Red Dead Redemption 2

 PC
User Score
6.8

Mixed or average reviews- based on 5614 Ratings

User score distribution:
  1. Positive: 3,639 out of 5614
  2. Mixed: 316 out of 5614
  3. Negative: 1,659 out of 5614

Review this game

  1. Your Score
    0 out of 10
    Rate this:
    • 10
    • 9
    • 8
    • 7
    • 6
    • 5
    • 4
    • 3
    • 2
    • 1
    • 0
    • 0
  1. Submit
  2. Check Spelling
view
per page
  1. andnotmetoo
    Aug 25, 2023
    0
    Rockstar launcher sucks and support sucks. Cant play game, because account is stolen, but after few weeks talkins with rockstar support still cant play steam game, wasted money. Stay away from rockstar
  2. Puglyc
    Aug 19, 2023
    3
    Game has a good graphic side, but story is too extended. For me it became not interesing playing after 40 hours of literally doing nothing, because main story cant give u anything interesting in the begining and in the middle of the game. Open world is good, but it is not a gta where u could take someones car and ride to ur mission or other activity, no, traveling in this game is megaGame has a good graphic side, but story is too extended. For me it became not interesing playing after 40 hours of literally doing nothing, because main story cant give u anything interesting in the begining and in the middle of the game. Open world is good, but it is not a gta where u could take someones car and ride to ur mission or other activity, no, traveling in this game is mega annoying. I would not recomend this game 3/10… Expand
  3. Nerwan
    Jul 3, 2023
    0
    This game is dreadful really. I've given it a point for being pretty but the game play is some of the most tedious I've experienced and even having forced myself to restart it after a year and play through a solid 20 hours, I can find absolutely zero fun in this game.
  4. nvision
    Jun 1, 2023
    0
    WTF. You need to be online to run Campain - major problem on Steam Deck.
    And using two launchers, Steam and Rockstar Games is disgusting. Not only takes data to Rockstar, but also takes A LOT OF TIME to run the game. There is no problem when you ran version from the internet.
  5. ulvido
    Apr 19, 2023
    0
    rdr2 maybe the most overrated game of all time. I loved rdr1 and bought xbox one for it. but rdr2 is not a game, it's a cowboy simulation. and a very good simulation but not a game. there's no fun in it.
  6. Ozzy34
    Apr 18, 2023
    0
    I've never commented on a game in my life, but for this game it's just perfect
  7. passionne
    Apr 18, 2023
    4
    The good :
    - western atmosphere
    - large map - graphics - dialogues The bad : - low resolution textures - bad optimization : a few stutters at 4k with a RTX 4090 and a 13900K ! - mission failed if you go too far from the "allowed" area The awful : - "woke" propaganda : feminism and anti-racism are omnipresent and no choice is allowed in these missions. Fed up with this sh*t.    The good :
    - western atmosphere
    - large map
    - graphics
    - dialogues

    The bad :
    - low resolution textures
    - bad optimization : a few stutters at 4k with a RTX 4090 and a 13900K !
    - mission failed if you go too far from the "allowed" area

    The awful :
    - "woke" propaganda : feminism and anti-racism are omnipresent and no choice is allowed in these missions. Fed up with this sh*t.

    A praised game by the subsidized press, which in fact is not up to par with the Rockstar reputation. A great disappointment.    … Expand
  8. realWhiteMan
    Apr 8, 2023
    3
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. My rating is based on my impressions of the game. This is not an objective review. I play quite a big number of titles per year and decided to review them as a peace of art and not as a product.… Expand
  9. triadne
    Mar 15, 2023
    3
    plagued with issues right from the start, design flaws, crashes, gameplay mechanics, just the most frustrating experience.
  10. BOWi
    Jan 26, 2023
    0
    (I will change my rating once the bug is fixed.) I bought the game on the Rockstar Games Launcher. It works when online, but no matter what I tried, the offline mode (when there's no internet connection) doesn't work. GTAIV worked OK last time I tried.
    They should ditch the Rockstar Launcher altogether and give us Steam Keys. (GOG would be the best.)
    Also: I send a bug report and for    (I will change my rating once the bug is fixed.) I bought the game on the Rockstar Games Launcher. It works when online, but no matter what I tried, the offline mode (when there's no internet connection) doesn't work. GTAIV worked OK last time I tried.
    They should ditch the Rockstar Launcher altogether and give us Steam Keys. (GOG would be the best.)

    Also: I send a bug report and for single player and they ask me to write a "feedback" in the "Red Dead Online" mailbox... What?    … Expand
  11. Gamezombie
    Dec 25, 2022
    0
    It's so broken you can't literally play it, because you need connection to the social club that is blocked for some reason.
  12. MegaBaran
    Nov 30, 2022
    0
    it was released in 2019, it is 2022 and it is still a pain to play it on PC
    1. I bought it on Epic and guess what, I need to use Epic launcher, then Rockstart launcher and social club, I can't just launch the game, I need all 20 launchers to be working to play in a SINGLE PLAYER game
    2. They spent too much time on launchers that's why game is ALWAYS starting in windowed mode. You also    it was released in 2019, it is 2022 and it is still a pain to play it on PC
    1. I bought it on Epic and guess what, I need to use Epic launcher, then Rockstart launcher and social club, I can't just launch the game, I need all 20 launchers to be working to play in a SINGLE PLAYER game
    2. They spent too much time on launchers that's why game is ALWAYS starting in windowed mode. You also can't change it in the setting from windowed to fullscreen, like, there is a button, it doesn't work. I spent a couple of hours and finally found the way to do it, you need to change Resolution without changing the mode and then magically, the mode will be set to fullscreen by itself, till the restart of the game
    3. Controls and interface... I can write a doctor thesis on that one, but I will be short. They created it for consoles and gamepad, they did nothing to adjust it to pc players, nothing. It is as painful as trying to it cactus. Activate - E, take - P, take something else - TAB, interact - hold right mouse button and then press something else on a keyboard, etc. The list is indefinite. The same goes to interface and navigation in it, you can try to use mouse there, but god protect you from touching any button in the process including the mouse wheel, it will forget immediately about mouse input and will switch to something

    The game looks atmospheric, a bit too much cutscenes and a bit too slow character with huge inertia, like I am controlling a huge ball and not a person with legs, a bit too much enemies and too easy shooting but it could be a good experience IF IT WAS PROPERLY SET UP FOR PC GAMING    … Expand
  13. Game0fLife
    Sep 26, 2022
    2
    To be honest, I CAN NOT wholeheartedly recommend this expensive AAA game for a few reasons:
    1. Still terrible optimization (7/7/2021): Unstable and low FPS for RTX 2070 & i7-9700k (by the way, the graphic still looks like ♥♥♥♥).
    2. Crappy and clumsy moment (i.g walking speed and picking the thing up) 3. Confusing control. Not just countless complicated control layouts but also ​I am    To be honest, I CAN NOT wholeheartedly recommend this expensive AAA game for a few reasons:
    1. Still terrible optimization (7/7/2021): Unstable and low FPS for RTX 2070 & i7-9700k (by the way, the graphic still looks like ♥♥♥♥).
    2. Crappy and clumsy moment (i.g walking speed and picking the thing up)
    3. Confusing control. Not just countless complicated control layouts but also ​I am surprised a game can be both over hand-holding and confusing at the same time.
    4. Inconsistent control: For instance, pointing a gun at someone's face and talking to them is the same button, especially worse when it repeatedly flicking different actions for the same button within a second.

    It's an over-hyped game overall, I would suggest you first pirate the game/borrow this game from a friend just to see the gameplay or how it runs on your computer, then buy it at the discount price.

