Read User Reviews and Submit your own for Rogue One: A Star Wars Story

10

ColourSurroundJan 4, 2017

I came in with meager expectations and was genuinely blown away with how the film handled the story, paced the action, and played out as a whole. The acting was superb, the effects made you feel like you were watching a Star Wars film - andI came in with meager expectations and was genuinely blown away with how the film handled the story, paced the action, and played out as a whole. The acting was superb, the effects made you feel like you were watching a Star Wars film - and not some CGI mind-maze - and the story was genuinely well written. I loved all of the classic Star Wars easter eggs that were thrown in, and that the main character gave a nod to Jan Ors from the Dark Forces games of the 90s. It was original, but above all very entertaining. The critic metascore does not reflect its quality. It definitely plays out more like a war drama in a sci-fi setting than anything else, but I think it is all the better for it. Although quite different from any of its predecessors, it is a wonderful film that I feel surpasses The 'Force Awakens' in almost every facet, and can rightly take its spot with Episodes IV-VI in the Star Wars canon.… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

10

abydosMar 25, 2017

Excellent Star Wars movie. Light years better than Force Awakens. This movie is a give new story of the Star Wars universe, a very good and very exciting story.

3 of 6 users found this helpful33

All this user's reviews

10

CommonsenseDec 19, 2016

Critics are pretty wrong on this one. Characters could have been developed a little more, but the tension, cinematography and, overall story didn't disappoint. No one in my theater seemed unhappy and many even clapped an cheered and this wasCritics are pretty wrong on this one. Characters could have been developed a little more, but the tension, cinematography and, overall story didn't disappoint. No one in my theater seemed unhappy and many even clapped an cheered and this was 2 days after the premier on a 6:30 showing.… Expand

4 of 12 users found this helpful48

All this user's reviews

10

BoabDreepsDec 16, 2016

I was 12 when the last decent Star Wars movie came out.
I've been burned ever since: Special Editions, Prequels, Force Awakens (sorry, it sucks).
So the bar was pretty low going in to the midnight screening. 10 minutes in and I rememberI was 12 when the last decent Star Wars movie came out.
I've been burned ever since: Special Editions, Prequels, Force Awakens (sorry, it sucks).
So the bar was pretty low going in to the midnight screening.
10 minutes in and I remember turning to my friend (another 70's child) and saying "I don't know about you, but I'm f**kin lovin this already".
By the end I couldn't get out of the seat. I was an emotional wreck. I had another emotional breakdown in the car on the way home.

To everyone involved in making this film:
Thank you for making Star Was awesome again

I'm going again tonight, just to make sure I didn't dream this.… Expand

51 of 84 users found this helpful5133

All this user's reviews

10

CombinerMar 27, 2017

Great movie with all that traditional Star Wars moments , epic space battles tragic moments ! This movie has something that The Force Awaken had not ... Maybe it's much more soul in it .

2 of 4 users found this helpful22

All this user's reviews

10

BoombastixDec 18, 2016

Rogue One was spectacular and everything I wanted it to be. I consider this movie an apology for the abysmal Force Awakens and for this I can only say one thing: Apology accepted!

6 of 13 users found this helpful67

All this user's reviews

10

TryASummersaultDec 16, 2016

10/10 I AM ONE WITH THE FORCE, AND THE FORCE IS WITH ME! I'm absolutely stunned and thrilled right now because I just witnessed the most authentic and truest representation of a Star Wars film since the original classic trilogy. This was10/10 I AM ONE WITH THE FORCE, AND THE FORCE IS WITH ME! I'm absolutely stunned and thrilled right now because I just witnessed the most authentic and truest representation of a Star Wars film since the original classic trilogy. This was nothing short of phenomenal and executed every single aspect of the galaxy/franchise in flawless fashion. From the gargantuan scale of the vastly magnificently planet scapes and ships to the wild variation of the characters, this might be the greatest film in the franchise yet. The action scenes are plenty and are amazingly set up on the ground and in the air. The cgi is the best I've seen in any film ever and the grand scale is masterful. The story was easily the most adventurous and well told than any in the franchise. The score was brilliant and captured the Star Wars feel beautifully. Gareth Edwards will now be known as one of the best new directors around after crafting this masterpiece. I was going to wait to see but couldn't hold my excitement and I would recommend everyone see this in the theatre for all It's glory.… Expand

39 of 68 users found this helpful3929

All this user's reviews

10

kendrickdkDec 16, 2016

Love this movie so much. Great story, great acting, great pacing, great plot. The ending was epic. Going to see it again tomorrow. The movie starts of slow but builds to a hectic tempo by the end.

22 of 38 users found this helpful2216

All this user's reviews

10

Tss5078Jan 10, 2017

The purpose of Rogue one was simple, to fix a plot hole that had bothered Star Wars fans for nearly forty years. How did the rebels get a hold of the plans for the death star and why was it so easy to destroy? At a young age, Jyn Erso'sThe purpose of Rogue one was simple, to fix a plot hole that had bothered Star Wars fans for nearly forty years. How did the rebels get a hold of the plans for the death star and why was it so easy to destroy? At a young age, Jyn Erso's (Felicity Jones), father Galen (Mads Mikkelsen) was taken by the empire, to help develop the death star. Jyn was protected by the rebels before fleeing and living on her own, until one day, the rebels receive a message from Galen, saying that his daughter is the key to everything, and if they help get her to him, he can stop the empire. What I love about Rogue one, is the fact that for this film the franchise took a step back. If you ask anybody what their favorite Star Wars movie is, inevitably you will hear A New Hope or The Empire Strikes Back, but why? It's because these films didn't have massive budgets, big name movie stars, the top directors in Hollywood, complex story lines, special characters thrown in for the kids, simply put they were the greatest space adventures of all-time. Rogue one leaves in the special effects, but the actors are not very well known, the director has only two films under his belt, the story is easy to follow, the characters are extremely likeable, (much more so than the new ones in the Force Awakens), and most import of all the story is more narrowly focused and much easier to follow. There aren't a million different things going on here, there is one objective and it is being attempted by characters you can actually get behind. Jyn Erso, very much has the Katniss Everdeen tough girl thing going for her and she is paired with Cassian (Diego Luna), who has all the charisma of a young Harrison Ford, together the pair is infectious and you can't help but like them. I didn't feel any of that with Rey and Finn, in fact, I barely remembered their names. I'd also be remiss if I didn't mention the scenery and special effects in the film, unlike in recent films, we see a multitude of planets, it isn't just all sand and sun. The planet in the final scene with the beaches and the energy shield in particular was just amazing. Finally there is the ending, I won't give anything away if you haven't seen it yet, but I will say this. While controversial, in my opinion, more perfect it could not have been. Rogue One is the best Star Wars film since the original trilogy and I hope J.J. Abrams took notice. This is what the future of the franchise should be. Just because you have the largest film budget in history, doesn't mean your film has to have dozens of plots, and all these random characters we don't care about. Use that money on special effects, more amazing ships, weapons, and planets, and just make Star Wars fun again in a way that Rogue One reminded us it could be.… Expand

3 of 7 users found this helpful34

All this user's reviews

10

imthenoobDec 21, 2016

While Force Awakens played heavily on the nostalgia factor, Rogue One takes all the risks and it works out wonderful. No opening scroll so we jump right into the action. It ties up a lot of plot holes from the previous films (such as why theWhile Force Awakens played heavily on the nostalgia factor, Rogue One takes all the risks and it works out wonderful. No opening scroll so we jump right into the action. It ties up a lot of plot holes from the previous films (such as why the Death Star had it's fatal flaw), The action scenes are beautiful and the ending couldn't have been any better. They took a lot of risks with the CG (anyone who saw the film knows what I am talking about) but it paid off perfectly.

My only complaint is that they didn't use the new villain as well as they could have. Aside from that, Go and see it immediately. It blows FA out of the water imo and I loved FA.… Expand

4 of 10 users found this helpful46

All this user's reviews

10

ejbeebyApr 4, 2021

I love Empire Strikes Back. Empire Strikes back rightly deserves all of the acclaim it gets. But this is my favorite Star Wars movie. The final act captures the desperation of their mission and makes watching A New Hope better.

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

10

AthanasiosTMar 26, 2017

Finally a SW movie with a story that made sense and is made to be watched by adults and not 10 yrs old children (as the previous one). A good point also was that not everyone was wielding a lightsaber and not everyone was using the force. IFinally a SW movie with a story that made sense and is made to be watched by adults and not 10 yrs old children (as the previous one). A good point also was that not everyone was wielding a lightsaber and not everyone was using the force. I liked the darkest atmosphere, which extremely added to the realism. My faith on SW is re-established...Please consider the KOTOR and Sith era for a new trilogy !!!… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

10

deekanDec 17, 2016

Great.great.great! Everything I wanted, yet so much more. Some of the best war scenes in any fantasy film, let alone star wars! Edwards is one to look out for.

