User Score
7.8

Generally favorable reviews- based on 333 Ratings

User score distribution:
  1. Negative: 48 out of 333

Review this game

  1. Your Score
    0 out of 10
    Rate this:
    • 10
    • 9
    • 8
    • 7
    • 6
    • 5
    • 4
    • 3
    • 2
    • 1
    • 0
    • 0
  1. Submit
  2. Check Spelling
  1. May 24, 2016
    1
    Its not that goi isn't a fun game or doesn't try, it is simply that the developers do not care about or play their own game. Patches are consistently loaded with bugs and broken features or even worse intentionally remove well beloved and used features, the developers are openly semi-hostile to all nearly all input from the playerbase regarding their new issues (aka "working as intended-Its not that goi isn't a fun game or doesn't try, it is simply that the developers do not care about or play their own game. Patches are consistently loaded with bugs and broken features or even worse intentionally remove well beloved and used features, the developers are openly semi-hostile to all nearly all input from the playerbase regarding their new issues (aka "working as intended- the crash when you do X is supposed to prevent you from getting bored with playing the game uninterupted.")

    tldr; I don't regret buying the game but it absolutely does not live up to its potential
    Expand
  2. Jan 14, 2018
    0
    Not worth investing in, neither in time or money. The game itself is mediocre, which wouldn't be too bad were it not for the playerbase. First off, there aren't many players - now, that's to be expected of a game like this, but the attitude of most of those remaining probably contributes to the decline. Out of the players that I met, only a couple of them were decent enough to play with.Not worth investing in, neither in time or money. The game itself is mediocre, which wouldn't be too bad were it not for the playerbase. First off, there aren't many players - now, that's to be expected of a game like this, but the attitude of most of those remaining probably contributes to the decline. Out of the players that I met, only a couple of them were decent enough to play with. The others were entitled and controlling, they even went so far as to encourage everyone in the match to report me for 'trolling' because I was bad. Expand
  3. Jan 14, 2018
    1
    The game has a great concept, BUT DO NOT BUY IT.
    The game is DEAD. Nobody plays it, therefore you will not find a game. I tried searching for a game with 3 other friends, and after 15 minutes had no luck. Even if you get a game by looking through custom matches, there's a high chance you won't be on the same team as your friends.
    ALSO, if you have no friends this game is not for you.
    The game has a great concept, BUT DO NOT BUY IT.
    The game is DEAD. Nobody plays it, therefore you will not find a game. I tried searching for a game with 3 other friends, and after 15 minutes had no luck. Even if you get a game by looking through custom matches, there's a high chance you won't be on the same team as your friends.

    ALSO, if you have no friends this game is not for you.

    I really liked the idea, i was so ready to play, but i guess a lot of games match their price.
    Expand
  4. Jan 14, 2018
    0
    Got it free through humble bundle. Lacking in players.
    I think part of the problem is the high level players can be quite nasty. Saltier than DOTA2 player.
    No wonder new players don't want to stick around to play. Types of users - just plain rude (swearing on mic) or unfriendly. - unforgiving to lower level player (raging because players "can't" do things as well as them) - just
    Got it free through humble bundle. Lacking in players.
    I think part of the problem is the high level players can be quite nasty. Saltier than DOTA2 player.
    No wonder new players don't want to stick around to play.

    Types of users
    - just plain rude (swearing on mic) or unfriendly.
    - unforgiving to lower level player (raging because players "can't" do things as well as them)
    - just can't chill, and enjoy the game. No GLHF

    Having said that, there are some good player. But quite often it'll be quite nasty.
    If you're a high level GOI player, be nice to others.
    Expand
  5. Jan 14, 2018
    0
    Most of the player base has been driven away by veteran players stacking lobbies, developers that dont play understand their own game and bias moderation. I wish a real game developer was responsible for this game.
  6. Jan 14, 2018
    2
    Fun game but the community is lame. They hate you and scream at you if you're new. No wonder there's only about 200 active players. Did the tutorials, tried to play, got screamed at for having the audacity to be new.
  7. Jan 15, 2018
    0
    Used to be a fantastic game, not sure what happened...Sort of.

