Red Dead Redemption 2

 PlayStation 4
User Score
8.7

Generally favorable reviews- based on 21344 Ratings

User score distribution:
  1. Positive: 18,146 out of 21344
  2. Mixed: 1,261 out of 21344
  3. Negative: 1,937 out of 21344
Buy Now
Buy on

Review this game

  1. Your Score
    0 out of 10
    Rate this:
    • 10
    • 9
    • 8
    • 7
    • 6
    • 5
    • 4
    • 3
    • 2
    • 1
    • 0
    • 0
  1. Submit
  2. Check Spelling
view
per page
  1. Selvaris
    Oct 28, 2018
    10
    Everyone will buy it even if it really is not for everyone. Those who look for GTA : Far West edition will be disappointed.

    It's definitely more complex and slow paced wich makes it one of the most immersive games ever. If you have the time for it, the game will greet you with a great journey.
  2. javironcho
    Nov 18, 2018
    10
    The game is amazing, as someone said, it is the game of the generation, my only criticism is that the semi automatic shotgun is not properly reloaded, but aside from that it is a long game, with a really good story and very fun overall
  3. Deependra
    Oct 31, 2018
    10
    This game does deserve perfect 10. Most of the negative reviews out here are by PC gamers so, I am not surprised why the ratings are comparatively low.
    To all those people who are a console gamer, yet rated it as 0 or bad score, I believe you do not have patience to sit around and play these kind of games which is more focused on story. I just have one suggestions for you guys, sit and    This game does deserve perfect 10. Most of the negative reviews out here are by PC gamers so, I am not surprised why the ratings are comparatively low.
    To all those people who are a console gamer, yet rated it as 0 or bad score, I believe you do not have patience to sit around and play these kind of games which is more focused on story. I just have one suggestions for you guys, sit and play the game for few more days, explore it well, then come and rewrite the review. This game is masterpiece from each and every angle. All you need is, "time" to explore it properly.
    Pros:
    Great story so far
    Good effects
    Realistic approach
    Good open world game
    Great control.
    Great game mechanics .
    Huge world.
    Justified cowboy life.
    Side missions will keep you occupied.

    Cons:

    Can't really see any expect for no multiplayer experience on day one.    … Expand
  4. omfri
    Oct 29, 2018
    10
    I was worried that the diffrent hygiene tasks should pull this gem down. But I was so wrong, all humans shall play this game before the grave! buy it or regret it this is an masterpiece. Thank you rockstar for this amazing game
  5. BBUENO
    Dec 4, 2021
    10
    The best game ever. I just dream for an other game like this one. Please Rockstar take my money
  6. Allthat
    Oct 26, 2018
    10
    This game was developed over eight years, by thousands of people working long hours. And it shows. The level of polish is unparalleled, and the level of quality is immense; this is quite simply the best game of this console generation and easily one of the best games of all time. Am I surprised though? No. This is Rockstar after all, and anything they touch is gold, they have a knack forThis game was developed over eight years, by thousands of people working long hours. And it shows. The level of polish is unparalleled, and the level of quality is immense; this is quite simply the best game of this console generation and easily one of the best games of all time. Am I surprised though? No. This is Rockstar after all, and anything they touch is gold, they have a knack for making extremely high quality games and every Rockstar game release is a big event in the world of gaming. Games like this don't come out every year, so cherish this game. The only idiots hating on this game are the salty PC fan-boys who are sad that they cannot play this masterpiece.

    If I could rate this game higher I would but unfortunately Metacritic wont let me. This is an 11/10 for me, games like this only come along once in a generation and this game deserves all the praise it gets. Pure quality.    … Expand
  7. Goalzzz
    Nov 11, 2018
    10
    One of the best games ever. A game which serves as prequel to the game that came out on 2010. What an upgrade it was, for those who liked the first will definitely enjoy this more because this game is bigger, longer and definitely much more complex. So far it was one of the best open world games ever. The story tells about Arthur Morgan and the importance of change. Showing how the westOne of the best games ever. A game which serves as prequel to the game that came out on 2010. What an upgrade it was, for those who liked the first will definitely enjoy this more because this game is bigger, longer and definitely much more complex. So far it was one of the best open world games ever. The story tells about Arthur Morgan and the importance of change. Showing how the west evolved into a modern civilized place where gunslingers and outlaws must understand that the world have changed, consequences and rules based on action of characters on the game affects the people around them. The game involves chapters that sets the standard for the first game. The original Character of Red Dead Redemption returns with a wider Role than the first game with more in depth. While the Red Dead Redemption was ambitious due to the Red Dead Revolver not showing much promise as other rockstar IP. But this sequel of the original Red Dead Redemption is far more ambitious than GTA 5. I liked this game because this game shows how the world evolves and how Civilization changes. Difference on Honest and Non Honest Characters are very important and shows realism and Idealism which makes the character memorable for many years to come.… Expand
  8. Rahsmoove
    Oct 26, 2018
    10
    I normally don't give 10's to games but Red Dead Redemption 2 blew me away. From the presentation to the missions to the freeroaming, I was felt so immersed through out New Hanover. The the amount of detail in this game is unbelievable. I maybe overexaggerating, but this just might be most detailed I've played. In RDR 2's story you follow what occurred before it's predecessor being JohnI normally don't give 10's to games but Red Dead Redemption 2 blew me away. From the presentation to the missions to the freeroaming, I was felt so immersed through out New Hanover. The the amount of detail in this game is unbelievable. I maybe overexaggerating, but this just might be most detailed I've played. In RDR 2's story you follow what occurred before it's predecessor being John Marston, being apart of Dutch's gang as this time as an out law, Arthur Morgan. This time you make a good bond with all of the outlaws in the gang and story fellows them perfectly. The game makes you interact with your fellow gang members, look after your camp, make decisions in and out of missions (They actually shape your character), look after your horse and whole lot more. I like how get change in out of different types of clothes instead of using only outfits. You can also work on your personal grooming too. There so much to get involved in this game. it's a true masterpiece, improves at lot of gameplay mechanics from it's predecessor, it's worth $60 and I'd say it's definitely game of the year material and I don't say these quite often.

    BTW: To PC gamers,

    I got two options for you. Wait until there's a possible PC release or buy a PS4 or Xbox one to get RDR 2. If you already have one of those, get the game for it. Instead of acting like a complete lowlife mad man-child and downvoting the game because it wasn't created for your precious PC. Thank you!    … Expand
  9. HayvenMoses
    Oct 26, 2018
    10
    Been a gamer all my life,since the Atari,very few games have blown me away like this,The Last of Us the very First Tomb Raider,Splinter Cell come to mind. This games a once in a lifetime expierence,its so well done,the story,voice acting and gameplay are second to none. This is just one of those games EVERYONE should have,do yourself a favor pick this one up.
  10. Drakkhan
    Nov 21, 2018
    10
    One of the greates Games i've ever played. IT sets new borders für open World, Detail, Story Telling and a lot of love to the Games itself. Rockstar is one of the greatest and shows in this game all there Skills and this game is pretty much close to a perfect Game. !0 Points and PLS PC RELEASE ROCKSTAR T:T
  11. MaxPayneIsGod
    Nov 18, 2020
    10
    After numerous restarts and finally giving this game the time it deserves I feel i can now actually give a considered review.
    RDR 2 is a magnificent experience, its more of a simulation than a game, its as close as you're ever going to get to living life as a cowboy.
    The dynamic environment is something to truly marvel at and its something that only a few developers could ever dream of    After numerous restarts and finally giving this game the time it deserves I feel i can now actually give a considered review.
    RDR 2 is a magnificent experience, its more of a simulation than a game, its as close as you're ever going to get to living life as a cowboy.
    The dynamic environment is something to truly marvel at and its something that only a few developers could ever dream of coming close to. Everything is alive and the random encounters are worth the effort alone.
    It does start slow, so slow in fact I had given up on the game 3 times previously, but I pushed through and my god I'm glad i did.
    Full disclosure; I'm nowhere near completion but I'm far enough through to know that this is the best game I have played in 2020.
    Its an adult game, mature, there are no in-jokes, there is no satire, its based wholly in what probably was the reality of that time and place, this is not for gamers who want something as user-friendly and "ruleless" as GTA. This is a deliberately paced game and the amount of time that has been put into every aspect is something that needs to be experienced to believe.
    I was going to give this a 9 because of annoying framerate drops on PS4, but that's just not enough to sway me from the 10/10 I'm going to give it.
    It has an incredibly low completion rate and its a shame, but I can see why. It takes dedication and time and with the market as flooded as it is, as a mature gamer you owe it to yourself to invest in it.
    I absolutely hated this game when it released and its taken along time for me to comprehend what I was getting myself into.
    You must persist, learn it, understand it and love it.    … Expand
  12. Solid2312
    Oct 28, 2018
    10
    Best game of this generation in my opinion. The level of immersion and details only Rockstar can deliver for us. Great graphics, great story, huge open world, many different things to do. It is really a masterpiece.
  13. Saeedscorpion
    Nov 19, 2018
    10
    This game is easily a 10/10 ... this game is not for kids ...it is RockStar’s go and play it without doubt . It is not a **** or EA **** game
  14. lionars
    Nov 13, 2018
    10
    "When the time comes, you gotta run and don't look back. This is over" Arthur Morgan
  15. MaximumD
    Jan 9, 2019
    10
    I've now put in about 150 hrs into the game and I'm on a second playthrough right now so I've decided to re-review the game here. Slowing down the pace and really soaking in the game this time around has made me garner a greater appreciation for this mesmerizing open world. The slow pace of the game is not for everyone and those who blaze through the story will have missed a whole lot.I've now put in about 150 hrs into the game and I'm on a second playthrough right now so I've decided to re-review the game here. Slowing down the pace and really soaking in the game this time around has made me garner a greater appreciation for this mesmerizing open world. The slow pace of the game is not for everyone and those who blaze through the story will have missed a whole lot. That's what I see now that I'm taking my time. The game has some flaws to be sure, but it is a near masterpiece if not an outright masterpiece depending on what your game preferences are.

