Making a Murderer

:

Season 1
  • Network: Netflix
  • Series Premiere Date: Dec 18, 2015
Season #: 2, 1
User Score
9.0

Universal acclaim- based on 315 Ratings

User score distribution:
  1. Positive: 290 out of 315
  2. Mixed: 11 out of 315
  3. Negative: 14 out of 315
Watch Now

Where To Watch

Stream On

Review this tv show

  1. Your Score
    0 out of 10
    Rate this:
    • 10
    • 9
    • 8
    • 7
    • 6
    • 5
    • 4
    • 3
    • 2
    • 1
    • 0
    • 0
  1. Submit
  2. Check Spelling

User Reviews

view
per page
  1. anhelus
    Jan 13, 2016
    10
    I always thought, as an Italian citizen, we had some of the worst and most corrupted justice systems in the whole world. Well, after seeing Making a Murderer, I must admit the U.S. justice system is worse than ours. Intentionally neglecting so many evidences is typical of dictatorships, and is not well suited with the (self-given) definition of "leaders of the free world".
  2. OscarTheGrouch
    Jan 1, 2016
    10
    I don't normally give a 10 score to anything I've seen, however I could not agree more with another review that this should be required viewing for any person really.

    As you watch this documentary you will be amazed how at first an innocent man is kept in jail for countless years for a crime he did not commit. In which the law enforcers, either by incompetence or downright corruption,    I don't normally give a 10 score to anything I've seen, however I could not agree more with another review that this should be required viewing for any person really.

    As you watch this documentary you will be amazed how at first an innocent man is kept in jail for countless years for a crime he did not commit. In which the law enforcers, either by incompetence or downright corruption, keep this man in jail despite having credible signs he was not the culprit. Only to have your jaw fall off when after he has been cleared for the initial crime, the same people who covered up his innocence are the ones in charge of the investigation of the murder.

    Despite there being a huge conflict of interest, which even they themselves admit to when they publically dismiss themselves from the case, they not only remain on the case after they said they would not participate: they are also coincidently the ones who find the "proof" that the protaganist was guilty. The exact same people who were in danger of being found guilty of keeping said (innocent) man in jail in a previous case. The exact same people.

    This documentary is a very depressing look at the failure of the Wisconsin justice system; a failure to correct any neglicence/corruption in the system due to colleagues protecting their peers from seeing any consequence for their wrongdoings. And really a failure of humanity that a seemingly innocent man can not only be locked up once for a crime he did not commit, but twice in his life.    … Expand
  3. phj1986
    Jan 17, 2016
    10
    Great documentary. I hope Brendan gets out and fulfils his dreams of having a family. My heart reaches out to him. I do not believe Steven was involved and certainly do not believe he had a fair trial. im looking at this Colborn and Lenk for answers. I am sure they have reason to want Avery in prison (as he was suing them for millions) and I am sure they know more than they want us toGreat documentary. I hope Brendan gets out and fulfils his dreams of having a family. My heart reaches out to him. I do not believe Steven was involved and certainly do not believe he had a fair trial. im looking at this Colborn and Lenk for answers. I am sure they have reason to want Avery in prison (as he was suing them for millions) and I am sure they know more than they want us to know. I hope these corrupt police officers are put in the spotlight (and ultimately destroyed) just like Ken Kratz was.… Expand
  4. cassioguiot
    Dec 21, 2015
    10
    I'm absolutely scared. The justice don't failed? Really? I think not. Great documentary and impressive production. On target! Really really good Netflix!
  5. foxgrove
    Feb 13, 2016
    8
    Like one reviewer has already stated this is a true horror film. Observing the activities and lack of compassion of a corrupt and complacent police force is anger inducing and terrifying. This is a series that I am pretty much forcing myself to watch out of duty more than anything else. As entertainment it is compelling, but an an extremely difficult watch.
  6. avan1976
    Feb 10, 2016
    10
    The most captivating show I have watched in a long time. Completely addicted. My heart was pounding during some of the court scene, where those involved had everything on the line. The show is totally enthralling as a whodunit, but also reveals the severe failings of the criminal justice system in the US, where police (rather than courts) act as judge and jury. The show reminds us of theThe most captivating show I have watched in a long time. Completely addicted. My heart was pounding during some of the court scene, where those involved had everything on the line. The show is totally enthralling as a whodunit, but also reveals the severe failings of the criminal justice system in the US, where police (rather than courts) act as judge and jury. The show reminds us of the immense power the state has over the individual (even in the country like the US which proudly exclaims the rights of the individual). If you are young, dumb (let alone Black) and the cops decide you did something that you didn't, your chances of getting justice seem slim.
    This show reminds me of The Jinx, which I also loved. Watching these two show together highlights the opposite scenario; how those with deep pockets and a keen mind can twist the system with impunity.
    If I was going to compare the shows, I would say Making a Murderer is more gripping throughout , but The Jinx has the better climax.    … Expand
  7. Evic21
    Jan 8, 2016
    8
    This show is highly engrossing because there is so much evidence that contradicts itself in general. If the police did frame him, this was a highly elaborate plan that needed a lot of thought and people to pull it off. It can be overwhelming at times and is not necessarily "binge worthy" to me, but with some breaks in between episodes, it can make you think for yourself about what youThis show is highly engrossing because there is so much evidence that contradicts itself in general. If the police did frame him, this was a highly elaborate plan that needed a lot of thought and people to pull it off. It can be overwhelming at times and is not necessarily "binge worthy" to me, but with some breaks in between episodes, it can make you think for yourself about what you think really went down, and then once again, you find yourself stumped and questioning what you actually believe.… Expand
  8. MEFzelder
    May 22, 2016
    9
    "Making a Murderer" es un ejemplo del fuerte calibre que tiene el periodismo de investigación, éste documental nos presenta a Steven Avery, una víctima del sistema judicial que tuvo que vivir más tiempo en prisión que en libertad por la negligencia policial.
    La producción de Netflix centra el material en el juicio que tiene que atravesar la familia Avery para probar la libertad de su hijo    "Making a Murderer" es un ejemplo del fuerte calibre que tiene el periodismo de investigación, éste documental nos presenta a Steven Avery, una víctima del sistema judicial que tuvo que vivir más tiempo en prisión que en libertad por la negligencia policial.
    La producción de Netflix centra el material en el juicio que tiene que atravesar la familia Avery para probar la libertad de su hijo por segunda vez, porque tras un largo periodo en prisión la ciencia le permitió una segunda oportunidad a Steven.
    A lo largo de los episodios uno puede ver cómo el nuevo caso que vincula a Steven ha sufrido de muchas irregularidades y los medios han tomado una postura que no beneficia a su defensa, y todo suma para que al final uno espere a ver cómo lo defienden sus abogados.
    En general es un documental muy detallado, que puede generar una nueva postura sobre lo que pudo pasar y como la justicia aún del primer mundo está corrupta.    … Expand
  9. tazkhan
    Oct 28, 2018
    10
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Making a Murderer is a harrowing, disturbing and shocking piece of essential filmmaking. It rightly challenges all of us to ask questions of the law and the systems that underpin whilst warning us that we can never take our freedom for granted. In season 2, lawyers for both Brendan and Steve reflect the very best traits of humanity whilst their brilliant legal team's fight for truth and justice against a corrupted system that refuses to support the truth. In the journey of season 2, a few judges offer us a glimmer of hope which is welcomed as we ultimately have to ask ourselves what the point of a Supreme Court is if it refuses to protect the most vulnerable from the most corrupt. The brilliant work done by Kathleen and her Team uncovers the likely killer whose new interview by Manitowoc Sheriffs Dept shows that even all of these years later that counties public services are corrupt to the core. Sadly the corruption cannot be challenged because those who perpetrate it hide behind the grief faced by Terresa Holbocks family. At the sametime, Steve sister tragically refuses to recognise that she will have to make some tough choices about who it is she wants to believe in future. As it stands she is praying for one son to come out of prison not accepting that the other one put him there. The story exposes the best and worst of humanity and the story will continue to have lessons for us all for many years to come. One can only hope that they are both freed and that the real killer and those responsible for corruption that hid the killer away do ultimately face justice. Certainly, the series sends the guilty a warning that the truth is known and that they are increasingly exposed.… Expand
  10. tvguyla
    Oct 28, 2018
    10
    Part 2 is incredibly eye-opening. I went into it thinking I'd be bored based on some reviews I saw - I have no idea what they were talking about. Aside from the fact that situations like this shouldn't be expected to be pure entertainment, Part 2 is an important glimpse into our justice system.

