Super Mario 3D All-Stars

 Switch
User Score
6.4

Mixed or average reviews- based on 823 Ratings

User score distribution:
  1. Positive: 430 out of 823
  2. Mixed: 170 out of 823
  3. Negative: 223 out of 823
Buy Now
Buy on

Review this game

  1. Your Score
    0 out of 10
    Rate this:
    • 10
    • 9
    • 8
    • 7
    • 6
    • 5
    • 4
    • 3
    • 2
    • 1
    • 0
    • 0
  1. Submit
  2. Check Spelling
view
per page
  1. TheCrappyArtist
    Sep 28, 2020
    6
    So, I feel mixed on this release. Because the games included in the collection are very enjoyable and fun, but looking this as a collection, it's pretty bad. With recent releases such as the Crash and Spyro remakes, we've seen these classic 3D platformers rereleased in a modern form. But this collection feels quite a last-minute release. Not saying there was no effort put into this, that'sSo, I feel mixed on this release. Because the games included in the collection are very enjoyable and fun, but looking this as a collection, it's pretty bad. With recent releases such as the Crash and Spyro remakes, we've seen these classic 3D platformers rereleased in a modern form. But this collection feels quite a last-minute release. Not saying there was no effort put into this, that's far from true. The higher resolutions, the tweaked controls, the smoother framerate. But the fact that this is just emulated version, with no other tweaks other than the higher res, is very disappointing. But then, we have some strange changes that raised my eyebrow somewhat. The use of the relatively disliked SHINDOU version of Super Mario 64, and the loud beep in Sunshine, and the lack of button controls in Galaxy's minigames. All of this would've been fine if it wasn't a full 60$. When the Spyro and Crash collections, which are from the ground up recreations, are only 40$, you know you **** up. And then, ooooh boy, then we have the limited release. Nintendo, please answer me, why the hell are you doing this? This is clearly very anti-consumerist. I thought we were gone from the days of the Wii selling out and the Great Amiibo War. These practices make you hated more and more by the community. I know people will still enjoy your games, but you must make an effort to still hold the respect many fans still hold over you. I don't like using numbers for reviews, because it makes readers only focus on the big circle with the number on it like they're moths attracted to a lamp, but Metacritic won't let me not have a number, so I'll just stick with 6/10. I still believe it's worth it, as the games inside are very fun, but the collection is surrounded by a shadow of bad practices. Hope Nintendo backtracks on some of their choices before it's too late.… Expand
  2. Yuvalito
    Oct 12, 2020
    5
    As someone who is new to Nintendo and loved Mario Odyssey, I learned 3 important things:
    * Mario Odyssey really is an amazing game.
    * 2 out of 3 of the games in the pack really DID NOT age well.
    * I really shouldn't impulse buy things just because they are in limited edition.
  3. ChronoMoogle
    Oct 4, 2020
    5
    Great games, but one of the worst legacy collections ever made. Stripped features, flawed emulation and close to no bonus content. A sad sight.
  4. Onioncreature
    Oct 8, 2020
    7
    On the one hand, being able to play three of the best games of all time in HD on a portable console is wonderful, and does inherently hold a great deal of value. On the other hand, this is a full price release, and the upgrades and content inclusion doesn't even come close to justifying the $60 price tag. This collection really was pretty much the bare minimum that Nintendo could getOn the one hand, being able to play three of the best games of all time in HD on a portable console is wonderful, and does inherently hold a great deal of value. On the other hand, this is a full price release, and the upgrades and content inclusion doesn't even come close to justifying the $60 price tag. This collection really was pretty much the bare minimum that Nintendo could get away with, which is highly disappointing since so much more could've been done to update these games. The lack of Super Mario Galaxy 2 is also bizarre.… Expand
  5. jfumero2585
    Sep 28, 2020
    6
    Nothing special. Of course, there's a lot of nostalgia value to be had with these classic games, but if you're not going to release a full-on remake, it would've been nice if Nintendo had at least added some additional content, a ratio adjustment, or fixed the damn Super Mario 64 camera. As it is, these games are still pretty enjoyable on their own, but in no way is the $59.99 priceNothing special. Of course, there's a lot of nostalgia value to be had with these classic games, but if you're not going to release a full-on remake, it would've been nice if Nintendo had at least added some additional content, a ratio adjustment, or fixed the damn Super Mario 64 camera. As it is, these games are still pretty enjoyable on their own, but in no way is the $59.99 price justified. I know it's a completely different platform and genre, but compare this to Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 1+2 for PS4, which is far superior, is an actual remake, and comes in at $39.99. Step up your game, Nintendo!… Expand
  6. Rickk
    Sep 24, 2020
    7
    All these games are great, with a really good story and extremely fun, but Nintendo could have done so much better, for example, Super Mario 64 could have been wide screen and 60 fps, and Super Mario Sunshine could have been 60 fps too.

