Robert K. Elder
Select another critic »For 245 reviews, this critic has graded:
-
66% higher than the average critic
-
2% same as the average critic
-
32% lower than the average critic
On average, this critic grades 5.1 points lower than other critics.
(0-100 point scale)
Robert K. Elder's Scores
- Movies
- TV
| Average review score: | 60 | |
|---|---|---|
| Highest review score: | The 39 Steps | |
| Lowest review score: | The Devil's Rejects | |
Score distribution:
-
Positive: 141 out of 245
-
Mixed: 55 out of 245
-
Negative: 49 out of 245
245
movie
reviews
-
- Robert K. Elder
What makes XX/XY so engaging; it attempts to define love through broken characters who know neither themselves nor the meaning of love.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
Against the rest of his dramatically flimsy crew, Snipes' sunglasses-at-midnight strut conveys an almost lifelike sheen. Almost. He's more alive than the movie, which is dead on arrival.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
Stands as a successful cinematic experiment and a gripping -- though a little too long -- study of humanity's most primitive instincts.- Chicago Tribune
-
- Robert K. Elder
Whatever the film lacks in presentation, it makes up for in laughs and ensemble performances that sing.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
Viewed through the right lens, "My Date…" succeeds as a warm, heartfelt story about childhood crushes and the pursuit of lifelong dreams. (Through another, it's downright unnerving.)- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
An old-fashioned comedy. And in this case, "old-fashioned" means tired, out of date and so abominably blah that you'll fall asleep in your popcorn.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
Muddles through as a film so uninterested in character, it doesn't bother assigning names to them.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
Oscillates between pragmatist genius and B-movie mediocrity.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
It's a compelling drama, if only a little hollow. For my money, Pacino's bark is ultimately better than Two For the Money's bite.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
A talented craftsman of dark raillery, Day and his fixation on Hollywood melodrama are indulged to delicious effect in his sophomore effort.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
A confusing and not entirely believable ending clouds the issue, though, burying some fine performances and cinematography under an avalanche of gore and plot twists.- Chicago Tribune
-
- Robert K. Elder
The notion that stories are the lies that tell the truth isn't new -- even Shakespeare knew that -- but the central conceit of "let's save lives by putting on a play" seems not only artificial, but also hollow.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
A master of atmosphere, Japanese director Takashi Shimizu leads his audience along on a celluloid leash to his pitch-black attic of horror, inviting each hair on the back of your neck to stand up.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
Plays like an amateur debut effort written over a weekend during which its writer wasn't entirely sober.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
Plot doesn't matter much here, as Scary Movie 3 exists solely to reference and lampoon other movies, in this case "The Ring," "Signs " and "8 Mile."- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
Exploits the epidemic of kidnapping in Venezuela without offering solutions or insight--only sophomoric platitudes. Jakubowicz's talents as a filmmaker are many, but crafting an articulate, well-examined social theory isn't among them.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
Is it a political movie? Yes. A movie with strong ideas and issues? Yes. But propaganda with its heart in the right place is still propaganda, and seldom easy to watch.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
This sequel succeeds as a slightly convoluted, paint-by-the-numbers buddy/action comedy with fast, funny banter and well-choreographed fight scenes.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
For all the whiz-bang visuals, however, "Little" could use a little consistency in tone.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
Black delivers the best line (“Do you want me to get naked and start the revolution?”), and Lithgow scores a giggle for calling his ex-wife “coyote ugly” to her face, but neither of them can disguise this lemon.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
Bobby Long can enchant you. It's a film that feels lived in, confident despite its conventions.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
Hits more laughs than it misses and its characters are likable, empathetic people.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
While sci-fi conceits still permeate the plot (alien DNA, rogue scientists), attention to personal detail float world-weary, superbly-drawn protagonists in a rare movie-a character-driven animated film.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
The beautifully shot but dramatically strained I Am David falls prey to the defect of all poor road movies: In gluing together unbelievable but convenient episodes with sugary sentimentality, it loses most of its credibility.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
Call it a weepy for the gay community:The Trip is an oddly marketed, oddly titled romance. Yes, there is a trip, but it takes place during the last 15 minutes of the film and seems almost tangential.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
It's a dense, winding tale with all of Sayles' razor-sharp dialogue and intrigue. But instead of tracing character paths, Sayles sacrifices solid storytelling in favor of forwarding a political (and environmental) ideology.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
If "Mean Girls" was Lohan's debutante ball, "Herbie" sits her back at the kiddie table. She's matured, and no longer fits in the Disney mold.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review