Fine Line
by Harry Styles
User Score
8.7

Universal acclaim- based on 3032 Ratings

User score distribution:
  1. Positive: 2,636 out of 3032
  2. Mixed: 66 out of 3032
  3. Negative: 330 out of 3032
Buy Now
Buy on

Review this album

  1. Your Score
    0 out of 10
    Rate this:
    • 10
    • 9
    • 8
    • 7
    • 6
    • 5
    • 4
    • 3
    • 2
    • 1
    • 0
    • 0
  1. Submit
  2. Check Spelling
view
per page
  1. Marjoriel
    Dec 24, 2019
    9
    I’ve been listening every day since it came out, love it! Not a single song I’d skip, except for watermelon sugar. It could be because of how much I listened to it before the album came out, but I can still listen to Lights Up and Adore You and I’m still not tired of it.
  2. nalelily
    Dec 24, 2019
    9
    A true masterpiece. It reminds me of the 70s music and aesthetics. Highly recommend.
  3. Mathias_JG
    Dec 27, 2019
    9
    The kind of album that finds the fine line between all that’s good about modern pop/rock and the eclectic eccentricities of classic rock. Think Fleetwood Mac meets Hunky Dory Bowie meets Mark Ronson. Don’t let critical snobs or boy band archetypes hinder your decision to listen and go into this realizing this is the ascension of a new artist free from that aforementioned boy band.
  4. Kevinramirez
    Jan 10, 2020
    9
    Ha hecho un buen trabajo en cuestión de letras,es muy bueno,esperaba una mejor puntuación de este album
  5. benjiminss
    Jan 10, 2020
    9
    a masterpiece. the aesthetic of this album is what i’ve been waiting for. so many bops.
  6. bonjourxz
    Jan 19, 2020
    9
    Harry é um artista que tem muito que mostrar e o 'Fine Line' só comprova isso. Fora do ambiente do self-titled, o segundo álbum trabalha com instrumentais diferenciados mas que se encaixam perfeitamente no estilo de música que H. tanto se caracteriza. Com músicas muito boas para chorar e também dançar, o Fine Line não surpreende em ser um dos mais vendidos e um dos melhores de 2019. EuHarry é um artista que tem muito que mostrar e o 'Fine Line' só comprova isso. Fora do ambiente do self-titled, o segundo álbum trabalha com instrumentais diferenciados mas que se encaixam perfeitamente no estilo de música que H. tanto se caracteriza. Com músicas muito boas para chorar e também dançar, o Fine Line não surpreende em ser um dos mais vendidos e um dos melhores de 2019. Eu ainda tenho preferência pelo primeiro álbum, mas é inegável o crescimento artístico que ele demonstra e a ambição de fazer boa música.… Expand
  7. Pentamikk
    May 31, 2022
    9
    An amazing album. The perfect Harry Styles in my opinion. This album also contains my favorite song of all time, Sunflower vol. 6! it's very dear to my heart :)
  8. claradf
    Jan 30, 2020
    9
    Harry always surprises me in the best possible way. With each song you get to know a new side of him. With a Beatles vibe, Harry makes me happy with this album and cry too.
  9. JenBi
    Jan 30, 2020
    9
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Un álbum con lyrics muy buenas Solo hay que ponerle mucha atención, además de que el sonido y ritmo es más que agradable… Expand
  10. Agr_
    Jan 30, 2020
    9
    This album is an emotional trip. From high to lows. The production is beautiful, real instruments, beautiful lyrics. His voice is soulful. You can discover treasure in the tracks Even after listening to them for a whole month. The last track Fine Line, it’s just made for a movie soundtrack. We’ll be alright...
  11. urprecious
    Feb 14, 2020
    9
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. coucou coucou coucou aaaaaaaaaaAAAAH aaaaaaaaAAAAAAAAAH zevwa coucou coucou… Expand
  12. Narney
    Mar 27, 2020
    9
    A song for every mood and feeling. Not a huge Harry Styles fan but I heard it at my local music shop and fell in love! Great album!
  13. Fra101
    Nov 30, 2020
    9
    Rock vibes, interesting lyrics, catchy sounds, this album is one of the best albums of the year (both 2019 & 2020 to be honest)
  14. matthewjoseph_
    Aug 2, 2020
    9
    This album is SO GOOD! There were so many different genres of this album which was impressive considering it only has 12 songs. The singles chosen for the album were the perfect ones to give listeners a the vibe of the album. GIVE THIS ONE A LISTEN!
  15. Diogoroman
    Aug 28, 2020
    9
    Heres the proof that a mainstream singer can make a great album, Fine Line is such a rollercoaster of emotions this bring you to sad and nostalgic , to a very happy and enjoyable songs, Harry Styles makes his own way , in his previous work he show up a out time álbum , and now Fine Line sound like something never seen before but a the same time doesnt sound like currently pop, thatHeres the proof that a mainstream singer can make a great album, Fine Line is such a rollercoaster of emotions this bring you to sad and nostalgic , to a very happy and enjoyable songs, Harry Styles makes his own way , in his previous work he show up a out time álbum , and now Fine Line sound like something never seen before but a the same time doesnt sound like currently pop, that means he has found his sound , and this is the reason why of his success, this album is a fine line between the main stream pop and the good music.… Expand
  16. Bhavin12
    Feb 23, 2021
    9
    It's just the amazing variety of music and rock are balanced by him. I hope this is a beginning of astonishingly good songs to come from him.
  17. pug-daniel
    Mar 22, 2021
    9
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Fine Line (Harry Styles) -
    Golden - 9/10
    Watermelon Sugar - 9/10
    Adore You - 9.5/10
    Lights Up - 10/10
    Cherry - 9.5/10
    Falling - 9/10
    To Be So Lonely - 9/10
    She - 9.5/10
    Sunflower Vol.6 - 10/10
    Canyon Moon - 10/10
    Treat People With Kindness - 9.5/10
    Fine Line - 9/10
    Overall: 9/10 i’m not a big fan of harry but this album is really great. all the songs have a unique flavor of taste with pop, indie, alternative, etc. the instrumentals in the songs are so great    … Expand
  18. Akura-ou
    Feb 1, 2023
    9
    Definitely better than the debut album. I love every song on this record. No skips.
  19. Wael
    Jan 11, 2020
    8
    While his debut self-titled LP was a pleasing collection of beautiful odes to soft rock and britpop, Harry Styles' second effort sounds like its altered, upgraded, better-crafted, grown sister. "Fine Line" is so well arranged, ranging in style and in sounds, but still being so aesthetically cohesive. It kinda, sorta, tells a story, not a new one, from being in love ('Golden', 'Adore You')While his debut self-titled LP was a pleasing collection of beautiful odes to soft rock and britpop, Harry Styles' second effort sounds like its altered, upgraded, better-crafted, grown sister. "Fine Line" is so well arranged, ranging in style and in sounds, but still being so aesthetically cohesive. It kinda, sorta, tells a story, not a new one, from being in love ('Golden', 'Adore You') to being heartbroken ('Cherry', 'Falling'), to the getting over ('Sunflower, Vol. 6', 'Canyon Moon') and peace-finding ('Fine Line'), but it sure tells it with great music playing in the background.

