Punch Line

 PlayStation 4
Metascore
66

Mixed or average reviews - based on 9 Critic Reviews

Critic score distribution:
  1. Positive: 3 out of 9
  2. Mixed: 4 out of 9
  3. Negative: 2 out of 9
Buy Now
Buy on
  1. PlayStation LifeStyle
    Oct 4, 2018
    90
    The game was a joy to experience and I cannot wait to see how the world is saved. Visual novel fan or not, the characters, writing, and unique gameplay are all easily appreciated and enjoyed. And while the fan service is definitely there, it’s not the focus of the game. In fact, in a perfect, non-destroyed world, you’ll see as few panties as possible.
  2. PlayStation Universe
    Oct 15, 2018
    85
    Punch Line tells a fantastic story amidst all the chaos that takes place. It may seem pervy from its advertisements but there is a charming experience here that you will surely remember.
  3. Digitally Downloaded
    Sep 3, 2018
    80
    Very much an insider's parody of a type of anime that only the most dedicated (and therefore, likely aware) fans of anime in the first place. For that niche Punch Line is pitch-perfect.

User Reviews

All reviews »
User Score
5.1

Mixed or average reviews- based on 20 Ratings

User score distribution:
  1. Positive: 8 out of 20
  2. Mixed: 2 out of 20
  3. Negative: 10 out of 20
  1. hyphz
    Feb 25, 2021
    5
    I'm in two minds about this game. On the one hand, there's the story, which can basically be summed up in two words: Kotaro Uchikoshi. It'sI'm in two minds about this game. On the one hand, there's the story, which can basically be summed up in two words: Kotaro Uchikoshi. It's got all his classic strengths: creative use of time travel and metafiction, mysteries and bangs that keep the plot driving forward, and distinct characters - and unlike many of his games, it has an actual proper ending. Unfortunately, it also has many of his classic weaknesses: too many conveniently outlandish characters in too small a physical and narrative space and a massively confused scale, characters not acting their age, some moments with very awkward pacing, and some tremendous contrivances (such as a major military battle in which apparently no-one was badly hurt). It's the kind of story that's great to go through once, but it's probably not going to be that memorable.

    And let's be clear - this is all about the story. This is a visual novel, not a puzzle game. Yes, there's sections where you try to manipulate objects in order to play "tricks" to get events you want to happen, but the number of choices of object is quite small and inconsistent and the consequences are too unpredictable to really be tactical. Yes, it can be hilarious to see how your actions domino through to affect the characters, but that's a double edged sword - in order to be hilarious, it has to be unpredictable, which means you're just guessing at what to do in most of the scenarios. It's also weirdly stop/start - when you click on an item to manipulate, you have to wait while the screen fades to black and white, the object moves, it pauses, the screen fades back in, you see the reaction, and then the screen whites out completely with a "cleanup in progress" sign because they couldn't be bothered to animate the character recovering from being tricked. It's irritating and breaks any immersion the game was going for.

    In fact, about three-quarters of the way through the game it drops the "trick" part entirely and becomes a traditional VN with binary choices, most of which lead have one option to continue and one that is instant death. What's worse, they often don't make sense. For example, the very first choice you get is when a character asks you to do something that makes perfect sense at the time, but if you say you'll do it, you get an instant ending saying that you ultimately failed to achieve a key goal as a result of being too dependent on them. Which is ridiculous because a) you've been depending on them the whole game up to that point, and b) when you make the correct choice, you find that all they were going to do is tell you they aren't going to give you orders and leave!

    And then there is the elephant in the room. Panties. The weird thing is that they aren't needed in the game, or plot, at all. There's never like a critical moment when they matter, and the only influence they have on the game is that if they come into view during the trick segments the controls go wobbly and you have to pan away from them before a timer runs out (or just press a single button to change the camera position to a different one, which makes it trivial, and also makes you notice that there are camera positions which exist only to upskirt the female characters). You might be looking at panties (on a cartoon 3D model) like 3-4 seconds, if you play badly - so if you actually want to do that, it won't be satisfying, and if you just find the whole thing a bit creepy like I did, it's just unnecessarily so. Yet the game mentions them all the time, the loading screen shows a girl with her skirt riding up, there's a "gallery" of viewed panty shots, one of the chapters is called "panty party" (which does not contain any panties nor even mention them) etc.. It just comes across as unnecessarily creepy, and has the feeling of having been glued onto the game because of the popularity of salacious VNs in some markets and/or because of the tie-in with an existing anime (although the anime just treated it as an occasionally-mentioned joke).

    There's also some QoL problems. The game doesn't tell you a whole bunch of useful things, such as that you can skip videos by holding down X (which you will want to do, because the game plays an identical anime opening and closing sequence for every one of the 20 chapters) or that you can save at any time (which you will also want to do, because the instant deaths in part 2 otherwise require you to play the entire chapter from the beginning, and one of them is right at the end of a chapter!)

