Todd McCarthy
Select another critic »For 1,835 reviews, this critic has graded:
-
49% higher than the average critic
-
2% same as the average critic
-
49% lower than the average critic
On average, this critic grades 2.5 points lower than other critics.
(0-100 point scale)
Todd McCarthy's Scores
- Movies
- TV
| Average review score: | 63 | |
|---|---|---|
| Highest review score: | Mulholland Dr. | |
| Lowest review score: | Showgirls | |
Score distribution:
-
Positive: 947 out of 1835
-
Mixed: 724 out of 1835
-
Negative: 164 out of 1835
1835
movie
reviews
- By Date
- By Critic Score
-
- Todd McCarthy
With the combination of mobster characters and heavily R&B, hip-hop and disco/soul tune orientation of the soundtrack, pic has a more streetwise feel than most animated fare, which is not to say that it has street smarts.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Ewan McGregor’s directorial debut, in which he also stars, is decently performed and delivers some potent scenes of inter-generational discord between a concerned father and a radicalized daughter who becomes a murderous terrorist. But the filmmaking is prosaic when it should crackle with tension and disruptive undercurrents,- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Sep 13, 2016
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Robinson's script is alive to the material's literary roots, although there is a sense that the brakes have been applied so as not to push into territory perceived as too esoteric for American teenagers.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Odd mixture of ultra-sleek visuals, psychological probing, "Paper Moon"-like father-daughter swindling, self-improvement efforts and abrupt tough-guy stuff keeps the picture percolating, even if it seems too artificial to genuinely convince on an emotional or dramatic level.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Craig Zobel effectively sets all its surface parts in motion but, crucially, doesn’t sufficiently develop that turbulent undercurrents of tension and intrigue that are called for in the hothouse circumstances.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Jan 31, 2015
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Director Rob Cohen has pulled together a simple yarn of an itinerant dragonslayer who decides to team with his prey to rid the land of an evil ruler who has betrayed them both. Tale’s poignancy stems from the fact that fire-breathing, armor-plated, high-flying creature is the last of its kind; when he dies, dragons will have passed entirely from Earth.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Elaborate, sporadically amusing but awfully lightweight followup, which has close to the same tone as its predecessor but makes one realize that freshness had a lot to do with its impact.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Although The Postman conveys a thoroughly imagined vision of a future society, its basic concerns are actually far from those of traditional sci-fi, as it quickly comes to feel more like a Western than anything else.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
The doc swells with wonderful archival footage that immerses you in the hedonistic environment the principals occupied, but in ranging wide it somehow doesn’t go deep, or at least deep enough, into its twin protagonists to satisfy as the full story.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted May 22, 2019
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Highlighted by a strong and sensual performance from Salma Hayek as the doomed heroine, elegant pic's muted quality and the central character's vexingly contrary behavior will keep auds from connecting with characters who themselves have trouble establishing bonds.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
This paean to youthful irresponsibility applies the right crude and rude 'tude to its bulging sack of gags to have the desired effect on its target audience.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Feb 28, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
A heaping serving of metaphysical gobbledygook wrapped in a physically striking package.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
A minor affair, a confection based on dalliances and the way a set of sophisticated theater people handle them, that lacks true distinction.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
The blood and grunge run thick on the mean streets in Romeo Is Bleeding. This heavy dose of ultra-violent neo-noir gives Gary Oldman a face-first trip through the gutter that would make Mickey Rourke drool, but the far-fetched plotting eventually goes so far over the top that pic flirts with inventing a new genre of film noir camp. Gramercy release will find a cadre of devotees who will groove on the hot cast, high style and low-down macho fantasies, but more people will be turned off by the excessive gore and progressive facetiousness.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
There is a trumped-up quality to the action climaxes that is disappointingly perfunctory, and the story's final revelation is simultaneously far-fetched and unsurprising.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Intelligent scripting, solid thesping and eye-catching location shooting aren't enough to make a compelling modern film of The Painted Veil.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Mildly engaging but very far from being for 50 Cent what "8 Mile" was for Eminem, this lurchingly structured story of survival against the odds looks to get off to a strong start thanks to the singer's large following.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Stories of resistance to oppression will never become obsolete, but this feels like a picture that should have been made a long time ago.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
After lightly going through the motions of a plot, it all ends up in the quarry, where assorted machinery provides the excuse for a parade of slapstick gags and amusement park-like predicaments that seem mostly lumbering.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
The mildly engaging silliness of its premise is never transformed into something more substantial, and the attempt at a fine-tuned "Clueless"-like tone is only sputteringly achieved.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
The central premise is arresting, as is the style, but there's a lot more that could have been done with it than just show how one ill-defined individual instantly opts to join his country's lowest form of life.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Jul 24, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
A film of gorgeous surfaces and negligible emotional resonance, this third rendition of a perennial sentimental favorite is easy on the eyes and has its share of beguiling moments in the early going, but crucially lacks a compelling climax and any sense of urgency in its storytelling.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
