Ian Nathan
Select another critic »For 266 reviews, this critic has graded:
-
54% higher than the average critic
-
3% same as the average critic
-
43% lower than the average critic
On average, this critic grades 2.5 points higher than other critics.
(0-100 point scale)
Ian Nathan's Scores
- Movies
- TV
| Average review score: | 68 | |
|---|---|---|
| Highest review score: | The Big Lebowski | |
| Lowest review score: | Billy Madison | |
Score distribution:
-
Positive: 124 out of 266
-
Mixed: 138 out of 266
-
Negative: 4 out of 266
266
movie
reviews
- By Date
- By Critic Score
-
- Ian Nathan
Justice hasn't been done. The heavens haven't fallen. But skilfully prodding and probing at the edges of America’s greatest crime scene, Oliver Stone reinforces the argument that this was far from an open-and-shut case.- Empire
- Posted Nov 22, 2021
- Read full review
-
- Empire
- Posted Feb 9, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
Despite moody flashbacks to the Nazi takeover, Hirschbiegel draws a blank. Elser remains an enigma, a great what-if whose German torturers cannot comprehend acted alone.- Empire
- Posted Feb 7, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
Vallée’s post-traumatic stress comedy is more scientific than genuinely moving. Nevertheless, Gyllenhaal continues his post-Nightcrawler upgrade with another vivid performance in the key of strange.- Empire
- Posted Apr 18, 2016
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
For all the special effects and half-starved A-listers, this is a sodden beast. Perhaps there’s a reason that Melville only told half the story.- Empire
- Posted Jan 4, 2016
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
Charming in that neurotically adorable way Charles Schulz established over many years, this is a fond continuation of the Snoopyverse.- Empire
- Posted Jan 4, 2016
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
On one level a fascinating refraction of the Amanda Knox trial into an examination of perception, on another an increasingly trying hall of mirrors.- Empire
- Posted Mar 23, 2015
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
Lavish and sporadically powerful, Jolie's POW biopic may have just enough gravity to entice the Academy, but struggles to bring truth to an unbelievable truth.- Empire
- Posted Dec 1, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
A persuasive, warts-and-bolts depiction of warfare from the guts of a tank yoked to an overwrought, sub-Private Ryan account of innocence under fire — so a hit and a miss.- Empire
- Posted Oct 20, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
Weightless, but not without its enchantments, this is Woody Allen coasting. But where better to coast than the loveliest coast of all?- Empire
- Posted Sep 15, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
For all its chilled intelligence and topical ambition this is a bloodless adaptation, but worth seeing for Hoffman’s deft and ghostly presence.- Empire
- Posted Sep 8, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
What begins as a thrilling pastiche of comic-book formula gets bogged down in its own scientific prattle — not that you ever stop adoring Johansson’s magnificent heroine.- Empire
- Posted Aug 18, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
An uneven debut from John Slattery that nonetheless shows flashes of flair and a jet-black sense of humour.- Empire
- Posted Aug 4, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
For all it boasts in ingenious style, this genial American yarn lacks the delicious bile of Jenuet’s early days.- Empire
- Posted Jun 18, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
With Eastern Promises and Dirty Pretty Things, screenwriter Steven Knight has proved his ear for London's darker rhythms. Here, though, there's little to raise the pulse.- Empire
- Posted Oct 21, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
Good intentions, vivid setting and TLJ on top form do not make up for a lack of anything truly compelling.- Empire
- Posted Sep 30, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
However exotic the locations and starry the stars, there’s no escaping this is The Devil’s Advocate of online gambling. Fold.- Empire
- Posted Sep 28, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
Already a hit in America, 42 is a well-told but square biopic doing justice to Jackie Robinson rather than exploring him.- Empire
- Posted Sep 9, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
The CG does its part of the bargain, but even more than the brighter, breezier original this is a pale imitation of Potter.- Empire
- Posted Aug 9, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
Del Toro is giving scope to a boyhood lust for mayhem, the multi-million-dollar equivalent of kicking over sandcastles and torturing insects. There is something infectiously juvenile in that.- Empire
- Posted Jul 8, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
Despite DiCaprio’s prize performance, purists will fume, but even as lit-crashing razzle-dazzle entertainment Luhrmann’s adaptation is a candelabrum too far.- Empire
- Posted May 19, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Empire
- Posted Feb 4, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
An uneven mix of impressively executed, violent clichés about good ol' boys defending the American right to flout the law.- Empire
- Posted Sep 3, 2012
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
As earnestly as they have tried to continue the formerly excellent spy series, everything Gilroy and crew concoct only serves to mock the excellence and passion with which Greengrass delivered his films.- Empire
- Posted Aug 12, 2012
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
Family dysfunction to make Jeremy Kyle blush, but thanks to McConaughey's oily power and Friedkin's unflinching purpose it's a compelling beast.- Empire
- Posted Jul 18, 2012
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
Buffeted by a lack of suspense, threadbare characters, and a very poor script, the stunning visuals, gloopy madness, and sterling Fassbenderiness can't prevent Prometheus feeling like Alien's poor relation.- Empire
- Posted May 30, 2012
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
