Alan Scherstuhl
Select another critic »For 727 reviews, this critic has graded:
-
59% higher than the average critic
-
3% same as the average critic
-
38% lower than the average critic
On average, this critic grades 3 points higher than other critics.
(0-100 point scale)
Alan Scherstuhl's Scores
- Movies
- TV
| Average review score: | 69 | |
|---|---|---|
| Highest review score: | A Bread Factory Part Two: Walk With Me a While | |
| Lowest review score: | Saving Lincoln | |
Score distribution:
-
Positive: 447 out of 727
-
Mixed: 233 out of 727
-
Negative: 47 out of 727
727
movie
reviews
- By Date
- By Critic Score
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
It’s a Rocky movie, just the latest go-round, its story more formulaic, its people less specific, its rhythms as wheezily familiar as a workout you should have changed up weeks ago. It’s a diminishment of Creed, a dumbing down, just as Rocky II was a diminishment of Rocky.- L.A. Weekly
- Posted Nov 21, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
El Angel is a crime spree as improvised reverie, one with a subject who is as quick to give away his loot as the director is to make the subtext explicit.- L.A. Weekly
- Posted Nov 8, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
The family squabbles jangle the nerves while not hitting on insights or memorable emotion.- L.A. Weekly
- Posted Oct 18, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Helped along by news clips, the filmmakers do better with the crash-and-burn business story than with the actuality of the Studio experience.- L.A. Weekly
- Posted Oct 11, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Double-stuffed with kill squads, killer ’80s couture and mood-killing howlers, Fernando Leon de Aranoa’s Loving Pablo is more a greatest hits than a story, the kind of radically compressed life-of-a-legend movie where everything happens in a giddy, ridiculous gush — except for when it slows down to dwell on horrors.- L.A. Weekly
- Posted Oct 4, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
While sometimes messy, this material is emotionally resonant and cinematically alive.- L.A. Weekly
- Posted Sep 20, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Active Measures is an assault on the eyes, the ears, the mind. By coming on so strong, so fevered, Bryan achieves the dubious feat of making his host of documented facts, reasonable inferences, and alarming subjects for further research all seem seem less persuasive than if they had been presented more soberly.- Village Voice
- Posted Aug 30, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Rather than the cagey, caged mastermind who later would play dumb at trial, this Eichmann is just another movie bad guy — and Operation Finale is just another movie.- Village Voice
- Posted Aug 28, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
What are the concerns of coherent storytelling or in-depth documentation when all of these good boys and girls — yes they are! — are leaping and licking and tail-wagging and just being the best?- Village Voice
- Posted Aug 28, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Village Voice
- Posted Aug 9, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Since it’s hard to buy the character, it’s hard to buy the story, no matter how good Macdonald is.- Village Voice
- Posted Jul 26, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
By turns, Greenfield’s survey is alarming, hilarious, and indulgent, sometimes strained and a little dull, prone to overstatement and an abuse of synecdoche.- Village Voice
- Posted Jul 18, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
It’s hard to appreciate the hero’s crafty planning when we can’t really make out what he’s crafted.- Village Voice
- Posted Jul 18, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
The good intentions it carries out to the plains don’t make up for the tentative falseness at its center, a hero who could herself benefit from a portraitist’s clear vision.- Village Voice
- Posted Jun 28, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Village Voice
- Posted Jun 21, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Honestly, I’d probably love this film’s wandering spirit and Elvis-is-everywhere philosophizing if it were half as fast or twice as long, if it pinned any thought down long enough to really TCB. Instead, it’s as scattered and disorienting as the infamous LP Having Fun With Elvis on Stage, an official cheapie that consisted of nothing but the King’s between-songs Seventies stage banter.- Village Voice
- Posted Jun 21, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
The film is about being overwhelmed by Los Angeles, its sprawling indifference, but also about finding your place in it — and even, at times, its welcoming warmth.- Village Voice
- Posted Jun 21, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Simply put, the clockwork heist that Ocean’s 8 promises (and, by its end, dazzles with) limits the film’s ability to offer what you might actually want from it: the chance to relish this cast.- Village Voice
- Posted Jun 5, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Rather than plumb the apparent sociopathy that gripped these young men, Layton toys with unreliable narration and the vagaries of collective memory.- Village Voice