8 of 18 users found this helpful810

All this user's reviews

10

RixusDec 31, 2016

This is the Star Wars you've been waiting for. This is the Star Wars we deserve. The best Star Wars movie since the original trilogy. Its got everything you could ever want, from storm troopers and gritty combat, to space battles and aThis is the Star Wars you've been waiting for. This is the Star Wars we deserve. The best Star Wars movie since the original trilogy. Its got everything you could ever want, from storm troopers and gritty combat, to space battles and a more traditional take on faith in The Force. I want to go into detail, but I dont want to ruin the experience for anyone. Just know its a great Star Wars film, and perfectly ties into the original trilogy.

Hollywood: this is it, this is what we want. All future movies need to take their cue from Rogue One. I dont know why the critics rated this lower than Force Awakens, clearly the fans are rating this higher, and I'm right there with them.

Great, great movie. Go watch it!… Expand

3 of 7 users found this helpful34

All this user's reviews

10

DreadLordAvatarJan 10, 2017

absolutely the best star wars film since empire strikes back. it totally captures the Ep4 feeling, Director Gareth Edwards is a genius. glad the music isnt a rehash of john williams score, this feels refreshing and a true delight. saw itabsolutely the best star wars film since empire strikes back. it totally captures the Ep4 feeling, Director Gareth Edwards is a genius. glad the music isnt a rehash of john williams score, this feels refreshing and a true delight. saw it in 3d at the theatre. hope the bluray release includes the 3d version this time unlike the milking morons that did force awakens double dip release. i truly hope JJ Abrams studies rogue one and capitalizes on it's magic and applies it to Ep8 to make a true star wars film.… Expand

4 of 10 users found this helpful46

All this user's reviews

10

mAs7eRaJun 1, 2017

It's amazing. I just found out about this movie. And after such a BIG letdown (Star Wars Episode 7) I did not have any expectations about this. I thought that it's hard to be worse than Episode 7. But in reality, it was amazing! It had theIt's amazing. I just found out about this movie. And after such a BIG letdown (Star Wars Episode 7) I did not have any expectations about this. I thought that it's hard to be worse than Episode 7. But in reality, it was amazing! It had the REAL atmosphere of a star wars series without the cheesy disney part. Yes, since it is followed by a episode, the ending can be expected, but it really feels fresh and right. I don't like all of the actors, but the acting itself was great! There was emotion, there was spirit, and the atmosphere was kept with the true star-wars atmosphere. It might not be on the level of the old trilogy, but it certainly deserves a place somewhere in between the old and new episodes! One is over-hyped, over-marketed, so much $$$$$ spend on mass advertisement. This one, I didn't even hear about it, at the same time I'm sure I'll remember it for a very long time (unlike the episode 7). And reviewers such as "San Francisco Chronicle - Mick LaSalle" rating 100 for episode 7 and 25 for this... Just would never consider a review by you.. so far from what I think...… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

10

mrmonsterDec 20, 2016

This is my second favorite movie of the entire year so far, behind only Captain America: Civil War. This movie was action packed, had great performances, and tied in perfectly to the Star Wars universe. It's everything we've been hoping for and more.

1 of 7 users found this helpful16

All this user's reviews

10

G3RDec 16, 2016

This movie is simply amazing. Walking out of the theater I wasn't thinking about how great it was but rather, "I have to watch this again NOW". If you were not around when episode 4 hit the screens then it would be hard to imagine how itThis movie is simply amazing. Walking out of the theater I wasn't thinking about how great it was but rather, "I have to watch this again NOW". If you were not around when episode 4 hit the screens then it would be hard to imagine how it changed our culture. People didn't ask you if you have seen Star Wars. They asked you how many times you have seen Star Wars. A feat that movie makers have not been able to accomplish since. This move IS episode 3, despite it's billing. Was it perfect? No. Good luck finding that on a screen today. If you are a fan of Scifi you will not be disappointed. If you are old you will feel again what you felt upon watching the original.… Expand

12 of 28 users found this helpful1216

All this user's reviews

10

oraborsaDec 16, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Cuesta escribir una critica objetiva siendo fan de la saga SW, pero cumple con todas las expectativas y las supera. La película, llena de guiños a episodio IV transforma a la doctrina jedi y "la fuerza" en portadora de fe.… Expand

6 of 18 users found this helpful612

All this user's reviews

10

NostalgicDec 23, 2016

First of all all the haters out there need to stfu. How pathetic and unintelligent does a human have to be to rate this epic movie low? We are talking about the most loved franchise of all time and what these filmmakers have managed to doFirst of all all the haters out there need to stfu. How pathetic and unintelligent does a human have to be to rate this epic movie low? We are talking about the most loved franchise of all time and what these filmmakers have managed to do is nothing short of extraordinary. Go see this movie in 3d now !!! All I have to say is bacta tank !… Expand

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

10

dannytran555Dec 17, 2016

**** the critic that all i can say. This film is pure gold with great visual and story telling. star wars rogue one is perfect link between ep 3 and 4 also there so many good character in flim with marvel sense of humor . If u wonder should**** the critic that all i can say. This film is pure gold with great visual and story telling. star wars rogue one is perfect link between ep 3 and 4 also there so many good character in flim with marvel sense of humor . If u wonder should you watch this then the answer is yes… Expand

23 of 41 users found this helpful2318

All this user's reviews

10

PlutarcoMar 28, 2017

This is a wonderful movie. I just want to thank the people who created this beautiful masterpiece. Thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, Rogue One!!!

2 of 4 users found this helpful22

All this user's reviews

10

DrChocolateDec 22, 2016

Phenomenal. The Star Wars film I've been waiting for since 1983. Dark and foreboding, excellent characterization,and the hour-long battle in the second half of the film is the best in the franchise yet. A worthy achievement and highlyPhenomenal. The Star Wars film I've been waiting for since 1983. Dark and foreboding, excellent characterization,and the hour-long battle in the second half of the film is the best in the franchise yet. A worthy achievement and highly recommended for all old Star Wars fans like me.… Expand

7 of 15 users found this helpful78

All this user's reviews

10

StyggeJul 22, 2023

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. This is how you perform as an whole doing a film. Mads , Orson & Fores what an performance from them and the whole crew. Writing for the lead up to one of the biggest movies must have been harrowing but it was made to perfection.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

10

JackalJan 18, 2017

I am 51, I have seen each film as they came out from 1977...I played as the characters (I didnt have a cellphone)...this story was a great missing piece to the puzzle even more so for a glimpse of the great Darth Vader. Excellent film. I cantI am 51, I have seen each film as they came out from 1977...I played as the characters (I didnt have a cellphone)...this story was a great missing piece to the puzzle even more so for a glimpse of the great Darth Vader. Excellent film. I cant believe it would have any rating below 10.… Expand

4 of 8 users found this helpful44

All this user's reviews

10

VendonJun 22, 2017

Anyone rating this movie below a 7 is a troll. The user reviews on this website make it cancerous, they should remove user reviews because most people come here to give BS ratings. The movie was great, down with the trolls.

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

10

stevegroundhogDec 18, 2016

This movie is for true Star Wars fans. It is the best movie since Empire. Perfectly ties in between Episode 3 and Episode 4. They even brought back Peter Cushing from the grave (albeit freaky and cool at the same time). There is no loveThis movie is for true Star Wars fans. It is the best movie since Empire. Perfectly ties in between Episode 3 and Episode 4. They even brought back Peter Cushing from the grave (albeit freaky and cool at the same time). There is no love story, no stupid characters like Jar Jar, no annoying little kid who loves Pod Racing, no anorexic chick named Rey who can wield the Force within three minutes, no whiny Kylo Ren with daddy issues, it is a perfect Star Wars movie. It is purely Empire vs Alliance in a Dirty Dozen type atmosphere. Go see it!… Expand

3 of 12 users found this helpful39

All this user's reviews

10

krikaoliJan 10, 2017

Wow! This Metacritic is full of very critical people! The rating is too low for the fantastic movie this is! It is just the best Star Wars movie I have ever seen, better than The Empire Strikes Back. I was so surprised that they could make aWow! This Metacritic is full of very critical people! The rating is too low for the fantastic movie this is! It is just the best Star Wars movie I have ever seen, better than The Empire Strikes Back. I was so surprised that they could make a movie much better than Star Wars VIII. Very impressive plot, actors, etc.… Expand

4 of 8 users found this helpful44

All this user's reviews

10

Twist_Of_FateDec 24, 2016

They left the best movie of the year for last wow!.Incredible cast and relateable characters and atmosphere was definitely a step up and proves what Disney can do,haven't seen it? go see it NOW!,seen it? go see it again to relive what anThey left the best movie of the year for last wow!.Incredible cast and relateable characters and atmosphere was definitely a step up and proves what Disney can do,haven't seen it? go see it NOW!,seen it? go see it again to relive what an impressive,outstanding movie this is.Legendary… Expand

2 of 6 users found this helpful24

All this user's reviews

10

RookeyFeb 3, 2020

So much better than the new trilogy. Definetly worth watching, especially as a fan.

1 of 1 users found this helpful10

All this user's reviews

10

Molag-BalDec 21, 2016

Dont expect anything like the originals, but this was a damn good movie for what it is. The second part of the movie is beyond amazing and the main character she is a fun one. Her companion is boring though.