    I have followed Kathleen Zellner for many years and was excited to see her in action. She    Part 2 is incredibly eye-opening. I went into it thinking I'd be bored based on some reviews I saw - I have no idea what they were talking about. Aside from the fact that situations like this shouldn't be expected to be pure entertainment, Part 2 is an important glimpse into our justice system.

    I have followed Kathleen Zellner for many years and was excited to see her in action. She does not disappoint and the evidence she uncovers is infuriating. You'll find yourself in a constant state of controlled rage - which also happens to be the most badass line from Zellner throughout the series.

    There is no lack of sadness seeing what these 2 men are being put through, and the lack of closure for Teresa is heartbreaking, but Zellner's unwavering dedication to the case is the glimmer of hope that'll keep you glued to the screen.

    My only question is - will there be a Part 3? I hope so!    … Expand
  11. Shelleydub
    Oct 29, 2018
    10
    Ashamed of the state of Wisconsin and their lack of integrity to the truth. Very eye opening.
  12. Troublewalking
    Dec 22, 2015
    10
    This is a great crime documentary. After watching this, I can't see how this man and his nephew weren't giving a mistrial. The crime itself has to be one of the most improbable and least motivated crimes in the history of modern justice. Avery was released for a false rape conviction after 18 years in prison. The state of Wisconsin was ready to pay him restitution, and made a law with hisThis is a great crime documentary. After watching this, I can't see how this man and his nephew weren't giving a mistrial. The crime itself has to be one of the most improbable and least motivated crimes in the history of modern justice. Avery was released for a false rape conviction after 18 years in prison. The state of Wisconsin was ready to pay him restitution, and made a law with his name. And yet for no apparent reason he kills a woman who would of left the most obvious trail to him and inexplicably has the time/opportunity and means to cover up the evidence but fails to crush the car in his junk yards crusher. Which is within walking distance of where the car is found. But also some how insidiously raped, slit the throat of the woman, without somehow leaving a blood trail from his bedroom to his garage to the place he supposedly burned the body. Which was moronically within site of his house. Yet somehow the extra police force that had unprecedented access to the property found no DNA, blood, or ballistic evidence to support the case. Until a police officer who was facing a civil case against him for wrongly putting the accused in jail the first time, is somehow allowed on the crime scene. This same man also had access to previous trial DNA which was illegally opened and could have allowed him to plant DNA evidence. And then this extremely biased man who has more motive to nail the accused somehow is the only person who stumbles across keys and a bullet that make this case. All after many other officers missed the evidence after many days. Then in an even more bizarre twist, the ex boyfriend of the dead girl, who was never even questioned for an alibi. Who was estranged, and his girlfriend was living with another man and had motive and opportunity to kill her wasn't even considered. Then this same ex leads a search group, that miraculously is allowed access to and on an active crime scene. And without knowing the territory finds the deceased's car on a 40 acre lot with 1,000's of cars that all of the police some how missed, in less than 15 minutes. Then throw in the nephew making an obviously forced and inaccurate confession, and then both men going to jail for life. And you have possibly one of the most biased cases in the history of modern justice. As the police department, county courts and the local population were facing bankruptcy of their county if they would of had to paid the accused for his wrongful previous conviction. Yet inexplicably this police force, county court system and tainted jury were given unrestricted access to try a man they had plenty of reason to make sure got put away. And they were given this task after they had already dropped the ball horrible in the first case. And possibly with extreme prejudice let the man sit in jail when other police forces thought another man committed the crime. Yet somehow this badly motivated and obviously flawed county was expected to give a fair trial? Shocking.… Expand
  13. Olira
    Dec 22, 2015
    9
    Serial meets The Jinx. So gripping, so depressing, so hard to watch because you can't believe how bad and unfair things can really be but you also stop and question yourself for siding with the protagonist because maybe, just maybe you're wrong, he's guilty.... A MUST watch!
  14. obviouslydone
    Jan 16, 2016
    10
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. I am right now totally done with the American Justice System. What is about the central idea 'innocent until proven guilty'? Well, in this documentation you need to ask yourself, how far can you trust of the sense of justice? I do not want expand it. You can see the series' potential. BUT there is just one of thousand questions I do not want to leave open - it is kind of 'less important' - HOW CAN BRENDAN DASSEY BE PROVEN GUILTY IN MUTILATION AND STEVEN AVERY NOT, IF BRENDAN IS THE KEY WITNESS IN STEVEN AVERYS TRIAL?

