Lady in the Water

Warner Bros. Pictures | Release Date: July 21, 2006

6.3	USER SCORE Generally favorable reviews based on 451 Ratings

USER RATING DISTRIBUTION

Watch Now

Stream On

Buy on

Stream On

Expand

Review this movie

VOTE NOW

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

Please sign in or create an account before writing a review.

Check box if your review contains spoilers

0 characters (5000 max)

User Reviews

User score By date Most helpful

AmandaPJul 22, 2006

My favorite of M's so far. One critic wrote that this movie wasn't believable. Isn't that what movies are all about? Was Signs supposed to be believable? If you watch the movie as a bedtime story, like it should be watched My favorite of M's so far. One critic wrote that this movie wasn't believable. Isn't that what movies are all about? Was Signs supposed to be believable? If you watch the movie as a bedtime story, like it should be watched then you'll love it. Terrific job by all the actors, including M himself.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

GregoryB.Jul 22, 2006

I can't believe this got such low reviews from critics, but I can see why. M. Night, isn't really liked by them in the first place, cast himself a small part in his own movie, and even had a critic character in this that was made I can't believe this got such low reviews from critics, but I can see why. M. Night, isn't really liked by them in the first place, cast himself a small part in his own movie, and even had a critic character in this that was made fun and says in the movie, "there is nothing original anymore." Well if that critic would have stepped out of the screen, he would have seen something that was. If you liked the village, you will like this. It is a beautiful story that is intriguing as it is hypnotic. It is "slow" as there isn't anything blowing up every 5 seconds, but who wants that 24/7. The acting is superb and as I don't think he should have necessarily cast himself in this, he does a good job. GO SEE IT. My fiancee and I love his movies and were talking for an hour after this one. Critics should drop their biases and grudges and see this movie for what it really is, a compelling and thought provoking tale.… Expand

1 of 1 users found this helpful

JeffreyA.Jul 22, 2006

I never expect much from critics, but reading the reviews before seeing the movie my expectations were a lot lower. However, I was completely blown away after watching the movie. M is brilliant in creating a fairytale that shadows paradigm I never expect much from critics, but reading the reviews before seeing the movie my expectations were a lot lower. However, I was completely blown away after watching the movie. M is brilliant in creating a fairytale that shadows paradigm shifts that are occuring in our present time. I love the characters, the way they evolve over time and the emotions they create on film. If you can connect with this movie through it's layers and symbolism you will be in for a beautiful movie experience. As for holes in the story line, uhm, there are none!… Expand

1 of 1 users found this helpful

NicoleV.Jul 22, 2006

I didn't know what to expect and given the reviews, I wasn't expecting too much thinking the story might be confusing or, as one critic said "with too many holes in it". It is not confusing at all!! And the story was great- I didn't know what to expect and given the reviews, I wasn't expecting too much thinking the story might be confusing or, as one critic said "with too many holes in it". It is not confusing at all!! And the story was great- inspiring, humorous, suspenseful, symbolic, heartfelt... It definitely surpassed my expectation! I liked MNS other movies, but this is my favorie now by far and I have greater respect for his art now. I can see where some critic gave bad reviews because MNS basically makes fun of them by incorporating a critic character into the film as someone who doesn't know good films. The critics definitiely don't know a good film when they see it! This maybe a fairytale, but many people missed that it is still a representation of life now.… Expand

1 of 1 users found this helpful

jaimeharringtonJul 22, 2006

Horrible film. What was he thinking? I liked his earlier films but hits is embarrassing bad. Giamatti did a good job in his role (thus the 2 rating).

0 of 1 users found this helpful

LouV.Jul 22, 2006

Something different and memorable good acting.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

JohnS.Jul 21, 2006

Don't listen to the critics. Most of them have totally overlooked the fact that this has no intention to tie itself to everyday life. It's a fairy tale, and the characters complicating of everything is just what you and I would do Don't listen to the critics. Most of them have totally overlooked the fact that this has no intention to tie itself to everyday life. It's a fairy tale, and the characters complicating of everything is just what you and I would do if we had to figure out a fairy tale for ourselves. Shyamalan is brilliant with monsters, and it's a relief that there isn't a twist ending for its own sake. The story has no holes, but the meaning of what goes on is up for debate. Do NOT confuse that with a misshapen plot.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

RickyQ.Jul 21, 2006

A very weird movie, but it is quite entertaining. A fairy tale is what it is, so don't go in taking the movie too seriously.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

JoshC.Jul 21, 2006

Great movie--but you have to watch it as a fable. Not a horror film, not a "M. Night-twist" film, but as a fable. Enjoyed the characterizations. A rare summer movie that actual made me feel something while watching it, and think a lot afterwards.

1 of 1 users found this helpful

RobertB.Jul 21, 2006

Suprisingly funny, tasteful, modern fairytale. The critics can go to hell on this one.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

JacksonE.Jul 21, 2006

It appears from other votes that you will either love this film or hate it. To quote Blaine and Antoine . . . Hated it!