- Posted May 30, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
The real Rodin imbued his clay with reverent, lusty life, while Doillon merely offers a buffet of nude day players.- Village Voice
- Posted May 30, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Mary Shelley marshals its evidence without revealing more, without connecting to the soul of the matter. Its Mary Shelley may walk and talk, kiss and rage, but she has no more of the true spark of life than that specimen in that lab.- Village Voice
- Posted May 24, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Howard stamps the material in some welcome ways: The scruffy breeziness of his early comedies (Night Shift, Splash, Gung Ho) suits the hit-and-miss script, by Lawrence and Jonathan Kasdan. Here’s a Star Wars that’s more appealing when its characters are chatting than when they’re pew-pewing.- Village Voice
- Posted May 16, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Village Voice
- Posted May 14, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Onstage, we get to choose which face to regard, to watch each hard truth or unexamined lie crash against each character’s carefully maintained set of illusions. Here, we mostly see one face at a time. Those faces are grand enough that this Seagull still has much to recommend.- Village Voice
- Posted May 10, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Revisiting Beast may prove more satisfying than just visiting once. The first time through, the film simply proves too successful at capturing the listless ennui it’s depicting.- Village Voice
- Posted May 9, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
The film is less a distillation of the real Soussan’s memoir than a radical simplification of it.- Village Voice
- Posted Apr 25, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
It’s stuck between earnest examination of a case and exploitative hustle — and is unlikely to please the audiences interested in either.- Village Voice
- Posted Apr 18, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
The film — which is nowhere near as interesting as LaBeouf’s performance — is hopelessly reductive about its subjects’ psychology even as it mocks the press of 1980 for being reductive about its subjects’ psychology.- Village Voice
- Posted Apr 12, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
ACORN and the Firestorm fumbles with the media story, offering cable-news talking heads in montage but not digging deeply into how the story spread — or why elected Democrats believed they had to shut Acorn down. That sense of fumbling shapes the film.- Village Voice
- Posted Apr 5, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Reynolds never appears in full command of his body, and at times the performance is painful to watch, not simply because the one-time golden boy has aged but because the role demands that he act as if aging is a betrayal, as if he has nothing to offer the world without his youthful vigor.- Village Voice
- Posted Mar 29, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Rothstein’s film, for the most part, is more well-reported exposé than it is cliché-driven agitprop, a film that blows the whistle on ongoing financial crimes.- Village Voice
- Posted Mar 29, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
I admire the seriousness with which everyone involved treats these characters, and the smart ways that the script (from Geneva Robertson-Dworet and Alastair Siddons) on several occasions dashes expectations to the rocks. I have hopes for a sequel.- Village Voice
- Posted Mar 22, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
For all its occasional familiarity, this first English-language feature from Italian director Paolo Virzì (Human Capital, Like Crazy) is at times moving in its sincerity, thanks to stellar casting and the director’s clear-eyed perspective on aging and dementia, even when the story skirts toward sensationalism.- Village Voice
- Posted Mar 8, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
You know that moment about fifteen minutes before the end of most American narrative features, when the protagonist is brought to his or her low point, and it looks as if there’s no possible way things could get better? Something has probably gone wrong if viewers are cheering that.- Village Voice
- Posted Mar 1, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
There’s something dazzling in the audacity of applying the most conventional and conservative techniques to the portrayal of radical thinkers and thoughts. That frisson keeps the movie interesting without quite jolting it to life.- Village Voice
- Posted Feb 22, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
The characters wander in baffling circles, but the story soldiers dutifully from beat to beat, scare to scare. It has this going for it — when it comes to offing its characters, The Ritual proves more pitiless than you might expect for a film that has this tony a look.- Village Voice
- Posted Feb 8, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Watching it is something like watching a play’s first full dress rehearsal or a gangly baby deer’s initial efforts to stand, where it’s the effort that’s more engaging than the achievement itself.- Village Voice
