Alan Scherstuhl
Select another critic »For 727 reviews, this critic has graded:
-
59% higher than the average critic
-
3% same as the average critic
-
38% lower than the average critic
On average, this critic grades 3 points higher than other critics.
(0-100 point scale)
Alan Scherstuhl's Scores
- Movies
- TV
| Average review score: | 69 | |
|---|---|---|
| Highest review score: | A Bread Factory Part Two: Walk With Me a While | |
| Lowest review score: | Saving Lincoln | |
Score distribution:
-
Positive: 447 out of 727
-
Mixed: 233 out of 727
-
Negative: 47 out of 727
727
movie
reviews
- By Date
- By Critic Score
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
The biggest suspense: As everything gets worse for everyone, will this consummate director's outraged worldview afford anyone any pity? At first you'll seethe — then your heart will ache.- Village Voice
- Posted Jan 13, 2015
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
The scale of the occasional mayhem is heightened, but its spirit and ingenuity doesn't feel wholly at odds with the books.- Village Voice
- Posted Jan 13, 2015
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
The film is work, but it's upsetting, insightful, and sometimes gorgeous — admire its cold suns and withering cornfields.- Village Voice
- Posted Jan 7, 2015
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Haupt persuades viewers to surrender to a place, to a vision, and to a scale of thinking beyond our own lives.- Village Voice
- Posted Dec 16, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Village Voice
- Posted Dec 16, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Rob Marshall simply cuts from one tale to the next, isolating his actors. There's little sense that the fairytale space is a shared one -- it's just a bunch of noisy incident transpiring in unrelated treestands.- Village Voice
- Posted Dec 16, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
This patient, beautiful, painful, engrossing film pits husband and wife against each other and their world in a series of extended conversations/confrontations.- Village Voice
- Posted Dec 16, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Serge Bozon's smart, surprising, marvelously realized French crime-and-sex police drama/comedy distinguishes itself with trenchant plotting, inspired framing, and performances that honor true human feeling even as they lunge into the screwball.- Village Voice
- Posted Dec 9, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Landscapes and lyric conundrums distinguish the first two-thirds of this find-your-own-meaning artflick, which unfurls like some stranger's life you're half reliving.- Village Voice
- Posted Dec 2, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
One of the year's best films, Mary Dore's She's Beautiful When She's Angry is an urgent, illuminating dive into the headwaters of second-wave feminism, the movement that — no matter what its detractors insist — has given us the world in which we live.- Village Voice
- Posted Dec 2, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
A commanding indictment of the exploitative nature of geopolitics, and of Europe's and the U.S.'s abuse of native peoples around the world.- Village Voice
- Posted Dec 2, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Zero Motivation opens as bleak, rebellious comedy but grows into a smart and moving story of entering adulthood.- Village Voice
- Posted Dec 2, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
The longer versions of all Jackson's Middle-earth films have played better (and made more sense) than their theatrical cuts, but this time he's trimmed out something absolutely vital, the one element that, besides his mad gore-minded grandiloquence, has kept everything together five films running: an attention to the emotional lives of his hobbits.- Village Voice
- Posted Dec 2, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Jennifer Kent's maternal nightmare The Babadook is the imperial stout of recent fright flicks -- it's the one that will have you walking funny and might rip into your sleep. It's hard to say that you'll enjoy this film, but it's hard not to admire it, if maybe with your eyes half shut.- Village Voice
- Posted Nov 25, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
If beauty and revelation is your bottom line, Anthony Powell's rhapsodic Antarctica: A Year on Ice will prove a grand time at the movies.- Village Voice
- Posted Nov 25, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Village Voice
- Posted Nov 18, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
The Mule proves a tough sit, but by the end you might be satisfied you gritted through it.- Village Voice
- Posted Nov 18, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Nothing in this film (and little in any other movie this year) compares to the scenes of Sandusky's adopted son, Matt, recounting his realization that the charges of pedophilia against Sandusky squared with the ways Sandusky had treated him, too — treatment he'd never been brave enough to admit.- Village Voice
- Posted Nov 18, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
All My Children's Brittany Allen proves herself a big-screen presence as the lead earthling; her commitment to each scene's emotional truth is all the more impressive considering that the schoolboyish Vicious Brothers introduce her character ass-first.- Village Voice