    God bless they, S.A. and B.D. - I think they are innocent.

    You need to watch!    … Expand
  15. Prosmooth
    Dec 22, 2015
    10
    Should be required viewing for every American. A documentary about an injustice in Wisconsin. Imagine the West Memphis, Arkansas case and then multiply the corruption in that by about a 1000 percent. This is a documentary--but I think it's also one of the greatest horror films ever made.
  16. Mitchla
    Dec 25, 2015
    10
    The filmmakers are granted rare, intimate footage into the inner workings of a murder "investigation" trial and the result is absolutely riveting television -- I couldn't stop watching. This important document is an incredible indictment of the criminal justice system -- it must be seen by everyone.
  17. Knighthawk81
    Dec 21, 2015
    8
    Real crime tales are all the rage right now, and "Making A Murderer" is Netflix attempt to jump into those crowded waters. The first two episodes I watched were riveting and do a good job of introducing the world, the people involved, and the crux of the narrative drama. It's a show that's about a miscarriage of justice -- or so it seems at the outset -- and one that draws you in and makesReal crime tales are all the rage right now, and "Making A Murderer" is Netflix attempt to jump into those crowded waters. The first two episodes I watched were riveting and do a good job of introducing the world, the people involved, and the crux of the narrative drama. It's a show that's about a miscarriage of justice -- or so it seems at the outset -- and one that draws you in and makes you want to see how it turns out.… Expand
  18. Samsonyte
    Jan 9, 2016
    10
    if you want to see true evil that exists in this world then look no further, this will pull at your heart strings in the deepest of manners, it will upset you it will make you want to smash your tv. the true power of propaganda, manipulation and corruption are here to see in the most transparent of forms. it gave me a true sense what the system can do to a family if it is not seen in theif you want to see true evil that exists in this world then look no further, this will pull at your heart strings in the deepest of manners, it will upset you it will make you want to smash your tv. the true power of propaganda, manipulation and corruption are here to see in the most transparent of forms. it gave me a true sense what the system can do to a family if it is not seen in the right light, what people with power are capable of, if they striving forward with ignorance, fear and prejudice. when the truth of it all or lack of it seeps into your skin, you might realize that things need to change but whats first is needed is a change of perspective and if you need that then you need to watch this.… Expand
  19. shoulderoforion
    Jan 10, 2016
    9
    If you watch this and aren't disgusted by the entire State of Wisconsin criminal justice system & State government entire, I don't know what's wrong with you. Obviously the filmmakers had a story to tell & they told it so well it would make the most disinterested livid. I'd like to see what happens when these cases are reopened, I hope this film does the trick. Good weekend bingeIf you watch this and aren't disgusted by the entire State of Wisconsin criminal justice system & State government entire, I don't know what's wrong with you. Obviously the filmmakers had a story to tell & they told it so well it would make the most disinterested livid. I'd like to see what happens when these cases are reopened, I hope this film does the trick. Good weekend binge watching material.… Expand
  20. CarribeanDean
    Jan 1, 2016
    10
    WOW. I love a good forensic documentary, but when it started I couldn't imagine 1 case being 10 hours of watching. It was the fastest 10 hours ever. Excellent
  21. pdesaab07
    Jan 13, 2016
    9
    SImply watch it and make up your mind about it. Bravo to Moira Demos and Laura Ricciardi, this is a great documentary, very well edited. A story like this should have been out years ago !!
  22. RvwFromUpHere
    Jan 4, 2016
    10
    Who: The world's unluckiest man as himself
    What: The greatest Documentary since Thin Blue Line
    Where: A county in Wisconsin that has to be run by the cops from Super Troopers When (will I be addicted to this show): Around episode three you are so dumbfounded by these real life events that you will be unable to turn away Why: If you like watching terrible things happen to seemingly    Who: The world's unluckiest man as himself
    What: The greatest Documentary since Thin Blue Line
    Where: A county in Wisconsin that has to be run by the cops from Super Troopers
    When (will I be addicted to this show): Around episode three you are so dumbfounded by these real life events that you will be unable to turn away
    Why: If you like watching terrible things happen to seemingly innocent people, like Game of Thrones, this show is for you. Except in this show, the victims are real as opposed to Game of Thrones where they're pretend, but we still care about them more than real people    … Expand
  23. gmonster320
    Jan 3, 2016
    6
    Making A Murderer" is for sure a thought provoking examination of the criminal justice system. How many other innocent people are in jail for crimes they didnt commit? It's pretty scary stuff.