- Posted Feb 7, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
The series’ borrowings often have about them a whiff of playful improvisation, the logic of kids with action figures saying, “And what if then they had to drive into that tunnel from The Stand and it was full of zombies?” As The Death Cure grinds on, though, they become less inspired.- Village Voice
- Posted Jan 25, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Fuglsig is adept at showing choppers and peaks, caves and campfires, at suggesting the great silence at the roof of the world. He’s also a sure hand with the geography of battle, with ensuring we understand why the bullets fly in the direction they’re flying — and both where they come from and where they hit. That said, the firefights do wear on.- Village Voice
- Posted Jan 20, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
The filmmakers offer us glimpses of the diplomatic life but too little telling detail.- Village Voice
- Posted Jan 18, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
The mayhem is hypnotic, scabrous, scarifying, unpredictable, astonishing, dispiriting, repetitious, clearly both amoral and immoral, and by the end, a little dull. Even over the short running time, you can feel your humanity’s diminishment.- Village Voice
- Posted Jan 18, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Django expresses, via the language of film genre, not what Reinhardt’s life was but what it might have felt like.- Village Voice
- Posted Jan 4, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
The finely realized Annette Bening performance at the center of Paul McGuigan’s Film Stars Don’t Die in Liverpool doesn’t power the movie. Bening is subject to its rhythms rather than vice versa, and her blood seems to pump faster than McGuigan’s, whose film is listless and thinly conceived.- Village Voice
- Posted Dec 31, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
The material is often weak, but the stars earn their paychecks.- Village Voice
- Posted Dec 20, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Woodshock is a study of a mind’s stoned studying, of its slipping in and out of a haze, rather than one of a mind’s unraveling or snapping. It’s just as interesting as that sounds — you’ll either embrace it or find it agony.- Village Voice
- Posted Dec 18, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Village Voice
- Posted Nov 30, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
An article, a book, and now a film, Talese’s fascination with Foos’s voyeurism still hasn’t resulted in anything like rigorous journalism. The movie, though, at least lets us be the witnesses to something unsettling rather than just asking us to take some dude’s word for it. That means these cameramen are journalists.- Village Voice
- Posted Nov 30, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
The movie — based on Les Standiford’s novel — is pleasantly simpleminded, often assembled from parts of other movies.- Village Voice
- Posted Nov 21, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
What Gustafson has achieved is certainly artful, and sometimes, through montage and smart camerawork, suggests correspondences between these century-crossing assignations that the stage show could not. But even at its best, this Hello Again struck me as an uncertain, even ancillary work.- Village Voice
- Posted Nov 13, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
LBJ slips from an examination of a sometimes admirable leader into a hagiographic daydream, a fantasy of a father figure to save us all. That’s a matter of Reiner’s politics, of course, but even more so a matter of his instincts as a popular filmmaker: He’s offering us an American presidency to escape to.- Village Voice
- Posted Nov 1, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
The filmmakers observe rather than interview or investigate, and much of the film is footage of actual church-sanctioned exorcisms.- Village Voice
- Posted Oct 19, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Curiously drab and airless, tinted to a distracting bluish miasma that suggests an advertisement for antidepressants, Peter Landesman’s Mark Felt is the wrong movie at the right time.- Village Voice
- Posted Oct 4, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
With rasps and desperate eyes, Gugino communicates Jessie’s thinking and planning so powerfully that cutaways to that other Jessie, the chatty vision, egging her on, prove redundant.- Village Voice
- Posted Sep 28, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
It’s almost as if, in their fascination with trauma, the filmmakers have forgotten entirely what everyday life looks like.- Village Voice
- Posted Sep 21, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
It’s less the story of a woman taking a year off from city life and her husband than it is a pleasant revue of sketches and scenarios on that topic.- Village Voice
- Posted Sep 7, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Village Voice
- Posted Aug 24, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Destin Daniel Cretton’s adaptation of Walls’s book of the same name just often enough bursts to raucous life.- Village Voice
- Posted Aug 9, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
