Melinda and Melinda

Name: Melinda and Melinda
Genre: Drama, Comedy
Released: March 18, 2005
Duration: 99 min
Rating: 54
Cast: Chiwetel Ejiofor, Will Ferrell

2005

METASCORE

Mixed or average reviews based on 40 Critic Reviews

See All

USER SCORE

Mixed or average reviews based on 42 Ratings

See All

6.0

VOTE NOW

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

6.0	Your Score
6.0	User Score Mixed or average reviews based on 42 Ratings

Would you like to write a review?

There is a 75 character minimum for reviews. If your review contains spoilers, please check the Spoiler box. Please do not use ALL CAPS. There is no linking or other HTML allowed. Your review may be edited for content. 0/5000

Check box if your review contains spoilers

Play Sound

Please enter your birth date to watch this video:

You are not allowed to view this material at this time.

Melinda And Melinda

Now Playing: Melinda And Melinda

Movie Details & Credits

Fox Searchlight Pictures | Release Date: March 18, 2005 | TV-MA

Starring: Chiwetel Ejiofor, Will Ferrell

Summary: This film combines romantic comedy and drama in a way that Woody Allen, unique among filmmakers, likes to contrast. (Fox Searchlight)

Director: Woody Allen

Genre(s): Drama, Comedy

Rating: TV-MA

Runtime: 99 min

See All Details and Credits

Watch Now

Stream On

Buy on

Stream On

Expand

Metascore

Positive:

Mixed:

Negative:

Critic Reviews

Mike Clark

Smart, satisfying and compact but so modest in scale that only true-blue fans will sense - immediately - that it's Woody Allen's best outing in many years. Read full review

Joe Morgenstern

Full of entertaining vignettes that eventually make a happy mockery, as they're meant to do, of the tragedy vs. comedy dialectic.

Mick LaSalle

More accomplished, adventurous and original. Instead of Allen's usual investigation into the nature of existence, this new film looks at the way stories are created, particularly comedies. Read full review

Lawrence Toppman

Whatever you think of Melinda and Melinda, you have to admire Woody Allen for this: After years of criticism that he didn't use people of color in films, he's written two interracial romances. Read full review

Kyle Smith

Not since Edward Norton kicked his own butt in Fight Club has the screen witnessed such a brutal self-drubbing. Read full review

Dallas Observer Melissa Levine

It's merely all right--very high-concept and on its way to interesting, but never there. Read full review

Kimberley Jones

These days, Allen's pictures are more like snuff films, in which the viewer must suffer both gifted actors committing screen hara-kiri and a once-brilliant filmmaker soldiering on with his long, bullheaded decline. Read full review

SEE ALL 40 REVIEWS

Write a Review

User Reviews

WallyS.

Dec 8, 2005

Woody Allen is in good shape, he creates a wonderfull plot full of autentic characters that are performed with majesty. Definetly, a cult film to see over and over again, just to capture the delightfull essence of the story, that is great.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

J-Shap

Oct 10, 2011

Melinda and Melinda is not a particularly bad film, but just a limp one. In many ways, that's worse. The switching between a comic and tragic interpretation of the same movie keeps afloat with thought, but the film itself is rather empty, and neither story is particularly strong on its own.

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

Spangle

Feb 2, 2017

Released in late 2004 in Europe, but early 2005 in America, Melinda and Melinda stands as a testament to the change that was afoot in Woody Allen's career. After this film, he took off to Europe and began filming in various vacation destinations across the continent. One of the last few NewReleased in late 2004 in Europe, but early 2005 in America, Melinda and Melinda stands as a testament to the change that was afoot in Woody Allen's career. After this film, he took off to Europe and began filming in various vacation destinations across the continent. One of the last few New York City shot Allen flicks (Whatever Works and Cafe Society would later represent brief returns to the city he loves), Melinda and Melinda is a mixed bag. Touching on typical Allen themes, the film poses the question: is life more tragedy or comedy? Set during a dinner conversation between two playwrights, one a comic writer and the other a tragedy writer, both pose theories based on a story offered by a mutual friend. The setup: a couple is hosting a dinner party and a woman randomly shows up at their door. The two playwrights envision two entirely scenarios in which a woman named Melinda (Radha Mitchell) knocks on the door of a dinner party unexpectedly. One goes tragically and the other turns comedic. Which is the actuality of life and better captures the likelihood of the mystery behind this girl?

