Andor

10

ThemadcowNov 10, 2022

This is an exceptional show. If it wasn't Star Wars, it would still hold up due to the great casting, top-quality dialogue and action set pieces. The initially slow pacing might surprise people, but broadly speaking it is a series of 3This is an exceptional show. If it wasn't Star Wars, it would still hold up due to the great casting, top-quality dialogue and action set pieces. The initially slow pacing might surprise people, but broadly speaking it is a series of 3 episode arcs with a significant payoff in each arc. It's Star Wars for people who love Chernobyl and political drama. The best show this year in a competitive field.… Expand

6 of 7 users found this helpful61

All this user's reviews

9

hammbone18Sep 21, 2022

So far this show is very good. The world actually feels alive. It’s a little slow at first but I thought the slow build up was fine. Might be the best Star Wars content released since Rogue One. Maybe ever.

8 of 14 users found this helpful86

All this user's reviews

9

MrWolf88Nov 9, 2022

When I began watching Andor I was expecting more of the standard Disney/Star Wars action packed recipe, and was initially disappointed after the first few episodes when I realized I wasn't going to get it. I didn't realize at the time thatWhen I began watching Andor I was expecting more of the standard Disney/Star Wars action packed recipe, and was initially disappointed after the first few episodes when I realized I wasn't going to get it. I didn't realize at the time that this series would become my favourite entry in the Star Wars universe, and one that I now fear will be short lived.

For anyone reading this that is on the fence, I urge you to JUST WATCH IT. Even if you have no interest in the Star Wars universe, WATCH IT. Andor is a slow burn of a series that places heavy emphasis on character building and story telling, the action isn't plentiful, but when it appears it's terrific. My greatest fear for this series is that it's splendor will be lost on the masses of Disney subscribers looking for disposable thrills. My eternal thanks go to the producers who stepped out of the box to make this series, and I sincerely hope Disney will see fit to fund several seasons more.… Expand

5 of 6 users found this helpful51

All this user's reviews

10

thoodeeNov 9, 2022

Best recent star wars story telling I’ve seen yet. Please disney produce more of this and more like this.

4 of 5 users found this helpful41

All this user's reviews

10

BrabdockNov 8, 2022

Just an excellent show.....that's it. It's written for the fan who doesn't want to be spoonfed.

6 of 7 users found this helpful61

All this user's reviews

10

Fluid_DynamicsNov 6, 2022

This show is wonderful. This would be a great story even outside of the Star Wars universe, but is even better because it is. Surprisingly, even better than the Mandalorian. It’s amazing this finally exists. Tony Gilroy is one heck of a showThis show is wonderful. This would be a great story even outside of the Star Wars universe, but is even better because it is. Surprisingly, even better than the Mandalorian. It’s amazing this finally exists. Tony Gilroy is one heck of a show runner. This is one of those shows that will have legs for decades to come.… Expand

4 of 5 users found this helpful41

All this user's reviews

10

beast18Nov 5, 2022

Amazing series and production by Gilroy and all actors and crew. Best Star Wars

6 of 7 users found this helpful61

All this user's reviews

10

MarqThomasNov 3, 2022

Incredibly smart, tightly plotted, visually stunning, and thematically rich.

6 of 7 users found this helpful61

All this user's reviews

9

ImmobilienHaiNov 3, 2022

Star Wars for mature, intelligent fans! 9 episodes in and i'm on the edge of my seat. This is like a Tom Clancy novel, detail oriented, smart dialogues, realistic characters, an Empire that is truly threatening and uncompromising, realStar Wars for mature, intelligent fans! 9 episodes in and i'm on the edge of my seat. This is like a Tom Clancy novel, detail oriented, smart dialogues, realistic characters, an Empire that is truly threatening and uncompromising, real stakes. A glimpse into how the rest of the galaxy experiences the Empire's chokehold. Fans aren't treated like lobotomized consumers: no memberberries, no breaking canon, no spectacle without substance, no gaping plotholes, no tearing down of legacy characters. If you enjoyed Book of Boba Fett and Kenobi this is not for you. -1 point simply because it could move a bit faster.… Expand

5 of 6 users found this helpful51

All this user's reviews

9

Fed_PittNov 2, 2022

truly amazing series. If you like SW, it's a must. really good job. Acting, directing, the script, the details .It's not an action-driven series, but it doesn't need to be, like most SW movies and series. I really love it.

5 of 6 users found this helpful51

All this user's reviews

10

devgreNov 1, 2022

I'm so grateful for this iteration of Star Wars story telling. It's masterful writing, music, cinematography and character dynamics take me back to a feeling of a galaxy far, far away that I haven't felt in a long, long time.

8 of 10 users found this helpful82

All this user's reviews

8

BlokinNov 1, 2022

I wasn’t even gonna watch this after the series of disappointments KK’s Lucasfilm had subjected me to. Very pleasant surprise! You can tell that KK had nothing to do with this. Yes, slow paced, but intriguing and captivating. The world feelsI wasn’t even gonna watch this after the series of disappointments KK’s Lucasfilm had subjected me to. Very pleasant surprise! You can tell that KK had nothing to do with this. Yes, slow paced, but intriguing and captivating. The world feels enormous, like a real world, and full of life. I like Rogue One and I like this one.… Expand

5 of 6 users found this helpful51

All this user's reviews

10

JediMosEisleyOct 23, 2022

Andor series is strong on characters & serious acting. Some will miss "baby yoda/little Leia" Disney cuteness but this series is gritty & good.

