- Network: Apple TV
- Series Premiere Date: Apr 29, 2026
Critic Reviews
- Critic score
- Publication
- By date
-
The failure to flesh out the population of Widow’s Bay beyond a handful of characters doesn’t just undermine its sense of place. It deprives the show of something every good horror story needs: victims. Although the season grows eerier as Tom discovers more of the island’s dreadful backstory, it’s rare that anything terrible happens to anyone we truly care about.
-
Where other actors might play the part of a straight man surrounded by hysterical weirdos, well, straight, Rhys is always dropping hints that Tom’s sanity is more fragile than it looks. Yet the show is more a jumble of stylish allusions and skillful performances than it is a transformative work unto itself.
-
Another example of those semi-generic, too-teased-out streaming mysteries that have become plentiful.
-
While never as scary nor funny as it could be, "Widow's Bay" is still an enjoyable place to visit, with enough Stephen King-ish shenanigans going on to keep horror fans interested, even if they've encountered a lot of what's being offered here before.