I Disagree
by Poppy
User Score
8.5

Universal acclaim- based on 350 Ratings

User score distribution:
  1. Positive: 307 out of 350
  2. Mixed: 15 out of 350
  3. Negative: 28 out of 350
Buy Now
Buy on

Review this album

  1. Your Score
    0 out of 10
    Rate this:
    • 10
    • 9
    • 8
    • 7
    • 6
    • 5
    • 4
    • 3
    • 2
    • 1
    • 0
    • 0
  1. Submit
  2. Check Spelling
view
per page
  1. MaroKauil
    Jan 16, 2020
    9
    Una propuesta totalmente nueva para la música actual. Moderno, fresco y oscuro. Es la combinación perfecta entre pop, nu-metal y electrónica que pueden escuchar. Sin duda un gran álbum. Poppy tiene mucho que ofrecer a la cultura pop, y desde Am I a Girl? lo viene haciendo con esa experimentación que nadie mas esta haciendo.
  2. Kevinrubio
    Jan 10, 2020
    10
    Poppy has finally set free from the chains of the interweb where she was trapped in. I disagree celebrates the Art of NU Metal from Poppy's transition from Pop into a whole new genre of her own. Post-genre is what describes Poppy's style. Loved this album to the fullest.
  3. lucwelch
    Jan 10, 2020
    10
    her best work yet period very cohesive and progressive album... she's ahead of her alternative peers who sounds all the same
  4. BrennanH
    Jan 11, 2020
    10
    Not gonna lie, my expectations were high, and did it hit them? Well, no...

    They surpassed them by miles and easily became my favorite of Poppy’s discography! The only way I can describe it is if Billie Eilish was metal, which I’ll have you know is an awesome idea that worked wonders for her. Within a day this album has become kinda iconic. It’s fantastic if you haven’t already, check it    Not gonna lie, my expectations were high, and did it hit them? Well, no...

    They surpassed them by miles and easily became my favorite of Poppy’s discography! The only way I can describe it is if Billie Eilish was metal, which I’ll have you know is an awesome idea that worked wonders for her. Within a day this album has become kinda iconic. It’s fantastic if you haven’t already, check it out. If you have, do it again. Easiest 10 of my life Favorite songs: all of them. Least favorite songs: N/A    … Expand
  5. Zizi1
    Jan 10, 2020
    10
    Siento que esta versión de Poppy me gusta más Gracias Poppy por liberarnos de la Rare con semejante obra de arte
  6. lukecolin
    Jan 10, 2020
    10
    simplesmente um álbum incrível, o grito de liberdade da poppy das garras de seu antigo companheiro criativo
  7. Nagpig
    Jan 12, 2020
    10
    Unique, iconic and Lynchian, this one. It is probably the kind of album you need to "get" to enjoy, and you may not get it first time, so it may be a slow burner. It obviously went over the heads of many of the professional reviewers. However, if you do get it, your open mind will be rewarded, and you are likely to be left grinning from ear to ear frequently (and repeatedly askingUnique, iconic and Lynchian, this one. It is probably the kind of album you need to "get" to enjoy, and you may not get it first time, so it may be a slow burner. It obviously went over the heads of many of the professional reviewers. However, if you do get it, your open mind will be rewarded, and you are likely to be left grinning from ear to ear frequently (and repeatedly asking yourself under your breath "what just happened"?). There are also a couple of emotional sucker punches, and all sorts of unusual matters come under scrutiny in the songs. For me, I came to the music through one or two songs, then gradually found the others. Each song I heard was more impressive. It is pretty much an album of best songs, which is quite an achievement. The songs are all richly referential, using genre bending for observational, sarcastic, satirical and dramatic purposes. Some of the biggest emotional punches come from the rapid stylistic changes. Some people think that these are a weak point, but when you get to know the music, they are coolly calculated and effortlessly executed. The music videos are also rich with imagery and references for you to enjoy. Finally, music nerds will enjoy some awesomely complex rhythms in a couple of the tracks- everyone is going to need to learn to bop in 7/4 and sing tunes that feature augmentation and diminution of rhythms. It definitely blew the January blues away, and I hope it will be recognised in the long term for the dizzying achievement it is.… Expand
  8. Pollution
    Jan 10, 2020
    10
    Simply iconic. Transitioning form her pop persona to a much more mature and diverse character, offering a palette of emotions and depths absent in previous works.
  9. 123zombie123
    Jan 10, 2020
    8
    I like the ambitious that her put in this album, lots of ideas and experimental elements mixed in it . It was pretty risky to composed these kind of mixed-genre stuff especially mixing pop with heavy sound together, high chance to messed it up but thankfully she done it pretty well.
  10. cameron9814
    Jan 10, 2020
    10
    This album is FANTASTIC!!! She’s grown so much as an artist and I’m glad to see her leave behind the gimmick of her character and just live her angry little life vicariously through crazy ass music
  11. juangalmeidx
    Jan 10, 2020
    9
    first full album from Poppy I hear and I couldn’t be more pleased and satisfied. what a beautiful journey she’s provided, she showed how easily she can go from a genre to another without boredom. already one of my favorites of the year. best songs: bloodmoney, nothing i need & sick of the sun.
  12. Cucu10106
    Jan 10, 2020
    10
    Just amazing. I'm glad she's finally free to express herself in an unique way!!!!
  13. Freud26
    Jan 10, 2020
    10
    After having been in other musical genres, it seems poppy has found a way to mix everything learned with metal.
  14. poppyspills
    Jan 10, 2020
    10
    best album of the month, year, and decade so far. I can’t wait to see what’s next for poppy!! She’s got a new fan for life in me.
  15. giomezzadra
    Jan 13, 2020
    10
    Her best work to date. I've been a fan of her for a long time but none of her previous albums have caught me the way this one did. All the tracks mesh together in a perfect way and even if you don't like heavy music you will find a song you'll like for sure. Definitely worth your time
  16. deadhornet
    Jan 13, 2020
    9
    i love rock poppy. this album is fun, thrilling, blood rushing and energizing. i do not usually listen to rock music/ metal music but there’s something about poppy’s music that is so alluring and catchy, to the point i can’t peel my eyes away from it. the skillful and frenzied guitar riffs, liberating vocals chanting with rebellious energy, chaotic and twisted screams and the prominenti love rock poppy. this album is fun, thrilling, blood rushing and energizing. i do not usually listen to rock music/ metal music but there’s something about poppy’s music that is so alluring and catchy, to the point i can’t peel my eyes away from it. the skillful and frenzied guitar riffs, liberating vocals chanting with rebellious energy, chaotic and twisted screams and the prominent distortion makes this a wild and electrifying package. i enjoy how poppy experiments with versatility on this album, how she stitches one genre together with the next, transitioning between moods almost instantaneously. it almost feels like she’s a robot malfunctioning and glitching, screaming at the top of her lungs and then singing the sweetest bedtime lullaby seconds later. these switch ups kept me on my toes, wondering what she would deliver next.