    The gameplay is pretty solid, the mechanics are pretty solid. The community and developers...eh, not so much. People ask why there is no community or how they wish there was, well I'll tell you. I bought this game during its kickstarter (yes, it was on kickstarter!) and thoroughly enjoyed it for a good couple of years. But
    Used to be a fantastic game, not sure what happened...Sort of.

    The gameplay is pretty solid, the mechanics are pretty solid. The community and developers...eh, not so much. People ask why there is no community or how they wish there was, well I'll tell you. I bought this game during its kickstarter (yes, it was on kickstarter!) and thoroughly enjoyed it for a good couple of years. But everything changed when the dev's attacked. Once they changed matchmaking and the entire overhaul of the UI, all the veterans (most of the community at the time) left.

    The reason being the matchmaking became poor (still is) and the communication dropped by about 150% down to -50% where you're communicating with yourself more than anything. Trust me when I say this game REQUIRES communication and is WAY more fun with a jokey, banterous team who also know what they're doing and can talk to each other. Sadly, you don't have that anymore, the community who supported them got betrayed and left and now it's empty and full of kids or 3/8 player lobbies with just bad game play...
    Expand
  8. Jan 15, 2018
    4
    The GREAT BASTION of A Game !
    There is some fun in the actual game-play, but the real fun is in the lobby and during the matches! You will hear all sorts of colorful language especially from the crew to the pilot and pilot to the crew uncensored and RAW! I have heard of pilots causing nubs to almost cry cause they yelled at them constantly for not fixing the hull or the balloon properly.
    The GREAT BASTION of A Game !
    There is some fun in the actual game-play, but the real fun is in the lobby and during the matches! You will hear all sorts of colorful language especially from the crew to the pilot and pilot to the crew uncensored and RAW! I have heard of pilots causing nubs to almost cry cause they yelled at them constantly for not fixing the hull or the balloon properly. But this is what makes the game so great. You can be your true self. I want to give it more stars but the game play is dead and boring. I got this on special since they released a new DLC that seems to have caused the already small player base to become smaller. What is the point of having a multiplayer game if very few people are online? This game requires thick skin so be prepared, and have fun.
    Expand
  9. Jan 15, 2018
    3
    As A Free Game 5 - But As A Paid Game 1
    This game is wonderful for stress management. After a hard day's work and nagging wife, their is nothing like yelling, screaming and training newbie players in the game to take out all of my stress. If I did this on any other online game I would get banned almost instantly and have to buy the game again or open another account. This game is better
    As A Free Game 5 - But As A Paid Game 1
    This game is wonderful for stress management. After a hard day's work and nagging wife, their is nothing like yelling, screaming and training newbie players in the game to take out all of my stress. If I did this on any other online game I would get banned almost instantly and have to buy the game again or open another account. This game is better than any other game for that one reason. The players in this game makes the players in LOL look like boy scouts. So I give it 3 stars for stress management tool. The game play downright sucks. It is BORING and is probably why most people that buy this game most likely use it as an ANGER MANAGEMENT tool just like me. That is why I am subtracting 2 stars from a free 5 star game. The trick to never getting banned is to always have an excuse like training new players. They will never ban you if you use that excuse. Also join a Clan. because even if you are unlucky enough to get caught by a newb for harassment, your friends can gang up and yell at your accusers and the great thing is moderators will keep silent just make sure you look like you are "defending the game" or training new players lol. Good Times.
    Expand
  10. Jan 15, 2018
    0
    Why do you have advertisement on a paid game? I buy this game and it have advertisement on the game to buy other another game. Why you do this? This game not good. You not have many players! Why me want to buy other alliance game for? I feel cheated! You sell half game with 20 players online! I thought USA honest, but me wrong. Muse just do anything to make money. Like big advertisementWhy do you have advertisement on a paid game? I buy this game and it have advertisement on the game to buy other another game. Why you do this? This game not good. You not have many players! Why me want to buy other alliance game for? I feel cheated! You sell half game with 20 players online! I thought USA honest, but me wrong. Muse just do anything to make money. Like big advertisement on a PAID Game. No morals! Expand
  11. Jan 15, 2018
    0
    Trash in = Trash out.
    The moment you log on to your GOI account you can instantly tell that the developers made a cash grab. You can always tell that a game is dying when you have huge advertisements in game. That is never a good sign. Forget about the unforgiving player-base, or the Maximum of 25 players when you log in. (Keep in mind that it takes 5 people just to fly one ship) What
    Trash in = Trash out.
    The moment you log on to your GOI account you can instantly tell that the developers made a cash grab. You can always tell that a game is dying when you have huge advertisements in game. That is never a good sign. Forget about the unforgiving player-base, or the Maximum of 25 players when you log in. (Keep in mind that it takes 5 people just to fly one ship) What bothers me the most is that I paid good money for a freemium game with advertisements. It really shows through the game that the developer do not care at all about their players. I would rather have a giant middle finger displayed on my Guns of Icarus login screen, at least that is a more honest and straightforward message from the developers. This is just my opinion of this game G'day.
    Expand
  12. Jan 16, 2018
    0
    This game is the same trashy game re-branded or reworked 3 times. First in 2009, then in 2012, now they just recycled content from GOI to create a up sell expansion. All of them scored low to very low on metacritic.

