Super Mario Galaxy

 Wii
User Score
9.1

Universal acclaim- based on 4045 Ratings

User score distribution:
  1. Positive: 3,683 out of 4045
  2. Mixed: 164 out of 4045
  3. Negative: 198 out of 4045
Buy Now
Buy on

Review this game

  1. Your Score
    0 out of 10
    Rate this:
    • 10
    • 9
    • 8
    • 7
    • 6
    • 5
    • 4
    • 3
    • 2
    • 1
    • 0
    • 0
  1. Submit
  2. Check Spelling
view
per page
  1. Joeyburger1985
    Jul 25, 2023
    7
    This is a work of art, a masterpiece the storytelling is amazing. This game is very good in all facets. 10/10
  2. Fardnite
    Jun 9, 2023
    5
    Super Mario Galaxy, developed by Nintendo for the Wii console, is a mesmerizing and enchanting gaming experience that captivates players with its innovative gameplay, whimsical motifs, breathtaking visuals, and unforgettable soundtrack. This celestial adventure takes Mario to new heights as he embarks on a quest to rescue Princess Peach from the clutches of Bowser, exploring galaxies, andSuper Mario Galaxy, developed by Nintendo for the Wii console, is a mesmerizing and enchanting gaming experience that captivates players with its innovative gameplay, whimsical motifs, breathtaking visuals, and unforgettable soundtrack. This celestial adventure takes Mario to new heights as he embarks on a quest to rescue Princess Peach from the clutches of Bowser, exploring galaxies, and overcoming challenges along the way.

    At the core of Super Mario Galaxy is its gameplay, which seamlessly blends platforming mechanics with gravity-altering mechanics. Each galaxy presents a unique and imaginative environment where Mario must navigate treacherous landscapes and overcome gravity-defying obstacles. The level design is nothing short of brilliance, offering a perfect balance of challenge and accessibility. The precise controls and responsive motion controls of the Wii Remote make Mario's movements feel intuitive and satisfying. From gravity-flipping puzzles to exhilarating comet challenges, every moment is a delight for players of all skill levels.

    The game's motifs and themes are infused with a sense of wonder and discovery. The concept of exploring different galaxies, each with its own distinct theme and challenges, sparks the imagination and keeps players eagerly anticipating what lies beyond. From lush grassy worlds to fiery volcanic realms and even surreal dreamscapes, the game offers a stunning variety of environments. Nintendo's attention to detail is commendable, as each galaxy is meticulously crafted with vibrant colors, whimsical architecture, and imaginative inhabitants, bringing the game's universe to life.

    Accompanying the stunning visuals is an unforgettable musical score. Composed by the legendary Koji Kondo and Mahito Yokota, the soundtrack elevates the game to new heights. The orchestral arrangements perfectly capture the game's sense of grandeur and evoke a range of emotions. From the sweeping orchestral melodies of the main theme to the playful tunes that accompany each galaxy, the music enhances the overall experience, creating a magical atmosphere that immerses players in Mario's cosmic journey.

    The visual presentation of Super Mario Galaxy is a visual feast for the eyes. The game pushes the limits of the Wii console, delivering vibrant and detailed graphics. The character models are charmingly expressive, and the animations are fluid and lively. The breathtaking celestial landscapes, with their swirling galaxies and mesmerizing starry backdrops, create a sense of awe and wonder. The attention to detail in the level design is astonishing, with every nook and cranny of each galaxy filled with visual delights. From the smallest sparkling star bits to the massive bosses, the visuals are a testament to the creativity and craftsmanship of the development team.

    Furthermore, Super Mario Galaxy's replayability is exceptional. With over 120 stars to collect and hidden secrets to uncover, the game offers a wealth of content to keep players engaged long after the main story is complete. The addition of the Co-Star mode, where a second player can assist Mario on his journey, adds a cooperative element that enhances the multiplayer experience.

