Metascore
65

Mixed or average reviews - based on 21 Critic Reviews

Critic score distribution:
  1. Positive: 3 out of 21
  2. Negative: 0 out of 21
  1. Jan 25, 2021
    80
    After playing Orwell’s Animal Farm, I found myself gobbling up every analysis I could find on the original work and ultimately settling into bed with a copy of the book found online. From the subversion of politics through the subversion of language and logic to reducing complex ideals to meaningless catchphrases, it was truly eye-opening just how Orwellian the past few years have been — although not the way in which the word has been thrown around after January 6th. The team’s unique history with totalitarianism made them competent candidates for the game version of this compelling allegorical tale, and I find myself still trying to wrap my head around the experience with these additional layers of context. If you’re looking for an incredibly memorable and surprisingly emotional refresher on this all-too important story, look no further than Orwell’s Animal Farm.
  2. Jan 20, 2021
    80
    Orwell’s Animal Farm is a very good reimagining of the famous novel, staying true to the spirit of the dystopic Republic of the Animals. Though it lacks the kind of puzzles and gameplay to make it a full-fledged adventure, it’s a must-play for those who would enjoy a well-executed exploration of a classic novel.
  3. Dec 10, 2020
    80
    Orwell's Animal Farm faithfully recreates and even reinvents the classic allegory at a time when it's never been more relevant for some players.
  4. CD-Action
    Jul 23, 2021
    70
    I fully recommend Orwell’s Animal Farm as a great way to familiarize oneself with the timeless novella. It lacks a lot as a game though, because the adaptation is completely faithful and therefore restricts the player’s freedom heavily. [02/2021, p.47]
  5. Jan 4, 2021
    70
    Its mechanics are muddled and confusing at best and frustrating at worst, but it remains a decent and charmingly presented adaptation of the farmyard fable that so strikingly warns of the dangers of corruption and totalitarianism.
  6. Dec 21, 2020
    70
    I really think of all the ways to adapt Animal Farm, this is definitely one of the best ways. Actually making the decisions and watching corrupt leadership undermine them, or being the one to justify sacrificing the “lesser” people for the “greater good,” really emphasizes how easily selfishness ruins a perfectly good dream. It’s not terribly long, but there is plenty of replay value in trying for various routes and endings and it’s relatively cheap.
  7. Dec 17, 2020
    70
    Orwell's Animal Farm is a pleasant mix of Visual Novel and management experience, with some lovely visuals, music and a very good narrator. The fact that it allows you to retell the story is interesting. But as it still offers a good way to know what the book has to say, it can feel redundant, and a bit foggy in its intentions and mechanics.
  8. Dec 14, 2020
    70
    A video game based on Animal Farm is a crazy idea on paper, but it mostly manages to stick the landing with its weighty political themes still intact.
  9. 70
    Orwell’s Animal Farm is clearly a respectful adaptation. From the closely adapted text onscreen to the demarcated destinies and potential outcomes, it interacts thoughtfully with Orwell’s ideas of dictatorship and manipulation. But, in the mechanics of gameplay, some of its intentions get lost.
  10. Dec 10, 2020
    70
    Animal Farm remains an important story, and this retelling in game format feels incredibly timely and poignant. With lots of ways the game can play out depending on your choices, you can revisit Orwell's themes as well as being able to dive even deeper into them.
  11. Mar 23, 2021
    60
    The game looks beautiful, and its source material is brimming with potential, but the gameplay itself is lacklustre in the extreme. Most of the time you simply don’t know what to do or how to achieve the few things you’re sure you want. A very confusing, sometimes frustrating experience rescued only by the strengths of the book.
  12. Feb 11, 2021
    60
    Orwell’s Animal Farm relays the content of the book well, but stops short of drawing from any new depths, as choices are limited and the plot takes second place to a dry management sim.
  13. Jan 6, 2021
    60
    The game is also too faithful to Orwell’s plot, for all the alternative endings. At its best, it encourages you to rethink and even challenge some of the novella’s concepts, including its rather dated classist metaphors. What if the rats were more of an opposition than an infestation? What if the sheep were more than mindless propaganda machines? But these divergences are frustratingly limited by the need to pack in familiar scenes and conversations from the book. In the end, Orwell’s Animal Farm can’t work out whether it’s a retelling or a revolution – but with the nation’s schoolkids in lockdown, it’s nonetheless a valuable adaptation.
  14. Dec 21, 2020
    60
    Orwell's Animal Farm could have been something really special, but plays like a flat interactive fiction that will (maybe) please those who have loved the original novella.
  15. Dec 10, 2020
    60
    Orwell’s Animal Farm is a pleasant retelling of the 1945 novella, and revisiting the story again after reading it in high school has been lovely. As a lover of literature as well as video games, I couldn’t help but smile seeing the story come to life. Not everyone will feel the same way though, and as an adventure game or even a visual novel, Orwell’s Animal Farm is unlikely to grab players that don’t already have a vested interest in the original story. Still, it’s a valiant effort in bringing a classic novella to new audiences, and might just be a valuable tool for students.
  16. Dec 10, 2020
    60
    The turmoil of a revolution gone wrong is conveyed through nothing more than a few mouse clicks and quick decisions. It’s flawed and frustrating, but there’s an undeniable elegance to the game.
  17. Dec 10, 2020
    60
    Ultimately, Orwell's Animal Farm is still worth a look because its presentation is so strong, but the actual gameplay may leave a lot to be desired for those expecting a strong foundation like Orwell's writing to translate into equally engrossing decisions.
  18. Dec 14, 2020
    58
    Where it does succeed is in its original intention – to bring this story to a new, modern audience. I finally understand George Orwell’s Animal Farm a bit more, even having still not read it. Despite my frustrations, I still spent yet more hours outside the game thinking about the ramifications and meanings of this Orwellian tale. In that at least, Orwell’s Animal Farm realizes its potential.
  19. Jan 6, 2021
    55
    I commend the developers for keeping true to Orwell’s work, depressing endings and all, but unfortunately what we have here is a worst-of-both-worlds situation — as a visual novel, it’s a slog to get through the repetitive mundane, choices, and the gameplay isn’t refined or engaging enough to be a solid management sim. Simply reading the book might be a better option.
  20. Dec 10, 2020
    50
    The game adaptation of Orwell’s Animal Farm tells a disjointed story, without the kind of buildup and nuance that makes it a classic novel. As a game, it lacks the kind of options and menus necessary to make you feel like you’re ever in control of your farm.
  21. Dec 10, 2020
    50
    While Orwell’s Animal Farm stays true to its source material, its repetitive and unclear gameplay weakens a stylized portrayal of the book. It’s not the worst way to spend a couple hours thanks to replayability and excellent narration, but it’s not compelling to get every ending and collect every stamp. You’ll get a lot more out of reading the book than you will from the game.
User Score
5.3