    The open world design on display here will be the golden standard moving forward for creating living, breathing game worlds. In that regard Rockstar have outdone themselves. I agree that some of the gameplay is clunky and the story is about as linear as it gets these days. Still the amount love and work poured into this game really shines through overall. I say take the advice of a lot of online sites and play the game as slowly as possible to soak it all. Go explore, find treasure, hunt, etc. Spend some time in the towns. On a second playthrough and I"m not even bored yet. I can't believe how much I actually missed on the first run.

    It's not perfect as there some glitches and well let's say the bounty system is kind of rigged and wonky at times. The law will basically always side against you in confrontation and it seems pretty unfair at times. Other times I had no idea if I was experiencing a glitch, logic fail, or if the bounty system was working as intended but just badly designed. I had some issues with the story overall, but that's really personal preference.

    ON the other hand, I love the slow paced nature of the shooting mechanics and all the stuff some people find tedious and unnecessary I find really helps provide total immersion in the game playing as newly iconic character, Arthur.

    Online, well that's another story. The same basic gameplay but a barebones world as compared to SP. There is work to be done there for sure.

    Overall though, I would give this game a 9.5 if I could, but have no problems giving it a ten here. I think it's up there with Witcher 3 as the games of the generation. It's truly a special product and you can see the love that Rockstar put into this. The level of detail is astounding. You can say it's unnecessary even, but it's there and it brings the world to life like no other game previously. Is it perfect? Nope, but what game has ever been? There are some flaws, but the overral package is amazing. I recommend that you shirk the naysayers and don't deprive yourself of the experience of playing this game. Hell, just rent it and try it out at least. You owe it to yourself to try the game and then decide if it's for you. Highly recommended, much better than GTA V and RDR 1.    … Expand
  16. berserklover
    Oct 26, 2018
    10
    It's really fascinating to read review.

    You got one guy who gave it a 0/10 because it runs terribly on his brand new PC. The game isn't even out on PC. You got another who talks about the frame rate dips under 10 fps all the time. Even though, there's many video who did runs on the game and it's a constant 30 fps with 0 dips. Overall, like every popular group, You got 1 group who    It's really fascinating to read review.

    You got one guy who gave it a 0/10 because it runs terribly on his brand new PC. The game isn't even out on PC. You got another who talks about the frame rate dips under 10 fps all the time. Even though, there's many video who did runs on the game and it's a constant 30 fps with 0 dips.

    Overall, like every popular group, You got 1 group who will kiss everything bout the game, and the other who will give it a 0/10 because the first 5 minutes weren't good.

    I think it's 8/10, after 10 hours, it has a lot to do but my god, riding that horse from end to the other for each quest, gets a bit annoying. Took me 20 minutes to get one quest done because the horse ride was so far. Once in a while that would be great, but constantly just add time to gaming that we simply don't have today.

    The graphics are incredible, the best I've seen on console this generation. The only other game that compare is horizon zero dawn and god of war. Sadly, graphics aren't everything and the giant maps with nothing to do for 5 - 10 minutes at a time, that's just straight painful.

    I'll review it again and delete this one if it changes by 50 - 60 hours but if you are rating the game a 0/10, not only are you a **** reviewer, you should get your account revoke. Metacritic really need to clear that stuff up, it was the same with Zelda. You have a bunch of no life who watch a few minute on twitch (that's very clear from the 0/10) and comment right after. Many of you didn't even play nor really tried. Especially, the 10 or so review about how PC runs poorly.    … Expand
  17. IAmClementine
    Sep 22, 2020
    10
    Beautiful scenery, Amazing gameplay and story, anyone who gives under a 9 is delusional!
  18. akoahi
    Dec 16, 2018
    10
    Excellent game, just perfect for me, new level of open world, deep emotion story and one of greatest video game protagonists.
  19. Fincasey
    Sep 9, 2020
    10
    Took everything from the first game and just expanded upon it immensely. Such an amazing immersive open world with so much vast amount of effort out into realism (respectable yo a video game of course haha) more than any game I can recall.
    Amazing world to explore with countless free roaming activities (hunting being the most addicting feature of it for me), amazing characters and    Took everything from the first game and just expanded upon it immensely. Such an amazing immersive open world with so much vast amount of effort out into realism (respectable yo a video game of course haha) more than any game I can recall.
    Amazing world to explore with countless free roaming activities (hunting being the most addicting feature of it for me), amazing characters and narrative (in order to do so need to TRULY play the game. Take the time doing as much as you can with little things such as spending time in camps where you’ll see numerous camp hidden dialogue /interactions that make for such a great experience, and often you’ll notice you missed in your first play through.
    Rarely would I ever say something like this, but 10/10.
    Only qualm being the at time annoying slow action animation of doing things, (eg picking up flowers for crafting ingredients or harvesting/skinning animals (albeit looking amazingly real.. again for a game) when say you kill 5 dear using deadeye and don’t wanna have to take (    … Expand
  20. Gurjinder_GJ
    Oct 26, 2018
    10
    This is a really cool game. I recommend it to everyone. No compromises. Just rare quality.
  21. heckler
    Oct 26, 2018
    10
    One of the best games I've ever played. Too bad the contemplative nature of this isn't what most people are after these days, because I really want more of this type of game. But barring that, I'm happy that we got one made by a dev studio with the caliber of Rockstar.
  22. weisscraft
    Jan 13, 2019
    10
    I've passed the game through the end. And only 25% of players did this by the moment (this fact is got from PS achievements statistics). So most of the negative commenters don't have right to judge the game. It's completely 10/10.
  23. erfanbasket
    Feb 20, 2019
    10
    10/10 must play dont judge it by first hours. there is a lot of things to learn so dont get frustrated.
  24. ketexan
    Feb 6, 2020
    10
    After reading some of the reviews for this game, the only thing I can come up with to explain some of the bad reviews is this: Either all the hype for this game gave some reviewers such high expectations that no game, from any publisher, from any genre could live up to those expectations and the grievances are so minor and so nit-picky, that most people won't even notice them unless theyAfter reading some of the reviews for this game, the only thing I can come up with to explain some of the bad reviews is this: Either all the hype for this game gave some reviewers such high expectations that no game, from any publisher, from any genre could live up to those expectations and the grievances are so minor and so nit-picky, that most people won't even notice them unless they read the reviews first and then go out of their way to find it. If you are not the kind of person that plays a game, just to pick out the flaws of it, you will thoroughly enjoy this game and every last bit of the 80+ hours of single player game play. (assuming of course you try to 100% the game) some may finish quicker, others will take a lot longer (like me) but not once did I finish a 4 or 5 hour play session and regret spending that amount of time on the game. I always left reluctantly and not being able to wait to pick up the controller again.
    Lets get the obvious out of the way first. The graphics in this game are just absolutely amazing! The world is rich and vibrant and I found myself just stopping and looking around at the environment from time to time. The attention to detail is well documented and you can see the amount of work put into the graphics and the open world. The story kept me engaged and wanting to get to the next part of the story to see what happens next. I was invested in the characters. I genuinely liked some of them and disliked some of them. The story will grab your attention for sure. I found the game play to be very good. Sometimes the controls got a little bit tricky, running gave me a hard time for awhile until I got used to it. gun play was great. You can tweek the difficulty of it to your suiting. You can keep it simple with an auto aim, that does make head shots extremely easy, or you can turn it off and make it more difficult. However you like to fit your play style. There are a ton of weapons in the game, although I think most people, like me will find a few that they like the best and will stick with those throughout. I found the weapon wheel easy to navigate and not to clunky. I also like the fact that there are no micro-transactions for the single player mode. Now as far as online, this is Take-Two and Rockstar, so if you choose, there are plenty of opportunities to spend your money if you wish. Overall, this game is amazing. It will keep you coming back to finish it and try and 100% it. Hell, I even bought a copy for my xbox one x so I can play it on that system as well. This game definitely deserves to be mentioned as one of the best of this console cycle. If you have not played this game yet, go buy it. You will not regret it.    … Expand
  25. GreenKing
    Apr 17, 2019
    10
    A truly impressive game that pushes the limits of this generation's consoles that also happens to have one of the finest stories in gaming. The characters are all very polarizing and draw you into the game's massive world, and the game just feels full of life.

