Read Mixed User Reviews for Rogue One: A Star Wars Story

6

LamontRaymondDec 17, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. It's a relatively fun movie, especially as a nostalgia fix if you liked the original three films (like I did), but one element REALLY annoyed me - the CGI-created faces of Grand Moff Tarkin and Princess Leia. I mean, great attempt, and fun. But they simply don't look real! I mean, if they could pull this sort of thing off in Avatar and hundreds of other "animated" movies, why was this such a tough ask? They don't even get near the uncanny valley. Highly off-putting, but it didn't ruin the movie for me. I also don't think Felicity Jones can handle the lead role. Even the "young" version of herself was a stronger actress. What made the movie was Alan T. as the new droid and the cast of supporting actors including Diego Luna and the blind force-believer (who is amazing).… Expand

3 of 9 users found this helpful36

All this user's reviews

6

TVJerryDec 20, 2016

As action flicks go, this one is too slow and talky, but does have a decent final battle. As Star Wars flicks go, it's a standalone with little of the legacy characters, a story that's tangential to the originals and no scrolling text at theAs action flicks go, this one is too slow and talky, but does have a decent final battle. As Star Wars flicks go, it's a standalone with little of the legacy characters, a story that's tangential to the originals and no scrolling text at the beginning. A group of rebels sets out to steal the plans to the Death Star before it can destroy planets. The expected cool locations, technology and creatures dance around the edges, but there are no breakthru visuals or individuals to make this one stand out. The drama that dominates the first 90 minutes isn't especially compelling or interesting. Overall, it continues the legacy without bringing much new or exciting to its inheritance.… Expand

2 of 6 users found this helpful24

All this user's reviews

6

TheQuietGamerJan 9, 2017

Rogue One succeeds at showing a darker and more desperate side of the Star Wars universe. The galaxy is being crushed under the Empire's oppression, the Rebel Alliance is being forced to resort to grim tactics in order to survive, and to topRogue One succeeds at showing a darker and more desperate side of the Star Wars universe. The galaxy is being crushed under the Empire's oppression, the Rebel Alliance is being forced to resort to grim tactics in order to survive, and to top it all off the Empire is in the process of putting the finishing touches on some sort of super weapon. One rumored to have the power to destroy planets. All of this sets off a chain of events that make for the most unique Star Wars yet. One that feels more like a heist and war film, than what's come before.

One of the movie's greatest strengths is that it captures the bleak atmosphere one would expect from a Star Wars story set in this period of the series' timeline. There's a feeling of hopelessness that follows the characters around through every scenario they find themselves apart of. Nearly every planet they visit has that dirty, rundown, right in the middle of a warzone feel that sells the tone excellently. When it comes to the depiction of the state of the galaxy the movie succeeds near-perfectly.

Another area where the movie is at it's best is in it's incredible battles. These conflicts standout as the best the series has to offer. The scale is grand, the stakes are intense, and the shear amount of eye candy is stunning. The series even gets involved in some non-blaster fights that rival the series best lightsaber duels, despite not having a single Jedi in sight. When it comes to action the movie does not disappoint. Unfortunately the same thing cannot be said for it's writing and characters. Something that leaves an unfortunate sour patch in an otherwise stellar movie.

It's not that the events aren't interesting. The concept of watching a ragtag team come together to steal the plans for the freaking Death Star with all odds stacked against them is one that would excite any Star Wars fan. The problem is that early on it just sort of moves in a way that unceremoniously throws them together. It jumps around so much at the beginning it's actually a little confusing to piece together what's going on. It doesn't take long for things to click, but when they do your left with an even bigger problem; you have no way to connect with the characters, so it's impossible to care about them. The exception being Alan Tudyk's excellent K-2SO. It's not that they're unlikable characters. It's just that there's no spark or flair to them that causes them to standout as anything more than the Star Wars universe's B-team. A group of bland faces meant to carry things on here while things are being prepared for Episode VIII. Given that the popularity of the Star Wars series partly stems from the compelling nature of it's characters and plot, it's disappointing to see the series first anthology film fall short in those areas. This is primarily a movie you watch for the spectacular action. I say primarily because the movie does have a great deal of fan-service for Star Wars fans. Things like special references and even a few surprise cameos are sure to please. Especially since they feel natural to the story and not just shoehorned in. So in the end Rogue One isn't a disaster. Just more of a disappointment in some areas. There are still plenty of reasons to check it out, longtime fan or not. It's noticeable differences in things like tone have the potential to appeal to newcomers. So in the end all is not lost.

6.9/10… Expand

2 of 8 users found this helpful26

All this user's reviews

6

IsotopesamDec 16, 2016

Its not until the second half that you realize the importance of the story in the Star Wars world. I wish they had built it up better in the first half. But poor character development turns this movie. Second half is great and a treat for theIts not until the second half that you realize the importance of the story in the Star Wars world. I wish they had built it up better in the first half. But poor character development turns this movie. Second half is great and a treat for the eyes but the overall story was just rushed. It was disappointing that they didn't start with the Star Wars theme either. You can wait to watch it on bluray or stream it.… Expand

6 of 13 users found this helpful67

All this user's reviews

6

ayarlettDec 16, 2016

Stars wars has become the Terminator franchise. First two movies were good but every one since has been average at best. This one was ok again. Nothing mind blowing and the robot K2 was the best actor. That says it all. I even thought theStars wars has become the Terminator franchise. First two movies were good but every one since has been average at best. This one was ok again. Nothing mind blowing and the robot K2 was the best actor. That says it all. I even thought the mexican guy was french until someone pointed out he was hispanic the next day. Anyway it wasnt bad but was just about average-ish. last 30 mins was the best part.… Expand

3 of 15 users found this helpful312

All this user's reviews

6

VDSMar 25, 2017

Standing on the shoulders of giants, or giant in this case (George Lucas). I know GL's Star Wars movies weren't great, and sometimes they weren't even good, but they had heart and a feeling you were in a familiar universe. They felt coherent.Standing on the shoulders of giants, or giant in this case (George Lucas). I know GL's Star Wars movies weren't great, and sometimes they weren't even good, but they had heart and a feeling you were in a familiar universe. They felt coherent. Rogue One, on the other hand, felt like a hotchpotch of plagiarism from previous Star Wars movies, and everything plus the kitchen sink thrown in to try and create settings/characters. And BTW, resurrecting the past via CGI does not work. Disney, if you want to make a Sci-fi movie, make one, create something new and develop your own mythos. Don't just get your cheque book out, purchase greatness, and then try (but fail) to make it your own.… Expand

3 of 7 users found this helpful34

All this user's reviews

6

JoeCoolJan 2, 2017

I'm going to go with a 6 for this one, since I feel a 7 would just be too generous, even being a pretty big Star Wars fan. I had some doubts about the whole 'Star Wars Story' thing at first, but the movie managed to get the looks of the StarI'm going to go with a 6 for this one, since I feel a 7 would just be too generous, even being a pretty big Star Wars fan. I had some doubts about the whole 'Star Wars Story' thing at first, but the movie managed to get the looks of the Star Wars universe right, but the feeling was off from the get go. The grittiness of it all and the throw-away characters spoiled the fun quite a bit. The CGI was great, and there was no shortage of action near the end, but I still wonder why this movie was created at all. It doesn't fit with the Star Wars feeling except maybe for the space battle at the end which is great, but not enough to completely save this otherwise really bad movie. If this is the direction these Star Wars stories are going to take then they might as well call it a day right now.… Expand

4 of 12 users found this helpful48

All this user's reviews

6

DemoraseJan 1, 2017

I don't know how to describe Rogue One for the first hour and half other than I was utterly bored out of my mind. However, the last thirty minutes were full and engrossing enough to salvage this troubled movie. But surely you can do betterI don't know how to describe Rogue One for the first hour and half other than I was utterly bored out of my mind. However, the last thirty minutes were full and engrossing enough to salvage this troubled movie. But surely you can do better than that, Disney.… Expand

4 of 8 users found this helpful44

All this user's reviews

6

gzayas91Dec 29, 2018

This was okay. This could have been a novel or a comic book. It just does not have the same punch as the film series.

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

6

endisniApr 16, 2017

The film was okay. Glad I only rented it. There are some stand out pieces, such as Vader's appearance. The music is pretty good, the acting fine. I won't be watching again, it's not especially memorable. I felt the Force Awakens was farThe film was okay. Glad I only rented it. There are some stand out pieces, such as Vader's appearance. The music is pretty good, the acting fine. I won't be watching again, it's not especially memorable. I felt the Force Awakens was far superior.… Expand

2 of 4 users found this helpful22

All this user's reviews

6

samichsupernovaDec 17, 2016

This film was entertaining but ultimately adds up to less than the sum of its parts. The Good: The insane (amount and quality of) action, cinematography, and some performances. Felicity Jones and Ben Mendohlson did a lot with weak materialThis film was entertaining but ultimately adds up to less than the sum of its parts. The Good: The insane (amount and quality of) action, cinematography, and some performances. Felicity Jones and Ben Mendohlson did a lot with weak material and were seriously great. Alan Tudyk, Donnie Yen and Diego Luna's characters are cool. Certain cameos work really well. There's some poetry and clever visual ideas in the prolonged conflict in the third act, which almost makes up for the terrible first 1/2 of the movie (Jyn dispatches Stormtroopers with a stick... OK...). The action kind of feels like a kid playing with Star Wars action figures, in both good and bad ways. Oh and there's a monkey Rebel gunner.

The Bad: Everything else. The script tries to be darker and more realistic but there's hardly any depths of conflict beyond "good guys" VS "bad guys" where one good guy is only slightly more morally compromised than the others. There's no character development whatsoever. The story overall is paint-by-the-numbers. A total missed opportunity there. Forest Whitaker's character dies early on for no reason. The score is weak. There is little dramatic drive because we all know how this story will end. Too much "fan-service" and nostalgia. Callbacks to the original trilogy can only go so far.

