Read User Reviews and Submit your own for 1899 (2022)

4

marlNov 28, 2022

Yes, it's from the makers of Dark. A fact that only amplifies how terribly soporific and hugely disappointing this has been. Stretched overly thin with repetitious dialogue and over-extended scenes to attempt to cover up an utterlyYes, it's from the makers of Dark. A fact that only amplifies how terribly soporific and hugely disappointing this has been. Stretched overly thin with repetitious dialogue and over-extended scenes to attempt to cover up an utterly incomprehensible story capped with a cheap, unearned 'twist'. A waste of some fine craft in cinematography and FX. Season 2. I wouldn't be surprised but I won't waste my time on this again.… Expand

4 of 4 users found this helpful40

All this user's reviews

8

clubmirabileDec 15, 2022

I couldn't have expected mora from the creators of Dark. I really love it. And, as with Dark, I am already thinking on watching it again to grasps details I missed in the first run. Fantastic job

1 of 1 users found this helpful10

All this user's reviews

8

AdayaLZJan 7, 2023

Me gustó mucho esta 1er temporada y me da lástima que quede cancelada. A pesar de que no es perfeta, tiene un concepto interesante que debe explorarse más. Como es una serie independiente de Dark, no quiero compararla, ya que ambas tienen susMe gustó mucho esta 1er temporada y me da lástima que quede cancelada. A pesar de que no es perfeta, tiene un concepto interesante que debe explorarse más. Como es una serie independiente de Dark, no quiero compararla, ya que ambas tienen sus diferencias… Expand

1 of 1 users found this helpful10

All this user's reviews

1

ishurikNov 22, 2022

Honestly, the story seemed like a jumbled mess of imagery and random plots that didn't mesh together into a cohesive story.

When the authors try to convey some idea, all their characters start talking about it, which looks strange. In someHonestly, the story seemed like a jumbled mess of imagery and random plots that didn't mesh together into a cohesive story.

When the authors try to convey some idea, all their characters start talking about it, which looks strange.

In some scenes, it was clear from the first seconds what all this meant because "the message" was woven into the plot, and from the first words, it was obvious how the scene would end.

When you remove the music from a very simple scene, it becomes an empty, boring production. It's just a collection of clichés and boring characters.

Bad script. Slow and boring. Cold characters. Nothing like Dark. Woke.… Expand

5 of 6 users found this helpful51

All this user's reviews

1

tdebugNov 26, 2022

I really like mystery, thrillers and horror films. But this one is just a neverending mess. Boring as it is senseless.

5 of 6 users found this helpful51

All this user's reviews

2

loumexNov 23, 2022

Another example of bad writing and sloppy mysteries. Throw a bunch of puzzle pieces but never bother to actually check if they fit. This is a great example which follows the Lost/OA/Dark dogma. Eventually end up closing the whole series withAnother example of bad writing and sloppy mysteries. Throw a bunch of puzzle pieces but never bother to actually check if they fit. This is a great example which follows the Lost/OA/Dark dogma. Eventually end up closing the whole series with nonsensical elements that sound cool and look cool, but once thoroughly checked, fail to connect the dots and provide a satisfying resolution and well-thought storyline. Skip it, or hate watch it, but don't for once think you will be satisfied with how this series will eventually one day end. Each season will just throw it further into the Lost abyss.… Expand

5 of 6 users found this helpful51

All this user's reviews

1

Doobie1Nov 19, 2022

This reminds me of Lost, but the dialogue is worse (you will understand why as soon as you watch it). This prevents the characters really bonding with each other and therefore leaves you feeling a bit detached from them. I watched it rightThis reminds me of Lost, but the dialogue is worse (you will understand why as soon as you watch it). This prevents the characters really bonding with each other and therefore leaves you feeling a bit detached from them. I watched it right through to the end. The overall premise had potential, but they made a royal mess of it. The pace and plot kept stuttering, and they never quite found their footing. As a result, it's boring, filled with drivel, but is remarkable as an insomnia cure (true story; I fell asleep on three different episodes). Give this one a miss, it pales in comparison with Dark (heh).… Expand

5 of 7 users found this helpful52

All this user's reviews

0

notwistNov 19, 2022

This show has been compared with "Lost" (2004), and for good reason. If you enjoy being teased with one "mystery box" after another only to experience a completely underwhelming season climax that explains absolutely nothing and really doesThis show has been compared with "Lost" (2004), and for good reason. If you enjoy being teased with one "mystery box" after another only to experience a completely underwhelming season climax that explains absolutely nothing and really does nothing apart from forcing you to watch another season -- still not greenlit at time of writing by Netflix by the way -- and adding a new gigantic mystery box that all the other boxes fit in, then this show is for you. If this makes you feel like you wasted several hours on a story that gave you nothing apart from feeling infantilized, annoyed and duped, then this show is not for you.