    I will come back and edit my review if I change my mind.    … Expand
  14. StarkAgentos
    Aug 16, 2022
    4
    .Управление нереально неудобное, персонаж непослушный, вид от первого лица сделан для галочки. Геймплей нереально скучный. Кому вообще нужен этот излишний реализм?! Ту самую атмосферу, о которой все говорили, я просто не нашёл. Оптимизация не самая лучшая. Графика, при которой мой ПК может выдать более 60 ФПС, выглядит нереально убого. Единственное, что сделано хорошо, это сюжет, судя по.Управление нереально неудобное, персонаж непослушный, вид от первого лица сделан для галочки. Геймплей нереально скучный. Кому вообще нужен этот излишний реализм?! Ту самую атмосферу, о которой все говорили, я просто не нашёл. Оптимизация не самая лучшая. Графика, при которой мой ПК может выдать более 60 ФПС, выглядит нереально убого. Единственное, что сделано хорошо, это сюжет, судя по началу игры. Такое чувство, будто разработчики реально решили просто сделать реалистичную игру на основе крутого сюжета, и получилось какое-то уныние.… Expand
  15. ekmekbey
    Jul 18, 2022
    0
    I lost my horse because of a ridiculous bug, it was literally the best horse in the game you could acquire and now there's no way of me getting it back. Im sick of this game and I have lost all my desire to play it. I wouldn't recommend it.
  16. slasheer
    Jun 16, 2022
    0
    the **** animals spawn system which i can **** imagine. Rockstar sucks. hate this ****
  17. nonaste
    Jun 6, 2022
    0
    A damned bore and chore. I've been playing shooters for 30 years. Rarely do I delete one two hours into the game because it is tedious.
  18. eblack
    May 30, 2022
    2
    Очень медленно. Нудная подача сюжета. Перестрелки тормознутые.
  19. Alexandr1987
    May 20, 2022
    0
    Местами скучноватая игра, Нет Русской озвучки, ехать куда-то и читать субтитры неудобно.
  20. rafaeal
    May 15, 2022
    1
    Lixo, bugadasso, 4 anos e nada de conteúdo novo, ainda tô sendo legal em dar nota 1
  21. PETRAKITO
    May 12, 2022
    0
    This game is too overrated. I think they did it so stupid , so next time when they do good game = people will say "ah, this better than rdr2". Disguisting controls, disguisting "realism", too much movies, lotta time spend on horse and **** cheapchats. bb
  22. roten
    Apr 30, 2022
    0
    this product is not available in your region
    "games out of politics" right?
  23. tremault
    Apr 5, 2022
    3
    plagued with issues right from the start, design flaws, crashes, gameplay mechanics, just the most frustrating experience.
  24. MNecromancer
    Apr 5, 2022
    3
    Seemed fun but I lost internet and now there's nothing I can do to get into the game to play the single player. Hotspoting didn't work, I've been trying everything for the last hour and this is completely unnecessary. This is all to avoid piracy, but I should have just pirated the game to begin with.
  25. woodwardsyx
    Mar 30, 2022
    0
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. So buggy, played for 8 hours with 4 crashes and 3 times freezes. Never will buy another RS game.… Expand
  26. OBORMOT89
    Mar 10, 2022
    0
    Мне не понравилось, что вы вы не делаете русскую озвучку, теперь я ненавижу вас за что мне запретили покупать игру и играть.. Я надеюсь, что эти 145000000 человек никогда больше не купят у вас игру, а только скачают ее) Полное неуважение к людям!Мне не понравилось, что вы вы не делаете русскую озвучку, теперь я ненавижу вас за что мне запретили покупать игру и играть.. Я надеюсь, что эти 145000000 человек никогда больше не купят у вас игру, а только скачают ее) Полное неуважение к людям!
  27. Parangaritiwi
    Mar 8, 2022
    0
    Another trash game made by rockstar, these critics are full of crap the game is boring tedious and has a cliche narrative. Horrible!
  28. killra
    Mar 7, 2022
    0
    Мне уже стыдно что я играл в ваши игры за свои деньги. **** you Rockstar
  29. Kaizek1
    Mar 6, 2022
    3
    Какой же это тягомотный, ужасно растянутый, отвратительно управляемый, ужасно растянутый, переоцененный, ужасно растянутый, плохо портированный, ужасно растянутый, с тупой логикой, когда после перестрелки с БАНДИТАМИ, на место перестрелки приезжают ЗАКОННИКИ и ищут убийц БАНДИТОВ, ах да, ещё он ужасно растянутый, с бесконечными анимациями, ужасно растянутый, с бесконечным зажиманием клавишКакой же это тягомотный, ужасно растянутый, отвратительно управляемый, ужасно растянутый, переоцененный, ужасно растянутый, плохо портированный, ужасно растянутый, с тупой логикой, когда после перестрелки с БАНДИТАМИ, на место перестрелки приезжают ЗАКОННИКИ и ищут убийц БАНДИТОВ, ах да, ещё он ужасно растянутый, с бесконечными анимациями, ужасно растянутый, с бесконечным зажиманием клавиш для любого действия, ужасно растянутый и много чего ещё!
    Единственное, ради чего можно взять на распродаже за копейку лишнюю- это отличные персонажи и в меру неплохой сюжет, но я же писал, что он ужасно затянут, к сюжету это также относится!    … Expand
  30. Mahdialshorafa
    Feb 21, 2022
    1
    So boring
    I nearly slept when I was playing it
    Build the characters not mean all that **** in the first 3 chapters
  31. OmerKaya
    Jan 10, 2022
    2
    For game play + graphics 2 points
    Story, character development, realism etc and rest 0 points
    I was trying to play this game calm since it is a RPG. I wanted to murder no one unless it is totally necessary but most of the game gang and you, have to kill people because NPCs are trying protect themselves from you or in some cases you kill for no reason at all for the sake of the mission    For game play + graphics 2 points
    Story, character development, realism etc and rest 0 points

    I was trying to play this game calm since it is a RPG. I wanted to murder no one unless it is totally necessary but most of the game gang and you, have to kill people because NPCs are trying protect themselves from you or in some cases you kill for no reason at all for the sake of the mission like you go get drunk with your friend and for no reason you start fighting this scenario happens more then it should. In one of missions we have to save one of our friend from jail we ripoff jail bar and whole town start shooting at us(whole town has 13-15 building) we kill 80-100 people and when we turn back we can observe that incident had no impact to town at all. This game lacks realism a RPG must have and relies heavily on mindless killing for sake of game play like call of Juarez. Don't get me wrong call of Juarez is a good game but imagine all the possibilities with a massive open world wild west map and developers decide to make main character a bandit. Its such a waste of potential.

    [spoiler] In one of the mission we decide to sneak into fort with the help of an old lady who is a traitor. She snuck us inside and decided to ask more money than we have and Dutch kills her for a obvious reason that if you don't pay she will rat on us but Arthur who killed countless innocent people to that point be like "damn Dutch are you gonna kill me to"

    [spoiler] I realize Micah will betray us right after he join back to gang. He was the only person who acts like he doesn't care about others and next 2 missions with Micah proved that I was right but Dutch be like traitor can be anyone but Micah and I don't even want to point Micah joined gang just 6 months ago.

    [NO SPOILERS]
    At the last parts of the game I realize that I don't give a f*** about game any more. I tried to not to kill a single innocent person but game and scenario make you commit many crimes even if you don't want to. Basically you don't have any choice that changes to flow of the story. I found myself looting and killing and stealing more than I should since missions are forcing you to be careless anyways and then at the end game reward you if you tried to be "good guy".    … Expand
  32. Fanchylul
    Nov 20, 2021
    4
    Перегруженное неудобное консольное управление, когда слишком много действий и слишком мало кнопок
    Все хвалят графику, но чтобы добиться приемлемой картинки нужно что-то получше чем моя 2070s, понадобилось целый день убить на изучение настроек и просмотр гайдов, но графен на средне-высоких выглядит не прям живописно, к слову, на ютубе и стримах на ультрах она так же не особо впечатляет    Перегруженное неудобное консольное управление, когда слишком много действий и слишком мало кнопок
    Все хвалят графику, но чтобы добиться приемлемой картинки нужно что-то получше чем моя 2070s, понадобилось целый день убить на изучение настроек и просмотр гайдов, но графен на средне-высоких выглядит не прям живописно, к слову, на ютубе и стримах на ультрах она так же не особо впечатляет
    Сюжет просто нереально нудный, скучнее ковбоев могут быть только самураи и викинги
    Отсутствие русской локализации тоже сказывается на игровом опыте, я не из любителей пялиться в субтитры, а на слух тут язык почему-то воспринимается намного труднее, чем во многих других играх
    Мне только в покер понравилось играть и на поезде кататься    … Expand
  33. Bushido95
    Nov 19, 2021
    1
    Наиграл 64ч и у меня больше нет терпения и сил тратить на это время. Я лучше посмотрю как сохнет краска на стене.
    Персонажи максимально шаблонные, скучные и даже, когда они начинают дохнуть один за другим я должен был что-то почувствовать очевидно, но мне было всё равно потому что я с трудом мог вспомнить кто это вообще были и почему мне должно быть не всё равно?
    В очередной миссии где    Наиграл 64ч и у меня больше нет терпения и сил тратить на это время. Я лучше посмотрю как сохнет краска на стене.
    Персонажи максимально шаблонные, скучные и даже, когда они начинают дохнуть один за другим я должен был что-то почувствовать очевидно, но мне было всё равно потому что я с трудом мог вспомнить кто это вообще были и почему мне должно быть не всё равно?
    В очередной миссии где надо 10 минут скакать из точки А в точку Б чтоб пострелять тебя сопровождают члены вашего цыганского табора и их бесконечный словарный понос ни о чем будет все эти 10 минут.. Господи, ну помолчите хоть секунду. Также в игре нету русской озвучки потому что АТМОСФЕРА!! ВЫ ПОНЯЛИ?? АТМОСФЕРА!! Но ни один человек не сможет отличить озвучку GTA от RDR2. Жаль конечно, что у маленькой инди-студии rockstar games не хватило ресурсов на озвучку.
    Анимации хоть и сделаны качество, но очень долгие и шарится в поисках лута это настоящее испытание к счастью деньги тратить не на что и спустя часов 15 я перестал искать лут, а просто покупал всё в магазинах.
    RDR2 это сплошные рельсы.. заскриптовано до смешного просто ты даже не можешь на полметра повернуть, когда нпс тебя куда то ведет или вот ещё пример была миссия спасти девушку из нашего цыганского каравана. Я всех убил мне надо подойти и развязать её, но в доме разбросан лут и я не могу его подобрать потому что я обязан прямо сейчас развязать её или была перестрелка где на наше цыганское братство напали и в определённый момент мне нужно немного отойти назад т.е игра прям говорит тебе отступи вот туда и я никак не могу убить бомжей с которыми справляюсь как нефиг делать потому что меня по скрипту убивают из-за того что я не отступил и причём пару раз подряд меня убивали через стену и таких примеров можно приводить очень долго.
    Надо отдать должное RDR2 действительно красивая, но нужно понимать, что подавляющая часть мира пустая. Также в отличии от GTA в RDR2 открытый мир хотя бы есть и не служит исключительно декором.
    Я даже не знаю, что сказать про геймплей.. Кат сцена > 10 минут скачаешь из точки А в точку Б > тир > кат сцена > 10 минут скачаешь из точки А в точку Б > кат сцена > 10 минут скачаешь из точки А в точку Б > тир > кат сцена > 10 минут скачаешь из точки А в точку Б и это геймплей "одной из лучший игр в истории".    … Expand
  34. OyunKolik
    Nov 14, 2021
    0
    This game is like out of this world.. No explanation. Everything is just like.