The Ugly: How much money this is going to make, undeservedly. Unless you REALLY need to see the epic finale on the big screen, just wait for it to hit home video.… Expand

7 of 15 users found this helpful78

All this user's reviews

6

SmoothrunnerDec 27, 2016

Unexpectedly good movie for a Star Wars. At least I've saw it out to the end unlike previous "episode". I'm not a fanboy of this "fairy tale rubbish", but at last they've filmed something that makes sense and really reminded war to meet theUnexpectedly good movie for a Star Wars. At least I've saw it out to the end unlike previous "episode". I'm not a fanboy of this "fairy tale rubbish", but at last they've filmed something that makes sense and really reminded war to meet the movie title. Attractive Felicity Jones is a fine choice for the main role, but other staff are mediocre. Pathetic speeches are laughable and heroes behave unnaturally but still better than in most other SW "episodes". But what really bothers me is that "rebels" are as much unsympathetic as Empire is. They are depicted as bunch of zealots willing to sacrifice their own and others lives for an unclear and morally ambiguous purpose - vague illusions and dreams. They are fanatics with dubious motivation. Even religious suicide bombers have more reason and logic in their doings than SW's rebels. At least they are expecting to end up in an imaginary "paradise" and are dying for their "brothers". But all these rebels - what are they killing and dying for? As I said - they are scary zealots with irrational behaviour and no better than Imperial Stormtroopers. In fact, they are behaving utterly unrealistic. But this is SW after all.… Expand

2 of 8 users found this helpful26

All this user's reviews

6

QuietlionmusicNov 18, 2017

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. I would say I enjoyed much of the special effects of this movie but had lots of gripes with it. I take my Star Wars seriously as many fans do and I just found the main character to be so lackluster to try and carry this film. Underwhelming characters throughout the film made the film as a whole just 'alright'. The droid was very funny. Darth Vader was cool in the end, but his interactions with Krenig were somewhat cringy, but not as much as the CGI Grand Moff and Leia. Overall I didn't hate it, but It was not very noteworthy either.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

6

Sirik_MatakDec 17, 2016

Surprisingly for me - this movie is OK! I expected it to be a total disaster. It didn't try to recreate anything, it's just a decent action/character story picture with a Star Wars paint over it. And even if they actually did break theSurprisingly for me - this movie is OK! I expected it to be a total disaster. It didn't try to recreate anything, it's just a decent action/character story picture with a Star Wars paint over it. And even if they actually did break the barrier of the cringe here and there, I liked it a lot. Rolled my eyes a lot on some parts and still forced humour, but despite that, I still liked it. I was afraid that the "diversity hurrr" gimmick will kill this movie, but even if some characters are weak, they were characters with personalities (maybe except them monk dudes and the main lead, which is Rey 2.0 who can barely act), not token characters.
A quick meal that tastes good. Also, it's a relief to know that they ended all main characters in the same movie they were introduced in and don't plan to sequel their story.… Expand

2 of 10 users found this helpful28

All this user's reviews

6

tigerskin84Jan 11, 2017

Despues del desastre que fue the force awakens, una copia horrenda del episodio 4 recibimos rogue one, el film que nadie pidio(como el proximo de han solo), no me malinterpretes la pelicula no es tan mala pero tiene demasiados personajes y noDespues del desastre que fue the force awakens, una copia horrenda del episodio 4 recibimos rogue one, el film que nadie pidio(como el proximo de han solo), no me malinterpretes la pelicula no es tan mala pero tiene demasiados personajes y no profundiza nada en ellos por lo tanto es dificil sentirse apegado a ellos cuando llega el final.Otro problema con esta pelicula es que ya sabemos que es lo que va a pasar por lo tanto tiene 0 factor sorpresa y tambien quiero mencionar la obsesion de disney con las death stars y la ya trillada trama de alguien que viene con un mensaje importante y vital y los problemas entre padre e hijos, ya cansan... espero que el episodio 8 sea buena o adios a esta gran saga de peliculas.… Expand

1 of 6 users found this helpful15

All this user's reviews

6

moviemitch96Dec 26, 2016

This is probably just me being bias against Star Wars ever since it was ruined for me by The Force Awakens last year, but I really do feel like I got burnt again by this series with this prequel/spinoff (or whatever you wanna call it.)This is probably just me being bias against Star Wars ever since it was ruined for me by The Force Awakens last year, but I really do feel like I got burnt again by this series with this prequel/spinoff (or whatever you wanna call it.) Basically it's simply the exact same formula that's been used over and over again and is riddled with cliche moments throughout. Even the acting couldn't be helped, with Felicity Jones reduced to really cheap, and yes, cliche lines throughout along with the rest of the cast as well. And I don't even wanna start talking about the ridiculous CGI that was used to bring back some classic characters from the original trilogy and making them look younger again. Overall, this did nothing whatsoever to bring anything new to the table for Star Wars and is simply a further reminder to me why I'm really wanting to distance myself from Star Wars more and more. Keep it up Disney (not!)… Expand

2 of 4 users found this helpful22

All this user's reviews

6

ozymandias79Mar 29, 2017

When the most human character in a movie is a robot, there's a problem, a major one. Rogue one is a disposable popcorn flick. One viewing is more than enough. It's completely forgettable and the fan service is cringe worthy.

2 of 6 users found this helpful24

All this user's reviews

6

SpookydarrenDec 16, 2016

So, just wanted to make a point and say that some of the best bits were missing from the trailers. Jin saying "that's what I do, I rebel". She sounded like a bad ass but the character ends up being somewhat diminished imo. Also the face offSo, just wanted to make a point and say that some of the best bits were missing from the trailers. Jin saying "that's what I do, I rebel". She sounded like a bad ass but the character ends up being somewhat diminished imo. Also the face off with the tie fighter on the tower looked spectacular but was also cut. On the plus side the new droid and Vader were AWESOME. Film saved in the last five minutes. Looking forward to the Han Solo story.… Expand

9 of 36 users found this helpful927

All this user's reviews

6

evokingsApr 7, 2019

I wanted to love this movie, but i realized I only loved the Vader scenes, the rest of the movie is okay here and there I'm not sure what to think of the Leia and tarkin CG scenes sometimes it works other times it gets a little creepy butI wanted to love this movie, but i realized I only loved the Vader scenes, the rest of the movie is okay here and there I'm not sure what to think of the Leia and tarkin CG scenes sometimes it works other times it gets a little creepy but ultimately I enjoyed the movie, one of the key issues is they reintroduce us to new characters only to kill all of them so I would have liked it if they spun this off in it's own way in the background of the star wars universe instead they went SOLO lol.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

6

sciencehedgeDec 18, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. I have been a big fan of the Star Wars movies over the past several decades. Rogue One definitely excelled on the action side; however, the characters were flat and most of the performances quite boring---especially Felicity Jones and Diego Luna. Although I was rooting for their success in getting the plans for the death star, I felt almost no kinship or sympathy for them as characters. I would say that Rogue One was a good action movie without a soul and without the magic that most of the Star Wars movie had. The force was not with Rogue One.… Expand

3 of 8 users found this helpful35

All this user's reviews

6

HotelCentralMay 22, 2017

Back in 1977 when the original Star Wars movie came out no one had ever seen anything like it before. So if the story was a little trite no one really cared because they were too busy being wow-ed by the spectacle of it all. But it's now 40Back in 1977 when the original Star Wars movie came out no one had ever seen anything like it before. So if the story was a little trite no one really cared because they were too busy being wow-ed by the spectacle of it all. But it's now 40 years later and we've had 9 "Star Wars" films, a bunch of Star Trek films, Blade Runner, Independence Day, Battlestar Galactica, X-Men, Guards of the Galaxy, Transformers and God knows what else. And Rogue One ends up seeming like just more of the same and not particularly enthralling.

The first hour is a bit of a bore. I didn't feel any particular interest in the characters or the story until finally someone opened her mouth and started talking about heroes and sacrifice and this kind of thing. But even with the pace picking up in the second hour I wasn't terribly impressed. Even the interludes of robotic comedy seemed kind of tired. So ultimately I'd say if you're into Star Wars give Rogue One a shot but save it for a day when you've got nothing better on tap.… Expand

2 of 4 users found this helpful22

All this user's reviews

6

MattBrady99Dec 25, 2016

Rogue One follows Jyn Erso (played by Felicity Jones) a Rebellion soldier and criminal, who is about to experience her biggest challenge yet when Mon Mothma sets her out on a mission to steal the plans for the Death Star. With help from theRogue One follows Jyn Erso (played by Felicity Jones) a Rebellion soldier and criminal, who is about to experience her biggest challenge yet when Mon Mothma sets her out on a mission to steal the plans for the Death Star. With help from the Rebels, a master swordsman, and non-allied forces, Jyn will be in for something bigger than she thinks.

I had my worries with Rogue One, if I must admit. After the massive success of "The Force Awakens", the universe of Star Wars has now expanded even more. There's going to be more sequels, prequels, and spin-offs every year now. Why this worries me is because I fear I'm going to be sick of theses and not really get exited anymore. Star Wars should be treated like a three year event like before, it gives more time for the writers & director to really flesh out the story. It may seem like a long wait, but it'll be worth the wait. But that's not all. The trouble re shoots this went through and the ridiculous short deadlines during post-production. But after seeing the film myself, I can safely say that this new prequel isn't a bad one.

"Rogue One: A Star Wars Story" is a good movie. Not great or amazing, just decent. In my opinion, it's not up there with "A New Hope" or "Empire Strikes Back". It's more in the middle for me. If I have to be honest, I actually enjoyed "Force Awakens" more than this. Yeah, I said it. The movie is flawed, but it dose have a lot to like about it.

I can't imagine the pressure Gareth Edwards must have felt making this, kinda like what Abrams was feeling. In interviews, Gareth has said he was a Star Wars fan and it was the reason why he wanted to make movies. So this is very dear to him and while there where some slip ups in parts, but I must say that he handed the material really well. Gareth Edward is very good at making things feel huge and the heavy scale of things. The action scenes were directed so brilliantly that it actually felt like a war movie.