While overstuffed and scattershot, this episodic documentary makes a vital argument: That American popular music, especially the blues and rock ’n’ roll, owe much more to Native Americans than has been commonly credited.- Village Voice
- Posted Jul 27, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
The film creates a conflicting impression: Here’s a committed wonk and public servant seizing every opportunity he can to combat what appears to be the greatest danger facing our planet. But here’s also a man who would sign off on a movie that so often sets aside his message so that we might admire him and his work.- Village Voice
- Posted Jul 27, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
It’s nice to see everyone, but the analysis never runs too deep.- Village Voice
- Posted Jul 20, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Here, as Berry warns, the imagination is limited by the camera. In a world in which I couldn’t buy Berry’s New Collected Poems, I might make an effort to see this again someday, with my eyes shut.- Village Voice
- Posted Jun 29, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Rather than reveal a showman, The Reagan Show in the end imitates one.- Village Voice
- Posted Jun 28, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Village Voice
- Posted Jun 15, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
The movie is glazed in flop sweat, moist with the producers’ fear that if the wildness lets up for a heartbeat, we’ll be bored.- Village Voice
- Posted Jun 14, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
The proportions of good parts to not are more generous than they’ve been in years, though there’s still much too much of the usual undead sea dogs killing their prisoners and rumbling on about curses.- Village Voice
- Posted May 23, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
On occasion, director Degan attempts to capture the plant's power via psychedelic montage, layering colors over jungle footage and Freeman's home movies, but more fascinating are the details of the rituals, the river-trek photography, Freeman's frankness about his struggles with depression, and Degan's quick portraits of the people Freeman meets along his way — none of whom gets enough screen time.- Village Voice
- Posted May 11, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Other than a from-nowhere burst of violence that nearly destroys the movie, Lowriders is a refreshingly muted celebration of family and forgiveness, of honoring your roots while being yourself.- Village Voice
- Posted May 11, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Liman, for all his action acuity, struggles to make lying behind a wall exciting. He manages some tense and rousing sequences, but between them yawn scenes of the killer jabbering bullshit and the hero passing in and out of consciousness.- Village Voice
- Posted May 9, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
It's not for nothing that generation and generic share a root; the characters scan as vague, of-their-age types, despite having each been dressed up with superficial quirks.- Village Voice
- Posted May 3, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Ponsoldt’s film is caught between comedy and paranoid thriller. I fear he half-asses the latter.- Village Voice
- Posted Apr 28, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Village Voice
- Posted Apr 26, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
LA 92 is about what this all looked like on TV, a sort of Los Angeles Burns Itself.- Village Voice
- Posted Apr 20, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Gere jabbers amusingly, and there's something touching in his Norman's persistence.- Village Voice
- Posted Apr 13, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
It’s hard not to wish, as Scheinfeld's restless film hustles along to touch its next base, that we could just sit and listen to more from Shorter, who actually has insight to share. Lord knows the movie won’t make time to let us hear some John Coltrane.- Village Voice
- Posted Apr 13, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
The talking heads (lower case) are fine, but the dream-drama music-video theater piece of Rock on a gurney while nurses and doctors consult around him takes too much time away from the reason people want to see this: what Rock saw.- Village Voice
- Posted Apr 6, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
The Widers opt for much footage of the still-empty house itself, inside and out, shot by gently gliding cameras. This conveys an appropriate lonely stillness, a sense of a soul wandering a static world, especially in early scenes, but by the end the footage seems repetitious – yes, we’ve nosed around this sad doorway before.- Village Voice
- Posted Mar 29, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Powell can be evasive and embarrassed at times — who wouldn’t be, faced with the worst of your own youthful mind? But Siskel seems to think this film is exposing a monster in the now rather than witnessing a man wrestle with his past selves.- Village Voice
- Posted Mar 21, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
The clock, Cogsworth, serves as a perfect metaphor for the production itself: The movie’s just as poky and lumbering as he is while huffing up the staircase to escort Belle to her bedroom.- Village Voice