    " - I'm Afraid " to talk ... " -I'm Afraid " ....
  35. SLBrest
    Sep 27, 2021
    3
    Игра красивая, сюжет вроде неплохой, но игра нудная очень. Заставляю себя, что бы пройти игру до конца.

    P.S. Все же не осилил пройти из-за нудности... 3 балла только за графику.
  36. mmdcasdca
    Sep 23, 2021
    1
    Beside the graphic, everything else in this game is bad.

    Gameplay: 4 hours in the game, I think I was mostly in conversation and riding the horse around. Maybe 10 or 15 minutes in the fights, but it was so boring Story: I was almost completed chapter 2 but... man... all quests are like completely independent and no connected to each other. You can do any quest in any order because    Beside the graphic, everything else in this game is bad.

    Gameplay: 4 hours in the game, I think I was mostly in conversation and riding the horse around. Maybe 10 or 15 minutes in the fights, but it was so boring

    Story: I was almost completed chapter 2 but... man... all quests are like completely independent and no connected to each other. You can do any quest in any order because they are just like side quest. Quests mostly talk to someone, find somethings or someone and riding around. that is it. 90% of time is traveling around

    Feel bad for someone who bought this game at full price.    … Expand
  37. RafoRafo
    Aug 25, 2021
    4
    interesting story, but bugs in the side quests still over one yer after premiere, some mechanics do not look like fully tested, to much of console filling
  38. Foldergan
    Jul 29, 2021
    3
    Неплохо проработанный мир, куча интересных мелочей. Но сюжет, как издевательство над игроком - временами вроде ничего, но большую часть, просто скучное, нудное УГ. Некоторые сюжетные повороты, вообще никакой логике не поддаются. Такое чувство, что делали "на отвали", лишь бы было. Кое как осилил, чтобы пройти её до конца. И не потому что она сложная, а потому что боишься убить себяНеплохо проработанный мир, куча интересных мелочей. Но сюжет, как издевательство над игроком - временами вроде ничего, но большую часть, просто скучное, нудное УГ. Некоторые сюжетные повороты, вообще никакой логике не поддаются. Такое чувство, что делали "на отвали", лишь бы было. Кое как осилил, чтобы пройти её до конца. И не потому что она сложная, а потому что боишься убить себя фейспалмом. Вообще не понятно, как такое можно хвалить. Сюжет не то что не проработан, он как будто сделан в рандомайзере. Чувство, что разработчики тебе в этой игре не рады, и делают всё возможное, чтобы ты скипнул сюжетку и перешёл на онлайн версию. Заставлял себя через силу пройти, потому что все её хвалили. Больше в жизни не буду слушать всяких умников с ютубе. Есть, конечно, интересные моменты в прохождении, но большую часть вызывает жжение в пятой точке.… Expand
  39. Muminus2
    Jun 26, 2021
    1
    Maybe this game is good on console, it's definitively not good PC game.
    The first hour after buying I spend trying to launch the game on anything better then ultra-low graphics settings. I can run Witcher 3 on high, but RDR2 somehow determined anything better than ultra-low is not available. Another hour I spend trying to get audio working, for some reason game doesn't work with aby    Maybe this game is good on console, it's definitively not good PC game.
    The first hour after buying I spend trying to launch the game on anything better then ultra-low graphics settings. I can run Witcher 3 on high, but RDR2 somehow determined anything better than ultra-low is not available. Another hour I spend trying to get audio working, for some reason game doesn't work with aby bluetooth headphones.
    Finally, I am able to run the game - and fail tutorial quest. My goal is to ride behind some guy - and I am unable to do it, as sometimes, when I hit "left" my horse turns left, and sometimes, when I hit "left", my horse turns right. And the guy I am following does not wait, just rides off and bam, quest failed, restart and waste another 10 mins staring into snow and my horse's backside. And this is good summary of the game - further game has exact same problems.
    The controls are so clunky it strips the game of all fun. The game saves progress when it wants, so expect to re-do 5-10 mins of gameplay quite often. During dialog, my possible lines are displayed in lower-right corner, choosing any requires me to press 2 keys at the same time, and all of this while keeping track on whats going on screen (as most conversating happens when something is going on - riding, stalking etc.) and hearing what the NPCs are talking - so the effect is what I say is pretty much random. The in-game journal is intrersting, but written in font I am not able to decipher... I could go on much more. This game could be interesting. A pity it is so poorly ported onto PC.    … Expand
  40. DSRevler
    Jun 24, 2021
    0
    Red Dead Redemption Online is a worst of worsts. Everything is very lame in the game. Just stay away..
  41. recognized
    Jun 21, 2021
    3
    Masterpiece?

    - Dull main quest missions - Any mission fails if you are trying a bit creative approach, there is always a "right" way to complete a mission - Weak open world enemy AI (shooting through walls, every enemy instantly notified when you are spotted by one of them) - AI of allies may fail your stealth or non-lethal approach to mission - Buggy controls (e.g. movement forward    Masterpiece?

    - Dull main quest missions
    - Any mission fails if you are trying a bit creative approach, there is always a "right" way to complete a mission
    - Weak open world enemy AI (shooting through walls, every enemy instantly notified when you are spotted by one of them)
    - AI of allies may fail your stealth or non-lethal approach to mission
    - Buggy controls (e.g. movement forward breaks after each alt-tab, awkward horse controls)
    - Doing crime in open world is very discouraged and affects some missions
    - Very few crime activities in open world
    - Random open world encounters repeat quite often
    - Blurry and buggy TAA antialising
    - Low variety of weapons
    - Unskippable dialogs and rides from A to B if mission fails
    - Useless crafting, useless weapon modifications
    - Nowhere to spend money
    - Very limited camp upgrade progression
    - No gameplay progression throughout the game
    - Not really fast "fast-travel"

    What is good?
    + Animations
    + Environment, world details
    + Main plot (better be a film than game)    … Expand
  42. Eredar
    Jun 19, 2021
    0
    Game is just boring, I stopped after a few hours of gameplay (reached chapter 3) and I realized it's just not fun to play any further. Attention to details and realism is good when it's provided not in exchange of fun. This game is mediocre at best. Think twice about a puchase, it seems very, very overrated. Actually first game in years from Rockstar that I dropped, played almost every ofGame is just boring, I stopped after a few hours of gameplay (reached chapter 3) and I realized it's just not fun to play any further. Attention to details and realism is good when it's provided not in exchange of fun. This game is mediocre at best. Think twice about a puchase, it seems very, very overrated. Actually first game in years from Rockstar that I dropped, played almost every of them since around 2001.… Expand
  43. TomasOlsson
    Jun 15, 2021
    0
    Easily the most boring game I've ever played. I love third person action RPG's and though it would be similar to Witcher 3. It's so incredible slow at the beginning. Two shooting action scenes after about two hours of game play. And the shooting game play is boring as heck also. Controls are so clunky. Characters are also boring and annoying. Everybody praises this game and i don't know why...
  44. Forboint
    Jun 13, 2021
    1
    из-за ебучего лаунчера рокстар так и не смог скатать
  45. jake_siege
    Jun 2, 2021
    0
    Nothing but bugs, glitches, and getting kicked back to the rockstar launcher. I can't even use any dead eye abilities or it's an INSTANT crash. Games broken, been broken and they don't care. Guess they don't see enough money in fixing anything.Oh well.
  46. Traist
    May 7, 2021
    0
    Rockstar, WTF?! I bought the game for 50 bucks on PC and what I see... No optimization, when you change the graphics-artifacts, 20 minutes of gameplay - 3 departures! Put the game on pause, the game does not allow me to use the pause window because it just does not exist! Graphics..- it feels like I launched the game on PS3! How could you release such a thing?! I will never pre-orderRockstar, WTF?! I bought the game for 50 bucks on PC and what I see... No optimization, when you change the graphics-artifacts, 20 minutes of gameplay - 3 departures! Put the game on pause, the game does not allow me to use the pause window because it just does not exist! Graphics..- it feels like I launched the game on PS3! How could you release such a thing?! I will never pre-order again! I had no idea that I would be disappointed in such serious company... People who return the money in this is impossible to play!… Expand
  47. Maitrify
    Mar 26, 2021
    0
    I've been waiting for this game, eagerly for almost 2 years.

    This is, so far, the biggest disappointment I've had of this year. Rockstar, you'd better learn from this mistake before it costs you a large majority of your customers. Do NOT simply just half-assedly port a console game to PC. Do the actual work to make it decent. Don't expect your customers to just take it lying down.    I've been waiting for this game, eagerly for almost 2 years.

    This is, so far, the biggest disappointment I've had of this year.

    Rockstar, you'd better learn from this mistake before it costs you a large majority of your customers. Do NOT simply just half-assedly port a console game to PC. Do the actual work to make it decent. Don't expect your customers to just take it lying down. Bethesda took forever to learn this and it's slowly but surely dwindled their playerbase to almost nothing.