    The whole project exudes personal energy, like really confessional lyrics ('Falling' is literally an entry from Styles' diary) or just real-life recordings (Camille Rowe's voice as the ending of 'Cherry' is such a moving addition to the already beautiful track). Another impressive thing is the variation in sounds and styles, going from rock on 'She', to ukulele-based alternative on 'To Be So Lonely', to Vampire Weekend-esque indie sounds on 'Sunflower'. It all plays out so well, coming to the beautiful closer, which happens to be the title track, on which Styles asserts repeatedly "We'll be alright", such a basic, but exquisite-in-its-hope line.

    Both aesthetically and musically pleasing, "Fine Line" is a step (or a leap) in the right direction for Harry Styles' career.    … Expand
  20. brockcheese
    Jun 27, 2020
    8
    As a follow up to his first album here he clearly finds his own voice and has a bit more to say about love and living. These tracks are so poppy and smooth.
  21. manu_carnevale
    Nov 28, 2020
    8
    For the first time, I've got to say that Harry has left me with mixed opinions about his album. There are amazing songs (especially Falling, and the other singles), but there are also forgettable songs. Still a very nice work overall.
  22. bernxrdo
    Dec 13, 2019
    8
    Álbum coeso, letras que vão da brincadeira a sinceridade. Harry Só mostrou mais uma vez que é ARTISTA, diferente de seus antigos colegas de banda!!! Tirando o zayn pq ele não é mais da banda
  23. ivanhugo
    Jun 22, 2020
    8
    Conheci o Harry por esse álbum e me apaixonei ❤️
    ps: Adore you e Falling donas do álbum
  24. soundmate
    Dec 28, 2019
    8
    I always thought Harry Styles had an old soul. I always thought he was born to return us to another soulful rock musical era, until now.
    It is evident that the British musician has matured amazingly and evolved into a ver interesting artist since his departure from pop phenomenon One Direction. "Fine Line" feels more pop and commercial than his previous album. This, however, doesn't mean    I always thought Harry Styles had an old soul. I always thought he was born to return us to another soulful rock musical era, until now.
    It is evident that the British musician has matured amazingly and evolved into a ver interesting artist since his departure from pop phenomenon One Direction. "Fine Line" feels more pop and commercial than his previous album. This, however, doesn't mean it isn't good. The album is very enjoyable and playful. It truly feels that he has taken the best of his One Direction days and all what he has learnt this few years as a solo artist. While his debut album felt a bit monotone, "Fine Line" brings a lot of joy and emotion to the listener. It truly feels like a nice and confident evolution for the singer but still on his way to define himself and his music. The use of a gospel choir, intelligent harmonies and good production makes the album a must for pop-rock music lovers.    … Expand
  25. greedybadidea
    May 31, 2020
    8
    Harry Styles' sophomore solo album 'Fine Line' is a beautiful record, but it doesn't show a lot of growth from him as an artist. I felt like this album was just like his debut in terms of sound and overall vibe, but it does help that his vocals were amazing and the songwriting is superb. Like his debut solo record, there are some production issues, but all in all I think it was a greatHarry Styles' sophomore solo album 'Fine Line' is a beautiful record, but it doesn't show a lot of growth from him as an artist. I felt like this album was just like his debut in terms of sound and overall vibe, but it does help that his vocals were amazing and the songwriting is superb. Like his debut solo record, there are some production issues, but all in all I think it was a great listen but I want growth on his third record.