2 of 7 users found this helpful25

All this user's reviews

10

OlrikusDec 17, 2016

-- Spoiler Free --
Rogue One is the best Star Wars film since original trilogy. Period.
Significant to say it adds weight to original trilogy and that is a worthy achievement itself. Lore of original trilogy was left intact and overall it is-- Spoiler Free --
Rogue One is the best Star Wars film since original trilogy. Period.
Significant to say it adds weight to original trilogy and that is a worthy achievement itself. Lore of original trilogy was left intact and overall it is a must see film.

Also it is a completely unusual film for Star Wars franchise and some people will dislike this film for that since it has no light saber duels and it's more focused on the heart of rebellion and it's people.… Expand

8 of 18 users found this helpful810

All this user's reviews

10

AvalordJan 2, 2017

First I have to state: I disliked, even despised "A Force Awakens", a movie without a single original thought, badly executed. Rogue One is no less than the best Star Wars Movie ever made. The characters are great, the pacing is just right.First I have to state: I disliked, even despised "A Force Awakens", a movie without a single original thought, badly executed. Rogue One is no less than the best Star Wars Movie ever made. The characters are great, the pacing is just right. With Protagonists that matter to you, you want to spend some time with, before you descend into the slaughterhouse together.
All those who criticise the slow start of the film I have to tell: Just wait for the next Star Wars Movie (VIII). You'll get your soul/mindless J.J.Abrams opus soon enough!… Expand

3 of 6 users found this helpful33

All this user's reviews

10

Can7onaLegendDec 16, 2016

The Greatest movie since sliced bread and various other bread based thing's. like egg's and car's. wanna find out how the death star blew up? this is the movie for moviegoers!

23 of 44 users found this helpful2321

All this user's reviews

10

ChopperGunnerNLDec 17, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Star Wars Rogue One was personally one of my favorite Star Wars movies. The movie takes a while to get the viewer's attention, but after that the movie became very interessting. CGI was well done, casting and acting was good and storyline was well written and unpredictable. (SPOILER ALERT): This is also one of the few action movies and the only Star Wars movie were they main characters die.… Expand

18 of 32 users found this helpful1814

All this user's reviews

10

SkeptecDec 17, 2016

My favorite star wars movie to date. I absolutely loved the new characters. The monk character being my favorite by far. I honestly couldn't think of any negatives really.

8 of 17 users found this helpful89

All this user's reviews

10

theRobotDec 17, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. "In the grim darkness of the galaxy far, far away, there is only war."

This movie is so much different than anything you have ever seen from Star Wars. It's like guys at Disney got inspired by Game of Thrones attitude to plot armor and decided to do something similar in their movie. And the fact that their movie is 7+ didn't stop them at all.

Seriously, this movie plays with your mind by making you think it will be yet another rehash from previous parts. Once again we get an orphan, who gets adopted, who apparently is rich in force and whose relatives are kidnapped by the empire. At the begginning we get loads of miracles, stormtroopers are as inaccurate as always and we are made into thinking it will be like that for the whole movie. Except it's not - at some point the plot armor for characters starts to get worn out and falls from them, leaving them fragile and unprotected. First insignificant characters start to die. Then gradually more significant ones. Eventually we aren't even sure about the fate of main protagonists, but we are still getting hints that they might survive. And then it turns out they don't. That's when the whole tragicness of this situation hits us. They are not superheroes, not another reincarnation of Han Solo and Luke Skywalker, that will get miraciously rescued from almost every situation. They are just desperate guys with nothing to lose, doing their suicide mission. Flashbacks of them saying various stuff, that might spoil the final ending hits you like a goddamn train and you get really, really depressed. If you took away the details from this movie, you would think it's the description of some Warhammer 40k novel, because how grimdark it is. But like WH40k, it's much more than that. It's a beautiful tale about hope, fighting against all odds, sacrifice and heroism. For me it's probably the best Star Wars movie since Empire Strikes Back and who knows if not the best Star Wars movie ever.… Expand

7 of 15 users found this helpful78

All this user's reviews

10

jc18241Dec 16, 2016

It was the best in the franchise right behind Empire Strikes Back. The cast was amazing. The story was amazing. The cameos were awesome. This movie is so damn good on so many levels. The only complaints I have are the slow opening and theIt was the best in the franchise right behind Empire Strikes Back. The cast was amazing. The story was amazing. The cameos were awesome. This movie is so damn good on so many levels. The only complaints I have are the slow opening and the movies score. Music could have been better. Nothing more to complain about after that.… Expand

10 of 27 users found this helpful1017

All this user's reviews

10

kivayugimotoDec 17, 2016

Good movie; thoroughly enjoyed it! It is worth seeing it in a movie theater. Favorite character is the robot; it's dialogue responses just added to make it a fun action movie.

5 of 13 users found this helpful58

All this user's reviews

10

MattzoneDec 18, 2016

Just got home from the movie. Extremely good movie, BUT be aware that this is more like a war movie with the Star Wars brand. I took my 6 year old and he was very bored (he was fine during "Force Awakens"). Noting those facts, this isJust got home from the movie. Extremely good movie, BUT be aware that this is more like a war movie with the Star Wars brand. I took my 6 year old and he was very bored (he was fine during "Force Awakens"). Noting those facts, this is perhaps one of the better movies from the Star Wars brand... great acting, sets, effects and tie in to the franchise. Perhaps think of it as Star Wars Episode 3.5! Good Work!… Expand

7 of 15 users found this helpful78

All this user's reviews

10

RandomLetters27Dec 21, 2016

What a fantastic Star Wars film. Star Wars for adults who grew up wanting to do battle in a galaxy far, far away. The characters here are some of the most interesting you'll find in Star Wars, and the villains are darkly glorious. Fathers,What a fantastic Star Wars film. Star Wars for adults who grew up wanting to do battle in a galaxy far, far away. The characters here are some of the most interesting you'll find in Star Wars, and the villains are darkly glorious. Fathers, hug your daughters; we're in for a ride.… Expand

3 of 11 users found this helpful38

All this user's reviews

10

DPtdrysteDec 17, 2016

Really just reviewing this a 10 to balance the critic reviews. As a casual Star Wars fan I want to say 3 quick things about this movie:

1. It is a very "efficiently" produced film. No scene seems unnecessary. 2. It is accessible for non-StarReally just reviewing this a 10 to balance the critic reviews. As a casual Star Wars fan I want to say 3 quick things about this movie:

1. It is a very "efficiently" produced film. No scene seems unnecessary.
2. It is accessible for non-Star Wars die-hards like me, and today I'm actually gonna watch 4, 5, and 6 because it has piqued my interest in the series.
3. Based on talking about this with friends, it feels like what "Reach" was to the Halo series. As Vox has put it, while a Disney movie, this is a movie about war.

I really liked this movie. It was better than the last movie I saw in theatres, Arrival, and I really liked that movie too. This movie isn't as deep and provocative, but it's better.

If you are an experienced consumer of culture stuffs like games, music, movies, and TV shows I would say that a good lens to try to see this movie from is you as a kid, watching a serious war movie. As I get older I tend to compare everything to the best entries in the entire gamut of the culture genre, but if we are just going to compare every game to The Last of Us and every show to Breaking Bad and Game of Thrones, everything is going to suck comparatively.

Rogue One is definitely worth your $15 to watch in 3D. Go with someone younger than you, I went with my niece, and she really liked it.… Expand

8 of 17 users found this helpful89

All this user's reviews

10

joyalexandreDec 28, 2016

This is a good Star Wars. A refreshing look at the franchise. It patch a lot of the faults in the old trilogy. I like the more mature look at the characters as well.

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

10

BitmouseDec 19, 2016

I really enjoyed the movie.

However, the movie doesn't contribute to the canon in any meaningful way.