That's what really surprised me about "Rogue One" is how dark and depressing it is. Some people may have a problem with that, since everyone is use to these adventures with are favorite characters. For me, I didn't have an issue with it. Heck, I'm kinda glad it had the balls to go that far and be violent. The humor is very limited, but when there is humor is mostly from K-2SO (played by Alan Tudyk), who was just the best.

The CGI in this movie was incredible and quite groundbreaking. I mean, it's TOO GOOD. The way it blended with the real life environment and the action scenes was so good that half of the time I was watching computer effect's on screen. How it was executed was so beautiful and quite the achievement.

Now the biggest complaint I've been hearing from Star Wars fans is about Peter Cushing Digital Resurrection. Yep, he's back to cinematic life through the use of state-of-the-art visual effects wizardry. He's character Grand Moff Tarkin is in the movie, but instead of re-casting the role or kept his digital face in the shadows, but that's surprisingly not the case. He's in the movie quite a lot as you see him in full form and up close. This is getting a mix response from people and even I was a bit mixed on it. I was a bit weird out by it, as Peter Cushing has been dead for 22 years and seeing up there was hard to digest. But after letting it sink in, I thought it wasn't too noticeable and in a few scene I actually brought into it. I thought it looked real when he wasn't moving around or any close ups to his face. But that's just my thoughts.

Speaking of bringing back old characters, Dark Vader makes a appears in this. While he's screen time is very short, but he steals every scene he's in. Eventually the hallway scene, that was so bad-ass and one of my favorite moments in the movie. It's great to see him and James Earl Jones back as one of greatest villains of all time.

The first half of "Rogue One" was a bit rough for me and I was kinda bored at times. I didn't care or got attracted to the characters. The characterization was lacking and that's a real shame, because Star Wars is all about the characters, as it's the thing we remember from these movies. It's not all about Lightsabers and battles, it's the characters. Felicity Jones, Alan Tudyk & Mads Mikkelsen characters were the only ones that I cared about. The others not so much.

Another major part of the Star Wars movies is the score. John Williams score is so iconic that it's hard to top it. It's the heart of the series and I kinda wish he did the score for this, because Michael Giacchino score wasn't that good. But I'll cut Giacchino a little slack, he only had 4 weeks to compose it and it is a tough act to follow. That goes back to what I said about the deadlines being too short.

"Rogue One: A Star Wars Story" is a good entry to the series and it dose feel like a dark Star Wars movie. I may have problems with the movie and I have to be honest with that, but I do think it ties in very well with "A New Hope".… Expand

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

6

russiangamerDec 24, 2016

На персонажей наплевать, идите умирайте, мне то что? Сюжет скучный, всё равно знаем, что у них всё выйдет, чего волноваться то?
Робот, которого так хвалили... что в нём такого, обычный персонаж, который типа шутит и все типа смеются.На персонажей наплевать, идите умирайте, мне то что? Сюжет скучный, всё равно знаем, что у них всё выйдет, чего волноваться то?
Робот, которого так хвалили... что в нём такого, обычный персонаж, который типа шутит и все типа смеются.
Вейдер... По ощущениям, он находился в кадре минуты 2-3 из которых 1-1,5 минуты он дрался. Вау... Единственное, к чему нет претензий - это спец-эффекты. Ну и всё таки первый час даже интересно смотреть.… Expand

1 of 9 users found this helpful18

All this user's reviews

6

Young_NachoDec 30, 2019

The characters? AIN'T IT. The storyline? AIN'T IT. The Action scenes and new planets? Aight, imma fvck wichu.

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

6

Rebecca31Dec 20, 2016

So here's a Star Wars movie that's not really a Star Wars movie. You get a whole bunch of new and dispensable characters most of which I've completely forgotten, a story that's missing the wow factor, a great soundtrack and a decent cast.So here's a Star Wars movie that's not really a Star Wars movie. You get a whole bunch of new and dispensable characters most of which I've completely forgotten, a story that's missing the wow factor, a great soundtrack and a decent cast. Don't get me wrong I didn't hate this movie, there was some scenes I thoroughly enjoyed and honestly most of them were towards the end. Yet overall I was a little underwhelmed but can take comfort in the fact that this is not the worst Star Wars movie you could watch.
However, let us not forget what this movie really is...a cash grab. A filler movie with some nice little bits of nostalgia to remind you that oh yes this IS a Star Wars movie. The inevitability of Disney owning Star Wars is we'll get a new movie every year and that might sound like a dream come true now but in the year 2040 with the 32nd Star Wars movie you'll wish you never heard the words Disney and Star Wars together. I'll recommend this because it's worth a watch once but if you're a Star Wars fan you'll go see this no matter what anyone says.… Expand

9 of 17 users found this helpful98

All this user's reviews

6

zappbrannigan23Jan 8, 2017

I hoped for more out of this film.

Negatives: Probably my biggest negative is the CGI for the pivotal actors faces (ones no longer with us). Their not being an actual persons face were obvious and poorly done. The first half of the movie isI hoped for more out of this film.

Negatives:
Probably my biggest negative is the CGI for the pivotal actors faces (ones no longer with us). Their not being an actual persons face were obvious and poorly done.
The first half of the movie is too slow
The character development not quite as good as it should be. 2 characters voices/words were very difficult to understand what they were saying.

Positives:
There were a lot of fun (albeit a bit simple) references and lead ins to past and future movies this one sits in between. Fans eat this stuff up and so did I.
The final 1/4 of the movie was very well done action/battle sequences in both space and ground.
The lead actress and her father were well casted and likable.
With a little more script and dialog polish this could have been much more flowing and stronger ties to the characters. I offer my revision/suggestion services to review any future movies for free.… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

6

nahtan1244Dec 28, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Warning MAJOR SPOILERS TURN BACK IF YOU MUST. I was VERY excited to see Rouge one as I am with any star wars movie. Star wars is a very Exciting franchise and each movie leaves you in anticipation of what may hold in the newest movie. Did Rouge one disappoint me? No It had some really good moments and some flaws too. After reading critic reviews and audience reviews alike I feel I am the only one brave enough to give this a 6. Let's get down to the bottom of this review shall we? So first of all I really liked the character of Jyn Erso. Her character was not only well fleshed out but we care about her as a person and her fight for justice after we witness her father die as he turns his back on the empire. The actor who played her father was fantastic as well as the person who played mother. Gareth Edwards perfectly balanced nostalgia and really good cgi. He and his team of animators did very well at replacing passed away characters with new actors who played their part very well such as General Tarkin. Characters such as Darth Vader and Carrie fisher were replaced with CGI models and voice archives of that character to fit the timeline as this took place around the same time a new hope did. The Robot K-2SO was probably my most favorite chacter he was so sassy, funny and all around liable and was clearly the comic relief and it worked very well. The last scene with Darth Vader as everyone has been making a big fuss about is as good as everyone has been making it out too be. The final battle was brilliant and added a sort of world war 2 vibe too it However this is were the positives end. First the person who plays Riz Ahmed is probably the weakest actor out of the bunch. Also the character of Saw Guerrera was kinda pointless and did not add much to his character or the story. You remember how we got a great backstory to make us care about the lead. Well that is nowhere too be found in the heroes pals. Donnie yen a blind solider who is part of Jyn's team of resistance fighters is fun too watch but he and Cassian are supposed to be friends but no good backstory is given to any of the characters except jyn which makes it hard for me too care about them when everyone expect jyn dies at the end. Which brings me to my next point. Nothing in this movie will surprise you. Now you may be thinking the robot never got any backstory why are you not giving him a hard time. The way the characters are set up the rebel fighters backstory is important as they are risking their lives to save humanity. They are not here too play the comic relief and are the main point of the story the robot is more of a side character. All in all their are many things too like about rouge one but the problems the plague it from being a great movie really keep it from being near perfect and are crucial if they wanted this to be a near perfect film.… Expand

1 of 7 users found this helpful16

All this user's reviews

6

AproxxAug 13, 2018

But this one is just nothing like Star Wars... and I liked it. Not at first. It took a while, but it was a good movie, not as dumb as I expected it to be

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

6

Burnouts3s3Dec 18, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Rogue One is an ambitious film that's constantly hindered by the Studio's interference. Gareth Edwards (Director of films such as the independent film, Monsters, and the 2014 reboot of Godzilla) emphasizes slow build-up, scale and a sense of melancholy in his works. Rogue One, for the most part, uses Gareth's natural inclinations and makes a film less like the optimistic A New Hope and more like the bleak Empire Strikes Back. The film centers on Jyn Erso, a daughter of an ex-Imperial engineer who designed the plans of the Death Star. When Jyn's father is captured by the Empire and Jyn's mother is killed, Jyn joins the Rebellion as a means of survival. Years later, Jyn grows up to a be a jaded cynic, turning herself away from the cause. However, when a hologram of her father reappears, Jyn joins up with the new Rebellion in hopes of finding her father.

Jyn joins up with a cast of rebels in order to fulfill her goal. Unfortunately, whether by mandate of the studio or Edwards himself, a majority of the cast doesn't receive the much needed character development needed to form a strong emotional connection to them. (I'm told that a prequel novel, Catalyst, details many of the backstories and origins of the side characters. As I recall, there used to be a time when movies had to stand alone and didn't require the aid of a peripheral novel to explain characters). The stand outs of the cast are Donnie Yen's Chirrut Îmwe, a believer in the Force who cannot wield it makes the people around him question his figurative and literal blind faith and Alan Tudyk's K-S2O, a reprogrammed Imperial droid that can't help but say what's on his mind. While neither character full develops, the actors imbue their roles with such personality, that when the possibility of "They will not come back from this mission" starts to sink in, you genuinely feel for their loss.