    I refunded this game within the hour because of how bad it was.    … Expand
  48. Anubis00V
    Mar 11, 2021
    2
    Incredibly disappointing
    Let's start with the core of any game, the gunplay. The guns and their mechanics are almost from 2001. It's copy pasted from GTAV which was copied from Max Payne 3. And it didn't even keep it at that. It just got worse. I felt no fun at all shooting. All guns are the same almost.
    Secondly the mission design. There is none. Half the game is riding your horse. Then    Incredibly disappointing
    Let's start with the core of any game, the gunplay. The guns and their mechanics are almost from 2001. It's copy pasted from GTAV which was copied from Max Payne 3. And it didn't even keep it at that. It just got worse. I felt no fun at all shooting. All guns are the same almost.
    Secondly the mission design. There is none. Half the game is riding your horse. Then a cutscene. After the cutscene you'll find a cover, get behind it. Use your slow motion thing to get 4 heat shots. repeat until the next cutscene. There's no design at all. Some missions you have to stand in an exact place and do an exact thing. You can't do anything other than the game tells you to do. It's like you're just watching the game and occasionally press E or some other button.
    Then there's the world. It looks amazing on the outside. But once you start digging in it you discover it's all empty. All the towns are the same to the point I don't even know their names. Except for one city that looks different but by the time I got there I didn't bother explore it cause I was so disappointed by the game so far. It's all just empty areas and animals to hunt which you don't need to hunt cause it's useless and boring. I found an NPC with a cool small quest then after an hour I found the same NPC with the same quest then discovered it's all copy pasted around the world.
    The game has cool systems but it ruins it somehow. I liked the honor system until I discovered it's of no consequence and the main mission will just change it for me.
    And now for the story, anyone who praised the story just didn't complete it. The story is great until chapter 5 then it take a dip in quality that I can compare to GoT S8. And it never recovers. After that I stopped caring about the story, the characters, everything. And wasn't looking forward to any of the missions because I know I will be just pressing the buttons the developers want me to press till it's over. I had to complete the game because I complete any game I play. But honestly it was more annoying than fun.
    The graphics of the game are cool but actually playing it isn't fun at all. After 2 cutscenes I just stopped caring.    … Expand
  49. Metipayton
    Feb 28, 2021
    1
    pc version is not rly a pc version! rockstar dont optimize and fixed it like gta! they just released it! for benefit
  50. taweley869
    Feb 13, 2021
    1
    Pointless grinding to buy “cool” new horse/hat.... whatever...

    Oh, and awfull community
  51. Stryker_777
    Jan 25, 2021
    0
    Most linear game of all-time.
    These days, I accept that some games are gonna be easy and linear. It's irritating but many games have options and mods to increase difficulty and reduce handholding.
    RDR2 is another matter. The mission design is shockingly inferior. There is no game here, you are constantly ordered around. It is vital for a game to have player agency. I have never seen the    Most linear game of all-time.
    These days, I accept that some games are gonna be easy and linear. It's irritating but many games have options and mods to increase difficulty and reduce handholding.
    RDR2 is another matter. The mission design is shockingly inferior. There is no game here, you are constantly ordered around.
    It is vital for a game to have player agency. I have never seen the complete removal of player agency in a game before. I am disgusted they got away with this lazy, incompetent mission design and I will never touch a Rockstar game again.    … Expand
  52. shamon
    Jan 24, 2021
    1
    BORING...online is BORING, story is BORING, this whole game is BORING.... overrated boring crap
  53. Deymas
    Jan 19, 2021
    0
    Убогое Фэнтези на Диком Западе.
    RDR 2: Настолько шедевральная игра, что из моих знакомых, сюжетную линию никто не прошёл. Масштабы игры сводятся к трем-четырем Деревням часть из которых были перенесены из первой части. Игра настолько заскриптована, что задания в миссиях ты выполняешь с одним единственным условием: Шаг влево, шаг вправо - расстрел, будь добр, начни заново. Вторична    Убогое Фэнтези на Диком Западе.
    RDR 2: Настолько шедевральная игра, что из моих знакомых, сюжетную линию никто не прошёл. Масштабы игры сводятся к трем-четырем Деревням часть из которых были перенесены из первой части. Игра настолько заскриптована, что задания в миссиях ты выполняешь с одним единственным условием: Шаг влево, шаг вправо - расстрел, будь добр, начни заново. Вторична настолько, что первая часть в сравнении с этим убожеством кажется откровением. А затертый до дыр сценарий и сюжет не вызывает в принципе никаких эмоций. Артур Морган: Был мудаком - сдох мудаком. А ну да: Яйца Коня. Сломанный квест Рыбалки в моём случае - баг Консольной версии, который с любовью был перенесён на PC.     … Expand
  54. shag00
    Jan 12, 2021
    3
    This game hardly qualifies as a game. It is more an interactive animated movie. What's worse you need to keep your "W" key depressed while watching. I do not buy into the, "It's a fantastic game spoiled by a few technical glitches", story, rather it is just terribly boring. When I want to play a game, I want to be doing **** not watching a C animated western with a little of input from me.This game hardly qualifies as a game. It is more an interactive animated movie. What's worse you need to keep your "W" key depressed while watching. I do not buy into the, "It's a fantastic game spoiled by a few technical glitches", story, rather it is just terribly boring. When I want to play a game, I want to be doing **** not watching a C animated western with a little of input from me.

    Pretty visuals do not a great game make.    … Expand
  55. sunstorm76
    Jan 6, 2021
    4
    I tried it 3 times to play to the end. Could not do it because the game is so awful. It has the WORST pacing in any game ever!! I am a big fan of RDR1 but this one is quite unplayable for me. No fast travel option TO your camp only from your camp WTH R* what where you thinking? Hunting is boring af, fighting is boring af, shooting is even worse - even a monkey could do that. It's one ofI tried it 3 times to play to the end. Could not do it because the game is so awful. It has the WORST pacing in any game ever!! I am a big fan of RDR1 but this one is quite unplayable for me. No fast travel option TO your camp only from your camp WTH R* what where you thinking? Hunting is boring af, fighting is boring af, shooting is even worse - even a monkey could do that. It's one of the most tedious games I've ever played. The control schemes are awful. Also 0 Innovation it's the same core mechanics since GTA3.… Expand
  56. SeeNoFuture
    Jan 1, 2021
    3
    Кааак же меня бесит эта игра, почему ГГ такой сука тормоз, я понимаю это типа "реалистично", но какого черта надо было делать его настоооолько медленным в разных локациях, какого черта я должен смотреть как он совершает каждое мать его действие, каждый обыск тела, каждый сраный ящик... Ну в это же невозможно играть, управление - отдельный разговор, из-за консольщиков приходится страдать сКааак же меня бесит эта игра, почему ГГ такой сука тормоз, я понимаю это типа "реалистично", но какого черта надо было делать его настоооолько медленным в разных локациях, какого черта я должен смотреть как он совершает каждое мать его действие, каждый обыск тела, каждый сраный ящик... Ну в это же невозможно играть, управление - отдельный разговор, из-за консольщиков приходится страдать с тупым интерфейсом... Хорошо что я ее не покупал.… Expand
  57. c64gamer
    Dec 24, 2020
    0
    This game is so boring, so pathetic writting. Typical mission looks like this get to point A, speak with NPC about made up cheap story, get to point B (this takes like 5 minutes) during your journey listen to phony story, get to point A (5 minutes) ... so boring like dying
  58. egorbely
    Dec 24, 2020
    4
    Начнем с оптимизации.У меня 2070 видеокарта и i76700. При этом система очень сильно грелась, такого даже не было в релизном киберпранке 2077. Сюжет в игре очень быстро надоедает. Вступление калл . Сайд квесты тоже подкачали. 4 балла только за крайне щепетильную детализацию.Начнем с оптимизации.У меня 2070 видеокарта и i76700. При этом система очень сильно грелась, такого даже не было в релизном киберпранке 2077. Сюжет в игре очень быстро надоедает. Вступление калл . Сайд квесты тоже подкачали. 4 балла только за крайне щепетильную детализацию.
  59. plouis
    Dec 23, 2020
    2
    The game looks nice but that's about the only good thing I can say. Movement is sluggish. The controls are atrocious. The keys don't make sense. Am I supposed to remember a gazillion keys which can change usage based on context? Whoever came up with the control scheme should never work in gaming ever again. I paid $60 for this. UGH
  60. RocknRolla128
    Dec 22, 2020
    3
    The Good: Beautiful Graphics. Fantastic setting. Good Story.

    The Bad: - Horrendous controls. You are constantly in some urgent task with people shooting at you, when keys that normally work cause you to stand up and walk slowly around a horse or something. - Story not synced with settings of game engine... You are constantly told to hurry by NPCs when you are locked into "slow-walk    The Good: Beautiful Graphics. Fantastic setting. Good Story.

    The Bad:
    - Horrendous controls. You are constantly in some urgent task with people shooting at you, when keys that normally work cause you to stand up and walk slowly around a horse or something.
    - Story not synced with settings of game engine... You are constantly told to hurry by NPCs when you are locked into "slow-walk mode" by the game. Or similar cases where you are supposed to do something the game engine does not allow.
    - Many "no way to win" situations... Sometimes you loot someone and are rewarded. Sometimes you loot someone and get negative rep because it turns out they were a "good guy" before they got killed off-screen.
    - Too many cases where the story locks you into completing something. If you have a real life, be careful playing this game because it will randomly punish you if you have to stop for the day.