    Album Track Ranking:
    1. Falling
    2. Lights Up
    3. Adore You
    4. Watermelon Sugar
    5. Golden
    6. To Be So Lonely
    7. Fine Line
    8. Sunflower, Vol. 6
    9. Cherry
    10. Canyon Moon
    11. She
    12. Treat People With Kindness    … Expand
  26. Izanglez
    Jun 7, 2020
    8
    This albums gives me peace, which I need. He really knows what he is doing. It has amazing songs and some other fillers, which are not bad. Now, I would love to hear a more modern Harry Styles.
  27. Oaoj
    Jun 3, 2020
    8
    You can feel what he wants to portrait in the songs. Watermelon Sugar is good. Very. Good.
  28. uglysfck
    Dec 13, 2019
    8
    nice album, nice artist
    harry styles is one of the biggest names artists of this generation, he deserves all suport.
    there's a fell songs which i don't like cause it's not my kind of music, but there's amazing songs too
  29. ourendlesseason
    Dec 16, 2019
    8
    Harry non smette mai di stupire; qui troviamo una maturità ed una consapevolezza della musica che nel primo non aveva raggiunto completamente. In quest'album trova il coraggio di sperimentare, creare e proporre qualcosa che, anche se fortemente ispirato agli anni '70, risulta fresco e contemporaneo, pieno di carattere. Non mi sento di dare un voto superiore all'otto per i testi ancora nonHarry non smette mai di stupire; qui troviamo una maturità ed una consapevolezza della musica che nel primo non aveva raggiunto completamente. In quest'album trova il coraggio di sperimentare, creare e proporre qualcosa che, anche se fortemente ispirato agli anni '70, risulta fresco e contemporaneo, pieno di carattere. Non mi sento di dare un voto superiore all'otto per i testi ancora non all'altezza della sua musica.… Expand
  30. Brennin
    Dec 14, 2019
    8
    O álbum é bom. Indiscutível. Agora, as temáticas trabalhadas e, mais especificamente, a forma em que foram trabalhadas não fugiram dos cenários óbvios. Vocalmente incrível. Sonoramente agradável (ponto positivo para o coral em Treat People With Kindness e a instrumentalização em Cherry ). Liricamente ok, porém previsível. Em suma, a gente se diverte.
  31. tabacodenrolar
    Dec 14, 2019
    8
    Harry Styles’ follow up to his eponymous debut record is a major improvement on all fronts.
  32. girlcrushcover
    Dec 15, 2019
    8
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. album of the decade. the song fine line is literally healing my soul. loads of different sounds and styles. you can really see how the shrooms influenced him in terms of creating the sounds.… Expand
  33. namelesspup
    Dec 24, 2019
    8
    Harry Styles’ second album definitely sounds different than his first. There are few songs (from HS1) that sound lot alike his second album concept but they too took me few listens to start liking them. First listen was hard for me since it barely sounds like nowadays’ mainstream music, which is a good thing, considering many artists’ put out alike music. It definitely took me few listensHarry Styles’ second album definitely sounds different than his first. There are few songs (from HS1) that sound lot alike his second album concept but they too took me few listens to start liking them. First listen was hard for me since it barely sounds like nowadays’ mainstream music, which is a good thing, considering many artists’ put out alike music. It definitely took me few listens to start liking this album. When you compare Fine Line to the 70s, which apparently what inspired HS during the process of recording, it will never match to David Bowie, Stevie Nicks, and such. It’s not necessarily a bad thing, because HS somehow still came out with original sounds

    GOLDEN’s opening has a One Direction feeling to it. It put me on nostalgic mood for a moment. Sounds a lot like most stuff he put during 1D’s days in Four era.

    WATERMELON SUGAR has ‘funny’ lyrics. Looking at how he has ‘Kiwi’ back on his first album, it seems like HS is keeping up with his fans’ inside joke of having him made an entire salad fruits as his songs title. However, it’s apparently a sexual song. This proves HS is a good songwriter with his metaphor-plays in this song. Some melodies have same feeling to “Olivia” in 1D’s old album

    ADORE YOU is the song with more “mainstream music” feeling to it. It’s catchy and easy to like. With a more upbeat melodies, it contradicts the sadness you can see through the lyrics. HS also managed to pull one of the most clever promo tactics with his music video and Eroda. It’s a good watch. Would be down to see him make a whole album visual, and continuing Adore You music video.

    LIGHTS UP is my favourite out of this album. I personally think the melodies along with lyrics, song’s art work, and music video match up really well. HS managed to represent this song greatly because of that. The only downside is it (sadly) repeats the same lyrics over and over. I think HS could’ve done better to it. All in all, it’s still a great song

    CHERRY has a sweet and heartbreaking feeling to it. I love that HS managed to show glimpses of his personality and personal memories through this song without having to tell us explicitly. The voicemail at the end proves it. A normal, simple snippet of conversation but yet seems more personal since it’s attached to HS’ memory, sorta heartbreaking to hear.

    FALLING is the expected slow song of an album. It paints a sad time during a break up perfectly. HS wrote quite numerous relatable lyrics on it. With a simple mellow melody of piano, he managed to speak his hurt to the listeners

    TO BE SO LONELY is yet another sad song with happier tone of melodies. If I had to rank all of the songs on Fine Line, this definitely will come out last. A song I’d skip on my playlists. Not my cup of tea, but would love to hear it again if HS ever made an acoustic / more mellow cover of this.

    SHE has old school rock feeling. It’s too bad that HS didn’t put more high notes on it. It seems like he’s reflecting on a one night stand memory, or a love at first sight nostalgia but was beautifully put

    SUNFLOWER VOL 6 is a very summer-y song. A little snippet of his memories going through Long Distance Relationship and unexpectedly, instead of cute or sweet lyrics, it has more sexy ones. It’s not Fine Line if it doesn’t include a good portion of sad lyrics too, a good balance to it

    CANYON MOON is a more nostalgic song. HS reminisce his memories here, with more country (?) sounds to it. An easy listen and it succeeded in making me feel nostalgic too

    TREAT PEOPLE WITH KINDNESS has the title that attracted me into buying both digital and physical albums. Felt disappointed that it doesn’t represent the title well. HS had a great opportunity of turning it to a hit, alongside Heal The World and Earth. I felt like it was a wasted opportunity. Though, it has more “feeling good” vibe that actually puts you in good mood

    FINE LINE is the closing song. Just like it’s role, it’s longer than the rest and has a closing melodies for the album. I personally think it’s way too long with the same over repeated line. However HS put a good end note through the lyrics that made it good    … Expand
  34. PedroIsnard
    Jan 10, 2020
    8
    Loved it, Harry just found his real music, btw Adore You is just perfect!!!
  35. Sadeeedwards
    Feb 12, 2020
    8
    Fine line is a lot better than his debut album, showing major growth as an artist. My favorites are adore you, lights up, watermelon sugar, falling, golden and cherry.

    86/120
    80%
    8/10
  36. vicka
    Jan 30, 2020
    8
    wow i love it.... your musics so good its vibes so amazing!!! he so talented
  37. dizzia
    Apr 17, 2020
    8
    Maybe, I say maybe, he can't become a legend but must be an icon of our generation.
  38. Diego0329
    Mar 17, 2020
    8
    Much better album than his last one. Favorite song is either falling or adore you.
  39. GamePlayer77
    May 25, 2021
    8
    Although experiencing a quality drop in the second half, Fine Line is a very impactful album, and is one of the best pop albums of 2019.