0 of 1 users found this helpful

KimberlyG.Jul 21, 2006

This is not about a lady in the water, grass wolves or flying monkeys. It is simply about how a group of culturally diverse people come together to make something great happen!! It shows us that we as neighbors, no matter how young, how This is not about a lady in the water, grass wolves or flying monkeys. It is simply about how a group of culturally diverse people come together to make something great happen!! It shows us that we as neighbors, no matter how young, how emotionally broken or mentally ill can ban together to make a difference.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

JamesH.Jul 21, 2006

I am a big fan of M's work but this movie seems to have its feet in everywhere. the plot is convoluted but strung out. M always brings a great story but to be honest-the movie is mesmerizingly confusing and ridiculous. I thought PAUL I am a big fan of M's work but this movie seems to have its feet in everywhere. the plot is convoluted but strung out. M always brings a great story but to be honest-the movie is mesmerizingly confusing and ridiculous. I thought PAUL GIAMATTI was excellent along with BRYCE DALLAS HOWARD. The movie touches many emotional levels for several characters and is heartfelt. REDEMPTION, ONE'S FUTURE and HEALING. I really think this movie has too much of a good thing, which hinders the overall impact. you could say that simplifying the plot would get less confusion but more clarity. overall?, I liked it-but I expected more-or should I say less?--really only 2.5 stars… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

SamiN.Jul 21, 2006

An incredible film, a poetic challenge to the audience. Better than 99% of Hollywood rubbish!

0 of 0 users found this helpful

NickT.Jul 21, 2006

A fairy tale with more rules than chess. A plodding, contrived and ultimately silly story. But still the picture is studded with moments of directorial genius and saved from banality by Paul Giamatti's formidible but understated A fairy tale with more rules than chess. A plodding, contrived and ultimately silly story. But still the picture is studded with moments of directorial genius and saved from banality by Paul Giamatti's formidible but understated portrayal. MSN, like Jim Cameron, is too gifted a director to be permitted to contiue to do all his own writing. As for his "acting"...MSN please take a tip from Hitchock and stick with the nonspeaking walkby.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

JCFJul 21, 2006

I still don't know why anyone ever liked any of "M" movies they are ALL BADDDD, starting with the 6th sense with its mediocre acting, bad visuals and the CHEESY kid...lol..."i see dead people" as cliché as M.Night, the director I still don't know why anyone ever liked any of "M" movies they are ALL BADDDD, starting with the 6th sense with its mediocre acting, bad visuals and the CHEESY kid...lol..."i see dead people" as cliché as M.Night, the director himself. He might aspires to be like Hitchcock, M.Night does not have what it takes, hopefully this will be the end of him and his large EGO.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

EdRMJul 21, 2006

Marvelous. SImply marvelous, if you open your head to a movie which is not mainstream by any movies. It is a piece of art and, as such, you have to comprehend it.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

MarkC.Jul 21, 2006

What a bunch of hooey! MNS has gone totally over the edge if he thinks this is at all 1) interesting, 2) intriguing, 3) scary, 4)other worldly. In fact, it's none of the above. It's just plain stupid and a complete waste of What a bunch of hooey! MNS has gone totally over the edge if he thinks this is at all 1) interesting, 2) intriguing, 3) scary, 4)other worldly. In fact, it's none of the above. It's just plain stupid and a complete waste of celluloid! MNS, it's time to try a new genre.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

DaveK.Jul 21, 2006

Misguidedly earnest, numbingly arbitrary. Even the long shots and layered framing is tired by now.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

XcriticJul 21, 2006

A very good thriller-fantasy movie to see this summer,,,well if u want something different!.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

RathM.Jul 21, 2006

Someone please stop him before he makes another truly pathetic attempt at storytelling. "M" really needs to stuff his ego where the sun doesn't shine, fire the yes men around him and truly work on something that isn't utter tripe. Someone please stop him before he makes another truly pathetic attempt at storytelling. "M" really needs to stuff his ego where the sun doesn't shine, fire the yes men around him and truly work on something that isn't utter tripe. First year film school students produce better films than this garbage. I saw this as a free pre-screening promotion and still want a refund and my time back!… Expand

0 of 1 users found this helpful

SusanH.Jul 21, 2006

beautiful and suprising. Disagree with most of the reviews, again.

1 of 1 users found this helpful

BobS.Jul 21, 2006

very original which is more than you can say about other films around. And funnier than I expected. I will see it again to catch more details.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

K.ShanmugaJul 21, 2006

Simply and truly superb. Shyamalan has once again proved his superior movie making abilities. I am sure that "Lady..." will once again prove all those critics wrong and be a runaway hit.

1 of 1 users found this helpful

MattF.Jul 20, 2006

absolutely ghastly. A twisted, uninteresting pile of steaming dung.

0 of 1 users found this helpful

prev next

Page: