Haley Scarnato

Biography: Although this aspiring pop princess tried her best, no one thought Scarnato would make the final cut on the sixth season of American Idol. But never try to second-guess public taste: On March 8, 2007, the former wedding singer shocked the judges when she beat out diva Sabrina Sloan for a Top 12 spot. With her long legs on prominent display, Scarnato struggled along week to week, finally becoming the fifth contestant voted off the competition. Post-Idol, Scarnato has turned to country music. She released a country single, "Girls Night Out," in 2008.