Mafia II

 Xbox 360
User Score
8.1

Generally favorable reviews- based on 751 Ratings

User score distribution:
  1. Positive: 550 out of 751
  2. Mixed: 145 out of 751
  3. Negative: 56 out of 751
Buy Now
Buy on

Review this game

  1. Your Score
    0 out of 10
    Rate this:
    • 10
    • 9
    • 8
    • 7
    • 6
    • 5
    • 4
    • 3
    • 2
    • 1
    • 0
    • 0
  1. Submit
  2. Check Spelling
view
per page
  1. Salazar0797
    Sep 6, 2023
    10
    I can't understand the giving low point to this game, I think this game a masterpiece and just real gamers can know this.
  2. MusicCriticG
    Aug 28, 2023
    9
    This game is truly amazing, so many plot twists, and jaw dropping moments that make this game special in its own way I would play this game again 100%
  3. FrankCreeper
    Jul 28, 2023
    10
    A fantastic openworld game with an amazing characters and one of the best protagonist of this series of game,the atmosphere is still pretty good,gunplay and car fisics are very awesome...aged very well still worth it to play
    P.S (I Play both console versions PS3/XBOX360)
  4. 34m2121
    Jul 3, 2023
    8
    Güzel bir hikaye, Oldukça iyi ve gerçekçi hissetiren karakterler, güzel aksiyon sahneleri ve mekanikleri, Harika sürüş deneyimi, Mükemmel müzikler, Vasat bir sonu ve Oyundan silinen kısımlar olsaydı çok daha iyi olurdu
  5. Rustick
    Jun 9, 2023
    8
    Красивый город, атмосфера очень хороша, сюжет пусть и не без минусов, но за ним интересно следить, персонажи врезаются в память, в городе нет контента и сама игра очень короткая, графика очень красивая
  6. melihabuaf
    May 19, 2023
    6
    its avehje game but sttil gufn to play car mekaniks are **** gogogogogo ciritic
  7. Funder
    Mar 29, 2023
    8
    Would be 10/10 had they not removed too much content. Played for the first time in 2023, game did not age at all in terms of gameplay mechanics. Driving and controlling the character, and shooting is better than gta's.
  8. sprf
    Mar 12, 2023
    7
    Mafia II is a good game overall but comes off a bit disappointing on the end. Thanks to the troubled history development it is only a 1/3 of the game developers wanted to make, it could have been so much more. Yet what we got on release is not bad, solid gameplay and story and characters. Atmosphere is probably the best Mafia II can offer, especially in the beginning chapters. GraphicsMafia II is a good game overall but comes off a bit disappointing on the end. Thanks to the troubled history development it is only a 1/3 of the game developers wanted to make, it could have been so much more. Yet what we got on release is not bad, solid gameplay and story and characters. Atmosphere is probably the best Mafia II can offer, especially in the beginning chapters. Graphics look amazing for an Xbox 360 title 10 years later, and vehicle physics are top notch.… Expand
  9. drewcedarwild
    Feb 13, 2023
    8
    Considering this game came out in 2010, much can be forgiven: graphics, poor lip-sync, some screen tearing, etc ... but the story is fantastic! The combat is middling, but you don't shoot all that much really, what you have are fun missions with interesting dialogue that keeps you guessing what will happen next. A lot of tender loving care went into this, and the soundtrack takes it toConsidering this game came out in 2010, much can be forgiven: graphics, poor lip-sync, some screen tearing, etc ... but the story is fantastic! The combat is middling, but you don't shoot all that much really, what you have are fun missions with interesting dialogue that keeps you guessing what will happen next. A lot of tender loving care went into this, and the soundtrack takes it to that next level!… Expand
  10. farrrullll
    Jan 27, 2023
    8
    Mafia 2 Mafia 2 Mafia 2 Mafia 2 Mafia 2 Mafia 2 Mafia 2 Mafia 2 Mafia 2
  11. Reaper0
    Jan 5, 2023
    7
    A really good game whith a good world and a nice a story and it was okay iii
  12. Joe2539
    Jan 3, 2023
    10
    Very Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good
  13. OnlyGoryGames
    Dec 4, 2022
    8
    I can’t think of words to o express my love for this one. So many aspects of this game is what I want in gaming.
  14. Blackshine
    Nov 16, 2022
    10
    ТОП-1 игра в моём личном списке.

    Проходил раз 10.

