitza Aparicio and Marina de Tavira deliver Oscar-worthy performances, however the star of this spectacle is director, writer, editor and cinematographer Alfonso Cuaron.… Expand

8 of 21 users found this helpful813

All this user's reviews

9

michimichNov 21, 2018

Wow. I understand that this film won't appeal to every single viewer's sensibilities, but I am just incredibly surprised/entertained at some of the commenters who seek to dilute this film to nothing more than a fluff piece about theWow. I understand that this film won't appeal to every single viewer's sensibilities, but I am just incredibly surprised/entertained at some of the commenters who seek to dilute this film to nothing more than a fluff piece about the importance of maids. If one were to do a simple google search (I know, imagine having the gall to do something so simple!), they would know that Roma is a district in D.F. and not some highbrow reference or attempt at being avant-garde. Based on the first user review here, it's almost like asking "how DARE a filmmaker give insight into a piece of history/their own past and how it factored into the greater societal conflicts of the time????" I suppose we should only tell stories of westernized families who mostly resemble our own, correct? Or even better, how about we simply disregard every history book and biographical novel who explains a worldview/experience different from our own! The fact that some reviewers have the audacity to call Cleo a "weak" character reveals a failure to understand the ever fluctuating nature of a family's dynamics. There is no inherent hierarchy in Roma's family, as the familial roles ebb and flow based on the unexpected internal and external situations the family find themselves in. Losing one family member often translates to the rest of the family taking on new or unfamiliar roles and responsibilities. The long-term identity of a family (and ultimately, the values and identities of its children) is based on the members who become solidified in that family over several years. It's not about who the family started out with, it's about the members who stayed and formed the foundation. I wasn't aware that a film seeking to express and reflect on the development of a child's memory (Cuaron's own) would be considered "high-brow."… Expand

5 of 18 users found this helpful513

All this user's reviews

0

AvidDivaNov 21, 2018

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. I am shocked at the reviews of this thing called Roma. First off, I have no idea what ROMA actually is. Is ROMA a person? A place? A terrible film? All of the above? This moving photograph will mean nothing to anyone other than a critic looking for a high brow concept with a low brow delivery. All I came away from the screening of this thing was #MaidsLivesMatter and... so what. The flimsy story is constructed around beautiful images, that more rightful belong in a photo album and not on a movie screen. I was appalled at the lack of reality in the substance of the characters. Also, I do not believe that the ending is in any way plausible. The character who was the weakest suddenly becomes superhuman and stronger than a riptide. I call bollocks. Any one who isn't trying to blow something up someones somewhere, will not like this movie, and that is most everyone.… Expand

24 of 82 users found this helpful2458

All this user's reviews