    The game is a little bit overpriced too, I know that these are 3 incredible games, but paying 60€ for these games is ridiculous. The soundtracks    All these games are great, with a really good story and extremely fun, but Nintendo could have done so much better, for example, Super Mario 64 could have been wide screen and 60 fps, and Super Mario Sunshine could have been 60 fps too.

    The game is a little bit overpriced too, I know that these are 3 incredible games, but paying 60€ for these games is ridiculous.

    The soundtracks feature in Super Mario 3D All-Stars is cool, but I can't barely see any usage for that.

    Controls were really good in my opinion, the only downside of them is using the touch for Super Mario Galaxy in portable mode, I found it very uncomfortable and overall not a great experience, I recommend playing Galaxy on the TV.    … Expand
  7. Alvz9
    Nov 8, 2020
    6
    Una colección no puede ser evaluada como una "suma de sus partes". Para lanzar una colección, se debe valorar la "Idea" que da coherencia a dicho lanzamiento. En este caso, es una celebración del 35 aniversario de Mario; una oportunidad desaprovechada considerando que Mario es probablemente el personaje más importante de la historia del video juego. La colección trae los tres juegosUna colección no puede ser evaluada como una "suma de sus partes". Para lanzar una colección, se debe valorar la "Idea" que da coherencia a dicho lanzamiento. En este caso, es una celebración del 35 aniversario de Mario; una oportunidad desaprovechada considerando que Mario es probablemente el personaje más importante de la historia del video juego. La colección trae los tres juegos principales de Mario en 3D, más el soundtrack de cada juego, nada más. Es una celebración pobre, que sería muy deficiente en términos de "producto ofrecido" si es que no estuvieran presente tres de los juegos más importantes de la historia. Super Mario 3D all star es como el cobro de una pensión de un jubilado por varios "años de servicio", pero que implica una pensión baja que de ninguna manera equipara al sueldo original (en términos de "calificación", porque en términos monetarios cuesta lo mismo que un desarrollo de videojuego nuevo).… Expand
  8. DetectiveDonut
    Oct 6, 2020
    7
    Look, it's 3 of the best 3D platforming games of all time, which is enough to warrant a 9 or a 10. But the reality is, this is a barebones portfest. It's just 3 emulated Mario games thrown together with a cheap splash screen and the soundtracks for $60. I rarely encourage emulation, but you can get Super Mario 64 running at widescreen resolution with HD models and infinite draw distance onLook, it's 3 of the best 3D platforming games of all time, which is enough to warrant a 9 or a 10. But the reality is, this is a barebones portfest. It's just 3 emulated Mario games thrown together with a cheap splash screen and the soundtracks for $60. I rarely encourage emulation, but you can get Super Mario 64 running at widescreen resolution with HD models and infinite draw distance on PC or homebrew. This is simply asking too much for too little that was thrown together too fast.… Expand
  9. Lopezmadrid7
    Sep 24, 2020
    6
    A mario experience with nostalgia bearing all the weight on its shoulders (A Review of Super Mario 64 from the 3d collection, having just completed the game). Having played Super Mario 64 in my early years, nostalgia plays a huge part in the enjoyment of this 3D 'all star' experience. As a modern experience, the little work nintendo has done to bring these games to the switch has doneA mario experience with nostalgia bearing all the weight on its shoulders (A Review of Super Mario 64 from the 3d collection, having just completed the game). Having played Super Mario 64 in my early years, nostalgia plays a huge part in the enjoyment of this 3D 'all star' experience. As a modern experience, the little work nintendo has done to bring these games to the switch has done nothing but mar these hallmark games. Super Mario 64 makes for a frustrating experience. Poor resolution (especially on a switch lite), no camera improvements, no tightening or improvment of gameplay all contribute to a hair pulling time controlling the iconic Italian. Mario constantly bumps and slides off little edges causing you to lose minutes of gameplay, being booted out of the level for a tiny mistep, forcing you to replay entire large segments over and over. The camera rarely keeps up with the game but this all to be expected for a game released in the 90s. This is the issue, nintendo had the chance to create a perfect version of the great Super Mario 64. Instead they settled for a low effort port (a poor emulation for that matter) which simply put a nintendo 64 game onto a switch and made it function. Overall, I stand by my opening statement. Nintendo truly put the nostalgia to work by making it dance infront of a hat waiting for you to throw in your $60.… Expand
  10. JackH2551
    Sep 28, 2020
    6
    I was very excited for this collection since I only played Mario Sunshine for about 1 week as a kid (Never bought it, we rented it) and I never played Mario Galaxy. And its been years since I had played Mario 64, so I was very much looking forward to this collection. I completed Mario 64, and I was just as fun as I remembered. Then I started Mario Sunshine and boy is that game terrible...I was very excited for this collection since I only played Mario Sunshine for about 1 week as a kid (Never bought it, we rented it) and I never played Mario Galaxy. And its been years since I had played Mario 64, so I was very much looking forward to this collection. I completed Mario 64, and I was just as fun as I remembered. Then I started Mario Sunshine and boy is that game terrible...

