United 93

10

DaveH.May 14, 2006

One of the most intensely powerful and moving films I have ever seen. Hands down this is the best film of the decade to date.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

7

NathanS.May 14, 2006

First of all, I want to first mention that any criticism towards the movie is not suposed to be meant negatively as I realize the events actually happened and it is a very serious matter. I'm trying to analyze the movie for that - just First of all, I want to first mention that any criticism towards the movie is not suposed to be meant negatively as I realize the events actually happened and it is a very serious matter. I'm trying to analyze the movie for that - just a movie- nothing more. It's hard to criticize movies like this because they are not really meant to entertain - how can someone be entertained by terroism? They are more ment to inform, to make us remember. First off I saw the rave reviews and thought "I gatta see that!" I even had to do some convincing with a friend for a week or so before she agreed to go with me. Well, to sum it up, I was very disappointed. The first hour plus was extremely borning (on an entertainment level) with people in command centers calling one another, and a whole lot of people pointing to small little X's on screens going "Possible hijack! Possible hijack!" I probably heard that phrase 100 times in that hour, no joke. Well, maybe a little exaduration. Anyhow, the good part was when the people actually overtook the plane and made it crash. Well, not good that it crashed, just that was the exciting and thrilling part. Let's just say I didn't leave the movie with joy in my heart, but It did make me remember what our country has gone through and ALMOST make my cry (no movie has ever made me cry). If you want to leave a movie sad, be reminded of terrorism, but at the same time pay your tribute to those who gave yoru lives, see this movie. If you want to go to a movie for entertainment, to go with your girl, to leave happy, to feel entertained, etc, go see something else and wait until maybe 9/11/06 and watch it in a dark room with some kleenex as you remember those who lost their lives.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

sk.May 13, 2006

Outstanding movie on a difficult topic. One can't exactly have a happy ending. Also, all the main characters, of course, die. This was a movie about the heroism of the passengers on one flight. Some of them were more important than Outstanding movie on a difficult topic. One can't exactly have a happy ending. Also, all the main characters, of course, die. This was a movie about the heroism of the passengers on one flight. Some of them were more important than others in the action, but nothing was contrived, nobody was larger than life. Even the sound track was good, as were the special effects (though this was not a "special effects movie"). Signficantly, a number of the participants on the ground acted their real-life parts.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

EdS.May 13, 2006

The most intense movie going experience for me. This re-creation might have worked as a stand-alone thriller, but we know it's more than that. It's a tribute to those heroes who prevented what might have been the worst disaster on The most intense movie going experience for me. This re-creation might have worked as a stand-alone thriller, but we know it's more than that. It's a tribute to those heroes who prevented what might have been the worst disaster on that day.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

1

BenS.May 13, 2006

Give me a break! This pathetic attempt at government propaganda was just stomach-churning for those of us who know what REALLY happened that day.....that plane was shot down, which is why there were pieces of the plane up to 8 MILES from theGive me a break! This pathetic attempt at government propaganda was just stomach-churning for those of us who know what REALLY happened that day.....that plane was shot down, which is why there were pieces of the plane up to 8 MILES from the crash site. This flight, and the rest of the flights, were CONTROLLED BY REMOTE BEACON, NOT HI-JACKED by "Muslims" (why are 8 of the 19 "hi-jackers" STILL ALIVE, and why are their names NOT on the final flight compliments of any of the airliners? Hmmmm?). They're trying to convince you that the people's cellphones actually WORKED at that altitude? Pleeeease. Oh, and a bunch of passengers charged the "Muslim Hi-jackers" with "box-cutters"? Riiiiiiiight. This movie was so factually inaccurate it was almost hilarious. Many will scream that I am "dishonoring the memories of the victims" by writing this. On the contrary, I'm honoring them by asking some very disturbing questions and seeking answers. "United 93" is a LIE, people. Get the facts before you make an emotional judgement.… Expand

0 of 1 users found this helpful

8

JayCMay 12, 2006

I left outragged at the lack of coordination and decision making of everyone except the head traffic control leader. Where were all of the military aircraft? Where were our leaders when we needed a fast decision? I expected the ending I left outragged at the lack of coordination and decision making of everyone except the head traffic control leader. Where were all of the military aircraft? Where were our leaders when we needed a fast decision? I expected the ending verbage to say "we have fixed our system of command and control so this won't happen again"… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

DylanS.May 12, 2006

Great!