    My issue with the show involves it's structure and the opinions presented. Full disclosure here. I previously knew about the case (and my view may be skewed). I also only watched four of the ten    Making A Murderer" is for sure a thought provoking examination of the criminal justice system. How many other innocent people are in jail for crimes they didnt commit? It's pretty scary stuff.

    My issue with the show involves it's structure and the opinions presented. Full disclosure here. I previously knew about the case (and my view may be skewed). I also only watched four of the ten total episodes. To be honest, I was kinda bored. The script needs to be tightened. Many of the facts are covered numerous times. Lots of courtroom footage is used.

    Even though "MoaM" is presented as a documentary, the filmmakers (Laura Ricciardi and Moira Demos) obviously believe Avery is innocent. I would have liked a more balanced presentation of the material.

    They also lose sight of the fact that there is more than one victim in this story. Yes, the false imprisonment of Avery for the first crime is inexcusable but what does the evidence point to in the second crime? ...And no, we dont want to hear any crazy convoluted conspiracy theories. Just the facts please. Three quick points:

    1. DNA- In these post CSI/NCIS days, Americans seem to think DNA can be used to solve EVERY crime. That is simply not true.
    2. Motive- A common argument for Avery's innocence is that there was no motive. Many crimes are those of opportunity. There is no pre-planned motive. They see a weak/isolated victim and go for it.
    3. Stupid Criminals- Surely Avery would not be stupid enough to leave all that evidence at his house. It happens all the time people. Criminals aren't exactly known for being smart. If they were, they wouldnt have committed the crimes in the first place.    … Expand
  24. Saint_Satan
    Jan 5, 2016
    6
    A one-sided documentary for the brain dead masses that leaves out near all evidence against Avery. The documentary leaves out literally everything about his relationship with Teresa, the women he murdered. This documentary was specifically made to make him look innocent, which he isn't if you had a brain and watched the news or followed the trial. Let's see what they left out shall we?A one-sided documentary for the brain dead masses that leaves out near all evidence against Avery. The documentary leaves out literally everything about his relationship with Teresa, the women he murdered. This documentary was specifically made to make him look innocent, which he isn't if you had a brain and watched the news or followed the trial. Let's see what they left out shall we?

    He bought handcuffs, leg shackles, and chains like Brendan described.
    He called Auto Trader and requested Teresa.
    He called her from a blocked number several times that day.
    Teresa complained to her boss that Avery was a creep that answered the door half naked.

    Let's not forget he doused a cat in oil and threw it in a bonfire, much like the fire used to burn Teresa. He masturbated in public. He pulled a gun on a female. He ran a family member off the road. Avery is a total creep and a murderer.    … Expand
  25. Flibbertygibbet
    Oct 28, 2018
    0
    This is an emotionally manipulative "documentary" told from the point of view of the killer of an innocent young woman, who, like most guilty people in prison, says he's innocent. He's not. Be sure to look into the evidence before you make your mind up, and ask yourself why the people who made the documentary left out facts like his history of domestic violence, sexual deviance, andThis is an emotionally manipulative "documentary" told from the point of view of the killer of an innocent young woman, who, like most guilty people in prison, says he's innocent. He's not. Be sure to look into the evidence before you make your mind up, and ask yourself why the people who made the documentary left out facts like his history of domestic violence, sexual deviance, and sociopathic behavior.… Expand
  26. alexislee
    Feb 6, 2016
    6
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. I first began to watch this documentary series because all my friends were talking about it and I needed to see what the buzz was all about. Although I did enjoy the first couple of episodes due the interesting and unique nature of situation unfolding, I did feel that ten episodes was a little much and by the end I was utterly bored by the series. Along with that I feel that the series is extremely biased towards one side of the case and only presents the information they want seen. But overall it is an interesting situation to learn about and debate with your friends.… Expand
  27. drazgon
    Aug 10, 2019
    8
    Es realmente impactante ver como funciona el sistema en los USA. Desde luego si ves esta serie como espectador no puedes pensar nada contrario a que este hombre sea inocente.
  28. mikepariscritic
    Mar 11, 2016
    10
    Definitely one of the most compelling legal documentary in years. I was in awe as I watched all 10 episodes in a single sitting. I certainly hope for further episodes if developments occur in this case.
  29. Jspotter89
    Jan 27, 2016
    9
    Making A Murderer is a true-crime documentary that is a lot of things. It is a documentary about one case, specifically that of the murder of Teresa Halbach in 2005. It is largely presented from the perspective of the defense, which is where many of its critics come from. They are absolutely correct when they call it "one-sided," however it clearly was not made to be a perfectly balancedMaking A Murderer is a true-crime documentary that is a lot of things. It is a documentary about one case, specifically that of the murder of Teresa Halbach in 2005. It is largely presented from the perspective of the defense, which is where many of its critics come from. They are absolutely correct when they call it "one-sided," however it clearly was not made to be a perfectly balanced view of the events. The access to the Avery family and Steven Avery's defense team is almost unprecedented, and there is no such access to the Halbach family or the law enforcement/prosecution team. Whether this was because said access was denied, or never requested, is not abundantly clear.