- Posted Nov 18, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
For all its familiarity and rote nastiness, the film's sharply crafted and quite promising.- Village Voice
- Posted Nov 11, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Greutert's savvy enough to sprinkle some white folks among his houngans and mambos, but Jessabelle still plays out as Haitian traditions ruining the life of a nice-ish white lady.- Village Voice
- Posted Nov 4, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
The fights Virunga documents couldn't feel more urgent. This is one of the year's most compelling and important films.- Village Voice
- Posted Nov 4, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Found-footage horror flicks laboriously source the provenance of every shot, letting us know which camera each image comes from, but they demand that we never wonder who has edited those images together — and to what purpose.- Village Voice
- Posted Nov 4, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
With sharper on-the-ground footage, True Son might have been as sharp a doc as it is inspiring a story.- Village Voice
- Posted Oct 30, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Matthew VanDyke, Point and Shoot's hero/subject, can't forget the mediated, imitative nature of his adventures even when he has dedicated himself to a grand cause.- Village Voice
- Posted Oct 28, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Valedictory and elegiac, Keach's film captures a performer who only truly seems to inhabit himself during the performances.- Village Voice
- Posted Oct 21, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Poitras shows us history as it happens, scenes of such intimate momentousness that the movie's a must-see piece of work even if, in its totality, it's underwhelming as argument or cinema.- Village Voice
- Posted Oct 21, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Dylan Baker's film bests larger-budgeted fare like When the Game Stands Tall thanks to ace acting, a humble spirit, and all-around sturdy craftsmanship.- Village Voice
- Posted Oct 21, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Accomplishes the nearly impossible trick of updating viewers on the prevalence of genocide in the 20th and 21st centuries without rubbing our noses in our failure to stop it.- Village Voice
- Posted Oct 14, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Any 30 minutes of Summer of Blood might have me in hysterics. But the sputtering torrent of Eric's yakking proves wearying over 90: Dude's built for speed-dating.- Village Voice
- Posted Oct 14, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
A 45-minute proto-hip-hop bliss-out, a masterpiece of train- and tag-spotting dedicated to memorializing the extravagant graffiti on its era's MTA trains and how those trains rumbled across Brooklyn and the Bronx, bearing not just exhausted New Yorkers but gifted artists' urgent personal expression.- Village Voice
- Posted Oct 14, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
For much of its running time, Camp X-Ray stands as the fullest on-screen imaginative treatment of two of the defining developments of the last 15 years of American life: the deployment of women in our volunteer army, and the indefinite detention of men we think, but can't quite prove, deserve it.- Village Voice
- Posted Oct 14, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Vital, thoughtful, and deeply personal, first-timer Darius Clark Monroe's autobiographical doc stands as a testament to the power of movies to stir empathy.- Village Voice
- Posted Oct 7, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Village Voice
- Posted Oct 7, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
The directors demonstrate confident technique in most of the scare scenes, but their uncertain touch with actors and dialogue makes a cock-up of the climax.- Village Voice
- Posted Oct 7, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Too much of the last hour is a muddle of unconvincing, hard-to-read nighttime action scenes.- Village Voice
- Posted Oct 7, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
What's perhaps most moving in Waiting for August, a quiet film of weight and joy, is its sense of desperate normalcy.- Village Voice
- Posted Oct 2, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Co-writer/director/proudly nude star Amalric cuts everything to the quick: Most shots have the feel of still photos, the camera firmly planted, and the movie always hustles us to the next, back and forward in time, the effect part Resnais and part staccato Kodak slideshow.- Village Voice
- Posted Oct 1, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
The filmmakers have gotten extraordinary access to Mohamed and ravaged Somalia... But it's disappointing that they did not capture more scenes of Mohamed's wife and her family, who in the end are the ones who make the most momentous decision.- Village Voice
- Posted Sep 30, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Strachwitz's enthusiasm — "This ain't no mouse music!" he's given to shouting — and a brace of choice anecdotes prove compelling on their own.- Village Voice