    In conclusion, Super Mario Galaxy is a masterpiece that showcases Nintendo's commitment to delivering exceptional gaming experiences. Its innovative gameplay, imaginative motifs, breathtaking visuals, and enchanting soundtrack combine to create an unforgettable adventure. Whether you're a longtime fan of the Mario franchise or a newcomer to the series, Super Mario Galaxy is a must-play game that will leave you starry-eyed and longing for more. Strap on Mario's iconic red cap, jump into your spaceship, and prepare for a cosmic journey like no other.    … Expand
  3. Zanchi
    May 22, 2023
    5
    The best game of all time. It's incredible how advanced was the game for 2007 including the gravity in the planets and all the whole galaxy's. The levels are awesome with great re-playability, and the post game it's kinda lazy buts ok
  4. Deviln
    Apr 28, 2023
    6
    Gameplay is good, I don’t pay attention to lore at all because its just a snoozefest and I want to play the game, but the lore is just alright nothing much.
  5. Uncle_Beth
    Apr 13, 2023
    5
    Super Mario Galaxy is a genuine step down from its predecessors in the 3D Mario series. It attempts to be Mario's most grand and accessible adventure yet, however, it suffers for it at almost every turn. Super Mario galaxy opts to be a more simple game than previous instalments in the series to appeal to a wider and younger audience. Gone are the open world style levels and complexSuper Mario Galaxy is a genuine step down from its predecessors in the 3D Mario series. It attempts to be Mario's most grand and accessible adventure yet, however, it suffers for it at almost every turn. Super Mario galaxy opts to be a more simple game than previous instalments in the series to appeal to a wider and younger audience. Gone are the open world style levels and complex mechanical movement based systems found Super Mario 64 and Sunshine. Levels are now linear and less engaging, Mario’s movement is exceedingly simplified and sluggish, and the puzzles are easier than they’ve ever been before. This is great for young or casual players, but loses the essence of what originally made 3D Mario great. While I appreciate the developers attempt at creating a diverse world, I find that the lack of consistency in theming detracts from the immersion, causing the world to feel un-relatable and “video gamey” to a fault. Additionally, while the idea behind having an all orchestral soundtrack is neat, the music in many instances falls flat or feels out of place which is uncharacteristic for Nintendo games. In my opinion the Galaxy series has some of the most forgettable music amongst prolific Nintendo games from their era. As a whole Super Mario galaxy succeeds at being a simple 3D Mario game that appeals to a general audience. However, it fails to bring many of the most successful core features that had defined the series thus far, let alone innovate on them. While I think Super Mario Galaxy has its place, I hope that it is the only time Nintendo deviates from the direction the series had previously been in with 64 and Sunshine, and gone back to with Super Mario Odyssey.… Expand
  6. spicy617
    Mar 4, 2023
    7
    Super Mario Galaxy is a total mess of a game. The levels are confusing and poorly designed, with random obstacles thrown in without any rhyme or reason. The controls are clunky and unresponsive, making it difficult to control Mario as he jumps and spins his way through the game's environments.

    The graphics are also terrible, with pixelated textures and blurry visuals that make it    Super Mario Galaxy is a total mess of a game. The levels are confusing and poorly designed, with random obstacles thrown in without any rhyme or reason. The controls are clunky and unresponsive, making it difficult to control Mario as he jumps and spins his way through the game's environments.

    The graphics are also terrible, with pixelated textures and blurry visuals that make it difficult to even see what's going on. The sound effects are equally grating, with annoying music and sound effects that will make your ears bleed.

    The game's storyline is also nonsensical and pointless, with Mario inexplicably floating around in space for no apparent reason. The game also lacks any sense of progression or challenge, with levels that are either too easy or too frustratingly difficult.

    Overall, Super Mario Galaxy is a total waste of time and money. The game's poor design, clunky controls, terrible graphics, and nonsensical storyline make it a game that no one should bother playing. Save your money and invest in something better.    … Expand
  7. Tabbou
    Jun 28, 2022
    6
    Not as good as people say, it sure is fun but the story is inexistant and 3D platform + gravity can be lethal.
    Llot of Nintendo supporters here I guess
  8. Mahrio
    Jun 25, 2022
    5
    How not to marvel at the physics of this game giving you countless possibilities to enjoy. The songs are a show apart.
  9. LikeOrNoLike
    Mar 27, 2022
    6
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Slow movement and extremely easy. Music is really good and surprisingly good boss fight against Bowser.… Expand
  10. milesg305
    May 8, 2021
    7
    Great game, and a huge part of my childhood. The aesthetics are on point and the storytelling, especially in Rosalina's library, is really something to behold for a Nintendo game.
  11. DistH
    Feb 28, 2021
    5
    Ok so this game is Good in 3d all stars but in the Wii the force you to use motion controls that is frustrating. I literally broke my Wii remote because of this Game. there are soo many levels in this game that makes is nearly impossible to beat this game in the Wii. I like the Story tho. the power ups are cool. if this game wasn't on the Wii it would probably be better but if you want theOk so this game is Good in 3d all stars but in the Wii the force you to use motion controls that is frustrating. I literally broke my Wii remote because of this Game. there are soo many levels in this game that makes is nearly impossible to beat this game in the Wii. I like the Story tho. the power ups are cool. if this game wasn't on the Wii it would probably be better but if you want the best version it's on the Switch.… Expand
  12. awesomesuace
    Dec 14, 2020
    7
    I didn't know mario judah has own game and it very great!!! Mario looks like mario judah but mario white and I love mario judah music
  13. TatsMcGee
    Sep 8, 2018
    5
    What Kind of Adventure?