- Posted Mar 11, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
This movie's got everything except gravity or a sense of emotional coherence.- Village Voice
- Posted Mar 9, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Everything you would expect happens, but little of it is funny or affecting.- Village Voice
- Posted Mar 2, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
The film is sometimes too sentimental, too predictable in its drift, but electric in individual moments.- Village Voice
- Posted Feb 7, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
The film itself is more a record than a narrative: proof to the future that, yeah, we knew.- Village Voice
- Posted Jan 19, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Davis holds forth memorably on the histories of country, blues, and rock 'n' roll. (He played with Chuck Berry.) But neither he nor Accidental Courtesy has much time to consider the scene with the BLM activists, who, in the film's schematic presentation, get depicted as something like a Klan equivalent — just less friendly.- Village Voice
- Posted Jan 5, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
This paranormal cops-versus-serial-killer procedural is never not ridiculous, but it's often entertaining as well.- Village Voice
- Posted Dec 14, 2016
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
The movie — at first scrappy and strange but an increasingly tough sit as it goes — never fixes its gaze on any singularly compelling idea.- Village Voice
- Posted Dec 8, 2016
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Commercial filmmaking still fumbles interiority and moral complexity. So it’s fortunate for the filmmakers that Brierley's book also is thick with the kinds of things that crowdpleasers ace.- Village Voice
- Posted Nov 24, 2016
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
The Birth of a Nation offers a troubling tangle of the personal and historical. But above all else it's commercial, an entertainment of purpose and some power. Parker knows how to juice a crowd.- Village Voice
- Posted Oct 6, 2016
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
The movie is fascinating in its approach to legal arguments, forensic evidence, and the uses and abuses of history — but, like the courtroom at its center, it doesn't have much feel for the feels.- Village Voice
- Posted Sep 29, 2016
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Passage to Mars is almost apologetic about being stuck on our world; to make up for it, it continually cuts to digital explorations of Mars itself, while Quinto asks more haunting questions. It's a thrill to see so careful a re-creation — and some actual footage — of Martian geography.- Village Voice
- Posted Sep 28, 2016
- Read full review
-
- Village Voice
- Posted Sep 28, 2016
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
You get enough of a sense of this place and these men — and that widow! — that it's a disappointment when, in the end, we just have to watch it all blow to hell.- Village Voice
- Posted Sep 28, 2016
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
It's often more The Office than le Carré, and none of it's anywhere as interesting as the great counter-historical gag at the film's heart.- Village Voice
- Posted Sep 15, 2016
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Come What May stirs little suspense or unease as it cuts between these stories.- Village Voice
- Posted Sep 9, 2016
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Occasionally, Noah, who wrote and directed, hits onto something that feels like life.- Village Voice
- Posted Aug 30, 2016
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
It's all sickeningly accomplished, with incidents so tense and audacious that you might not have the headspace to wonder until afterwards, "Hey, wait, what was the point in grinding us through so many terrifying minutes of that?"- Village Voice
- Posted Aug 9, 2016
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
The city and the plot points wheel right by, the leads fetchingly entranced with each other. If one patch of dares disappoints, there's another coming right up, and the directors stage and shoot them with swooning neon kinecticism.- Village Voice
- Posted Jul 27, 2016
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
Meyers allows takes to run long, staging naturalistic conversations on sidewalks and in apartments. The result is hit or miss: We may not know what the characters feel, but we're way up to speed on how many steps it takes them to walk to a bar.- Village Voice
- Posted Jul 14, 2016
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
The fights are quick and brutal and bloodless, with too much slo-mo and sped-up stuff, and some clever camera angles that get cut from before you can work out what you're looking at.- Village Voice
- Posted Jun 29, 2016
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
The movie gets wilder and weirder as it goes.... But then, at some point, it all gets ponderous, especially all the vague political machinations.- Village Voice
- Posted Jun 2, 2016
- Read full review
-
- Alan Scherstuhl
When it slows down, when it gives you time to think, Popstar reveals its weaknesses.- Village Voice
- Posted Jun 1, 2016
- Read full review