    https://secure.metacritic.com/company/muse-games Point of this review is that the game is just recycled garbage. I was curious to read some of the high 10 and 9 comments
    This game is the same trashy game re-branded or reworked 3 times. First in 2009, then in 2012, now they just recycled content from GOI to create a up sell expansion. All of them scored low to very low on metacritic.

    https://secure.metacritic.com/company/muse-games

    Point of this review is that the game is just recycled garbage. I was curious to read some of the high 10 and 9 comments like the game is perfect, and there are no bugs, Everyone is friendly etc. After reading the reviews I had to wonder if these people ever played this game to give it 9 or 10 points. Then when I looked at many of the 9 and 10 point review I noticed something strange. Many of them only reviewed this game in 2012-14 then diapered. Seems very odd. Anyway the game sucks in short do not every invest any money into muse or their games. Knowledge is power check out the 9 and 10 reviews. Muse how about you actually spend time on making the game better instead of doing things half way for a once.
    Expand
  13. Jan 16, 2018
    0
    This game plays like a demo. Horrible training and people can be nasty. Just wait for it to go free to play again. Do not buy this game you will waste money due to lack of players, bugs lags and very little updates.
  14. Jan 16, 2018
    0
    Limited game play and general bugginess, lack of updates and nasty player base hold everything back.
  15. Jan 16, 2018
    1
    If you are a girl playing this game is Okay until you reject the advances of other players. They get mad at you and yell at you for doing everything wrong. I rate this 4 star cause my brother play with me as well and they treat him poorly. They yell at him say he no good. Laugh at him. He is only 10 years old and is lvl 1. Some American players need to grow up and act more mature.If you are a girl playing this game is Okay until you reject the advances of other players. They get mad at you and yell at you for doing everything wrong. I rate this 4 star cause my brother play with me as well and they treat him poorly. They yell at him say he no good. Laugh at him. He is only 10 years old and is lvl 1. Some American players need to grow up and act more mature. Developers seem to do nothing about this. So sad. This game is only as good as the game play. For my brother I can not give higher score. Expand
  16. Jan 17, 2018
    0
    I bought this game for my young daughter and thought nothing of this game until one night I came home to see my daughter crying on her bed. I thought it was typical teenage drama and that she had broken up with her boyfriend , But discovered later that it was because of a player pilot yelling at her through the mic that caused her to cry. I found out the story from my daughter thatI bought this game for my young daughter and thought nothing of this game until one night I came home to see my daughter crying on her bed. I thought it was typical teenage drama and that she had broken up with her boyfriend , But discovered later that it was because of a player pilot yelling at her through the mic that caused her to cry. I found out the story from my daughter that everything was okay with the game until one day she reject another player and that pilot player got mad and screamed at her through the microphone as other players did nothing! I reported this game but I later found out in the hidden in the negative reviews that this is normal and nothing is done about this. When i report they say they will look into the player, but I still see him play even today! I learned my lesson the hard way ! A game like this can cause emotional trauma that can stay with a person for a long time. Maybe Muse are understaffed or maybe they just don't care but the emotional damage is the same. As a parent I beg you to protect your children and do not buy or support any games from this company. Expand