Rogue One ordered a number of reshoots during production. Unfortunately, many of the studio's re-shoots stick out. Just when I felt that Gareth Edwards was about to take the Star Wars movies in a different and original direction (such as in the peripheral media or even the now non-canon Star Wars Extended Universe, a series of tie-in novels, books and games deleted from continuity by mandate of Disney purchasing the Star Wars license), there's a random cameo or reference that feels so out of place that it literally took me out of the movie. For example, Jyn, early on, bumps into the two strangers Luke meets in Mos Eisley. While the cameo is fun, it does little to move the plot or the characters. Perhaps, it's a small universe after all.

And while I liked K-S2O's character, you can't help but feel every time he's in a scene, a humorous moment will be around the corner, effectively making him a comedic relief robot (I heard a poster refer to him as a Bazingabot).

As such, there are moments of tonal whiplash throughout the film. Just as the film is about to take a darker turn or a depressing outlook, a random cameo appears or K-S2O says something funny. Were these moments intended from the beginning or did the studio worry that the film was too bleak and ordered reshoots to make the affair lighthearted? We may never know what Gareth's original cut of the film would've differed from what we have now. That being said, the director takes bold risks and does things to the characters a lesser director wouldn't have done. That takes guts. Rogue One is enjoyable. It is worth seeing in the theater. But, when I hear audiences compare this to Empire Strikes Back, I really wish the narrative would've taken more risks and Edwards would've been free to do what he intended. As for now, I recommend seeing it at a Matinee.… Expand

2 of 8 users found this helpful26

All this user's reviews

6

UNARMED_JORDFeb 26, 2017

A very average anthology film that is not without some fantastic sequences such as action and emotional but overall Rogue One is a good action movie but a faltering Star wars one

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

6

Captain_ChaosJan 15, 2017

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. A visually amazing film with many, many treats for long-time fans of Star Wars, with a grittier, more human cast of characters marred by an unsatisfying conclusion. Killing off most of your principle cast is not good writing.… Expand

0 of 4 users found this helpful04

All this user's reviews

6

indigobeastJan 6, 2017

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. I was disappointed by this movie because the story was poorly written because I was very confused with what was actually going on so thinks were randomly happening to make the movie progress. Most of the characters were forgettable and didn't have anything special about them. The final sequence is what saved this movie in my opinion because the quality and imagination really shows here like this is when i started getting engaged in the movie. The only bad thing about the battle was the random deaths of all the big characters they happened too quickly between each other. Only see this movie if you're a die hard star wars fan as they would pretty much love this movie either way.… Expand

1 of 5 users found this helpful14

All this user's reviews

6

ThreeboxIndoorsDec 16, 2016

Rogue One: A Star Wars Story is about as flawed as it is entertaining. With almost documentary-like camerawork, this is the most handheld Star Wars film by far, offering a more grounded and realistic feel, but the dialogue can feel cheesy andRogue One: A Star Wars Story is about as flawed as it is entertaining. With almost documentary-like camerawork, this is the most handheld Star Wars film by far, offering a more grounded and realistic feel, but the dialogue can feel cheesy and cliche at times. Very well shot but also very imperfectly shot, this film looks flat-out gorgeous. The editing can be a little choppy at times though, but that isn’t anywhere near as distracting as the CGI version of Grand Moff Tarkin, as well as some other CGI characters. Which brings me to my biggest gripe - The characters. Likeable, funny, but that’s about it - They lack any depth, background, or proper development, and we aren’t given any reason to care for them. Director Orson Krennic is an extremely weak villain and doesn’t even compare to Darth Vader, who was only in TWO SCENES. This wouldn’t have been as much of a complaint if the rest of the characters were more interesting, but it still would’ve been a stupid choice. The first act of the movie is quite messy, and feels like a series of loosely tied together scenes, jumping from location to location too quick and repetitively. There isn’t really much else for me to say about the rest of the movie apart from the last act, which is a long if not too long action sequence, and although VERY entertaining and brilliantly directed, it has endless cliches and does get repetitive after awhile. Lacking any suspense that the previous Star Wars excelled at, this is a fun, decent ride with incredible effects but it is a very disappointing installment to the Star Wars franchise. I don’t see there being any replay value either. Rogue One: A Star Wars Story gets a 6 out of 10. It’s decent.… Expand

20 of 41 users found this helpful2021

All this user's reviews

6

dspratlinJan 3, 2017

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. What's it about?

It is a period of civil war. Rebel spaceships, striking from a hidden base, have won their first victory against the evil Galactic Empire. During the battle, Rebel spies managed to steal secret plans to the Empire's ultimate weapon, the DEATH STAR, an armored space station with enough power to destroy an entire planet. This is their story. What did I think?

Where Return of the Jedi was a let-down due to "alleged" toy company requirements, Rogue One seems a let-down by a meddling committee. Too many cooks dilute a terrific premise and muddy great characters thanks to an overly-convoluted introduction and dollops of unnecessary spoon-feeding.

But make sure you see it on the big screen for the final battle sequence - it's basically a 21st-century version of the ROTJ final act.

Epilogue: If you recall, we all loved Star Wars for George's ground-breaking "used universe" and the mythical unanswered questions (Jedi, Clone Wars, why there is no underwear in space). Edwards delivers a gloriously dirty reality, but the committee let the movie down by interrupting him and providing us with too many answers to questions we didn't ask. A Star Wars movie doesn't require title cards to tell the audience where we are, that's part of the charm. Drop us in and let us swim!… Expand

2 of 4 users found this helpful22

All this user's reviews

6

Dr_Shooter24Dec 26, 2016

The problem of Rogue One is not the technical part, which is compelling and incredible, but the lack of interest that produces either the plot and the characters. I understand to be amusing for those who are huge fans of the saga, but for me,The problem of Rogue One is not the technical part, which is compelling and incredible, but the lack of interest that produces either the plot and the characters. I understand to be amusing for those who are huge fans of the saga, but for me, there is no story to tell, and that, for a presigious name like Star Wars is something inadmisible. And let´s be honest, Felicity Jones doesn´t have any charisma.… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

6

JorgeLestreJan 12, 2017

Although it has great visuals and a very amusing new android, Rogue One doesn't quite achieve the instant connection to the main characters, even though fans will enjoy the visual bonanza.

1 of 5 users found this helpful14

All this user's reviews

6

TrevorsViewDec 16, 2016

Okay, so the first spinoff of the immortal Star Wars saga has finally hit theaters, but how does it compare to the rest? Well, it’s miles ahead of those embarrassing prequels (no surprise), but Rogue One: A Star Wars Story just can’t competeOkay, so the first spinoff of the immortal Star Wars saga has finally hit theaters, but how does it compare to the rest? Well, it’s miles ahead of those embarrassing prequels (no surprise), but Rogue One: A Star Wars Story just can’t compete with the originals, or The Force Awakens.

As I’m sure you’ve heard, there’s no opening crawl or John Williams score this time, just a silent view of space with a single planet. Everything else from here is an X-wing flight of an experience you’d expect from a Star Wars movie, including booming sound effects and AT-AT walkers that look as epic as ever. There’s an appropriate mix of practical sets and good CGI to create all sorts of new settings, including a tropical planet and a claustrophobic prison. It’s got all the checklist requirements to make a good Star Wars movie, but there’s something missing.

Basically, without giving anything away, the Death Star is in its finishing stages of development, and war zones land on all areas of conspiracy against the weapon, the strife of war affects the lowest of the low in the galaxy. But we are introduced to the struggle on a rock and moss planet that houses a small family of farmers. The father is forcefully invited to join the Empire, along with his wife and daughter. He is soon taken away, and the little girl manages to escape, only to be transported place to place by an Imperial prison as an adult.

Now, she ends up with the Rebel Alliance so that she can be this movie’s “feminist protagonist” in helping steal the plans to the Death Star, and also to see her father again. You know how it all goes from here.

The problem I had with this movie is not just in how we already know how it will end before it even begins, but in the excessive use of characters with so little humanity I cannot connect with a single one of them.

Think of it this way: you remember how in The Force Awakens we saw a detailed introduction to Rey that showed us what her day-to-day life on Jakku was like? Remember the clear backstory given to Finn and how that motivated his actions? Here, none of the new characters have any of that. Jyn’s not motivated enough to fight for what she has lost, as we never know what her relationship with her father was ever like. Then she starts to cry over this inner pain, and let me tell you: Felicity Jones (Like Crazy, The Theory of Everything) is not skilled in making crocodile tears. Her story just moves by too quickly to balance a feel of hope with letting us feel for her.

Everyone else around her is just a plot device. While Forest Whitaker’s (The Butler, The Last King of Scotland) new cyborg character has a sympathetic redemption story screaming to get out, the poor performance of the man behind the mask just doesn’t land. Then there’s the cameos of characters from the original trilogy. Remember how the appearances of older characters in The Force Awakens actually advanced the emotional story and improved your appreciation of the originals? This does none of that. Darth Vader does appear as epic as ever, but he just comes to explain the plot, and leaves, only to make one more brief appearance. There are a couple of others from the originals who appear, but none of them are very satisfying or necessary. Although there was one cameo that just blew my mind, making me go, “Whoa! How did the visual effects crew make that possible?!”

But there is a god, strong saving grace though: one of the new characters proves to be strong with the force, despite it being a time when the force is thought of as an ancient religion. He’s also blind, and an epic master of hand-to-hand combat. Let me tell you: he gets a moment to shine in his fight against a gaggle of Stormtroopers, and it’s the most amazing thing ever.