With so many films adapted from novels, it's nice to see cinema paying homage to unheralded greats of literature like Sebald. While this one often struggles to do justice to his sense of grandeur and poetry, it'll be manna for fans of the German's work.- Empire
- Posted May 8, 2012
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
There's no question it's stunningly mounted, and Wasikowska makes a much stronger Jane than Alice, but the romance is overripe and the climax underdone.- Empire
- Posted Sep 5, 2011
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
Not one to let slow-building tension and mystery get in the way of wild flourishes of extremism and shock, Ken Russell hit upon a story that more or less handled his structural excesses and tendency toward blasphemy.- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
Unfortunately, half the time this feels more like an Omen parody than a chance to give it a great send off.- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
For much of its slowburn build there is a classy, intelligent thriller at work, something closer in tone to The Odessa File. Still, you must remain guarded to how over the top and quasi-horror events will finally turn.- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
It picks up in the last hour, though this is a very minor compensation in an otherwise long and listless film.- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
What a peculiar but effective children’s adventure movie this is.- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
One for the die hards. The saving grace here is a knowing sense of humour so lacking in its predecessor, For Your Eyes Only.- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
In the grand pantheon of Sinbad movies, those pleasurable Arabesques of silly beasts, big swords and scantily clad maidens, this lower league Ray Harryhausen stop-motion thriller squeezes between the better Eye Of The Tiger and the worse Seventh Voyage.- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
This sprawling epic rewards patience with an emotional pay-off and non-triumphant ending that reminds us all too starkly of the sacrifices made during war.- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
Forgettable, innocent, old fashioned fairy tale with not nearly as much sexual chemistry as is required.- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
The jingoism is blindingly awful, but by the time of the showdown, the film has descended into an unaware parody of itself.- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
Michael Caine as a Nazi and Donald Pleasance as Himmler...what more could you want?- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
A tormented movie about torment; loopy, over-reaching and occasionally suspicious. Simultaneously, it is a daring artistic endeavour.- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
It's not the plot that disappoints, it's the poor dialogue between action sequences. Sadly another film to file under not as good as the book.- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
Running at just over four hours, it is as spectacular, lush and extravagant as the studio would have liked its audience to believe. But it also has moments of mind-numbing boredom as the plot, slowed by extraneous dialogue, drags from Egypt to Rome.- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
Classic War caper with a few too many plot contrivances but high on adventure.- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
A bit silly really but it has a bizarre mix of a cast and some tension in places.- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
The effects may have dated, as have the Cold War themes, but the almost real time adventure still has some tension to offer.- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
The tale from the past is very nostalgic, heartwarming and mouth-watering and all, as Idgie and Ruth cook up a storm, are kindly to their black domestics and stand up to piggy men while events fitfully progress to a courtroom climax. And Masterson is a peach. But the best bits belong to Bates as her dreary Evelyn raises her consciousness, lowers her weight and starts speaking her mind. It's a nice, pleasant celebration of friendship, but without much meat to chew on.- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
It’s ragged round the edges, but then Fritz Kiersch is working with a budget Roger Corman would laugh at, and he does a good job.- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
Derivative sci-fi hokum but some imaginative touches here and there.- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
Only distinguishable from the original movie by its obvious cheapness.- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
An insanely effective no-brainer of a film, sparkling with a simple charm and energy rarely witnessed this side of illegal substances.- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
The definitive wacky screwball comedy that spawned a genre.- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
Not a masterpiece, by any stretch of the imagination, but it's pleasing to see a sequel strive so hard to reach the same heights. That it fails is through no fault of its own - the original simply raised the bar too high.- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
As a light family sports feel-good this works but don't look for anything more.- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
This is supposed to be serious hard-hitting but with most prehistoric depictions, only manages either school reconstruction or parody.- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
Fairly routine western makes a disappointing swansong for Hawks. Still good fun though, if you like this kind of thing.- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
One of Heston's best work, this shows our lead at his most macho and heroic, inspiring a whole army while also managing to woo the stunning Loren in this romantic war epic.- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
Clearly not a |Disney classic as almost no-one has heard of it, this is vaguely enjoyable 70s hokum.- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
No matter how well dressed, the movie can’t escape the gravitational pull of formula. Without a convincing subtext, Black Rain is pretty dull fare indeed.- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