0 of 0 users found this helpful

5

matta.May 10, 2006

I was not impressed. Very messy direction, bad acting, and I even found the writing (was it mostly improvised?) to be shoddy. It just didn't resonate with me emotionally. I would say that Slate's critic is the only one that has the I was not impressed. Very messy direction, bad acting, and I even found the writing (was it mostly improvised?) to be shoddy. It just didn't resonate with me emotionally. I would say that Slate's critic is the only one that has the balls to be honest and admit that this movie kind of sucked. All of the other critics just don't want to put down a movie about 9/11.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

michellec.May 10, 2006

Without a doubt the best movie I have seen this year!!! Being prepared with a box of kleenex was simply not enough. I simply could not anticipate the pit in my stomach. It was amazing how real this was and how it triggered the emotions of Without a doubt the best movie I have seen this year!!! Being prepared with a box of kleenex was simply not enough. I simply could not anticipate the pit in my stomach. It was amazing how real this was and how it triggered the emotions of that very day. The cast of unknowns was phenonmenal and direction was brillant. This truly speaks to the heroism the country witnessed during and following this tragedy.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

R.RikardMay 8, 2006

As the credits roll and the term "starring" appears it should read "us." Greengrass powerfully, unapologetically places us on that flight. It is a flight we need to take. This film, created in a documentary fashion, reminds us that the As the credits roll and the term "starring" appears it should read "us." Greengrass powerfully, unapologetically places us on that flight. It is a flight we need to take. This film, created in a documentary fashion, reminds us that the wounds of that day are far from healed. Our vulnerability becomes more evident as each minute of viewing passes. I left the theater with a wound believed to be healed ripped forcefully open. Now the healing process can begin again.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

9

BradB.May 8, 2006

Grenngrass knows how to get the most out of his actors - using real world air traffic controllers and military personnel has added a depth to the dimension of the tragedy that day.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

7

CheleMay 8, 2006

Not like the TV A & E movie-- better for the families to watch this one....and a lot was about the Air Traffic controllers and no names were really mentioned on the plane of who was who- but you know them if you've followed the story. I Not like the TV A & E movie-- better for the families to watch this one....and a lot was about the Air Traffic controllers and no names were really mentioned on the plane of who was who- but you know them if you've followed the story. I did not cry at this but did on Flight 93. Very respectful movie.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

PaulFratianniMay 7, 2006

I'm not embellishing when I say this was either a perfect movie or very close to it. From the first moment I started watching I felt a queasy feeling in my stomach. This movie had power. I would not call this an entertaining movie but II'm not embellishing when I say this was either a perfect movie or very close to it. From the first moment I started watching I felt a queasy feeling in my stomach. This movie had power. I would not call this an entertaining movie but I do not think that was the point. There was very little mood music, the terrorists did not come across as desiring to be evil but rather zealous about their beliefs. There was an interesting point of dueling prayers. This was an essential movie to help reawaken an America falling back into its slumber ***Spoiler*** One thing that gave me more respect for these passengers and less for the readiness of the American political and military system, is without their actions the Capital Building would in all probability have been hit with who knows how many other causalities. Thank You all for your willingness to fight your fear and sacrifice for our right to be free. Do not let anyone kid you, this is not about some vast conspiracy drawn up by George W. Bush, Secret Societies, And the Oil Companies. This is about a particular brand of Islam (and not too uncommon in the middle-east) whose goal is a one World Islam. In this world there is no room for freedom of thought. Dissent is met with among many other things death. Just watch what they are doing to each other in the middle-east. Realize we are at war and still are. We are fighting an enemy whose methods are unscrupulous and difficult to tract with the end goal ill virtued among other things. I will not preach as to what needs to be done but this movie relit the fire of knowledge for me that this issue needs constant attention. When we let ourselves sleep and not see the writing on the wall events like 9/11 happen. I encourage all who read this to educate yourselves. One thing I am disheartened about in America, which thankfully on 9/11 we weren… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

TomD.May 7, 2006

Emotionally distant in one scene and then nose-deep in shaking, powerful drama the next. I can't say I enjoyed it, but I highly recommend it.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

0

PrudenceKhillersMay 7, 2006

I really despise this film. I brought kleenex, because I thought I would cry during this. Well, I certainly did not... didn't capture anything of what I remember from the day. Extreme disappointment. The entire "film" was EXACTLY like aI really despise this film. I brought kleenex, because I thought I would cry during this. Well, I certainly did not... didn't capture anything of what I remember from the day. Extreme disappointment. The entire "film" was EXACTLY like a TV movie. Pathetic. The story is sad... but I knew what was going to happen. Didn't pay any respect for the real heroes and nearly offends me.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

8

MaseMay 6, 2006

Not an easy movie to watch, this movie challenges what exactly you are looking for from the cinema. All aside when if you get it, this movie will punch you in the gut.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

DavidZ.May 6, 2006

Wonderful telling of a story we all know but need to remember. The notion that it has no overt moral to my mind is a tribute to the moviemakers. We don't need to be preached at. It simply shows the truth.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

6

TonydannieMay 5, 2006

The movie was very powerful. There is really nothing more you could say about it. It does what it is suppose to do. shed some light. At Least that is what i want to say but however. This movie did not answer any questions. This movie just The movie was very powerful. There is really nothing more you could say about it. It does what it is suppose to do. shed some light. At Least that is what i want to say but however. This movie did not answer any questions. This movie just reanacted what some people consider to be a lie. Greengrass did what he does best. create an action movie. People have asked if this is the right time for a 9/11 movie. Sure, As long as it tells the truth. And again. Stop with the shaking of the camera!! If I have offended anybody. I greatly apologize. That is just how I feel.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