4 of 6 users found this helpful42

All this user's reviews

6

TristanHemlockOct 30, 2022

Andor... We're again exploring the time span between movies. Fortunately unlike with Obi-Wan, Andor seems to be heading somewhere.

In this show we're seeing how the Rebellion began, and I got to say that I'm amazed the Rebellion ever gotAndor... We're again exploring the time span between movies. Fortunately unlike with Obi-Wan, Andor seems to be heading somewhere.

In this show we're seeing how the Rebellion began, and I got to say that I'm amazed the Rebellion ever got anything done. Seeing its own members are more in it for their own personal reasons, than for the liberation of the galaxy from the rule of the Empire.

Cassian Andor is an interesting character, but he isn't that interesting. If the show was carried only by him, then we would have another flop on our hands. Fortunately we've Luthen Rael (Stellan Skarsgård) and Mon Mothma (Genevieve O'Reilly), giving the show more than Cassian can offer. Although not exactly playing by the same rules Rael and Mothma are clearly crucial pieces of hopefully will become a far more efficient Rebellion than the one shown thus far.

The inner dynamics of the agents of the Empire are also very interesting to observe. Seeing that they show that the Empire only sustained their grip on the galaxy, because of certain key individuals. Without them, Vader and Sidious wouldn't matter for the Empire would've fallen even to a very inefficient Rebellion. The best Imperial characters thus far are Dedra Meero and Major Partagaz. All the other Imperial characters are mainly to give contrast to those two characters.

Andor has enough room to become better, and if it does I'll increase the score I gave it. But if it does not, then I'll have no problem stop seeing it.

Andor so far is only interesting and worth watching because it has lots of potential. If the show will live to that potential, that's another matter altogether… Expand

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

7

TimmooreOct 29, 2022

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Really enjoying it so far. Much prefer the slower pace and character development when compared to shows like kenobi, and boba fett. Not perfect, I'm a bit sick of Disney orphans to be honest. Why does every rebel or hero have to be an orphan or not have proper parents. Literally all the characters in star wars now have such a similar back story it's boring. I don't need to watch more scenes about protagonists without parents who somehow raised themselves without turning into lord of the flies

I find the imperial scenes and storyline more interesting tbh. Almost routing for them which means the writing is good. Would be interesting to see some of the imperial characters empathize with the rebels and vice versa (as people)… Expand

2 of 3 users found this helpful21

All this user's reviews

8

JoGeronimusKerOct 27, 2022

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. REVIEW FOR THE FIRST 8 EPISODES OF THE SERIES, UPDATE WILL FOLLOW AFTER THE FINAL EPISODE

Andor is the best Star Wars show in 2022 and if it sticks the landing, it might even be the best show of this year all together.
Andor is a show that is very different from other Star Wars shows. It strips away a lot of the action, fantasy ellements and, dare I say, romanticism that we find in other Star Wars media, instead giving us a dialogue heavy and gritty sci fi show that focuses on the origin of the Rebel Alliance. This has unfortunately alienated some of the regular Star Wars audience, meaning we might not get more shows like this in the future. Such a shame.
Pasing wise I think it comparable to the earlier seasons of Game of Thrones: there are a lot of scenes of characters talking about their lives and views and characters scheming and working on a grand plan, with large action scenes mainly being reserved for the end of a story arc.

This pacing has worked so-so for the first arc of the season, which is a problem that mainly comes from the characters featured on Andors home world (non of them are very interesting, hence making their scenes a bit dull), but has an excellent action packed climax which introduces Stellan Skarsgård's Luthen, aka the best character in the show.
The second arc is executed much better, giving us an interesting look at the many souls that drift towards the rebellion and the interactions between them. It also gives us more lore on the inner workings of the empire through the escapades of Mon Mothma and a focus on the ISB (the Imperial Gestapo), with scenes in which the dialogue peaks. This arc builds up perfectly towards a spectacular climax in which we see something we haven't seen much in Star Wars (and no, Last Jedi's piss poor attempt to comment on war profiteering does not count): a less black and white but more grey view at the Galactic conflict. The Rebellion in this show is not afraid to fight dirty. They have an empire to crush and if innocents get hurt in the process, then so be it. It almost makes them come across as real revolutionaries.

Anyhow, here is a list of things the show does well:
- Great Dialogue that reveals bits of character intell naturally rather than in a forced manner
-Great expansion of the Star Wars lore
-Good performances from the majority of the cause, especially from Skarsgård, Andy Serkis and Faye Marsay
-Interesting side characters -Great cyberpunk-esque soundtrack
-The show knows how to craft great environments

And here is a thing the show could do better
-Make the protagonist more interesting / more focus on the protagonist. The show might be called Andor, but he more often feels like a spectator in his own show. He sometimes feels more like an audience surogate than an actual character. They have layed out some interesting story beats for him, but are yet to really pick up on them and they might be taking just a bit too long with that.