    Platforming Adventure Was it fun? No, it wasn’t. My friends were telling me how great this game was. So I borrowed it from one of them and at best I was content and mostly I was annoyed. Are there any similar games? It reminds me of a really poorly made, Super Mario 3D World. Favorite Character? No one. Would you play it again? I tried    What Kind of Adventure?

    Platforming Adventure

    Was it fun?

    No, it wasn’t. My friends were telling me how great this game was. So I borrowed it from one of them and at best I was content and mostly I was annoyed.

    Are there any similar games?

    It reminds me of a really poorly made, Super Mario 3D World.

    Favorite Character?

    No one.

    Would you play it again?

    I tried this game twice and I had to stop both times.

    Any Complaints?

    I didn’t like the controls on the game and although there aren’t a lot. There are enough motion controls to be annoying. I didn’t like all the gravity changes and going upside down and all the camera angle changes. There’s a lot about this game that didn’t work for me.

    How many hours did you play it?

    I played this game for about 4 hours. I gave it a fair chance and just didn’t like it. I know its a popular game and I legitimately tried to like it but I just couldn’t.    … Expand
  14. Kick454
    Apr 20, 2018
    6
    This game has a fanbase worse than the Bubonic Plauge, and I wish I was joking. This game is OVERRATED AS HECK. It would not stop crashing before the final boss and when I found out what the final battle was... well, Galaxy went from a 10 to a 6.5 (ok, there are other issues I have with the game, but that was a MASSIVE disappointment). I haven't been as disappointed in a game in my life.This game has a fanbase worse than the Bubonic Plauge, and I wish I was joking. This game is OVERRATED AS HECK. It would not stop crashing before the final boss and when I found out what the final battle was... well, Galaxy went from a 10 to a 6.5 (ok, there are other issues I have with the game, but that was a MASSIVE disappointment). I haven't been as disappointed in a game in my life.

    Pros:
    + Soundtrack: Overrated, but... decent. Also, not that memorable aside from Gusty Garden (which is the only song that I loved from the game).

    Mix:
    = Level Design: "OdYSsEY hAsS ThE WoRSTESt LEveL DesSIGN!!11!11" Galaxy ALMOST has the worst level design due to the copy-paste levels (Honeyhive and Gold Leaf Galaxy), but Sunshine's Beach + Random thing theme seemed to make it worse.

    Cons:
    - Gameplay: "GALAXY HAS THE BESTEST GAMEPLAY" Shut up Galaxy fanboys! If spinning pleases you so much, why don't you literally go do it right now? Also, the motion controls make me want to puke.
    - Story: I'm honestly putting this here mostly for the fanboys, but also due to the fact that I personally don't like Galaxy 1/2's stories that much.
    - Bosses: ...Copypasta the Game.