    Going to be honest here. I absolutely HATE Mario Sunshine. For lack of a better word, its **** To be fair, I did put in a good amount of time, getting 50 Sun sprites / stars in it. But any time I start playing Sunshine, it just feels like a damn chore. The controls are horrendous. They are super clunky and frustratingly difficult to maneuver at times. Then comes the Camera Angle issue which I've heard bad things about before. The camera has a mind of its own. It randomly spazzes out on me, causing me to miss important jumps and die, having to start over.

    The gameplay is really bad and poorly designed. I'm stuck at 50 Sun Stars / Sprities because there is a certain Secret Level that is insanely difficult to complete. This game doesn't have that Sand Box feel like Mario 64 and other amazing Mario games. Instead, you're FORCED to complete stupidly difficult tasks to progress instead of just being allowed to complete the challenges that YOU want and progress the game that way. Being forced to do certain things is NOT fun. Overall, Mario Sunshine is complete garbage. And now that I've played every single 3D Mario Game out there, I can honestly say Sunshine is the WORST. Makes perfect sense why Nintendo never re-released it until now.

    As for Mario Galaxy, I must say, this game is an MASTER PIECE. 1 hour in, and I love it. Seeing how others say MG2 is better, I am a little disappointed that MG2 was not included in this collection. I would gladly trade Mario Suncrap for Mario Galaxy 2 to be apart of this collection. That being said, I've given this game a 6.5 out of 10, because Sunshine - (1/3 of the game) is terrible and there's no Mario Galaxy 2. Other than that, Mario 64 and Galaxy are amazing, and its awesome to play them with updated graphics and on my Switch that can go anywhere I want with it.

    As for the $60 price tag. I paid $50 for it (Plus California sales tax). Amazon randomly refunded me $10 for this game. Not sure why, but I'm happy with it. 2 amazing games for $50 is well worth the price.    … Expand
  11. djstull
    Oct 12, 2020
    5
    Note: This is a review of the quality of the collection itself, not the games in the collection, because obviously those are all master pieces.