    11-тый будет не лишним.
  15. Hiccup3319
    Aug 20, 2022
    10
    This game.... it's just amazing. What every narative game should aspire to be and helped create Legendary games like GTA 5. It's a masterpiece.
  16. Random124
    Jul 13, 2022
    10
    One of the best games ever made pls play it if u haven't had the chance to do so yet
  17. Mgf1Ery
    Jun 22, 2022
    9
    hikaye,oyun mükemmel amabitişine anlam veremediğim için 1 puan kırdım
  18. V7q
    Jun 19, 2022
    8
    I recommend playing and familiarizing yourself with this game. I had fun playing this game.
  19. faruk_128
    Jun 12, 2022
    8
    That's a great Mafia game. It was a good game, though not as good as Mafia 1.
  20. TheMockbuster
    May 6, 2022
    8
    Amazing story, decent sandbox mechanics and cover shooting. Would love more life to make this open “world” feel like one.
  21. SemmelMerlin
    May 2, 2022
    10
    Jetzt mit der definitive Edition nochmal gespielt und ich merke Mal wieder was für ein großartiges Spiel dies ist
  22. Babo2003
    Mar 11, 2022
    0
    Better than GTA for many reasons. When taxi crushes to your car, he got penalized for it. Can you imagine that in GTA?
  23. ONEEX
    Feb 12, 2022
    10
    Отличное исполнение. Графика нормальная.
    Очень нравится сюжетная линия и постановка диалогов.
    К сожалению Мафия 3 не сумела даже на не много приблизиться ко второй части, ни в графике, ни в сценарии ни в постановке диалогов.    Отличное исполнение. Графика нормальная.
    Очень нравится сюжетная линия и постановка диалогов.
    К сожалению Мафия 3 не сумела даже на не много приблизиться ко второй части, ни в графике, ни в сценарии ни в постановке диалогов.
  24. Masterfifer623
    Feb 3, 2022
    10
    Очень жду продолжения и очень надеюсь,что в 4 части будут фигурировать Вито и Джо
  25. Amorph0us
    Jan 7, 2022
    9
    Excellent game, my favorite of the series. Dope aesthitic, great scenario, liked the action and the game mechanics. It includes everything that I like about godfather-ish games.
  26. JJ2FAS4U
    Dec 28, 2021
    8
    Atmosphere: 9
    Enjoyment: 9
    Gameplay: 7
    Graphics: 8
    Music: 8
    Story: 9
    Total: 8.33
  27. Cardinal357
    Sep 26, 2021
    7
    Шедевральный сюжет, но за 10 лет так и не исправили баги. Я лично перепроходил 14 главу потому что тупо игра бегала
  28. wraiththinx
    Aug 9, 2021
    10
    the story of the game is very good and never bored this game must be played
  29. phiphi
    Aug 7, 2021
    6
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. the best part about this game is the story, it pretty realistic but gameplay is so boring, 70% of gameplay is driving from here to there again and again anytime you outside, if you prefer the story tham gameplay it is so good but if you want "free feeling" it'll make you dissapoint… Expand
  30. nomeoriginale
    Aug 6, 2021
    10
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Легендарная игра
    P.S джо в сделку не входил    … Expand
  31. Alex_Pilgrim008
    Feb 22, 2021
    7
    Mafia II is an entertaining, linear action game in the tradition of The Godfather. You basically drive from Point A to Point B and then either steal a car or shoot bad guys. It's not as open-world as I expected. But the period is nicely captured with a cinematic form. The voice acting is a bit cartoonish, but the story will keep you hooked. Not many collectibles aside from vintage PlayboyMafia II is an entertaining, linear action game in the tradition of The Godfather. You basically drive from Point A to Point B and then either steal a car or shoot bad guys. It's not as open-world as I expected. But the period is nicely captured with a cinematic form. The voice acting is a bit cartoonish, but the story will keep you hooked. Not many collectibles aside from vintage Playboy magazines. Customization is limited to wardrobe changes. If you liked L.A. Noire or the PS2's The Getaway, then you'll probably like this. I'd rate it with a 7.5 out of 10.… Expand
  32. lazonlop
    Feb 21, 2021
    8
    With an amazing story and game play, this is one of the best games i've ever played. The ending is fabulous.
  33. Necrophat
    Feb 10, 2021
    9
    A great game, if you're a fan of Mafia 1 / Mafia 1 remake then I highly recommend playing this. Holds up very well on PS4, great story.
  34. LyoneX
    Jan 6, 2021
    0
    First of all the amount of traffic is way over-done. I wish game creators would stop trying so hard to push realism because this game is a good example of what happens when game creators try to hard with realism. How am I suppose to keep my car on the road let alone stop my car at a red light when Its constantly snowing or raining. Another thing that made me sick with this game is the factFirst of all the amount of traffic is way over-done. I wish game creators would stop trying so hard to push realism because this game is a good example of what happens when game creators try to hard with realism. How am I suppose to keep my car on the road let alone stop my car at a red light when Its constantly snowing or raining. Another thing that made me sick with this game is the fact that I can even sneeze without the cops turning around and wanting to chase me down for it. Really guys! The game started out ok, but started loosing interest real fast. Problem is even when a game is **** if I start it I almost always have to finish it, But this one I Can't. So the only plus I can give to this game is the fact it has lifted my curse of having to finish games even if they are crap. To finish up my review I will say to the game creators there is a huge difference between fun and frustration. It's a game, it's a game, It's a freaking game. Knock off the horse **** realism and get back to pure fun gaming… Expand
  35. DonCorl3on32003
    Dec 13, 2020
    6
    Buen juego, pero le falta desarrollar mejor su historia, cosa que muchos alaban pero en realidad no logra, intenta abarcar demasiado
  36. Sikskskskskdkks
    Oct 13, 2020
    10
    Perfecto, tiene buen argumento, historia y personajes con un buen desarrollo de estos es muy recomendable
  37. SunshineRex1885
    Sep 27, 2020
    10
    Este não foi o tipo de jogo que chamou minha atenção a princípio, não me interessava por esta franquia, mas depois que joguei e comecei a me aprofundar na história, não deu outra! Me apaixonei, a história, os gráficos,a jogabilidade e até mesmo os detalhes dos veículos de época me fascinaram, além do que é claro o coletável peculiar... Mafia 2 com certeza está no meu ranking de melhoresEste não foi o tipo de jogo que chamou minha atenção a princípio, não me interessava por esta franquia, mas depois que joguei e comecei a me aprofundar na história, não deu outra! Me apaixonei, a história, os gráficos,a jogabilidade e até mesmo os detalhes dos veículos de época me fascinaram, além do que é claro o coletável peculiar... Mafia 2 com certeza está no meu ranking de melhores jogos que tive o prazer de completar em 100%!… Expand
  38. Petrovsky
    Aug 21, 2020
    9
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. All in this game are good: The music, the graphics, the story but once you finish the game you can't play in a free mode and if you want to do this, you will found a desert city… Expand
  39. Leonardo10
    Aug 16, 2020
    9
    his game is very interesting I personally very much connected to Vito driving just great fun shooting with the weapons but I think the story of that first game was more interesting than the second
  40. BassBoostron
    Jun 20, 2020
    10
    Обзор на эту легендарную игру будет слишком краток, но это не делает его плохим.
    Начнем с минусов:
    первый минус - минусов нету. Да, в игре присутствуют незначительные баги(которые по ходу прохождения ни разу мне не встретились) но снижать за это оценку - глупо. Плюсы: +Потрясающий сюжет и проработанный характер персонажей +Глубокое погружение в атмосферу США 50-тых +Реалистичная    Обзор на эту легендарную игру будет слишком краток, но это не делает его плохим.
    Начнем с минусов:
    первый минус - минусов нету.
    Да, в игре присутствуют незначительные баги(которые по ходу прохождения ни разу мне не встретились) но снижать за это оценку - глупо.
    Плюсы:
    +Потрясающий сюжет и проработанный характер персонажей
    +Глубокое погружение в атмосферу США 50-тых
    +Реалистичная физика машин(одна из самых лучших, которые я встречал в играх)
    +Журнал PlayBoy
    +Внимание к деталям
    +Приятные мелочи, среди которых:
    При возвращении на место преступления спустя некоторое время, очевидец может вас узнать и полиция откроет огонь
    Разные способы угона машины
    Взаимодействие с объектами на улице
    Полиция может оштрафовать игрока за превышение скорости или дтп
    и т.д.
    +Мемы
    Заслуженно 10 из 10
    Все что есть в мафии - этого достаточно и не нужно больше.    … Expand
  41. drewbrees9
    May 18, 2020
    9
    Still amazing 10 years after it came out. Great story, great characters, stunning graphic for a 2010 game, and Empire City is the perfect scenography. Just very good.
  42. radwansky
    Apr 27, 2020
    9
    Mafia 2 - игра была пройдена мной 8-9 раз на Пк , и 5 раз на XBOX 360 , Данная игра заслуживает 9 балов , минусы - Короткий сюжет , много вырезаного контента , баги ( последний пункт зависит от стиля игры )
  43. Lord_Gaben_Sama
    Apr 22, 2020
    9
    graphics--> 9/10 story-->10/10 gameplay-->7/10
    The story line was just perfect , the missions weren't repetitive , the game had some good plot twists that you would not have imagined.
    Furthermore the graphics made the game have a noire feeling which for those who love movies made by quentin tarantino or martin scorsese will absolutely appreciate.
  44. Lennox19
    Apr 17, 2020
    9
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Ein (fast) perfektes Spiel. Für damalige Verhältnise eine gute Grafik und auch eine spannende und sehr gute. Story. Sammelobjekte, verschiedene, wunderschönder Soundtrack,... alles ist dabeiein. Ein sehr gutes Spiel vorallem da man auch, Gefängnis Infos zu den ganzen Charakteren finden kann,. Sehr gutes Spiel!… Expand
  45. Rolis86
    Apr 15, 2020
    7
    Good game but not finished to full potential. I liked story cut scenes and voice acting was great. Best sound track. Missions are just one big grind but in wired way I was not stop playing game.
  46. SleepNot
    Apr 1, 2020
    8
    Mafia II is a very good open world game. Great action part of the game. It's a best part of mafia series.
  47. MauryEdson
    Feb 26, 2020
    8
    ESSE é bom hein, vale a pena .........................................................................
  48. Lizadavid127
    Feb 11, 2020
    0
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Шановні дивелопери! Мене супершу дуже зацікавила ваша гра. Але коли коли я побачила краватку Генрі у мене стався розлад шлунку! Виправте будь ласка… Expand
  49. tiagomido
    Sep 8, 2019
    8
    um jogaço e valeu cade centavo pago nele fora que a historia é fantastica
  50. Miguelbpaes
    Jul 7, 2019
    8
    Se você é um fã de filmes como ''O poderoso chefão'' e do ''mundo'' da Máfia, Mafia II é provavelmente um dos melhores títulos que se pode encontrar no mercado. Não tão inovador quanto seu antecessor e ainda sim um game digno de ser jogado, Mafia II apresenta uma história excelente, personagens divertidos e memoráveis, uma trilha sonora fantástica e gráficos muito bonitos. Talvez o que oSe você é um fã de filmes como ''O poderoso chefão'' e do ''mundo'' da Máfia, Mafia II é provavelmente um dos melhores títulos que se pode encontrar no mercado. Não tão inovador quanto seu antecessor e ainda sim um game digno de ser jogado, Mafia II apresenta uma história excelente, personagens divertidos e memoráveis, uma trilha sonora fantástica e gráficos muito bonitos. Talvez o que o estrague seja sua gameplay, que é extremamente travada e ultrapassada, que pode atrapalhar em momentos mais decisivos na gameplay. Tirando isso, não deixe de conferir o 2º título da franquia, que é digno de muitas horas de diversão e imersão.… Expand
  51. eva3si0n
    Jun 20, 2019
    7
    Mafia 2 is the game causing the deepest disappointment. Sometimes long development goes to harm to the video game. For 2010 the majority of elements of a gameplay became already outdated, it even if to consider that GTA IV left for 2 years earlier. The plot separately disappointed, the main character Vito he has a character who is brought together from a template there are no emotions andMafia 2 is the game causing the deepest disappointment. Sometimes long development goes to harm to the video game. For 2010 the majority of elements of a gameplay became already outdated, it even if to consider that GTA IV left for 2 years earlier. The plot separately disappointed, the main character Vito he has a character who is brought together from a template there are no emotions and development of character. And here Joe Barbaro complete antithesis. And against the background of a weak plot and sample Vito the beautiful city, an excellent action and a fine soundtrack flaunts. While a game prepared for release, it lost if not a half, then the most part of content. The city is dead, there are no additional tasks. The disappointment only arises for the reason that the first part of a game is amazing. Starting with the 5th head the real Mafia already comes to an end. And yes subject DLC Joe’s Adventures closed several subject holes. Without it everything was much worse.… Expand
  52. brendo214
    May 22, 2019
    9
    Mafia II is one of the best GTA-like games. At the very least, it has the best story of any GTA-like game.
  53. CenkAlp
    Sep 2, 2018
    8
    Hikaye = 8
    Oynanış = 7
    Grafikler = 7
    Sesler = 7
    Keyif = 8
    Atmosfer = 8
    Süre = 8
  54. Dreadblocks
    Aug 8, 2018
    8
    Mafia ii is indeeed a worthy sequel. wich anyone would buy or play who likes open world games.
  55. Ashra12
    Apr 13, 2018
    10
    Mafia II is a must-play game (like the GTA series) and a true classic of the last gen. Highly underrated, superb graphics and brilliant gameplay mechanics, along with a polished storyline.
  56. iddqd4
    Mar 19, 2018
    6
    Мафия выглядит как малобюджетная поделка на фоне других игр того времени в открытом мире.
  57. tsampson25
    Sep 17, 2017
    9
    Why the mixed views? I can't tell you, for I think Mafia II is a great game and is worth a shot, here's why. GTA IV is a great game, along with all the other GTA's, and Mafia II gets the GTA feel just right but still feels like its own game. The game takes place in the 1940's and 1950's, giving it a classic mellow feel. The cars are nice and the traffic unlike many openworld city games,Why the mixed views? I can't tell you, for I think Mafia II is a great game and is worth a shot, here's why. GTA IV is a great game, along with all the other GTA's, and Mafia II gets the GTA feel just right but still feels like its own game. The game takes place in the 1940's and 1950's, giving it a classic mellow feel. The cars are nice and the traffic unlike many openworld city games, you can drive with legally. The world is interactive, you can open your trunk and car, fix the trunk, rob a store, turn on a sink, open and close a door, turn on the jukebox, and other things that make the world feel more live. The story is great, once you complete one story, you get another and another, and it all rolls together. There bumps and turns everywhere and things you will not expect, some of which will put you in the mood. The characters are easy to like and relatable to, making the whole game more likable. The gun mechanics are easy to use and it is easy to move around and sneak during the games action sequences. The game doesn't stick with one type of play the whole game, for it goes on different missions like stealth, guns blazing, stealing, assassination, rescue missions, all sorts of stuff you won't regret trying.… Expand
  58. This_username_
    Jul 11, 2017
    6
    It's a decent mafia game.. if you are not sure, you can always try the free demo and if you enjoy that, you can buy the full game.