    In any case, the documentary focuses on Steven Avery, a poor and slow-witted Wisconsin man imprisoned for 18 years on a rape and attempted murder that he did not commit. When DNA evidence proved his innocence beyond doubt, he commenced a civil suit against the county for pressing the case against him despite evidence that pointed to someone else.

    The same month that his $36 million civil suit was deposing the officers in question, a young woman disappears after being on the Avery property. What happened that day is unclear, but in the events that followed, Steven Avery was arrested and charged with her murder. Her vehicle is found on his property with his blood in it. They car key shows up in his trailer. Her burned bones are found in a burn pit 50 feet from his garage. And worst of all, his borderline mentally retarded nephew confesses to helping him rape and murder the woman.

    But all is not as it appears to be. The vehicle was found on his property, but the property was an auto salvage lot with a car-crusher...why would he not have used that to dispose of the vehicle? His blood was found in the vehicle, but where did the blood come from? One of the officers deposed in his civil suit had knowledge of a vial of his blood in the county clerk's office and there was substantial evidence to show that vial was tampered with. The car key was found in his trailer with his DNA on it, but why was it found on the 7th search when it was supposedly in clear view? And why was it found only by two officers deposed in his civil suit a few weeks before? And why did it have none of Halbach's DNA on it if it was a key she used regularly? Her burned bones were found outside his garage, but was that where the body was originally disposed? There were three locations on the property where her bones were found, and no one could say for sure which one was the burn site. Why was not one person who knew Teresa ever considered a suspect, and why was no one else on the Avery property that day looked at despite some suspicious behaviors?

    And finally, his nephew, Brendan Dassey, at the time a 16-year old with no criminal record who by even the most generous descriptions was extremely slow, intellectually. His "confession," elicited by professional investigators without an attorney present, revealed that he and Avery raped and murdered her in his trailer and garage, yet not a single piece of physical evidence confirmed her presence in either location. (Brendan is currently serving a life sentence as well for this crime). Was Steven Avery brilliant enough to clean these two locations of blood evidence to a professional standard and then not bothered to even give her car a cursory wipe-down?

    At its heart, Making A Murderer is a cautionary tale. It is a warning that the American justice system is imperfect and frequently subject to the darker sides of human nature, despite the precautions in place to prevent that. Is the presumption of innocence possible in cases that are heavily publicized before they go to trial? Does law enforcement engage in duplicitous behavior in the search for a suspect on occasion? Do they have a false sense of certainty when it comes to who they "like" for committing a crime? Does this occasionally lead to "tunnel vision," or the failure to follow promising leads if they don't point to a favored suspect? And when and if law enforcers do stray into the illegal to secure a conviction of a desired suspect, is there anything resembling oversight in place to correct any wrongs done? And most importantly, does our jury system function the way it's supposed to? Do jurors really convict only when they have proof beyond a reasonable doubt, or do they convict when they feel that it might be more likely than not that a person has committed the crime?

    The Avery case is a perfect case to focus on to pose these questions to a broad audience. It seems clear that what took place on October 31, 2005 was not what the State attempted to (and did) prove. And so, guilty of the murder or not, Steven Avery and Brendan Dassey will likely sit in prison until they die despite all the unanswered questions.    … Expand
  30. silverado
    Feb 1, 2016
    10
    Making A Murderer is a meticulously crafted documentary series that provides deep insight into America's crazy juridical system as well as poor and uneducated lives being their victims.
  31. ckeitel
    Feb 2, 2016
    10
    First off for anyone who is into law and order and the first 48 will really enjoy this documentary. Making a Murderer is a 10 episode season that will have any viewer sitting on the edge of his/her seat wanting to know more. Steven Avery is the center of attention in this documentary, he is a man that was wrongly convicted of murder and sent to prison for life. More than 15 years afterFirst off for anyone who is into law and order and the first 48 will really enjoy this documentary. Making a Murderer is a 10 episode season that will have any viewer sitting on the edge of his/her seat wanting to know more. Steven Avery is the center of attention in this documentary, he is a man that was wrongly convicted of murder and sent to prison for life. More than 15 years after going to prison Avery was found innocent, wrongly convicted and released from jail.

    Avery found himself in jail no more than a week after being released for another murder brought upon him. This is were the 10 episode series becomes intriguing and baffling. This is a documentary that deals with crime, law enforcement, and the murder of one innocent woman that really is up to the viewer to wonder who is actually guilty.

