Jack Mathews
Select another critic »For 1,391 reviews, this critic has graded:
-
49% higher than the average critic
-
3% same as the average critic
-
48% lower than the average critic
On average, this critic grades 5.7 points lower than other critics.
(0-100 point scale)
Jack Mathews' Scores
- Movies
- TV
| Average review score: | 60 | |
|---|---|---|
| Highest review score: | Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind | |
| Lowest review score: | Perception | |
Score distribution:
-
Positive: 810 out of 1391
-
Mixed: 296 out of 1391
-
Negative: 285 out of 1391
1391
movie
reviews
-
- Jack Mathews
A by-the-numbers, let's-put-on-a-show quasi-musical that has absolutely nothing going for it, except Alba.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
Allen was out of his element in creating characters who feel like East Coast cousins of the Clampetts, and his dialogue has never been more banal or forced.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
Despite the audience pandering -- not just in its violence, but in its wall-to-wall sexual vulgarity -- there are terrific elements in Baby Boy.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
Sitting through the film is punishing work. The jittery closeups create a response that is more physical (I'm thinking nausea) than emotional, and there are no respites.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
It's in French with French actors, but its film noir sensibilities have a filtered Hollywood vibe about them. In other words, it's pretty much a mess.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
Features some of the year's most beautiful scenery and two of its most wooden characters.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
Farrell, adding to the case for his impending stardom, locks into his role with the laser precision of the sniper's rifle scope.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
Amen is propelled by a most dubious assumption -- Gerstein's belief that if the German people knew of the Holocaust, they'd stop it.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
A guy flick, but I can't imagine many male viewers actually identifying with Elliot or his friends. The depression would be unbearable.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
The World has a pokey pace, but it presents a uniquely powerful look at the new big kid in the global economy.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
Has many of the qualities that made the actor such a great target for self-parody in Spike Jonze's "Being John Malkovich" - it's sober, deliberate, self-consciously mysterious and no fun at all.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
Sillier than it is clever, and Toback's self-indulgence is tiresome. He's a genuine auteur, all right, but his life and the funky tastes that inspire him are just not as interesting as he thinks they are.- New York Daily News
-
- Jack Mathews
Trying to resist Reese is like trying to resist Reese's Pieces: They're always the same but you can't help yourself.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
The source for Jieho Lee's The Air I Breathe is an ancient Chinese proverb about the four cornerstones of emotion - love, pleasure, happiness and sorrow. But Lee and co-writer Bob DeRosa went 0-4 with their convoluted screenplay, making me thankful they didn't try to adapt the Seven Deadly Sins.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
Notre Musique is a cry against war and man's inherent needs for tribalism and violence, a position that wouldn't start a good argument in a college cafeteria.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
There's an inherent distance between movies and their audiences that -- combined with the distance between 9/11 and today's opening of the film -- The Guys can't bridge.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
A vanity project by a moderately talented artist that has moments of real brilliance in it.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
D.O.A.P. would be more effective, and more entertaining, if it took a cue from "Dr. Strangelove" and used Sterling Hayden's paranoid, quick-triggered Brig. Gen. Jack D. Ripper as the model for Cheney to get more outlandish behavior from him.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
While I understand Vergès' oft-repeated claim that he wants to use these sensational cases to point out that the French were no better than the Nazis in their treatment of colonial subjects, it's impossible to overlook his glib dismissal of his clients' crimes and the smug righteousness that rests in the smirk constantly on his face.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
The Beat That My Heart Skipped has nonetheless brought attention to a nearly lost classic. For more than two decades, "Fingers" was not available on video or DVD and was rarely screened. But it's available now, and if you've never seen it, put it on your must-rent list immediately.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
The result is a long night of confrontations that feel heavily rehearsed and unlikely. There are some good moments, but I didn't believe any of this.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
Surely, this bloodthirsty comic farce about a sadistic backwoods family being hunted by a sadistic backwoods sheriff is the "Citizen Kane" of hix-ploitation horror.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
A combination ghost and shaggy dog story that is so well-made and acted you can nearly overlook its murky, unsatisfying ending.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
The movie never really comes alive, and Crialese's coyness with Lucy's character is more frustrating than mysterious.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
Looks stunning, but it's an ill-conceived mess that plays like two movies awkwardly spliced together. In one movie, parents are asked to stand by while the kids are entertained with cute animal tricks and slapstick pratfalls. In the other, the kids will be hushed while the parents are treated to inside jokes.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
Among the creepiest adult monologues you'll hear in a regular theater this year comes from Karen Young in Heading South, a well-acted but misguided tale of displaced sexual longing on the beaches of Baby Doc Duvalier's 1970s Haiti.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
The intimate love story is overwhelmed by the carnage. It may be an accurate picture of life in Medellin, but it's not convincing.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
The themes are about the power and consequences of sex, but the stories are too glib and episodic to leave any impression.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
It irks the ink out of me to see Lane exalted as a hero for doing what any responsible editor would do, then being paid to consult on his own canonization.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