    The Ugly:
    - Teases at potential relationships between main and secondary characters, but zero actual options. Failed romances are not the kind of in-game fantasy I enjoy.
    - Low actual control. The game is highly scripted. Make no mistake, you are acting in a (100 hour) movie when you play. You can't save people you might want to save, and you can't kill people you might want to kill.
    - I have to put the controls under this category too... They really are constantly awful, impossible to fully work around by learning them, and impossible to fix in settings.    … Expand
  61. DENNNN13
    Dec 22, 2020
    0
    Боже, это шедевр! Такой тупой и нудной игры я еще не видел. Меня предупреждали что она "затянута" и "местами нудная", НО ЭТО ПРОСТО ***НЯ! Интересно играть первые 3 часа. Потом одно и тоже. Геймплей искусственно растянут до невероятных размеров. Делать в игре нечего. Куча крафта который не нужен в игре вообще.
    Талисманы, оружие, деньги, улучшение лагеря, охота, рыбалка, покер,    Боже, это шедевр! Такой тупой и нудной игры я еще не видел. Меня предупреждали что она "затянута" и "местами нудная", НО ЭТО ПРОСТО ***НЯ! Интересно играть первые 3 часа. Потом одно и тоже. Геймплей искусственно растянут до невероятных размеров. Делать в игре нечего. Куча крафта который не нужен в игре вообще.
    Талисманы, оружие, деньги, улучшение лагеря, охота, рыбалка, покер, исследование мира это все не интересно от слова СОВСЕМ - ТУХЛЯК. Единственная полезная вещь для крафта это сумки, но потом когда ты понимаешь что тебе
    достаточно и стандартных с головой отпадает желание искать этих животных по всей карте и тратить 20 часов на крафт. Миссии фигня полнейшая они начинаются и заканчиваются одинаково.

    Вот сценарий:
    0) Едем до квеста 5 мин
    1) Начинаем квест и едем на указанное место еще 5 мин
    2) Делаем квест еще мин 5
    3) едем назад в лагерь 5-10 мин чтобы начать новый
    Нудно...
    В игре есть репутация которая ни на что не влияет. Сначала всем помогаешь +, украл лошадь -, убил 1000 человек в городе по сюжету ничего...
    Выбора нет в сюжете вообще, ни на что влиять не можете. 2019 год найс!
    Мир огромный и пустой, квестов интересных нет. прошел игру не могу вспомнить
    ни одного момента интересного который бы удивил.
    ЕЗДА, ЕЗДА, ЕЗДА!
    Симулятор езды на лошади.

    После квестов Ведьмака 3, где любой квест был сделан на отлично,
    любой побочный квест вызывал эмоции и восторг,
    то в рдр 2 вызывает только БОЛЬ как все топорно сделано.

    Ну и вылеты тоже портят игру. Особенно когда вылетает под конец миссии и
    тебе надо опять ехать и слушать херню 15 мин...

    Самая нудная игра в которую я когда либо играл.

    -100/10    … Expand
  62. auttore
    Dec 21, 2020
    2
    Total misunderstanding, it was boring and tiring to play this game, i left it after 5 hours, lot of bugs and game-play is adjusted to PC play. It is nice graphic thou
  63. francisco25479
    Dec 17, 2020
    2
    es muy lento y muy,muy aburrido ,largas caminatas a caballo que carecen de interes ,muchas cinematicas e historia tosca,solo se salva el apartado tecnico
  64. frootloopers
    Dec 15, 2020
    4
    Game looks great but everything else is vapid, from the story to the gun play. Makes for a better nature documentary than a game.
  65. Feuerschein
    Dec 14, 2020
    4
    Ну, такой себе геймплей, крайне скучный. Спать захочешь, пока игра начнётся.
  66. Reos44
    Dec 14, 2020
    0
    This is not rpg. This is a simulation game! This is very boring and big hype.
  67. Georgina360
    Dec 14, 2020
    0
    One of the best games and most stunning in terms of gameplay mechanics and visual. It is not a perfect game but all the good things in this games outshines even those small bad ones. I truly enjoyed playing this game and Rockstar Games made a masterpiece. I really enjoyed and had fun playing this game. If there will be future DLC to the single player mode, I will play it again and again!
  68. Alphixx
    Dec 12, 2020
    3
    Pomijając to że nie można było zagrać w premierę podczas, której nie mogłem uruchomić gry a sam update, który miał to podobno naprawiać nic nie wnosił i gra była dopiero grywalna tydzień po premierze. To gra jest zwyczajnie nudna, sama gra nie potrafi przyciągnąć gracza do siebie. Gra może i pięknie wygląda ale to chyba jedyny plus tej gry. Grałem ok. 10h z myślą, że sama gra się jakośPomijając to że nie można było zagrać w premierę podczas, której nie mogłem uruchomić gry a sam update, który miał to podobno naprawiać nic nie wnosił i gra była dopiero grywalna tydzień po premierze. To gra jest zwyczajnie nudna, sama gra nie potrafi przyciągnąć gracza do siebie. Gra może i pięknie wygląda ale to chyba jedyny plus tej gry. Grałem ok. 10h z myślą, że sama gra się jakoś rozkręci ale się nie rozkręciła i już więcej nie próbowałem w nią grać. Spróbowałem również trybu multiplayer nastawiając się na niego jako takie GTA online tylko na dzikim zachodzie i w tym wypadku też zwód, ponieważ w tym trybie nie ma zbytnio co robić. Widać, że ludzie też nie chcą w niego jakoś chętnie grą ponieważ sprzedają go jako osobna gra za 22 zł (ok. 5$)… Expand
  69. HakanKeles
    Dec 8, 2020
    0
    Oyunun optimizasyonu rezalet derecede kötü.Asla parasına değmeyecek bir oyun.
  70. EugeneYap83
    Dec 5, 2020
    0
    Online is filled with cheaters.
    Rockstar is actively not doing anything to protect honest players from cheaters.
    Now that game only cost 5 dollars, this game is over flowing with cheaters.
  71. ian111
    Dec 3, 2020
    0
    Warning to Everyone! DONT BUY JUST TORRENT GAMES FROM ROCKSTAR!!

    Nov 2020, the game was running fine.
    Dec 1, 2020 you released a patch that forces the game audio to low. How can i play this piece of **** game then!?


    **** Rockstar and your DRM's, your unnecessary patches that introduce bugs. I will never buy anything from Rockstar again until the remove this filthy DRM's.
  72. Pipe8600
    Nov 27, 2020
    4
    El juego es lento, mal optimizado, muchos errores, tiene gráficos buenos y escenas chistosas pero no es amigable con el usuario.
  73. KOBITA
    Nov 13, 2020
    1
    Yesterday me and other players were attacked by a cheater. He blocked the exits in the store with chests and began to spawn all the players there, and there were also chests, and players opened them and ordinary players do not know what kind of chests they are! Ban not wine players who are not to blame that they are trapped by cheaters whose mass is in the game and they have nothing toYesterday me and other players were attacked by a cheater. He blocked the exits in the store with chests and began to spawn all the players there, and there were also chests, and players opened them and ordinary players do not know what kind of chests they are! Ban not wine players who are not to blame that they are trapped by cheaters whose mass is in the game and they have nothing to lose and they have accounts for cheating And ordinary players suffer and you ROCKSTAR do not understand who is right and who is wrong - your company sucks and your game is low for this down! It is not the wine gamblers who suffer from your consequences!… Expand
  74. Dgamax
    Nov 3, 2020
    0
    Sorry Rockstar, I love your game but you ignore your client, your game can't be launch on Shadow.tech since this naturalist update and your support is aware of this issue but they said they don't care... great service, I was a huge fan but to be ignored like this make me very disapointed
  75. clarky
    Oct 26, 2020
    0
    I "played" the game for 3 hours and nothing happened. It is the most tedious game I have ever played and fans of the series are just movie watchers who got confused.
  76. zorranco
    Oct 24, 2020
    0
    Ok folks, let's keep it straight:

    Graphics: game should run at least 3x of the actual framerate, so NO, you are wrong about this aspect Storyline: a deep, profound "meh"..20 mins riding and chitchatting retarded things is not fun. Anyway, it's a matter of tastes, thats why my score is a "1". Dan Houser thinks he is Tarantino and it's boring as hell. Controls: well...I'm only going    Ok folks, let's keep it straight:

    Graphics: game should run at least 3x of the actual framerate, so NO, you are wrong about this aspect

    Storyline: a deep, profound "meh"..20 mins riding and chitchatting retarded things is not fun. Anyway, it's a matter of tastes, thats why my score is a "1". Dan Houser thinks he is Tarantino and it's boring as hell.