  17. Jan 18, 2018
    1
    Yo here is the real lo down about this game. It is whack! I played for a few mins and I hear sum guy hollering at another player and then a shouting match starts. I was like are you for real ? Wow drama level 10! Peace out not worth the money or time. Dont think they can even pay people to play this game. Maybe for a good laugh at hearing people holler at each other like like try hardYo here is the real lo down about this game. It is whack! I played for a few mins and I hear sum guy hollering at another player and then a shouting match starts. I was like are you for real ? Wow drama level 10! Peace out not worth the money or time. Dont think they can even pay people to play this game. Maybe for a good laugh at hearing people holler at each other like like try hard gangsters . I was like where is the regulators at? Nobody stepped in! It was cray cray. Expand
  18. Jan 18, 2018
    1
    This game is not fun to play at all. No players, No cooperation just yelling, Super long waiting times. Its a small miracle that this corporation is still alive. Also I did not like the fact that they decided to place advertisement in a paid game. Not cool.
  19. Aug 24, 2013
    4
    I really love the concept of this game, but the game-play is flawed. The game is simple too plain for three different classes. Every ship can carry 4 people, often a captain, gunner and 2 engineers. I played engineer most of the time, since they need them the most. As an engineer you can have 3 tools, wrench for repairing and rebuilding, buff-hammer and something to put the fire out. YouI really love the concept of this game, but the game-play is flawed. The game is simple too plain for three different classes. Every ship can carry 4 people, often a captain, gunner and 2 engineers. I played engineer most of the time, since they need them the most. As an engineer you can have 3 tools, wrench for repairing and rebuilding, buff-hammer and something to put the fire out. You simple running around whacking on the ship-part that needs to be repaired, rebuild, buffed or extinguished. This gets so boring, so fast. The tactics as an engineer is nihil. One engineer repairs one part of the ship the other whacks on the other parts. You can play with all your buddies and fly with multiple ships in deathmatch 2v2 or 3v3, but i can't think of a reason ever recommending this game to a buddy. Expand
  20. Jul 23, 2013
    3
    A game that could have been great but ruined by the learning curve and incredibly rude player base. The tutorials teach you the bare minimum with no information about how the different matches work. The player base must be the second rudest I've come across (beaten only by Eve Online.) People yell at you for repairing things, for not repairing things, for buffing things, for notA game that could have been great but ruined by the learning curve and incredibly rude player base. The tutorials teach you the bare minimum with no information about how the different matches work. The player base must be the second rudest I've come across (beaten only by Eve Online.) People yell at you for repairing things, for not repairing things, for buffing things, for not buffing things. I've had strings of profanity thrown at me for daring to buff a gun that someone was using. Not at all the welcome a person on their 1st or 2nd match needs.