    All in all, Super Mario Galaxy is not the best game of all time, nor is it the best Mario game of all time, and I personally would warrant it a 6.5/10. Also, shut up about Galaxy 3. (Also I didn't deduct any points because of the fanbase, I deducted because of actual issues I've had with the game).    … Expand
  15. Sdfgboy
    Jan 17, 2018
    7
    To be honest, this is the type of game where you just want to shout "The sequel is better!".
    It is still a fun game, but it badly aged.
    My real unique problem is the camera.
    I hope for a trequel of the series.
  16. JdubbzReviews
    Oct 6, 2017
    7
    This game is very infuriating due too difficulty and the camera angles. The camera is the only thing that holds this game back. This game has arguably the best graphics on the Wii. This game is good but not a game that deserves the top game. Sorry i just thought i would be honest. Its fun and boring at the same time.
  17. artificeprime
    Jun 16, 2017
    7
    A very fun platformer with some really interesting puzzles but other than that it doesn't offer much depth. If you are looking for a game to play casually after a long day this game offers plenty of fun but I just can't understand how it is considered one of the best games of all time. The game certainly isn't bad but it is very simplistic. The gameplay is solid and the game has a lot ofA very fun platformer with some really interesting puzzles but other than that it doesn't offer much depth. If you are looking for a game to play casually after a long day this game offers plenty of fun but I just can't understand how it is considered one of the best games of all time. The game certainly isn't bad but it is very simplistic. The gameplay is solid and the game has a lot of charm but in most areas it is average. I find it strange that people dock games like Zelda or Final Fantasy points when their stories falter a bit but Mario gets a pass despite its story being a random mess. Most platformers aren't exactly known for their story telling but even among platformers Mario Galaxy's story and progression is below average.

    The gameplay is really good in most areas, the mechanics are simple and responsive. Menus are simple and functional. There are quite a good variety of puzzles and challenges to solve but they didn't really seem to offer meaningful discoveries. The reward for completing challenges is really just more of the same, other games do a much better job of giving the player collectibles that actually impact gameplay in a way that enhances the experience. There are some really cool game mechanics but some of the best ones are limited to specific areas which made the game feel more like a collection of mini-games. While almost everything works well the game doesn't offer as much freedom as many of the best platformers.

    The Visuals are fun and colorful but they aren't really groundbreaking in any way, it doesn't look much better than Mario Sunshine looked and they certainly don't stack up with a lot of games that came out around the same time. I don't expect Mario to look realistic of course but it still needs more creative visual designs in order to merit a high score.

    The music and sound design if fine but nothing ground breaking Mario makes his typical sounds. The soundtrack is fitting enough but none of the songs really stood out to me as being exceptional.

    The world is really cool, with many planets of varying designs. I found the mechanics of the planets themselves to be one of the most appealing aspects of the game and reaching new worlds almost always offered something new and interesting. I think the idea of mini-planets could have been used in more creative ways. While there is a decent amount of variety there is also a lot of repetition.

    Overall I think Mario Galaxy is a good game and it is worth playing. There is a lot of content and most of it is enjoyable but it is no where near being one of the best games of all time.