    The graphics are GREAT for 2010, which is the year this game was released.
  59. FeerFrikazus
    May 23, 2017
    10
    Me pareció un juego fantástico, ya que la historia engancha muchísimo, al menos yo no tuve bugs, el control del personaje es bueno, la inteligencia de la IA es buena, la conducción me gusto y la duración del juego esta bien (alrededor de 13 horas me duro).
    Sin dudas lo recomiendo 100%.
  60. MiguelNeto
    Dec 30, 2016
    9
    quando eu comprei Mafia la em 2011 mais ou menos, eu nao esperava gostar tanto do jogo, a cena inicial ja foi muito bom, onde mostra o personagem principal quando serviu o exercito, tem fases excelente, a quantidade de capitulo é boa, sao 15, o grafico é muito, a direçao de arte é excelente, a trilha sonora é ótima, o enredo é muito bom, os personagens sao bons, alguns sao engraçados, e oquando eu comprei Mafia la em 2011 mais ou menos, eu nao esperava gostar tanto do jogo, a cena inicial ja foi muito bom, onde mostra o personagem principal quando serviu o exercito, tem fases excelente, a quantidade de capitulo é boa, sao 15, o grafico é muito, a direçao de arte é excelente, a trilha sonora é ótima, o enredo é muito bom, os personagens sao bons, alguns sao engraçados, e o mapa que é quase mundo aberto, tem bastante coisas para fazer, como roubar lojas e etc. Nota 9.2… Expand
  61. Karimzadeh7
    Oct 8, 2016
    10
    Best story, best gameplay, best graphic
    That's realy great! I played it on pc and xbox 360...This game can win good rewards...I realy love it........!
  62. cronopio
    Sep 2, 2016
    6
    I am disappointed by this game, because the idea could have work really well. There are two issues that ruin the experience, and some facts that take from it.