All and all, I am really enjoying Andor thus far and am eager to see how this show will continue from this point onwards.… Expand

4 of 5 users found this helpful41

All this user's reviews

9

tarant75Oct 27, 2022

I think this series is really very well done. It tells you the story of how the rebellion came about in the first place. How the rebellion against the empire has developed. The ambience, the costumes, the setting are very lovingly done.I think this series is really very well done. It tells you the story of how the rebellion came about in the first place. How the rebellion against the empire has developed. The ambience, the costumes, the setting are very lovingly done. There's a lot of emphasis on making it look like Rogue One and A New Hope as well. They really took a cue from Episode 4 instead of finding something completely new.… Expand

4 of 5 users found this helpful41

All this user's reviews

9

TwoTheOct 26, 2022

The best Star Wars series I have ever seen. In the dust of failures like Obi Wan and The Books of Boba Fett it feels like they finally hired a professional to do the job. Every single part of this series is outstanding, especially theThe best Star Wars series I have ever seen. In the dust of failures like Obi Wan and The Books of Boba Fett it feels like they finally hired a professional to do the job. Every single part of this series is outstanding, especially the soundtrack and sound effects. On top of that a convincing and deep story that will captivate you and make you feel with the characters. Just the overuse of shaky cam makes it a bit tough to watch at times, but those are luckily rare.

Instead of pointless SJW boredom they actually present characters with stories, traits and flaws. No one is a superman and no one can take it on a squad of Storm Troopers alone, because they are actually hitting and killing people. The seriousness of the situation of the empire turning from evil to worse is transmitted believably, and you feel the horror of their oppression with the characters as you watch it. The story takes it slow, too slow maybe for some who are used to action-packed Star Wars movies. But if you are ready to breathe in the air and the feeling of the universe of Star Wars, then you come to the right place. The scenery, the ambient sound, the music, everything radiates love for details, and makes you feel right at that place. The script shines with believable reactions and decisions, understandable, deep characters, and despite the fact that we know where it is going to still manages to surprise and shock you. Must watch for every Star Wars fan, and still outstandingly good for everyone who loves Science Fiction.… Expand

8 of 10 users found this helpful82

All this user's reviews

3

SuronalOct 23, 2022

I absolutely love Star Wars, but I just can’t get into this one, I gave it 2 episodes, tried to stay awake … just not for me.

2 of 16 users found this helpful214

All this user's reviews

7

NAMESISREVOct 20, 2022

They basically killed my Star Wars affinity with the previous junk. I'm pleasantly surprised, Andor is good! It's a different Star Wars series to what we've seen recently, which is very positive. And it definitely fits in very well with RogueThey basically killed my Star Wars affinity with the previous junk. I'm pleasantly surprised, Andor is good! It's a different Star Wars series to what we've seen recently, which is very positive. And it definitely fits in very well with Rogue One. A smart approach would have been to make one big episode out of three small ones and release them 2 weeks apart.… Expand

4 of 5 users found this helpful41

All this user's reviews

8

chrisothenOct 20, 2022

I'm only a couple of episodes in but i'm really enjoying it so far. Engaging story which is more like an very long movie. Better than the movies in any case!

4 of 5 users found this helpful41

All this user's reviews

10

TheSandolorianSep 24, 2022

Slower Pace than other Star Wars Series which actualy leads to a deeper story telling. Characters have human flaws which is nice. Overall the first episodes are brilliant.

6 of 10 users found this helpful64

All this user's reviews

9

Cerealz19Oct 19, 2022

This take on Star Wars feels like a real world, with real people, facing real stakes. It's very well done. Excellent performances, writing, and effects. Diego Luna is fabulous as usual. The tone is darker, with this show feeling honestly moreThis take on Star Wars feels like a real world, with real people, facing real stakes. It's very well done. Excellent performances, writing, and effects. Diego Luna is fabulous as usual. The tone is darker, with this show feeling honestly more like Bladerunner or Dune to me than Star Wars. They removed the space opera, the romance, the swashbuckling adventure, and it makes sense for this story. Still, I hope that Star Wars returns to fun adventure in future shows, but I also recall that The Empire Strikes Back was a profound tone shift from A New Hope, so trying new things is in Star Wars' DNA. Other than Mandalorian (which is gold), the other Star Wars shows have felt like good TV shows at best. But Andor transports me into the far far away universe again. It's a dark time for the galaxy, but hopefully a bright one for Star Wars stories!… Expand

4 of 5 users found this helpful41

All this user's reviews

10

Pomidor781Oct 18, 2022

This is the best Star Wars project ever! more projects like this are needed to be as serious and dark, showing the reality of this world, as this series does!