    I actually preferred the story of Red Dead Redemption 2 to its predecessors, but I think that Red Dead Redemption had a better    A truly impressive game that pushes the limits of this generation's consoles that also happens to have one of the finest stories in gaming. The characters are all very polarizing and draw you into the game's massive world, and the game just feels full of life.

    I actually preferred the story of Red Dead Redemption 2 to its predecessors, but I think that Red Dead Redemption had a better end-game to mess around with. It's also quite easy to get enough money to unlock everything in the game, which is good and bad, in that it allows you to focus on other things without worrying about the next purchase, but also means you'll have every gun unlocked pretty early.    … Expand
  26. ps4lover
    Oct 26, 2018
    10
    Omg, what the **** wrong with PC gamers who gave 0 on this game.. Metacritic need to figure it out for keep haters, trollers and PC gamers away from give zero on games if it is not for PC version.. i played this for 2 hours last night so graphic is amazing and details like jaw dropping. gameplay is great.. physic and animations look realistic.. voice acting is top notch. music is so goodOmg, what the **** wrong with PC gamers who gave 0 on this game.. Metacritic need to figure it out for keep haters, trollers and PC gamers away from give zero on games if it is not for PC version.. i played this for 2 hours last night so graphic is amazing and details like jaw dropping. gameplay is great.. physic and animations look realistic.. voice acting is top notch. music is so good while playing game.. Please make Bully 2 and GTA VI for PS5.. RDR 3 should take event after RDR 1… Expand
  27. mohannedd
    Nov 5, 2018
    10
    The game improves nearly every aspect on it's predecessor , visuals and graphics , Music and sound , Story and cinematics , gameplay , content and side quests , missions .
    It's a masterpiece .
  28. Razel90
    Oct 26, 2018
    10
    Absolue gem of a game, little slower paced than the first red dead redemption but its not such a bad thing as it allows you to take in all the mind boggling details.
  29. kpower
    Oct 29, 2018
    10
    An adult video game. The realism brings the immersion home for me and I have never seen a more beautiful game. This game is very slow paced, but to it's benefit. There is no GTA ridiculousness here thank god. I will be playing this game for many years both online and off. Stop and smell the roses, its the more realistic open world experience ever made. People who dont like it are mouth breathers!
  30. Halovarth
    Oct 26, 2018
    10
    look at all the idiots giving it 0's just because this game is not out on PC. its a console exclusive only. just like the first one. never came out on PC. what a bunch of idiots.
  31. RuNIghtmare
    Oct 27, 2018
    10
    Абсолютно не понимаю ПК игроков, которые наставили тут нули только из-за того, что игра вышла эксклюзивно для консолей. Почему то консольные игроки не бегут ставить нули старкрафту или новой Зельде. Что же качается самой игры, то Рокстар в очередной раз превзошли себя. Великолепный и живой мир, множество случайных ситуаций и общее ощущение игры просто на высшем уровне. Крайне рекомендую кАбсолютно не понимаю ПК игроков, которые наставили тут нули только из-за того, что игра вышла эксклюзивно для консолей. Почему то консольные игроки не бегут ставить нули старкрафту или новой Зельде. Что же качается самой игры, то Рокстар в очередной раз превзошли себя. Великолепный и живой мир, множество случайных ситуаций и общее ощущение игры просто на высшем уровне. Крайне рекомендую к покупке.… Expand
  32. jelikey
    Nov 16, 2018
    10
    Overall its what I expected. A huge cash cow of a world for there online services... with a medicore single player game thrown in it.

    Pros - great world, quirky characters.

    Cons - basic gameplay, sluggish movement, inventory system awful, rpg elements worthless, lack of weapons, ultimately I found it boring.
  33. tonyneculai
    Mar 11, 2021
    10
    One of the best games I played on Ps4. Great graphics, great story, good game play, and the environment is simply great and how the world of those times is imagined. Also there's this sense of evolution in game and of things happening if you keep close to the story missions.. You can get a little side tracked if you start doing all the side missions challenges etc, but they help withOne of the best games I played on Ps4. Great graphics, great story, good game play, and the environment is simply great and how the world of those times is imagined. Also there's this sense of evolution in game and of things happening if you keep close to the story missions.. You can get a little side tracked if you start doing all the side missions challenges etc, but they help with character upgrade. I'd still advise though to stick to the story as it feels different… Expand
  34. azules88
    Oct 27, 2018
    10
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. RDR2 pasa a ser el mejor videojuego de la generación y en el top de la historia. Rockstar ha desarrollado una obra de arte. Graficamente lo más potente, sonoramente, jugablemente e historia. Es todo de 10. Gracias por darnos esta magia. Y que llegue a todos los hogares esta joya.… Expand
  35. LooTheLou
    Sep 14, 2019
    10
    Never before have I played a game that reacts to everything that you decide to do (which are MANY ways to do so) in such a way that Red Dead Redemption 2 does. RDR 2 is an outstanding masterpiece that makes the player experience what took place before RDR1. Rockstar proved, as always, they can further improve upon their existing formulae/IP plus reinvent and reimagine the worlds they soNever before have I played a game that reacts to everything that you decide to do (which are MANY ways to do so) in such a way that Red Dead Redemption 2 does. RDR 2 is an outstanding masterpiece that makes the player experience what took place before RDR1. Rockstar proved, as always, they can further improve upon their existing formulae/IP plus reinvent and reimagine the worlds they so carefully create. DO NOT MISS OUT: PLAY THIS GAME.… Expand
  36. Pandopa
    Nov 19, 2018
    10
    Best RPG ever. It's amazing to see the attention for every detail, the realism, the voice-acting, story, game-play and so on.
  37. greekgod
    Nov 11, 2018
    10
    Amazing game, all these people rating 6 and 7's are porn addicts with desensitized brains
  38. SenseyZ
    Nov 15, 2018
    10
    -NO SPOILERS-

    This is by far Rockstar's biggest achievement, and it's a game that raises the bars for RPGs by a long shot (I know it isn't really an RPG, but it sure feels and plays like one.) All these people with bad reviews are weirdly enough the kind that won't put any amount of time into the game's miscellaneous tasks such as cleaning weapons, eating, drinking, caring for your    -NO SPOILERS-

    This is by far Rockstar's biggest achievement, and it's a game that raises the bars for RPGs by a long shot (I know it isn't really an RPG, but it sure feels and plays like one.)