    The saving system is easily the worst I remember in a game. Sure, the game is short, but that is no excuse for a broken auto-save system that forces you to repeat fights over, and over, and over again. The power balance also plays    I am disappointed by this game, because the idea could have work really well. There are two issues that ruin the experience, and some facts that take from it.

    The saving system is easily the worst I remember in a game. Sure, the game is short, but that is no excuse for a broken auto-save system that forces you to repeat fights over, and over, and over again. The power balance also plays against this, since you are basically a war machine that can dispatch wave after wave of enemies BUT it is also rather easy to die in just a couple of hits (after a few seconds you will recover if you manage to survive). This means that fights turn into a chore (fight is not a challenge, but there is an important risk of death if you are careless: a chore). Also many scenes cannot be skipped.

    Then we have to face the elephant in the room: this is not a game about Mafia, this is a taxi simulator. Wake up, pick up the phone. Get an address where you need to go, where you get another address, where you will fight a bit, and then get a new address or drive home. Sometimes it is even worse since you have special assignments such as (kid you not) "drive an old lady carefully to the hospital" or drive really fast here or there. The driving experience, at least in a PC, is not really enjoyable.

    This game works for the story, since the world around you is large enough but void of any interest. The story is short and, worse, a bit shallow. Characters have no development and, well, there is not much depth anywhere to be found, not in the plot, not in how it is presented.

    Also: what's with the Playboy magazines? They serve ZERO purpose to the game, the story or the game-world. It is hard to avoid thinking they simply placed them here because the developers still have the horny-geeky-adolescent cliché in their minds. I found this slightly off-putting and sexist (mind you, not because I think sexual content is not appropriate in a game, quite the opposite, because I believe it is an interesting topic which should not be used in such a lazy way).

    The only thing I really enjoyed in this game is the voice actors. Nice job there!    … Expand
  63. SuperMarioBro
    Jul 30, 2016
    9
    Mafia 2 - i think this game one of cool open world games. Awesome and sad storyline, cool soundtrack, graphics and... gameplay. He is so realistic. Game is actually fun
  64. duckhost
    Jun 5, 2016
    7
    Mafia 2 looking from a perspective it's a good game, but looking from another perspective it's a **** awful experience, most of the game still holds itself, but some other stuff just got so old so fast. The graphics even in 2010 were bad, some of the textures looks like a PS2 game, the music is forgettable, and some of the voice acting isn't good, but on the other stuff the story is great,Mafia 2 looking from a perspective it's a good game, but looking from another perspective it's a **** awful experience, most of the game still holds itself, but some other stuff just got so old so fast. The graphics even in 2010 were bad, some of the textures looks like a PS2 game, the music is forgettable, and some of the voice acting isn't good, but on the other stuff the story is great, the presentation of this game is great, you will believe that Empire Bay exist, you will feel like you're on the 40s or the 50s. Overall it's no a bad game, but it aged quickly.… Expand
  65. Jaliver
    Mar 31, 2016
    7
    Mafia 2 is a well made open world game with a world that articulately resembles the 1940s-1950s in a very appreciative light. As a lover of the American classic era I have a real soft spot for the game's story which is very good and the overall atmosphere the game tries to put you in. The radio plays several classics from the 40s and 50s, all the cars are correct for their time and so areMafia 2 is a well made open world game with a world that articulately resembles the 1940s-1950s in a very appreciative light. As a lover of the American classic era I have a real soft spot for the game's story which is very good and the overall atmosphere the game tries to put you in. The radio plays several classics from the 40s and 50s, all the cars are correct for their time and so are the outfits. Why give this game a 7 with all these great things mentioned you ask? Well here is why...

    Mafia 2 although is "open world" fails to capture the essence of an open world game. Exploring seems pointless and the lack of side quests really hurt the play life of this game. Its a relatively short experience due to this and the game feels like one giant cut-scene. You enter area to area for the main story with encouragement from the characters and maps to continue onward constantly. Diverting from the main story feels pointless and with the lack of content to sustain players through this, its impossible for me to justify giving this game an 8 for myself. Still, I'd recommend Mafia 2 to anyone looking for a solid gaming experience from start to finish.    … Expand
  66. TheHonestJack
    Dec 1, 2015
    7
    Mafia II features an intriguing story with likable characters, and excellent music, all in a sprawling atmospheric open world. The only problem? That's all it has. Because along with the great story and characters come rather poor technical aspects.

    Optimization on console is somewhat poor, with frame rates varying drastically at certain points in the game. Gameplay consists of decent    Mafia II features an intriguing story with likable characters, and excellent music, all in a sprawling atmospheric open world. The only problem? That's all it has. Because along with the great story and characters come rather poor technical aspects.

    Optimization on console is somewhat poor, with frame rates varying drastically at certain points in the game. Gameplay consists of decent driving controls, along with very bland combat and shooting mechanics (The crosshair in shooting sections isn't even in the middle of the screen), albeit with a neat cover system.

    Even the entertaining story is hurt by the extreme linearity of the game. Sure, you have a big open city to explore and buy things in, but that's it. There are no side missions, you are restricted to the main story with nothing else to do other than just messing around. Robbing stores and diners adds a little fun, but it doesn't last long.

    The story, music/art, and presentation in this game are all there, but the lack of actual open world elements such as side missions or NPC interaction in this supposedly "open world" RPG and lackluster combat mechanics makes it a rather boring game when you want to do something other than main missions or robbing a shirt store for the 20th time.

    Not a bad game by any stretch, but it leaves something to be desired.    … Expand
  67. RacN
    Nov 1, 2015
    7
    I really enjoyed Mafia II but there is a slight issue, for me at least. I completed the campaign and I wasn't particularly satisfied with how the game ended (I will not spoil the story.) Then it put me back into the Main Menu. I tried to get back into the free roam but it wouldn't let me. Apparently, you can't play it once you've completed it. That is why this game doesn't have a higherI really enjoyed Mafia II but there is a slight issue, for me at least. I completed the campaign and I wasn't particularly satisfied with how the game ended (I will not spoil the story.) Then it put me back into the Main Menu. I tried to get back into the free roam but it wouldn't let me. Apparently, you can't play it once you've completed it. That is why this game doesn't have a higher rating. Because I hadn't collected all of the collectibles and I never will.… Expand
  68. BritishWolf
    Sep 21, 2015
    10
    This game is a cinematic, story-driven masterpiece that outshines the average open-world shooter (and yes, I have played the original game). The plot, though not without its cliches, was well constructed and had me engaged from the opening cut-scene. Even now, after playing the game half a dozen times, I am amazed at how well the story is told. Although there is not much to do once you'veThis game is a cinematic, story-driven masterpiece that outshines the average open-world shooter (and yes, I have played the original game). The plot, though not without its cliches, was well constructed and had me engaged from the opening cut-scene. Even now, after playing the game half a dozen times, I am amazed at how well the story is told. Although there is not much to do once you've completed the game (indeed, the map is rather lifeless and dull), it is still great.… Expand
  69. Jefferygamer200
    Sep 5, 2015
    6
    This game has a interesting setting, decent fighting and hijacking cars is rad. As for problems the Cops are always after you constantly, repairing cars takes a while. And this game is quite long which is good, in a way. You're only weapons are guns and your fists nothing else. It's a average game nothing to bad, yet nothing to go good either.
  70. Bo33y
    Sep 3, 2015
    2
    This game had an entertaining story only.