    Appearance wise, the game is nice enough and has some scenic moments. The graphics clip often and the sound can skip when too much is going on.

    In short the game is not release worthy and not welcoming to new players. Keep away.
    Expand
  21. Aug 2, 2013
    0
    This game proved to be unplayable. I started it up assuming it was going to work but it kept trying to connect to the server. Then I troubleshooted. I turned of Windows Firewall, opened the right UDP ports, re-installed the game, and I tried to get in the lobby probably 15 times overall. I looked on the forums. I sent an email to the developers about it (who care about their customers andThis game proved to be unplayable. I started it up assuming it was going to work but it kept trying to connect to the server. Then I troubleshooted. I turned of Windows Firewall, opened the right UDP ports, re-installed the game, and I tried to get in the lobby probably 15 times overall. I looked on the forums. I sent an email to the developers about it (who care about their customers and respond to everyone) but they were unable to help me. They wanted me to do a bunch of stuff in order to see what the problem could be. I have never actually played the game and it has caused me at least an hour of trouble. I don't have ANY time for that, and I never want to set foot on a game made by these people ever again. A game needs to work- and this game won't. Unacceptable. This game deserves my zero star rating. Expand
  22. Jan 19, 2018
    1
    30 Mins of waiting for a game. Played maybe a few times but the game is complicated and the player that have been playing for years are very rude. Very unbalanced game and Rude players in the game. Muse does nothing about the rude behavior so it grows. Not worth spending money on a game that will go free to play for survival. Only 20 players online! If you buy this game you will feel30 Mins of waiting for a game. Played maybe a few times but the game is complicated and the player that have been playing for years are very rude. Very unbalanced game and Rude players in the game. Muse does nothing about the rude behavior so it grows. Not worth spending money on a game that will go free to play for survival. Only 20 players online! If you buy this game you will feel cheated when you can not get a game. Expand
  23. Jan 19, 2018
    0
    This game is has hardly anyone playing it. Muse has a horrible track record of producing inferior games. The gameplay is loaded with advertisement to buy their other alliance game. This game feels cheaply made. You fly around shoot or ram or die game over. As for the social atmosphere of the game there are no forms of protection from predatory players. The players are troll tastic! TheyThis game is has hardly anyone playing it. Muse has a horrible track record of producing inferior games. The gameplay is loaded with advertisement to buy their other alliance game. This game feels cheaply made. You fly around shoot or ram or die game over. As for the social atmosphere of the game there are no forms of protection from predatory players. The players are troll tastic! They judge quickly and are very tribal minded. Maybe that is why they have problems with player retention. http://steamcharts.com/app/209080 So even if you do purchase the game, you will feel angry when you find out you have hardly anyone to play against. Expand
  24. Jan 19, 2018
    0
    I have to agree with famous vetted critics like XGN that the game was a decent idea executed very very poorly. Bug, lag, and balance issue plague the game and troll and cancerous players are what kill the game. If express any dissatisfaction with the game, the player base will send you and your friends hate mail. Check out the GOI forums to see how baddy things can get. These will beI have to agree with famous vetted critics like XGN that the game was a decent idea executed very very poorly. Bug, lag, and balance issue plague the game and troll and cancerous players are what kill the game. If express any dissatisfaction with the game, the player base will send you and your friends hate mail. Check out the GOI forums to see how baddy things can get. These will be the player that you will be playing with. Not very fun getting told off while learning this complicated game. Expand
  25. Jan 19, 2018
    0
    The Metacritic rating for these games tend to be dead right except this one. This game is way too high when it comes to user score. I have to agree with many of the recent critics that this is really a Stress Management tool disguised as a game. The players while playing the game can curse, and make racial slurs. They say anything they like to each other with no one monitors on theThe Metacritic rating for these games tend to be dead right except this one. This game is way too high when it comes to user score. I have to agree with many of the recent critics that this is really a Stress Management tool disguised as a game. The players while playing the game can curse, and make racial slurs. They say anything they like to each other with no one monitors on the voice chat. The game has large advertisement to up sell the customers when they log in. The tutorial is lacking and matchmaking is a joke. You will get pitted against a Diehard Veteran player while your side has only new players. The old players fix that matches so all of the experienced players are on one side. No amount of teamwork will get you to win. The game takes many many hours to learn. Not worth the money, time and energy. Expand
  26. Jan 20, 2018
    0
    If I got the game for free I wouldn't care. I payed money for this a few years ago and still hate it. I regret putting the little time and money I did in to this game. It was free because it was dead. It died because it's bad. Simply put, atl+f4 made for the best Guns of Icarus experience I've ever had. Uninstalling the game was more gratifying than the game-play.
  27. Aug 5, 2020
    3
    Hello everyone, I am the most impressive Gordoth Enodious, a classy gentleman who has played the best Steampunk game in the world (Arcanum) and I am talking about another steampunk game on this day. That game is Guns of Icarus.

    Simple review details - I rank games on an out of 10 basis, granting up to 3 points in 3 categories, as well as a last, single point from my own self, depending
    Hello everyone, I am the most impressive Gordoth Enodious, a classy gentleman who has played the best Steampunk game in the world (Arcanum) and I am talking about another steampunk game on this day. That game is Guns of Icarus.