150 characters long dong sing-a-long song. Yeap

2 of 9 users found this helpful27

All this user's reviews

10

DeathSladeDec 16, 2016

In my opinion this is one of the best star wars movies ever. It's gritty, grounded, has a lot of action and callbacks to the original trilogy, and overall great. Most of the characters also have great development and i am actually sympatheticIn my opinion this is one of the best star wars movies ever. It's gritty, grounded, has a lot of action and callbacks to the original trilogy, and overall great. Most of the characters also have great development and i am actually sympathetic for the villain. Vader in this movie is so satisfying and all the scenes that he's in is amazing, it really shows what Vader really is. The only negative that i have with this movie is probably the characters with the CGI face which doesn't work as seamlessly as it could be.… Expand

18 of 32 users found this helpful1814

All this user's reviews

10

GeelongDec 20, 2016

The force is strong with Rogue One. After a clunky but enjoyable first act, the movie finds its true setting and continues to grow on itself. The film is written fantastically with no cheesy or cringe worthy moments which allows the moreThe force is strong with Rogue One. After a clunky but enjoyable first act, the movie finds its true setting and continues to grow on itself. The film is written fantastically with no cheesy or cringe worthy moments which allows the more mature audiences to enjoy the pacing and tone of the film. Gareth Edwards took a risk with this film by adding certain elements into it and it pays off beautifully and sets up the NOW perfect film "A NEW HOPE".… Expand

0 of 5 users found this helpful05

All this user's reviews

10

SNovackDec 27, 2021

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Rogue One: A Star Wars Story, is easily the best of the Disney Star Wars films released so far. The writers were able to take two sentences from the opening crawl of a film made in 1977 and create a masterpiece that fits seamlessly into the established story, and even add and enhance it.
Immediately after seeing the midnight showing of the film on opening night I had to go home and watch Episode IV, and I was shocked at how well the writers had done. How many times do you see Vader actually angry, rather than coldly mocking? Not many. However, right after the introduction of the character we see him holding Captain Antilles of the Blockade Runner by the throat and choking him to death, then screaming at his men to find the plans. That scene makes sense after the hallway scene in Rogue One that ends with him watching the ship with the stolen plans flying away.
Little details like that make a film worth watching, and Rogue One is full of them.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

10

TrevorDevendorfDec 23, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Being a Star Wars fan-girl is a plus! You will enjoy this movie til the end! Some of the characters in Rogue One die off in very random paced areas in the film, but i still thoroughly loved the film! Gareth Edwards really did it for me... I was skeptical about him, because of Monsters. Now that i've seen this movie twice, and it still amazes me! Loved Donnie Yen's character Chirrut, his take on the Force has really refreshing... the chant/mantra he says will stick with me forever! "I am with the Force, and the Force with me." Fantsatic Classic to put in Best of films books of 2016!… Expand

1 of 5 users found this helpful14

All this user's reviews

10

anichelsJan 24, 2017

I did not expect much coming into the theater, being disappointed with the logic of the story line of TFA. This movie is brilliantly written, and nicely plugs the only plot holes in the original series. There is obvious CGI that I immediatelyI did not expect much coming into the theater, being disappointed with the logic of the story line of TFA. This movie is brilliantly written, and nicely plugs the only plot holes in the original series. There is obvious CGI that I immediately noticed, but I'm still giving it a 10.… Expand

4 of 8 users found this helpful44

All this user's reviews

10

easterfieldsDec 19, 2016

I loved this film! I am a huge Star Wars fan and was not as satisfied as most with The Force Awakens (I won't even discuss the prequels). To me it was just missing something that this film has in abundance, heart! The characters really sellI loved this film! I am a huge Star Wars fan and was not as satisfied as most with The Force Awakens (I won't even discuss the prequels). To me it was just missing something that this film has in abundance, heart! The characters really sell this story and they are perhaps one of the most interesting motley crews in Star Wars history. It was so fascinating to see how everything fit together just prior to A New Hope and this film actually answers several questions fans have had for nearly 40 years. It really does fit in nicely with the Star Wars mythos and it's exciting to watch! Some have criticized it for being too dark. Well keep in mind that this time period was the peak of the Empire's dominance. The Rebel Alliance had to make a huge stand to start any kind of challenge against it's tyrannical grip over the universe. Thus war was inevitable. This movie does an amazing job of conveying the dark period in which everything was set and it does an even better job of showing how even the smallest sacrifices during such a period can cause huge effects. People die. That is part of war. What really shocked me about Rogue One is that there really is no Force, no Skywalkers, no Jedi, and yet it feels more true to the original films than the last 4 have. It breaks every rule of a Star Wars film and yet managed to do everything right in the process. There are so many pleasant surprises in watching this that every fan should be smiling ear to ear by the time it's over. Yes there are sad moments, but this isn't supposed to be the feel-good movie of the holidays. It's supposed to fill in a spot that existed prior to the very first time Star Wars was introduced to us. Not only is it successful in this regard, but it introduces characters that will long go down in the history books of how the Empire crumbled. Don't miss it!… Expand

6 of 12 users found this helpful66

All this user's reviews

10

unclebillyDec 17, 2016

As a star wars fan, not a single movie in recent history has made me as excited and amazed as rouge one has. This movie has some over extended moments that get a bit pale, and some acts may be slightly weak; but the rest makes up for it 100%.As a star wars fan, not a single movie in recent history has made me as excited and amazed as rouge one has. This movie has some over extended moments that get a bit pale, and some acts may be slightly weak; but the rest makes up for it 100%. The action, cinematography, feel of wonder is all there and better than ever. I don't think Darth Vader has ever been more Vader and I don't we have ever seen a ground battle to this scale. This isn't your regular star wars movie but definitely not in a bad way.… Expand

5 of 19 users found this helpful514

All this user's reviews

10

NaxDec 17, 2016

I was 7 when I watched my first Star Wars movie "A New Hope" it was the year 1987. I guess I can say that I prefer old movies above all else, maybe because of that I hated every frame of it. Before I was going to ROGIU ONE I honestly had noI was 7 when I watched my first Star Wars movie "A New Hope" it was the year 1987. I guess I can say that I prefer old movies above all else, maybe because of that I hated every frame of it. Before I was going to ROGIU ONE I honestly had no expectations, NO HOPE at all.

My GOD. I was gonna cry in the end. That was the movie I was waiting for since "Empire Strikes Back". Visually the movie is a masterpiece, way and way better then "Episode VII". Battles are breath taking, I dont wanna spoil it that is why I cant go into detail. THIS MOVIE DESCRIBES THE "WAR" in STAR WARS. A real war, where everyone SUFFERS, where darkness looms, innocent & evil die, this story shows what we have never seen before.

And such an ending, thanks to Gareth Edwards, really I can die in peace now, this movie is the one and one only that almost made me cry, smile, laugh, made me sit on the edge of my seat on the second part.

I GUARANTEE YOU, if you love EPISODE 4-5-6 the most, THIS IS THE MOVIE YOU HAVE BEEN WAITING FOR.… Expand

26 of 42 users found this helpful2616

All this user's reviews

10

fgallindoDec 16, 2016

The TOP3 : 1 - ROGUE ONE; 2 - STAR WARS (Yes, it is! the one and only Star Wars); 3 - THE EMPIRE STRIKES BACK. And the rest? WIPE THEM OUT, ALL OF THEM!

13 of 29 users found this helpful1316

All this user's reviews

10

ProsmoothDec 16, 2016

This is a guy's Star Wars movie that stars a chick in the lead. Trust me--if you owned all the toys when you were 11 years old, you are going to go bonkers over this thing. It's The Dirty Dozen in space with Darth Vader and AT ATs. During theThis is a guy's Star Wars movie that stars a chick in the lead. Trust me--if you owned all the toys when you were 11 years old, you are going to go bonkers over this thing. It's The Dirty Dozen in space with Darth Vader and AT ATs. During the last third of this thing I felt like I could take on the whole Empire myself. It's a flawed masterpiece. Weakest part is the music and some pacing problems in the first act--but it's not weak enough to affect my score.… Expand

85 of 153 users found this helpful8568

All this user's reviews

10

TJAWApr 22, 2017

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. In the same way that The Force Awakens grew on me, Rogue One has really grown on me too, which is why I'm upgrading my score for this film from 4/10 to 7/10. No, it's not as good as The Force Awakens - its characters are kind of flat and it's nowhere near as fun. But after giving it a second viewing, Rogue One is honestly pretty good to me now. It's far from perfect, but it's a decent enough Star Wars experience with very strong visuals, great action scenes and a dark tone. What it lacks, unfortunately, is the colourful spark and charm that TFA provided. Too many scenes from Rogue One feel like a soap opera and it can come across as miserable and boring at times. So, for anyone who disliked it the first time, give it one or two more viewings and it may grow on you.… Expand

5 of 9 users found this helpful54

All this user's reviews

10

theexarDec 17, 2016

After the disappointment from the Force Awakens I went to the cinema with very low expectations for Rogue One. However, the movie far surpassed them. I expected cheesy moments, hollow motivational speeches, badly adapted setting. It was noneAfter the disappointment from the Force Awakens I went to the cinema with very low expectations for Rogue One. However, the movie far surpassed them. I expected cheesy moments, hollow motivational speeches, badly adapted setting. It was none of these. Apart from an unconvincing martial arts character, everything in Rogue One was Star Wars from the beginning to the end. Great humor, memorable cameos and references, intensive action scenes and all of this - without overdoing it. Awesome work!… Expand

6 of 16 users found this helpful610

All this user's reviews

10

Paulo-LameirasDec 22, 2016

From the visual direction taken from the original trilogy, to the dirty environments, darker tone, interesting and varied cast of characters, and phenomenal ending, this just turned out to be my favoutite Star Wars movie since The Return ofFrom the visual direction taken from the original trilogy, to the dirty environments, darker tone, interesting and varied cast of characters, and phenomenal ending, this just turned out to be my favoutite Star Wars movie since The Return of the Jedi! While far from bad, only the soundtrack didn't 100% met my expectations.

Surprisingly good movie and even better Star Wars one. 9.5/10… Expand

2 of 7 users found this helpful25

All this user's reviews

10

Weeeeee711Jan 3, 2018

This is what I imagine an UPDATED VERSION of the Originals being.