Largely devoid of any charm or intelligence that made other Apes films entertaining, this one should be buried in the Forbidden Zone.- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
Those with the patience to sit through a slow first half will be rewarded with another gutsy ending.- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
Clint doing roughneck humour with an orang-utan, what's not to like?- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
This has some very, very funny bits...interspersed with a very slight film.- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
Christopher Walken sleepwalks his way through playing smarmy Nazi geneticist Zorin, where you would think he would have a ball hamming it up as a Bond villain. Indeed, it is a rare moment when Grace Jones makes the biggest impression as an Amazonian (naturally) henchman called May Day.- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
The sugar level is positively diabetic, but the whole aura of warmth and cuddliness is hard to resist.- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
What saves the movie is its relaxed sense of self-awareness. Reynolds all but winks at the audience with his collection of Dick Dastardly sneaks and dodges, but holds onto that winning, hangdog warmth that got him to the top of the pile in the seventies.- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
While you cannot dismiss its place in history, its power is in what it represented rather than what it did.- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
Certainly not Raimi at his best, but some knowing genre nods and an array of great effects make up much of the deficit.- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
Willow is not without its charms - the effects are more than special, the set-pieces suitably epic but it just doesn't fulfill the promise of certain other fantasy films.- Empire
-
- Ian Nathan
Who could ever buy Atticus Finch as the demonic Ahab driven by hellfire to hunt down that dreaded white whale?- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
Arnie still swings that sword with aplomb, but with a story this ludicrous, he's on slippery ground.- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
It's mindless entertainment, but its critical and commercial failure doomed the pirate genre to a watery grave.- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
Imagine if Stanley Kubrick had made Ghost and you're some way to this classily restrained oddity, but its morbid preoccupations and ambiguity might prove too cuckoo for most.- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
All gothicky, christmassy, romantic and Burtonesque. Worth a look.- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
A pretty craven attempt by Disney to cash-in on Star Wars blockbusting success, this lightweight but well-written sci-fi adventure movie is well pitched at the very young. More discerning fans of the genre would do well to smother their indignation at the levels of general plagiarism floating around the deck of the supership Cygnus.- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
Connery has a ball with great stunts, snappy dialogue and a bevy of typically Bondish beauties.- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
Slow and foreboding with a memorably creepy Christopher Walken. If you're looking for fun, this ain't it.- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
Peckinpah is never quite as comfortable with the high-rise terrain (including sloppy kung fu) as he is with the dusty rawhide of the West, but it still shows up the slick trigger-edits of new action cinema for the gutless vacuum it has become.- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
The first of the silly VW Beetle with a cute personality comedies, is as childish dated and occasionally sweet as the others.- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
So so adaptation of the Kipling story. The human performances are riotous but their animal counterparts are blank canvases yet to be coloured.- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
Like Lansbury, the film has aged well and retains almost all of it's magic.- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
The film seems to be pitched at shrieking level, as if that’s the only timbre children can register.- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
Very hit and miss and not a patch on the first spoof but when a joke strikes home it'll have you going for a while.- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
Ustinov may not be the Poirot that we all think of now, after the David Suchet series, but this is pure Agatha Christie, steeped in nostalgia and atmosphere.- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
Excessive and self-indulgent it's true but still the Pythons at their worst are still worth a look.- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
The Net entertains but is unlikely to hang around on the cerebral hard disk for too long.- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
This has grit coming out of its ears but not the greatest Eastwood feature by a long shot.- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
Ridiculous premise and hilarious acting which is mostly famous for the Lolita-type Brooke Shields cavorting in tropical settings.- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
Unoriginal, unfunny superhero spoof with a bewildered cast and an obvious plot.- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
A sci-fi which balances big themes and claustrophobic action with apparent ease.- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
Film is elegant but never beautiful, a pretence at Lean’s magnificence contradicted by a lavish but anachronistic score by Vangelis. It is the words and performances which excite; their director is out of his depth.- Empire
- Read full review
-
- Ian Nathan
Moore just looks confused. He obviously wants to do his thing then hit the bar for cocktails, but John Glen is nagging him to add a roughness to the slick exterior. Equally, it just doesn’t fit. The news is clear, there’s only so far you can push a Bond before it breaks.- Empire
- Read full review