    my only complaint is that the tracks “nothing i need” and “sick of the sun” requires a little bit more polishing. there isn’t many distinctive qualities of these two songs, and they sound like they could be easily placed on her previous pop album.
    the structure and flow of the closing tack could also be formatted better imo.
    other than that, this is a really great album!    … Expand
  17. lolitaslies
    Jan 11, 2020
    10
    It’s just so amazing how Poppy became so self aware of what she actually wants to offer to her public.
  18. imcarlos
    Jan 10, 2020
    10
    It is a masterpiece and this is the only thing I can say about it. It’s a big transition to Poppy’s new version, the best one, all Poppyseeds are freaking out now!
  19. hellokittypie
    Sep 3, 2020
    9
    Poppy gave us a job worthy of acclaim! This mix between Pop and Metal got together perfectly.
  20. TheQuietGamer
    Feb 16, 2020
    9
    In a time where so many metal bands have been adopting a softer sound in order to achieve more mainstream appeal, it's nice to an artist from the other side of the spectrum do the exact opposite. Poppy still leans on her pop roots (and dubstep) to help compensate for her lack of ability to deliver the kind of heavier vocal style we associate with the genre, especially during the album'sIn a time where so many metal bands have been adopting a softer sound in order to achieve more mainstream appeal, it's nice to an artist from the other side of the spectrum do the exact opposite. Poppy still leans on her pop roots (and dubstep) to help compensate for her lack of ability to deliver the kind of heavier vocal style we associate with the genre, especially during the album's second-half where it loses a bit of steam, but it's done in a sort of tongue-in-cheek manner.

    The lyrical content chronicles Poppy's evolution as an artist and her feelings in regards to whatever happened with that Titanic guy. Given that I have no prior knowledge of Poppy outside of this album, a lot of that was lost on me. Yet, I did not once fail to see how empowering the messages of self-discovery and escaping toxic relationships are. All of this may be about Poppy's personal journey, but the things she(?) has learned can resonate with all of us.

    The only problem with the album is really that second-half. With the exception of "Bite Your Teeth," everything after the fifth track kind of feels like filler. It is where Poppy is at her most emotional though, dealing with themes like depression. It's also hard to fault the concluding track "Don't Go Outside" which plays out like a classic rock ballad. So while the latter portion of these songs might not be to my taste, I'm overall not going to be too hard on the package as a whole.

    It's such an atypical move for a musician to branch off into a less popular genre like this and I applaud the bravery. Not only are the results exciting and fantastic, but the decision has allowed to Poppy to express her voice in a more authentic manner while serving as a nice bridge between two different worlds of music. Whether or not this change sticks, I Disagree has made it so Poppy will always have my respect and I will be listening to many of its tracks for years to come.