    This is great documentary for any mystery seeking viewer who wants to connect the dots and find clues to answer the real question, "is Steven Avery innocent?"    … Expand
  32. EPMD
    May 19, 2018
    7
    The show is about twice as long as it needs to be, and the presentation of the case was completely misleading in some key areas. Nevertheless, it's one of the most compelling things I have seen on TV in years. I think it's a must watch even with those two key flaws. Just be sure to research the case on your own afterward to get a truer sense of reality.
  33. biltagi04
    Oct 29, 2018
    10
    my goodness, this documentary is both insanely good, and sad. The best true crime documentary out there. It purely sheds light on the truth of this nightmare of a case. Its infuriating to say the least. The American criminal justice system is so corrupt, twisted, and flat out wrong for convicting Steven and Brenden to life for a crime they did not commit. I highly recommend you to watchmy goodness, this documentary is both insanely good, and sad. The best true crime documentary out there. It purely sheds light on the truth of this nightmare of a case. Its infuriating to say the least. The American criminal justice system is so corrupt, twisted, and flat out wrong for convicting Steven and Brenden to life for a crime they did not commit. I highly recommend you to watch this documentary and be angry at how they were 100% framed.… Expand
  34. FFinklestein
    Oct 28, 2018
    10
    An absolute real life Shock and Awe into exposing police and prosecutorial misconduct. Luckily the story comes with a real life Super Hero, Kathleen Zellner
  35. Isaiah1108
    Oct 28, 2018
    10
    The second season just adds more mystery and asks good questions. I wish we would find out what really happened to poor Teresa...
  36. gilmours2728
    Oct 28, 2018
    10
    Making a Murderer returns and covers Brendan Dassey and Steven Avery's post-conviction appeals. Put simply, a must see.
  37. STLMarvel
    Oct 28, 2018
    10
    I didn't think part 2 could be as gripping and intense as part 1 but I was wrong. Kathleen is the hero everyone needed to know still existed in today's corrupt world. The new evidence and testing they go into is detailed and interesting. I really hope there is a part 3
  38. StrangePanda
    Oct 28, 2018
    10
    Amazing documentary, but it also leaves me so heart broken and makes me so disgusted with how much evidence was with held from the trial, Kratz and any one else involved should be held accountable for destroying these families. I also do not understand how they denied the county coroner access to the site the bones were found. i can they legally do that? THE TRUTH WILL COME OUT!!!
  39. guardianwyf
    Oct 28, 2018
    10
    I must admit I was so skeptical the first season! I watched it and within three episodes I couldn't stop! i have fully become addicted to the love for the Avery Family! A story you won't soon forget. By the end...you won't doubt it either....
  40. paytonnatella
    Oct 28, 2018
    10
    This documentary opened my eyes to the corruption of our justice system. I can not believe the cops and lawyers involved have not gotten in trouble. 2 innocent people are living in hell while the real crooks live free. Honestly makes me disappointed to be in American with a justice system as jacked up as ours. Kathleen Zellner is a god sent. EVERYONE NEEDS TO WATCH
  41. jchappel
    Oct 28, 2018
    9
    This fascinating documentary follows Steven Avery, a poor white Wisconsin man, who was wrongly accused of a murder and rape and served 18 years behind bars only to be exonerated by DNA evidence. Despite his exoneration, when a murder and rape happens near his family's property, he is once against convicted despite the questionable nature of much of the evidence. After serving over 10 yearsThis fascinating documentary follows Steven Avery, a poor white Wisconsin man, who was wrongly accused of a murder and rape and served 18 years behind bars only to be exonerated by DNA evidence. Despite his exoneration, when a murder and rape happens near his family's property, he is once against convicted despite the questionable nature of much of the evidence. After serving over 10 years for this second allegation, MaM2 traces the efforts of two teams of lawyers, one of SA and the other for his nephew, Brendan Dassey, who was pulled into the murder/rape allegation when, under duress from police officers, he confessed to raping and murderer the woman in question, Teresa Halbach. This despite the fact that there was zero forensic evidence corroborating anything he said. Making a Murderer 1 and 2 is ultimately about the flawed justice system in the US and the nature of wrongful convictions. Grieving families want closure. Police departments want a "win"--and will do anything to pin the blame on someone. The amazing efforts of Kathleen Zellner, an expert in post-conviction acquittals, leads the unraveling of the case, and is a modern-day Sherlock Holmes, laying bare the absurdity of much of the evidence and offering clear evidence pointing to other suspects. The only reason I give it a 9, rather than a 10, is because it does not really reflect too much on the larger implications of the case. That will have to be for the reviewers, I guess. Rather, it just presents true crime fiction, and the story is fascinating, because there are so many grubby hands who've gotten involved in this case, and we don't yet know what actually happened or how the will turn out.… Expand
  42. FanaDisney
    Oct 29, 2018
    10
    These court cases have been a part of my life since 2007 way before the making a murderer programme came on Netflix. I cannot believe they are still in prison for a crime they did NOT commit. Ken Kratz is going all out to keep them in but the truth is starting to unfold and YOU are going to be the one behind bars! With no followers and no one to help you..

    I would highly recommend this    These court cases have been a part of my life since 2007 way before the making a murderer programme came on Netflix. I cannot believe they are still in prison for a crime they did NOT commit. Ken Kratz is going all out to keep them in but the truth is starting to unfold and YOU are going to be the one behind bars! With no followers and no one to help you..