    All these people with bad reviews are weirdly enough the kind that won't put any amount of time into the game's miscellaneous tasks such as cleaning weapons, eating, drinking, caring for your horse. These are the kind of people that keep comparing it to GTA V, when they haven't even realized it isn't even related to it.

    Here's the gist of it, this is a phenomenal game, and don't let these red reviews lead you away from it. It's a fantastic, detailed and, inevitably, a time-consuming game (A good thing or bad? I dunno).

    This is a must play.    … Expand
  39. dr_heartless
    Nov 20, 2018
    10
    Rockstar's best game to date! It's rare that a game lives up to the hype and then some and RD2 does so. The lush living world, outstanding voice acting, a great story and all the strange and wonderful side quests you have come to expect from Rockstar. It's like a victory lap for a developer at the top of their game.
  40. PPaul27
    Oct 26, 2018
    10
    The real masterpiece of this generation console..the other software house must to learn from rockstar..years and years for build a great game..but the final result is awesone!!! RDR2 is destinate to became the new reference ponit for all future action/open world games.
  41. sscott0829tw
    Oct 28, 2018
    10
    Absolutely a game of the decade. Only MGSV, Witcher3, Zelda BoTW reach this level of greatness in this generation. Graphic and details are like PS5 level. The animation,physics,voice acting, music and story surpass all other games in this generation. The gunplay feels realistic and fun, especially in FPS mode. Side missions feels like a small story on it's own. The world feels so aliveAbsolutely a game of the decade. Only MGSV, Witcher3, Zelda BoTW reach this level of greatness in this generation. Graphic and details are like PS5 level. The animation,physics,voice acting, music and story surpass all other games in this generation. The gunplay feels realistic and fun, especially in FPS mode. Side missions feels like a small story on it's own. The world feels so alive filled with wild animals and interesting peoples. Hunting in this game feels real, you really need to track the animal to find it. Long story short, this game is a true masterpiece.… Expand
  42. LatinCritic13
    Oct 26, 2018
    10
    I'm happy to report that Rockstar Games' very first current gen game is a bonafide masterpiece in gaming history. Everything from the technical aspects all the way to the superb storytelling is what made the prequel of Red Dead Redemption a true hier for future gaming as time passes by in the future and yet, Rockstar never loses their touch. This game will resonate you compared to almostI'm happy to report that Rockstar Games' very first current gen game is a bonafide masterpiece in gaming history. Everything from the technical aspects all the way to the superb storytelling is what made the prequel of Red Dead Redemption a true hier for future gaming as time passes by in the future and yet, Rockstar never loses their touch. This game will resonate you compared to almost every Rockstar game you will ever play, especially you can feel the western intimacy as you play almost 60+ hours of story missions and it's quite spectactular. To be honest, this game feels as cinematic as it can get when you watch these cutscenes transition organically one another especially it's the first time that Rockstar used a cinematography-like in-game cutscene engine that can be used throughout the game and it's damn beautiful to look out compared to films like Blade Runner 2049, Logan, Django Unchained, Unforgiven, The Revenant, Sicario, and The Hateful Eight. If you haven't have a copy of this game yet, you better buy it, otherwise, you will be lost freely in the real wild west since the RDR. Trust me, you won't regret it.… Expand
  43. Paulocamilo
    Nov 6, 2018
    10
    this is well good game made and a sollid game ,beautifull graphics rdr2 is masterpiece.
  44. Rofalot
    Nov 6, 2018
    10
    All of my complaints with this game can be fixed by having it released on PC. There's a bit of a noticeable input lag, making the controls feel clunky, but I don't mind the game prioritizing realistic animations over responsiveness in this particular game. The textures are a bit low res sometimes when up close, and the meshes are low-poly up close. Those are all issues that can be fixedAll of my complaints with this game can be fixed by having it released on PC. There's a bit of a noticeable input lag, making the controls feel clunky, but I don't mind the game prioritizing realistic animations over responsiveness in this particular game. The textures are a bit low res sometimes when up close, and the meshes are low-poly up close. Those are all issues that can be fixed with a PC version. I won't take points away from a game just because PS4 Pro has outdated specs compared to PC.… Expand
  45. ghassenga
    Oct 30, 2018
    10
    MASTAPIEACE ! nuff said.

    btw i'm only rating writing this "review" to counter all the trolls that only came here to rate the game down due to them being console haters or playstation haters.
  46. Ethrocentaur
    Nov 17, 2018
    10
    It takes time to get used to the controls, there are some minor issues that patches might fix, but....and this is a big but.......give it time. Get used to the way it works and understand the intricacies of the game mechanics and this game is absolutely incredible. I am now 60 hours in and I'm glad I waited to write this review. It is immense, it is detailed, it is a masterpiece ofIt takes time to get used to the controls, there are some minor issues that patches might fix, but....and this is a big but.......give it time. Get used to the way it works and understand the intricacies of the game mechanics and this game is absolutely incredible. I am now 60 hours in and I'm glad I waited to write this review. It is immense, it is detailed, it is a masterpiece of gaming. This is the new cornerstone of the industry. It currently lacks on-line play but who cares....games to me are about the experience I have and it releases me from the realities of the daily grind. This game is the ultimate release. Enjoy.… Expand
  47. Aeromusic
    Oct 29, 2018
    10
    Великолепное произведение искусства с большой буквы. Аутисты с ПК не понимают, что не нужно собирать машину за тысячи $, достаточно купить маленькую коробочку под телевизор и получить великолепную картинку, идеальную оптимизацию, а главное - грамотно проработанный виртуальный мир со вниманием к мельчайшим деталям. 10 из 10. Пожелание к Rockstar Games: сохраните эксклюзивность для консолей,Великолепное произведение искусства с большой буквы. Аутисты с ПК не понимают, что не нужно собирать машину за тысячи $, достаточно купить маленькую коробочку под телевизор и получить великолепную картинку, идеальную оптимизацию, а главное - грамотно проработанный виртуальный мир со вниманием к мельчайшим деталям. 10 из 10. Пожелание к Rockstar Games: сохраните эксклюзивность для консолей, как было с первой частью! Покажите тупым имбецилам, что эра громоздких ящиков под столом ушла навсегда.… Expand
  48. PatHub
    Jan 5, 2022
    10
    One of the best games ever made. Can't wait for the next gen upgrade. Had a great time with it.
  49. toxicon
    Oct 28, 2018
    10
    So funny just to watch the PC master race giving the game 0's

    Guess the master race is getting a punch lately - GoW, RDR, Uncharted, Horizon, Zelda.

    Great stuff!
  50. Dal_ReviewedDat
    Jan 25, 2019
    10
    10/10 Not much to add.

    The game, like the RDR1, starts with a slow grind of learning mechanics. I felt the plot was okay, and then I reached the end of Chapter 3, blew my mind, and what followed was an experience I absolutely loved. It's a fantastic, deep, story driven game with very few noticeable flaws, if any. Couldn't recommend RDR2 enough, it maybe the best game I've ever    10/10 Not much to add.

    The game, like the RDR1, starts with a slow grind of learning mechanics. I felt the plot was okay, and then I reached the end of Chapter 3, blew my mind, and what followed was an experience I absolutely loved. It's a fantastic, deep, story driven game with very few noticeable flaws, if any.

    Couldn't recommend RDR2 enough, it maybe the best game I've ever played in my life    … Expand
  51. benhez
    Jul 24, 2019
    10
    A pure masterpiece in every way shape and form.
    One of the greatest games ever produced!

