MLB The Show 16

 PlayStation 4
User Score
7.3

Mixed or average reviews- based on 188 Ratings

User score distribution:
  1. Positive: 139 out of 188
  2. Mixed: 8 out of 188
  3. Negative: 41 out of 188
Buy Now
Buy on

Review this game

  1. Your Score
    0 out of 10
    Rate this:
    • 10
    • 9
    • 8
    • 7
    • 6
    • 5
    • 4
    • 3
    • 2
    • 1
    • 0
    • 0
  1. Submit
  2. Check Spelling
view
per page
  1. EK3MK3
    Jun 2, 2016
    2
    horrible game
    I have had so many issues with this game that mlb road to the show 15 did not have.
    1.I was playing franchise mode and i hit a ball in to the crowd which obviously means foul ball but the right fielder was running towards the crowd and the ball teleports to his glove and counts as a out then i went to replay to make sure i was not just seeing things and in the replay it    horrible game
    I have had so many issues with this game that mlb road to the show 15 did not have.
    1.I was playing franchise mode and i hit a ball in to the crowd which obviously means foul ball but the right fielder was running towards the crowd and the ball teleports to his glove and counts as a out then i went to replay to make sure i was not just seeing things and in the replay it shows the ball doing just as i thought teleports to his glove
    2.Whenever you tell a player to sac bunt he will put his bat out and go to bunt to move players into scoring position but if the pitch is a ball he will not pull back the bat but leave it out there and it still counts as a ball even though his bat was sticking out but not the only issue with this but also when i told my player to sac bunt on 3-0 it was another ball so you would think 4 balls that means a walk right? well yes but then my player gets stuck there at the batters box with the bat sticking out to bunt and never moves i cant save the game and leave i cant do anything so i close the game and have to restart the whole game over again.
    3.I have had so many issue with graphics the lighting will go from amazing to complete **** in the same arena match to match
    So anyone that gave this a good score or better score then mlb 15 you need to never review anything ever again thanks bye    … Expand
  2. rthlssob
    Apr 27, 2016
    4
    I truly think any review higher then maybe a 7 for this game is a paid review. 10/10 is an utter joke with so many bugs in a game like this so do not trust any of those. Now for the game break down, there are plenty of good mixed with a ton of bad in this game so I will list the pros and cons of the game and let you judge.

    Pros: -Battle Royale- Its a fun unique way for balanced pvp I    I truly think any review higher then maybe a 7 for this game is a paid review. 10/10 is an utter joke with so many bugs in a game like this so do not trust any of those. Now for the game break down, there are plenty of good mixed with a ton of bad in this game so I will list the pros and cons of the game and let you judge.