The Czech Republic and Russia, the respective homes of Emil and Oleg, should sue.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
There is a vengeance motif that is worked out in a way that is both emotionally satisfying and completely unbelievable.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
It takes chutzpah to title this movie Déjà Vu; every scene in it rings a bell. Certainly, I had just seen the same affable-righteous performance from Washington in Spike Lee's "Inside Man."- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
The movie is as unpleasant as its hero, and the film audience gets no more for its money than the customers at the Laughing Stock. Still, watching Whaley take Jimmy down his tortured path has some morbid appeal -- like a train wreck in progress.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
The joke is that the salesmen believe they're actually trying to discover talent and - like the people they're encouraging - are victims.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
Have Marc's friends tricked him with a conspiracy of silence, or was that mustache a growth only in his mind? The filmmaker has said there is no intended meaning to any of this, so search for it for your own amusement.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
It's never a good thing to notice that the actors in a movie are having a better time than you are. It's so unfair. They're paid to work, you're paying for fun.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
Clintonistas may want to look away when Carville and his colleagues lay out their political philosophy for Lozada, or, as he's affectionately known, "Gani." It's pragmatic in a way that defies the needs of the impoverished majority of Bolivians.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
The setting and circumstances of the war overwhelm the personal story and diminish the dilemma of the title character's love life.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
Beware of movies whose creators boast of the little effort involved. Little reward is what you're likely to get.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
Beautifully shot, and graced with another winning performance from the lovely Beart, Strayed nevertheless fails because the relationship between Odile and Yvan never makes us feel the sexual passion it implies.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
Night at the Museum takes a can't-miss comedy premise and misses by a country mile.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
Miller takes Chekhov's themes and checks them off, but he never gets under his egocentric characters' thin skins.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
To say Spike Lee is repeating himself is itself repetitious -- he is getting B-O-R-I-N-G!- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
Some people will want to call it pornography. In one respect, it's the opposite.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
No one makes something out of nothing like the French, and in this wispy tale about a jilted middle-age man and the very young housekeeper who briefly lights up his life, writer-director Claude Berri's got plenty of nothing.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
It is both inside-baseball and self-parody, exposing a world that is just as ruthless and shallow as we've been shown it is in films like "The Player" and "Permanent Midnight."- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
Barely qualifies as a documentary. It's the personal journey of a man hoping to claim a million-dollar literary prize by proving that Marlowe wrote Shakespeare.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
The film's overriding messages are of personal responsibility and redemption. If that is Villeneuve's objective, it's done as an insidious polemic. If not, it's guilty of an even greater sin: It's boring.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
For Kidman, it is a one-note performance dictated by the script. Leigh had more dimension to work with and gives the film's most honest performance. Meanwhile, Black, whose job is mostly to deliver comic relief, is completely lost - that is to say, not funny - in the material.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
The script gets so silly, the Monty Python troupe would reject it.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
The lone gem of the anthology takes place in the loft of a trendy L.A. restaurant where a snooty Steve Coogan learns from starstruck Alfred Molina that the actors are cousins...This is the longest of the shorts, and has a payoff ending that nearly makes the whole thing worthwhile.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
George Bush supporters may think this dissection of the President's narrow and decisive 2004 election victory in Ohio is better than sex. But Democrats and Bush voters who have come to rue the day are more likely to compare it to losing the World Series on a seventh-game walkoff home run.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
Despite four very strong performances, Closer is hard emotional work to sit through. It's impossible to empathize with either the viciously insecure Larry or the unscrupulous, childlike Dan.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
There are some effective group scenes with Darius and Nina and their friends, but Witcher's dialogue and direction more often show the craft than the naturalism he's after. [14 Mar 1997, p.F1]- Los Angeles Times
-
- Jack Mathews
the director works way too hard to cover his tracks, and the resolution is a disappointment - if you get it at all.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
It was against all odds that Michael Mann ("The Insider") would make a boring movie focusing on the most eventful decade in the life of the most dynamic athlete in history. But that's what he has achieved with Ali.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
It's no wonder Sidney Lumet's Find Me Guilty had trouble finding a distributor. Its target audience is behind bars.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
The movie turns into something strange and annoying, an attempted blend of a suburban thriller with an Old West shoot-'em-up.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
The hand-held camera work gives the film an effective documentary pulse, but it adds up to only half a movie.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
An improvement over "Jackpot," but not much. The best thing about it is Nolte, playing the grizzled priest as an angel in his own right. Everyone else- - save the young boy playing the orphan -- seems to be in on a joke we just don't get.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
The laugh ratio in this run-on of skits is pretty low, at least to the unaltered mind of one who's seen enough of these films and eaten enough White Castle burgers to last a lifetime.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