    A personal fave was the realism from every single detailed contextual immersive animation and inventory management, shear breathe taking engine which took my breathe away every time.
  52. LinttaFlamingo
    Sep 30, 2020
    10
    RDR Redemption 2 is bad. It's bad. So bad that I've never actually played it. It was close to being zero stars, but one thing saved it: Dicx in damelio
  53. Wahorezko
    Oct 28, 2018
    10
    лучшее во что я играл, со времен ведьмака, боже как я хочу в отпуск
  54. LexUlanov
    Nov 3, 2018
    10
    Video games of this level come out once a decade. All possible game mechanics, game design and visuals are at a new level. RockStar did it again!
  55. marco88
    Oct 29, 2018
    10
    There is no much to say. Clearly is the best open world in the market , a game that you have to live, and play as u want, feel free, I been spending hours just to go hunting and there is so much things u can do. Everything can happen to you on the way back to your camp , so be aware ! Just got robbed by 3 bandits after been catch a legendary animal, but was my fault , I was trying toThere is no much to say. Clearly is the best open world in the market , a game that you have to live, and play as u want, feel free, I been spending hours just to go hunting and there is so much things u can do. Everything can happen to you on the way back to your camp , so be aware ! Just got robbed by 3 bandits after been catch a legendary animal, but was my fault , I was trying to help someone from this bandits.. is just awesome and hard to explain, just enjoy .… Expand
  56. LucianoMarinho
    Feb 1, 2019
    10
    Esse game me encanta pela qualidade apresentada em todos os aspectos. Tudo nele é grandioso e totalmente imersivo. A Rockstar fez um trabalho excepcional e ao meu ver, elevou o padrão dos games. Simplesmente fantástico.
  57. warmakern
    Oct 26, 2018
    10
    Red Dead Redemption 2 isn't a game that should be taken lightly. This is true in most of Rockstar's long list of games, which often overwhelm the player with their sheer size and mechanical depth. Red Dead Redemption 2, however, stands out as a pinnacle among masterpieces. You may, understandably, assume that I'm simply riding the "Red Dead hype wagon" but, unless the game drasticallyRed Dead Redemption 2 isn't a game that should be taken lightly. This is true in most of Rockstar's long list of games, which often overwhelm the player with their sheer size and mechanical depth. Red Dead Redemption 2, however, stands out as a pinnacle among masterpieces. You may, understandably, assume that I'm simply riding the "Red Dead hype wagon" but, unless the game drastically changes after the first 10 hours or so, this is certainly not the case.

    From what I've experienced so far, Red Dead Redemption 2 offers the player an unprecedented amount of options in what to do and how to tackle the, both optional and integral parts of the game. Fortunately these options do not overwhelm the player, but are instead revealed progressively, allowing you to first master what is already there. After several hours spent with the game I was still constantly being surprised by a steady stream of new features and added complexity to pre-existing mechanics.

    All this depth, however, wouldn't be worth 2 cents if it wasn't for the incredibly high degree of fine tuning and polishment that went into the game. The frame rate stays smooth and constant throughout the whole experience and, incredibly enough, so far I haven't encountered a single bug during my 14 hours of playing the game. Rockstar have certainly nailed the shooting mechanics, but there are also more discreet options for those who aren't completely certain that lead is the be-all end-all problem solver.

    To summarize: Red Dead Redemption 2 is a must buy for anyone looking for a deep and fleshed out experience, that gradually unfolds during many hours of game time. It's not a game that you can rush through over the weekend (though, admittedly, I myself might in retrospect have been a bit too hasteful in order to experience as much as possible in a short time window). If you're willing to put in the time however, Red Dead Redemption 2 is guaranteed to offer you a complete and thrilling experience, brimming with possibilities for the player to discover. If I have one complaint regarding the game it's that it didn't come out sooner.    … Expand
  58. No1Livz4ever
    Feb 1, 2020
    10
    GOTY 2018, one of the best games of this gen .
  59. rosnk30
    Nov 11, 2019
    10
    RDR2 is awesome game. In fact, I didnt know, if I'll like it mostly cause I didnt expect nothing about, and it was greater good for me. I really enjoy it.

    RDR2 represents a lot of dramatic-self-story, and a whole world to explore. Great things and poor things....you choice what to do, and when to do. Its a freedom game, like other ones of Rockstar.

    10/10
  60. Minge
    Nov 5, 2018
    10
    Red Dead Redemption II Red Dead Redemption II Red Dead Redemption II ?
    Yes pretty great LMAO
  61. Maikuroha
    Nov 14, 2018
    10
    In our times of lootboxes and game content being purposely cut short for DLC's, it is really refreshing to have a game that actually worth more money than what you paid for it and not the other way around. Hats off to Rockstar for delivering this gem.
  62. Deadheadbill
    Oct 28, 2018
    10
    Amazing game. Story, graphics and world building are heads above anything released this year. Like playing a Sam Peckinpah western. Highly recommended.
  63. Hillmaus
    Oct 29, 2018
    10
    This is "must have game" beautiful scenery of wild west,hunting animals,absolute freedom, you can do whatever you want.
  64. jerrymimus
    Nov 13, 2018
    10
    When I started the game and got a few hours in I was not very impressed and was ready to rate a 5. However after sticking with it I found the things which irrotated me in the beggining quickly became solid charms of the game and the story just gets better and better. I have never been so impressed with a game and this is in my opinion a masterpiece of a game. This game is like a fineWhen I started the game and got a few hours in I was not very impressed and was ready to rate a 5. However after sticking with it I found the things which irrotated me in the beggining quickly became solid charms of the game and the story just gets better and better. I have never been so impressed with a game and this is in my opinion a masterpiece of a game. This game is like a fine whiskey and best enjoyed slowly not smashed down like a shot of cheap zambuka.… Expand
  65. sp1ney
    Jul 23, 2020
    10
    I can't believe how good it is. 11/10

    And I don't even count multiplayer...
  66. GTA-5-ROCK
    Dec 15, 2018
    10
    Red Dead Redemption 2 is amazing and stunning. This game has super beautiful graphics and a great storyline.
  67. HHosseinKhalaji
    Oct 26, 2018
    10
    Red Dead Redemption 2, This game is the best game I ever played so far and it is an art, The storyline, Graphic, atmosphere of the game is just like life breathing, so much details, it is just amazing, every corner you can find new things to do, you can do things, decide what you want to do, and the game will surprise you like real life. The only negative thing I found so far is how toRed Dead Redemption 2, This game is the best game I ever played so far and it is an art, The storyline, Graphic, atmosphere of the game is just like life breathing, so much details, it is just amazing, every corner you can find new things to do, you can do things, decide what you want to do, and the game will surprise you like real life. The only negative thing I found so far is how to play, there is so much details so the game must guide you properly, and sometimes in the game the player confuse what is happening or what they have to do to earn rewards as they complete a mission or start it but the real life is confusing too. So I will update the review after I go further in the game. The only things I have to say is to those that gave the game zero or negative. Whats wrong with you guys? Just it does not have PC version?!… Expand
  68. 7thSapphire
    Oct 31, 2018
    10
    This game is unlike anything I've ever played. The world is compelling visually and mind-boggling in its details. But it's not just a gallery to walk through and observe -- you can interact with it in many dynamic and interesting ways, experimenting and trying different approaches to different situations. Some open worlds are filled with content represented by points on a map to explore. IThis game is unlike anything I've ever played. The world is compelling visually and mind-boggling in its details. But it's not just a gallery to walk through and observe -- you can interact with it in many dynamic and interesting ways, experimenting and trying different approaches to different situations. Some open worlds are filled with content represented by points on a map to explore. I think that's a bad design decision which removes the joy of discovery. Here, visual and audio clues drive exploration, and it's a joy to traverse through the same areas again and again because each time the developers have striven to make it a fresh experience.

    For example, I've traveled to a town called Valentine countless times. Sometimes there's someone being mugged there at night, or gang members will show up, or a preacher will be preaching, or a beggar begging. You can interact with each of these and it never seems to stop. Whether these are dynamic or scripted (and probably a combination of both), doesn't matter to me. Nothing in this world seems to be repeated.

    Many games have countless side quests, and your time with the characters in each one is brief and not that interesting. Here, there are extended side quests where you interact with a single character in a story arc. It's much more compelling.

    In essence, if you like to explore a world AND interact with it, you should get this game.

    The amount of excellent dialogue in this game is crazy, especially with your fellow gang members. I'm constantly surprised when I go back to the camp; the gang seems to be talking about something else, whether I'm listening in or not.

    The world has this feeling of going on without you.

    The game does have a slower pace; there are animations for just about everything. But I actually enjoy the slower pace, and I feel like the game is more tactile and interactive because of it.