    The game play is a massive let down, driving is often like manoeuvring a tank. There is little differences between each of the various cars they all look and handle like a shed on wheels, otherwise a box. Excluding one, or two of the sporty exceptions. Shooting the guns and it is case of duck and fire, the AI rarely flank, and no matter the    This game had an entertaining story only.

    The game play is a massive let down, driving is often like manoeuvring a tank. There is little differences between each of the various cars they all look and handle like a shed on wheels, otherwise a box. Excluding one, or two of the sporty exceptions. Shooting the guns and it is case of duck and fire, the AI rarely flank, and no matter the difficulty, dead is dead as fast, without using cover or stealth. The clothing is all the same I don't feel I customised my character at all. The same with tany cars, their colour schemes and handling is almost as awful. The streets are full of cars, no matter what the time of day is and moving into head on traffic lanes the AI pulls into the opposing lane instead of steering to avoid collision. Accommodation owned isn't customised. Money is mostly absolutely pointless. Guns shops who needs them? There is no customisation on the various weapons used. Weapons are found with the ammo in abundance on each chapter. Fighting stinks, the moves are so limited, a motion of were they dead yet, yawn..

    The save system is done through story progression. What? The Dev's had an entertaining collectible in the form of some real dated porn, containing yucky tan lines and quite ugly awful 50's chicks. Apart from the one or two exceptions. These are collected in the chapter missions, most are easy finds, adding something else to the game. Although what was the point in collecting them? It wasn't like I was able to meet them, or date them in game. Just some rather ugly photo's. However what the hell were they thinking, making those wanted posters? 159 stupid pointless **** posters that all look the same, found in the most obscure locations, adding hours on to this really short game. I reckon they literally made them up, by taking pictures of themself and photo shopping a beard or haircut on. I mean who f'ing thought that they would be a fun idea to add into this game? I don't give a **** about jimmy the fish some f'ing smoe, and any of the rest of them. There was absolutely no point in exploring half of the map except to collect any wanted crap, but why than why the f would you bother?

    The chapters themselves take all of about 10 hours of game time from start to finish. Okay I agree within a some what entertaining story. Although the accents used mostly sounded wrong, they didn't really sound like goodfellas or wise guys.. The DLC's got a bit funner having better idea's on how to play a game, but the gameplay was still that same design, and the DLC were just too damn late. Today the DLC's cannot even be acquired anymore, because this game hasn't renewed the licensing..

    If your gonna make a mafia game A**holes. Make the Russian mob, Cartels,. Yakuza, Triads or IRA. Make a story about horse racing, gambling, casinos, weapon trafficking, human trafficking, everything smuggled from ivory to whatever electronics, and drugs. Fighting championships, assassinations, rampages, vehicle racing, girls and strippers. Make it something 18, starting in the streets or a prison and working up to owning the city and whatever other islands. Don't make another god awful GTA 5 story about absolute stinking bull****, it had some better ideas but those characters really stunk apart from gangster Trev but he was insane.. I don't want any **** collectibles that don't provide any reason to collect them. I want customisation on everything fom clothes, tattoos, body, haircut, accommodations, weapons, vehicles and girlfriends.

    Go on now and make a proper game instead of selling another ripped off cloned generic bull****. I bet they literally took some sucking GTA variable, pixeling in all of the rest, this game really stinks.    … Expand
  71. TrueGameOpinion
    Jul 28, 2015
    9
    TrueGamerOpinion here bringing you the truest opinion that one man can count on! Mafia 2 is the sequel to the highly influential and cult classic game Mafia 1. In this story you leave off after the end of World War 2 bringing you on many adventures that await the main character of Vito Scaletta and the second main character named Joe Barbaro. Mafia 2 involves lots of rich and deep storyTrueGamerOpinion here bringing you the truest opinion that one man can count on! Mafia 2 is the sequel to the highly influential and cult classic game Mafia 1. In this story you leave off after the end of World War 2 bringing you on many adventures that await the main character of Vito Scaletta and the second main character named Joe Barbaro. Mafia 2 involves lots of rich and deep story telling along with great gameplay mechanics that make you feel like you are a part of the mafia itself. The characters and everything surrounding the game is well told and understandable to see just how the first game ties in with the second one nearly a decade later. The game is almost as masterful as the first one but it does fall short in some areas, but its not bad enough to keep you distracted from being pulled in the games rich story and gameplay. Mafia 2 is a worthy successor to the first game and is seen by many as well as being understood but to the real fans and gamers out there who saw the potential this game had it will be noted in history as one of the best. This is Mafia 2.… Expand
  72. LuanGamer
    Jun 12, 2015
    7
    Dia 16 tem e3 e finalmente vou fazer minha Crítica ao mafia 2 . Eu zerei mafia 2 duas vezes , mafia 2 é um jogo com uma história ótima mais muito mal como podemos dizer "investida" , eu como futuro produtor de games "investiria" muito mais nessa historia muito ótimo , o roteirista tirou um 10 , mais a outra parte da equipe vacilou neh , praticamente podemos dizer " 15 missões " pra umDia 16 tem e3 e finalmente vou fazer minha Crítica ao mafia 2 . Eu zerei mafia 2 duas vezes , mafia 2 é um jogo com uma história ótima mais muito mal como podemos dizer "investida" , eu como futuro produtor de games "investiria" muito mais nessa historia muito ótimo , o roteirista tirou um 10 , mais a outra parte da equipe vacilou neh , praticamente podemos dizer " 15 missões " pra um jogo que prometei tanto ai é fod* , então recomendo esse jogo para quem quer um jogo para zerar apenas isso .… Expand
  73. dajhorn
    Jun 6, 2015
    5
    Mafia II is like a Grand Theft Auto episode on rails. It has a world and a basic linear campaign, but not enough material for sandbox fun or side missions. This results in low replay value.