    Nintendo really did us dirty. This is hands down the biggest cash grab that they have ever produced. They reached into the wallets of all Nintendo fans and took their 60 dollars for what basically amounts to a couple old games slapped onto the    Note: This is a review of the quality of the collection itself, not the games in the collection, because obviously those are all master pieces.

    Nintendo really did us dirty. This is hands down the biggest cash grab that they have ever produced. They reached into the wallets of all Nintendo fans and took their 60 dollars for what basically amounts to a couple old games slapped onto the Switch with little to no improvement. Here are the biggest issues:

    Super Mario 64: This game received a UI texture overhaul which looks nice, as well as a couple textures such as Mario's hat and overalls. This is great and makes the game feel a little updated, but somehow the game still runs at 30 fps in a 4:3 square aspect ratio. They have given no reason why this is the case, and it is honestly really sad that a multibillion dollar company can't put as much work into making a game run at 1080p widescreen with 60 fps at least. The excellent community behind the Mario 64 Decompile project did such great work reverse engineering the game, that now you can play the game in all it's beauty in a way that is much better than Nintendo's efforts for the Switch version. (*cough* googlesm64pcBuilder2 *cough*)

    Super Mario Sunshine: This is by far the game I have the most nostalgia for in the collection. I will admit that it was fun replaying this classic on Switch, but we have similar problems here to Mario 64. While it is nice to have some of the texture improvements and widescreen, zero effort was put in to making the game run in 60 fps. The game is plagued with frame drops and bugs. The Dolphin Emulator has been able to run this game in 1080p 60fps with an HD texture pack for years now. The controls are no longer inverted in the collection, which is really disorienting for fans of the original, and the updated controls are just not as good. You can't even use the GameCube controller adapter for Smash Brothers Ultimate in order to enjoy those classic controls. The fact too that this game has things like debug cubes visible in levels and other such things is such a spit in the face of fans of the original game, and only adds to the evidence that this was a quick cash grab.

    Super Mario Galaxy: Ignoring the fact that they ignored the excellent sequel to this game entirely and are pretending that it didn't exist, this is the only game out of the collection to run at 1080p 60 fps. From what I've seen most people agree that this game is the highlight of the collection. While there are still some bugs present, this version is at least close to matching the experience of the original. I will need to play this version more to comment on the quality. Seriously though, how can they just sweep Mario Galaxy 2 under the rug like this.

    Conclusion: This is a horrible cash grab of a collection of 3 classic masterpieces. When Activision of all companies, (who are usually considered way more greedy than Nintendo) can release the excellent Vicarious Visions remasters of Crash Bandicoot and Tony Hawk at very reasonable prices and with a boat load of extra content to boot, but yet Nintendo can't, this is simply a direction that the company is going in that I cannot stand behind.