    FAV TRACK: Golden
    LEAST FAV TRACK: Sunflower, Vol. 6
  40. hellokittypie
    Sep 3, 2020
    8
    It's a good album, but only good! It has great music, Harry delivered a cohesive album, but it's more of the same.
  41. kevss
    Oct 30, 2020
    8
    lyrically is great and has interesting elements that makes the album really special
  42. matthewmirliani
    Dec 16, 2019
    7
    Fine Line by Harry Styles isn’t the modern classic it wants to be, but it offers a mostly engaging demonstration of his talent as an artist. The record excels at tapping into and sampling Styles’ obvious inspirations - The Beatles, Simon and Garfunkel, Nick Drake, Queen, Elton John - and takes the listener on a pleasant sonic journey through 1970’s funk-rock and folksy, gray sky ballads.Fine Line by Harry Styles isn’t the modern classic it wants to be, but it offers a mostly engaging demonstration of his talent as an artist. The record excels at tapping into and sampling Styles’ obvious inspirations - The Beatles, Simon and Garfunkel, Nick Drake, Queen, Elton John - and takes the listener on a pleasant sonic journey through 1970’s funk-rock and folksy, gray sky ballads. It never manages, however, to get past being a tribute to a bygone era of music; it certainly hints at Styles’ massive potential as a rock star, but it doesn’t quite stick the landing despite the ambition.… Expand
  43. wales7388
    Mar 20, 2021
    7
    i wasn't originally fond of the album upon my first listen but it did have some replay value later on. i still don't find myself listening to it besides 3 or 4 tracks but not even that. still a step up from his debut
  44. aidencheung
    Dec 14, 2019
    7
    The sound throughout the album is new for Harry Styles. Quite different from his debut album.
  45. gabrielmatos
    Dec 13, 2019
    7
    This album is very different of “Harry Styles”, him debut album. Harry sounds more pop than before. The production is amazing, the lyrical content too, but for me, not sounds very good as before. But the album is not bad at all
  46. guitarh4
    Dec 20, 2019
    7
    In terms of songwriting, Styles takes a step back from his self-titled record, his first. But in terms of aesthetic and vision, it’s leagues ahead. It’s a shame the songs aren’t stellar, because the vibe certainly is, but luckily, it’s got a few absolute hits — namely, “Adore You” and “Lights Up” — to serve as highlights and permanent playlist fixtures.
  47. Iamdougls
    Jan 5, 2020
    7
    Harry não era o meu 1D favorito, mas com certeza me parece ser o único que até agora soube o que quis fazer uma vez que todos seguiram caminhos distintos. Fine Line trás um Harry mais aberto a possibilidades e ao mesmo tempo um recado para os fãs do 1D que curtiam o som da banda: "fique comigo ou me deixe."
  48. mios97
    Jan 11, 2020
    7
    Its a good album. he’s grown a lot from the last album, both musically and lyrically.
  49. brehnrr
    Jan 11, 2020
    7
    nota 7 pq ele prometeu uma coisa e entregou algo diferente, mas as músicas são muito boas, tudo com ele eh na base do conceito e aclamação
  50. Intheshade
    Jan 15, 2020
    7
    Showcases a wide range of sonic styles that can feel messy at times, but still manages to be cohesive in themes.
  51. coolguylestat
    Jan 20, 2020
    7
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Let me preface this by saying I am a rock fan. Harry Styles has always been the odd one out of my playlist, as everything else I listen to is much... harder? I've always appreciated this guy's influence of old classic rock and his enigmatic pretense both in real life and in interviews. Harry has such an intelligent, mature soul (I honestly get the vibe that there's something more to him but I'm gonna keep that to myself). OK, this isn't a review on Harry himself, but the album Fine Line. Let me start out by saying this; it was okay. It wasn't trash, it wasn't mediocre, it wasn't bland, but it wasn't... excellent. it's definitely a 7.5 for me. Only 2 songs had me really genuinely embraced in the music, and only 3 could manage to suck me in. It seemed like, while the others held significance they just simply lacked depth, like everything that wanted to be said was stated directly.

    'She' was a knockout for me, probably one of the best songs of 2019. The guitar was IMMACULATE the channeling of 70s-80s rock with the vocals on the chorus sent shivers down my spine, and did I mention the guitar? The song pulls you in and doesn't let you go. You feel high while the guitar solo plays. Honestly, give me an album of just Mitch playing that guitar and I'll buy it, I swear. 'Fine Line' (the song) was probably second best for me. While people say that the constant repetition of the title is annoying, I just get more and more emotion from it every time its sang. Anxiety and tension build until it's released with the smashing of drums. Truly a wonderful closing song! Other notable good songs were 'Golden', 'Lights Up', 'Adore You', and 'To Be So Lonely'. Sunflower gets an honorable mention.

    Now, what this album lacked that his first album did so well: the 'Kiwi' moment. There was no jump up, scream the lyrics at the top of your lungs and thrash moment on Fine Line and it was... disappointing to say the least. The hyping up of 'Watermelon Sugar' to be the next Kiwi led to an underwhelming reveal. I don't like that song at all, I'm sorry. I refuse to even compare it to my darling 'Kiwi'. Harry Styles, if you're out there, just know that I am still so upset that Medicine had a chance and yet you put in Watermelon Sugar. Medicine would have been the second best song on the album (yes, 'She' is better than 'Medicine', i admit that) and it would have been the kiwi moment we deserve. Please Harry, I beg. It doesn't even have to be on an album just please release Medicine.

    All rants about Songs aside, this is a fun album, and easily one of the best releases of 2019. If you compare this album to the other ones released this year... yeah it's probably like number three or something. But in the general history of music, and of Harry Styles, it really isn't too high...

