I think that the main problem with the direction FFXI is going is that the game is only appealing to veterans, specifically the elitist or hardcore FFXI gamers. While FFXI is trying to improve its new player base by giving incentives, the problem is that the new players are alienated from the rest of the players. FFXI has a step learning curve after level 15 and XP grinding is very hard orI think that the main problem with the direction FFXI is going is that the game is only appealing to veterans, specifically the elitist or hardcore FFXI gamers. While FFXI is trying to improve its new player base by giving incentives, the problem is that the new players are alienated from the rest of the players. FFXI has a step learning curve after level 15 and XP grinding is very hard or long without a party or tome burn party until level 30 and even then, new players can't readily access abyssea areas without doing prerequisites quest. I'm not alone on this, most veterans know that new players are screwed nowdays because new players do not have any sort of assistance from veterans nor do veterans party with newer players anymore because their characters are all maxed after abyssea xp parties. It is very sad to watch a new player enter FFXI because you will know that the person is screwed. I'm not saying that there is no hope because linkshells do typically help people but linkshells cannot help people they do not meet and new people are in Wings of the Goddess areas and linkshells are either in Jeuno or Seekers of Adoulin areas.
In terms of end game content, I think the game has direction left. The only thing keeping this game going is equipment rivalry between the elitist players. Some dreams such as obtaining level 90-99 empyrian weapons are hopeless because the population base can't even support voidwatchs anymore. In a period of half a year, specifically March 2013 to December 2013, the population across all servers have dropped in half from an average of around 2000 persons logged on at a time to 1000 persons and even so, roughly 5%-10% of them are just bots fishing for gil.
The gear from Seekers of Adoulin are extremely overpowered, for example you could a entry level SoA weapon makes level 90 empyreans look like wooden weapons. Black mages can solo liar reives all by themselves and within a short amount of time. The problem with this is that it gives no chance for weaker players to even accumulate points and the process which you get these points is extremely boring. In abyssea, FFXI had a great idea to make the process which you obtain gear party based such that each party member was seeking a certain item and that they unified in order to achieve that common goal and that different roles were a necessity.
Content wise, the three abyssea addons were way better than Seekers of Adoulin.… Expand