A desperately slight romantic comedy marked by contrived romance and little comedy.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Cheesy homage to a level of horniness Austin Powers could only imagine will be a dream movie for many a teenage boy.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
A purist's delight, something the millions of die-hard fans of his Lord of the Rings trilogy will gorge upon. In pure movie terms, however, it's also a bit of a slog, with an inordinate amount of exposition and lack of strong forward movement...There are elements in this new film that are as spectacular as much of the Rings trilogy was, but there is much that is flat-footed and tedious as well, especially in the early going.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Dec 3, 2012
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
A creepy, well-acted story of contagious evil, Apt Pupil has more than enough chilling dramatic scenes to rivet the attention but suffers from some hokey contrivances and underlying insufficiencies of motivation.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Despite a sensationally attractive cast and an array of well-staged combat scenes presented on a vast scale, Wolfgang Petersen's highly telescoped rendition of the Trojan War lurches ahead in fits and starts for much of its hefty running time, to OK effect.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Jewish and academically inclined audiences worldwide will respond to numerous aspects of this unusual drama, although it is paradoxically both too broad and too esoteric for the general art house public.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Mar 4, 2012
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
A witty and sometimes surreal sci-fi comedy, Men in Black is a wild knuckleball of a movie that keeps dancing in and out of the strike zone.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
A comprehensive, personal and surprisingly engaging look at how film crews routinely work hours far beyond anything that can be considered safe, healthy or conducive to a balanced life.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
The only problem is that the great majority of screen time is devoted to the kind of loutish, drunken, small-minded, confrontational macho posturing that, in assorted ethnic stripes, has been paraded across the screen innumerable times in recent years.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Decked out with sharp and colorful design work, some well-drawn characters and six snappy Randy Newman tunes, this first entry from Turner Feature Animation goes down very easily but lacks a hook to make it anything other than a minor kidpic entry commercially.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Although there is incident in the film's second half...it doesn't build to the level of compelling drama, leaving the film in a quiet, temperate realm that scarcely makes the pulse race.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Mar 26, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Although uneven and too deliberately obscure in meaning to be entirely satisfying, result remains sufficiently intriguing and startling to bring many of Lynch's old fans back on board for this careening ride.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
It is far from unpleasant to watch an attractive cast led by Kirsten Dunst parading around Versailles accoutered in Milena Canonero's luxuriant costumes to the accompaniment of catchy pop tunes. But the writer-director's follow-up to her breakthrough second feature, "Lost in Translation," is no more nourishing than a bonbon.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Swicord took on a daunting challenge in adapting this piece, and she’s met it more intelligently than convincingly. It would have been asking a lot from any actor to carry this film, and Cranston has done the heavy lifting and more.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Apr 24, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
But the film also has its turgid, dialogue-heavy stretches, and the leading performances, if acceptable, are not everything they needed to be to fully flesh out these elegant immortals.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
From a sensory point of view, the film is a pleasure, the images having been manipulated in various ways to evocative effect, Anderson’s voiceovers proving more amusing than not, and the music taking mostly lively turns.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Sep 16, 2015
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Intensely self-conscious of its status as a cultural commodity even as it devotedly follows the requisite playbook for mass-audience blockbuster fare, Jurassic World can reasonably lay claim to the number two position among the four series entries, as it goes down quite a bit easier than the previous two sequels.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Jun 10, 2015
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
"Chinatown" it ain't, not in any department. On its own level, however, new pic generates a reasonable degree of intrigue.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
The lead performances have power, whereas pictorially the film is pretty rough and ordinary.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Jul 18, 2016
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
A feel-good film about death, a sitcom about mortality, "Ikiru" for meatheads. It's also a picture about two cancer patients confronting reality, and deciding how they want to spend their presumed last days, that has not an ounce of reality about it.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
In its considered, neatly packaged way, the film occupies a safe and solid middle-class middle ground in teen storyland, between crass gross-out comedies and mawkish romance on one side and edgy, exploratory indie fare on the other.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Jul 5, 2015
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
After creating such promise through the intriguing setup of stunning twin vampires in trendy, nocturnal Gotham, it’s disappointing that Almereyda develops narrative butterfingers, letting the storyline become too diffuse and cutting among too many principal characters.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
It doesn’t have Jack Nicholson, Stanley Kubrick or even much of the Overlook Hotel, but Rebecca Ferguson and other good actors provide some shine of their own in Doctor Sleep, a drawn-out and seldom pulse-quickening follow-up to The Shining that still has enough going on to forestall any audience slumber.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Oct 30, 2019