    By the way I am still salty about what Harry did to Medicine but that's fine it's cool. :)    … Expand
  52. noinguyen
    Dec 7, 2020
    7
    Harry Styles' sophomore "Fine Line" truly has some impressive moments, but lacks consistency.

    Favorite tracks: Golden; Adore You; Lights Up; Falling; She; Sunflower, Vol. 6; Fine Line
    Least favorite tracks: To Be So Lonely; Treat People With Kindness
  53. HenryFischer
    Apr 29, 2020
    7
    This is a good album, personally I don't think it is as good as people say it is. Positive: Harry Styles has an amazing voice, that he used in bangers and ballads for his second album. He is amazing at smoothly mixing various genres together throughout the album. He makes his pop music reminiscent of the 60's-90's in one way or another, by adding his standard pop sound to the sound ofThis is a good album, personally I don't think it is as good as people say it is. Positive: Harry Styles has an amazing voice, that he used in bangers and ballads for his second album. He is amazing at smoothly mixing various genres together throughout the album. He makes his pop music reminiscent of the 60's-90's in one way or another, by adding his standard pop sound to the sound of those eras. Negative: He should have added more depth to his lyrics, they seemed sort of one dimensional; several songs on this album sounded very similar to each other. Overall analysis: This album is decent, I think he'll be the future of pop, especially among his male pop singer peers. When I look back at his first album to this one I think that he has professed quite a bit as an artist. I'm excited to know what the follow up to Fine Line will be like.… Expand
  54. RipItUpMusic
    May 23, 2020
    7
    I absolutely despised One Direction as a child and then as a teenager. Therefore, while somewhat dreading listening to this album, I was pleasantly surprised when I did get round to having a listen to Styles’ 2019 album. The album is a nice melange of genres. There’s almost folky Ben Howard-esque number ‘Cherry’, sombre moving ballads ‘Falling’ and ‘Fine Line’, but also poppier numbersI absolutely despised One Direction as a child and then as a teenager. Therefore, while somewhat dreading listening to this album, I was pleasantly surprised when I did get round to having a listen to Styles’ 2019 album. The album is a nice melange of genres. There’s almost folky Ben Howard-esque number ‘Cherry’, sombre moving ballads ‘Falling’ and ‘Fine Line’, but also poppier numbers ‘Golden’ and ‘Watermelon Sugar’. Not the sort of album I usually enjoy, and not in all my cup of tea, but I surprisingly enjoyed listening to it. Well done for proving my premonitions wrong, Mr Styles!… Expand
  55. fernanda49
    Aug 28, 2020
    7
    Es un buen álbum, pero siento que no innova mucho en las canciones, letra y melodías. Como fan de él desde One Direction me hubiera gustado ver una evolución mas profunda sobre todo en el ritmo de las canciones ya que a mi parecer muchas tienen un sonido muy básico.
  56. ferzeli
    Sep 2, 2020
    7
    U menine mandou bem aqui... comparando com o debut eu consegui me amarrar muito mais com as musicas. Mesmo tendo tracks completamente desconexas (na minha cabeça são) eu consigo reconhecer as tracks bem escolhidas (e feitas). Fine Line, a música, segue com o titulo de maior da carreira
  57. Dalmx
    Mar 23, 2021
    7
    qqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqq
  58. gianivalen
    May 21, 2022
    7
    Good album, nice aesthetic. The lyrics improved and most songs are catchy. I would’ve like to see more rockish songs like in the first one, but still a nice album.
  59. miguelcstb
    Mar 8, 2023
    7
    I had to listen to some songs twice to understand what I was listening to. This album has a very mature sound that I enjoyed very much, which for me it was a surprise because the only song from
    this album that I knew was “watermelon sugar”, and that made me expect something very commercial and basic.
  60. leogarcia132002
    Nov 25, 2022
    7
    It's a concept album of the kind of commercial pop we're used to, I think Styles has the lyrical potential to form aesthetics.
  61. musicreviews7
    Dec 15, 2019
    6
    It's a good pop one, but offers little more than that. Harry Styles is a decent songwriter with a decent voice, but there's nothing unique here I'm afraid.
  62. All_ButTrU4
    Feb 11, 2022
    6
    It appears Harry has taken the best parts of his debut and improved upon them. This record feels truly like something only he could do which is what makes it so impressive and diverse. The lead "lights up" gives a Harry like never before seen,in the video he's shirtless, dirty in a orgy of ckose body's seemingly setting off the unbearable sexuality rumours. It felt like a perfume genius NoIt appears Harry has taken the best parts of his debut and improved upon them. This record feels truly like something only he could do which is what makes it so impressive and diverse. The lead "lights up" gives a Harry like never before seen,in the video he's shirtless, dirty in a orgy of ckose body's seemingly setting off the unbearable sexuality rumours. It felt like a perfume genius No Shape era influenced bop,the chorus is built up to in a cathartic message to be yourself. "Adore You" is a passionate longing for something that won't work so rather than commit to it he revels in enjoying it's luxury. His first number 1 with a chorus that smart it's no surprise it took over the charts. In what I see to be the only misstep "canyon moon" Harry still sounds good but the song is empty, just words set to song without the personality that reinforces the strength his performances. The fun self depreciating "to be so lonely " is a short lived groove bound for many shower karaoke's. But out of all this and maybe his discography is the grabd title track. Omg i cannot stress the tracks draw. It's lyrics guilt and regret feel grown up and the instrumental build up and eventual catharsis (with trumpets even!) comes exactly when you need it. Despite it's 6min runtime it doesn't overstay it's welcome. It's a beacon of hope for what Harry is capable of and a crown in his discography.… Expand
  63. WyrdSister
    Dec 15, 2019
    6
    Fine Line is not a bad album, but it seems like Harry isn't quite sure of his musical direction (no pun intended). His surprising, self-titled debut album combined different influences and sounds as well, but they were held together by their similar instrumentation, consistent tone and high-quality, but understated production. The sound of Fine Line on the other hand seems all over theFine Line is not a bad album, but it seems like Harry isn't quite sure of his musical direction (no pun intended). His surprising, self-titled debut album combined different influences and sounds as well, but they were held together by their similar instrumentation, consistent tone and high-quality, but understated production. The sound of Fine Line on the other hand seems all over the place, there's not much common ground between the radio friendly, but lightweight pop songs, introspective, acoustic guitar songs, psychedelic reggae, campfire country etc. What's missing though are any good, fast rock numbers that were a highlight on his debut album (and in live concerts) or a timeless hit like Sign of the Times. Instead he included a track called Treat People With Kindness, that appears involuntarily comical in its Kumbaya anthem attempt.