    Simple review details - I rank games on an out of 10 basis, granting up to 3 points in 3 categories, as well as a last, single point from my own self, depending on my experience with it. Also, I am a gameplay designer and a writer so I got the credentials to talk ****

    Gameplay

    Guns of Icarus is an interesting game, in the sense that it is based around being played by a team of people, who need to communicate a lot so as to operate an airship and keep it afloat, while also firing their weapons at other teams like themselves.
    There are 3 types of playable classes - Gunners, Engineers and Pilots.
    The Pilots can navigate the airships and wield one tool. Most of the game, for a Pilot, is spent moving the ship about and battling the controls whilst praying that the relatively unresponsive vessel at their hands does move in a manner somewhat similar to what the player wants. Ship mobility is very, very limited, in the sense that it is very difficult and quite lacking in enjoyment. The movements appear to be simulating a realistic manner of motion for a floating air-bubble based airship, but the sheer fact of the matter is that this aspect of the game is very, very unappealing, even though I could see myself enjoying it a lot more if there was around 25% extra maneuverability added to the navigation of an airship.
    The Gunners have 4 ammunition options and get bonuses to how well they can man the guns of the ship, while wielding 2 tools. Playing as a Gunner is one of the more enjoyable things the player can do whilst experiencing Guns of Icarus Online, as the gunplay, even though not inclusive of handheld firearms, is quite decent. There are different types of guns, each having their own type of firing, with different projectiles and varying missile speeds. Gunners need to focus on shooting down the enemy ships.
    The Engineers have 4 tools and can sprint around the ship. The Engineer’s main task is to keep all the facilities of the airship operational, so as to avoid losing some, or all, of the ship’s ability to move, fight or even stay afloat. Engineer gameplay revolves around them running around the ship and applying different solutions to damaged machinery, be it through extinguishing fires or repairing said machinery by banging it with a hammer.
    All three of the playable classes need to work in unison to keep the ship operational and to wipe out enemy ships. The game is very good on paper, but the fact of the matter is that the implementation could have used a lot more work.

    The dependency on teamwork, the flaws in each class’ opportunities to perform and the evident lack of balance when it comes to the impact of each class make this a very disappointing experience. It’s good in concept, but it is not executed all that well. 1/3

    Presentation
    The game is a 3D, First Person walking simulator with First Person Shooter Turret Section influences. As such, it features a 3D world with well done modeling and nicely applied textures. The music is very lackluster, as there felt to be just 3 or 4 tracks that looped on and on, but the title screen song is quite nice, reminiscent of that wondrous melody that plays when one boots up Arcanum.
    The theme of the game is quite nice, as I personally enjoy it greatly. Steampunk is close enough to fantasy and distant enough from modernity that it is a meld of both, although Guns of Icarus is, as hinted at by its name, much more inspired by modernity than it lets on. The look of the game is relatively stylized, which is not a bad thing, but the environments are just dreadfully drab and boring. A desert. A ruined city. A coast with crashed ships. And each has one color associated with it. Orange for the desert. Dark green for the ruined city. Muted blue for the coast with crashed ships. 2/3

    Story
    he story of Guns of Icarus goes as follows:
    Industrial revolution began but mankind is bad so they did war and everything went to **** But there’s like a bunch of factions that remained and now they are going to war with each other again. There is no story to speak of, none whatsoever, although, in defence of the game, it is, supposedly, a Simulation game… But also an Adventure game. Alas, a tiny amount of story, when the premise is what it has been so far, would not do any good, as far as I am concerned. 0/3

    Legendary Point
    Does this game-- No.
    It does not. It could have - if the gameplay was a bit smoother, if there was more to it. Alas, there ain’t much more to it.

    Conclusion
    3/10. It's a disappointment with a promising concept, and I do not recommend it.
    Check out my tumblr, better reviews. 5k andy lel bby mode
    Expand
Metascore
64

Mixed or average reviews - based on 7 Critic Reviews

Critic score distribution:
  1. Positive: 1 out of 7
  2. Negative: 0 out of 7
  1. May 19, 2013
    65
    There is some fun to be had with this game, and there is definitely a lot of potential given how the game is still evolving even though you can play it now.
  2. Nov 30, 2012
    60
    It's good to see there are still developers who dare to try something different. Because let's be honest..how many zeppelin sims are out there now? Exactly. Guns of Icarus Online offers a fun concept, working together with some random players on a flying fortress, trying to defend it from other, similar foes. Bugs and lag cause major disappointment however. That's a shame, because the idea is great. Let's hope a great amount of patches will deal with these problems.
  3. Nov 16, 2012
    73
    Despite its visual beauty and impressive execution, limited gameplay and general bugginess hold everything back. This beast has room to grow. When it does, expect great things. For now, a little turbulence makes for a bumpy ride.