6 of 7 users found this helpful61

All this user's reviews

10

Anton56432Oct 17, 2022

Best Disney Series Yet!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

4 of 6 users found this helpful42

All this user's reviews

9

bcdserraOct 17, 2022

Waited until episode 6 because of the slow buildup but it was worth the wait as that is one of the best tv episodes of 2022 and one the best hours of the Star Wars medium in existence. This show is thrilling, well written, well directed andWaited until episode 6 because of the slow buildup but it was worth the wait as that is one of the best tv episodes of 2022 and one the best hours of the Star Wars medium in existence. This show is thrilling, well written, well directed and with great cinematography. Luna and Skarsgaard are doing a tremendous job and it's very interesting seeing them kick off what is going to be the rebellion. Do not sleep on this.… Expand

5 of 7 users found this helpful52

All this user's reviews

10

EvgenSOct 16, 2022

Love the first episode. It gives hopes that from all Disney's plotless SW movies (except Rogue one ofc) at least Andor has will have well made script.

3 of 4 users found this helpful31

All this user's reviews

7

Jones76Sep 21, 2022

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. After a few more episodes I upgrade my rating to a 7. It is still slow, but well written with a good story and Ep. 6 had some really good action as well. I was hoping for more of a thrill ride, but it is some of the best Star Wars I have seen in recent years.

Not the worst show Disney has done the last years, has potential, but currently fails to excite me. Andor feels like someone tried to turn depression into a TV show and it's sloooow. In addition it tries to be overtly dramatic in some places e.g. the prep talk to the guards, but scenes like this come over as bad comedy. Andor could also profit from an R rating, the show literally starts in a strip club with no strippers. Characters so far are not very memorable, the main character will be a problem for many, as he has no problem with killing. I don't need him to be a shiny hero, but I can see the problem. From a technical perspective it is good so far, haven't seen anything that I would lable bad cgi.

All in all the best Star Wars show after Mandalorian, not as abysmal as Obi Wan or Boba Fett, but it has to gain speed to get a better rating out of me.… Expand

6 of 11 users found this helpful65

All this user's reviews

9

RobobobOct 14, 2022

Previews said that Andor is Star Wars for adults and I couldn't agree more. Kids might call it slow and dull but I call it building tension and character growth, things that most Star Wars lacks lately. On top of that the show looksPreviews said that Andor is Star Wars for adults and I couldn't agree more. Kids might call it slow and dull but I call it building tension and character growth, things that most Star Wars lacks lately. On top of that the show looks beautiful with a lot of scenes shot on location instead of the virtual Stagecraft used for the Mandalorian. The Empire feels like a real threat here and I love the easter eggs and new additions to the lore. More Star Wars for adults, please!… Expand

5 of 6 users found this helpful51

All this user's reviews

10

Kelliente13Oct 14, 2022

As a huge fan of Star Wars, I couldn't be more delighted with this show. Not only does it use deep lore references in great ways that contribute to the worldbuilding (not just fan service) It has the best writing, acting, and cinematographyAs a huge fan of Star Wars, I couldn't be more delighted with this show. Not only does it use deep lore references in great ways that contribute to the worldbuilding (not just fan service) It has the best writing, acting, and cinematography of any star wars media since Empire. It would be a well made thriller in its own right. The fact its set in the Star Wars universe and fleshing out the pre-rebellion era is icing on the cake.… Expand

3 of 4 users found this helpful31

All this user's reviews

9

YeahYeahJoeFoxOct 13, 2022

A more mature take on Star Wars. Great acting, writing and directing. This is a more intimate look into the start of the rebellion and it’s brilliant. When a story is told this way, every thing that happens carries more weight. I hope we getA more mature take on Star Wars. Great acting, writing and directing. This is a more intimate look into the start of the rebellion and it’s brilliant. When a story is told this way, every thing that happens carries more weight. I hope we get more like this.… Expand

3 of 4 users found this helpful31

All this user's reviews

10

HyperBooperOct 12, 2022

The best Star Wars in a long time. If you don't like slow-burns, this isn't for you. Watch the episodes in groups of three rather than one at a time. It feels like it was meant to be movies rather than a TV show.

6 of 7 users found this helpful61

All this user's reviews

5

LtlombardiOct 12, 2022

Finally star wars for the grown-ups. Really enjoyed it. Good characters, good story, good acting, good photography .

2 of 6 users found this helpful24

All this user's reviews

10

sabinoplaneOct 12, 2022

Wonderful show with a delightful, more grounded take on the star wars universe

4 of 5 users found this helpful41

All this user's reviews

10

jrossreviewsOct 12, 2022

Fantastic show. Great drama, suspenseful and exciting. Star Wars done right.

6 of 7 users found this helpful61

All this user's reviews

8

OlivierPielOct 12, 2022

Far superior to the cartoonish Mandalorian -and the rest of the dreck that shan't be named that Disney has tried to peddle-, cleverly and overtly borrowing and combining an atmosphere from Blade Runner and story lines from 60's and 70's WWIIFar superior to the cartoonish Mandalorian -and the rest of the dreck that shan't be named that Disney has tried to peddle-, cleverly and overtly borrowing and combining an atmosphere from Blade Runner and story lines from 60's and 70's WWII commando/heist and French resistance movies (Bridge on the River Kwai, Canons of Navarone, The Eagle has landed, Army of Shadows), it is indeed a treat for a mature audience.
The early episodes are a bit clunky and the decors look a bit cheap , but once the action moves to Aldani and the heist scene, the directing, esp. editing is impeccable. Just like in ...the Empire Strikes Back.… Expand

5 of 6 users found this helpful51

All this user's reviews

3

DarthKevinOct 12, 2022

So... 5 episodes into Andor and I'm still wondering if anything is going to happen.

