Robert K. Elder
Select another critic »For 245 reviews, this critic has graded:
-
66% higher than the average critic
-
2% same as the average critic
-
32% lower than the average critic
On average, this critic grades 5.1 points lower than other critics.
(0-100 point scale)
Robert K. Elder's Scores
- Movies
- TV
| Average review score: | 60 | |
|---|---|---|
| Highest review score: | The 39 Steps | |
| Lowest review score: | The Devil's Rejects | |
Score distribution:
-
Positive: 141 out of 245
-
Mixed: 55 out of 245
-
Negative: 49 out of 245
245
movie
reviews
-
- Robert K. Elder
If you can simply get lost in the crushing splendor of the waves themselves, the script might not leave you so seasick.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
After clawing their way into the Olympics, so-called extreme sports deserve respect, but this is no way to get it.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
Overnight's only narrative hole is an inability to pinpoint why Miramax stonewalled him.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
Resonates and inspires rapid-fire bouts of laughter, perhaps even a few giggles from the author himself, whom posterity has rewarded the last laugh.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
As a document of his history, it's breathtaking, inspiring stuff. As an overlong documentary, it still manages to be inspiring, but also an uphill viewing experience.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
Combining cutting-edge computer animation with traditional two-dimensional characters, Treasure Planet pops off the screen, reviving Stevenson's adventure with surprising accuracy.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
Shackles its characters with stale dialogue straight out of decades-old Sgt. Rock comic books.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
It's not revolutionary filmmaking. But Seducing Doctor Lewis sails by on charm and confident character acting, even if it's navigating well-charted waters.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
Ambitious, yes. Does it work? Not really. While it's genuinely cool to hear characters talk about early rap records (Sugar Hill Gang, etc.), the constant referencing of hip-hop arcana can alienate even the savviest audiences.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
Presented with such confidence, such care, that we love all of the characters, even if we don't like them.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
It's one thing for a script to set the framework for an action film -- it's quite another when the script gets in the way.- Chicago Tribune
-
- Robert K. Elder
McKee, like Amenabar, knows how to position his film against type -- which ultimately makes May a refreshing, macabre tale.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
Gets under your skin with laughs that are fast, slick and slippery and with visuals as vivid as anything this side of Demerol.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
Unlike the intrigue and winding switchback of moral mysteries that defined "L.A. Confidential," Dark Blue travels on flat, predictable terrain.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
There's much to love about this "Rocky" on horseback, and those laughable blemishes just fold into jokes that Helgeland likely intends audiences to laugh at.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
Stands a triumph of stunts over plot, of style over substance--of the wool we pull over our own eyes. It's brainless, high-speed, popcorn fun.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
About overcoming adversity and one's innermost fears. On this count, Paxton hits the ball squarely in capturing the psychology of his characters, but hooks it into the sand trap of effects and thematic overselling.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
Commits the cardinal sin of all bad IMAX films: It favors visuals over narrative, glitter over substance.- Chicago Tribune
-
- Robert K. Elder
Jakes' characters are points to be made, flesh and blood cautionary tales that don't particularly feel human. His dialogue, even in the mouths of Michelle and her troubled mother, sounds as if it comes straight from the pulpit.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
Limps along on a squirm-inducing fish-out-of-water formula that goes nowhere and goes there very, very slowly.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
The movie's computer-generated castles, magic visuals and sloppy effects echo a low-budget fantasy movie on cable. It's glossy, shiny candy that tastes oddly familiar yet lacks sugary punch.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
As an intentionally campy film, Girls Will Be Girls dips a cinematic toe into shark-infested waters. Not only must it operate on several levels-making us care for deeply flawed characters and laugh at their bitter lashings-it also has to carry a cohesive story arc. On this count, Girls Will Be Girls fizzles a bit.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
Sky Blue slows things down, creating a ponderous, almost languid movie-going experience.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review