Metascore
77

Generally favorable reviews - based on 7 Critic Reviews

Critic score distribution:
  1. Positive: 5 out of 7
  2. Negative: 0 out of 7
  1. May 11, 2026
    85
    Call of the Elder Gods is a fabulous sequel to Call of the Sea that manages to be even more interesting for those who enjoy cosmic horror, environmental puzzles, and mystery stories with the flavor of pulp literature, tabletop RPGs, and impossible archaeology. It improves on its predecessor in every way: in length (it’s somewhat longer), in its number of different locations, characters, narrative, script, technical quality, and, above all, in the variety, mechanics, and depth of its puzzles.
  2. May 11, 2026
    82
    Call of the Elder Gods sticks to its formula of pure adventure—no action—with a wide variety of puzzles and situations that keep you hooked from start to finish... though its gameplay style may not be for everyone. But if it clicks with you, get ready for a fun challenge.
  3. May 11, 2026
    80
    Beautiful and mysterious, Call of the Elder Gods is a must-play for any fan of puzzle games. It might not be quite as good as its predecessor in terms of story and setting, but it's still absolutely worth your time, as long as you've got your thinking cap on.
  4. May 16, 2026
    78
    Call of the Elder Gods proves to be a convincing sequel to that Call of the Sea, which delighted players a few years ago. The strength of this adventure lies in its fantastic Lovecraftian narrative, which proves engaging and up to expectations. Adding variety to the dynamics is a puzzle gameplay system that is decidedly satisfying and intuitive, even though it may cause serious difficulty on more than one occasion (fortunately, the difficulty is scalable, in a sense). Building on excellent foundations, the second chapter of this saga (which we recommend you experience in full) presents us with a new fork in the road that leaves a door open (but we won't say anything more) and puts two endings in front of us to discover, even though they will essentially head in the same direction. Even though Call of the Elder Gods was designed as an experience aimed at everyone, we are sure that those who have already played Call of the Sea will be able to delve more deeply into this worthy little piece of the Lovecraft universe.
  5. May 12, 2026
    75
    Thanks to a generous hint system and another excellent story, Call of the Elder Gods, is a puzzle game that everyone can enjoy.
  6. ScreenHub
    May 12, 2026
    70
    Ultimately, between the two, I prefer Call of the Sea. It’s a more cohesive game with a stronger story. But Call of the Elder Gods is a worthwhile follow-up, one that offers similarly challenging puzzles with satisfying solutions. If you enjoyed the first game, this call’s worth heeding, too.
  7. May 11, 2026
    70
    Call of the Elder Gods is a decent enough game, but its storytelling and puzzle design leaves a little to be desired.

There are no user reviews yet.