I'm not sure why there's a following for this show. The production is good, overall, but the writing is pretty terrible. The visuals, cinematography andSo... 5 episodes into Andor and I'm still wondering if anything is going to happen.

I'm not sure why there's a following for this show.

The production is good, overall, but the writing is pretty terrible. The visuals, cinematography and score are pretty great. It feels like you're watching a movie. The dialogue is written well, but it's much to do about nothing... the acting is fine, but the characters are taking us nowhere fast. The sub-plots/side stories are pretty meaningless.

If not for the name of the show, I wouldn't even know this was Star Wars. It feels more like Krypton, but with less action... which is not a good thing. Krypton drudged along at a snail's pace with equally meaningless drivel, but at least there was a story that moved forward with action sequences and conflicts that meant something.

I think I've seen maybe 3 droids, 2 aliens, and zero alien creatures. How is this Star Wars and how is it remotely entertaining for people?

Look at the poster... looks pretty exciting right? It's not. Bait and switch.

Why the good reviews, then?

I think some have been beaten down with so much **** material, over the last few years, that they'll just accept anything that has good production value and zero wokeness as "good."

Andor isn't good. It suffers from weak writing, sub-plots that lead nowhere and provides zero reason for anyone new to Star Wars or Andor to remain engaged. I can't get the comparison of this to Krypton out of my head, because the two shows are very similar.

If you have to say "it's slow, but it's building up to something big" or "it's a slow burn, but it's good," or something along those lines, then it's not a good show. A good show shouldn't seem like a slow burn, or that it's building up to something big... it should give you a reason to become engaged and hang on. Even Star Trek or Babylon 5 could do that in 1-2 episodes... We're 5 episodes into Andor and nothing's happened.… Expand

4 of 24 users found this helpful420

All this user's reviews

9

kirkenderOct 7, 2022

I've watched three episodes and this is legitimately good television and a good Star Wars. There is a distinct lack of twee nostalgia nonsense present in other Star Wars shows. This is an actual story told well. There are stakes, itsI've watched three episodes and this is legitimately good television and a good Star Wars. There is a distinct lack of twee nostalgia nonsense present in other Star Wars shows. This is an actual story told well. There are stakes, its genuinely thrilling, and the script and acting are excellent. It's not "slow paced," it has pacing. There is a difference and this show understands pacing.… Expand

8 of 10 users found this helpful82

All this user's reviews

9

EddieHokieOct 6, 2022

If you have the attention span of a goldfish, this show isn’t for you. It takes its time to build characters. The writing is tight, the scenes well acted. It’s Star Wars for adults. Where the movies tell the colorful (literally andIf you have the attention span of a goldfish, this show isn’t for you. It takes its time to build characters. The writing is tight, the scenes well acted. It’s Star Wars for adults. Where the movies tell the colorful (literally and figuratively) stories of the upper class-Jedi’s and Emperor’s and Rebellion leaders, and gang leaders—— this tells the story of the every day guy in the universe.

It’s gritty. Ever wonder what powers those glorious starships around the galaxy? Andor SHOWS you. And there is the distinction. Previous Star Wars TELLS you all the time with exposition and writing that conveys the obvious.

Andor assumes it’s audience can connect the dots for themselves. And there are many parallels to todays society. Corporations keep the people down. A scene where a man literally hammers a bell signifying the start and end of the miners work day and then blends into the excellent musical score, it can give you the feels. And the protagonists real talent is not light saber fighting or war strategy. His talent is relating to all kinds of different people and being true to his word. Something we see less and less of today. I recommend this show and proof that not all stuff made by Disney will be cookie cutter.… Expand

8 of 10 users found this helpful82

All this user's reviews

10

hekathepekaOct 5, 2022

Finally Star Wars for grownups! If you liked the Han Solo movie, Obi-Wan series and all the main story line movies after the original trilogy, you won't like Andor (and you can go to hell BTW). I just had to give it a 10 even though I've seenFinally Star Wars for grownups! If you liked the Han Solo movie, Obi-Wan series and all the main story line movies after the original trilogy, you won't like Andor (and you can go to hell BTW). I just had to give it a 10 even though I've seen only 5 episodes so far. Character development, writing and directing is top notch. Reminds me of the legendary The Wire somehow.… Expand

9 of 11 users found this helpful92

All this user's reviews

5

busiekOct 4, 2022

Four episodes watched... In world of Disney's "Star Wars" mediocre is new masterpiece. Better than "Obi-Wan" and "Boba Fett" for sure...