    Controls: well...I'm only going to say that a first week student of Unity private academy (3.000 € / year) would code it better....    … Expand
  77. psylife
    Oct 18, 2020
    3
    This game is a genuine chore to play. Sluggish, repetitive, and ultimately tedious, the game essentially consists of an endless concatenation of Ad nauseam back and forth trips to various shoot-out locations, intertwined with shallow mini-games and telegraphed action prompts. The cowboy simulator aspect is superficial and redundant since it is not required in order to survive or progressThis game is a genuine chore to play. Sluggish, repetitive, and ultimately tedious, the game essentially consists of an endless concatenation of Ad nauseam back and forth trips to various shoot-out locations, intertwined with shallow mini-games and telegraphed action prompts. The cowboy simulator aspect is superficial and redundant since it is not required in order to survive or progress the story. On a more positive note the game is gorgeous - perhaps the best looking game of the generation - and the care and attention to detail must be praised. Characters, scenario, and overall immersion are above and beyond anything I have played in a long time ; but when it is all said and done, I have found that for all of its greatest aspects, it was never enough in redeeming the mediocrity, boredom, and tedium I had to endure in order to reach the end credits.… Expand
  78. LaiShaWo
    Oct 4, 2020
    1
    Bought the game a year after release hoping the bugs would be fixed, instead I find myself with a buggy mess that cost me 50 euros, after spending hours finding a workaround for the game crashing after loading intro (had to reach the first autosave point playing in safe mode).

    I don't get the people who praise the game's graphics, for me the game looks absolutely awful, the textures are    Bought the game a year after release hoping the bugs would be fixed, instead I find myself with a buggy mess that cost me 50 euros, after spending hours finding a workaround for the game crashing after loading intro (had to reach the first autosave point playing in safe mode).

    I don't get the people who praise the game's graphics, for me the game looks absolutely awful, the textures are horrible even at ultra, the vegetation is absolutely disgusting and the cloth on your character looks it's made of plastic, and guess what it can't even run at 60 fps on an RTX 2070 Super.

    This game was absolutely not ready to be released, there are much better looking games that run much smoother than this, I don't care about plot or gameplay, it's all worthless if it can't be played.

    Dishonest publisher, revolting experience, never buy a game from Rockstar again.    … Expand
  79. Kxtota
    Sep 3, 2020
    4
    This not only boring game because long timethrough. It's also bad game, because of Rockstar Games Launcher. If it can't working, you can't play at all in this game (buyed in EGS). Even if you played before it do not take you access. And also why Rockstar servers so often are dead???? Shame on you, Rockstar!
  80. NiceG
    Aug 31, 2020
    0
    I don't think I've ever been so disappointed in a developer. I love all of the GTA games, and GTA 5 was my favorite game for years. I just purchased a gaming PC with a high end gpu (rtx 2060) and the newest intel cpu. I did so with the sole intent to play RDR2, because my other PC couldn't handle it. Now I've spent a little over 20 hours in this game with probably around 17 hours alteringI don't think I've ever been so disappointed in a developer. I love all of the GTA games, and GTA 5 was my favorite game for years. I just purchased a gaming PC with a high end gpu (rtx 2060) and the newest intel cpu. I did so with the sole intent to play RDR2, because my other PC couldn't handle it. Now I've spent a little over 20 hours in this game with probably around 17 hours altering graphics settings and reading reddit threads just trying to get this game to run. It's so buggy. It crashes reliably once an hour, and usually more frequently than that. I don't think I ever want to support Rockstar again after this horribly optimized game. And it really sucks because I can tell just how beautiful of a piece of art this is. I've reached out to Rockstar support with little help from them. It's a damn shame.… Expand
  81. emos
    Aug 27, 2020
    1
    Okay, where to start. Unfinished and unpolished. The storyline is fine, and the graphics are also okay (for this era). But many aspects of the game still lacking a proper level of quality compared to other games (of this era). Might have better potential when bugs and illogical situations are fixed for good. Firstly, the controls feel very very heavy and slow, it feels like steering a hugeOkay, where to start. Unfinished and unpolished. The storyline is fine, and the graphics are also okay (for this era). But many aspects of the game still lacking a proper level of quality compared to other games (of this era). Might have better potential when bugs and illogical situations are fixed for good. Firstly, the controls feel very very heavy and slow, it feels like steering a huge stubborn elephant through woody mountainous terrain. Furthermore, the in-game guide's and tips are really useless, lame and noninformative. You constantly need to google very simply stuff just to understand the control mechanisms and how to actually do things. Simple idiotic situations, such as your horse running into a tree stump or a rock thereby killing you, can ruin your gameplay or a chase/escape, taking away the pleasure, leaving you with a "WTF just happened" feeling. You have no idea or sense about your skills, health, energy or ammo level. You have to figure out this by yourself within different menus. Hell, I've been playing for many hours now, I still don't know how to change clothes to warm or cold weather... my guess is I need to go to the camp or a shop... who knows? Anyways, if you survive the torturous and patience-testing "controls" and illogical setup, you might start enjoying parts of the game when you get used to it. But this is really a requirement. Well... Good luck discovering for yourself. My review is quite obvious, don't waste your money and avoid this developer. BTW.. written by a passionate gamer.… Expand
  82. Howie22
    Aug 24, 2020
    2
    Gorgeous graphics ruined by boring gameplay! My steam version runs well but the controls are not optimized for a PC and just plain monotonous! As you play you need to look to the right to see what different button to use to interact with anything....How about "E" for everything, plants, horses, NPCs? Also, should be Quick draw right mouse (whatever in the tab menu as the chosen weapon),Gorgeous graphics ruined by boring gameplay! My steam version runs well but the controls are not optimized for a PC and just plain monotonous! As you play you need to look to the right to see what different button to use to interact with anything....How about "E" for everything, plants, horses, NPCs? Also, should be Quick draw right mouse (whatever in the tab menu as the chosen weapon), and left click mouse to shoot. In the beginning, are we supposed to believe a seasoned outlaw doesn't know how to fight with his fists or shoot well already? It's a chore to even draw a pistol. They took the fun action out of it. If you so much accidentally bump into a NPC with these clunky controls they will want to fight, and apparently this dumb law system knows wherever you are and comes after you even if a NPC steps in front of your horse. They made everything so tedious it's boring. 2 for great graphics, 0 for boring gameplay. It's a shame, it should've been Max Payne 2 with Cowboys (action from start to finish). This is a horse riding simulator, not Outlaw Jose Wales.… Expand
  83. NightfallRob
    Aug 18, 2020
    0
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. The game could be awesome, but instead it's a clusterf**k. The law enforcement system has the law show up so quickly you are penalized for playing an outlaw. You can't really rob anyone unless it's a gang mission, your gang missions send your bounty through the roof...oh yeah, and you can't actually win a gunfight with bounty hunters or lawmen until you are at least 20 hours into the game. You're also supposedly part of a gang, but you can't take anyone with you unless it's a special mission, so with the law system so ridiculously johnny-on-the-spot you can count on dying against impossible odds over and over again until you can, 20+ hours into the game, hold your own.

    Now let's talk about game play, which is also a total f**cking disaster. The cover system is horrible, the supposedly improved dead eye system is even worse than the cover system, and your enemies take between 2 and 10 shots each to die. Literally, the game will show people getting shot, dropping, and then getting back up like they're some kind of zombie. Meanwhile if you show much as pick up a splinter you're a goner. Add to this a ridiculous health tonic system that transforms you from being the wimpiest gunfighter in the West into the Terminator (able to shrug off dozens of rounds of gun fire), and you have to wonder what Rockstar was smoking when they put this together.

    The truly crowning achievement is that they manage to do all of this while delivering a graphically gorgeous game with a compelling story. Although, even the story needs work as it becomes abundantly obvious early in to the game that you either need to leave the gang and take as many people with you as you can (which you can't do) or murder Dutch (which you also can't do).

    And finally, the other problems. First of all that you can't quick save. That's right, once a mission starts you're screwed if it breaks. And they break all of the god damn time. There are also several graphics glitches, although these at least are minor and don't break the game. All-in-all, it seems to me that Rockstar had a great idea but a poor plan, which lead to the inevitable piss-poor execution. If you haven't been suckered into buying this game due to all of the good reviews and hype, do yourself and favor and save your money.    … Expand
  84. Auxiom
    Aug 16, 2020
    0
    Perfcetly unplayble on pc... UX is just inexistant...
    i guess due to a simple copycat form console to pc with a stupid key mapping.
    HF to interact with ANYTHING and remember what key to press and when... HF to do a good Action you Willed without being criminal by miss clicking or messing up with your weapon or talking to people. .. This is just a **** DUMB MESS from a compagny    Perfcetly unplayble on pc... UX is just inexistant...
    i guess due to a simple copycat form console to pc with a stupid key mapping.

    HF to interact with ANYTHING and remember what key to press and when...