    My biggest gripe is that some systems are not explained very well. Just one for example, why do I need to donate supplies to the camp apart from upgrades? Is there some benefit to that? The game needs to teach duels prior to a duel and not during a duel (where you have a super small time window to read the hints on the screen). Why do you have to walk so slowly at camp?

    Sometimes I also feel like there's too much going on. Eating constantly to gain weight is a drag, constantly brushing your horse, maintaining your guns. My OCD nature tells me I'm always forgetting to do something, and there aren't ui warnings for all of these. I feel like especially maintaining weight is superfluous.

    But overall, these do not detract from what's here. It's a very long game, but because it's so engaging, I imagine I'll be playing it for a very long time to get all the extra collectibles and whatnot.    … Expand
  69. MrNiceGuy
    Sep 1, 2019
    10
    Masterpiece, an artistic and atmospheric adventure with every angle perfected
  70. europepro
    Jul 19, 2020
    10
    Este fue mi primer juego de acceso anticipado y no me decepcionó . Espere tanto por el que disfrute cada minuto de la historia luego al llegar al online lo deje ...existe un antes y un después con este juego en muchas mecánicas .. realmente vale oro
  71. lipesg
    Oct 27, 2018
    10
    A masterpiece.
    Rockstar once again raised the bar for the open world genre.
    I won`t say much, just that this is a game that everyone who loves videogame needs to play.

    PS: PC retards stop posting negative reviews. Instead grow up and go get yourselves a PS4 or Xbox One!
  72. MrTibster
    Oct 27, 2018
    10
    People who are giving this a 0 because it's not on PC... grow up.

    The game is simply everything I could have hoped for a sequel, its a gorgeous love letter to the western genre, and a beautifully told tale with a cast of wonderful characters.
  73. ecimir
    Nov 3, 2018
    10
    Probably the best game ever made. Immersive, beautiful and fun. Makes you feel like a real outlaw in Wild West.
  74. diegorper
    Jan 23, 2021
    10
    "Unbelievable" it's the best word I found to define this masterpiece. Simply the best game ever made.
  75. AlexVS
    Oct 27, 2018
    10
    Its amazing! Best open-world with a great opportunities, interesting story line and stunning graphics. Thank you so much, Rockstar!
  76. FootCreem9
    Nov 16, 2018
    10
    This is tied with the original Call of Duty 4 and age of mythology for the 3 best games I have ever played, hands down...most of these reviews seem fake....especially the ones that are talking about how their online service is pay to win, THE ONLINE HAS NOT BEEN RELEASED YET.....nobody knows what it's going to be, but just based on the single player I like this game more than anything IThis is tied with the original Call of Duty 4 and age of mythology for the 3 best games I have ever played, hands down...most of these reviews seem fake....especially the ones that are talking about how their online service is pay to win, THE ONLINE HAS NOT BEEN RELEASED YET.....nobody knows what it's going to be, but just based on the single player I like this game more than anything I have played in the last 5 years at LEAST. oh by the way I have played through the game 2 times completely and starting a third time so i'm not one of these 15% ers who are still in the tutorial and whining.. BUY IT, seriously, this is the first game I have ever bought the deluxe edition and not regretted it. And yes I changed my icon to the cover art, that's how much i liked it.… Expand
  77. Sammyy06
    Nov 8, 2018
    10
    That 7.7 user score is a shame. Not being available on PC shouldn't have an impact on a video game rating and most of the bad ratings are because of that. This is easily one of the best video game ever made. (The best in my opinion) It took 7 years to create this game and honestly, you can see why every time you play it. The attention to details is unmatch, the world is alive like no otherThat 7.7 user score is a shame. Not being available on PC shouldn't have an impact on a video game rating and most of the bad ratings are because of that. This is easily one of the best video game ever made. (The best in my opinion) It took 7 years to create this game and honestly, you can see why every time you play it. The attention to details is unmatch, the world is alive like no other game, the story is brilliant (even the side quests and random encounters are really well written), the content available in the game is just ridiculous, and I won't even talk about the graphic because we've all seen images. This game is objectively one of the most polish game ever made.… Expand
  78. radiorock
    Jul 19, 2020
    10
    Fantastic environments. Tons of entertaining activities. Good story. Great characters. Must play indeed.
  79. ZMZMZM2900
    Oct 26, 2018
    10
    Read dead 2 is a fantastic game, from fun addicting game play to amazing graphics. I had loads of fun playing this game
  80. MattchewHawk
    Feb 9, 2020
    10
    A true gunslinger
    Often after finishing a game, I find myself going back, getting the last few easy trophies and then uninstalling it and starting something else. But Red Dead Redemption is one of those very few games that I can't bring myself to remove from my PS4, I keep wanting to go back, I keep wanting to be a part of that sprawling open world, to search for any tiny thing i might    A true gunslinger
    Often after finishing a game, I find myself going back, getting the last few easy trophies and then uninstalling it and starting something else. But Red Dead Redemption is one of those very few games that I can't bring myself to remove from my PS4, I keep wanting to go back, I keep wanting to be a part of that sprawling open world, to search for any tiny thing i might have missed, to search for more...of everything.
    Video games, although amazing in their own right, rarely draw you in like a good book or an awesome movie does. making you invest in the characters and care what happens to them. Maybe it's the fact that in video games your character can die 50 times along the way and still come back, they can take 5 bullets to the chest and somehow still win the fight, so the outcome of a story can be somewhat disjointed. But sometimes you can play a game, and be totally immersed into that world, and character that you can't put it down.
    Describing the world of Arthur Morgan can never do it justice, its beautiful, massive, alive, mysterious and full. it's a toy box of small and big stories and characters. it looks and feels like a window into the past, down the tiniest details. Rockstar has always delivered rich and interesting worlds, but this far exceeds anything they've done before.
    From the stunning graphics, to the immersive sound, to the believable, if somewhat flawed characters, none of which are saints, but all of which are likable in their own right. everything just feels real and raw.
    At first, I wasn't sold on the protagonist Arthur Morgan, he seemed spiteful, nasty and vindictive, but you soon realize that underneath all that hard skin is a real person, with a troubled past, with friends and enemies, with hopes and dreams, and it makes you gradually care more and more about him as the game goes on. And you also develop a liking for Arthur's unruly band of scoundrels too.
    My favorite place in the game is the home camp. I often found myself spending hours sitting around the campfire, listening to everyone's stories and songs, interacting with everyone and always hearing something new. There seems to be a never ending supply of dialogue, some of which you'll only hear at certain points of the games story. It feels like a typical dysfunctional family, where everyone has their own quirks, likes and dislikes, some people don't get on, but as a whole everyone enjoys each others company.
    The Gameplay is also top notch, The gunplay, the riding mechanics, the cover system and the hand to hand combat all feel like they've been finely tuned and refined over and over again to near perfection.
    Visually this game is beyond beautiful, the lighting, realistic textures, character models that change over time, the mud, water, trees, everything all just works together to create a believable open world.
    outside of the story is the multiplayer, at the beginning this was very bare bones and not something that interested me much, but this has been added to over time and has improved, but the single player element is where this game shines. The story will grip you from start to finish, it's hard to put down. I played this game for 18 straight hours one day, and I have a short attention span usually so that speaks volumes.
    this game isn't perfect, you'll probably encounter the odd bug here and there, I fell through the map on a few occasions, and some of the missions miss the mark, but it's all forgivable as on a whole this game is amazing. You owe it to yourself to play this game. Then go and play Red Dead 1, as it's aged pretty well and fleshes out the events after this game. Rockstar has definitely done it again. I can't wait to see what they do if they ever revisit this world again.    … Expand
  81. lookash001
    Feb 10, 2019
    10
    Arthur Morgan - one of the best playable character of all time! What a game...
  82. mrwarlock
    Oct 26, 2018
    10
    I am so sad that so many PC haters show up just to bring this console exclusive down and give 0 ratings. Many of them literally state that it's for the exclusivity or 30 fps. It's too early to give proper ratings, but I just have to oppose those as**oles. 5 hrs into the game and it feels and looks great so far.
  83. WWEJoker2013
    Oct 27, 2018
    10
    Red Dead Redemption 2 is by far the best game of the year and probably the best game of the generation. Now...for the Pc haters, chill. Rockstar will most likely bring this game to PC next year.
  84. v3nomro
    Mar 30, 2020
    10
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. A masterpiece game ! Thank you Rockstar, one of the very few companies that gives you games worth the money you spend on them! Graphics, story, characters 10/10. The only lack is romance scenes. But its still a great a game!… Expand
  85. kyle20ellis
    Mar 9, 2022
    10
    'Red Dead Redemption II (2018)' simply is a masterpiece. It might even be better than its predecessor. It's one of the absolute best looking games ever to be released; its huge, varied world is rendered in an impressive, almost photo-real way. It's filled to the brim with life, from birds circling in the sky overhead to fish swimming in the river beneath your feet to strangers stuck by the'Red Dead Redemption II (2018)' simply is a masterpiece. It might even be better than its predecessor. It's one of the absolute best looking games ever to be released; its huge, varied world is rendered in an impressive, almost photo-real way. It's filled to the brim with life, from birds circling in the sky overhead to fish swimming in the river beneath your feet to strangers stuck by the side of the road. The open-world is probably the most detailed and lived-in I've ever experienced. It feels markedly real. That's a good thing, too, considering the amount of time you'll spend traversing it. Riding to and from your main objectives will often take longer than the missions themselves. The lack of comprehensive fast travel means you'll be doing this long after you've seen every beautiful location the map has to offer. Thankfully, then, no two journeys are ever the same. The amount of ways you can interact with the people you meet out in the world is amazing, and the small encounters you directly control are incredibly satisfying to play. They're possibly the best aspects of the game. That's because the main missions, which can often feel restrictive when compared to the free-roaming stuff, are as often utterly thrilling as they are frustratingly slow. The piece has a deliberate pace which unfortunately means that it takes a while to truly get going. However, it very much adds to the overall experience. It's supposed to be long, ebbing and flowing as its seasons and circumstances change. Its extended epilogue does take the wind out of the sails of its ending, but it's arguably vital in achieving the effect the finale is meant to have. Regardless of its issues, the narrative is straight-up phenomenal. It tells an at once personal and sweeping tale, crafting characters that seem so human you could swear they were real. Something that the piece does a phenomenal job with is the development of its side-characters. The people who don't get much play in the cut-scenes can be spoken to around camp, or even taken on small adventures, which is somehow enough for you to form almost as close a connection with them as you do with any other. When one of your companions inevitably dies, it's genuinely heartbreaking. That can be said of the overall thing, too. It's heartbreaking. Yet, it's also exciting, funny, hopeful, tragic, beautiful and, even, poignant. It strikes the perfect balance between sincere and satirical. It's generally more serious than its predecessor and, as such, it's more impactful. Most of the silliness is reserved for its entertaining side-missions, which suits them well. It's often genuinely affecting and it has a strong underlying theme that lives up to its title. The writing is just wonderful. It's consistently good across each and every character you meet. The morality system actually changes some small things about the story, too. For the best result, you should get all of your dastardly doings out of the way to begin with; the most fitting ending, thematically, is the 'high honour' one. The gameplay itself is enjoyable and varied, with satisfying shooting and surprisingly deep mini-games. The animation, which is superb, does sometimes get in the way, causing some slight chunkiness that can be cumbersome to begin with. However, this is easy to adjust to and it simply adds to the overall slower pace of the game. It's a measured affair, never as unrelentingly fast as some of its peers but nearly always more satisfying. In the end, this is an engaging, entertaining and affecting experience. It's a massive, thematically rich ride that stands out as one of the best games of all time. 10/10… Expand
  86. saintninja
    Oct 26, 2018
    10
    THIS. IS. AWESOME, DUDE! This is not a game. Seriously. This is new life, revolution in game industry! Sorry, Geralt, but you will be second now... Here astronomic level of detalization. Not polygons. But life of whole world. Everything here is alive. No programming, alive! Yes, you must play this... not game... masterpiece!
  87. MagiCPSG
    Sep 20, 2019
    10
    The most immersive open world game ever made at that date. Everything in this world is so credible and realistic, and Arthur Morgan is a touching character, I really loved RDR2. Thanks Rockstar, i'm not a fan of GTA but RDR is really the kind of games I love.
  88. Narson
    Nov 16, 2018
    10
    I love the game, its attention to details, realism, but as well ability to do anything you want. Arthur Morgan is in my opinion the best character of all Rockstar games. He is not some random generic character like you often see in games, but deep and complex human being with internal struggle with what he's done and been doing. Map is full of stuff to do. There are variety of differentI love the game, its attention to details, realism, but as well ability to do anything you want. Arthur Morgan is in my opinion the best character of all Rockstar games. He is not some random generic character like you often see in games, but deep and complex human being with internal struggle with what he's done and been doing. Map is full of stuff to do. There are variety of different strangers, who you can help or just kill. You can just drown in the amount of content, and easily forget about the main story. Oh yes, the story is amazing. Every mission had meaning and going through 6 main chapters of the game was great. I couldn't wait for new events of the game to unravel and pushed some parts of the game forward just to get to know what happens to the gang.