6 of 15 users found this helpful69

All this user's reviews

9

PhoenixReveiwsOct 3, 2022

A well-written, gritty story that we did ask for, but to our surprise turns out to be the best Star Wars has been since Mandalorian season 1. This show definitely holds a slower pace, and there are episodes where not one blaster is fired, soA well-written, gritty story that we did ask for, but to our surprise turns out to be the best Star Wars has been since Mandalorian season 1. This show definitely holds a slower pace, and there are episodes where not one blaster is fired, so if you need action I suggest waiting for more episodes and binging it.… Expand

7 of 9 users found this helpful72

All this user's reviews

9

vandalay1125Oct 3, 2022

It takes its time which may not appeal to some, but I love it. Writing is top-notch and gives a better feel for life in the Star Wars universe than any other show or movie. This is Star Wars for adults.

7 of 9 users found this helpful72

All this user's reviews

3

TheCriticatorOct 1, 2022

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Boring. Boring. Boring. I'm four episodes into this series and all I know is that dude's name is Cassian Andor and that he's Kelarian, and looking for his sister, but then it turned into him trying to sell an innocuous stolen ship part for money, and now he's joining the rebels to steal Empire money and forgetting about the sister. Every line of dialogue with every character is "Who are you?", "Why is he joining us?", "You're a Klerian?", "That's not the plan", "That's not what I was told", "Give me money", and "Who are you?", and nothing that gives us any insight to the plot. All the leaders are female and overly questioning/distrusting of Cassian's existence in every scene. Look, you are either need him or you kill him if you're that suspicious. But why him? Why Cassian Andor? He's literally every generic background character on these planets. Apparently he's Kelarian, which is a noticeable trait. A flashback showed Andor's childhood as a Klerian, and they are actually a child tribal race that has zero technology, no civilization. Even the Ewoks on Endor had buildings. They fight using blow darts, BLOW DARTS! Against actual weapons. They don't even have spears or knives. And of course, its led by alpha girl-boss teenage girls, the boys just simply fall in line behind them. An imperial ship crashes and a basic soldier is able to take out members of this Klerian tribe, while 30-40 of these Klerian kids shoot blow darts at him which takes forever to take him out. And the Empire comes and takes out all the Klerian with no resistance. Andor is saved by some old **** named Maarva who spent her life keeping his Klerian identity a secret, why? Klerians are no threat to anyone. They have no abilities and no technology like a Mandalorian or even Mon Calamari. Like every modern Star Wars antagonist Andor lives a predictable rough life with no parents, and gets by stealing ship parts for money. Apparently, the Empire thinks very highly of this basic component which Andor later says becomes useless if it's plugged in or used. So then we change the stakes to Andor being recruited by some old dude who tells Andor "I know who you are Cassian Andor" and doesn't tell us anything else. And like every other male in the cast he answers to a woman.… Expand

3 of 22 users found this helpful319

All this user's reviews

1

Sagan75Oct 1, 2022

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Another series with political message and bad acting. The soul of Star Wars is missing more and more, this is really sad.… Expand

3 of 22 users found this helpful319

All this user's reviews

10

subcontractingSep 30, 2022

One of the best serial of the last years. The main thing is its originality.

6 of 14 users found this helpful68

All this user's reviews

8

MohhSep 29, 2022

Rogue one is the best star wars film and This so far on par with movie in terms of writing.

5 of 9 users found this helpful54

All this user's reviews

10

mhvelplundSep 29, 2022

Except for the Mandalorian, most of the Disney Star Wars stuff has been pretty terrible. I came into this, dreading another snooze-fest. After two episodes I have to say, this is not Star Wars, but it's good. Like Rogue One, it's more like aExcept for the Mandalorian, most of the Disney Star Wars stuff has been pretty terrible. I came into this, dreading another snooze-fest. After two episodes I have to say, this is not Star Wars, but it's good. Like Rogue One, it's more like a gritty sci-fi film than space opera, but the characters and the look and feel have me hooked.… Expand

7 of 9 users found this helpful72

All this user's reviews

9

YcoSep 29, 2022

Andor doesn't mind taking its time, which works well for the show. Excellent worldbuilding is obtained through a combination of a good ensemble cast, and style reminiscent of great films like 'in bruges' and 'tinker tailor'. One scene, inAndor doesn't mind taking its time, which works well for the show. Excellent worldbuilding is obtained through a combination of a good ensemble cast, and style reminiscent of great films like 'in bruges' and 'tinker tailor'. One scene, in which a senator gets into her vehicle and opens her coat for some air, communicates her vulnerability masterfully. In an age where shows hit you over the head with dialogue and explain everything explicitly, this is a salve to my SW fan's soul.… Expand

6 of 9 users found this helpful63

All this user's reviews

1

VulcanSep 28, 2022

Aside from some very good acting, this is possibly the most boring thing I've seen coming out of the franchise. Waste of time.