    9.5/10    … Expand
  21. CDizzness
    Apr 11, 2020
    9
    Titanic Sinclair better pray for forgiveness from Jesus the Christ....I've never been much of a Poppy fan but this metal take on pop breathes all the freshness of the genre I have been looking for. Sampling the likes of j-pop and electronica as well.
  22. adrielaguilaruv
    Jan 10, 2020
    10
    Amazing album all are bangerz! Poppy really thaaaaat! Yas shes amazing! I disagree is a new thing and shes doing well! So proud
  23. Gabrielovato
    Jan 10, 2020
    10
    the best rock/metal album of the year!!!! poppy is a genius and iconic. LEGENDARY
  24. Himayocat
    Jan 10, 2020
    8
    A wonderful album. I disagree is the best track out of the whole album. While the mood swings in the songs (e.g the really dark part and then going into really happy and cheery) can be quite annoying at some times (this was especially ruined on "Fill The Crown") but still quite good nevertheless. And yes, there are like 1/2 pop (ish) songs on this album. Overall, good album, made me a fanA wonderful album. I disagree is the best track out of the whole album. While the mood swings in the songs (e.g the really dark part and then going into really happy and cheery) can be quite annoying at some times (this was especially ruined on "Fill The Crown") but still quite good nevertheless. And yes, there are like 1/2 pop (ish) songs on this album. Overall, good album, made me a fan of this new genre she's doing.… Expand
  25. CherryAlterlife
    Jan 10, 2020
    10
    Ppppy is her most abstract self in 'I Disagree', an album celebrating her rebirth as a Nu-Metal star.
  26. sweetenerartpop
    Jan 10, 2020
    10
    Poppy apresenta seu terceiro álbum de estúdio da maneira mais orquestrada e coesa possível. Com referências Pop/Rock/Post-Genre, podemos perceber a fúria e a rebeldia ao longo do projeto, fazendo o título tomar sentido. 10/10
  27. Lajaleaa
    Feb 13, 2020
    7
    ( 77/100 )

    Un proyecto que trata de atender a la comunidad Metal-Pop que varias veces no logra un buen equilibrio, pero cuando lo logra, hay una interesante propuesta tanto musical como lírica en la que se puede notar un esfuerzo en la producción, a cargo de Zakk Cervini y Chris Greatti, de dar un Pop y un Metal de calidad. . A project that tries to serve the Metal-Pop community that    ( 77/100 )

    Un proyecto que trata de atender a la comunidad Metal-Pop que varias veces no logra un buen equilibrio, pero cuando lo logra, hay una interesante propuesta tanto musical como lírica en la que se puede notar un esfuerzo en la producción, a cargo de Zakk Cervini y Chris Greatti, de dar un Pop y un Metal de calidad.
    .
    A project that tries to serve the Metal-Pop community that sometimes doesn't achieve a good balance, but when it does, there's an interesting musical and lyrical proposal in which can be noticed the effort of the production, in charge of Zakk Cervini and Chris Greatti, in giving quality Pop and Metal.    … Expand
  28. KatysTouch
    Oct 3, 2021
    10
    this album is very good, for the ones who want to hate it just want to be edgy and cool. but you aren’t lol.
  29. Churchino
    Jan 12, 2020
    10
    É doido como apesar esse álbum ao mesmo tempo que apresenta "desconexões" melódicas/ritmicas tão forte, I Disagree é o álbum mais coeso da Poppy. Gostando muito dessa nova fase!
  30. samgenesi
    Jan 10, 2020
    10
    poppy se reinventou mais uma vez, e quando analisamos toda sua trajetória e todas os problemas envolvendo ts podemos perceber nitidamente amadurecimento, empoderamento e liberdade
prev
Page:

Awards & Rankings

27
#27 Most Discussed Album of 2020

Critic Reviews

All reviews »
Metascore
72

Generally favorable reviews - based on 16 Critic Reviews

Critic score distribution:
  1. Positive: 11 out of 16
  2. Mixed: 5 out of 16
  3. Negative: 0 out of 16
  1. DIY Magazine
    Feb 7, 2020
    80
    Whether viewed as empowered statement from a newly-free artist, or simply as a great record from pop’s new princess of darkness, ‘I Disagree’ is in fact, extremely agreeable indeed.
    Read full review
  2. The Quietus
    Jan 22, 2020
    80
    The result is very convincing; as much a young artist finding her voice as an AI besting the machine.
    Read full review
  3. Kerrang!
    Jan 16, 2020
    80
    For every comparison you can make of individual moments, there is little here that you can honestly say you’ve heard before, and little that can be judged on traditional terms. But that’s what makes her such a fascinating force.
    Read full review
See all critic reviews »