GuyG.May 4, 2006

A flawless representation of reality. Movies based on the event were inevitable. We couldn't have possibly hoped for something better that this film. It manages to avoid exploitation of the subject entirely. The best movie of the year so far.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

JorgeS.May 4, 2006

WARNING: Not for the faint of heart. This just may be the best movie of the year...why? Because a lot of people that I know who have seen the film, including myself, experienced actual pysical pain afterwards. The movie is so well-made and WARNING: Not for the faint of heart. This just may be the best movie of the year...why? Because a lot of people that I know who have seen the film, including myself, experienced actual pysical pain afterwards. The movie is so well-made and so intense it is as if you had 3-D glasses on and experienced every single emotion that the passengers on the fateful flight had. I left with my hands shaking and stifness slowly moving up my spine. One of the most intense and taut films that I have seen in my 15 years of life. Oh...and that ending... *shivers*… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

DennisM.May 4, 2006

An excellent, restrained, intelligent improvisation -- crafted together from the cell phone transcripts, operator notes, cockpit tapes, FAA snippets, surviving sponse interviews who listened on the other end of the tense phone line. I loved An excellent, restrained, intelligent improvisation -- crafted together from the cell phone transcripts, operator notes, cockpit tapes, FAA snippets, surviving sponse interviews who listened on the other end of the tense phone line. I loved that there was little or no "mood music", no sentimental speeches... and the hand held shots gave me the feeling of witnessing the ordinary becoming extraordinary. It is a subtling chilling film about such a sensitive event. Breath deep and be brave and just watch the morning on Flight 93 unfold. As for all the negative "2" votes by John B and JJ and John L... (maybe all the same guy?) Perhaps the Johns of this world shouldn't see it. But if your name is anything else... don't miss it!… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

5

BillyS.May 4, 2006

Yes it's gripping. yes it's tense. yes, it even brings tears to your eyes and leaves you feeling completely helpless, but then, why would'nt it, it's about the most horrorfying nightmare that everyone on the planet sharesYes it's gripping. yes it's tense. yes, it even brings tears to your eyes and leaves you feeling completely helpless, but then, why would'nt it, it's about the most horrorfying nightmare that everyone on the planet shares and it puts you right back smack down in the middle of it. But, it is a nightmare that most people have already come to grips with in their own personal way and watching this movie is like seeing Hollywood trying to be first to cash in on an event that changed the world and I for one, am sorry I fell into the whole "unmissable" promotion by paying 10 bucks to see something I relive on a daily basis anyway.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

0

MobiusMay 4, 2006

im giving this a 0 on the grounds that the hollywood have now gone to the lowest of lows. with hollywood running out of material to make films with. this all started at the "lets make a sequel and maybe part 3 part 4 and so on, then theyim giving this a 0 on the grounds that the hollywood have now gone to the lowest of lows. with hollywood running out of material to make films with. this all started at the "lets make a sequel and maybe part 3 part 4 and so on, then they moved into the lets do movies about all the super hero comics then they moved to the lets make a remake of all those old films that made money mabe if we re do them we can fleese Jo Public, then as they thought that they had ripped off everthing some bright spark thought "hey lets make movies about computer games". now that they have done all of the above lets make a movie about 9/11 hey no one has done that. maybe we could do a sequel to it aswell like the bombing of some mountains and the ousting of the taliban so they can make some oil pie run through it to saddams palace.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

3

TomW.May 3, 2006

Very "respectful", but ultimately I don't know what this movie accomplished. Rhetorically, it seems it has nothing to say. No viewpoint, no politics, no real moral. Artistically, it also accomplished very little. Yes, it was directed Very "respectful", but ultimately I don't know what this movie accomplished. Rhetorically, it seems it has nothing to say. No viewpoint, no politics, no real moral. Artistically, it also accomplished very little. Yes, it was directed with a great deal of research and skill, but the final product feels more like the work of a great recreatist or archivist, not an artist and certainly not an entertainer. I left feeling like the movie was exactly what I expected, yet also realizing that MetaCritic scores made me think what I expected would be worth seeing. I can't say I would recommend this to anyone, even if I respect the craft Paul Greengrass used to bring it to fruition.… Expand

0 of 1 users found this helpful

10

NancyM.May 3, 2006

A movie that should be seen by every one. Expertly done, and as for timing not to soon.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

TonyB.May 2, 2006

If you think you can take it, please see it. To miss "United 93" is to miss the best film of the year so far. There's not a false moment in this awesome piece of work. On every level, what we have here is inspired filmmaking. But If you think you can take it, please see it. To miss "United 93" is to miss the best film of the year so far. There's not a false moment in this awesome piece of work. On every level, what we have here is inspired filmmaking. But remember that after you see it, it won't go away.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