    All in all there are some really good elements on this album, where Harry can definitely show his versatility and vocal prowess, but against his biggest competition - himself on his previous album - it appears confusing, of less consistent quality and falls ultimately (both musically and lyrically) short.    … Expand
  64. tommyelv
    Dec 13, 2019
    6
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Первые впечатления после прослушивания — не того материала мы ждали. Альбом радикально другой нежели предыдущая работа Гарри. Второе впечатление — очень достойно! Но, треков уровня Sign of the Times, больше нет и не будет:(… Expand
  65. Mcritique12
    Dec 14, 2019
    6
    Harry failed to step aside of his comfort zone in terms of exploring different themes on this album. Like his last body of work it seems like his writing consist of using the same phrases to try and explain his heartache about a certain breakup. In songs where he does try to dabble in some different teritory like TPWK he fails to lyricly bring out the essence of the song. There is also aHarry failed to step aside of his comfort zone in terms of exploring different themes on this album. Like his last body of work it seems like his writing consist of using the same phrases to try and explain his heartache about a certain breakup. In songs where he does try to dabble in some different teritory like TPWK he fails to lyricly bring out the essence of the song. There is also a lot of unecessary long outros and boring sequences of instrumentals. On the bright side his vocal arrengments are really nicely done and songs like Lights up make up for the lack of thematic diversitality on the album. All in all a solid album that has a lot to offer but it certainly isnt a record that will be remembered for a long time.… Expand
  66. Goobersnot
    Dec 17, 2019
    6
    Pretty good sonically but lordt the navel gazing lyrics, which were probably the part Styles was responsible for.
  67. r4r3
    Jan 10, 2020
    6
    no importa cuando leas esto, te amo cada días más que el anterior, estoy orgullosa de todo lo que eres y se que vas a lograr más, brilla más que cualquier otra estrella.
    @JosDice

    #SuccessJos https://t.co/XayvR9GIk2
  68. kassus
    Oct 30, 2020
    6
    Totally did not get the hype this album is recieving. Only liked half of the song on the album. Maybe he should've spent more time on this album cause it's not clear to me what he wanted to even convey.
  69. LsSiel
    May 29, 2020
    5
    De veras que amo "Watermelon sugar" y "Adore You" y quizás sólo por ellas me atrevo a darle la calificación de 5. Sin embargo siento que el resto del disco no es ni remotamente tan bueno.
  70. nonblonde
    Dec 13, 2019
    5
    The three pre-release tracks are way more interesting than anything on the album. They sound like they belong to a different project.

    You can hear him struggling in some tracks despite the autotune. He's definitely going to have to change the keys to perform this. Overall, it's not bad but it doesn't live up to the hype and over the top praise. It doesn't bring any emotional moments    The three pre-release tracks are way more interesting than anything on the album. They sound like they belong to a different project.

    You can hear him struggling in some tracks despite the autotune. He's definitely going to have to change the keys to perform this.