Mixed or average reviews- based on 6 Ratings

User score distribution:
  1. Positive: 2 out of 6
  2. Negative: 2 out of 6
  1. Mar 20, 2021
    3
    An attempt at a tycoon game while also forcing the player to fail to fit the book's plot.

    Good: - well, at least it may be a way to get
    An attempt at a tycoon game while also forcing the player to fail to fit the book's plot.

    Good:
    - well, at least it may be a way to get the younger generation learn about the Orwell's book "Animal Farm".

    So-so:
    - the graphics and the music are okay. Nothing spectacular though

    Bad:
    - it may look like a tycoon game to you at first, where you need to optimize your decisions and strive to keep the food supply sufficient, the mood high etc. However, by year 5 the farm just falls apart through no fault of yours. And by year 6 there are no available actions left apart form "sing" and "cheer". I had to drop the game when, in year 6, the game literally showed no available actions. That's effectively game end.
    - the game totally fails to deliver the book's message, or any message at all. E.g. I've managed to build the windmill but then human neighbors attacked the farm, and destroyed the windmill. Given that story, one would have to say that the USSR was a great country and only failed because the evil West attacked it or at least strangled it with sanctions and the nuclear threat. Ridiculous. Similarly, by day 5 there were simply no animals remaining who would want to do any work. Hens, sheep, cows - these all just weren't on the yard anymore and couldn't be assigned tasks. The last animal to do any work (planting seeds) was actually a pig! Which totally contradicts the book's idea that pigs became lazy and never did any work
    - animals are constantly "tired'. This begs the question: "if they are constantly tired now when they don't need to feed a human, how didn't they get mortally tired when a human was exploiting them?"
    - there are plot inconsistencies. E.g. I let the dogs run away on day 3. Still, on day 6 the story mentions dogs arresting the Clower horse.
    - for many actions, the result is unclear, and the action itself is just one word. I didn't bother to reload and just tried those actions out to see what they do. This all made the gameplay feel random and meaningless.

    I'd say that the designers of this game took an impossible task: to take a political book with a linear story and turn it into something that, at least to a gamer, looks like a tycoon or farm management game. The thing is, tycoon games ARE about central planning, just on a scale of a single company (run authoritatively by a CEO, in an environment of a free market economy). But this game has to "prove that communism is bad" by cheating against the player and forcing him to fail.

    Oh yeah, and just to be clear: I'm a Russian, and I still remember the USSR as a child. And I've read the "Animal Farm" book a few times: first time at school and then a couple times in English as an adult. And I hate communism. And I run my own business and hate all the leftist madness that's plaguing the West right now.

    Gee, what a mess of a game.
    Full Review »