WAKOJAKOMay 2, 2006

Expertly made. Not for everyone, but defenitely worth a look.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

2

JohnB.May 2, 2006

Way overrated! Dramatic and well directed, but, honestly, there was nothing new or worthwhile here for anyone who knows what happened (which is everyone) on Flight 93 on 9/11. The acting was good, except for the air traffic controller who Way overrated! Dramatic and well directed, but, honestly, there was nothing new or worthwhile here for anyone who knows what happened (which is everyone) on Flight 93 on 9/11. The acting was good, except for the air traffic controller who played himself. I've seen better acting in my kids school play. Enough is enough on 9/11. Let's get on with life.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

DougJ.May 2, 2006

It's more of a memorial than a movie. I felt the same as I did that day so it is not a pleasant experience, but you really can't miss it.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

ThomasM.May 2, 2006

Incredibly powerful and moving. Will go down as one of the finest films ever produced.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

ChadS.May 1, 2006

What's especially painful about "United 93" is the optimism that the passengers manage to convey in the midst of such dire circumstances. If the mutiny was a successful one, we learn, "United 93" could've turned into the best What's especially painful about "United 93" is the optimism that the passengers manage to convey in the midst of such dire circumstances. If the mutiny was a successful one, we learn, "United 93" could've turned into the best "Airport" movie ever. Of course, there was no Hollywood ending, and the filmmaker knows this, which is best exemplified by not overselling the "let's roll" utterance into a sort of Arnold-ism. The highlight of "United 93" is when events are at an obvious impasse and both sides engage in duelin' prayers. Personally, I felt a little less ultra-liberal walking out of the theater.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

HPMay 1, 2006

Excellent movie. Terrifying and disturbing this movie needs to be seen by all and especially those who have forgotten.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

8

JayS.May 1, 2006

Unsentimentally evokes the emotion of compassion more powerfully than any movie in memory. Well honed paced and crafted. The mechanics of air traffic control on 9/11 and the internal havoc the hijackings caused that day are intensely Unsentimentally evokes the emotion of compassion more powerfully than any movie in memory. Well honed paced and crafted. The mechanics of air traffic control on 9/11 and the internal havoc the hijackings caused that day are intensely represented in riveting sequence after riveting sequence. The final scenes and those where incomplete information exists might leave some viewers wishing for more but the film has many qualities beyond that to offer and is thought provoking on many levels. Recommended.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

BrianG.May 1, 2006

I think it is a great movie. It is also a great tribute. I don't care if the events on the actual flight a fictionalized. As told in the movie, they represented how I feel about the people on board. I agree with the viewer who states I think it is a great movie. It is also a great tribute. I don't care if the events on the actual flight a fictionalized. As told in the movie, they represented how I feel about the people on board. I agree with the viewer who states that if the producers made this movie with hope of raking in the dough they who have made a completely different movie. For those who don't like this movie only because it is too soon, I really have no doubt if they view this same movie 10 years from now, they will discover a new appreciation for it.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

JohnD.May 1, 2006

I'm awarding this film a 10. Not a 10 in the sense that 'it was entertaining and I want to watch it over and over', but a 10 for what was simply a job well done. I think the subject matter was extremely difficult to tackle I'm awarding this film a 10. Not a 10 in the sense that 'it was entertaining and I want to watch it over and over', but a 10 for what was simply a job well done. I think the subject matter was extremely difficult to tackle without cliches and 'drama for drama's sake' creeping in, and despite the challenges, the cast and crew succeeded admirably in this endeavor. I found the film endlessly taut and gripping, yet respectful and profound throughout its execution. My hat's off to Greengrass and crew for doing things right without resorting to the tired trappings of Hollywood. Utilizing a cast with little to no name equity was precisely the right thing to do. As I said, this is not a film I feel compelled to watch over and over again, as that implies being entertained...and entertainment was not my reason for going in the first place. I went to remember...and remember I did. I could tell this film connected with me personally after leaving the theater because it's been a very long time since I felt the numbness of 9/11. In witnessing this film's non-manipulative handling of that fateful day, much of that numbness returned to me, and I think that more than anything else indicates this film was a moving and worthy effort.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

JackieM.May 1, 2006

Omg this movie was one of the best movies i have seen.. it touched me ... it made me think a lot diffrent about 9-11 too.. i never really got it till i saw this movie.. it was really good.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

JoeMMay 1, 2006

I think this is one of the most profound movies I have ever seen. It has the authenticity that viewers deserve as well as the victims of that horrible action. In my opinion, the movie is a true masterpiece and fits in with the likes of I think this is one of the most profound movies I have ever seen. It has the authenticity that viewers deserve as well as the victims of that horrible action. In my opinion, the movie is a true masterpiece and fits in with the likes of masterpieces from John Ford and Frank Capra.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

DamienW.May 1, 2006

This was the most powerful movie i have ever seen very good and is going to win movie of the year never forget the bravery of flight United 93.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