    Some parts of the game are polished, and things like the licensed Playboy media are novel, but it isn't enough to make Mafia II a worthwhile purchase.
  74. Moensgrl1
    May 29, 2015
    0
    First of all the amount of traffic is way over-done. I wish game creators would stop trying so hard to push realism because this game is a good example of what happens when game creators try to hard with realism. How am I suppose to keep my car on the road let alone stop my car at a red light when Its constantly snowing or raining. Another thing that made me sick with this game is the factFirst of all the amount of traffic is way over-done. I wish game creators would stop trying so hard to push realism because this game is a good example of what happens when game creators try to hard with realism. How am I suppose to keep my car on the road let alone stop my car at a red light when Its constantly snowing or raining. Another thing that made me sick with this game is the fact that I can even sneeze without the cops turning around and wanting to chase me down for it. Really guys! The game started out ok, but started loosing interest real fast. Problem is even when a game is **** if I start it I almost always have to finish it, But this one I Can't. So the only plus I can give to this game is the fact it has lifted my curse of having to finish games even if they are crap. To finish up my review I will say to the game creators there is a huge difference between fun and frustration. It's a game, it's a game, It's a freaking game. Knock off the horse **** realism and get back to pure fun gaming… Expand
  75. Ventura94
    May 18, 2015
    10
    Great game and interesting story! I have started it not a long time ago and I can't play anything else, its a great game and also its realistic and typically based on the years 1940 to 1950s
  76. MrFunkman
    May 13, 2015
    8
    +Great story!
    +Good sandbox map

    -not the best graphical wise with screen blurring

    Looking forward to a sequel if there ever will be one!

    8/10 Recommend it
  77. LegendaryNOFX
    May 13, 2015
    8
    Mafia II is one of those games that delivers IF you are seeking a more story driven game than a open world sandbox type game. The voice acting and music in the game is wonderful. In fact, the radio play lists are top notch and remind me of the music in the Bioshock series. The cars and weapons feel and sound like they are straight out of the 1940-50's so you need to be into that sort ofMafia II is one of those games that delivers IF you are seeking a more story driven game than a open world sandbox type game. The voice acting and music in the game is wonderful. In fact, the radio play lists are top notch and remind me of the music in the Bioshock series. The cars and weapons feel and sound like they are straight out of the 1940-50's so you need to be into that sort of thing for this game to work for you.

    There are some really memorable moments in this game, and the soundtrack at times plays into some of the banter back and forth between the very well developed characters. Another moment that I kept finding hilarious was Joe complaining every time I hit another car or blew through a red light while driving.

    There are collectibles so I don't really see why people think there is not...I mean PLAYBOYS and PIN UPS!!!

    If you are willing to take into account that this game is more story and mission centered then you will have a fun time playing this game. The game is engrossing enough to make you think about what you just played after you have completed the game.    … Expand
  78. SirPercivale
    Feb 1, 2015
    8
    Look this game came out 5 years ago and it was a huge success for 2K Czech.Maybe they could do more content, story lines and most important multiplayer.That would give a long gameplay to game and we would be still playing it.
  79. Winterspark
    Dec 28, 2014
    5
    For a game about being a gangster in the 1950s, you seem to spend an inordinately long time driving around the pleasantly detailed city in classic cars. And with no ability to save the game when you feel like wandering off and enjoying the city you are largely confined to the staggeringly short story of 15 so-called missions of which a third are glorified cut scenes and the others largelyFor a game about being a gangster in the 1950s, you seem to spend an inordinately long time driving around the pleasantly detailed city in classic cars. And with no ability to save the game when you feel like wandering off and enjoying the city you are largely confined to the staggeringly short story of 15 so-called missions of which a third are glorified cut scenes and the others largely involve driving and/or creeping around. Perhaps the game would have been better titled "casual taxi driver prone to very occasional use of firearms."… Expand
  80. metacriticality
    Dec 17, 2014
    9
    Top Notch story and gameplayer! The story is better than most movies in a similar theme. The length of the story is very well done. Being able to see the world through 1940s , 50s, 60s is a real treat.

    Highly recommended if you like mafia / shooters with a great story.
    Popcorn worthy!
  81. Matty2012
    Oct 19, 2014
    9
    One of the best games ever created. I've been gaming since gaming began, and this game goes down in my top 8 games of all time. The story is great, the gameplay is solid, and the graphics are brilliant and still look brilliant in 2014. It is one of them rare games that makes you feel like your actually there. A very well made solid game. The only thing negative i can say about it is theOne of the best games ever created. I've been gaming since gaming began, and this game goes down in my top 8 games of all time. The story is great, the gameplay is solid, and the graphics are brilliant and still look brilliant in 2014. It is one of them rare games that makes you feel like your actually there. A very well made solid game. The only thing negative i can say about it is the pedestrian AI, they are a bit dumb and not as good as in other open world games like Grand Theft Auto. But thankfully the enemy AI is much better. If you love open world games with a nice long engaging story, then this is a must own. Can't wait for Mafia 3.… Expand
  82. wincenzo
    Oct 9, 2014
    10
    oynadığım en güzel oyundur ve en keyif aldığım. bu oyunun üzerine fazla söz söylemek istemiyorum yaşayamadığım yılları bana yaşattı adeta...
  83. Rahsmoove
    Jul 24, 2014
    8
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Mafia 2 is very great. The story strong, but depressing at the same time. The way the game ended was good, but not awesome either. After Killing Falcone, Vito gets in a car, with Leo. Turns out Joe was going to be killed because he wasn't a part of the deal, and after the game ends and if you want to go exploring you have to start the game over. I hated that. However The Storyline is great. Vito finding out that Derek was the one who killed his father, going to jail, getting your house set on fire felt real. The setting of a 1950's fictional city (Empire Bay) was sort of good but confusing. It felt like a replica of NYC, but missing a bunch of parts. It didn't really capture NYC, like GTA IV's Liberty City did. But a very great game, I would recommend this game if you're into open world games.… Expand
  84. JSXero
    Apr 7, 2014
    9
    Mafia II is a near perfect sandbox game that whilst following genre trends, keeps it in it's own distinctive style that separates it from the rest, but being an awesome experience at the same time.

    While the driving is slow, clunky and boring, the combat is terrific, really feeling like a full on 3PS experience instead of feeling loosely tacked on like other sandbox games. In Mafia II    Mafia II is a near perfect sandbox game that whilst following genre trends, keeps it in it's own distinctive style that separates it from the rest, but being an awesome experience at the same time.

    While the driving is slow, clunky and boring, the combat is terrific, really feeling like a full on 3PS experience instead of feeling loosely tacked on like other sandbox games. In Mafia II you have to think, you have to hide, the shoot outs are brutal, and not to be taken lightly. Everything feels gritty and realistic. Shotgun blasts will destroy you or your enemies, they wont be simply shaken off by a quick jog behind a dumpster.

