|
CRITIC SCORE DISTRIBUTION | ||
|
Positive:
14
Mixed:
5
Negative:
2
|
Critic Reviews
Mar 19, 2026
Season 2 Review:
Across the board, the cast is tremendous at building out the stage for this show to highlight Anthony. Against all odds, this has worked—twice now—because the creatives here understands that if they aren’t living every second on the brink of jeopardizing their own experiment, then maybe they are going too easy on themselves.
Read full review
Mar 20, 2026
Season 2 Review:
A delightful continuation of Jury Duty—even if it can’t quite capture the same magic that Season 1 produced. .... Fortunately, the show remains hilarious, with tons of comedic gags, like a bonkers talent show and a series of educational seminars that are anything but. And that’s to say nothing of the eccentric characters Anthony must befriend.
Read full review
RogerEbert.comMar 19, 2026
Season 2 Review:
It’s easy to put these niggling ethical questions aside when “Jury Duty Presents: Company Retreat” manages to pull off the impossible feat of making lightning strike twice. All while making the subject of its deception look not like a rube, but frankly a saint who brings out the best in everyone around him. And to do that while also delivering some deeply cringe laughs is nothing short of miraculous.
Read full review
Apr 5, 2023
Season 1 Review:
In the wrong hands, “Jury Duty” could have come across as mean-spirited and condescending, but the overall tone is almost whimsical, and turns into a toast to a regular guy who faces one dilemma after another and almost always does the right thing. We’ll not say how it all turns out, but it’s a most satisfying and just verdict.
Read full review
Mar 20, 2026
ColliderMar 19, 2026
Apr 14, 2026
Season 2 Review:
It withers under the force of its own unrelenting sunniness. .... It isn’t hard to buy that Anthony’s a good guy, and he’s so charismatic that you can forget, for long stretches of the season, how little else there is to define him. But even as the rest of the ensemble’s subplots become increasingly complex—and their high jinks increasingly overwrought—he remains a blank slate.
Read full review
The GuardianApr 5, 2023
Season 1 Review:
With the head of a hidden-camera prank show, the heart of a workplace sitcom, and the body of a true crime documentary, the boundary-blurring new comedy Jury Duty makes for an odd chimera of genres. ... With no inherent hilarity in his obliviousness, getting the odd laugh falls to the stealth players around him, best among them James Marsden as an insecure, preening, vainglorious parody of himself.
Read full review
Apr 6, 2023
Season 1 Review:
Ronald isn’t a black hole at the center of a show that’s supposed to be about his reactions to stuff, but he’s very much a beige hole. ... This leaves the various actors rather frantically staging a sitcom around a guy who’s just content to be there, even after 17 days of sequestration, and it’s a desperation that causes the format to make very little sense. ... Jury Duty is a bad show for benign reasons.
Read full review
The Daily BeastApr 3, 2023
Current TV Shows
By MetascoreBy User Score