2

JJJ.May 1, 2006

This movie left me with the feeling that America does anything for cash, a media whore who will take advantage of ANY situation for money. The acting and script left me with an empty feeling since the exact events are not known and to fill This movie left me with the feeling that America does anything for cash, a media whore who will take advantage of ANY situation for money. The acting and script left me with an empty feeling since the exact events are not known and to fill in the gaps to make money seems so Hollywood. I went into it will a bad feeling and tried to make the best of it but it was just a bad movie that was made way too soon. After watching the movie and seeing all the 100s in the scrore it leads me to believe that less than half of the reviewers were unbiased. Maybe a rental or better yet wait for regular cable.… Expand

0 of 1 users found this helpful

10

MikeK.May 1, 2006

One of the most terrifying movies I've ever seen, but also one of the best...not easy to watch, but an absolute must-see nonetheless.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

LuketheDukeApr 30, 2006

Considering that there were only scraps of information available regarding the innocent passengers and the venemous islamo-fascist killers, the movie turned out to be very well made. I recommend it highly to anyone unclear about the eventsConsidering that there were only scraps of information available regarding the innocent passengers and the venemous islamo-fascist killers, the movie turned out to be very well made. I recommend it highly to anyone unclear about the events of 9/11, or anyone who needs a refresher about the kind of scum that hates America. Tasteful, powerful.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

8

ChrisKApr 30, 2006

I found the movie to be a masterful creation, emotionally honest and lacking in histrionics. I give it an '8' rather than a '10' because it refused to acknowledge all the evidence (Namely: debris field scattered overI found the movie to be a masterful creation, emotionally honest and lacking in histrionics. I give it an '8' rather than a '10' because it refused to acknowledge all the evidence (Namely: debris field scattered over miles; eye-witness reports of a trailing jet; phone calls from the plane that end with the sound of rushing wind; phone call just before the crash that refers to smoke in the plane). Not that any of this PROVES the plane was shot down, but to pretend it doesn't exist points to a cover-up.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

9

T.GislerApr 30, 2006

I just saw the movie. I doubt that a " box office smash hit" was the producer's primary motive for making the film. If it was to be a money maker he would have appealed to the larger audience and given them what they wanted; whatever I just saw the movie. I doubt that a " box office smash hit" was the producer's primary motive for making the film. If it was to be a money maker he would have appealed to the larger audience and given them what they wanted; whatever that exaggeration may have been. Also, 10% of the ticket price is going to the families of UAL93 till today ( at least in this area). I heard one of the family members on the radio this morning and they were very pleased with how accurate and respectful the movie was to the subject. It was more a documentary than a movie. There was no need to dramatize this subject. It was a look into how the events of 9/11 as well as UAL 93, threw the passengers, the crew, the Air Traffic Control, and the military, (and much the world) into shock, confusion, fear, anger and action. It gave a perspective of those involved. It showed how we were unprepared for such an attack. We have hopefully learned and will not let something like this happen again. I found the Documentary by the two French Brothers "9/11" to be much more "disturbing" since it was all real footage of the event... I'm glad though that the producer did ask many of the families their opinion about making this movie. What I found beneficial about this movie was that it has (will) give an opportunity for those who want to know, the probable story that unfolded relative to flight 93. I know that I always think of the twin towers and the pentagon but not UAL 93. I won't over look it any more. Who knows what may have happened if this aircraft completed its goal? There are those who want to remember and those that do not. People will remember in their own ways. I personally am glad I saw this movie. I feel we are letting down our guard when we become complacent. We are foolishly opening ourselves up for another strike. I want to make them work very hard for their next one. And I do believe it is coming. Maybe that is the question. Who believes the threat of 9/11 still remains? Are those the people who are going to see this movie? I know we all wish it was a simple situation and had a even more simple solution: But it does not. We are at war. I feel for the families and passangers of UAL 93. This movie honors them well.… Expand

1 of 1 users found this helpful

9

DaedricLrdApr 30, 2006

Scary as hell, but thats what makes it a thrilling movie.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

screwums.s.Apr 30, 2006

MS. S. is an unsympathetic scumbag cuz its not just a movie u clown and it is good because it is based on true events. If u knew anything about film u would know how well made this movie is and it is never boring. How could u say this movieMS. S. is an unsympathetic scumbag cuz its not just a movie u clown and it is good because it is based on true events. If u knew anything about film u would know how well made this movie is and it is never boring. How could u say this movie was boring I was on the edge of my seat throughout. Keep your comments to yourself if that's what u were going to say.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