    Not to mention, you die hard Nintendo Fans better pick this game up quick while you still can, because in March you won't find it on the eshop or on store shelves. This is such a scummy release all around.    … Expand
  12. weskergamer
    Nov 11, 2020
    7
    I good collection, it doesn't do nothing new, but it's very recommended if you'd never played one of these really good games, even tho i didn't like sunshine that much. I think for this collection to be a lot better, it needs Galaxy 2 honestly
  13. CamyVero
    Mar 6, 2021
    6
    These 3 games are played for the first time in HD and with the possibility to play them portable. Still, it's not enough, as they haven't been retouched in any way, as was done in 'Super Mario All Stars', and even for collector's purposes the content falls short, missing 'Super Mario Galaxy 2'. As for the games themselves, 3 masterpieces of the best of the platform genre.
  14. MisterMacys
    Feb 28, 2021
    6
    Game does not include manuals scans, Nintendo Power scans, concept art, promotional materials, adjustable controls, Mario Galaxy 2, or the additions made to Mario 64 DS. Very disappointing. I expect the Metroid Prime Trilogy will be more of the same.
  15. Syhlcam
    Sep 27, 2020
    7
    Ce sont tous d'excellent jeux qui fonctionne très bien, mais sans plus. Nintendo ravie les fans de la licence avec cette réédition qui permet de jouer à trois excellent Mario 3D sur Switch. Mais les jeux à part une légère amélioration graphique les jeux ne sont pas plus travaillé, les bugs et éléments acceptables en 1996/2002 mais plus acceptable en 2020 ne sont pas corrigé. Mario Galaxy àCe sont tous d'excellent jeux qui fonctionne très bien, mais sans plus. Nintendo ravie les fans de la licence avec cette réédition qui permet de jouer à trois excellent Mario 3D sur Switch. Mais les jeux à part une légère amélioration graphique les jeux ne sont pas plus travaillé, les bugs et éléments acceptables en 1996/2002 mais plus acceptable en 2020 ne sont pas corrigé. Mario Galaxy à des contrôle en portable qui ne sont pas forcément les plus agréable avec le tactile pour le curseur, surtout que des stages l'utilise énormément. Nintendo aurait pu faire plus, et dommage que la société skip Galaxy 2.… Expand
  16. Cezico
    Dec 6, 2020
    7
    The games included are some of the best games ever created. 64, Sunshine, and Galaxy are still amazing, and slight improvements like a single button for the spin jump in Galaxy improve the game significantly. For some of these games, 3D All-Stars is the definitive way to play, and perfect if you've always wanted to check these games out or just want to revisit them.
    However, this is    The games included are some of the best games ever created. 64, Sunshine, and Galaxy are still amazing, and slight improvements like a single button for the spin jump in Galaxy improve the game significantly. For some of these games, 3D All-Stars is the definitive way to play, and perfect if you've always wanted to check these games out or just want to revisit them.
    However, this is brought down by the quality of the collection. At its core, 3D All-Stars is an overpriced, unimproved mess that includes issues fans fixed years ago that was barely changed to fit with the Switch better. If it weren't for those issues, this would likely by the best Mario game ever, but it's painfully obvious that this was meant to be a quick cash grab by Nintendo.