So is Rogue One: A Star Wars Story the spinoff to the saga we all hoped for? Not exactly. It’s a satisfactory action flick if you’re willing not to think too hard about it as high art. But if you are looking for the essential Star Wars experience that surpasses all of your expectations, you might end up disappointed.… Expand

6 of 24 users found this helpful618

All this user's reviews

6

Thatonenerd2187Dec 21, 2016

Star wars rouge one to me is dissipating, not as a film, but as a star wars movie. The special effects, action scenes, and overall filmmaking is solid. The one problem with this movie is the characters. Their not that memorable and don't haveStar wars rouge one to me is dissipating, not as a film, but as a star wars movie. The special effects, action scenes, and overall filmmaking is solid. The one problem with this movie is the characters. Their not that memorable and don't have much development. Plus the acting isn't bad, it's just o.k.… Expand

2 of 9 users found this helpful27

All this user's reviews

6

Biggs364Dec 18, 2016

Stars Wars fanatic since summer of 77, with a few disappointments along the way. (Episodes 1 &7) This one gives me mixed feelings. On the bad side: No crawl. No John Williams except a few 8 bar licks pasted in here and there. The beginningStars Wars fanatic since summer of 77, with a few disappointments along the way. (Episodes 1 &7) This one gives me mixed feelings. On the bad side: No crawl. No John Williams except a few 8 bar licks pasted in here and there. The beginning compresses about 5 minutes worth of plot into 90 minutes and despite the intermittent heavy duty action sequences, seemed somewhat boring. My bored-o-meter is usually rated on how many times I look at my watch during the film- more than once and its a dog, but I actually fell asleep (worse than looking at my watch) for about 90 seconds about 1 hour into this one! I didn't miss much.
Now for the good: Fundamentally, this movie is based on one line from what we now call "A New Hope". DV: "Several transmissions were beamed to this ship by rebel spies." The last 45 minutes gets around to this and it is a real thrill ride, ending with the perfect segue into Episode 4. Amidst the drama/action there are all the usual Star Wars things we have come to love- desperate space battles, impenetrable shields, storm troopers, AT-ATs, the Death Star, Vader at his darkest, and Episode 4 cameos left and right. I was totally satisfied with this ending. Too bad the beginning was so tedious.… Expand

3 of 8 users found this helpful35

All this user's reviews

6

johnny5aliveDec 18, 2016

Not good. Lazy and overdone fan service. Vader casting was bad as he's not big/imposing enough. Tried to shoehorn diversity for the sake of making marketing people at Disney happy. The score was meh. The actual story/screenplay was justNot good. Lazy and overdone fan service. Vader casting was bad as he's not big/imposing enough. Tried to shoehorn diversity for the sake of making marketing people at Disney happy. The score was meh. The actual story/screenplay was just boring with poor banter and acting. The CGI for Tarkin and Leia was bad. Just stop. No need for that Leia scene. No excuse for them to not just cast a look alike. Locations jumped around way too much in the beginning. Zero chance a stormtrooper could not track Jyn to the rock inside the cave seeing as the ground is dirt and her footprints would have literally led them to her. This is a movie a Marvel fanboy eats up. Loud, bright colors, corny one-liners. I'm going to obviously watch it a second time and it's possible it might improve. Highly doubtful though. If so, a 7 is the highest I could go.… Expand

2 of 4 users found this helpful22

All this user's reviews

6

GrievanDec 22, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. This film is either being utterly praised or wrongfully bashed, but I think it's a good movie filled with some flaws, the great thing about Star Wars movies are the characters, the emotional bound you make as a spectator with them, the tragic story of Darth Vader, Han Solo, Luke, you get a sense of their motivations, their background, that made you feel bad with their death. Rogue one doesn't seem to manage that well, the characters seem to lack development.

Another thing that is a negative for this movie is the CGI Tarkin, it's very good, almost flawless, but still, the CGI is distracting, and you could always tell that it was not a human there, you could have Guy Henry with practical make up, it would have a better effect than all the CGI in the world, or have him replaced by Vader since he could fill that role well.

It was a great adventure movie, but still what I love about Star Wars, besides the Sci-Fi setting, the lightsabers, Sith vs Jedi, are the characters, and if you don't make me care about them that's just sloppy writting.… Expand

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

6

Rpk_Dec 22, 2016

I have Rogue One a 60 score and here's why:

The purposely restrained tone and dourness of Rogue One was a real drag. At two hours running time where you go in expecting a high energy action movie this is not a good thing. It felt like R1 wasI have Rogue One a 60 score and here's why:

The purposely restrained tone and dourness of Rogue One was a real drag. At two hours running time where you go in expecting a high energy action movie this is not a good thing. It felt like R1 was trying to be more Blade Runner than Star Wars, except without the intelligence, cast, and superior craftsmanship. I understand Rogue One is set during a time of war, but SW has always been able to attack serious issues without losing its lighthearted soul.… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

6

ericrosarDec 28, 2016

While the movie has great visual effects, cinematography, and fan service (a lot), all these replaced character depth and a compelling story. Even episode VII had more relateable new characters. These were here just to advance a plot (aWhile the movie has great visual effects, cinematography, and fan service (a lot), all these replaced character depth and a compelling story. Even episode VII had more relateable new characters. These were here just to advance a plot (a simple plot). The first 30 to 45 mins is pretty slow (and I don't mind slow if character depth is being provided/not the case), then we get to some great action which overstays its welcome by 20 mins.… Expand

4 of 9 users found this helpful45

All this user's reviews

6

tobisanJan 3, 2017

I have mixed feelings with this movie. Love the way it connects to the original trilogy and it had great action sequences, but the characters were poorly developed and it seems to be an unnecesary story to tell.

4 of 9 users found this helpful45

All this user's reviews

6

sensorglitchJan 9, 2017

This was a good movie. However, when I compare it to other movies in the franchise I can't help but think of it as maybe the 6th best movie in the franchise? It's hard to give a movie a high rating based on that.

1 of 5 users found this helpful14

All this user's reviews

6

berserkoidJan 15, 2017

Well in a nutshell I thought the first half of the movie was boring and unnecessary. The new characters were not very captivating, especially that re-programmed Imperial droid. It got interesting for me from when they proceeded to land on theWell in a nutshell I thought the first half of the movie was boring and unnecessary. The new characters were not very captivating, especially that re-programmed Imperial droid. It got interesting for me from when they proceeded to land on the tropical moon to get the plans, although that whole deal was incredibly similar the Endor landing scenes from Return of the Jedi. I was almost waiting for new-age tropical Ewoks to appear and help the rebels - glad that didn't happen! I did like how the very end tied-in to right before A New Hope begins. Much better than Force Awakens. 6.5 out of 10 for me.… Expand

0 of 4 users found this helpful04

All this user's reviews

6

paychickJan 15, 2017

Bad CGI. I just can't get past (or forgive) that. Do not, I repeat, do not attempt to bring back actors from the dead by giving them dead-eyed impostors. Ug.

The movie might have been fantastic had it been released before "The ForceBad CGI. I just can't get past (or forgive) that. Do not, I repeat, do not attempt to bring back actors from the dead by giving them dead-eyed impostors. Ug.

The movie might have been fantastic had it been released before "The Force Awakens" but I'm so tired of the Death Star that it felt stale and a rip off of itself.… Expand

0 of 4 users found this helpful04

All this user's reviews

6

josei1985Mar 13, 2017

Una película que hasta que no llega a su final puede llegar a resultar algo tediosa. Más orientada a seguir exprimiendo una saga mítica. Cómo enlaza los últimos minutos del filme con el episodio IV la hace interesante como prólogo a laUna película que hasta que no llega a su final puede llegar a resultar algo tediosa. Más orientada a seguir exprimiendo una saga mítica. Cómo enlaza los últimos minutos del filme con el episodio IV la hace interesante como prólogo a la primera trilogía.… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

6

Benkoko11Feb 23, 2017

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Watching Darth Vadar massacre a couple dozen rebel soldiers was a hugely satisfying moment of badassery in what was otherwise a jumble of safely clichéd and predictable mediocrity.… Expand

4 of 8 users found this helpful44

All this user's reviews

6

StormSentryMar 28, 2017

It follows the same story routine as other Star Wars movies. There are many illogical moments... or overcomplicated. It is hard to relate to the cast.
Nonetheless it is visually stunning and mildly entertaining.

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

6

SonicHD7Jun 1, 2017

Former scientist Galen Erso lives on a farm with his wife and young daughter, Jyn. His peaceful existence comes crashing down when the evil Orson Krennic takes him away from his beloved family. Many years later, Galen becomes the Empire'sFormer scientist Galen Erso lives on a farm with his wife and young daughter, Jyn. His peaceful existence comes crashing down when the evil Orson Krennic takes him away from his beloved family. Many years later, Galen becomes the Empire's lead engineer for the most powerful weapon in the galaxy, the Death Star. Knowing that her father holds the key to its destruction, Jyn joins forces with a spy and other resistance fighters to steal the space station's plans for the Rebel Alliance.… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

6

mrdr4gonDec 15, 2017

Uneven in places, but this does the job for the most part. There's a few stretches were little happens that get a little irritating but the film as a whole is more or less effective. The atmosphere in the film is especially effective.