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Colaizzo’s dialogue often crackles with modern idioms and good pithy comments, flowing from the distinct characters in easy fashion. As a director, he’s paced the action well. He knows what he’s doing, even when he’s doing the wrong thing.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Jan 30, 2019
- Read full review
-
- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Sep 15, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Francis Ford Coppola's take on the Dracula legend is a bloody visual feast. Both the most extravagant screen telling of the oft-filmed story and the one most faithful to its literary source, this rendition sets grand romantic goals for itself that aren't fulfilled emotionally, and it is gory without being at all scary.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
LaBute has had middling success at best, having come up with a passably engaging time-jumping romantic melodrama that at least grapples seriously with one of the novel's most potent themes.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
While this John Singleton-directed sequel provides a breezy enough joyride, it lacks the unassuming freshness and appealing neighborhood feel of the economy-priced original.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
It is unfortunate when such a difficult, ambitious film doesn't quite pay off after building up so much solid credit, but that is the case here. It is possible that the nature of the history under consideration is as responsible for this as any other single factor.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Apart from startling, out-there comic turns by Robert Downey Jr. and Tom Cruise, however, the antics here are pretty thin, redundant and one-note.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
The generational mix of actors works well enough, although Campbell too often seems stranded with little to do until the climax.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Apr 21, 2011
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Serves up enough goofy pranks and fractured wordplay to keep the series purring along.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
A story very much by, about and for middle-aged men, and with the commercial limitations that implies, this intermittently amusing outing is graced by one of Robert De Niro’s more engaging performances of recent vintage.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
An oddly schizophrenic fantasy thriller that ultimately succumbs to a fatal case of sentimentality.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
A labor of love, to be sure, but a simple, small-scaled domestic drama with none of the broad appeal of the hugely popular "Shakespeare in Love" of 1998, this thoroughly respectable Sony Classics pickup will command the interest mostly of older-skewing art house habituees.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Dec 21, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
It's good to see Schwarzenegger doing his thing again after what, for him, was a long sabbatical.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
More than the film that surrounds him, Jack Black is worth the price of admission in Bernie, an oddball May-December true life crime story that would have profited from being a whole lot darker and full-bodied than it is.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Apr 21, 2012
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Frozen 2 has everything you would expect — catchy new songs, more time with easy-to-like characters, striking backdrops, cute little jokes, a voyage of discovery plot and female empowerment galore — except the unexpected.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Nov 14, 2019
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Director David Gordon Green’s latest unpredictable addition to his resume is offbeat and appealing on some levels but is neither as funny nor as trenchant as it might have been.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Sep 12, 2015
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Brad Pitt delivers a capable performance in an immersive apocalyptic spectacle about a global zombie uprising.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Jun 4, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
This Spanish-lingo farce plays very much like an SNL sketch. The only problem is that it packs about as many laughs into its 85 minutes as a good skit does in eight or 10.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Mar 12, 2012
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Lovingly and knowledgeably made by director Tony Bill, who got his pilot's license as a teenager, pic nonetheless has a lightweight, airbrushed feel; despite the brutal dogfights and inevitable deaths, there's little gravity or resonance.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Lacks narrative push...atmospheric drama that casts a minor but distinctive spell.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
The opposition of the two dramas winds up in gratifyingly moral and philosophical territory.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Often a gutsy, intelligent writer, Toback has yet to prove himself decisively as a director, and this, his first fictional effort behind the camera in a decade, shows his talents to be as variable as ever.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
The pain feels cushioned and secondhand, the characters are not terribly sympathetic or interesting other than for their misfortune, and the film shows little interest in analyzing the situation other than to point fingers at greedy CEOs.- Variety
- Posted Dec 8, 2010
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
First-time scripter Paul Bernbaum's framing story, designed to stir up suspicion that George Reeves was a murder victim rather than a suicide, unfortunately proves far less intriguing than does the melancholy tale of a limited actor reaching the end of the line during a transitional period in Hollywood.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
The homily-laden wrap-up, stressing the upside of bad days, is enough to make you hold your nose, but it only lasts a moment, which is suggestive of the way Arteta and the cast provide the energy and momentum to get the job done but not overstay their welcome.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Oct 2, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Although well made and acted, the real question surrounding this microscopic look at men enduring the severe pressure of trench warfare is what relevance it may have for a modern audience. The answer is, probably not much.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Mar 12, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