    So if you can get this as a sale price and you don't mind the visual novel gameplay and narrative style, and can tolerate the unnecessary creepage, it's probably worth a punt, especially if you're an Uchikoshi fan and are frustrated by his endings (since this has one of the most satisfactory endings of any Uchikoshi game). But it's generally too weak to be a global recommendation, and certainly not worth full price.    … Full Review »
  2. tomvs123
    Feb 20, 2019
    4
    Punch Line is a strange one and might be worth your time if:

    1. You like typical harem/sci-fi Anime. 2. You like looking at panties    Punch Line is a strange one and might be worth your time if:

    1. You like typical harem/sci-fi Anime.
    2. You like looking at panties (briefly).
    3. You don't mind spending 90% of your time pressing X to advance the story.

    Overall, the story is average. The characters are the main focus here, but there's not a lot interesting about most of them. How they interact with the world is flimsy story-wise, but at least there's no gaping plot holes or silly twists that makes the story completely unbelievable.

    You basically start out as a ghost that has been kicked out of your body for reasons you'll find out later. You spend the first half of the game leveling up your astral powers by playing tricks on the girls in the house, while trying to avoid their panties. Panties are bad for you, since that ends humanity. Thankfully, the reason for panties ending humanity is based in some reason, so it's not completely nonsensical.

    Then the story twist happens and things take on a whole different light. It's not the most amazing twist ever, but it was able to keep me interested enough to not get bored (I stopped watching harem Anime roughly 15 years ago).

    I'm disappointed with the panties. Except for a few loading screens, they're all 3D. The actual modeling of panties and butts is good, but not anywhere near the limits of what the PS4 could handle. Panty texture quality is low and there are obvious sharp angles in the butt polygons. And because looking at panties ends humanity, you can't look at them in-game for more than about 15 seconds at a time. Your camera is also fixed onto a single point, so you can only pivot it around. So no viewing the character models in their full glory.

    The panty-related extras are very disappointing. They unlock after you complete the game and consist only of pictures of the 3d models (lower half only). There's no viewer for the loading screen pictures and there's no 3d model viewer. A 3d model viewer is a necessity for any self-respecting panty game, and this one doesn't have it..

    As for the gameplay, it's very limited. Besides pressing X to advance the story, you'll occasionally get to move objects in the girls' rooms to scare them (revealing their panties) or to advance the story. Choosing the wrong option or doing the wrong thing ends humanity and you'll immediately be able to retry.

    So yeah, I don't like it that much. Average story, limited panties/extras, and almost no gameplay makes this one not so good. Though I suppose it's a valid alternative to actually watching the Punch Line anime.    … Full Review »
  3. Broyax
    Jun 21, 2023
    0
    A priori, c’est juste un autre jeu un brin débile -pour ne pas dire complètement con- pour otaculs voyeurs (pléonasme) puisqu’il faut jouer auA priori, c’est juste un autre jeu un brin débile -pour ne pas dire complètement con- pour otaculs voyeurs (pléonasme) puisqu’il faut jouer au ‘poltergeist’ et faire peur à des cocottes plus ou moins tarées (et/ou excentriques) afin de récupérer indirectement… son propre corps, puisqu’on est devenu à l’insu de son plein gré un fantôme !

    En déplaçant des objets, on peut aussi faire en sorte d’obtenir ce que l’on cherche… à obtenir, via un effet papillon provoqué… que l’on provoque cela dit tout à fait au pifomètre ou presque. Cela ne satisfera ni les amateurs de jeu d’aventure (ce n’en est pas un) ni les voyeurs d’ailleurs, car si l’on voit deux fois de suite une culotte, c’est… la fin du monde !

    Et il faut recommencer le ‘niveau’ , à savoir la séquence d’évènements depuis le début… autant dire que le principe amusant quelques minutes, devient vite très barbant… et que les sauvegardes rapides ne fonctionnent pas si l’on quitte le jeu ! à quoi servent-elles alors ? en outre, ce jeu de merde ne fait pas de sauvegardes automatiques et ne demande à faire la vraie sauvegarde qu’à la fin de chaque ‘niveau’…

    Or, un fond orange ou un fond noir, on ne sait pas lequel sélectionne l’autre dans la boîte de dialogue, on appuie au pif et en fait, on se retrouve gros Jean comme devant et faut tout recommencer du tout début, putain de merde ! et se retaper toutes les explications oiseuses du chat qui parle… (oui, un matou qui n’arrête pas de jacter, il nous gave à vitesse grand V !).

    Les voix sont uniquement en japonais et le texte en anglais. En plus, les cinématiques ne sont pas zappables ! les graphismes sont assez simplets et ça ne tourne qu’à 30 im/s (aucune excuse, donc !). Alors, on a plus vite fait de désinstaller ce paquet de merde et de passer à autre chose parce que cette daube, c’est de toute façon n’importe quoi de A à Z !    … Full Review »
See all user reviews »