Wenham and Porter are appealing actors, and Teplitzky's depiction of their coupling has an unflinching realism.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
A black comedy that some viewers may take as an assault. The disconnect between the realism of its violence and the near-slapstick tone of some of its comedy is too much to be framed within one movie.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
I've laughed harder during a single "Road Runner" cartoon than I did throughout Back in Action.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
Like a lost recording by the Beatles, Sylvester Stallone's Rambo arrives with its feet planted firmly in the past, a reminder of a time when Stallone, Chuck Norris and other wooden soldiers of the big screen filled multiplexes with the floor-shaking thunder of trivialized war.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
On stage, the attractive 34-year-old Silverman is very funny. She's too blue for Comedy Central, and too slow-paced for an HBO hour, but she'd come off better in either of those formats than she does in this mishmash.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
The result is a gorgeous, third-person version of an extended family-vacation movie that the Piersons, their friends and their former Fijian neighbors can enjoy for years to come.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
Undertow becomes unbearably imitative and predictable. It's a kids-in-peril B horror movie in the guise of an art film.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
Dunst makes Davies the most confident and interesting person aboard the Oneida and makes this voyage almost, but not quite, worth taking.- New York Daily News
-
- Jack Mathews
That final night of competition is exciting stuff, capped by a heroic victory ride, but this is otherwise a plodding feature about decent young people in a rough-and-tumble sport that makes you wonder how many IQ points they have being bucked around inside their heads.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
With each succeeding picture, Linklater seemed to grow as a filmmaker, just as his characters became more defined and developed. But with his fourth picture, subUrbia, he takes two giant steps backward.- Los Angeles Times
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
Danes' smart, fun, radiant and very attractive Mirabelle actually undermines the premise of the book- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
CSA is a sophomoric film essay that would have barely rated a passing grade from a tougher teacher.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
Cats Don’t Dance treads this territory with a whimsy that will be over the heads of young kids and too unimaginative for adults.- Los Angeles Times
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
Herzog, who deadpans his way through the high jinks, is the best thing about the movie, but even he gets wearisome before Nessie has sunk the boat.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
A tale of love, desperation and conspiratorial madness, comes off on the big screen as a wacky psychological snow job.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
Ultimately about the indomitability of faith, and the Christian symbolism is laid on thick. But the story, adapted from a famous behind-the-Iron-Curtain novel, sheds light on a subject few people have known about.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
From the beginning, Edmond is too self-absorbed for us to care much about his fate, but like the proverbial train wreck, you can't tear your eyes - or your ears - away from the spectacle.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
What they say, mostly over black-and-white stills from his early career and meandering footage of desolate Mali, could be said in 10 minutes. The good news is that much of the remaining documentary is devoted to Kar Kar's elegant voice and exquisite guitar playing.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
Mostly, though, Hayek's problem is one of physical miscasting. She's so tiny next to the tall, rotund Molina that she looks like child in their scenes together. And despite a fake caterpillar brow, she's just not believable as a woman bemoaning her disfigurements.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
An underdevelopment of a bad idea that is entertaining, so far as it is, because of McDormand's totally unselfconscious performance. This wonderful actress is never less than interesting, and even as a caricature of a stereotype, she's fun to watch.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
The second half, picking up 10 years after Eddie was institutionalized, is pure screwball comedy. It's as if Cassavetes had written the first half for himself to direct, and the second for Carl Reiner. [29 Aug 1997, p.F10]- Los Angeles Times
-
- Jack Mathews
The movie includes a postscript about her (McKinney's) loss, blaming it on more dirty tricks. That may be true, but it doesn't put the steam back in the film.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
Given the grim events, the buoyantly goofy An Amazing Couple has the effect of laughing gas pumped through the vents in a funeral hall.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
You have to look at the earlier film to understand where the Coen brothers went wrong - terribly, noisily, annoyingly wrong. They've made a broad comedy out of a black comedy and completely lost its charm in the process.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
The script (written by Susan Minot from a story by Bertolucci) suffers from the same tired blood as his characters, and his direction is often ponderously self-conscious.- Los Angeles Times
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
A bungled mess that spends an hour creating two characters whose lives are about as believable as a successful ambush set by Wile E. Coyote for the Roadrunner.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
If I were in the sign business, I'd produce a bumper sticker that reads "Even smart people make dumb movies" -- and give the first one to David Mamet.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
The subtitle of this interview/documentary about the late, great French photojournalist should be "For Collectors Only." There is no theme, no point, no history, no illuminating insights - it's just Bresson talking about his individual photos and early sketches.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
A film of epically hollow sentimentality, a movie that tells you how to feel every step of the way and ends on a symphony of false notes. The moment when we learn what Mr. Holland's Opus really means makes the ending of It's a Wonderful Life look like an exercise in restraint.- Los Angeles Times
- Read full review