If I had to say something forgiving about this series, there are a lot of great performances, and the special effects are good, but in terms of writing and pacing this whole season is a train wreck.

Netflix, please stop this madness before we end up with six seasons and a movie.… Expand

7 of 10 users found this helpful73

All this user's reviews

2

capt_morganDec 2, 2022

If you like watching characters running aimlessly around for hours this is for you.

2 of 3 users found this helpful21

All this user's reviews

2

william1134Dec 12, 2022

I really didn't enjoy this at all.

The story is not what you thought it was going to be. Lots of really dumb mystery stuff added in which may seem interesting but comes out to nothing in the end.

Felt like a massive waste of time.

2 of 3 users found this helpful21

All this user's reviews

0

vlajkoDec 12, 2022

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. First of all, show is extremely boring. I could barely find enough strength to finish all 8 episodes. After 3rd episode most of the time they are crawling through the "rabbit holes" and it was so booooring. We saw it ones, we saw it few times but for love of the god stop! At one point it reminded me to Nakatomi Plaza and I was waiting for the characters to start say: "'Come out the coast, we'll get together, have a few laughs...'" So Mr. Baran bo Odar why did you put in your show gay couple? What is thier porpose in this show? Representation? Diversity? How did they affect story? Are you flowing Netflixs orders? Strong female lead character? Well that is prescription for disaster...… Expand

3 of 5 users found this helpful32

All this user's reviews

3

icotzabbNov 19, 2022

The guy with the dark, soy sauce colored hair is particularly hard to love.

6 of 11 users found this helpful65

All this user's reviews

7

BioTofuDec 7, 2022

I wish this is a Cthulhu show... I enjoyed the setup in the first few episodes very much but as I got more and more answers, I didn't like where the show was going. It's like getting more and more dilute as it leaned harder into scifiI wish this is a Cthulhu show... I enjoyed the setup in the first few episodes very much but as I got more and more answers, I didn't like where the show was going. It's like getting more and more dilute as it leaned harder into scifi mystery. And the revelation made some of the early scenes, especially some with some characters' actions and silence inexplicable... The set and costumes are excellent... The music, hit or miss with me.… Expand

1 of 2 users found this helpful11

All this user's reviews

3

CastleGreyJan 2, 2023

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Starts out atmospheric and intriguing, then does the usual Mystery Box Storytelling trick of gradually unpacking into utterly meaningless nonsense that doesn't at all fit with anything anyone does if you watch the series again from episode 1 Basically 7 hours of people wandering around going "ooh this is all very mysterious," then a single hour of "lol none of this mattered in the slightest and you're an idiot for expecting any kind of payoff" Why was anyone but Maura on the ship? (Lol who cares, says the show)

What was the point of everyone's traumatic memory and excruciatingly drawn out backstory?
(Lol who cares, says the show)

Why was The Boy acting like a Horror Movie Weird Kid for so long despite there being no in-story reason for it ("they're listening" doesn't explain why a child should act so deliberately expressionless and creepy when the child knows what's going on from the off, knows he's being observed at all times, and could have handled his role in the story in countless other ways?
(Lol who cares, look at how many horror tropes we can sellotape onto this creepy weird kid for 6 hours! says the show)

I'm finding it hard to justify this show as anything more than a giant waste of time, and the sudden pivot 'twist ending' is such a pathetically cheap rug-pull that seems to be there purely as bait for getting a second season greenlit Safe to say I'm not interested in coming back… Expand