    Pros:
    -Battle Royale- Its a fun unique way for balanced pvp I liked this idea a lot with good rewards for long win streaks.
    -Conquest- Another good new addition to diamond dynasty.
    Most of the rest of the game little to nothing has changed. (so 2 new features garnering it a 10/10 score is utter BS).
    Cons-
    -Bugs-O-Plenty- If its your CF not even raising his arm to catch a fly ball, then its you throwing home and your catcher not even tagging the guy out.
    -Baserunning- Not sure how but i feel like your players are even dumber at baserunning in this game then the last. Prime example is I hit a single with a man on first and second but the CPU for some reason had both first and second players dive back to bags on a single.....by the time they could recover it turned into a double play instead of a single. You hit a double and sometimes the man on 2nd wont start to run even to 3rd and has to be done manually most of the time.
    -Cheaters- I'm not sure if they are actually cheating or throttling their connection somehow to do this but i have recorded and reported between 5-10 players that have cheated while playing pvp. Some examples of this are people not even throwing strikes to you but the umpire calling them strikes. (they will be like 2 feet off the plate of even hit you but the umpire will call them strikes). Smashing homeruns but suddenly it lag and then be called an out (this will happen with normal hits as well). You having a player on second base and they just throw to second and he's out(Although the player is clearly standing on the bag).    … Expand
  3. jsendre
    Jun 9, 2016
    3
    This game is full of bugs and glitches and that makes it very unpleasant to play. Runners over 85 speed can basically just take 3rd base as they are next to impossible to stop from stealing. The base running controls are slow and cumbersome. I have had base runners run right by a fielder on the base path trying to tag them. Plays in diamond dynasty will sometimes show opposite results forThis game is full of bugs and glitches and that makes it very unpleasant to play. Runners over 85 speed can basically just take 3rd base as they are next to impossible to stop from stealing. The base running controls are slow and cumbersome. I have had base runners run right by a fielder on the base path trying to tag them. Plays in diamond dynasty will sometimes show opposite results for plays(i.e. safe or out). etc etc etc. Imagine playing an hour long game and have it decided by such glitches. The graphics are good and the overall layout of franchise mode and diamond dynasty are good. The game play is just FAR from polished or smooth. Overall I am very disappointed in this game as I believe game play should be better for a competitive sports game . Wish I did not buy digital copy.… Expand
  4. mj33
    Apr 9, 2016
    1
    Hitting and gameplay is overrated. The only good part is the pitching, but overall, this game was really a waste of money. The fact that you have to hold down the button and if you dont, then it's a check swing. The game is kinda glitchy and you can barely control the player movements. Good graphics, but not good enough to change my opinion.
  5. Siesoft
    Apr 3, 2016
    3
    Great gameplay with great graphics, but there are some BIG problems The game is LOADED with bugs, the new radial graphs are impossible to read, diamond dynasty only works on occasion, the game is 10x slower than last year (I'm not exaggerating), among many more problems. Kind of disappointed.
  6. Har10ley
    Apr 12, 2016
    1
    If you play career mode do not buy this game,unless you like sitting on the bench your whole career.my created player has more home runs runs batted in and better fielding percentage and invited to play in the home run derby and play in the all star game but yet still miss have the season sitting on the bench.Whats wrong with this picture????? The fielding needs to be worked on haveIf you play career mode do not buy this game,unless you like sitting on the bench your whole career.my created player has more home runs runs batted in and better fielding percentage and invited to play in the home run derby and play in the all star game but yet still miss have the season sitting on the bench.Whats wrong with this picture????? The fielding needs to be worked on have problems making double plays because short stop won't go to the base and pitcher at times won't cover 1st base...like I said if you like career mode the game isn't for you… Expand
  7. GameHawk36
    Apr 6, 2016
    2
    Online franchise servers are a joke!!! Servers crash all the time and no information from the company. I have a full league of members and everyone is fed up and has either sold their game by now or given up on the game. If you plan to buy for online franchise, do not buy and save you money. This company is focused on one thing, stealing your money!!!!
  8. Dodo22
    Apr 1, 2016
    2
    Wow have things changed from MLB 14: the Show. I miss MVP baseball 2005 so bad. MLB 16 features even more horribly complicated menus that sometimes take forever to load or freeze altogether. There's like 1 thousand features i'm sure most people never ever use and the learning curve to figure out what exactly is going on is pretty ridiculous.

    There's also a save file for everything    Wow have things changed from MLB 14: the Show. I miss MVP baseball 2005 so bad. MLB 16 features even more horribly complicated menus that sometimes take forever to load or freeze altogether. There's like 1 thousand features i'm sure most people never ever use and the learning curve to figure out what exactly is going on is pretty ridiculous.

    There's also a save file for everything imaginable, including the settings! This is not built as a pick up and play game, and the gameplay isn't all that good. The default batting camera is at a ridiculously low angle, and while I like having options, I don't want to spend 1.5 hours stuck in poorly designed menus trying to get the game setup to something half decent.