    HF to do a good Action you Willed without being criminal by miss clicking or messing up with your weapon or talking to people.
    ..
    This is just a **** DUMB MESS from a compagny like rockstar....
    that was the last time i bought your ****    … Expand
  85. gamer_123
    Jul 9, 2020
    4
    Very boring game. Each line of code is aimed at delaying game time. Quick save? Didn't hear. Respavn from the same point? No, the game randomly takes you in some place and u need to run to the last failed place. Open world? Not for quests. Game will kill u, if u get out from quest area. Convenient inventory menu? Not in 2019. Even to exit the menu you have to wait! Gameplay formula forVery boring game. Each line of code is aimed at delaying game time. Quick save? Didn't hear. Respavn from the same point? No, the game randomly takes you in some place and u need to run to the last failed place. Open world? Not for quests. Game will kill u, if u get out from quest area. Convenient inventory menu? Not in 2019. Even to exit the menu you have to wait! Gameplay formula for this "masterpiece": 30% - boring movement, 30% - boring cutscenes , animations, minigames etc., 20% - micromanagement (including menu control). The remaining 20% allow you even light fighting (In action-adventure game, lol). Story mode is garbage, this game doesn't even come close to the Witcher 3. Very disappointed.
    P.S. Special "thanks" for RS* testers. I could not manage to get the game working on 5700XT and Win7. With Win 10 game starts normally but sometimes crushes. If the game crashes at the middle of quest (before autosave trigger) u will need to rerun quest from the beginning.
    P.s.s. 3 buttons for a simple drawer looting (open, loot, close) do not add atmosphere, but only make you nervous    … Expand
  86. tomflek
    Jun 27, 2020
    0
    I have to make account just for this game, I have waited so long this to come to PC, and when it finally got revealed to pc, I had to PRE-ORDER, I wanted to give a chance for Rockstar by preordering, and I even preordered that over 80€ edition, and then, release day comes and what I get, crashing crashing crashing crashing, crashing game between 1-60 minutes so randomly, and then I haveI have to make account just for this game, I have waited so long this to come to PC, and when it finally got revealed to pc, I had to PRE-ORDER, I wanted to give a chance for Rockstar by preordering, and I even preordered that over 80€ edition, and then, release day comes and what I get, crashing crashing crashing crashing, crashing game between 1-60 minutes so randomly, and then I have contacted Rockstar Support and what else I have received from there to this day but universal troubleshooting tips what haven't worked for me at all and they have also check'd my pc system files, and still only UNIVERSAL troubleshooting fix/tips from them, so now I drop the bomb here, I have to this day since pc release day, have get constant, same crashing as first time launching game, random crashes to this day, so I haven't been able to finish the game to this day since release day, think about it, this is f*cking disgusting, and I have already sent my most greatest hate mails to them, but it won't do nothing, I have even threatened them with suing... So I'm truly honest here, I paid over 80€ for this experience, the worst experience what I have ever had with any game, and I haven't never been so truly ANGRY for gaming company, but they did it, first time ever, I have gone trough hate, and there's nothing anymore left than tiredness, I don't have energy anymore to stand this, so they say that they are STILL aware of that ERR_GFX_STATE error in that game, but they couldn't up to this day find me a solution, THINK about it, to this day, they haven't fixed my problem with this game, over like 7 MONTHS I have been WAITING to play this game without crashing, AND still NOTHING!?!?! I will NEVER EVER preorder anything from Rockstar, my first and my truly LAST time!!!!!!!! And perhaps never ever I will buy any games from Rockstar.… Expand
  87. andvaree
    Jun 20, 2020
    0
    After so many months the game is still completely broken on PC (random crashes, broken fullscreen mode, graphics errors). The game saving system is horribly designed, requires way too many clicks (even if it allows you to save the game eventually) and doesn't always work. The control scheme of Elite Dangerous is easier to grasp than what's been born in the head of a sadist and implementedAfter so many months the game is still completely broken on PC (random crashes, broken fullscreen mode, graphics errors). The game saving system is horribly designed, requires way too many clicks (even if it allows you to save the game eventually) and doesn't always work. The control scheme of Elite Dangerous is easier to grasp than what's been born in the head of a sadist and implemented here. Also, compared to Rockstar, the guys at Ubisoft are grand masters of PC optimization. After 6hrs of play time I've simply lost my patience to deal with it anymore. That's an achievement on its own and is really worth coming here and leaving a review.… Expand
  88. aes23
    Jun 17, 2020
    1
    One of the most boring game in History .

    800 M USD of budget for that ? For "Hold whatever-the-key to change the wheel" Is this a joke ? In this game, sometime, left click will be use to Aim, is this a joke ? I timed myself, in order to do two quests, I spent 45 minutes on horse and 15 minutes actually playing and making the quest (there is no fast travel, at least not like any    One of the most boring game in History .

    800 M USD of budget for that ? For "Hold whatever-the-key to change the wheel"

    Is this a joke ?

    In this game, sometime, left click will be use to Aim, is this a joke ?

    I timed myself, in order to do two quests, I spent 45 minutes on horse and 15 minutes actually playing and making the quest (there is no fast travel, at least not like any other normal game)

    This game thinks of itself as a simulation and therefore forgets to be a game.

    It's boring, it's one of the most boring game ever. Even a walking simulator is less boring than this game.

    And it's so much scripted, it's insane. The first bounty hunting mission, you need to find a fake doctor.

    You find him near a river on a cliff. You arrest him, he falls in the river. You go on your horse to save him.

    You can see the guy moving in the river, suddenly you see a junction where you think you can catch the guy . You wait...You wait, he does not appear and you fail the mission, but why ? I was sure I saw the guy, he's suppose to come here.

    Well well, on second attempt you can clearly see the guy passing behing a huge rock BUT if you are at a right angle, you can see he's being "teleported", his position changes instantly, why ? Because Rockstar does not want you to use the junction to stop him, they want you to follow their gentle script and get the guy where they want you to get him.

    I can't stand that anymore, I want freedom in a video game, I want to be put infront of a problem and find a way to solve it by myself, the junction should have worked in my example and they destroyed that option on purpose.

    This game is just so bad.

    800M USD of budget for something than even a game made by students can beat easily in terms of gameplay .

    What a shame...    … Expand
  89. TheWaffle
    Jun 17, 2020
    0
    The Rockstar Games Launcher is such hot garbage. This thing has been around for months, and I'm literally filling out Captcha after Captcha just to access the account and play the game THAT I'VE ALREADY PAID $60 FOR! I would review the game, but I've spent too much time fighting the pathetic launcher, so I haven't actually gotten much game time in. You know who never made me fill outThe Rockstar Games Launcher is such hot garbage. This thing has been around for months, and I'm literally filling out Captcha after Captcha just to access the account and play the game THAT I'VE ALREADY PAID $60 FOR! I would review the game, but I've spent too much time fighting the pathetic launcher, so I haven't actually gotten much game time in. You know who never made me fill out Captcha before playing my games? Steam. Do you know who has a functional launcher? Battle.net. If you're going to create your own launcher, maybe make one that works.… Expand
  90. Jokerdick
    May 30, 2020
    3
    Its absolutely boring and worsr gunplay ever. Yes story is fking amazing. But its gameplay is so slow that you will fall asleep
  91. prstzbd
    May 30, 2020
    0
    Оптимизация-именно это слово забыли Rockstar во время разработки игры, смотря на то как была оптимизирована GTA 5 больно играть в игру, ах да, в неё нельзя играть без вылетов, багов, фризов и 30 фпс
  92. KaimArgonar
    May 20, 2020
    1
    Launcher no lanza el juego y Rockstar no hace nada para ayudarte, sólo te hace perder el tiempo. Es una vergüenza.
  93. Nullpoint
    May 13, 2020
    4
    Everything visual is amazing. The story is great, but too much cutscenes and by that, i mean they are extremely boring. The game in it self is awesome..
    But the worst part of it all, it is not enjoyable mechanics. Going from WASD to move and then use arrows to navigate then use Enter key accept, and interacting with anything kept switching from f, space to whatever. I wouldn’t mind key    Everything visual is amazing. The story is great, but too much cutscenes and by that, i mean they are extremely boring. The game in it self is awesome..
    But the worst part of it all, it is not enjoyable mechanics. Going from WASD to move and then use arrows to navigate then use Enter key accept, and interacting with anything kept switching from f, space to whatever. I wouldn’t mind key mapping the entire game, if it wasn’t because the game needs a new input for every action.. even an emulator could have done this better. This made it completely frustrating and tedious to play through.    … Expand
  94. Nikoltaiy
    May 11, 2020
    3
    Играю в игру первый день, и не пойму, откуда столько хайпа. Забавные ситуации:
    - убил кого-то, тут же появился свидетель. Тычешь ему пушкой в лицо, говоришь, мол, подумай, а он орет, что ты убийца, и бежит дальше, несмотря на пули, летящие в зад;
    - еду на коняшке, у дороге стоит 2 бандита, и целится в жертву. Подхожу к ним, говорю, не нужно так. Они в меня стреляют. Я их убиваю.    Играю в игру первый день, и не пойму, откуда столько хайпа. Забавные ситуации:
    - убил кого-то, тут же появился свидетель. Тычешь ему пушкой в лицо, говоришь, мол, подумай, а он орет, что ты убийца, и бежит дальше, несмотря на пули, летящие в зад;
    - еду на коняшке, у дороге стоит 2 бандита, и целится в жертву. Подхожу к ним, говорю, не нужно так. Они в меня стреляют. Я их убиваю. Появляется свидетель, который зовет полицию, и я становлюсь преступником;
    - та же самая ситуация, когда вижу человека, обыскивающей труп у дилижанса;
    - вижу, грабят чей-то дилижанс, помогаю, спасенный говорит, что дилижанс не его, он просто прохожий, и я могу забрать дилижанс. Я его забираю, привожу в лагерь, мне пишет, что я не могу приезжать на дилижансе в лагерь, я его оставляю рядом, и он пропадает после загрузки;
    - шкуры животных негде хранить, нет ни сундука, ни стойки, ничего. Шкуру можно или продать, или - выкинуть;
    - законники обладают телепортацией и связью. Стоит начать любую разборку со сторонники НПС, и законники будут бесконечно телепортироваться прямо под вас. Их можно убить 100-200-300, не важно, они бесконечны;
    - ограбить поезд невозможно из-за предыдущего пункта. Не важно, в каком пустыре вы находитесь;
    - у квестов есть 2 варианта ответов: да/нет, или пойду сам/пошлю компаньона.