    Mafia II doesn't joke around with it's subject manner, from it's storyline to it's brutal shootouts and contract kills, you don't feel like your playing the average glorification of a crime sim. This is deep stuff and it benefits from it. There are no wacky characters or weapons, this is the real thing, and while it could be slow and plodding for some, it is engaging to the end. An excellent take on a genre that follows suit one to many times.    … Expand
  85. IronPrometheus
    Feb 15, 2014
    10
    Video 10/10 The best ever!!
    Sounds 8/10
    Playboys 10/10 The Best!
    Gameplay 8/10
    Optimization 10/10 Best!!
    Story 10/10
    Game time 1/10 Mafia 2 just 10-15 hours O.o
    All gamers must play this game in they life.
  86. PastorHagbart
    Jan 17, 2014
    9
    This game is so beautiful. the enviroment have this great appearing. i love the soundtrack, very dramatic. the cinematic scenes is fantastic and they pulled that off in a way i've never seen before. the story is good as well. i also like the voice actors, especially Joe's. reminds me of anthony soprano in sopranos. even though some of the voice acting is a little bit overwhelming, i still like it.
  87. Moffen
    Jan 13, 2014
    9
    If you're looking for a game with a great story, good character development and a good look into the life of organized crime, this is the game for you. First the story is very good. It revolves around Vito Scarletta and his best-friend Joe. The two protagonist try to make it big and join the mob family. The game starts a little slow and can be a little boring at the start, but trust me, itIf you're looking for a game with a great story, good character development and a good look into the life of organized crime, this is the game for you. First the story is very good. It revolves around Vito Scarletta and his best-friend Joe. The two protagonist try to make it big and join the mob family. The game starts a little slow and can be a little boring at the start, but trust me, it gets much better. When the story drives forward it gets more interesting as you have to figure out who to trust, and who to no trust. No spoilers, the game has a lot of great plot-twists. Another thing the game does great is show the consequences of the mob-life. The game does a great job at showing the corruption and greed a life of organized can, and probably will, bring. But even if the story is very good and will keep you glued to the screen, there is some problems. The biggest one is that the game feels uncompleted. I get that it's a story-based game, but I can't help to feel like the world is empty and lifeless. Besides the missions there isn't that much to do. You can drive cars, buy new suits and rob stores, but that's about it. They could have done a lot more and let's hope that they take notes for the third installment of the franchise (If it comes out.)

    A great game you should 100% pick up if you are looking for a great story. But don't have your hopes up for sticking around after the game is complete.    … Expand
  88. FreeReviewer
    Jan 4, 2014
    9
    2K's Mafia 2 is and exemplary example of fantastic characters, gripping story, and masterful storytelling. The game centers on the story of Vito Scaletta and his tale of rising through the Empire Bay crime scene in the 1940s and 1950s. Along the way, and with his best friend Joe Barbaro, he and Vito travel through a difficult and long journey that ends only after an intense final act.2K's Mafia 2 is and exemplary example of fantastic characters, gripping story, and masterful storytelling. The game centers on the story of Vito Scaletta and his tale of rising through the Empire Bay crime scene in the 1940s and 1950s. Along the way, and with his best friend Joe Barbaro, he and Vito travel through a difficult and long journey that ends only after an intense final act.

    The characters in this game are absolutely and utterly fantastic, and even minor characters with small roles and mostly unknown stories leave a pleasant and memorable mark on the game. Vito and Joe share a great chemistry, and the player will become attached to both in no time. The mafia bosses and leaders are also all unique with various personalities. Leo Galante is an extremely wonderful secondary character and serves as a guide to Vito and mentor.

    The story is short, but well written and should never have any slow moments or uninteresting situations. It's very cleverly written and twists in the plot are sometimes not seen coming, but always sensible.

    Game-play is average, but the driving and amount of detail in the game is simply outstanding. While the combat is basic and the level of customization, those aspects make up for it completely.

    In all, Mafia 2 is game to be enjoyed by the gamer who values story and character, as well as action, but not wide customization.    … Expand
  89. funboyfun23
    Oct 14, 2013
    8
    I enjoyed this game, everything about this game is fun and unique. Not much games base their setting in the 40's and 50's making this game unique, also it being a mafia type game makes it really fun. It's easy to dump 3-5 hours into this game without even knowing it, just because of it's awesome game-play and story.

    You will have fun with this game and it sticks to the main plot so you    I enjoyed this game, everything about this game is fun and unique. Not much games base their setting in the 40's and 50's making this game unique, also it being a mafia type game makes it really fun. It's easy to dump 3-5 hours into this game without even knowing it, just because of it's awesome game-play and story.

    You will have fun with this game and it sticks to the main plot so you don't need to worry about having to do annoying side missions which you would see a lot in the Saints Row games. The plot of this game is where this game is strongest at and with every curve ball makes this game really interesting, you will want to be playing this game over others easily.

    What it lacks is customization, NOT saying there isn't any, but it would be nice to see more customization for cars and clothes for you're character would have gave the game more of a shine. Also the check point's in this game is really annoying. Defiantly if you get into a big gang fights you tend to die a lot sometimes, and the game will reset you to where you were 5-10 minutes earlier before you died making it really annoying to play at some points.

    None the less this game is really fun, the game-play is solid, plot is good, shoot outs are a ton of fun and in the end I have to say I recommend this game to anyone and is defiantly worth paying for!    … Expand
  90. NBAluke579
    Oct 10, 2013
    8
    One of the most underrated games I have ever played. Mafia 2 is a hidden gem, and one of the finest games I've played on the Xbox 360. Where do I even begin? The story here is extremely gripping, and is interesting every step of the way.The characters are sympathetic and fleshed out extremely well.There are subtle nods to films like Goodfellas and The Godfather here, and the game createsOne of the most underrated games I have ever played. Mafia 2 is a hidden gem, and one of the finest games I've played on the Xbox 360. Where do I even begin? The story here is extremely gripping, and is interesting every step of the way.The characters are sympathetic and fleshed out extremely well.There are subtle nods to films like Goodfellas and The Godfather here, and the game creates an immersive atmosphere. The soundtrack is fantastic. The gameplay is solid, and the graphics are beautiful.The main problems with the game are that there really isn't anything to do once your done with the 12-13 hour campaign. There's no multiplayer or anything of the sort, so the story is all you get. Still it's a fantastic game and worth playing just for the story. My rating:8.7/10… Expand
  91. DBurnsee
    Oct 7, 2013
    7
    Mafia II is a good game Not a great game. A solid game. The points that Mafia II excelled in is definitely the story. It feels great to go visit Empire Bay and be a member of a notorious crime family. The characters are incredible. The main character Vito is very strong in the lead role. Not to mention his best friend Joe, who grows on you instantly and you begin to care about him. TheMafia II is a good game Not a great game. A solid game. The points that Mafia II excelled in is definitely the story. It feels great to go visit Empire Bay and be a member of a notorious crime family. The characters are incredible. The main character Vito is very strong in the lead role. Not to mention his best friend Joe, who grows on you instantly and you begin to care about him. The areas that this game lacks in is the game play. The gun fights feel really clunky and it's hard to get your shots on target I was playing on the hardest difficulty) But that doesn't break the game Overall Mafia II is a good experience for someone looking for a game with a fantastic story. The game clocks in around 12 hours. So at the price that it is now. I recommend a buy.… Expand
  92. kev_i_n
    Sep 18, 2013
    6
    Summary
    +Good story with impactful moments, particularly in the 40s/50s setting.
    +Interesting combat that is surprisingly difficult +Great characters with each of their own unique personalities -The story in moments is confusing, yet in others is very predictable (particularly the end) -There should be more emphasis on free roaming, as free roaming is limited. -The driving can feel    Summary
    +Good story with impactful moments, particularly in the 40s/50s setting.
    +Interesting combat that is surprisingly difficult
    +Great characters with each of their own unique personalities
    -The story in moments is confusing, yet in others is very predictable (particularly the end)
    -There should be more emphasis on free roaming, as free roaming is limited.
    -The driving can feel clunky, and the use of police restricting gameplay can be annoying.