    I give Mario Galaxy a 75%    … Expand
  18. Captain_Faramir
    Apr 1, 2017
    7
    7.8 - Was a huge fan of Sunshine and 64, but this one didn't feel the same. Still generally a fun and good game, but things like music, level design and abilities were not nearly as cool.
  19. andree1991
    Nov 10, 2015
    5
    What a disappointment this game is. it's just a dumbed down 3d platformer. the wiimote sucks for this game. And you cant even do all the cool moves you could do in mario 64, you know, in 1996? It confines you to a little area so you don't get lost and dont feel too bad about yourself if you suck at it. This is the Nintendo audience now, soccer moms and children.
  20. TharosTheDragon
    Sep 27, 2015
    7
    It meets Nintendo's high standards of quality, and you're almost guaranteed to have fun with this game, but all that goes without saying. This game is clearly trying to be another Mario 64 and it fails to do so. Mario 64 allows you to explore each level like an adventure game. In Mario Galaxy, you have to pick which star you're going for before you even start the level, and then it's justIt meets Nintendo's high standards of quality, and you're almost guaranteed to have fun with this game, but all that goes without saying. This game is clearly trying to be another Mario 64 and it fails to do so. Mario 64 allows you to explore each level like an adventure game. In Mario Galaxy, you have to pick which star you're going for before you even start the level, and then it's just linear like an old-fashioned Mario game. There are plenty of cool gimmicks, but the lack of risks on the developers' parts makes this game a whitewashed experience.… Expand
  21. Steeldude
    Oct 13, 2014
    6
    It's really hard to control Mario and camera sometimes, leading to frustrating moments. Also, I am not a fan of the concept "repeat the same level 10 times and always do something slightly differently", I prefer platformers where each level is a unique experience.
  22. Javis
    Jun 4, 2013
    6
    What happened in here? This game is so wrong, too few levels and when they are easy, literally, THEY ARE VERY EASY, but they want them to be hard... OMG THEY ARE VERY, VERY HARD. And the game has many incoherences. The design of the planets are wonderful, I admit that, but when I play in them, I get dizzy. The good thing is that the new power and hilarious, and makes the game fun.
  23. IrishChai
    Aug 7, 2011
    7
    This is easily the best platformer I have ever played. It feels like it raises the bar to a level that I would never need another platformer again. In all fairness, I am not a big fan of platform games so I don't spend a lot of time with the genre, but this is just one of those quality games that goes above and beyond traditional expectations of a particular genre. The only real problem IThis is easily the best platformer I have ever played. It feels like it raises the bar to a level that I would never need another platformer again. In all fairness, I am not a big fan of platform games so I don't spend a lot of time with the genre, but this is just one of those quality games that goes above and beyond traditional expectations of a particular genre. The only real problem I have with it is the label. Do we really need another Super Mario? Please Nintendo, call it anything you want and make the main character look like anyone else but please move on from Mario/Zelda/Metroid. These same game mechanics could easily be used with a new IP to freshen things up a bit. It's getting to the point where I can't bare to look at another one of these three brands unless it comes with a 90+ consensus review score to help me see past the same increasingly irritating main character.… Expand
  24. ArkonBlade
    Mar 24, 2011
    7
    when it comes to platforming games mario has been king for along time . mario 64 is probubly the greatest of all time in that area. SMG not so much. its still a good game with some nice level desighn's . the controls are decent although it still leaves me wishing i could just use a damn game cube controllor over the wii's , the camera is dreadful for the most part since you are runningwhen it comes to platforming games mario has been king for along time . mario 64 is probubly the greatest of all time in that area. SMG not so much. its still a good game with some nice level desighn's . the controls are decent although it still leaves me wishing i could just use a damn game cube controllor over the wii's , the camera is dreadful for the most part since you are running around on small planets it does a sky view which just makes it feel kinda off and made me wish for the mario 64 camera (all be it not great was far better then this) its also kinda easy but most mario games are but not this easy . its still a fun game that captures for the most part the mario magic but it isnt as good as mario 64 or super mario 3 or world and just a hair better then sunshine .… Expand
  25. ss4mario
    Mar 9, 2011
    7
    It's definitely one of the better titles on the Wii, but it obviously lacks in some areas, such as polish, freedom, and re-playability. Unlike Super Mario 64, I feel like the game is linear, not letting you solve many problems on your own. While it is a fantastic attempt, it ABSOLUTELY does not deserve the flood of 100's critics game it, putting it higher than even Half-Life 2.
  26. Kurateesi
    Feb 25, 2011
    7
    While at least somewhat impressive on all fronts, Galaxy suffers from repetition, extreme linearity and lack of details. Controlling Mario is a little messy with strange tacked-on IR pointing (which, on the other hand, brings about some welcome multitasking), some minor jumping and falling stickiness and not too smooth underwater controls. Did complete and enjoy. Inferior to Mario 64,While at least somewhat impressive on all fronts, Galaxy suffers from repetition, extreme linearity and lack of details. Controlling Mario is a little messy with strange tacked-on IR pointing (which, on the other hand, brings about some welcome multitasking), some minor jumping and falling stickiness and not too smooth underwater controls. Did complete and enjoy. Inferior to Mario 64, Sunshine and Galaxy 2.… Expand
  27. TitaniumDragon
    Nov 14, 2010
    5
    This game is strictly mediocre. While it is okay for a while, it suffers from several large problems. The biggest problem is that, while it is a 3D platformer, it lacks exploration - the game is extremely linear, and most levels have to be completed in a single way. Worse, this game is inferior to previous titles in the series - Mario 64 had a lot of exploration in it, but this game lacksThis game is strictly mediocre. While it is okay for a while, it suffers from several large problems. The biggest problem is that, while it is a 3D platformer, it lacks exploration - the game is extremely linear, and most levels have to be completed in a single way. Worse, this game is inferior to previous titles in the series - Mario 64 had a lot of exploration in it, but this game lacks that exploration aspect. You can't randomly go for other stars, and the stars aren't clever in any way. The worlds are sadly less interesting than the Mario 64 equivalents.