- Posted Sep 25, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Here's the rare lionizing-a-musician doc that strikes a smart balance between vintage footage, talking-head testimonials, and contemporary tribute performances.- Village Voice
- Posted Sep 24, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Cutter Hodierne's gorgeous, harrowing debut feature, Fishing Without Nets, doesn't just ask you to feel a bit for Somali pirates, as Captain Phillips did -- Hodierne puts you in their shoes.- Village Voice
- Posted Sep 23, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Fuqua steadily parades his big moments, and the movie works as unhinged spectacle. As a thriller it's less certain.- Village Voice
- Posted Sep 23, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
It's part Live at Birdland, part Boy in the Plastic Bubble, all warmly thrilling.- Village Voice
- Posted Sep 18, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Sympathetic audiences may be diverted by Space Station 76's period design and skilled performances, and by the mystery of what exactly the filmmakers are going for. (The less sympathetic may just ask what the point is.)- Village Voice
- Posted Sep 16, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Despite some cutesiness, the film’s a fascinating portrait of loneliness, of talent undirected toward purpose, of the mysteries of the mind.- Village Voice
- Posted Sep 16, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
A Walk Among the Tombstones is an uncommonly well-made thriller.- Village Voice
- Posted Sep 16, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
The movie's so slipshod and half-assed that I almost feel for Rand, whose ideas have proved enduring enough that they at least deserve a fair representation, if only for the sake of refutation.- Village Voice
- Posted Sep 16, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
In his second feature, McCarthy shows he's mastered the things we already know scare us onscreen; next, how about something we don't expect?- Village Voice
- Posted Sep 9, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
There's much in Born to Fly to thrill to, dream with, flinch from: dancers leaping from a great whirling wheel and smacking onto mats far below; dancers ducking and leaping a wickedly spinning I-beam or cinderblock.- Village Voice
- Posted Sep 9, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
"I wanted to make something energetic, optimistic, universal, and real," Bailey announces in voiceover as the movie begins. She's certainly accomplished that, but it's too bad she didn't also aim for vital, illuminating, or consistently compelling.- Village Voice
- Posted Sep 9, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
What's singular here isn't that the stars are playing brother and sister, or that they stir such sublime and anxious joy from each other. It's that the real love story isn't even between the damaged-but-lovable characters. It's between two profoundly depressed people and life itself.- Village Voice
- Posted Sep 9, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Dolphin Tale 2 is a singularly honest animal film: It never insists that Winter wouldn't prefer to be elsewhere . . . or that what she feels for them has anything to do with what we think of as love.- Village Voice
- Posted Sep 9, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Sutton's Memphis framed in fascinating layers -- leaves and tree limbs, wig shops and overgrown gravel roads. It's a movie of a place and a character rather than about them.- Village Voice
- Posted Sep 2, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Vital, illuminating, and terrifying, Rory Kennedy's Last Days in Vietnam probes with clarity and thoroughness one moment of recent American history that has too long gone unreckoned with.- Village Voice
- Posted Sep 2, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Hilary Brougher's YA-ish horror satire/romance/whatzit Innocence, adapted from Jane Mendelsohn's novel, boasts a wicked setup, some strong performances, several gloriously bloody spook-out images, and a movie-wrecking hypoglycemic listlessness.- Village Voice
- Posted Sep 2, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
The comedy's too broad to take the characters seriously, and the vibe is breezily aimless, a mistake in a story about anxious waiting.- Village Voice
- Posted Aug 27, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
As far as escapist fluff laced with totally unnecessary real-world horror goes, The November Man isn't wretched.- Village Voice
- Posted Aug 27, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
The movie is more effective as sports fantasy than as theology.- Village Voice
- Posted Aug 21, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Every time a story thread seems to be getting somewhere, Winter in the Blood vaults to something else, with little regard for the tale’s rhythms — the movie doesn’t feel like a puzzle to solve; it’s a puzzle to assemble.- Village Voice
- Posted Aug 19, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Village Voice
- Posted Aug 19, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
The doc is often terrific fun. But it is a work of observation and advocacy rather than journalism.- Village Voice
- Posted Aug 19, 2014
- Read full review