    I would highly recommend this to anyone but be prepared it may consume your life and you might get hooked.    … Expand
  43. Jonmccx
    Oct 29, 2018
    10
    After watching both seasons, I am left with controlled rage as Kathleen puts it. She is doing a great job! Keep powering through! This is a great portrait of a failed system. This case is only one...think of all the other similar cases out there that have not had the benefit of being such a high profile case as this one. Our state and federal standards for incarcereration and for stateAfter watching both seasons, I am left with controlled rage as Kathleen puts it. She is doing a great job! Keep powering through! This is a great portrait of a failed system. This case is only one...think of all the other similar cases out there that have not had the benefit of being such a high profile case as this one. Our state and federal standards for incarcereration and for state prosecutors are apparently non-existent. This type of fraudulent and malicious activity happens everyday at these levels of the system without proper checks and balances.

    Oh, and Ken Kratz (the pedephile sexter) can rot in hell! I bet he regrets what he did now..... Kathleen’s got him by the balls! We’re coming for you...justice will be heard!    … Expand
  44. oskent
    Oct 29, 2018
    10
    Amazing documentary series. This riveting real life crime drama is a must see. The second part focuses more on the broken US justice system where it is an uphill battle for the defendants to prove their innocence in a system that is geared to favour the state and government. One only hopes there is justice in the end. You need to see this!
  45. jencannpro
    Oct 29, 2018
    10
    I thought Season 1 of MaM was astonishing. How can one guy have this much bad luck? To have spent EIGHTEEN years in prison for a rape he didn't commit and then be convicted for the murder of Teresa Halbach? No spoilers here, but as Season 1 shows us what a convoluted mess this case was turned into thanks to the many fabrications of Ken Kratz and Co., Season 2 is jaw dropping. KathleenI thought Season 1 of MaM was astonishing. How can one guy have this much bad luck? To have spent EIGHTEEN years in prison for a rape he didn't commit and then be convicted for the murder of Teresa Halbach? No spoilers here, but as Season 1 shows us what a convoluted mess this case was turned into thanks to the many fabrications of Ken Kratz and Co., Season 2 is jaw dropping. Kathleen Zellner is like a dog with a bone. Her steely resolve and attention to detail, details and evidence which the defense missed the first time around and which the prosecution chose to hide or leave out, has been uncovered. It doesn't take a rocket scientist to know why the state of Wisconsin and this sad little county want to keep Steven Avery and Brendan Dassey behind bars. This case is a great example of how people like Avery and Dassey - people who are considered "unfortunates" in this world by many- can be taken advantage of and railroaded by corrupt law enforcement. Kathleen Zellner has done the work and thorough research that should have been done the first time around. If the State of Wisconsin is so sure of their guilt, why are they so unwilling to grant a re-trial? *rhetorical* I believe the truth will eventually win in this case.… Expand
  46. rootje92
    Oct 29, 2018
    10
    One of the best tv shows I've ever seen! But it makes me sick and angry that the system is so corrupt. I will always support SA and BD!
    They deserve a new trial
  47. ThorZ
    Oct 29, 2018
    9
    First of all there shouldn't have been a number 2 because there was so much reasonable doubt in trial any normal Jury would have said not guilty. As it happens Netflix went and made a number 2 and it is a very interesting watch. It makes you understand how broken the justice system is in the USA, especially in Manitowoc Country & Minnesota as a whole. If i lived there i wouldn't be forFirst of all there shouldn't have been a number 2 because there was so much reasonable doubt in trial any normal Jury would have said not guilty. As it happens Netflix went and made a number 2 and it is a very interesting watch. It makes you understand how broken the justice system is in the USA, especially in Manitowoc Country & Minnesota as a whole. If i lived there i wouldn't be for much longer.

    The 10 episodes weaves you through the various trials and tribulations of the Dasey case which is exhausting and frustrating to say the least and not because the film makers made it that way, in fact is testament to them on making this thread of the story so interesting because its just a comical farce on how the court system works. Credit to his lawyers for their efforts here, Laura Nirider looked visibly frustrated but defiant by the end and had every right to. Ever tried banging your head against a solid oak tree so many times only to see its still be a stubborn old thing and not moving? That's how she and her team felt im sure.....

    While this is going on Steven Avery's case is a lot more interesting as Kathleen Zellner and team decides to do the work of the police and the prosecution... and actually investigate the murder rather than lazily accept circumstantial evidence. While doing this she uncovers even more evidence that casts reasonable doubt upon the conviction, which will have you watching more and more in a controlled rage. its quite astounding how far the country and state will go to not have a re trial.