3 of 23 users found this helpful320

All this user's reviews

10

Aleczander117Sep 28, 2022

Andor breaks (cleanses?) the mold of Disney’s handling of the beloved Star Wars franchise. It feels as though a creative team has been freed of the shackles that bound previous productions, forcing them to make streamlined “guaranteedAndor breaks (cleanses?) the mold of Disney’s handling of the beloved Star Wars franchise. It feels as though a creative team has been freed of the shackles that bound previous productions, forcing them to make streamlined “guaranteed successes”. Because of this freedom Andor is the first original and well told Star Wars story since the last Jedi. The writing and directing is masterful. The sets and art direction are beautiful. The act is phenomenal. I can’t get enough. A new standard for storytelling has been set by this amazing show and I hope that Disney will find talent that can meet it.… Expand

7 of 9 users found this helpful72

All this user's reviews

2

doodoo2Sep 27, 2022

Different, but the least interesting Star Wars since Episode 8‘s Canto Bight sequence. It‘s too slow, but not in a good oder rewarding way - at least for me. Main character doesn’t feel like one and the plot is pointless if you watched RogueDifferent, but the least interesting Star Wars since Episode 8‘s Canto Bight sequence. It‘s too slow, but not in a good oder rewarding way - at least for me. Main character doesn’t feel like one and the plot is pointless if you watched Rogue One.… Expand

3 of 23 users found this helpful320

All this user's reviews

5

Plain_Sight_DocSep 26, 2022

Nothing really happens to be honest. Really great writing and acting but it really just kinda stalls o it and never moves forward.

0 of 10 users found this helpful010

All this user's reviews

9

indieinsightsSep 25, 2022

It reminds me of Star Wars Rebels to some degree, which had many casual daily life storylines. And, if the writer of Star Wars Rogue is also the creator of Andor, you know what to expect, right? I like that. There have been so many crazy JediIt reminds me of Star Wars Rebels to some degree, which had many casual daily life storylines. And, if the writer of Star Wars Rogue is also the creator of Andor, you know what to expect, right? I like that. There have been so many crazy Jedi this, Sith that, and yet-another-Death Star stories, that it is hard for them to be unique in the end. I feel that Andor is the best Star Wars series since Mandalorian, with similar ideas on casual daily life outside of the Skywalker family soap opera. Andor is slow, yes. But we'll see.… Expand

6 of 9 users found this helpful63

All this user's reviews

0

Mandirigma88Sep 24, 2022

Absolutely worst star wars spinoff I have ever seen in my life. I couldn't even finish the first episode. It is about as exciting as watching paint dry. I hate this series for literally destroying any positive feelings I have towards the StarAbsolutely worst star wars spinoff I have ever seen in my life. I couldn't even finish the first episode. It is about as exciting as watching paint dry. I hate this series for literally destroying any positive feelings I have towards the Star Wars universe. Avoid. You have been warned.… Expand

7 of 57 users found this helpful750

All this user's reviews

3

TheWhiteManSep 24, 2022

One word: bland! This series was never going to be vital watching in the Star Wars canon, but it seems the creators are more than content to make a meaningless piece of backstory as there is no real interesting hook or twist to make viewersOne word: bland! This series was never going to be vital watching in the Star Wars canon, but it seems the creators are more than content to make a meaningless piece of backstory as there is no real interesting hook or twist to make viewers care. Andor himself just kind of gets thrown into the story and goes along with it. The antagonists are just about as wooden and generic as you can get in Star Wars. I don't care about them and don't care about how Andor holds up against them. We all know exactly how this story ends so they might have done more to make us interested in what is happening right now. But everything is done with such a dreary tone it has missed a lot of what makes Star Wars fun and exciting. Sure, Rogue One was a more serious and dark Star Wars story, but it also did a great job connecting to A New Hope with some fan favorite characters and intersecting plot. Andor has none of that, and if you did not know his character from Rogue One there is little connection to the larger Star Wars universe for fans to sink their teeth into. All of this would be fine if it was telling an interesting original story with characters we cared about, but sadly that is not the case. This does not feel like a good Star Wars story or a good story on its own right, and Andor is certainly not a strong enough character to carry a bland and meaningless story like this on his own.… Expand

3 of 23 users found this helpful320

All this user's reviews

7

UncleWillardSep 23, 2022

Star Wars for adults. I really like the gritty, lived-in feel of Andor. Everything looks used...worn. The dude in the tower needs to chill. Can't say I like Rogue One at all, but Ikke this.

5 of 7 users found this helpful52

All this user's reviews

7

Rich87Sep 23, 2022

Much better than obi wan the darker tone and the grittyness of andor is spot on for what I want from a star wars show in what is a prequel character series on cassia andor and how he came to be the rebel assassin who wanted to bring down theMuch better than obi wan the darker tone and the grittyness of andor is spot on for what I want from a star wars show in what is a prequel character series on cassia andor and how he came to be the rebel assassin who wanted to bring down the empire. My only gripe it's very slow in its pacing… Expand

8 of 9 users found this helpful81

All this user's reviews

1

Wang_LiquinSep 22, 2022

When a show is completely lacking in action and adventure and turns into a space-office bore fest. This could have been set in Iowa at a mall, and it would have made no difference other than the "accents" the actors use. Actually, if it wereWhen a show is completely lacking in action and adventure and turns into a space-office bore fest. This could have been set in Iowa at a mall, and it would have made no difference other than the "accents" the actors use. Actually, if it were in a mall, there's a chance you might see a Stormtrooper at the Sharper Imager store. There sure as hell aren't any in this... whatever it is. Boring.… Expand

8 of 35 users found this helpful827

All this user's reviews

9

elljawaSep 23, 2022

Best live action star wars show so far. No real competition. Great writing, cinematography, sets, acting, etc.