    Overall, it's not bad but it doesn't live up to the hype and over the top praise. It doesn't bring any emotional moments vocal or lyrics-wise. Some songs are too repetitive and they drag on. It's not different from his debut, which I didn't like but I give him some points for the production.    … Expand
  71. Hek_hadley
    Dec 18, 2019
    5
    FINE LINE is not necessarily a bad album...there are some tracks that are actually good and are worth listening over again. The issues I encountered were the lyrics on some of the songs. They can come off vapid. I also don’t feel like he stepped outside of his comfort zone. Lastly, all of the songs sound almost identical, I really wish the production could have done a better job atFINE LINE is not necessarily a bad album...there are some tracks that are actually good and are worth listening over again. The issues I encountered were the lyrics on some of the songs. They can come off vapid. I also don’t feel like he stepped outside of his comfort zone. Lastly, all of the songs sound almost identical, I really wish the production could have done a better job at distinguishing them. Bottom line: FINE LINE is okay....definitely not a bad record but it’s also nothing groundbreaking. Fans of Harry Styles will enjoy it and because of them this album will make a fortune. Here’s hoping that his next album is a bigger step than this since he actually have a talented voice.… Expand
  72. Mekakritik
    Dec 13, 2019
    5
    Pretty weak album, Golden and Watermelon Sugar are the 2 songs that stand out in a relatively boring attempt of an album to come off as both sweet but weird at the same time.
    Love Harry but I'll wait for his next album
  73. AEIOU57
    Dec 23, 2019
    5
    Great album. He has come a long way from his 1D days. He is proving that you can make sustainable music that grows with time. He shed the boy band image that his 1D fans were determined to keep him labeled with. He has matured and is finally finding his place in the industry
  74. Cherrysugar
    Dec 25, 2019
    5
    Except for the song Fine Line, which is definitely an ode Lucifer with intro that sounds like satanic ritual chants, all other eleven songs are classic earworms and pleasant to the senses. I heard that Fine Line is actually a Gematria code for Lucifer, which could be true because the creepy hand on the album cover art looks like that of a devil.
  75. Sonalidabir
    Dec 24, 2019
    5
    Listening to Fine Line was such a pleasant surprise. Definitely one of the best albums of the decade.
    It is best to listen it from first to the last song. Of these, Golden, Falling, She, To be so lonely, Canyon moon and Fine Line are the best songs for me. The title track Fine Line is timeless and will live on forever as one of the evergreen songs.
  76. idvntmind
    Dec 24, 2019
    5
    harry is such a good and kind person, we are always hoping he’s going to do something that will surprise us. and he did. he really did. he’s an amazing singer, writer and musician in general. u should listen his album. it’s perfect. u will feel a lot of emotions while listening and maybe it’s my favorite thing. anywayssss stream fine line! bye
  77. kermie_the_frog
    Dec 28, 2019
    5
    This record is very unfocused and inconsistent. There are a couple good singles off the record but it lacks the cohesion and consistency in style needed for a complete sounding album. However, Harry Styles has certainly made the best music of the ex-one direction members and I am looking forward to his future releases.
  78. DriaWoods
    Jan 27, 2020
    5
    Half the album is great (Golden, Watermelon, Lights Up, Fine Line, Falling, Adore You) but the other half is either okay or not good at all. Harry has voiced that he had more fun with this album than HS1 and I love that. I love that he had fun and enjoys this new 70s psychedelic-pop sound. However, for my ears and tastes it’s just not it. It’s not as good as his first record. The 6 songs IHalf the album is great (Golden, Watermelon, Lights Up, Fine Line, Falling, Adore You) but the other half is either okay or not good at all. Harry has voiced that he had more fun with this album than HS1 and I love that. I love that he had fun and enjoys this new 70s psychedelic-pop sound. However, for my ears and tastes it’s just not it. It’s not as good as his first record. The 6 songs I listed above are bops that I can jam to everyday. If he made an EP instead with those 6 songs I’d give this album a 10 review instead of a 5.… Expand
  79. musicismylife24
    Feb 5, 2020
    5
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. You cannot listen to She or Sunflower and not become addicted to this album. Harry’s high notes in She reminds me of an old school Prince song.… Expand
  80. sieb04
    May 11, 2020
    5
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Fine Line is (as you can hear) heavily inspired by creative geniuses like: David Bowie, Paul McCartney, Fleetwood Mac etc. Every song has that something that makes it interesting and fun to listen to. But it's not Harry Styles, and he is not yet on the creative level as those other artist where they found what fits them. Harry still plays around a bit too much with the sounds of other artists (heavily inspired). He hasn't really found what fits him, yet. And even though both of his albums are good and fun to listen to, I had hoped he had found a bit of his own style/lane a bit more on this album. In the end it is still a good album, but we all know he can do better! And make his OWN music.… Expand
  81. Dsros96
    Dec 15, 2019
    4
    A huge letdown since his debut. There are almost no songs worth it and Harry seems to have lost his different sound.
  82. Lazlo1
    Aug 28, 2020
    4
    Un álbum que si bien tiene singles muy buenos, algunos tracks dejan mucho que desear. Creo que no es lo que quería hacer el propio artista, y que hasta a él mismo le ha costado encontrar el sonido. Con ganas de saber qué nos trae en el siguiente álbum, porque sin duda este no me ha convencido nada.
  83. froz3nfire
    Dec 21, 2019
    4
    A good album, overhyped by media and fans. For me, his debut album is better than this one.
  84. Patriciabeag
    Jan 26, 2020
    4
    Overhyped and repetitive, every song is the same...his first album was better
  85. PeterSant
    Dec 29, 2019
    3
    It's very distressing for Harry Styles to try to go of the genre "Rock". Yes, he is extremely talented, but wanting to be like a David Bowie of this generation is not very sure.
    This new work has managed to be worse than the previous one, songs that I don't quite understand what message you want to convey, but maybe with one or two that still won't let it be a musical disaster.
  86. hsaosjn
    Sep 8, 2020
    3
    this man is EXTREMELY overrated. he is the definition of white mediocrity. all of the songs on this album sound like something i’ve already heard before. the majority of the people that listen to his music are his fans who mostly listen to mainstream pop so for them, this album seems revolutionary. but for me, who listens to music from almost every genre, this album is nothing special.
  87. lunalistens
    Feb 13, 2020
    3
    Ehh i gave it a try, wasn’t for me sorry. Kinda fell asleep. Wont listen to it again
  88. kepjang457
    Oct 3, 2020
    3
    Harry's vocals are truly outstanding and emotional, a strong point for this album. There seemed to be a clear concept as well. However, like many albums this year, many of the songs sounded incredibly similar to each other, the lyrics were also extremely similar from song to song, and the subject matter was really lacking. The production on some tracks was unique and they tried new thingsHarry's vocals are truly outstanding and emotional, a strong point for this album. There seemed to be a clear concept as well. However, like many albums this year, many of the songs sounded incredibly similar to each other, the lyrics were also extremely similar from song to song, and the subject matter was really lacking. The production on some tracks was unique and they tried new things but ultimately it was pretty messy. But production on other tracks like Cherry was smooth and pretty. This is another album that fell in the retro-alt category, but it failed to really stand out in any way.… Expand
  89. sassymah
    Jan 2, 2020
    2
    Most overrated and overhyped album of the year. Not Grammy-worthy. Do not understand these puff piece reviews.
  90. a_sebastian
    Mar 9, 2020
    2
    Waste of time.
    Mine and the guy singing.
    Will the industry ever get up from the voice and other idols?
    this guy is over represented in the medias. WHY?

    anyway the 2 points are for the title song. nice one.
  91. jasminn
    Dec 14, 2019
    2
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Everyone on twitter was hyping this album up like crazy but I listened to the leak and there was one good song. The songwriting is bland and boring. Falling is great but the lyrics could have had deeper meaning with more metaphors. Tpwk is horrible and sounds like a 80s rock influenced kids bop song. Sunflower had so much potential but the weird sounds in the bridge completely ruined the song. White male mediocrity strikes again… Expand
  92. Naz34
    Dec 16, 2019
    2
    I am baffled by the high critical score, then again the biased media always favored Harry over the others. This album is mediocre, bland, over hyped, and literally only has two decent songs.

