Zen Studios deserves credit for creating a game that has the potential to inspire enthusiasm for pinball: the first arcade game and a beautiful piece of Americana treasured by many worldwide. And though the Pinball FX 2 tables are fun and clever in their own way, they are distinctly and exclusively digital. As such, its flipper physics will feel strange to anyone who cut their pinballZen Studios deserves credit for creating a game that has the potential to inspire enthusiasm for pinball: the first arcade game and a beautiful piece of Americana treasured by many worldwide. And though the Pinball FX 2 tables are fun and clever in their own way, they are distinctly and exclusively digital. As such, its flipper physics will feel strange to anyone who cut their pinball teeth on a physical machine, or even the tables digitally recreated in Farsight Studios' Pinball Arcade (its chief competition), which mimic real-world feel and physics far more accurately. Old-school pinball players, such as myself, will likely find this to be PFX2's greatest weakness. Others will simply decide it's a matter of personal preference.
On the flip side (pun intended), PFX2 enjoys the freedom from real-world constraints in a number of admittedly novel ways. The table "Rome," for example, features burning torches, a flowing aquaduct, and a shooter that uses ropes, pulleys and counterweights in place of springs for a tongue-in-cheek touch of first-century "realism." Other tables feature a wide variety of playfield toys that would be similarly impossible in a real-world table, such as the Tesla coil in "Tesla."
For all PFX2's departures into the realm of the fantastic, however, none of Zen's tables rely on any device essential to play that couldn't be recreated on a physical table, at least to this reviewer's knowledge. Nor is there ever a suspension of "natural" physics (e.g. anti-gravity beams that float the ball). The ways in which PFX2 departs from reality are strictly cosmetic. The essence of pinball is the visceral interaction between the player and a physical device made of wood, steel, rubber, and plastic. This accounts for much of what makes pinball so enjoyable. Zen shows great wisdom and restraint in observing these facts, and is better for it.
So, should you, the pinball afficionado whose love for the silver ball predates the PC, buy Pinball FX 2? Yes, if only to help keep the idea of pinball alive in the minds of younger generations, until the day when physical pinball machines once again rule the neighborhood arcade. You might even enjoy it.
And should you, the younger gamer, who never experienced the brilliant rays of wonder and awe that shone from video and pinball arcades in the 1970s, '80s, and early '90s, spend your money on such an archaic form of entertainment? Yes. But don't be satisfied until you've found a real-world pinball table at a nearby bowling alley or arcade. Proceed to feed it quarter after quarter. And within $10 you will begin to experience the unparalleled, magic sensation of touching the soul of a machine.… Expand