There is unquestionably enough lively material here to snare one’s attention but, even at just 76 minutes, many will feel that this cruise has gone on plenty long enough.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Picture is impressively crafted and acted but far too narrowly and benignly conceived to satisfy even on its own terms.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
This is one of those pictures that unavoidably becomes part of the zeitgeist due to its coincidental arrival at a precise moment in history when its themes play into current events.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Compensating for the technical faults is the writer-director's unmistakable and undiluted need to express the issues he feels are at the heart of his community.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Takes plenty of liberties with the material and never generates much genuine excitement, but provides an agreeable ride without overloading it with contemporary filmmaking mannerisms.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
A tasty if wildly far-fetched thriller, Out of Time proves far stronger in its characterizations than in developing genuine suspense.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Neither the establishing dramatic linchpin nor the final conversion of conscience is terribly convincing, leaving this pared-down rendition of the original work diminished in power and meaning as well.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
The picture is lacking in the uproarious humor that might well have ensued from the material, which instead inspires occasional laughs but, much more often, bemused fascination and wonderment at the bizarre imaginations and impressive skill of the filmmakers.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
A cocoon of somber self-seriousness envelopes some fine performances and intelligent craftsmanship in Nell.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Eventually, the impression is created of notes for good scenes full of pungent observations and sharp asides, but without fully developed drama or emotion, leaving a sketchy, wispy feeling when all is said and done.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Less turgid and aggravating than its predecessor, this cleverly produced melodrama remains hamstrung by novelist's Dan Brown's laborious connect-the-dots plotting and the filmmakers' prosaic literal-mindedness in the face of ripe historical antagonisms, mystery and intrigue.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
It’s hard to detect a strong raison d’etre behind Sofia Coppola’s slow-to-develop melodrama.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted May 24, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
A generic suspenser that doesn't taste bad at first bite but becomes increasingly hard to swallow, The Saint comes off more as a pallid imitation of Paramount's Eurothriller "Mission: Impossible" than as anything resembling the further adventures of Leslie Charteris' charming rogue.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
The sense of evil overkill is entirely representative of the picture itself, which repeatedly looks ready to blow all its fuses due to sensory overload.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
A dash of showbiz pizzazz has been lost but some welcome emotional depth has been gained in the big-screen version of the still-thriving theatrical smash Jersey Boys.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Jun 16, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
This action-drenched roller-coaster of a film tries to have its cake and eat it too when it comes to generating a tidal wave of violence — but it undeniably delivers the goods when it comes to action and impudence.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Mar 11, 2020
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Design aspects are arresting and the filmmaker's abilities are obvious, but the basic survival story remains slight, just as the general setting, no matter how artfully imagined, is by now pretty familiar.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
This is a wannabe shocker with a clever premise that doesn't really get down and dirty or betray the base instincts of a born horror filmmaker.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Nov 13, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
A tad crasser and pushier than its predecessor, Ice Age: The Meltdown is still an entirely serviceable follow-up to the 2002 hit that will thoroughly amuse kids and get a rise or two out of parents as well.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Promised Land presents its environmental concerns in a clear, upfront manner but hits some narrative and character bumps in the second half that weaken the impact of this fundamentally gentle, sympathetic work.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Dec 7, 2012
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
A resourceful, if rather hyperbolic documentary that devotes 90 minutes to analyzing one of the most famous scenes in film history.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Oct 12, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
A picture that, even more than the previous two, feels like a bunch of gags tossed together. The laughs are here, to be sure, although even some of the best of them are retreads and the Swinging '60s recycling act is now feeling a bit past its zeitgeist prime.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Unswervingly sincere and dramatic without surprise or revelation, screenwriter Joe Eszterhas' longtime pet project may be personal, but it offers little to audiences that hasn't been served up in quantity in the past.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2 plays like a second ride on a roller-coaster that was a real kick the first time around but feels very been-there/done-that now.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Apr 24, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
One of the more absorbing and palatable entries in the rather disreputable "Death Wish"-style self-appointed vigilante sub-genre.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
A crudely funny farce that covers no new ground but sees its talented players running some surefire plays.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
A mostly standard-issue latter-day Arnold Schwarzenegger actioner spiked with a creepily plausible cloning angle.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
From a performance p.o.v., Aselton and Shepard hold the screen well and are most watchable, and Aselton does a fluid directing job within the limited challenge she set for herself production-wise.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Brandishes physical verisimilitude and intelligent seriousness but proves unable to really get inside its chameleon-like central character.- Variety
- Read full review