The Death Troopers/Shore Troopers were AWESOME. Great planets...great space battles. The people that said Last Jedi had the best visual must have AMNESIA..this blows it awayThis is what I imagine an UPDATED VERSION of the Originals being.

The Death Troopers/Shore Troopers were AWESOME.

Great planets...great space battles.

The people that said Last Jedi had the best visual must have AMNESIA..this blows it away (and so did Episode 3)!

The main hang up with most people were the characters...I'm hoping to see some of them either in Solo, Obi Wans movies or Rebels..but I thought they did fine..reading catalyst helped, too!

My main issue is where are the DELETED SCENES. I don't care if they wern't NECESSARY...neither was this film..neither are a lot of things..doesn't mean I don't want to see them!

I want to see more of Krennic, Vader, How Jyn got a gun on Yavin, etc.

This gets a 9.5 until I see some freaking deleted scenes..and a 10 it will be!

I round up, though!… Expand

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

10

JonNajemJan 12, 2017

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Even though this is a prequel to Star Wars (1977), it maybe the best standalone movie ive ever seen. Every character has their own quirks and importance within the roles they play which make each and every one of them likable for different reasons. The slow start just allows the movie to climb to infinite heights. Great acting all around from both the Rebel and Empire core cast. most people complain about the CGI Peter Cushing, but I honestly thought he was still alive cause the CGI was so convincing overall (Leia...maybe not so much, slightly more noticeable). The action was dirty, yet strategic, like the space battles back in Return of the Jedi or The Battle of Hoth in Empire Strikes Back. Made it feel just like a classic star wars movie, even more so than The Force Awakens did. Though the first act may chug a little on first viewing, it has a much less severe effect on second viewing. All in all, this is a damn good film.… Expand

5 of 9 users found this helpful54

All this user's reviews

10

akino3Dec 21, 2016

There is not much to say about this film other than the fact that it has exceeded all my expectations and its mediocre score. Seriously, what more could a Star Wars fan want? I can't thank the people involved in this film enough.

4 of 9 users found this helpful45

All this user's reviews

10

JonhyBotJan 7, 2019

I would put it this way: better than any of the fkn (so far) 2 sequels! Right up there with the original 3!

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

10

PrivataDec 17, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. A clever , deep and intellectual movie full of StarWars lore.
The best movie of the year , in 50 years we will still be talking about the wonders of R1… Expand

7 of 21 users found this helpful714

All this user's reviews

10

twall3Dec 19, 2016

I didn't care for the director's "Godzilla" movie (too much serious dialogue from characters I didn't care about), so I wondered how likeable this would be. I didn't like Rogue One ... I LOVED it (and the characters)! While it started on theI didn't care for the director's "Godzilla" movie (too much serious dialogue from characters I didn't care about), so I wondered how likeable this would be. I didn't like Rogue One ... I LOVED it (and the characters)! While it started on the slower end of things, by the time the movie ended and the credits rolled, my mind was blown. I knew it took place somewhere between SW3 and SW4, but what they did, how they handled it - hard to describe. Something like this: you go to the zoo to see a Lion, but before you leave, you've got your head in it's mouth looking down it's throat - unexpected up close view. Wow.… Expand

5 of 13 users found this helpful58

All this user's reviews

10

PeterAlexanderDec 16, 2016

Rogue One is gritty, charming and exhilarating. Gareth Edwards takes considerable risks in the very first Star Wars spinoff, all to huge success. Whilst the characters are played brilliantly, and the story is thrilling from start to finish,Rogue One is gritty, charming and exhilarating. Gareth Edwards takes considerable risks in the very first Star Wars spinoff, all to huge success. Whilst the characters are played brilliantly, and the story is thrilling from start to finish, it is the action and the gorgeous look of the film that stand out.… Expand

12 of 27 users found this helpful1215

All this user's reviews

10

AristMar 31, 2017

Unbelievable; great action with an in-depth drama. It was really brilliant to give lead acting to people who were not ultra stars. Very star warsy and yet very real and very deep!

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

10

delete013Jan 16, 2017

A slow, clumsy start perhaps, it slowly accelerates towards a dramatic ending. At first fractioned story parts collide just before the final act to perform a crescendo of visual and emotional enjoyment.

One just must admire the timing, careA slow, clumsy start perhaps, it slowly accelerates towards a dramatic ending. At first fractioned story parts collide just before the final act to perform a crescendo of visual and emotional enjoyment.

One just must admire the timing, care and precision, accompanied by great acting, especially on behalf of the Imperial side. No candy for children or primitive nonsense for teenagers, just gritty, glorious fight against the odds. And when the movie seems to reach the finish line, there follows a phantastic insidious ending. A triumph of cinema!

I it simply amazing that a story with heavyweight background of the Star Wars would be done in such a bold manner. I cannot think of a better gift for fans of a good fantasy cinema.… Expand

5 of 8 users found this helpful53

All this user's reviews

10

kushtopiaMar 27, 2017

It is the best Star Wars movie. I have personally gone to the theaters 3 times to see it. The violence is tough and gritty. The story was incredible and it contains my personal favorite star wars scene of all time.

4 of 7 users found this helpful43

All this user's reviews

10

LarrynautikDec 19, 2016

I am an old fan since before the Prequel Trilogy, and this Prequel Trilogy never enjoyed me a lot. I was disappointed by Episode 7. Where was the Star Wars spirit ? And then, I saw Rogue One. For many reasons, this is an excellent Star Wars.I am an old fan since before the Prequel Trilogy, and this Prequel Trilogy never enjoyed me a lot. I was disappointed by Episode 7. Where was the Star Wars spirit ? And then, I saw Rogue One. For many reasons, this is an excellent Star Wars. The scenario is very well-written, with a lot of unexpected developments. Special effects are very satisfying excepted for two characters. It doesn't affects the global felling however. Let's say it all : there's despair, hope, glory and emotion, humor, with a lot of winks towards all the other episodes. Most of all, this episode fit between espisodes 3 and 4 is perfectly articulated and acts as a real connection. I'm fully convinced this is a real Star Wars episode and should be seen by any fan or anyone else interested in Star Wars. I really enjoyed the show and the universe depicted. It looks believable and esthetically in absolute harmony with the "old" Star Wars movies, even if new ships are shown and new heroes too. There's also this specific and so appreciated urban chaos and crowds full of aliens on multi-storied cities. But you also get a lot of urban wars and exciting space fights.

To be honest, even the end of the movie will keep your breathe until the very last second. Impressive until the end, graphically and scenaristically. That's all, just a very good Star Wars an old fan appreciated a lot. It's clearly impossible to do better than that. Great job guys ! Shall all the following episodes be done like that !… Expand

3 of 12 users found this helpful39

All this user's reviews

10

HeavypointDec 17, 2016

This Movie is a love letter to the originals and fills the gap on why the Death Star was able to have such a weakness.

I love this movie plain and simple its a Star Wars movie done well and you must go and see it for yourself!!!This Movie is a love letter to the originals and fills the gap on why the Death Star was able to have such a weakness.

I love this movie plain and simple its a Star Wars movie done well and you must go and see it for yourself!!!

GOOOOOOOOOOOO WATCH IT ****

DO IT!… Expand

10 of 22 users found this helpful1012

All this user's reviews

10

forumsDec 19, 2016

My favorite Star Wars movie. I love this movie because; darker and more real.
birth of Death Star. Very scary Darth Vader. very scary laser from Death Star. no happy ending. sad ending. I don't enjoy lightsaber battles, I enjoy seeingMy favorite Star Wars movie. I love this movie because; darker and more real.
birth of Death Star. Very scary Darth Vader. very scary laser from Death Star. no happy ending. sad ending. I don't enjoy lightsaber battles, I enjoy seeing people killed by Darth Vader with lightsaber. People try to survive and escape from Darth Vader. People try to survive and escape from laser from Death Star. There should be movies like this not like Star Wars 1,2,3,7. There should be Star Wars every year. I can't wait.… Expand