    Not quite a 10/10, mainly due to a lot of filler content needing to be put in there but it doesn't detract from the purpose of the series enough to make it annoying.    … Expand
  48. ZenaCaldwell
    Oct 29, 2018
    10
    This documentary unveils a total miscarriage of justice! It is appalling that Mr. Kratz concealed evidence from Mr. Avery’s defense team! How do these people sleep at night? It is also a disgrace that law enforcement took advantage of Brendan Dassey’s disabilities and put him behind bars! Now not one, but two victims of this corrupt system are suffering for a crime they did not commit!This documentary unveils a total miscarriage of justice! It is appalling that Mr. Kratz concealed evidence from Mr. Avery’s defense team! How do these people sleep at night? It is also a disgrace that law enforcement took advantage of Brendan Dassey’s disabilities and put him behind bars! Now not one, but two victims of this corrupt system are suffering for a crime they did not commit! Let’s also not forget that the real murderer for Teresa Halbach is still out living their life in the free world while the innocent pay the price! I’m sure her family would like to seek justice for her murderer which clearly is not Steve Avery or Brendan Dassey! I pray that Mr. and Mrs. Avery get to see their son released before they pass from this world. I pray the same for Brendan’s parents.… Expand
  49. Retief
    Oct 29, 2018
    10
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. I rarely watch documentaries. But Making A Murderer had me riveted to my couch and binge watching both seasons. Although I'm sure the Netflix documentarians had to leave out compelling elements from both the prosecution and defense, for pacing and time reasons, I am more than convinced the State of Wisconsin and some of their officials and officers are complicit in ramrodding through the unlawful convictions of Steven Avery and Brendan Dassey. They just HAD to know that Avery and Dassey were innocent ... because they knew who had really killed Ms. Halbach. And for that: Shame on them!… Expand
  50. lbanigan
    Oct 29, 2018
    10
    Making a murderer season 1
    Making a murderer season 2
    Loved it. Ready for Justice!
  51. Pixietigerlily
    Oct 29, 2018
    10
    The best docuseries EVER! I’m fascinated by the sleazey lawmakers of Winsconsin and the barbaric American legal system although I read that KTZ says some states are not at all like WIN. Poor Steve and Brendan, but I recognise that they are only the two we know about, there will be 1000s more locked up whose names we don’t know. Well done Moria and Laura!
  52. sonicgumel
    Oct 30, 2018
    10
    This is the best documentary I have ever watched. i gave it 10 rating because it truly captures the rot within America's justice system and shows the human side of the consequences of miscarriage of justice through the Steven Avery case. Absolutely must watch!
  53. Cristian212
    Oct 30, 2018
    10
    Best indepth documentary, especially part 2, part 1 was really good and fascinating but part 2 takes it to a whole other level, Kathleen Zellner is a boss, the prosecution isn’t ready for her and her actual experts.
  54. radical92
    Oct 31, 2018
    10
    Making a murderer 1 &2 reveals the story and truth behind the FALSE Imprisonment of Steven Avery and Brenden Dassey. Not to mention the cover ups and lies that are exposed by Kathleen Zellner. Wisconsin has DIRTY Corrupt Cops, DA and AG I'm embarrassed to live in this State. Be prepared to have righteous anger for 2 innocent people that should be set free.
  55. Mattieboosh
    Oct 31, 2018
    10
    A fantastically compelling documentary, showing many pieces of evidence, clear to all who watch that these guys are innocent.
  56. ktoy1940
    Nov 3, 2018
    10
    I thought the first season was riveting and had me at the edge of my seat & then I saw the second season and I'm not sure my jaw ever left the floor. So many mixed emotions while watching this documentary. Anger towards the Wisconsin police department and judges. Saddened for the Avery's. Humored by the stupidity of the Wisconsin police department by the stupid choices they made andI thought the first season was riveting and had me at the edge of my seat & then I saw the second season and I'm not sure my jaw ever left the floor. So many mixed emotions while watching this documentary. Anger towards the Wisconsin police department and judges. Saddened for the Avery's. Humored by the stupidity of the Wisconsin police department by the stupid choices they made and actually thinking they're above everyone and can do whatever they want. Kathleen Zellner is amazing and I know she's going to find justice for Avery and Brendens justice will then follow suit. Ken Kratz is the definition of a joke and I hope he rots in jail for the rest of his life, wouldn't that be ironic?… Expand
  57. benn910
    Nov 3, 2018
    10
    Amazing documentary! A must see series, that will keep you on the edge of your seat.
  58. nisaac86
    Nov 7, 2018
    10
    You'd be an idiot to think this guy was guilty, especially now that Season 2 is out. Anyone with half a brain could see the lack of evidence putting these guys behind bars. The people who think they are guilty, don't actually think they are guilty. They actually just believe so much in their "system" and that there is no way that the cops or county could ever do something as crooked asYou'd be an idiot to think this guy was guilty, especially now that Season 2 is out. Anyone with half a brain could see the lack of evidence putting these guys behind bars. The people who think they are guilty, don't actually think they are guilty. They actually just believe so much in their "system" and that there is no way that the cops or county could ever do something as crooked as this.

    So when you say that he's innocent, you are challenging their belief of the system.    … Expand
  59. geewah
    Jan 6, 2021
    9
    Whilst it maybe one sided it's still a well researched, compelling, edge of the seat docuseries. Raises a lot questions which all good investigative docos should do

Awards & Rankings

19
#19 Best TV Season of 2015
21
#21 Most Discussed TV Season of 2015
28
#28 Most Shared TV Season of 2015

Critic Reviews

All reviews »
Metascore
84

Universal acclaim - based on 21 Critic Reviews

Critic score distribution:
  1. Positive: 21 out of 21
  2. Mixed: 0 out of 21
  3. Negative: 0 out of 21
  1. Uncle Barky
    Reviewed by: Ed Bark
    Jan 4, 2016
    91
    Do expect an absorbing tale of justice rendered but not necessarily justice served. Its star players have no formal acting training. But for better or worse, they all look born to play their real-life roles in another true crime drama that knocks fiction for a loop.
    Read full review
  2. New York Post
    Reviewed by: Robert Rorke
    Jan 4, 2016
    75
    The twists and turns on Making a Murderer are so crazy and real that the series stands on its own.
    Read full review
  3. Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
    Reviewed by: Rob Owen
    Dec 29, 2015
    70
    Overlong compared to the compact, well-edited six hours of "The Jinx," "Making a Murderer" could use a lot of tightening. ... And yet it's a fascinating story.
    Read full review
See all critic reviews »