    Когда меня бьют, я боюсь ударить в ответ, что бы тут же не попасть в розыск. Какой-то не дикий запад, а симулятор тотального полицейского государства. Вместо городов, где боятся быть шерифами, мы получаем армию федералов, которая по средствам спецсвязи и телепортации всегда прибудет на любой зов.

    Игра была бы хороша, как интерактивный фильм. Как версия низкобюджетной компании. Как демка. В этих случаях я бы поставил очень хорошую оценку. Но, когда ты везде слышишь, какая она бесподобная, заходишь в нее, а там - такое, то, извините. Неоправданные ожидания очень сильно бьют по рейтингу. Причем, заметьте, я не пишу про техническую часть, баги, оптимизацию, качество портирования с консоли и т.д.

    Из плюсов, мне сильно понравился покер. Когда ходишь вокруг стола, смотришь, как НПС сдают карты, держат их в руках, делают ставки, а потом ты садишься к ним за стол, и играешь вместе с ними - это очень круто. Я, даже, попытался найти какой-то 3D покер, где можно посидеть в друзьями, и поиграть по "скайпу", ни ничего подобного не нашел. Покер изумительный. Игра могла бы быть хорошей, если бы что-то сделали с законниками. А так, можно или поставить мод с какой-то телепортацией и чисто пройти сюдет, или ждать каких-то модов, где вас перестанут убивать бесконечные законники, хотя бы за самозащиту.    … Expand
  95. edi86
    May 11, 2020
    0
    Too many bugs, crashes, and it sucks, I want my money back.. You have to buy to much with Gold witch is hard to farm. Its kind of pay to get content like EA. We need more Quest online, because it is really boring right now. I want my money back.
  96. elKuarlos
    May 10, 2020
    0
    A cowboy game that hates you being a cowboy. A pound shop witcher.

    The acting is incredible. The views are stunning. You really get a feel you are in the right kind of cowboy fantasy. They ruin it by trying to micromanage every aspect. Its the most annoyed I have ever been by a game. its perfect but...the controls are awful. Just. Plain. Awful. They had the great idea; lets make    A cowboy game that hates you being a cowboy. A pound shop witcher.

    The acting is incredible. The views are stunning. You really get a feel you are in the right kind of cowboy fantasy.

    They ruin it by trying to micromanage every aspect. Its the most annoyed I have ever been by a game. its perfect but...the controls are awful. Just. Plain. Awful.

    They had the great idea; lets make looting realistic. Then forgot that looking every body for five seconds to see if they had a platinum pocket watch up their **** is not realistic.

    Its just a hassle to play that breaks the immersion evey time it gets going cos it has to tell you what button to press to interact in its one of many 100s of action scenes; because its absoutley clear the guys making the different senarios had no fecking idea either. And those action scenese arent like the witcher; thought out and planned.

    Nope. A few hours into your realistic western gameplay you will have depopulated half of america. but if you smack a guys teeth out in abar you are gonna get railed on.

    And the saves dont work properly.

    Its the best crap game I have ever played.    … Expand
  97. getrost
    May 5, 2020
    0
    Oyun tam anlamıyla bir başyapıt ancak optimizasyon aşırı rezalet ötesi ve oyunun pc versiyonunun çıkışı üzerinden 6 ay gibi bir süre geçmesine rağmen doğru düzgün bir çalışma ve açıklama yok
  98. nofunaloud
    May 4, 2020
    0
    While the game is beautiful at times with amazing detail and plenty of things to do, its just unfortunate the technical team over at rockstar isn't as skilled as their art team. Its a console port that forces you to get a new cpu because optimization wasn't as important as making sure the minigame of poker was intentionally coded to make you lose. UI wasn't even looked at, there isn't aWhile the game is beautiful at times with amazing detail and plenty of things to do, its just unfortunate the technical team over at rockstar isn't as skilled as their art team. Its a console port that forces you to get a new cpu because optimization wasn't as important as making sure the minigame of poker was intentionally coded to make you lose. UI wasn't even looked at, there isn't a single menu that houses the rest of the menus so each menu has its own individual hot key. The UI is massive and totally counter intuitive to keyboard and mouse users. If you want to change a hot key you need to scroll through pages and pages of other keys. The mouse UI sometimes completely breaks and the only way to use the menus again is to use the keyboard. but at least your horse poops every time you dismount. such detail, much game design. What would be amazing is if a studio made a game this detailed and beautiful but actually cared about the consumer more than just seeing them as potential micro-transactions. That way we would get a masterpiece not ruined by bugs, crashes and bad optimization just because fixing bugs and poor optimization cost more to fix than they bring in money.

    Also the trigger hoops the game forces you to jump through are so ridiculous, they are evident at every corner and it culminates in me being unable to even finish the epilogue, I just stand there in place glitched out. If they wanted to make a game on rails they should skip the trying to make an open world.

    I really wish the rockstar that made san andreas still existed, so that we would get a worth wile satirization of the piss poor state that current rockstar devolved into

    final note, as someone who lives in a desert other than the mojave or sonora it is annoying how over represented the saguaro cactus is. The cactus is found in one desert in arizona and that is it, but in this game it's in every desert except the one based on the mojave. It's also annoying there is a massive section of the map covered in saguaro cactus that isn't even used in the storyline, when the game cannot push a stable 60fps on a 3440x1440 monitor in the parts of the map you do use.    … Expand
  99. Morozzko
    Apr 30, 2020
    0
    раз в 30 минут стабильно вылетает с ошибкой, отдал 4к
  100. zinmon
    Apr 9, 2020
    0
    This game has wonderfully graphic, and this is everything positive I can say about it. I spent 40 hours in this game and was still in the second chapter because I love to explore and do side quests instead of pushing the main story in all that I play games. But this game makes angry ass hell.

    1) It's unstable, and I don't care about frames per second. I have a good enough rig to handle    This game has wonderfully graphic, and this is everything positive I can say about it. I spent 40 hours in this game and was still in the second chapter because I love to explore and do side quests instead of pushing the main story in all that I play games. But this game makes angry ass hell.

    1) It's unstable, and I don't care about frames per second. I have a good enough rig to handle it. But it hangs or quit to windows eight times per my whole 40h of gameplay.

    2) Game controls (i use keyboard and mouse because it's PC) were terribly designed. Even (1) after remapping keys to handle the most important actions by one hand. Even (2) if you move hud closer to the center You need to observe right corner by the entire game:
    for crafting
    for hunting
    for talking
    for interact with pets/horses
    for looting
    for trading
    That is stupid, especially on an ultra-wide monitor.
    And even (3) that You never know what Arthur will do. For example, I always kick to dead tied people instead of releasing them because this action was triggered by this same button! You can expect random shots or punch during a conversation.

    3) physic is a big joke. Riding a horse or running was uncomfortable keybindings also doesn't help in this area. Everything is swimming in this world and you can expect many impossible ragdolls which results in sudden death.

    4) You cannot trust your inventory. Items like to disappear. It will be acceptable if there is some lost and found system, but there isn't.
    For example, I found a pretty civil war knife in an abandoned fort. And after a while, it disappears, I cannot loot it again, Found in my knives select menu or repurchase it from someone It vanished from the entire game.

    5) Stupid bounty system. Why the hell Arthur takes off the mask on every cutscene. And how law enforcement recognizes you in disguise. Because of this, the mask is useless.

    6) Missions and NPC
    Quick load festival not only because of terrible handling but because your stupid folks don't wait for you and rush on the enemy.
    NPC was broken! In stealth tutorial, every time when I silently kill a target, never mind if with throwing knife or by stabbing him. All other NPC starts shooting even when they cannot see whats happened.
    In cities, You need to fight with controls to don't touch anybody it results with bounty or quick load.

    7) Tutorials
    The game doesn't tell you about important mechanics.
    You need to search on the internet how bounty works, how to save game, How to use quick travel in the middle of nothing. Or why you cannot get a bunny perfect pelt. Or even if it tells there are too many actions on the bottom right to read all tooltips when they appear.    … Expand
prev
Page:

Awards & Rankings

1
#1 Best PC Game of 2019
1
#1 Most Discussed PC Game of 2019

Critic Reviews

All reviews »
Metascore
93

Universal acclaim - based on 44 Critic Reviews

Critic score distribution:
  1. Positive: 44 out of 44
  2. Mixed: 0 out of 44
  3. Negative: 0 out of 44
  1. LEVEL (Czech Republic)
    Feb 28, 2020
    100
    An absorbing tale that will test your machine and tear ducts. A game that did not suffer from being brought to PC. RDR2 is worth overcoming all the shortcomings, since it is one of the best games of the decade. [Issue#300]
  2. PLAY! Zine
    Dec 30, 2019
    90
    Victory of gaming as an art and the pinnacle of creativity in the gaming industry. A true, impeccably-polished masterpiece that will set standards for a decade to come.
    Read full review
  3. Game Revolution
    Dec 17, 2019
    100
    My biggest warning to anyone considering purchasing RDR2 on PC is that you need to have patience when you set it up. Take the time to go through each graphics option, compare your performance on Vulkan vs. DirectX 12, and tailor the game to your specs. Once you have the game tuned, there’s no better way to experience it than on PC.
    Read full review
See all critic reviews »