4 of 9 users found this helpful45

All this user's reviews

10

vonMistontDec 30, 2016

No spoilers. Rogue 1 is the true awakening of the force. While last year’s cash grab made all 6 previous movies pointless, all our favorite heroes dirty and all their sacrifices and struggle irrelevant Rogue 1 only makes original trilogyNo spoilers. Rogue 1 is the true awakening of the force. While last year’s cash grab made all 6 previous movies pointless, all our favorite heroes dirty and all their sacrifices and struggle irrelevant Rogue 1 only makes original trilogy better by explaining some important plot holes (boy how many hours did we spend with friends laughing about how stupid constructor of a Death Star must have been to build so vulnerable station – well Rogue 1 has the last laugh!). It must have been made by true fans of everything that made original Star Wars great and not by some childish pretender who can only see the surface and doesn’t understand the essence. This movie is with The Force and The Force is with the Rogue 1. Beginning may be a bit slow for some people used to today’s action movies in which plot is only an excuse for some pointless combat but I myself prefer this kind of film structure in which first you have to learn why people do things they do. Finale on the other hand has no equal. And I’m not only referring to other Star Wars movies. It was so spectacular that I couldn’t sleep that night when I came back from the cinema. When I close my eyes I see magnificent scenes from Rogue 1. I watched original trilogy dozens of times, some scenes hundreds of times , I watched flawed prequel trilogy a lot too and it also had some good scenes, and while I will maybe never watch Force Awakens again I know that I will be rewinding Rogue 1 and watching some moments over and over again.
There is nostalgia in this movie but it’s not there just to trick you into liking this movie. It’s there because it truly is real original great Star Wars movie in it’s very core, you could literally make smooth transition between last scene of Rogue 1 and first scene of New Hope and you almost wouldn’t notice that another film just started (and that’s what I’m intending to do when Rogue 1 comes out!). It’s also great standalone film. You don’t have to know anything about other Star Wars movies to enjoy it and it makes it even better for Star Wars fan. When someday I will show my child Star Wars I would now have to decide if just maybe I should start with Rogue 1.
It really pains me to watch most of action movies, as often it seems that screenwriter was the worst payed person in whole crew. In Rogue 1 I would really have to search hole in whole to attack a plot. Story was really solid and could stand on its own even if it wasn’t set in Star Wars universe. As I mentioned above movie explains some questions concerning New Hope and some quite familiar characters (one in particular), we can also see even more of how tyrannical Imperial regime really was, we learn that Rebellion also isn’t a monolith but quite interesting group of people with different approaches. Humor was well placed and paced and unconstrained. It wasn’t one liner fest. I feel that every dialogue had sense and it was there for some reason. There was even one inspiring speech which actually inspired me! Usually in moments like these are tedious, but when Jyn was delivering her speech she was making sense and her arguments were convincing.
Soundtrack was ok it did its job and I know it was there which I couldn’t really say about previous movie. For me Star Wars was literally a space Opera or rather space symphony. I was watching beautiful scenes with no dialogue enjoying music and sights. And Rogue 1 has that quality too. Sights are magnificent, when spaceship is flying, even in battle you can see it clearly, camera doesn’t fly like crazy, you can really see what’s going on. I don’t know if it was just me but I also really liked ship’s landing scenes or when the ship flies by I find it very aesthetic and majestic and Rogue 1 has plenty of this awe inspiring moments and also plenty of great fight scenes.
Actors do a very good job, I really liked main cast a lot. Forest Whitaker was a bit overplayed, but on the other how do you not overplay a madman? Diego Luna was excellent as ruthless rebel driven by revenge, Donnie Yen was adorable human Yoda and like no other he showed us The Force really exists. After watching trailers I had many doubts to Felicity Jones as her character seemed too audacious and disrespectful with all this “I rebel!” etc. and I really want my heroes to care for what they do and be afraid to die, because if they don’t care why should I? But I was wrong, she was simply great. And she wasn’t some MaRey Sue either. I also had doubts about main villain but he was just repulsive enough to be believable and not some child’s vision of how mad space nazi would behave. CGI characters could have been made better, but I my fiance who didn’t grow up with Tarkins face said she didn’t notice he was CGI character.
I can’t wait for more movies by the authors of Rogue 1 it is without a doubt the best movie of this year and I couldn’t honestly say that any of the original trilogy films is better that Rogue 1.… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

10

ArconteDec 23, 2016

The Force Awakens was a total letdown last year but I have to say that this time Lucasfilm (Disney) did a great job. Rogue One is just amazing. Seriously go out and watch it becouse it deserve it, it's a true Star Wars movie. It's a story ofThe Force Awakens was a total letdown last year but I have to say that this time Lucasfilm (Disney) did a great job. Rogue One is just amazing. Seriously go out and watch it becouse it deserve it, it's a true Star Wars movie. It's a story of hope, a story of sacrifice for the greater good against the odds and oppression and I really loved the way the characters are well developed and plausible this time.
Also, even if there isn't (almost...) any lightsaber in it, still it shows us the force in a way that is so much better and convincing in comparison to what jj Abrams did in Episode 7, which totally broke my suspension of disbelief.
Both Visual and audio are stunning.
The ending is very climactic and the final battle (space and land)is just mind blowing.I do believe that this movie totally embrace the spirit of the Rebel Alliance. Finally!… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

10

Trent2012Dec 16, 2016

This was an excellent movie that fits in well with the Star Wars Saga. It is a far better movie than the horrible episode 4 remake known as The Force Awakens!

18 of 32 users found this helpful1814

All this user's reviews

10

Monkey_NutzDec 18, 2016

If you're an original trilogy purest this movie will hit you in the gut and hold you enthralled for just over two hours. THIS is the Star Wars movie we've been waiting for since 1985.

While not perfect, it is the perfect antidote to the lastIf you're an original trilogy purest this movie will hit you in the gut and hold you enthralled for just over two hours. THIS is the Star Wars movie we've been waiting for since 1985.

While not perfect, it is the perfect antidote to the last four weaksauce episodes (yeah, I'm talking to you too Force Awakens). I cheered, I cried, my mouth dropped in awe. I fell in love with Star Wars all over again, something I'd written off as impossible. As a previously bitter fan, this one movie has instilled within me the driving theme of this wonderful film, hope.… Expand

4 of 11 users found this helpful47

All this user's reviews

10

Rosvel92Apr 30, 2020

Sometimes simple works best, Rogue One proof. It spends little time re-explaining the context, because it knows is redundant, because everyone and specially the main audience has already watched the original "Star Wars IV: A New Hope" (toSometimes simple works best, Rogue One proof. It spends little time re-explaining the context, because it knows is redundant, because everyone and specially the main audience has already watched the original "Star Wars IV: A New Hope" (to which this film is a direct prequel to).

The time it could had spent doing that is better used. Finally clearing up the political context the original film didn't had time to explain. An in the process adding, some much needed moral complexity, into the Star Wars mythology. Is the thing we needed, but we didn't knew we wanted. As this movie shoews, it turns out that the Rebel Alliance aren't the saints the Original Trilogy painted. They did committed a few sins in their road to free the Galaxy from Emperor Palpatine.

Nothing here contradicts the Originals, it only makes the experience richer, by adding depth. The film is a like a prolonged prologue to "Star Wars IV:A New Hope". The protagonists are new characters, but the film is, also packed with cameos it doesn't bother to name them, neither to explain their role in the previous films, and honestly it doesn't need to. I'm glad it doesn't waste a second in redundant stuff you can see in previous movies. It instead makes clear, what they do, in this film. The hardcore fans sure will recognize them, I agree on this choice, what thit movie does explain is the new characters which is clever. Is a blend of old and new.

Another thing that makes better than The Force Awakens is that all the characters know their identity. They aren't building to a mistery or anything, they just tell you who everyone is right of the bath. As I said, simple works best.

Sure it lets a few things ambiguous, I would even say unexplored, and slightly unresolved. But I would say is fine. The movie does it's job at proving us that there is a bigger untold Star Wars narrative between each movie, and that this is just a small part of it. We are never going to get all details, because this characters were never meant to be as popular as the ones from the main movies.… Expand

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

10

MmkkJan 21, 2017

A fantastic film that has raised the bar for all the next Star Wars films. It may drag a bit in the beginning, but it makes up for it towards the end. A must see for any Star Wars fan.

4 of 8 users found this helpful44

All this user's reviews

10

MMBoschDec 18, 2016

Beautiful Star Wars Movie. It will fill your heart with joy and it will probably make you cry, all at the same time. Don't miss it it IMAX, it looks gorgeous.

7 of 15 users found this helpful78

All this user's reviews

10

Stroker_289Dec 16, 2016

Some of you are giving this movie an outstanding write-up review with a score of 0, make sure you give it a score along with a write-up. This movie is one-off star wars movie, one of the best in the franchise, far superior to episode 7 inSome of you are giving this movie an outstanding write-up review with a score of 0, make sure you give it a score along with a write-up. This movie is one-off star wars movie, one of the best in the franchise, far superior to episode 7 in every way possible. Everyone involved in this movie should be involved in every star wars movie from here on.… Expand

41 of 68 users found this helpful4127

All this user's reviews

10

Mike_ZmekeDec 24, 2016

Rogue One: A Star Wars Story BEST Star wars since original trilogy.
It's fresh brith in all star wars franchise!
Don't believe the stupid surveys of journalists and be sure to go to this beautiful film

2 of 6 users found this helpful24

All this user's reviews

10

DobypetiDec 26, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. The only thing I didn't like a bit that the characters died... Besides that, the movie was great, and maybe it's as good as The Empire Strikes Back!
Rogue One is better than The Force Awakens, Disney has learned their lesson (The Force Awakens is good too, but I agree that it was kinda like "A New Hope II").

However, I miss one thing from the new Star Wars movies: "calm parts", when there is no running away from enemies and things like that, namely when there is no action (the best example is when Yoda is teaching Luke in The Empire Strikes Back)...