    The much-vaunted planetary aspect SEEMS like it would be cool, but it almost always is actually a total letdown - almost all the planets with their gravity are lame, and only in a few places in the game can you actually do cool things with them, and I strongly suspect the team actually never intended for me to be able to do what is ACTUALLY fun with the gravity.

    The game is also extremely easy - many modern games are very easy, but this game is exceedingly so. Bafflingly, it still has a lives system, despite the fact that it is utterly irrelevant - you have effectively infinite lives, and yet they remain in the game for no good reason. Moreover, it is so easy you are never going to game over.

    The central staging area is also less enjoyable than what has been present in other games - in this game, the central staging area is like the levels, boring. In Mario 64, the castle was an interesting place to explore in its own right, being its own "level" of sorts with its own secrets, but the spaceship is just a boring place without interesting places to put its levels, and you progress through it in a very linear and not very interesting fashion.

    Perhaps the biggest letdown is the repetitive worlds - there is one world which shows up twice, and it was only okay the first time. The second time, it is simply tedious and uninteresting. Other sections of the game are a bit overly repetitive as well.

    While there are some fun areas in the game, most of it is just boring and not clever, and the game is actually worse than Mario 64, a game a decade older in the same series.

    This game is greatly overrated. I'd recommend against purchasing it.    … Expand
  28. Para-Dox
    Oct 21, 2010
    7
    Super Mario Galaxy is a must have for everyone. It's visuals are amazing and the music is brilliant (if not exactly fitting.) The gameplay doesn't stray far away from it's roots; it also has a few clever levels. The difficulty level is brilliant but a bit too hard for children. I don't really like the controls much; they feel a bit weird for me, and shaking the wii remote gets a bitSuper Mario Galaxy is a must have for everyone. It's visuals are amazing and the music is brilliant (if not exactly fitting.) The gameplay doesn't stray far away from it's roots; it also has a few clever levels. The difficulty level is brilliant but a bit too hard for children. I don't really like the controls much; they feel a bit weird for me, and shaking the wii remote gets a bit tiresome. At some parts, the controls are absolutely awful.

    This doesn't stop me from recommending it though. Please by this game. ITS BRILLIANT!    … Expand
  29. RobertC
    Nov 8, 2009
    7
    Mario Galaxy is a game that had many great ideas. Unfortunately, this game plays like a full priced set of gimmicks, from the controls all the way down to the platforming.
  30. NotmuchFun
    Aug 7, 2009
    6
    Oh god, this game has no business at the top of the wii games list. All Galaxy is, is a watered down version of mario 64 with several gimmicks. While 64's worlds were wide open, with the option of obtaining several stars in one go (which may or may not include the mission star) Galaxy's worlds are extremely linear. Power ups are only given when necessary and quickly disapear Oh god, this game has no business at the top of the wii games list. All Galaxy is, is a watered down version of mario 64 with several gimmicks. While 64's worlds were wide open, with the option of obtaining several stars in one go (which may or may not include the mission star) Galaxy's worlds are extremely linear. Power ups are only given when necessary and quickly disapear afterwards. Everything in this game is stifled, and the amount of freedom that can be enjoyed is scant. Even camera control is severely limited, and I often couldn't even see if i was positioned to squish a goomba.… Expand
prev
Page:

Awards & Rankings

1
#1 Best Wii Game of 2007
1
#1 Most Discussed Wii Game of 2007
1
#1 Most Shared Wii Game of 2007

Critic Reviews

All reviews »
Metascore
97

Universal acclaim - based on 73 Critic Reviews

Critic score distribution:
  1. Positive: 73 out of 73
  2. Mixed: 0 out of 73
  3. Negative: 0 out of 73
  1. Deeko
    100
    It's rare to play through a perfect game or one that nears perfection, but Galaxy definitely fits that mold.
    Read full review
  2. games(TM)
    90
    Nintendo has crafted a platform game that, while not as technologically pioneering as its grandfather, is, level for level, more fun to play than "Mario 64." [Dec 2007, p.128]
  3. 1UP
    95
    Galaxy proves that Mario matters just as much today as he did 25 years ago, and that makes him one of a kind in this medium. But don't play Galaxy simply because Mario is the timeless godfather of gaming. No, play Galaxy because it's fantastic.
    Read full review
See all critic reviews »