Dr.StrangeloveApr 30, 2006

I read Ms. S review and respectfully agree to disagree with her. Unfortunately, we all the know the horror and tragic ending before we enter the theater. Ms. S decided not to allow herself to be seated on that plane as most of us do whenever I read Ms. S review and respectfully agree to disagree with her. Unfortunately, we all the know the horror and tragic ending before we enter the theater. Ms. S decided not to allow herself to be seated on that plane as most of us do whenever we watch a movie. If she wasn't herself in that seat then she could sit back disinterested and tear the movie apart as she has done. It's very easy to be a critic when you can become dispassionate about what you are watching because the subject matter is too painful to watch. The truth be told from the director to all the actors you feel their raw emotions as well as the realization as to what must be done at the point of no return. It is simply masterful and captivating. Kudo's to all those involved for making such a great film. And yes, Ms. S as American's we should never forget the events of 9-11 nor should we bury our heads in the sand in the hope that it never happens again. God Bless America!… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

2

JohnL.Apr 30, 2006

This movie sucks!! I mean I feel for what happened on Sept 11 but that doesnt make for good entertainment....The camera was so shaky it made me sick, I was so bored throughout the whole thing....I hope this movie bombs....Its already heading This movie sucks!! I mean I feel for what happened on Sept 11 but that doesnt make for good entertainment....The camera was so shaky it made me sick, I was so bored throughout the whole thing....I hope this movie bombs....Its already heading in that direction, at the multiplex where I went to see it (on the first Sat it came out) it was showing at the way back of the theater...Which is usually reserved for garbage or for movies that have been out for weeks .There were less then ten people in the theater!!! I only went to see it bcuz it was my girlfriends choice...Although I hated it I could see why it was made and why it will affect people the way it does...Trust me watch it on dvd and save your money for popcorn movies like mission impossible or the davinci code.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

5

D.WillyApr 30, 2006

I'm sorry, but good intentions doth not a good movie make. Leaning so far backward to be unexploitive, this movie is virtually without dramatic value other than being a true story we're all close to. And, hey, acting is a I'm sorry, but good intentions doth not a good movie make. Leaning so far backward to be unexploitive, this movie is virtually without dramatic value other than being a true story we're all close to. And, hey, acting is a profession for a reason. Not just anybody can do it. Apart from reliving the events of that day, watching the real life people from the control room improvise their own dialog is downright grim.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

LiannS.Apr 29, 2006

Our family went to see this movie together, and I recommend that others consider this. It is very emotional, and you leave the theatre in tears.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

JackS.Apr 29, 2006

This was an exhaustive movie, and I really didn't want to watch it, but I'm glad I did. I was forgetting about the purpose of this war.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

MikeS.Apr 29, 2006

An amazing movie. Difficult to describe, everyone should see this masterpiece.

1 of 1 users found this helpful

9

FredG.Apr 29, 2006

This film did justice to a historic tragedy of which we hope to never experience again. Its impact left the theater I was in silent, somber and reflective - rightly so. The fact that there were heroes on that plane serves as a necessary This film did justice to a historic tragedy of which we hope to never experience again. Its impact left the theater I was in silent, somber and reflective - rightly so. The fact that there were heroes on that plane serves as a necessary reminder to all of us. Because of their courage, the plane did not get where the hijackers intended it to.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

AprilK.Apr 29, 2006

This film deserves to be seen. and i can't imagine it being executed any better than it was. it's both beautiful and important.

1 of 1 users found this helpful

10

StephenT.Apr 29, 2006

It is impossible not to flash back, when the military and air traffic control people are screaming "Where's the President?" on Michael Moore's footage of our leader sitting in that Florida classroom. It is Greengrass' genius It is impossible not to flash back, when the military and air traffic control people are screaming "Where's the President?" on Michael Moore's footage of our leader sitting in that Florida classroom. It is Greengrass' genius that he lets us make that connection, rather than force it upon us. This is bravura film making.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

KrisApr 29, 2006

Brilliant, masterful!

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

ChachiKruelApr 29, 2006

The movie is based completely on cockpit recordings, conversations with families that were talking to their loved ones on the plane, and includes people who play themselves such as the FAA administrator and the NORAD general that dealt withThe movie is based completely on cockpit recordings, conversations with families that were talking to their loved ones on the plane, and includes people who play themselves such as the FAA administrator and the NORAD general that dealt with the situation as it happened. Very little is speculation. Every American should watch this movie. We're facing an evil enemy and we should all stand up to them or they'll try to kill us all.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

United93circumspectApr 29, 2006

Apparently, the movie-going public is not as in need of coddling as some had declared. This is an important film, and while painful to watch, it reminds us that freedom is never free.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

PhilA.Apr 29, 2006

This film may not be the greatest story ever told. It may not have any CGI. It may not have any A-list celebrity actors, but it's got one thing that makes it better than any film that has all of those things...a true story about REAL This film may not be the greatest story ever told. It may not have any CGI. It may not have any A-list celebrity actors, but it's got one thing that makes it better than any film that has all of those things...a true story about REAL AMERICAN HEROES. This film paints an unvarnished view of how one piece of the terrorist plot on 9/11 was thwarted by a plane load of average Americans. Everybody needs to see this film and be reminded of the threat America is facing by the militant fundamentalist Islamo-facists in the Middle-East. If you want a portrait of evil on earth, this film will bring it home. Thank you Paul Greengrass.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