11 of 16 users found this helpful115

All this user's reviews

10

dingleberryjackSep 22, 2022

Rogue One was a film for thinking adults, and Cassian Andor was the most interesting character. This series is off to a great start in the same vein.

10 of 14 users found this helpful104

All this user's reviews

9

MaulcunSep 22, 2022

I really thought it was going to be mediocre. But it was amazing. I love the style, the directing, the music, the world building and character development. Andor definitely feels more mature, dark and gritty. It's a different take on starI really thought it was going to be mediocre. But it was amazing. I love the style, the directing, the music, the world building and character development. Andor definitely feels more mature, dark and gritty. It's a different take on star wars that I didn't know I wanted.

It's great to see regular people and how the empire effected them. It goes to show that when politicians talk about making things better, the working person gets left behind.

It's not perfect, but this is the most interesting thing that's happened to star wars in a very long time. I can't wait to see how the story develops.… Expand

8 of 13 users found this helpful85

All this user's reviews

9

CittadelSep 22, 2022

If you like endless action, this show isn't for you. I personally do really enjoy this more mature, more grounded take on Star Wars, so I'm really, really enjoying this. For once, Star Wars isn't plagued by wooden dialogue writing or awkwardIf you like endless action, this show isn't for you. I personally do really enjoy this more mature, more grounded take on Star Wars, so I'm really, really enjoying this. For once, Star Wars isn't plagued by wooden dialogue writing or awkward romantic tension; everything just seems to work here. I think it's fine for the universe of Star Wars to go beyond the simple and mindless fun of it all (which is valid), and to offer something more introspective instead.… Expand

6 of 10 users found this helpful64

All this user's reviews

3

ScienceAdvisorSep 22, 2022

Search for "Metacritic Andor Season 1" and leave your review there. This page will be shut down soon, based on Metacritic past behaviour.

The first three episodes are boring. It apparently takes half the season to get started. So whileSearch for "Metacritic Andor Season 1" and leave your review there. This page will be shut down soon, based on Metacritic past behaviour.

The first three episodes are boring. It apparently takes half the season to get started. So while better than Boba or Kenobi, it is still just a time-waster for a character that no one cares about.… Expand

9 of 36 users found this helpful927

All this user's reviews

4

ShaManaSep 22, 2022

Absolute snooze fest. The most boring thing I've watched in a while. Not that the other were any better

9 of 26 users found this helpful917

All this user's reviews

6

bjmetacriticSep 22, 2022

The characters are somewhat interesting, the story is coherent but slow, the dialogue is alright, and the effects are fine. Nothing stands out as being particularly strong or weak. Overall, it's just okay.

5 of 15 users found this helpful510

All this user's reviews

9

Joey_jojo_jrSep 21, 2022

A mature and thoughtful show without the Skywalker life vest (so far). It moves slowly, but the world building, set design, performances, and character development make it well worthwhile. A breath of fresh air and easily the best star warsA mature and thoughtful show without the Skywalker life vest (so far). It moves slowly, but the world building, set design, performances, and character development make it well worthwhile. A breath of fresh air and easily the best star wars show besides the mandalorian.… Expand

7 of 14 users found this helpful77

All this user's reviews

0

Sickboy0138Sep 21, 2022

Tried giving this a watch and it's just very very boring. Awkward diolauge and no real reason to even like him because he's already dead. Supporting actors are all bland and forgeteble. Why Disney can't just make a decent movie is beyond me.Tried giving this a watch and it's just very very boring. Awkward diolauge and no real reason to even like him because he's already dead. Supporting actors are all bland and forgeteble. Why Disney can't just make a decent movie is beyond me. It's not as full of "the message" as most Disney... But it's still Disney.… Expand

14 of 41 users found this helpful1427

All this user's reviews

10

Julio_OrtizSep 21, 2022

So far this show is amazing, it's definitely what Star Wars needed in live action these last few years, Book of Boba Fett was botched, Kenobi was vapid and disappointing, Andor is a fresh take on this rich universe and I'm glad that both TheSo far this show is amazing, it's definitely what Star Wars needed in live action these last few years, Book of Boba Fett was botched, Kenobi was vapid and disappointing, Andor is a fresh take on this rich universe and I'm glad that both The Mandalorian and this show exist despite the disgusting cashgrabs that were the sequels. The cast is perfect, you can actually appreciate the level of detail and production value, the cinematography and locations are incredible (for a Disney streaming show) and the story is pretty interesting so far, I know that Rogue One spoils the fate of Andor, but this story is promising and deepens the Star Wars universe nevertheless, I prefer new stories with new characters instead of watching my favourite characters being destroyed by social and political views. Let's see where this promising series goes, fingers crossed that Disney does not play a weird move as it always does....… Expand

21 of 32 users found this helpful2111

All this user's reviews

0

AcrofiloSep 21, 2022

Disney corporation keeps putting out series and movies under the premise that more is better but it is tiresome and quality pays dearly. This show is less childish than the rest but it is still a "family" thing like all things streaming these days.

11 of 40 users found this helpful1129

All this user's reviews

Andor

User Reviews