    This album is worse than his first one.
  93. skalivv
    Jan 29, 2020
    2
    A lot of hype but he really needs to work on his lyrics and think better about the deep of his work. I am seeing beauty and sex material only in a nice package of high profile producers. I can not see him properly in this. But if he only wants to be a performer and not a complete artist. That's fine.
  94. Agnes22
    Mar 27, 2020
    2
    despite what he says, it just doesn’t feel genuine or like there’s much thought behind it. i loved his first album and was looking forward to this one, but this doesn’t even compare in the slightest. there’s a catchy song or two on there and the obligatory ballads, which are the only ones that have even half decent lyrics. repeating the same two words 50 times isn’t songwriting (i’mdespite what he says, it just doesn’t feel genuine or like there’s much thought behind it. i loved his first album and was looking forward to this one, but this doesn’t even compare in the slightest. there’s a catchy song or two on there and the obligatory ballads, which are the only ones that have even half decent lyrics. repeating the same two words 50 times isn’t songwriting (i’m looking at you, watermelon sugar)… Expand
  95. vanessa13
    Dec 14, 2019
    1
    Just like its creator, Fine Line is a a colorful cover in a world of nothing with real substance. This album feels more like a rushed assortment of cute titles and promo marketing than actual artistic growth or genuine creativity and imagination. Harry Styles needs to put more effort in song writing and lyrical development instead of trying so hard to sell his image. That image being a ripJust like its creator, Fine Line is a a colorful cover in a world of nothing with real substance. This album feels more like a rushed assortment of cute titles and promo marketing than actual artistic growth or genuine creativity and imagination. Harry Styles needs to put more effort in song writing and lyrical development instead of trying so hard to sell his image. That image being a rip off of David Bowie, Elton John and Mick Jagger. For someone who looks highly of them, the listener would be confused if Harry was emulating or making a mockery of them. How drab and repetitive many tracks off the album come and go, building up to absolute nothing. Even the title track and the infamous motto of TPWK echo as uninspired. What seemed like a promising good start with Lights Up, you are left with an empty feeling as the album comes to a close. How did someone with the privilege and urge to be that different to his male counterparts miss the mark that hard? You think if only had Styles spent less time replaying Bowie videos and spent more time fostering his own artistic passion and vision, this album would have delivered something of interest. Frankly, I'm not buying what Harry Styles is selling.… Expand
  96. Dablyc
    Dec 23, 2019
    1
    If "meh" were a genre of music, this would definitely be an average "meh" album. In other words, between the extremes of "so-so" and "absolutely horrible", I would say Fine Line is "blah". Everything that people have said about the emptiness of the lyrics and the not-so-inspiring nature of the melodies is on the mark. The Wall Street Journal review is the most honest professional reviewIf "meh" were a genre of music, this would definitely be an average "meh" album. In other words, between the extremes of "so-so" and "absolutely horrible", I would say Fine Line is "blah". Everything that people have said about the emptiness of the lyrics and the not-so-inspiring nature of the melodies is on the mark. The Wall Street Journal review is the most honest professional review I've seen. Every other professional is covering their real opinion with what to me is masterfully crafted rhetoric... They won't directly say it's below average, but the way they are beating around the bush with hands-off phrases are the same thing I do with people who have done poorly, but I don't want to discourage them with outright criticism; so I encourage them with abstract criticism that doesn't seem like they failed, but is not direct praise, either. I notice so many reviews trying to make this album "seem" good by comparing it to what great musicians have done and what this "attempts" to do, without saying directly that it doesn't quite meet up to the standards of those others' great works. So... Kudos to Fine Line for being Middle Meh.… Expand
  97. Lullabyx
    Dec 23, 2019
    1
    Really boring album Not worth the hype at all same sound as hs1 thought it would be amazing from reading reviews
  98. anasimao888
    Jan 31, 2021
    1
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. é inacreditável como artistas visionários como prince, david bowie, iggy pop e afins criaram um movimento artistico que buscou quebrar padroes e papeis de genero só para em 2020 um pseudo, não-artista, farsante e estelionatario da arte como HARRY STYLES ser intitulado como revolucionario quando o maximo q o mesmo é capaz de proferir em sua "musicalidade" sao acordes banais, letras repetitivas e alguns looks "supostamente" provocativos quando na verdade não passa de um rapazinho revoltado com sua propria banalidade e q busca desesperadamente uma identidade coesa que expresse alguma realidade palpavel... ele nao é um grande compositor como taylor swift, não é um ícone como the weeknd e não tem o carisma de bruno mars... harry styles não passa de um FARSANTE que engana pre adolescentes e reforça esteriótipos com muito queer bait!… Expand
  99. ro-sana
    Dec 13, 2019
    0
    Boring album. He always wants to be innovative but ends up getting a dull salad. You won't empower wearing dresses.
  100. halliwells
    Dec 14, 2019
    0
    Absolutely horrible. Mediocre men and the pick me girls worshipping them for doing the bare minimum will be the downfall of the music industry.
Page:

Awards & Rankings

5
#5 Most Discussed Album of 2019

Critic Reviews

All reviews »
Metascore
76

Generally favorable reviews - based on 20 Critic Reviews

Critic score distribution:
  1. Positive: 15 out of 20
  2. Mixed: 5 out of 20
  3. Negative: 0 out of 20
  1. Q Magazine
    Dec 17, 2019
    60
    Free of the shackles that hobbled his debut, Styles manages to show more of his personality here, especially on the Vampire Weekend-style Sunflower, Vol. 6. It's just a shame he can't quite keep up with his ambition. [Feb 2020, p.110]
  2. Paste Magazine
    Dec 17, 2019
    73
    Fine Line is entirely inoffensive, but it’s also open-ended, and maybe those questions are the reward. Maybe Harry Styles just wants to keep us guessing.
    Read full review
  3. The A.V. Club
    Dec 17, 2019
    83
    Fine Line proves that the musician has absorbed the best lesson passed down by California’s great musicians: Don’t be afraid to take chances within a folk- or pop-rock framework, as that’s how you create iconoclastic music that endures.
    Read full review
See all critic reviews »