    (Played on the Nintendo Switch)    … Expand
  17. ElSmasher
    Mar 6, 2021
    7
    Super Mario 3d all stars is a compilation of 3 wonderful games from the Mario franchise. From the iconic Super Mario 64 to the revolutionary Mario Galaxy, including the 2002 opus that is the exotic Sunshine; on paper this best-of could only have the maximum score. Unfortunately, (almost) no effort made, except the switch to 720p for sunshine and motion control for galaxy. The facelift isSuper Mario 3d all stars is a compilation of 3 wonderful games from the Mario franchise. From the iconic Super Mario 64 to the revolutionary Mario Galaxy, including the 2002 opus that is the exotic Sunshine; on paper this best-of could only have the maximum score. Unfortunately, (almost) no effort made, except the switch to 720p for sunshine and motion control for galaxy. The facelift is brief and no additions and no Galaxy 2. 60 € is a lot for 3 more or less retro games but if you haven't done them. Get started !!… Expand
  18. Lucariomain05
    Dec 27, 2020
    6
    While the games themselves are great and fun to play, Nintendo became truly complacent when whipping up this collection. Everything, from the UI to the implementation of the controls and limited enhancements, paints a clear picture of Nintendo resting on their laurels. The poor decision of making this game a limited time release is also pitiful, as it makes buying it more of a hassle thanWhile the games themselves are great and fun to play, Nintendo became truly complacent when whipping up this collection. Everything, from the UI to the implementation of the controls and limited enhancements, paints a clear picture of Nintendo resting on their laurels. The poor decision of making this game a limited time release is also pitiful, as it makes buying it more of a hassle than a fun experience. Though these are certainly detriments to the experience, I still had fun playing these games for the first time in over a decade. The nostalgia factor of all 3 releases is a big plus, but that plus alone can't make up for these issues.… Expand
  19. GameFace98
    Feb 25, 2021
    7
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. A great collection of critically acclaimed games that seems rushed and bland. Super Mario 64 being the only game remastered with the other two not. The fact that the game is limited, and the collection to celebrate the plumber's 35th anniversary is bland and I like this collection. But this isn't a way to celebrate a mascot's anniversary. Perhaps when he turns 40 we'll get more, more extras, something like Kirby's 20th Anniversary. This game needs more content and games.… Expand
  20. lVicel
    Oct 4, 2020
    7
    The Games are "fine", but that because they are the GEMS-Games of Mario, obviously the are 10/10
    The Main Problem are the Control, I expected that Nintendo would repair the Control but they are EXACTLY the same; goofy and hard to control in 64 and Sunshine.
    If you would Buy the Game, is fine, but dont expect a Clear Control of Mario. If you have a Powerful PC to play Roms, DO IT, it would    The Games are "fine", but that because they are the GEMS-Games of Mario, obviously the are 10/10
    The Main Problem are the Control, I expected that Nintendo would repair the Control but they are EXACTLY the same; goofy and hard to control in 64 and Sunshine.
    If you would Buy the Game, is fine, but dont expect a Clear Control of Mario.
    If you have a Powerful PC to play Roms, DO IT, it would be the same that playing this Game    … Expand
  21. whyiexist
    Oct 9, 2020
    6
    I made an account to give the score I think it deserves, and hopefully warn people before they buy it that I think its mostly half baked. If it wasn't for mario 64 before competent with its texture upscale and being as fun as it was all those years ago it would be average. That doesn't excuse the low effort the put into this. These games don't feel like they are running natively becauseI made an account to give the score I think it deserves, and hopefully warn people before they buy it that I think its mostly half baked. If it wasn't for mario 64 before competent with its texture upscale and being as fun as it was all those years ago it would be average. That doesn't excuse the low effort the put into this. These games don't feel like they are running natively because they use so much power for their age. Why does my switch get hot when I play sunshine...? 64 I wish at least fixed the camera and some controls, it should have higher resolution and run at 60 fps, and why the heck are the additions from 64 DS not here? Are we supposed to forget about that, I know nintendo doesn't expect us to forget about galaxy 2. It needed that game to make it feel worth the asking price. Temporary digital window is seriously scummy, but I can understand the value of the physical copy might not exist if they didn't but these games exist as ports on other systems anyway so it doesn't make sense.
    Sunshine is frustrating as hell, even though its good and I was able to see it through, making a lot of sprites mandatory made it way less appealing though. Sunshine even has a bug that existed in 64 where mario gets stuck on an edge. Galaxy also has a bug where he runs in a circle until you stop moving. Its not about preserving them how they are, these are flaws that should be fixed. Make them run natively and 60fps full screen pls Nintendo and include galaxy 2 as a free download, I won't pay extra for it. I also refunded 1 game from you and the customer service is atrocious to me so that's why in light of this release Nintendo really need to pull their heads in and make it up to consumers.    … Expand
  22. thereal_turtle
    Oct 21, 2020
    5
    Simply put, it's a collection of great games, but a bad game collection. The games themselves are really fun and it's really cool to be able to play them on the Switch. 64 in particular is disappointing. It's still in the same old aspect ratio and the camera is still a hot mess. But I mean, I like how it's exactly how it used to be at least.

    Sunshine is great. Probably the best in the    Simply put, it's a collection of great games, but a bad game collection. The games themselves are really fun and it's really cool to be able to play them on the Switch. 64 in particular is disappointing. It's still in the same old aspect ratio and the camera is still a hot mess. But I mean, I like how it's exactly how it used to be at least.

    Sunshine is great. Probably the best in the collection. It plays exactly as you would expect. Gamecube controller support would be a plus, but it isn't a deal breaker.

    Galaxy is Galaxy. You cant mess it up. Touchscreen controls for the cursor can be a little finicky but it's fine.

    So far it's great, right?

    The extras (or lack thereof) is disappointing. There are some soundtracks which are cool I guess, but that's literally it. The menu is basically a PowerPoint presentation with some video and a paragraph about the game. It has the game's release date and that's all.

    In Canada, it's $80 on the eShop. $80 for 3 old games. $50 might be justifiable, but $80 is just sad.