    I'm so amazed by this stuff I almost forget about the downsides. For example looting bodies is pain in the ass after aprox. 50h, fast travel isn't really that fast and would be cool if I could just "teleport" to some places later on in the game instead of revisiting every place countless number of times. Those contextual controls were also annoying as hell (for example picking up different stuff on different button each time). Still, the best game, the most interesting (sidequest-wise) experience I've had in a loooong time. I thought about 9/10, but when I've completed the game I changed my mind and decided to give it a solid 10/10. I wish we had more games like it.    … Expand
  89. NexxeR
    Oct 28, 2018
    10
    I'm 37. In recent years, i'v lost interest in most games. Spiderman was great.. but nothing much excites me as before....Until RDR2 came out. i was hyped like everyone else, but i didn't expect to be sucked in to this game as i have in since launch. I literately want to play all the time. i simply love the emphasis on the immersion, the characters, the graphics... Absolutely amazing. Don'tI'm 37. In recent years, i'v lost interest in most games. Spiderman was great.. but nothing much excites me as before....Until RDR2 came out. i was hyped like everyone else, but i didn't expect to be sucked in to this game as i have in since launch. I literately want to play all the time. i simply love the emphasis on the immersion, the characters, the graphics... Absolutely amazing. Don't understand what all the fuss is about in regards to gameplay.... the hell is wrong with it? Not sure who the 500 or so people who gave a negative review are, but honestly, who cares. go play fortnight and leave us happy people to enjoy the game.… Expand
  90. anto81
    Oct 26, 2018
    10
    Best open world game ever made,as usual Rockstar set the bar and on this one is very high,perfect!!!!
  91. chescone
    Oct 26, 2018
    10
    Well, I haven't played this game. I won't play it for like another month. But I will give it a 10, because User Scores can't be trusted these days.

    I'm reading lots of burnt dudes who play on PC and that are angry because game didn't come out for PC and they gave it a 0. (HAHAHA BURN CRYBABIES!!!!) Second of all, i'm reading a lot of guys who gave it a 0 because there aren't any    Well, I haven't played this game. I won't play it for like another month. But I will give it a 10, because User Scores can't be trusted these days.

    I'm reading lots of burnt dudes who play on PC and that are angry because game didn't come out for PC and they gave it a 0. (HAHAHA BURN CRYBABIES!!!!)

    Second of all, i'm reading a lot of guys who gave it a 0 because there aren't any turtles in the game? Seriously??? Grow Up!

    And third, a lot of 0's because game does not run 60 FPS 4K. I'm just gonna say that i'm losing my faith in humanity.

    So, if these guys can give a game a 0 without even playing the game, and crying about turtles, and for not being patient with technology, I can give it a 10 just because. Cheers :)    … Expand
  92. SuperDuck23
    Nov 26, 2018
    10
    As I progressed further and further through Red Dead Redemption 2, the game continually found new ways to surprise me with it's bold and elegant storytelling. With the help of a fantastic performance from Roger Clark and exceptional writing, Arthur Morgan will go down as one of the greatest video game protagonists of all time.

    The world is breathtaking due to the sheer level of detail    As I progressed further and further through Red Dead Redemption 2, the game continually found new ways to surprise me with it's bold and elegant storytelling. With the help of a fantastic performance from Roger Clark and exceptional writing, Arthur Morgan will go down as one of the greatest video game protagonists of all time.