After all, I'm hyped for the upcoming Star Wars movies!… Expand

1 of 5 users found this helpful14

All this user's reviews

10

Mad_MonkDec 16, 2016

Loved it. Was a much better Star Wars movie than "the force awakens". This is the Star Wars movie many of us have been waiting for. Darker and more real. Will definitely see it again at the movies. 10/10

57 of 91 users found this helpful5734

All this user's reviews

10

SteelMashineDec 20, 2016

Although I am very biased attitude to Star Wars, and for me this whole saga is a favorite in the world, but still, being objective, I would say simply - it's the top !!! !!! Vader is gorgeous! The film breaks all the templates just modernAlthough I am very biased attitude to Star Wars, and for me this whole saga is a favorite in the world, but still, being objective, I would say simply - it's the top !!! !!! Vader is gorgeous! The film breaks all the templates just modern cinema, as well as sets a new quality standard for Star Wars! I tell you, as a man, very well versed in this universe - Seventh episode was excellent intonation of a new trilogy, but this film, from which there is little waiting, could overshadow the seventh episode, and I hope it will serve as a good benchmark for this movie in this universe to which the directors will seek the following episodes! Bravo! 10/10! Everyone is required to view, even if you're not a fan, because the cost to join the great saga !!!… Expand

12 of 29 users found this helpful1217

All this user's reviews

10

HammerOfThoriumOct 16, 2018

Without question the best Star Wars film since the original trilogy. A compelling tale that, crucially, captures the aesthetic and tone of the 70s and 80s classics, without ever lapsing into mere imitation. Why this film has been overlookedWithout question the best Star Wars film since the original trilogy. A compelling tale that, crucially, captures the aesthetic and tone of the 70s and 80s classics, without ever lapsing into mere imitation. Why this film has been overlooked by so many, while the comparatively mediocre "The Force Awakens" and abysmal "The Last Jedi" receive broad adoration, is confounding to me. Artfully crafted, sharply acted, beautifully rendered, and with a final act to rival any entry in the series.… Expand

0 of 4 users found this helpful04

All this user's reviews

10

Moviereviewer15Dec 16, 2016

Little note: my review will be spoiler-free

HOLY S--T! What I just saw blew me away. What I came out of was "Star Wars" at it's best. "Rogue One: A Star Wars Story" is, IMHO, now the TRUE best Star Wars film since "The Empire Strikes Back".Little note: my review will be spoiler-free

HOLY S--T! What I just saw blew me away. What I came out of was "Star Wars" at it's best. "Rogue One: A Star Wars Story" is, IMHO, now the TRUE best Star Wars film since "The Empire Strikes Back". Set before the original "Star Wars" from 1977, this film shows us a true WAR in "Star Wars" by having spies of the Rebel Alliance go up against the evil Galactic Empire to steal the plans to their original Death Star. And, since Gareth Edwards, the director of this movie, really wanted to deliver a war film set in the Star Wars universe, akin to "Saving Private Ryan" and "Black Hawk Down", he was telling the truth coming out of what I saw. It really feels like a Star Wars movie in a whole new way. I will admit that I enjoyed "The Force Awakens", but, after a while, I've come to realize that while it is watchable, it feels safe in some ways. This one, really showed how original, different and new it was while being familiar when it knew too and it payed off big time in what I consider it's most serious, if not darkest, Star Wars ever. The entire cast of this movie shines. Felicity Jones plays Jyn Erso, our lead hero with strong brashness but such vulnerability you can't help but feel bad for her when you see how things play out for her in the film, especially with her father Galen (played by the always devious yet charming Mads Mikkelsen). Diego Luna puts effort into his role as Cassian Andor and makes it as memorable as his character's arc in the film is. Riz Ahmed really shows how conflicted his character, Bodhi Rook, is as he delivers playing a former Imperial cargo worker now struggling to redeem himself. Donnie Yen," and Jiang Wen are awesome as the pair of Force-believing warrior Chirrut Imwe and trigger-happy gun-wielding Baze Malbus. And, Alan Tudyk as the sarcastic reprogrammed droid K-2SO rounds out the cast to help make this movie work in their best way and they all get moments to shine in such iconic ways. Ben Mendohlson really showed his determination playing Orson Krennic in a different kind of villain for "Star Wars" to show. Darth Vader when he shows up really shows in this time where the film is set, he really is the Vader everyone grew up with. But, I cannot get off the hook without saying how impressed I am by Forest Whitaker's performance of my most anticipated character from this movie, Saw Gerrera from "Star Wars: The Clone Wars". While he was in this movie for more or less of what I expected, Forest Whitaker REALLY got into character as Saw and portrayed him in all the ways he was portrayed when we first saw him in "The Clone Wars". Also, if you generational Star Wars fans are hoping for ties to the Prequel Trilogy instead of just the Originals, well you're in luck, as we get appearances of not just characters and actors from the Prequels but also planets from the Prequels as well. We also visit new planets that help expand many parts of the Star Wars mythology such as where people stand in believing the Force and what it took to build the Death Star. Plus, be on the lookout for appearances and mentions of certain characters and ships from "Star Wars Rebels", which you can watch on Disney XD, when it returns with new episodes in January. Also, two important characters from the Original Trilogy make a return in some of the most well-made VFX ever put to film. I'm not spoiling who they are, so, you'll just have to watch for yourself. And, you'll feel like you're part of the action especially once you get to the epic space battle in the climax of the movie. Finally, Michael Giacchino really delivered with his score for this movie that really brings out the action and emotional development these characters go through to complete their mission as well as bringing something new to score in "Star Wars" while sprinkling familiar scores when needed. Overall, if you're looking for a phenomenal "Star Wars" film, "Rogue One" is that. It truly delivers on taking huge risks, like abandoning the traditional opening crawl, and finding its place into the "Star Wars" universe while remaining a standalone movie that really doesn't need to setup anything for the future of "Star Wars". And, that's good. I hope this movie is successful enough to do more riskier Star Wars spinoffs, especially if Episode IX is the last of the core Star Wars saga. I hope you all love this film, because I most certainly did. This film is for all generations of Star Wars fans. Go see it. You'll be glad you did. 5 stars. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
10/10… Expand

27 of 55 users found this helpful2728

All this user's reviews

10

AldaluinDec 20, 2016

Finally a Star Wars story with dramatic depth, characters to root for and a portrait of war as the horrible situation it actually is. A lesson of film making and script for blockbusters to come. 10/10.

1 of 8 users found this helpful17

All this user's reviews

10

fashion_policeJan 2, 2017

The movie is really good I recommend it. The Star Wars feel is here, there is character development and it is not cliché. The last hour is particularly good. Only downside is that it would have been cool to have more lightsaber fights.

3 of 6 users found this helpful33

All this user's reviews

10

LeoZamprognoDec 22, 2016

One of the best StarWars Movie and one of the best movies I've seen in my life! And I am a big star wars fan. If you don't like, you are not a fan, sorry...

2 of 6 users found this helpful24

All this user's reviews

10

CheddarPlaysDec 22, 2016

Excelente filme. Não o considero como Spin-Off , pois ele pode muito bem ser chamado de Star Wars 3.5. Um filme cheio de ação e com efeitos especiais simplismente fantásticos. Rogue One: A Star Wars Story é um filme sensacional que vale aExcelente filme. Não o considero como Spin-Off , pois ele pode muito bem ser chamado de Star Wars 3.5. Um filme cheio de ação e com efeitos especiais simplismente fantásticos. Rogue One: A Star Wars Story é um filme sensacional que vale a pena assistir.… Expand

1 of 5 users found this helpful14

All this user's reviews

10

drrealitycheckDec 26, 2016

Best Star Wars movie since The Empire Strikes Back. This was a return to the very first two movies back in the 70s, a tribute to the best of this franchise and the kind of Star Wars saga we all came to love. A host of new characters was quiteBest Star Wars movie since The Empire Strikes Back. This was a return to the very first two movies back in the 70s, a tribute to the best of this franchise and the kind of Star Wars saga we all came to love. A host of new characters was quite successful and the humor wasn't left out either. It also fills in a lot of gaps from the original films. Oh, and your favorite all time villain, complete with the voice of James Earl Jones, makes a few appearances.Those who didn't give this event top end reviews are in immediate need of CPR.… Expand

3 of 8 users found this helpful35

All this user's reviews

10

rsullivaDec 23, 2016

The fact that this movie is rated lower than the 'Force Awakens' disheartens the credibility of all professional critics; this movie was epic to say the least. By far the most realistic and possible the most moving Stars Wars movie everThe fact that this movie is rated lower than the 'Force Awakens' disheartens the credibility of all professional critics; this movie was epic to say the least. By far the most realistic and possible the most moving Stars Wars movie ever produced; providing an extremely well integration of the first and second trilogies. This movie had absolutely no appeal no the 'stupid humor' or 'cute' appeal often found in the other Star Wars films. After watching the film for the second time, I can state that this is probably my favorite Star Wars film ever produced; due to its new definition of the force and the unstoppable force reprimanded by the empire and specifically Darth Vader. The almost impossible feats accomplished by the rebels, reinforces the 'underdog' feel of the rebel alliance provided in the original trilogy while also explaining how the force controls the fate of the galaxy. This film also had noticeable political claims which makes stand on almost the same level of greatness as the original film 'New Hope'.… Expand

4 of 13 users found this helpful49

All this user's reviews

10

stevenschatzDec 13, 2017

Rogue One: A Star Wars Story is a fantastic film that suggests a very bright future for the Star Wars franchise. The film contains a lot of action and answers tons of questions that were raised in the original trilogy. The characters are allRogue One: A Star Wars Story is a fantastic film that suggests a very bright future for the Star Wars franchise. The film contains a lot of action and answers tons of questions that were raised in the original trilogy. The characters are all very likable and they provide the perfect amount of humor to get the audience laughing occasionally. The amount of nostalgia in this film is very sufficient and will warm the hearts of long-term Star Wars fans. The only flaw in this film is that the plot is a bit uneven during the first act: the movie jumps between planets a lot, but I personally don't think it's a problem. Other than that, Rogue One: A Star Wars Story is a truly spectacular film and definitely feels like a Star Wars movie.