    Overall, it's ok, but definitely not worth the price.    … Expand
  23. Lee3820
    Oct 22, 2020
    5
    These games are classics and I feel like this is worth like 30 or forty.rember the Kirby one look at that is how you do a anniversary and that was forty dollars.This makes me worried for the legend of zelda 35th anniversary especially if ocarina are majora mask is part of it.
  24. DaviswagP
    Nov 2, 2020
    7
    The games alone are one of the best of all time in gaming. But as a collection, it lacks any charm that other collections have. There are no developer information of the making of these games, and concept art. Although Galaxy and Sunshine look great in HD, Super Mario 64 only have improved resolution and a few icon changes to make it more clear. The only other thing you can do isThe games alone are one of the best of all time in gaming. But as a collection, it lacks any charm that other collections have. There are no developer information of the making of these games, and concept art. Although Galaxy and Sunshine look great in HD, Super Mario 64 only have improved resolution and a few icon changes to make it more clear. The only other thing you can do is listen to the music and that's it, the bare minimum. But if you don't care about anything I've just said and want to play a Mario game that you're nostalgic for, go do it, but don't expect anything fancy or new other than graphic changes.… Expand
  25. jyf15
    Nov 20, 2020
    5
    Super Mario Galaxy may be a great game, yet a price tag of $60 makes the bundle not worth it. And having played SM: Galaxy on Wii and Switch, I can very well say that the infrared control by Wiimote is much more superior and accurate, while Switch's Joy-cons need constant calibration by "R" (for me, every 5 seconds). I would recommended anyone interested in SM: Galaxy get a pair of WiimoteSuper Mario Galaxy may be a great game, yet a price tag of $60 makes the bundle not worth it. And having played SM: Galaxy on Wii and Switch, I can very well say that the infrared control by Wiimote is much more superior and accurate, while Switch's Joy-cons need constant calibration by "R" (for me, every 5 seconds). I would recommended anyone interested in SM: Galaxy get a pair of Wiimote + Nunchuk, a SM: Galaxy disc, and run it on PC using Dolphin Emulator. I got mine for around $55 and this enables you to play even more Wii titles, without waiting for their remakes. Well, if you buy a physical copy of this compilation just to try it, it's ok because you can always sell it later. But I got a digital copy, and in HK district cannot get a refund. Regretted.… Expand
  26. SaturnTheCoyote
    Nov 25, 2020
    7
    Don't get me wrong, I think this game is enjoyable. 3 amazing classic Mario games thrown on one console, but do I think it was necessary or should have been a full £50 price? If you'd never played the games before, then yeah, absolutely! But if you have... then no, probably not. What did I think of the games? Well...

    Mario Galaxy. I much preferred the second game. Nintendo mentioned    Don't get me wrong, I think this game is enjoyable. 3 amazing classic Mario games thrown on one console, but do I think it was necessary or should have been a full £50 price? If you'd never played the games before, then yeah, absolutely! But if you have... then no, probably not. What did I think of the games? Well...

    Mario Galaxy. I much preferred the second game. Nintendo mentioned they updated the graphics a little. I fail to see it. It's enjoyable, brings back a wave of nostalgia, but when I own a Wii and Super Mario Galaxy, I fail to see the point to buy it on Switch full price, which I reckon is why it's 'limited time'.

    Mario 64. The camera aged horribly and was not changed at all. I've been wanting to complete Mario 64 for a while now on 3D All Stars, but I just find the camera irritating. I own Mario 64 DS and I've completed that 2 times in a row, and each time I enjoy it as much as the last. Maybe I'm biased with the camera as I was a Sonic kid growing up which didn't have camera issues for me, but I'd find the game much more enjoyable if they edited the camera a slight bit.

    I have not yet gotten round to playing Mario Sunshine. It looks like a fun game but I basically only played £50 for Mario Sunshine, which I could just get a GameCube and Mario Sunshine for probably only just a little more.