1 of 2 users found this helpful11

All this user's reviews

8

PulseDPDec 7, 2022

After allowing this series to sit with me for a bit, I have to give the creators of Dark a solid 8 for this first season. Expectations were high given that Dark is my benchmark in many ways. 1899 is incredibly slow going in and I fear mostAfter allowing this series to sit with me for a bit, I have to give the creators of Dark a solid 8 for this first season. Expectations were high given that Dark is my benchmark in many ways. 1899 is incredibly slow going in and I fear most will find the first 3-4 episodes a real grind and give up if they aren’t interested in dialogue heavy character building and story set up. I was prepared for this so had no problem with it. I found the character arcs intriguing and the story twisted and compelling enough to keep me onboard. The show really hits its stride after episode 4 as the pace picks up and events start taking dramatic turns. The story is convoluted enough to keep you on your toes. If you’re the person who likes to talk during a show you’ll get lost pretty easily. 1899 demands your full attention and pays off if you give it. My criticisms would be the opening titles. The edits are extremely fast which doesn’t sit right. Maybe that is the intention. The final moments of the last episode were a little predictable but the set up for a season two is good. The sound track deserves a mention as it is great with the return of Ben Frost who composed for Dark. Over all I thoroughly enjoyed this slow burn Sci-Fi but can certainly understand how the pacing and plot may put some people off.… Expand

1 of 2 users found this helpful11

All this user's reviews

10

respwnNov 18, 2022

absolutely stunning, amazing actors, lost-like story, the multi-language concept is refreshing.

5 of 11 users found this helpful56

All this user's reviews

10

okiki4641Nov 17, 2022

this show is disturbingly good!!!!
set design is amazing acting
and thrills

4 of 9 users found this helpful45

All this user's reviews

10

Sil542Nov 19, 2022

Do NOT listen to the negative reviews. Those people does not understand the genious writing of this masterpiece. People are talking a lot about a slow start. It does indeed have that, but it was kinda needed to really set up the characters ofDo NOT listen to the negative reviews. Those people does not understand the genious writing of this masterpiece. People are talking a lot about a slow start. It does indeed have that, but it was kinda needed to really set up the characters of the show.… Expand

3 of 7 users found this helpful34

All this user's reviews

10

Freeger278Nov 19, 2022

There are a ton of unexpected plot twists and unanswered questions. It seems like an unanswerable mystery.

Although the later episodes became better, the earlier ones were a little boring. Furthermore, the acting is excellent. Gets a 10There are a ton of unexpected plot twists and unanswered questions. It seems like an unanswerable mystery.

Although the later episodes became better, the earlier ones were a little boring. Furthermore, the acting is excellent. Gets a 10 rating from me.… Expand

2 of 6 users found this helpful24

All this user's reviews

10

gevianarifNov 18, 2022

Jantje Friese and Baran bo Odar never disappoint. Everything about this show is brilliant. The cast is stunning, not to mention the beautiful cinematography and amazing directing.

2 of 7 users found this helpful25

All this user's reviews

9

XishnikNov 20, 2022

Phenomenal acting, exquisite cinematography, stunning visuals, and great methodical pacing. Captivating in a refreshing way that you don’t see very often. The writing was overall really interesting with intricate exposes of differentPhenomenal acting, exquisite cinematography, stunning visuals, and great methodical pacing. Captivating in a refreshing way that you don’t see very often. The writing was overall really interesting with intricate exposes of different cultures. there are a few scenes where they could have written a bit differently to give them more substance and weight. For instance, the episode “the ship”felt like it needed something more going on to offset the main part of the plot. Overall, a kickass series so far, Im yearning for more!… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

9

joyalNov 22, 2022

Fascinating ! Director script couple baron boodar & jantje friese strikes again with another engrossing mystery series.

You must have some patience to go through the early episodes,once you reach the middle phase ,the effect will start kickFascinating ! Director script couple baron boodar & jantje friese strikes again with another engrossing mystery series.

You must have some patience to go through the early episodes,once you reach the middle phase ,the effect will start kick ok you, from then excitement and curiosity will drive you ! brilliant screenplay and stunning visuals with good performances and absorbing mystery awaiting !

It is available on Netflix , hopefully it will get another season, because the ending is the beginning of something more crazier… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

6

StevenDNov 25, 2022

Starts off well but becomes boring really fast towards the end. They need to work a lot more on the pacing since I could easily argue for the cutting of a whole 2 episodes for lack of content.
The language barrier is interesting. TheStarts off well but becomes boring really fast towards the end. They need to work a lot more on the pacing since I could easily argue for the cutting of a whole 2 episodes for lack of content.
The language barrier is interesting. The justification for it is unclear and I hope they don't keep it going forward. While I do appreciate a nod towards the local language watching an entire series, where it switches from english, spanish, french, german, mandarin, and a few more, becomes tiresome faster than you would expect.
While it's by no means a must see it's definitely entertaining enough to warrant a try. Hoping the second season is more polished.… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

8

JLuis_001Nov 20, 2022

For those who have already experienced what the creators of this show did in DARK, I can only tell you that you already know what to expect.
For those who haven't, keep in mind that mystery is key here, so if you're more into explanations andFor those who have already experienced what the creators of this show did in DARK, I can only tell you that you already know what to expect.
For those who haven't, keep in mind that mystery is key here, so if you're more into explanations and a more direct rhythm, I doubt you'll get along with this story.