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

6

gtwistNov 26, 2017

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Rogue One was not a bad movie, but was a Star Wars movie that I never really want to see again, and that's not something I should be saying. I'm not a Star Wars hater. I quite liked The Force Awakens, and is one of the few people who disagree with the opinion that it's too much like A New Hope. Rogue One was devoid of any good characters, and that's really disappointing. I can't even remember the name of the main character. These bland characters cause me to not care in the slightest when they died. I only cared when the robot died because so don't need to give a robot character development. You can't blame the director for this, because of things he has said in interview. That being said, the action scenes are cool, and the CGI was good. Darth Vader was awesome, and I liked how the tied it directly into the beginning of A New Hope.… Expand

0 of 2 users found this helpful02

All this user's reviews

6

spacebear1Dec 11, 2017

Rogue One: A Star Wars Story is a film that I loved on the first viewing but thought was just...ok on the second and third. The character setup was too rushed and some of the characters just felt expendable. But I did like the villain,Rogue One: A Star Wars Story is a film that I loved on the first viewing but thought was just...ok on the second and third. The character setup was too rushed and some of the characters just felt expendable. But I did like the villain, Director Krennic. Overall, this isn't a bad movie, just rushed. My rating would be 6.9/10… Expand

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

6

mateverywhereDec 31, 2017

Fun, and some of the best Star Wars battle scenes put to film, but incredibly linear storytelling. The protagonist is ultra-passive, and while I like her, everything happens to her rather than because of her - so it makes it hard to careFun, and some of the best Star Wars battle scenes put to film, but incredibly linear storytelling. The protagonist is ultra-passive, and while I like her, everything happens to her rather than because of her - so it makes it hard to care about her fate. The same could be said for everyone in the film, which takes a great concept and focusses more on the safety of fan service than being daring… Expand

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

6

Jaredc324May 15, 2019

Rogue One is better off and more relative in being a 30-minute intro-setup movie for A New Hope and the rest of the original 3 Star Wars movies. But as a movie all its own, as the Star Wars Story it's meant to be, it does fall a tad short onRogue One is better off and more relative in being a 30-minute intro-setup movie for A New Hope and the rest of the original 3 Star Wars movies. But as a movie all its own, as the Star Wars Story it's meant to be, it does fall a tad short on what could've been a very interesting solo Star Wars tale. It's intentions are good, it's build-up is strong, but the movie lacks focus or coherence for the first hour or so. But once our characters begin to set out on the mission of their lives, the gears amp up and so does the emotion. Rogue One goes out like some beautifully tragic pre-movie to a video game, in the most epic fashion imaginable. Including an escape sequence involving an iconic character, that's made to shock your nerves. But outside of it's final lap, Rogue One doesn't really have that appeal or rewatchable quality to it you'd think it'd easily have. Only for its send-off experience, but the movie as a whole as a story, and as an experience is all about the ending and not so much about it's foundation.… Expand

1 of 1 users found this helpful10

All this user's reviews

6

wuduuuuup123Jan 18, 2018

a perfect meh movie it i a depressing watch although some of the camera shots were pretty breathtaking it is not up to par with other Star wars movies (wel at least with the O.G and new trilogies) so if you are a fan of cinema maybe just skipa perfect meh movie it i a depressing watch although some of the camera shots were pretty breathtaking it is not up to par with other Star wars movies (wel at least with the O.G and new trilogies) so if you are a fan of cinema maybe just skip this one...… Expand

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

6

ArquireJan 16, 2018

The movie was interesting, visually great with some great action. However, it falls flat to me because the characters were lacking. The movie did very little to help me care for any of the main characters. By the end, I didn't really careThe movie was interesting, visually great with some great action. However, it falls flat to me because the characters were lacking. The movie did very little to help me care for any of the main characters. By the end, I didn't really care about the fate of the protagonists.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

6

LoletinAlexisApr 25, 2019

Rogue One: A Star Wars Story is a film that has the spirit of the classic movies, but that lacks something to be magnificent.

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

6

AMasterpieceFanJan 5, 2019

Its a decent movie but like others say, it can cause you to sleep at times, especially at the first parts. The plot is simplistic, not a good thing but not bad either.The characters....well...meh. Overall its fine.

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

6

WapitikevMar 11, 2019

The best Star Wars movie by Disney-Lucasfilm by a wide margin. The scenes with Vader, though unnecessary to the film, are well done and respectful to the character. CGI Leia was pretty cringy. CGI Tarkin was acceptable. The male and femaleThe best Star Wars movie by Disney-Lucasfilm by a wide margin. The scenes with Vader, though unnecessary to the film, are well done and respectful to the character. CGI Leia was pretty cringy. CGI Tarkin was acceptable. The male and female leads are unlikable characters doing the right thing. The droid and the two priests of "The Religion of the Force" were the best parts of this movie.… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

6

TEMP0May 30, 2020

I really like how Gareth Edwards wants to make a Spin Off to celebrate something that takes place within the Skywalker Saga to create even more plot holes. It didn't bring the joy I wanted compared to other Star Wars movies, but I just feelI really like how Gareth Edwards wants to make a Spin Off to celebrate something that takes place within the Skywalker Saga to create even more plot holes. It didn't bring the joy I wanted compared to other Star Wars movies, but I just feel that I only liked the last 15 minutes of the movie. Everything else was forgettable and boring.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

6

pur__0_0__Jul 10, 2021

I didn't know about the Star Wars anthology movies until I learnt about Solo. I didn't know anything about it, so I went in completely blind. The only thing I knew about this movie is the Darth Vader scene, and I thought if it has that scene,I didn't know about the Star Wars anthology movies until I learnt about Solo. I didn't know anything about it, so I went in completely blind. The only thing I knew about this movie is the Darth Vader scene, and I thought if it has that scene, it must be having plenty such scenes. Turns out that scene is to this movie what Flash and Superman's slow motion fight is to Josstice League: The only one good scene in the entire movie. Most of this movie is just talking, talking and more talking.
I won't complain about it though. I didn't know the "We were on the verge of greatness" meme was from this. I used to think that meme is about an agriculture scientist from Discovery telling how his experiment failed. So subsequently the "Are we blind? Deploy the troops!" meme also had to be from here, another one I didn't know where it was from. I ended up liking K2SO, he was my favourite character from the movie. I felt really bad seeing him die.
The action scenes of this movie are very good, now that I think back about it, especially the one with the blind Jedi. The scene where a droid that looked like H2SO gets shot and then the actual H2SO comes from the back saying, "I hope you knew it was not me." was hilarious. But that's the only scene I remember, other than the Darth Vader scene of course. Most of the scenes from this movie are very forgettable. Out of the over 2 hour of runtime, I only remember barely 2 minutes from it combined.
I don't see the point behind the making of this movie. It just answers a question nobody asked. I wasn't even paying attention because I was waiting for the Darth Vader scene, as I had begun thinking it isn't in this movie until the very end. I could definitely give it a rewatch whenever I get a Disney+ Hotstar connection, but that's really far from today.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

6

MaddoxWhiteApr 25, 2021

Weird. Different. Not really in a good way, though. Forgettable characters, not as fun as the others.

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

6

PeteyPirahnaFeb 6, 2022

6.5/10
My opinions on this movie change like the tide. I think I like it. I guess.

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

6

MikhailSoloJan 18, 2022

The first spin-off movie.Better than new episodes, but still a lot of nonsense.Stupid imperials who don't look after the person who is responsible for the development of the Death Star.The father of the main character who made a weakThe first spin-off movie.Better than new episodes, but still a lot of nonsense.Stupid imperials who don't look after the person who is responsible for the development of the Death Star.The father of the main character who made a weak spot.Which only a Jedi can destroy.And so the film is not so much boring, but watchable.The pros are the witty droid K-2SO.Darth Vader.That means that the legendary villain appeared for 4-5 minutes, great power is felt in him.Unlike the **** Kyle Ren.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

6

GDsReviewsJul 9, 2022

Honestly the only decent Star Wars movie to come out since Disney bought Lucasfilm in 2012.

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

6

bjmetacriticJun 16, 2022

This film managed to do some things well. The tone and atmosphere of the film felt like Star Wars, and the action war great. Unfortunately, like the sequel trilogy, the potholes and head-scratching story choices left a nagging feeling thatThis film managed to do some things well. The tone and atmosphere of the film felt like Star Wars, and the action war great. Unfortunately, like the sequel trilogy, the potholes and head-scratching story choices left a nagging feeling that prevented me from enjoying it fully.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

6

FionanMurphyAug 14, 2022

Whilist not a terrible movie, i feel its a boring and not engaging movie compared to Force Awakens or Last Jedi

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

5

A7sus4Dec 24, 2016

Sure, it was well produced, but frankly, this movie, while competent, was boring. The soundtrack was lousy, the characters were barely interesting to start and completely unmemorable by the end. It added absolutely nothing to the Star WarsSure, it was well produced, but frankly, this movie, while competent, was boring. The soundtrack was lousy, the characters were barely interesting to start and completely unmemorable by the end. It added absolutely nothing to the Star Wars universe. A total waste of time and money.… Expand

1 of 5 users found this helpful14

All this user's reviews

5

Mantis10Dec 28, 2016

This movie was exactly what I thought, nothing more nothing less. Nothing remotely interesting or clever about it. Just a long drawn out plot that probably could have been a really neat 1 hour short story. Zero attachment to the charactersThis movie was exactly what I thought, nothing more nothing less. Nothing remotely interesting or clever about it. Just a long drawn out plot that probably could have been a really neat 1 hour short story. Zero attachment to the characters and generally uninteresting people... Though Chirrut was sort of neat. That being said the movie looked good, plot holes were filled nicely, and the little bit of comedy was fun. Again, probably would have loved it if it was a 1 hour short created only to feed into A New Hope.… Expand

0 of 2 users found this helpful02

All this user's reviews

5

mintloDec 19, 2016

I didn't like it. I enjoyed Star Wars 7, and the original three. It seems like they were in a rush to make a Star Wars movie and just slapped a script together. Also too loud, way too much score and not enough pauses without music to takeI didn't like it. I enjoyed Star Wars 7, and the original three. It seems like they were in a rush to make a Star Wars movie and just slapped a script together. Also too loud, way too much score and not enough pauses without music to take in the subtle star wars sounds. Too much exposition as well. I get this was targeted at the kids but even though the original Star Wars is more mature I loved it as a kid. Disney, please don't be in such a rush to recoup your 4 billion dollars that you release sub par Star Wars films.… Expand

3 of 7 users found this helpful34

All this user's reviews

5

TyranianApr 13, 2019

Could not care less about the story and the characters are utterly uninteresting. Looks good though.

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

5

DodgerNov 9, 2018

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Mediocre at best.

This film is better than the main line Disney Star Wars films, but if we're honest with ourselves that not saying much.

The storyline is dull and predictable, the acting is passable and the visual effects are good.

My biggest gripe with the film is the way the "bad guys" (the Empire) are portrayed. Instead of the Heroes overcoming incredible odds against a tough enemy, but ultimately being victorious, the Empire is this film are instead bumbling morons who consistantly either do nothing or act to directly thwart their own plans. The best example of this is when the fleet turns up around the data core planet, the Rebels quite literaly could not have won if the Empire fleet had not turned up and ruined everything!