In the tragic tale, Melinda is a woman damaged. After cheating on her husband, killing her lover, and losing custody of her children, she shows up at the front door of a couple, Lee (Jonny Lee Miller) and Laurel (Chloe Sevigny), as they entertain. Now, this couple are people she knew in college and had planned to stay with months ago, but a suicide attempt on Melinda's part got in the way. While with them, she meets and falls for a musical man named Ellis (Chiwetel Ejiofor). Unfortunately, things do not work, Lee and Laurel's marriage falls apart, a lawyer she consults cannot help her with her custody case, and Melinda winds up wanting to kill herself. By the end, Laurel resolves that Melinda will always need help. In this section, the tragedy is quite clear. Her life is horrible, though some is self-inflicted. Much of this section falls flat comedically, however. As a Woody Allen film, one would expect some more comedic lines, but there is nothing here. I looked for comedy here simply because the tragedy seems so ineffective. Melinda is unlikable and probably brought all of this on herself by killing a man in cold blood and cheating out of boredom. She is unsympathetic and not a good main character. The first half of the film heavily focuses on this story unfortunately and Melinda here is simply not easy to like. While the acting here is great, especially by Mitchell in a scene where she spills her heart and past to Ejiofor, little works until she meets Ejiofor. When the two are together, the film really does click and the tragic playwright finds some magic in the darkness.

In the comedy section, Melinda arrives at the home of Hobie (Will Ferrell) and Susan (Amanda Peet). As Allen is a comedy writer, this section really zips at times, especially in the second half. A damaged woman who arrives after having downed 24 sleeping pills, the section quickly becomes charming as she as Hobie begin to fall for one another. Fearing hurting his wife, Hobie consults best friend Walt (Steve Carell) as to what he should do. Fortunately, the feeling is mutual between he and his wife and they have an awkwardly easy split where the duo just agree it is over. Now free to chase Melinda, the duo fall in love after spending some time with other people - Melinda with a regular guy who is quite nice and Hobie with a Republican Playboy mode. Ending on a happier note, the section is largely quite witty with Ferrell playing the Woody Allen character. It is funny throughout with Ferrell delivering good Elf-like performance in regards to the innocence and authenticity of his character. He plays the neurotic man quite well and delivers the witty and smart lines with ease. When this section takes focus, Melinda and Melinda is at its most enjoyable and is often incredibly funny, mainly because it plays to Allen's strengths as a writer/director.

A film about whether life is more tragic or comedic, the answer is simple: it is both. The film very clearly shows that tragedy does not work quite as well without some comedic lightness to liven it up and comedy lacks stakes or the final bit of punch without some tragedy. Comedic possibilities are introduced in the tragic storyline and vice versa, but never explored because of the defined focus of the storylines. The end result is an interesting concept, but with two sections that do not work quite as well as intended and prove that tragedy and comedy need each other to work. In isolation, the duo tend to just tread water.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

habrown

Dec 1, 2014

I revere Woody Allen. But this is one Woody Allen flm I cannot support. The juxtaposition of the storyline simultaneously along tragic and comedic lines just does not work. Most of all, it's confusing. Notwithstanding a terrible script, I have to say Will Farrell does an admirable job. TheI revere Woody Allen. But this is one Woody Allen flm I cannot support. The juxtaposition of the storyline simultaneously along tragic and comedic lines just does not work. Most of all, it's confusing. Notwithstanding a terrible script, I have to say Will Farrell does an admirable job. The other cast members fall flat.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

CraigA.

Jun 12, 2006

Just rubbish. Stilted, unnatural dialogue, wooden performances, pretensious and bourgious. Its concept is supposedly the same story told two different ways. Its not. Its two different stories told the same way - badly.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

SusanM

Dec 29, 2005

I rented this pitiful "film." I am appalled that anybody was willing to fund this. It reminded me of a beginning acting class where people pair up and do scenes in front of the class and "act" with all the realism of a piece of wood. Moreover, the archaic dialoge just sounded ridiculous. I rented this pitiful "film." I am appalled that anybody was willing to fund this. It reminded me of a beginning acting class where people pair up and do scenes in front of the class and "act" with all the realism of a piece of wood. Moreover, the archaic dialoge just sounded ridiculous. Does Mr. Allen ever listen to contemporary conversations? Oh, and everyone is an accomplished musician and they only like Cole Porter! "I was walking along a sidewalk and there was a piano. I used to play in high school. Actually, I gave concerts." Puh-lease. The only cast member I didn't pity was Amanda Peet, who emerged from this mess without losing any dignity. Can't say the same for everyone else. Hey, what did you guys think?… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

GregT.

Nov 9, 2005

Rhonda asks how anyone can hate a Woody Allen movie...easy, just watch this one.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

SEE ALL 9 REVIEWS