    Full Review
    The first thing to say about Mafia 2 is that the story is very unique in that it really demonstrates the dark nature of the gangster life style. This is particularly true with regards to how throughout the game your character will constantly be brought back from achieving any major success, and gets screwed over a lot. This in combination with great characters, in particularly Joe (who is surprisingly funny, while at the same time useful in combat) makes for a great story. Furthermore your character, Vito, is very interesting in the sense that his loyalty isn’t always where you think it is. This helps to make your character feel more hard done by, because he wants to gain power, yet his mixed loyalties prevent him from doing so. However unlike other games in this genre, most of the sub characters, like Henry, are also well executed. This is particularly enhanced with good voice acting.

    Unfortunately with regards to the story there are some issues. The first is that the story particularly when the other gangs within the city get involved can feel confusing at time, and difficult to follow. That said the explanations within the cut scenes help clarification. The second issue is how predictable the story is at moments, as you always know that the dark nature of the story prevents things from being as smooth as it should. This is particularly true of the ending which ends on a really shallow note that can be seen from a mile away. However possible the main issue is how the story feels too short, as you never actually get to play as Vito when he gains major success. This means that if you want to play as a Mafia boss and feel like a powerful badass, Godfather 2 is probably the game for you despite its falls.

    Nevertheless the story’s falls can be sort of forgiven as a result of the combat. The combat is broken down into melee and gun combat. The melee is ok but a bit easy once you unlock the ability to counter-attack. That said the melee is certainly better than it is in GTA4, but not as good as Sleeping Dogs. However the main combat is of course gun combat. This is a lot of fun as unlike other gang theme games, like Saints Row 2, even on normal difficultly gun combat is surprisingly challenging. This is because of a combination of surprisingly clever enemy A.I, e.g. they will try and outflank, other enemies will suicide charge while you are shot at by other enemies; and the fact that it can take less than four shots to kill you, and some weapons like the shotgun can kill you in one shot (the only drawback is that this can lead to a lot of trial and error). That said I feel that the combat could be improved with more weapon variety, and make each weapon feel different, as you will fine (particularly with the machine guns) that a lot of the weapons feel very similar. There also should have been more variety of throw able weapons, and they should have appeared more frequently for you to use.

    Also another thing to mention, which I personally like is the fact that like in “Scarface: The World is Yours”, gaining police attention is largely discouraged because if you get caught doing a crime in a car or certain clothing, you will become wanted meaning every time the police are nearby you will get a wanted level. While such restriction can be limiting, it is surprisingly well executed and gives the game some uniqueness.

    There are only two major complaints I have with the game. The first is that there is very little to do in free-roaming, as you can rod stores, sell cars, buy clothes/guns, improve cars, and that’s basically it. It is obvious that the game is focused on story, because each of the chapters is basically a long mission, giving you limited free-roaming opportunities. I feel that the developers should have place more functionality in free-roam as it would help give the game more replay-ability.

    The second complaint is the driving in the game. For me it feels clunky and a bit frustrating at times. Now this could be forgiven if the majority of gameplay isn’t driving. Unfortunately you will quickly realise a lot of gameplay is just driving around, e.g. you will often have to drive Joe home, them drive yourself home which is on the other side of a surprisingly large map. I can understand that because the cars are based in the 40s and 50s the designers weren’t going to make them as crisp as cars in games set in modern day, but you can’t help but wish that the cars were more fun to drive.    … Expand
  93. Rox22
    Sep 12, 2013
    5
    I actually preferred the first game to this one. Mafia 2 is bigger, has better graphics and a stronger story, but where it suffers is in its gameplay.

    Mafia 2 is meant to be an open world game, yet it feels like you are on rails most of the time. The main story id VERY good and excellently executed, but side missions are almost non-existent. and exploration feels pointless (old playboy    I actually preferred the first game to this one. Mafia 2 is bigger, has better graphics and a stronger story, but where it suffers is in its gameplay.

    Mafia 2 is meant to be an open world game, yet it feels like you are on rails most of the time. The main story id VERY good and excellently executed, but side missions are almost non-existent. and exploration feels pointless (old playboy cover collectibles are not much of an incentive when you consider how much "better" content is available online.)

    Overall:
    Mafia 2 does try to be better than the first game, and for the most part it does that successfully. But, as a game it feels a bit limp and feels more like you are traveling from one cut scene to the next. I can understand that many people will like this, but I didn't.    … Expand
  94. TheZeroPercent
    Jul 18, 2013
    8
    This game is AWESOME!!! for about 3-5 hrs, then it becomes quite obvious that that 'certain something' that makes for a 'top notch' game, is certainly missing from this one.
    Still worth a play through though, IMO.
  95. Aker
    Jul 15, 2013
    8
    Great gameplay, great story, great music, great environment, great vehicles, the only thing it lacked was things to do in the free roam world. There's hardly any interaction with non-story related characters, meaning there are no side missions. But with that being said I still easily put 20 hours of play time into the game, it's well worth the money.
  96. Compi24
    Jul 4, 2013
    7
    Its characters and environment may feel sincerely disconnected from the player at times, but the rest of "Mafia II" will tend to impress for the most part.
  97. M9ki
    Jul 1, 2013
    7
    This was a pretty good game I have to admit, but in some area's it was a drag.Spolier alert There is a mafia 3 on the making.My disc froze so I did not really get to enjoy it.
  98. NikolayG
    Jun 4, 2013
    10
    One of the best games ever made. Great acting. Great visuals. Great story. Great gameplay. It confounds me that this is not universally acclaimed as a straight up 10.
  99. ICEExMagic
    Apr 28, 2013
    5
    This game shouldn't be called a open world game.The entire game you have to beat the story and if you explore a red line appears at the bottom and never leaves.The controls are also horrible.The game is okay but only if you rent it.
  100. Justinavery7074
    Apr 9, 2013
    7
    It's ok, I guess. Some times I felt I shoudl be playing something else, though. The story is so short. For games like this, the campaign should be extensive, lush and brimming with life. It's just oka
prev
Page:

Awards & Rankings

7
#7 Most Discussed Xbox 360 Game of 2010
11
#11 Most Shared Xbox 360 Game of 2010

Critic Reviews

All reviews »
Metascore
74

Mixed or average reviews - based on 79 Critic Reviews

Critic score distribution:
  1. Positive: 51 out of 79
  2. Mixed: 23 out of 79
  3. Negative: 5 out of 79
  1. Video Game Talk
    Jan 12, 2011
    60
    A great story that manages to make old ground seem fresh, coupled with out-of-this world sound design, is sadly attached to a middle-of-the-road, limited third-person gaming experience.
    Read full review
  2. GameSpot
    85
    Mafia II's exciting action and uncompromising mob story make for an impressive and violent adventure.
    Read full review
  3. Giant Bomb
    60
    I'm a sucker for a good mob story, but Mafia II's is merely decent.
    Read full review
See all critic reviews »