    I sincerely doubt Sony San Diego puts much effort into these iterations. They need to go back, pull out a PS2 and play some MVP baseball 2005 and figure out why it's still heralded as the best baseball game ever made. I still play it on my PSP and have a modded version on PC with new rosters. Get it together, this ain't a show anybody should see.    … Expand
  9. gailr65gg
    Apr 21, 2016
    0
    Great game. But the servers are still totally broken after the game has been out for almost a month. Some nights I have to wait an hour just a get any of the online features to work. At this point Sony has stopped even acknowledging the game breaking server issues that plague their release. Having watched their Twitch streams before the game was released I must say that I am thoroughlyGreat game. But the servers are still totally broken after the game has been out for almost a month. Some nights I have to wait an hour just a get any of the online features to work. At this point Sony has stopped even acknowledging the game breaking server issues that plague their release. Having watched their Twitch streams before the game was released I must say that I am thoroughly disappointed. They claimed in their videos that the game when into testing a month before release. It is mind boggling that they did not find that their game is full of bugs. Also this company knows damn well how much server load to expect from pre orders. The servers for this game are garbage.… Expand
  10. sglas
    Apr 1, 2016
    0
    This is the same game has last year. The same animation problems with the catcher, pitcher being hit with the ball, and stealing is so easy. Do not buy it. Just play 15. The new legends are not all in the game offline only in Diamond Dynasty mode. Not worth the money you have to pay to play the new Draft Battle game mode it is not free.
  11. MyStupidName22
    May 3, 2016
    2
    The "good" reviews look planted, especially since they're all liked to raise them to the top. You CANNOT be have a legitimate review of this game if you gave it a "10." Every mode is broken. I don't play online, but most people have "Challenge Failed" repeatedly. Do some research on forums to see all the issues before you buy.

    This is one of the buggiest games I've ever played. I    The "good" reviews look planted, especially since they're all liked to raise them to the top. You CANNOT be have a legitimate review of this game if you gave it a "10." Every mode is broken. I don't play online, but most people have "Challenge Failed" repeatedly. Do some research on forums to see all the issues before you buy.

    This is one of the buggiest games I've ever played. I originally gave this a "5," but each update breaks the game further. If you like to be a paid tester (where YOU pay $60 for a broken game), then this is the game for you.

    Tough to review. Some great new features. Some things (line drive off the pitcher) that have been in the game for years that they haven't taken out and actually become worse. The rosters are awful. Ratings are written as if there is no baseball knowledge whatsoever.

    Vast improvement to pay for play portions of the game. Minimal improvement to RTTS and franchise. Player morale system that is shady (people upset about contracts they just signed, why?). People upset that THEY aren't playing at the level they'd like make their ratings go down    … Expand
  12. partyintheback
    Apr 16, 2016
    4
    Once again this game has great graphics and solid gameplay, however it's all brought down by how many bugs there are. Given that they release one of these every single year with some minor adjustments, I find it unacceptable that it has so many bugs and glitches. Avoid this one and buy an older one.

Awards & Rankings

25
#25 Best PS4 Game of 2016
82
#82 Most Discussed PS4 Game of 2016
65
#65 Most Shared PS4 Game of 2016

Critic Reviews

All reviews »
Metascore
85

Generally favorable reviews - based on 37 Critic Reviews

Critic score distribution:
  1. Positive: 35 out of 37
  2. Mixed: 2 out of 37
  3. Negative: 0 out of 37
  1. Gaming Nexus
    Jun 15, 2016
    88
    Another year and another good outing for SCE San Diego Studio. MLB The Show 16 has some great improvements for Road to the Show, but some problems still persist. Baseball lovers will definitely enjoy the game.
    Read full review
  2. Playstation Official Magazine UK
    Jun 13, 2016
    90
    You need to know the sport to master it - hence no 10/10 this year - but PS3's greatest sports series is on the verge of once more dominating all contemporaries. [June 2016, p.94]
  3. Multiplayer.it
    Apr 28, 2016
    90
    Sony San Diego continues to raise the bar with MLB 16: The Show, finding an almost perfect balance between innovation and tradition.
    Read full review
See all critic reviews »