EthanP.Apr 29, 2006

The momentum is unearthly: a synergy between kinetic suspense and heartbreaking reality that I don't recall witnessing before in real life, let alone a movie. I can understand why people aren't ready to see it. Yet for the rest of The momentum is unearthly: a synergy between kinetic suspense and heartbreaking reality that I don't recall witnessing before in real life, let alone a movie. I can understand why people aren't ready to see it. Yet for the rest of us, it's about time something other than cheesy Photoshop-filtered web art and political arguments about foreing policy shakes us into understanding the phrase, "never forget."… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

MikeApr 29, 2006

emotional,wrenching, powerful. makes you proud of the common man and mystified by the undertones of religiousity from opposing views.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

9

TomO.Apr 29, 2006

I was conflicted about seeing this film at all, but two reviews I read in the last several days tipped the balance. For me the subject is very painful and unsettling, as it is for many. If Paul Greengrass and his creative team succeeded in I was conflicted about seeing this film at all, but two reviews I read in the last several days tipped the balance. For me the subject is very painful and unsettling, as it is for many. If Paul Greengrass and his creative team succeeded in telling this awful story really well, I reasoned, it would be all the more harrowing. I think many others may feel as ambivalent as I, because my theater had only three or four customers on the opening day of the film. That… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

4

mssApr 29, 2006

To be honest I felt a little nervous while spilling my opinions into this review. One reason is because I am aware of how terrible this event was and I am aware that many people feel strongly about it. I do not mean to offend any of the otherTo be honest I felt a little nervous while spilling my opinions into this review. One reason is because I am aware of how terrible this event was and I am aware that many people feel strongly about it. I do not mean to offend any of the other reviewers here. Just to get that out of the way. As a story goes, this would have been uneventful and generic had it not been based on actual events. I get what the film maker is doing here...replicating fear, drama, and all the other things you need in a highjacking movie. I was awed by the performances, however, despite how this movie would be nothing without the tragedy it refers to. It must have been hard for some of them to act out things like this, and I respect that. But a lousy film is a lousy film. I felt no sense of true sympathy, enthrallment, sadness, or any emotion for that matter. It was sort of a heoic film that came across as more of a "Just so you know, these people risked their lives and yada yada yada..." no. When I see a film I don't like to feel as if someone is trying to prove that an event was great. The event stands on its own. It's only five years old. Which might be why some of the kick is gone because it will never forget 9/11. Some might say I'm unpatriotic for not being entertained or enlightened by a film that is so obviously going to have impact...I'm sorry but we don't need a reminder as to how terrible 9/11 was and we don't need another plane movie. It's just a movie to me...a very boring and a very strained movie.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

0

PrintNinjaApr 29, 2006

This is simply a disgrace.

No matter how good a film this may be, I would never go see it. It never should have been made. I don't need a film full of conjecture to know that the passengers of United 93 were heros. That is a fact.This is simply a disgrace.

No matter how good a film this may be, I would never go see it. It never should have been made. I don't need a film full of conjecture to know that the passengers of United 93 were heros. That is a fact. No American, no human being, with a conscious should be making money off one of the worst events in our Country's history. Not one dime. That includes the theaters, the concession stands, the parking attendents, whomever. I don't care how great the film is. I don't care if the victim's families endorsed it. You want to make a memorial, then make a memorial, but I'll be dam*ed before I'll give someone $10 of my money because some filmmaker felt five years was enough of a cooling off period to revisit this horrible event theatrically. Maybe living in NY and having tears spontaneously run down my cheeks for months has hardened me to the filmmakers "good intentions", but as far as I'm concerned, unless this film is being shown for free as a public service, and the filmmakers are providing free therapy for all the people who will be traumatized from seeing it (and there certainly will be some), then America simply doesn't need this. Let me say it again... AMERICA DOESN'T NEED THIS!… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

0

GerrickChrosseApr 29, 2006

I think a movie made to rehearse 9/11 is a load of garbage and displays absolute disrespect to the families who lost loved ones. I don't care how good it might be, but anyone who is patriotic and has any respect for that day in AmericanI think a movie made to rehearse 9/11 is a load of garbage and displays absolute disrespect to the families who lost loved ones. I don't care how good it might be, but anyone who is patriotic and has any respect for that day in American history shouldn't see it.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

NateApr 28, 2006

Reading the 911 commission's report does not prepare you for this movie. It's quite intense when the passengers rush the cockpit. I had to pull myself back a bit. While there is some conjecture as to how the events played out onReading the 911 commission's report does not prepare you for this movie. It's quite intense when the passengers rush the cockpit. I had to pull myself back a bit. While there is some conjecture as to how the events played out on board, this movie accurately reflects what we know to be true: that if those men hadn't acted, we would be rebuilding the capital. Excellent film.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