Pros:
- Fills in a major plot hole from A New Hope
- Nostalgia
- Comedic relief
- Likable characters
- Lots of action
Cons (if I had to pick one)
- Slightly uneven plot in act 1

Verdict:
Visuals/Music - 5/5
Plot/Characters - 5/5
Structure - 5/5
Acting - 5/5
Overall - 100%… Expand

0 of 5 users found this helpful05

All this user's reviews

10

SpecialK916Dec 17, 2016

I mean what else do you want? For what they had to work with I think they did a fantastic job. I just got home, so maybe I'm still high off the fumes of the rebellion, but I wouldn't put up too much of a fight with anyone that says it wasI mean what else do you want? For what they had to work with I think they did a fantastic job. I just got home, so maybe I'm still high off the fumes of the rebellion, but I wouldn't put up too much of a fight with anyone that says it was better than the force awakens.… Expand

6 of 14 users found this helpful68

All this user's reviews

10

PabloBird22Jan 4, 2017

Rogue one is awesome it's simply amazing, Darth vader was awesome as usual i swear on my life that I never saw Darth vader so bloody and brutal as in the last scene, it's awesome Rogue one always gonna find a place as the best STAR WARSRogue one is awesome it's simply amazing, Darth vader was awesome as usual i swear on my life that I never saw Darth vader so bloody and brutal as in the last scene, it's awesome Rogue one always gonna find a place as the best STAR WARS prequel.

P.S: R.I.P Carri fisher for his last scene in the movie :')… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

10

live4tantraDec 25, 2016

People are unbelievable with their ratings. Force Awakens was a joke. This movie is true to the Star Wars saga. I hope Disney keeps this Director for all future Star Wars movies. The only flaw I saw in this movie was Orson Krennic whosePeople are unbelievable with their ratings. Force Awakens was a joke. This movie is true to the Star Wars saga. I hope Disney keeps this Director for all future Star Wars movies. The only flaw I saw in this movie was Orson Krennic whose acting and speech pattern was a bit silly. Other than that, the movie was awesome!… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

10

hawkeye766Dec 17, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Rogue One: a Star Wars Story is a movie far different that anything
that has ever been released under the lucasfilm name. It is completely
devoid of a crawl at the beginning for one thing; Instead it starts
with a concussive sforzando of the score, and space flashes onto the
screen, as if to say, "Here it is, what else did you expect?" I love
those bold yellow words as much as the next guy, they function as a
call to adventure, an invitation to a place far different from anything
the viewer is used to. But Rogue One is different: it's a lot less
adventurous and far more familiar than the galaxy far far away has ever
been. I mean this in the most complimentary way possible; this is a
film that puts the War in "Star Wars" in an acute fashion. Rogue One's main strength is its action. In this reviewers humble
opinion, it features the best action the franchise has to offer. Before
you cry "Blasphemy!" and slam the computer shut in rage, allow me to
explain myself. The battle of the death star in Return of the Jedi is
probably the original trilogy's best space combat. It provides a
vigorous depiction of spacial warfare, displaying the speed and chaos
of ship to ship combat. It is, however, fettered by the primitivity of
early 1980s special effects. The Force Awakens brought to the table
modern effects, but was fairly unexciting to watch due to its being a
near carbon copy of the battle in IV. The battle that serves as Rogue
One's climax is an all-new concept. Things like planetary shield gates,
message transmissions, and ramming ships are brought in the picture.
Aided by 15 or so visual effects companies Disney recruited, it looks
considerably excellent as well. Many aspects of A New Hope are also addressed. The conveniently placed
exhaust port is no longer a shoehorned plot device, but a final act of
revenge by a defecting engineer. Tarkin isn't a Grand Moff but a lowly
Governor, and we get to witness his ascension to power firsthand. Darth
Vader also plays a fairly major role in the film. Many have criticized
Edwards for his habitation of barely three scenes, but really, this
makes them special. Lack of cinematic appearance for the last 34 years
makes it that much more exciting. I struggled in containing my
excitement when I heard that mechanical rasp coming out of the pitch
black hallway of the rebel cruiser in the last scene. After all those
warnings about cell phones, I figured a boisterous scream of childlike
glee would probably be frowned upon in the establishment. When Vader's
crimson blade appeared, spreading the faces of the trembling rebel
soldiers and the hallway of that ship in rufescent, evil glow, I was
actually shaking with anticipation. Vader precedes to hurl himself upon
the hapless rebels with wieldy might. The rebels rush back, handing
off the sought after plans from man to man, as Vader slashes, chokes,
and tosses through their ranks with ease. In a moment of perfection,
the trooper hands off his precious cargo to a CG Princess Leia. "What
did they bring us?" he says. "Hope" she replies. Needless to say, I
almost cried. As I exited the theater, barely keeping my balance after listening to
Giacchino's brilliant overture, I overheard a woman talking with
dissatisfaction about the movie: "I guess it was good, it was kind of
depressing though. I mean, they all died, right?"
"WRONG!" I wanted to scream. Yes, they all die, but in a blaze of
glory. Each character receives the fitting end that I only wish Han
Solo had been given. Countless rebel giants fall, fighting for the
rebel cause. Bohdie the pilot dies wiring an antenna, Baze Malbus dies fighting with newfound acceptance of the force, and Cassian and Jyn die having passed on the death star plans. While nothing else can ever fill the place the original trilogy holds in my heart, I must admit no other Star Wars film has ever portrayed, at least this powerfully, the theme of sacrifice, and how it can pave the way for a new hope.… Expand

4 of 10 users found this helpful46

All this user's reviews

10

KingofdanerdsJan 20, 2017

I just love how the directors were able to find a successful way to make a Star Wars movie taking place between Episodes III and IV. Action is amazing and this movie has a strong and supporting cast. Could not ask for more. I am one with theI just love how the directors were able to find a successful way to make a Star Wars movie taking place between Episodes III and IV. Action is amazing and this movie has a strong and supporting cast. Could not ask for more. I am one with the force the force is with me. R.I.P. Carrie Fisher. 10/10… Expand

4 of 10 users found this helpful46

All this user's reviews

10

RealmOfTheEnderJan 9, 2017

I'm likely not the kind of person to look to for reviews, but I found this film to be absolutely amazing. I'll go ahead and write here:

-Did it feel like Star Wars? =Yes, absolutely. It was perfect. The atmosphere, the characters, theI'm likely not the kind of person to look to for reviews, but I found this film to be absolutely amazing. I'll go ahead and write here:

-Did it feel like Star Wars?
=Yes, absolutely. It was perfect. The atmosphere, the characters, the planets, everything felt like how a Star Wars movie should.

-How about dat Darth Vader tho?
=It was...okay, I guess. He could've been better used, but the way he's used still makes up for it. -Was it the best Star Wars eva?
=I'd say 3rd best, behind A New Hope and Empire Strikes Back.

Overall, I believe this was a really good Star Wars film, and a good film in general.… Expand

5 of 9 users found this helpful54

All this user's reviews

10

blowme44Jan 12, 2017

For Star Wars Fans, this is what we've been waiting for,"a perfect blend of old and new with spectacular special effects." With a little poetic license this film rivals our fond memories of Empire and New Hope.

5 of 8 users found this helpful53

All this user's reviews

10

jamiejoyceDec 16, 2016

Rogue One is, quite frankly, MAGNIFICENT. Disney deserve praise for not shying away from allowing the filmmakers to apply some bold story decisions in the third act. This isn’t some neutered, watered down version of Star Wars – this is StarRogue One is, quite frankly, MAGNIFICENT. Disney deserve praise for not shying away from allowing the filmmakers to apply some bold story decisions in the third act. This isn’t some neutered, watered down version of Star Wars – this is Star Wars at its most uncompromised. Thrilling, beautiful and occasionally surprising, this is the prequel the fans deserve.… Expand

12 of 32 users found this helpful1220

All this user's reviews

10

HasskthugDec 16, 2016

Everything ever wanted from a Star Wars movie. I'm rooting for both the bad guys and the good guys. Funny, exhilarating and tragic. It adds deeper meaning to Episode IV. Thank you Gareth Edwards

25 of 45 users found this helpful2520

All this user's reviews