    It's great for a first time player, but compared to other remastered games (Star Fox 64 3D (which was on the DS, may I note), Twilight Princess HD), it lacks in adding updated features to build it up to modern expectations.    … Expand
  27. jakkebak
    Dec 9, 2020
    7
    I really do love the ports on this game, it's just that Nintendo could have made the game bigger/better. Maybe for future DLC.
  28. DonnieTrump
    Feb 7, 2021
    5
    This is Nintendo at its worst. It just took three old Mario games, pasted them in one bundle and added a soundtrack for each game. Then ask full retail price and make it available for only a limited time. This is the recipe for Super Mario 3D All-Stars. Granted, they did similar moves in the past as well, but then they always added a bonus. Think of the Lost Levels (the Japanese SuperThis is Nintendo at its worst. It just took three old Mario games, pasted them in one bundle and added a soundtrack for each game. Then ask full retail price and make it available for only a limited time. This is the recipe for Super Mario 3D All-Stars. Granted, they did similar moves in the past as well, but then they always added a bonus. Think of the Lost Levels (the Japanese Super Mario Bros 2) in the compilation game Super Mario All-Stars so many years ago. Moreover, they updated the Super Mario games on NES with SNES-worthy graphics.

    In this case Nintendo added nothing. No graphical updates whatsoever and no extra content. It doesn't play any worse than the original, but if that's the major selling point of a compilation it's time to start asking some critical questions. The advantage of this bundle is that you can play three different Mario titles on one system, but in my opinion that convenience isn't worth full retail price. If you haven't played one or more of these Mario games it's worth picking up Super Mario 3D All-Stars if you don't mind the age. They remain very solid platform games after all and I consider Galaxy as one of the best 3D platformers to this date and even one of best games in any genre.

    A mediocre product by Nintendo is scored with a mediocre score. Ten for the actual software and zero for the effort that Nintendo put in this compilation bundle. A five overall for something that is basically a quick money grabbing scheme by Nintendo.    … Expand
  29. Theemuis12
    Feb 4, 2021
    7
    not bad but did they really had to make sunshine the bugiest out of the 3? i found like 7 bugs out of complete accident in the FIRST STAGE. also why doesnt sm64 have all the bugs but not the BLJ glitch??
  30. cfc1998
    Feb 19, 2021
    6
    I'm sorry Nintendo but this is not how you treat your most iconic character. The 3 games are very good obviously but this compilation just feels lazy and simple, even the menu doesn't give you much thing to do apart from listening the soundtrack. For the 35th anniversary of Mario I feel very disappointed, this was rushed and it didn't even included super Mario Galaxy 2. I don't supportI'm sorry Nintendo but this is not how you treat your most iconic character. The 3 games are very good obviously but this compilation just feels lazy and simple, even the menu doesn't give you much thing to do apart from listening the soundtrack. For the 35th anniversary of Mario I feel very disappointed, this was rushed and it didn't even included super Mario Galaxy 2. I don't support this kind of practices.… Expand
prev
Page:

Awards & Rankings

34
#34 Best Switch Game of 2020
4
#4 Most Discussed Switch Game of 2020

Critic Reviews

All reviews »
Metascore
82

Generally favorable reviews - based on 102 Critic Reviews

Critic score distribution:
  1. Positive: 80 out of 102
  2. Mixed: 22 out of 102
  3. Negative: 0 out of 102
  1. Nintendo Force Magazine
    Apr 28, 2021
    70
    Nintendo had the chance to knock this one out of the park, but they settled for a bunt. [Issue #49 – November/December 2020, p. 72]
  2. iMore
    Mar 5, 2021
    80
    The classic games have been ported over to the Nintendo Switch with upscaled graphics. The old controls feel clunky compared to modern gaming standards, but if you already love these games, this makes for a great purchase.
    Read full review
  3. Ninty Fresh Magazine
    Dec 21, 2020
    75
    Super Mario 3D All-Stars is three masterpiece games in a lacklustre package thanks to poor upgrades, contrived control choices and barely any extra content. [Issue #2, p. 72]
See all critic reviews »