Also the blind monk on the beach scene... to quote Han Solo "thats not how the force works!"

The biggest saving grace of this film is the final scene on Tantive IV with Darth Vader. Possibly one of the best action sequences set to film and providing a clever and much needed tie in to the original trilogy.

Although by no means a must watch, if you find yourself at a loose end there are certainly worse things you can watch.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

5

IxamJan 5, 2017

It's a standard action film set in the Star War's universe. If that sounds like your cup of tea, then go see it and enjoy. A team of underdeveloped characters team up to accomplish a mission, this time with tie fighters and x-wings! The filmIt's a standard action film set in the Star War's universe. If that sounds like your cup of tea, then go see it and enjoy. A team of underdeveloped characters team up to accomplish a mission, this time with tie fighters and x-wings! The film lacks the charm of the better action films (and the original trilogy), and outside of the action sequences was pretty dull. The action sequences were pretty phenomenal, and redeem the movie to an extent. I hope Disney learns from their mistakes and includes more compelling/likeable characters in following films.… Expand

3 of 7 users found this helpful34

All this user's reviews

5

ReubenIsAGodDec 18, 2016

Plain. Idk man. I can hardly remember this film. It hasn't stuck with me. The characters were dull. Lifeless and uninspired. It just felt, idk, flat and bland. Kinda like white bread. It does the job, but eh, it's not very filling.

1 of 7 users found this helpful16

All this user's reviews

5

jonnxDec 28, 2016

Great visuals, sound and all that, but if you are not a Star Wars fan, what does it offers? Unfortunately not much. To me, it felt like Disney milking another franchise. It was too long and boring at moments, acting not great, story not thatGreat visuals, sound and all that, but if you are not a Star Wars fan, what does it offers? Unfortunately not much. To me, it felt like Disney milking another franchise. It was too long and boring at moments, acting not great, story not that interesting etc.

I would very much prefer some modern adaptation, without the classic costumes, props and sets. That would be much harder and riskier to make, but there would be chance of making actually great movie.… Expand

4 of 9 users found this helpful45

All this user's reviews

5

FortifierDec 31, 2016

This edition to the Star Wars cinematic universe felt a lot to me like "Suicide Squad"; great fan service and cool cast, but is ultimately empty due to undeveloped story and characters. Most Star Wars films begin with two protagonists, thenThis edition to the Star Wars cinematic universe felt a lot to me like "Suicide Squad"; great fan service and cool cast, but is ultimately empty due to undeveloped story and characters. Most Star Wars films begin with two protagonists, then as they journey throughout the galaxy we learn more about them as well as the world around them and the story itself. Then eventually the "torch" is passed down to two new characters who we follow as the story continues.

In short, the previous Star Wars films accomplished beautiful character, plot and world development at the exact same time. In "Rogue One", however, the "torch" is thrown around rapidly as the characters sit in a circle like a game of "hot potato". There is little to no character development, we're thrown around all over the place in the Star Wars universe, and the writers leave absolutely no time for its audience to emotionally invest in the story or characters (which is extremely disappointing for not only a Star Wars film, but for a film that is over TWO HOURS LONG).

This is what its like for the first two-thirds of the film; while there is a lot of fan service to go around (which is expected from this film), the story and character development is simply atrocious. The third and final act, however, is what saves this movie from being an utter waste of time. This is when the action and threat becomes real and the characters finally come to life. If this film was just the final 40 minutes I would actually give this film a much higher rating.

In conclusion, this series relies far more on fan-service of an already established Star Wars universe to please its audience rather than an actual (never mind "original") story. Believe me when I say that, unless you are an absolute die-hard fan of the Star Wars franchise, you're better off simply re-watching the Original Trilogy if you want to watch Star Wars again.

5/10… Expand

5 of 10 users found this helpful55

All this user's reviews

5

Castian77Dec 23, 2016

Over all the movie was good, but i could not handle the main heroine.
I can bet the movie could've done much better without her, she is at the center of everything, doing just exposure commentary, much like if she was not there at all.
TheOver all the movie was good, but i could not handle the main heroine.
I can bet the movie could've done much better without her, she is at the center of everything, doing just exposure commentary, much like if she was not there at all.
The better, established lore-rich characters were underdeveloped or changed to catter to this tasteless heroine.
See the movie again, imagine the scenes without her, you'll see, the movie not only does not change much, but any change is for the better.
This was more a war movie in a star wars themed world, ratehr a Star Wars classic movie, and that was good.

Gotta say, Disney sure wants to press the " Disney princesses" even to star wars to the point of nearly ruining the plot of the movies.… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

5

BadAidsDec 22, 2016

In a year where Hollywood has failed to deliver, the stage was set for Rogue One to steal the show, unfortunately that was not the case. Instead, Gareth Edwards gave us a Star Wars rendition that, while looking absolutely stunning, lacks anyIn a year where Hollywood has failed to deliver, the stage was set for Rogue One to steal the show, unfortunately that was not the case. Instead, Gareth Edwards gave us a Star Wars rendition that, while looking absolutely stunning, lacks any character and depth.
Despite on the service being a movie that is, arguably, visually superior to The Force Awakens, Rogue One offers little more than fan-service and leaves no lasting effects for audience members that have yet to be indoctrinated into this Lucas/Disney cult. What went wrong?
One of the most significant flaws of Rogue One is its protagonist, Jyn Erso (Felicity Jones). Jones' performance is utterly bland, especially when compared to last years predecessor Daisy Ridley, and she serves as more of a reference point for the audience instead of the charismatic leader that this film needed.
Very little motivation for Jones, as well as the rest of the cliched ensemble, means that it becomes difficult for the audience to get invested in what was actually quite an enjoyable and acion-packed final act.
This is a problem that I believe persists throughout Gareth Edward's filmography, most notably Godzilla (2014). While all his films do look visually stunning, he has yet to master the art of character development and when considering Rogue One's quite standard heist plot, the lack of engaging characters does mean that the film suffers heavily.
Although I enjoy Episodes 4-7, I am far from a Star Wars buff but I can appreciate the level of fan service that Rogue One contains and I can understand why fanatics seem to enjoy this film. However, the persisting thought I have about this film is; why was this made? Of course it whets the appetites of those eager for Episode 8 but Rogue One leaves no enduring moments for the Star Wars universe and with the rich history and depth of the Star Wars canon, it is a shame that this films biggest achievement is being better than the prequels. As it turns out, that's not a very difficult task.… Expand

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

5

OctomortDec 24, 2016

they made 200 mill on it in first two weeks so obviously it is a good film. The only likable character who had that Star wars rebel personality of determined optimism, with that touch of charming naivety, was the droid, even Mon Mothma was athey made 200 mill on it in first two weeks so obviously it is a good film. The only likable character who had that Star wars rebel personality of determined optimism, with that touch of charming naivety, was the droid, even Mon Mothma was a whinger (yes USA it is a real word it means whiny B**** but you can say it in front of your mum). All that matters is the box office and the opinions of the corporate lovers on this site who always seem to vote a product 9 or 10, maybe an eight if it poisons their grandmother. My comments are meant to reflect the tone of the film, jaded and depressive!… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

5

hcliffedDec 16, 2016

Not good, not horrible. Episode III.9 basically; filler with characters no one ever gets to know well enough to get attached to, I felt this movie was slow and emotionless.

Michael Giaccino kinda spit all over Williams with his sub-par score, too.

12 of 26 users found this helpful1214

All this user's reviews

5

DrSikoDec 27, 2016

Oh boy how fanboys can be blind for such tedious, atrocious and lazy movie such this. It's so cliche, so predicted, like I don't even need to check the 'spoilers' box because it's too obvious and mainstream. Seems fanboys only want to watchOh boy how fanboys can be blind for such tedious, atrocious and lazy movie such this. It's so cliche, so predicted, like I don't even need to check the 'spoilers' box because it's too obvious and mainstream. Seems fanboys only want to watch clowns wearing star trooper outfits so they can jerk off on any movie. The "3D" effects are non-existent, I took off and on my glasses multiple times in the movie, it's almost like 2D but the blurriness in some scenes. My gf and I started yawning after 30 minutes from boredom (we finished our popcorn by that time). We felt asleep unless a big explosion or a light strike hits us in the face after about 20 minutes of dim scenes so it wakes us up. We couldn't know how to pass time, we started laughing at the 'fight scenes' and cuddling. We almost got tired and the movie can't finish. No wonder the stage was almost empty I expected not to find any tickets when I came to the movies, but because there was nothing interested to watch. Seems we are going to have the same lame movie again and again every year because fanboys will jerk to anything 'Star warsy'.

And what about the female protagonist thing nowadays? Her staged and weak performance was nothing compared to Daisy Ridley, or now SJWs are controlling everything?

Oh sorry, 'gf' means girlfriend. I know SW fanboys won't understand such shortcut. No wonder, jerking off to Darth Vader's ugly mask makes them sexodus.… Expand

0 of 4 users found this helpful04

All this user's reviews

5

MadMaxFuryRoadJan 21, 2017

So unfortunately Rogue Onewasn't as good as Star Wars: The Force Awakens...
Rogue One was a movie in which my family kinda dragged me to see, since I'm not a Star Wars fan. The film was a bit long and the plot was cliched, but some actionSo unfortunately Rogue Onewasn't as good as Star Wars: The Force Awakens...
Rogue One was a movie in which my family kinda dragged me to see, since I'm not a Star Wars fan. The film was a bit long and the plot was cliched, but some action scenes were pretty good. I don't know if this is just because I'm not into Star Wars. (50/100)… Expand

0 of 4 users found this helpful04

All this user's reviews

5

spencieMar 15, 2018

The worst Star Wars movie since Revenge of the Sith, Rogue One is a bland, uninteresting movie with dull characters and a boring story. Yes, the visuals and action are great, but that's not what makes a great movie. The Star Wars franchise isThe worst Star Wars movie since Revenge of the Sith, Rogue One is a bland, uninteresting movie with dull characters and a boring story. Yes, the visuals and action are great, but that's not what makes a great movie. The Star Wars franchise is losing it's steam once again. They need to make something new, this is just fan service.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

5

ilushkaDec 30, 2016

I do not delivered as much excitement as any other film of the saga. Good play from Galen Erso and K-2SO. Other actors was bad. Movie is good as a cameo-film, like new ghostbusters.