7

larrystoneApr 28, 2006

9's and 10's. Give me a break! Put the flag away and evaluate the movie on it's merits, not on the subject of the movie. I saw a 5 star review in a local paper today. Why don't we just give it the Oscar right now .....9's and 10's. Give me a break! Put the flag away and evaluate the movie on it's merits, not on the subject of the movie. I saw a 5 star review in a local paper today. Why don't we just give it the Oscar right now ..... why wait. Let's keep it in perspective and do a fair job of reviewing the film regardless of the topic.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

ChristopherApr 28, 2006

I had to holdback the tears at the end of the movie. To go back to that day and experience it all over again was hard to do, but this film recaptures this event respectfully. Oliver Stone's World Trade Center is going to be hardpressedI had to holdback the tears at the end of the movie. To go back to that day and experience it all over again was hard to do, but this film recaptures this event respectfully. Oliver Stone's World Trade Center is going to be hardpressed to come even close to the emotional impact this movie has had on me or many of the viewers that have already seen this film.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

2

DjAlphaApr 27, 2006

I just saw a press screening of this movie. I didn't like it at all. It plays off the emotions of the day and you see everything from an American piont of view. It never gets into why the event actually took place or why the terroristsI just saw a press screening of this movie. I didn't like it at all. It plays off the emotions of the day and you see everything from an American piont of view. It never gets into why the event actually took place or why the terrorists were doing what they were doing. It brings nothing to society, it just takes us deeper into the Arab-American-hating hole. Terrible.… Expand

0 of 1 users found this helpful

9

MikePeronApr 26, 2006

Great movie - but still - tragey happens every day. Seems a little selfish to single out this one and ignore the everyday heros.

Personaly i think what the passengers did was heroic - but obvious to anyone who was in their situation. WhyGreat movie - but still - tragey happens every day. Seems a little selfish to single out this one and ignore the everyday heros.

Personaly i think what the passengers did was heroic - but obvious to anyone who was in their situation. Why would anyone let a few thugs with boxcutters control their lives… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

9

MartinLutherApr 25, 2006

Very good film. Solid acting from unknowns. Very intense and emotional. It also shows what it was actually like on Sept-11 watching the News and not knowning what had happened. Nice attention to detail in scenes. But a few complaints - theVery good film. Solid acting from unknowns. Very intense and emotional. It also shows what it was actually like on Sept-11 watching the News and not knowning what had happened. Nice attention to detail in scenes. But a few complaints - the continual "call you back" and phone conversations get repetitous, and why do the terrorists just let them all talk amongst themselves at the back? Why do there need to be 3 guys in the cockpit? Otherwise very good.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

0

JohnSimpsonApr 25, 2006

More Hollywood propaganda to keep the lies alive. This plane was shot out of the air with a missile, the debris was scattered over several miles which is not conducive in the slightest to a plane crashing in one place. Watch this film if youMore Hollywood propaganda to keep the lies alive. This plane was shot out of the air with a missile, the debris was scattered over several miles which is not conducive in the slightest to a plane crashing in one place. Watch this film if you want to continue to be duped into believing that there are hairy terrorists out to get us all, rather than our own government. This movie has been 'okayed' by all the agitprop govt dept's so watch at your own risk.… Expand

0 of 7 users found this helpful

10

JoséS.Apr 24, 2006

best movie ever.

0 of 0 users found this helpful

9

PeterAdamsonApr 23, 2006

Try and read a little bit about this one before going to see it. Greengrass and the actors all did thorough research and the film was certainly cast and shot in a non-traditional way. I found it to be a tremendously well-made film and feltTry and read a little bit about this one before going to see it. Greengrass and the actors all did thorough research and the film was certainly cast and shot in a non-traditional way. I found it to be a tremendously well-made film and felt like I learned a lot more about a subject that the media covered ad nauseum. The movie does not attempt to cash in on the tragedy, nor does it attempt to raise any sort of patriotism out of its viewers. It is simply a minute by minute account of pretty much the entire morning of 9/11/01 and what might have happened aboard United Flight 93.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

10

BenApr 21, 2006

You know.. I wasn't about this film..
I really was not sure.
Greengrass has always been on my radar, his 'Bloody Sunday' was one of the most powerful films I've ever sat through. It was the definition of riviting..You know.. I wasn't about this film..
I really was not sure.

Greengrass has always been on my radar, his 'Bloody Sunday' was one of the most powerful films I've ever sat through. It was the definition of riviting..
This film is no different. There's so much respect and care. This isn't a patriotic RAH-RAH american crap-fest. This is truely one emotional event and realistically portrayed in every way possible.

Greengrass might be one of the most intelligent film directors out there. He doesn't sugarcoat things, and presents them intelligently; and very emotionally.

For those of you who are screaming 'too soon!'
Then, it's you're choice not to see it. But I will say, this is powerful filmmaking. It can't be denied.

10/10… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful

United 93

User Reviews