    The world is breathtaking due to the sheer level of detail and dense wildlife Rockstar have put into it. Side quests are also worth your time as they flesh out Arthur's character making you appreciate the main story even more. I'm glad I took my time with the game, as I feel that's the best way to play through it. There's just too much there to ignore.

    Ultimately Red Dead Redemption 2 is a sheer masterclass in how to make an open world video game - where the flaws are so minimal compared to the strength of the positives, that it seems petty to complain about them. This will go down as one of my favourite games of all time.    … Expand
  93. GamingNinja
    Apr 16, 2019
    10
    The best and most immersive game of this entire generation. I loved every minute of this immersive goodness. The world looks incredible and the animations are so lifelike, I absolutely love the way you can interact with npc's.
  94. Eienkei
    Mar 14, 2021
    10
    Took me a while to play, get used to, like and then love RDR2.
    Hands down, it might be the game of the decade for me. I was not expecting such an amazing story by R*, I absolutely loved the characters and Arthur Morgan easily has become one of my all time characters.
    Everything about the game ended up feeling right.
    The first 5 hours are slow, but bear with it, it's an absolute masterpiece.
  95. DeaconFrost
    Oct 26, 2018
    10
    I will keep this short and simple : EA ? Are you watching ? This is how games should be made. There you have it.
  96. Kargun
    Jan 7, 2019
    10
    La inmersión es total. No juegas a este videojuego, lo vives. El sistema no te obliga a vivir la cotidianeidad del personaje pero no puedes evitar hacerlo. Además la trama es bastante interesante y está montada de forma que parece que avanzas tú libremente por ella, que no está guionizada, y eso es algo que no suele verse en un mundo abierto. Si que es verdad que las misiones en sí no sonLa inmersión es total. No juegas a este videojuego, lo vives. El sistema no te obliga a vivir la cotidianeidad del personaje pero no puedes evitar hacerlo. Además la trama es bastante interesante y está montada de forma que parece que avanzas tú libremente por ella, que no está guionizada, y eso es algo que no suele verse en un mundo abierto. Si que es verdad que las misiones en sí no son muy originales, pero están compensadas por todo las historias que se van narrando a su alrededor.
    Los compañeros de la banda viven sus vidas y te lo hacen saber, llegas a creerte sus sentimientos y acaban logrando que les cojas cariño o que les odies. Siempre que despierto en el campamento siento la necesidad de hablar con todos ellos para saber qué les inquieta y esa es una sensación maravillosa que ningún otro juego me había hecho sentir.    … Expand
  97. Darius11
    Nov 2, 2018
    10
    Just changed my score to a 10 because all those people giving a 0. What a joke. Its nevera 0 , its clear people that don't play or have a grudge are putting false reviews. Meta critic sort this out!

    Don't listen to the 0/10 people. They are most likely PC players that are jealous. Graphics 9/10 - On the Ps pro they are great. No doubt better on the One X. Either way a huge step up    Just changed my score to a 10 because all those people giving a 0. What a joke. Its nevera 0 , its clear people that don't play or have a grudge are putting false reviews. Meta critic sort this out!

    Don't listen to the 0/10 people. They are most likely PC players that are jealous.

    Graphics 9/10 - On the Ps pro they are great. No doubt better on the One X. Either way a huge step up for a game of this size. Always can be better but some moments will take your breath away.

    Gameplay 8/10- Gunplay is really good. Its always a thrill when you get into a battle. Horse riding is pretty basic, I don't think you can innovate much here, but they do it well enough. General controls are good. Only real issue is picking stuff up in small areas. Lastly the game can be too easy. You can do the missions by staying in cover a lot and using deadeye. Its a shame as I think they should of made it much more challenging.

    Story 9/10 - For me the story is really interesting. A really good feel to it. The pace starts slowly and builds up consistently. I wont spoil anything but a solid story for sure.

    Overall 9/10- This is not a game to be rushed. I took everything at my own pace, taking in the world, exploring , stumbling into random side quests. Its not a game for people that just want action and no travelling as you will spend a lot of time on your horse. But if you have the patience you will find a beautiful world to explore. If any game is worth the £60 tag then its this.    … Expand
  98. JaazP1
    Oct 26, 2018
    10
    Red Dead Redemption 2 , en adelante RDR2 para abreviar, no es un juego más, es el juego de esta generación como ha demostrado Alvaro en el análisis que no me he leído y en el 10 que creo que le van a poner. Este juego destila calidad desde los cojones del caballo (no esixise o como se diga) hasta las montañas nevadas, todo ha sido recreado con maestría por el talento que solo puedenRed Dead Redemption 2 , en adelante RDR2 para abreviar, no es un juego más, es el juego de esta generación como ha demostrado Alvaro en el análisis que no me he leído y en el 10 que creo que le van a poner. Este juego destila calidad desde los cojones del caballo (no esixise o como se diga) hasta las montañas nevadas, todo ha sido recreado con maestría por el talento que solo pueden ofrecer los chicos de Rockstar. Thx Mrs. Crunch.

    Gráficamente es de lo más bestia que recuerdo en mi vida, con más mérito siendo un juego de mundo abierto, especial mención a la gran calidad de los suelos y las tierras. Pero todo tiene un nivel de detalle que roza la locura por el perfeccionismo, como el control del caballo, el mejor que se ha visto con diferencia.

    Cuento los minutos para poder ponerme en la piel de Morgan y vivir sus increíbles aventuras junto con su banda de pendencieros, las misiones prometen ser adrenalina pura. Y los tiroteos de los más intensos de la historia de los videojuegos, con uso de tiempo bala incluido.

    Tal vez tenga algunos defectos como que no venga doblado al 2 idioma más hablado de forma nativa del sistema solar, pero es una pequeñez ya que el trabajo en doblaje de los juegos de R es magnifico, y la cantidad de líneas de diálogo es abrumadora.

    Un juego de época que disfrutaremos sin duda en PS4, en menor medida en xbox y en ninguna medida en switch y pc

    Algo como RDR2 pasa pocas veces en la vida, tenemos suerte de ser coetáneos de una obra de una calidad que pasará a los anales de los tiempos, La Odisea de nuestros tiempos, solo me queda felicitar a Álvaro y a los chicos/as de Rockstar por su impresionante trabajo y decir, ¡Qué viva el lejano oeste!    … Expand
  99. Gamercritic777
    Nov 9, 2018
    10
    I just giave it a 10 to balance out. There seemt o be many "new" aacounts here giving the game a zero rating. Paid trolls i assume.
  100. mattyiceboy
    Nov 6, 2019
    10
    Been replaying it to see if it's as good as I remember and it is. Beautiful and immersive, great gameplay loop. It does drag a bit in some sections but as someone wbo loves a good singleplayer story I don't really mind. I don't cate about the online and played it for a hour before I was bored lol.
Page:

Awards & Rankings

1
#1 Best PS4 Game of 2018
2
#2 Most Discussed PS4 Game of 2018
2
#2 Most Shared PS4 Game of 2018

Critic Reviews

All reviews »
Metascore
97

Universal acclaim - based on 99 Critic Reviews

Critic score distribution:
  1. Positive: 98 out of 99
  2. Mixed: 1 out of 99
  3. Negative: 0 out of 99
  1. CD-Action
    Nov 14, 2019
    95
    It’s an huge, outstanding piece of art – worth the hard-earned cash as well as countless hours that are needed to get to know at least some of the attractions of Rockstar’s rendition of Wild West. For those who put story first – the biggest virtue of Red Dead Redemption 2 is that it sets the stage for RDR 1 and does it wonderfully. [13/2018, p.40]
  2. LEVEL (Czech Republic)
    Dec 31, 2018
    100
    Amazing not only for Western lovers. No other game has probably offered so many options to express yourself in the open world, and at the same time did not have such an interesting, rough and moving story. A magnificent experience, with a slightly slower start. [Issue#291]
  3. TrueGaming
    Nov 30, 2018
    95
    The first new game from Rockstar for this generation of consoles doesn't disappoint, it is as impressive as you hoped it to be.
    Read full review
See all critic reviews »