It's a bit slow and doesn't start to pick up pace until its third episode, but if you stay tuned, the journey is very rewarding.… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

8

MaulcunNov 25, 2022

I really thought 1899 was going to be just some regular period drama like a titanic, finishing with the typical ending, but was something completely different!

Just remember one thing, don't let the slow start fool you. With every episode,I really thought 1899 was going to be just some regular period drama like a titanic, finishing with the typical ending, but was something completely different!

Just remember one thing, don't let the slow start fool you. With every episode, more details are added to put together the puzzle and you're left asking yourself questions and rooting for your favorite characters find out the answers as quick as possible!

They spends a lot of time exposing the backstory of the major characters. At first one thinks there is no connection, but through their "dreams" or is it their "reality", we began to see how each share a connection which brought them together on this voyage. The cinematography and direction have been on point. The music in first few episodes where amazing, so appropriate to dark atmosphere, fear and curiosity. I was mostly amazed by the diversity of the cast. The multicultural aspect led to a more authentic representation of life aboard an immigrant ship at the turn of the last century.

I hope to see a season 2 because the cast, producers and directors have really outdone yourselves.… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

10

HexxxagonNov 20, 2022

Stunningly shot, with another great score from Ben Frost, this slow burner is worth sticking with. I only wish we had more series like this, where the writers are willing to take chances and develop stories in a non linear way.

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

10

FraizouNov 22, 2022

Série incroyable, qui n'en est qu'à son commencement. Les rageux (notamment brésiliens) feraient mieux de s'intéresser à la vérité plutôt qu'au scandale, ça leur permettrait d'éviter de passer pour des guignols.

1 of 5 users found this helpful14

All this user's reviews

10

GreenhouseSlkNov 21, 2022

Masterpiece masterpiece great great great great great great great great great

1 of 6 users found this helpful15

All this user's reviews

4

Mr_ConnecticutJan 22, 2023

Drama upon drama, mystery after mystery, constant setups and no pay off. This is one of those shows that's filled with half baked ideas and ends up going nowhere.

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

5

Akk3d1sDec 29, 2022

I am pretty sure the ideas of this show came by means of drawing them from a hat and then the writers had to glue it all together.

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

6

getsmeliftedDec 1, 2022

I tried to temper my expectations because I love Dark but this show misses the mark ever so slightly. It's something that's hard to put your finger on but I reckon it's just that everything is slightly off. The mystery box story telling getsI tried to temper my expectations because I love Dark but this show misses the mark ever so slightly. It's something that's hard to put your finger on but I reckon it's just that everything is slightly off. The mystery box story telling gets annoying very quickly. With Dark mysteries abound however there's always something engaging going on but not so in 1899. Also, and this is my biggest issue, no one is particularly likable. Writers are forgetting this aspect of story telling. If no one is likable then no one cares what happens to them. The female lead in particular gives the audience no reason whatsoever to sympathize with her. I'm hopeful for the second season however recommending a show based on an unaired season would be pretty silly wouldn't it. I know it's Marvel's bread and butter (you just HAVE to see the end credits scene) but it's a dumb practice that I won't partake in.… Expand

0 of 2 users found this helpful02

All this user's reviews

2

guille3000Jan 5, 2023

It has the plot similar to Matrix, but with a low budget.

Tiene el Argumento similar a Matrix pero con bajo presupuesto

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

10

boznahtoAug 21, 2023

Серіал як на перший погляд здається прохідним серіальчиком про привидів на кораблі, виявився, як на мою думку - кращою екранізацією Убік на сьогоднішній день. З чудовою музикою, дуже естетично гарним, з гарним сіджіай і взагалі... як на менеСеріал як на перший погляд здається прохідним серіальчиком про привидів на кораблі, виявився, як на мою думку - кращою екранізацією Убік на сьогоднішній день. З чудовою музикою, дуже естетично гарним, з гарним сіджіай і взагалі... як на мене серіал року, мінімум… Expand