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

5

mace8704Dec 28, 2016

Dark, depressing, and mature. For better and for worse, this is arguably the least 'fun' I've had with a Star Wars film. The first entry in the anthology series creates a darker tone intended for older audiences hoping to have their nostalgiaDark, depressing, and mature. For better and for worse, this is arguably the least 'fun' I've had with a Star Wars film. The first entry in the anthology series creates a darker tone intended for older audiences hoping to have their nostalgia itch scratched as opposed to younger audiences hoping for an upbeat and fresh narrative. Personally, I'm in the camp that thinks Star Wars is currently in a state of narrative stagnation. We've seen the death star multiple times with both Lucas and Abrams. We've seen the orphan narrative with Luke, Rey, and now Erso. We've seen the comedic droid with C3P0, R2-D2, BB-8, and now K-2S0. It gave me an odd feeling of deja vu. Haven’t I seen this movie before? It’s indicative of either a concerning lack of creativity, or a fear of experimentation due to the sacred cow status of the Star Wars franchise. Rent if you’re a fan of the original trilogy. Avoid if not.… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

5

ThibaultVDec 25, 2016

The movie highly differs from Director's original version, and has been destroyed by Disney wanting to re-shot a lot of parts of it at the last moment.

0 of 3 users found this helpful03

All this user's reviews

5

LockeJohnJan 21, 2017

It's an OK movie, with some great scenes. As a whole the movie is a mess, with weak story. The acting is great but the characters aren't very interesting. The villain is weak as a character, even though the acting is good.

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

5

JodleMay 19, 2017

This movie is femninist and SJW propaganda and feminism is destroying Star Wars...
I m really disapointed where Star wars movies are going.

4 of 9 users found this helpful45

All this user's reviews

5

piercoDec 16, 2016

People who are voting this awful, boring, mishmash of a movie 10 realy need their heads examined. I now understand why the likes of Trump can manipulate people to vote for him. Whay a world of Idiocy we live in.

5 of 19 users found this helpful514

All this user's reviews

5

arostislavnaDec 15, 2017

Inherently flawed movie, there is so much that was cut out that it makes no sense.

The only redeeming quality is that they addressed many of the plot holes that the OT had.

I can't wait for a 10th anniversary Director's cut.

4 of 5 users found this helpful41

All this user's reviews

5

my02Dec 16, 2016

I kept thinking "did THIS many people have 19th century British accents in all the other films....the other accents all being European?". My friend & I had trouble staying awake just like many others have mentioned....& yes the end wasI kept thinking "did THIS many people have 19th century British accents in all the other films....the other accents all being European?". My friend & I had trouble staying awake just like many others have mentioned....& yes the end was colorful & exciting (especially Darth Vader 'sashaying' through....all I'm sayin').
I barely knew what was going on half the time, dialog sounded like those royalty history movies, just with intergalactic subject matter (but how would Luke, Leah & Han EVER hang out with these people"?).
I sort've plan on seeing it again, hopefully I'll piece the story together better the 2nd time.
I wouldn't say it's bad. It does fall into place well as the backstory of A New Hope. But I'd probably only recommend to people with a good attention span....there's a LOT of dialog delivered with that one-note 'what I'm saying is IMPORTANT' tone. I liked Felicity Jones in A Theory Of Everything (basically the wife who gets dumped for being boring), but her character is pretty boring here too & always had the same 'scowl with a mouth full of walnuts' look. Maybe everyone was directed that way & she nailed it....after all no character was anyone you'd want to have a beer with.
Maybe the robot.… Expand

9 of 19 users found this helpful910

All this user's reviews

5

dlwatso15Jan 21, 2017

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. I've been a huge fan of Star Wars since I was a child, since the day I saw the first installment and my mind was blown. I've loved almost all of them (I like Episode 1 and 2 but they're nowhere near as good as the rest of the films) but Rogue One is a piss poor Star Wars movie and a **** movie in general. Let me start off by saying the things I liked about the movie. - Good acting
- Great visuals and CGI
- Great settings - Ben Mendelsohn as Orson Krennic
- Alan Tudyk as K-2SO

Now here are the things I didn't like. - Boring characters outside of Orson and K-2SO
- Boring script and poor writing
- Terrible pacing throughout
- Darth Vader's cheesy joke
- Little to no mention to other films in the series
- Plays everything too safe - Not one Jedi in the film
- The actions scenes look great but nothing important really happens in them
- All of the action scenes are basically the same as the previous action scene
- Overall cheesiness throughout

Now, it's not a terrible movie but it's not good. It was so boring that my girlfriend fell asleep for the last half hour and I almost fell asleep in the middle. I don't think I've ever wanted to go to sleep during a Star Wars film to get out of it. My only suggestion is to find this movie at a Redbox or something and try it yourself but do not go into it with high expectations.… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

5

Joe95Dec 17, 2016

A movie which tries desperately to recreate the magic of the original trilogy failing it's goal. A bad soundtrack as we've never seen on Star Wars before, a meaningless plot, useless characters with no charm who add nothing to the Star WarsA movie which tries desperately to recreate the magic of the original trilogy failing it's goal. A bad soundtrack as we've never seen on Star Wars before, a meaningless plot, useless characters with no charm who add nothing to the Star Wars mithology. A junble of CGI characters who could have compleately been avoided. After all we were able to do worse than the sequel trilogy, but this time with no Jar-Jar. P.s.: What the f*** went wrong with Darth Vader armor?
P.p.s.: After all Vader smashing rebels was great!… Expand

38 of 99 users found this helpful3861

All this user's reviews

5

Ejdjski1234Dec 17, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. IT bored me and felt a bit long but had its moments. Everyone gets blown up which is upsetting but Vader has a badass scene and it opens up for a new hope… Expand

4 of 12 users found this helpful48

All this user's reviews

5

KeithAJohnstonDec 19, 2016

This film generates mixed feelings. On the good side the visuals excel, the ending is superb and there are some wonderful moments. It adds significantly to the impact of Star Wars: A New Hope by focusing on the sacrifices made to get theThis film generates mixed feelings. On the good side the visuals excel, the ending is superb and there are some wonderful moments. It adds significantly to the impact of Star Wars: A New Hope by focusing on the sacrifices made to get the plans to Leia.

On the downside the film fails to generate an emotional connection with the characters, which is its major sin. The main character is poorly done, the story is complex and unconvincing and its overlong and boring at times. A missed opportunity.… Expand

6 of 13 users found this helpful67

All this user's reviews

5

nukachuDec 19, 2016

The movie is full of super effects and tons of fighting scenes, this is normal for typical science-fiction film. I like the fact that, director doesn't try to promote the movie using sexual scenes, and this is not kind of "heroes shouldThe movie is full of super effects and tons of fighting scenes, this is normal for typical science-fiction film. I like the fact that, director doesn't try to promote the movie using sexual scenes, and this is not kind of "heroes should survive", but I didn't find this movie interesting, there are funny moments in the movie though.… Expand

2 of 4 users found this helpful22

All this user's reviews

5

andmyles2goDec 21, 2016

While Rogue One stands on its own as a movie, it's storyline is somewhat Hollywood-ized and not very unique. Perhaps using Star Wars as a theme it mixes the tomfoolery of Guardians of the Galaxy with some elements of Expendables (yikes!) lastWhile Rogue One stands on its own as a movie, it's storyline is somewhat Hollywood-ized and not very unique. Perhaps using Star Wars as a theme it mixes the tomfoolery of Guardians of the Galaxy with some elements of Expendables (yikes!) last ditch efforts to bring to you an interesting portion of the overall Star Wars storyline. As a movie goer, my expectations were lowered due to the reboot/rehash nature of Force Awakens, but having watched it now, I'm quite indifferent as to if it is something I would watch again. It was nice to know what they were thinking I suppose, but as a movie itself, I think it was merely ho hum and 5/6 out of 10 at best.… Expand

4 of 9 users found this helpful45

All this user's reviews

5

flowirinDec 24, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Its a star wars movie. That's good. tie fighters, death stars, corellian corvettes, space battles and storm troopers. YAY
but. meh.
There's obvious symbolism. the filmatic movement from darkness to light, representing despair to hope. but belaboured, and makes the movie hard to watch for the first forever. 50 shades of, well, darkness and that's all there is to see.
Then there's the lack of gravitas. The monologues are just that little bit too long and quite frankly i didn't care enough about the boring bearded dudes to care. And the star, is it Jen? no, its Jin. or something, she's not quite got the method down pat and I dropped out of the movie world several times when she was obviously acting.
Then there's the style. The first movement is all chop chop chop, switching frantically between worlds, clumsy exposition, not feeling much like a star wars movie, more like a complex detective film noir, which then changes mood halfway though and tries to pull a thin red line, or something.
I guess it did manage to build a sense of the human (and alien) cost of the plans that luke comes across in a new hope. there's that word again. They said it enough.
Then there's the 3D. The Force Awakens nailed it, and it was brilliant. Rouge One? meh. I like to look around each scene, take in the other players, check out the scenery, the sets. In Rouge One, the focal plane is really small, so only the person that the director wants you to look at is in focus (and even then they are often obstructed by shoulders or objects). Everyone else is blurry. So i spent a lot of time looking at a blurry person, waiting for the focus to shift so i could see them properly. Not so much in the second half, but it was a real irritant for the first half. This was compounded by a constant, unnecessary, shaky cam. So 3D added a tiny bit to the movie, but took more than it gave.

And dear GOD. please never use that CGI technique for people's faces EVER AGAIN. I'll have nightmares. So BAD
the droid was good.… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews