Read User Reviews and Submit your own for Star Wars: Episode I - The Phantom Menace - Page 3

6

samsterJan 21, 2018

It was alright. Not enough action besides the end and to cringe.

Plot: 3.5/5
Action/ Entertainment: 3/5
Music/ Visuals: 5/5
Acting: 2/5

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

6

GunganFeb 12, 2018

I am re-watching all of the Star Wars movies to cleanse my palette from the most recent one.

As much as this one in particular is panned, it had a well put together script, and the story was worth telling. The production values are easily onI am re-watching all of the Star Wars movies to cleanse my palette from the most recent one.

As much as this one in particular is panned, it had a well put together script, and the story was worth telling. The production values are easily on par with any modern movie, though the cinematography and storytelling is less bombastic that modern audiences are used to. The visuals and sound are fantastic as well, and really give you a good variety of settings to look at when the Republic was at it's height.

The only real problems with this movie stem from two factors. The first is the use of a child actor for the part of Anakin. If he was aged up a bit into his early teens, I think the performance would have been more natural, less creepy when played against Natalie Portman, and more believable as a whole with other minor tweaks. The other problem was Jar Jar, because of the slapstick physical comedy. If they had toned him down instead of amping him to 11 for the kids, I don't think people would have been particularly bothered.

It's still a very coherent story that sits firmly grounded in the universe enjoyed by many fans.… Expand

0 of 2 users found this helpful02

All this user's reviews

6

spacebear1Dec 9, 2017

Star Wars Episode I: The Phantom Menace has had massive amounts of mixed reviews over the years since its release. I have a lot of nostalgia for this film but I'm going to put all that aside for the review. Even after putting aside myStar Wars Episode I: The Phantom Menace has had massive amounts of mixed reviews over the years since its release. I have a lot of nostalgia for this film but I'm going to put all that aside for the review. Even after putting aside my nostalgic feelings, I still like this movie. Yes, Jar-Jar is useless and completely retarded and the senate scenes are a bit boring and tedious, and I know that the fact that almost every scene is filled with . But I like this film. I loved the the final fight with Darth Maul, awesome character by the way. Basically, I really can't say why I love this film, I just do. My rating would be 6.1/10… Expand

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

6

dougwiggins5Dec 15, 2017

Attempting to live up to the largest expectations imaginable and predecessors that had mythological reputations in cinema, The Phantom Menace fails miserably. However outside of the narrative of how Star Wars movies are made this movie isAttempting to live up to the largest expectations imaginable and predecessors that had mythological reputations in cinema, The Phantom Menace fails miserably. However outside of the narrative of how Star Wars movies are made this movie is more mediocre than terrible. The plot is easy to follow, the story has a sense of adventure, and the heavy use of practical effects compared to it's trilogy brethren make it feel the most like the revered OT. See this movie if you like your Star Wars happy and don't mind a bit of overly lighthearted elements.… Expand

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

6

TheRussianatorApr 6, 2018

The horrifically awful characters of Jar Jar and Anakin, and the aged blue screen/green screen extravaganza are paired with the really good lightsaber battles and charisma of Liam Neeson, which makes for almost a guilty pleasure - which isThe horrifically awful characters of Jar Jar and Anakin, and the aged blue screen/green screen extravaganza are paired with the really good lightsaber battles and charisma of Liam Neeson, which makes for almost a guilty pleasure - which is not a compliment for Star Wars.… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

6

GrantD243Apr 25, 2018

The Phantom Menace is another movie that had a crazy amount of hype behind it when it came out, or so I've been told... I actually didn't see it until around 2002 as I was still a very young chap when it came out in '99. And boy, I'm glad IThe Phantom Menace is another movie that had a crazy amount of hype behind it when it came out, or so I've been told... I actually didn't see it until around 2002 as I was still a very young chap when it came out in '99. And boy, I'm glad I didn't see this movie in the theaters. I can't imagine how disappointed I would have been, and how quiet the car ride back home would have been. The characters are...okay, I guess? Darth Maul seems cool but we don't get a whole lot out of him (although his character was flushed out pretty well in the animated shows), young Anakin is...yeah, and Jar Jar is downright terrible. But hey, at least Qui-Gon and Obi-Wan were pretty awesome. The plot is nothing special. It's essentially the story of how Anakin came to be trained by the Jedi (and how he met Padme), but it's not a very interesting story and honestly you could fast forward through most of this movie and you wouldn't miss much. Really, the only thing that redeems this movie for me is the duel between Darth Maul and Qui-Gon/Obi-Wan towards the end of the movie. Without that sequence, this would easily be the worst Star Wars movie.… Expand

0 of 2 users found this helpful02

All this user's reviews

6

KonlinerJul 16, 2018

The Prequel movie is nowhere as brilliant as the Original Trilogy. It is poorly written with unrealistic/annoying/unnecessary dialogue, weak plot, and robotic acting performance. It is also confusing whether this movie is intended for allThe Prequel movie is nowhere as brilliant as the Original Trilogy. It is poorly written with unrealistic/annoying/unnecessary dialogue, weak plot, and robotic acting performance. It is also confusing whether this movie is intended for all ages or adults only. It contains a lot of childish humor/scenes, but it also has some complex political dialogue. Often times you will hear political words like embargo, federation, senate, etc. The political scenes, though make a great instrument for Episode 3, ruins the story. This movie also makes the Star Wars universe seem a lot smaller, such as Obi Wan's early encounter with R2D2 or the fact that Anakin created C3PO which would later, somehow, in this huge galaxy, will unite with Anakin's son. It also ruins the romanticism of the force by trying to make it more scientific and less magical. On the other hand, Darth Maul is an intimidating antagonist (too bad he was killed instead of saved for the next sequel) and the lightsaber duel, though unrealistic, is stunning to look at. Its set and prop design is also worth to be praised, alongside with Episode 2 and 3. This movie serves well as an experimental movie.… Expand

0 of 2 users found this helpful02

All this user's reviews

6

DaddySakuOct 22, 2018

Although this movie gets a lot of negative response, I found there are a lot of things to love here. Even though the story is fairly boring and some of the characters are badly written, George Lucas succeded in the most important aspect ofAlthough this movie gets a lot of negative response, I found there are a lot of things to love here. Even though the story is fairly boring and some of the characters are badly written, George Lucas succeded in the most important aspect of this movie. He managed to create an original and exciting universe set before the rise of the empire in episode IV. Apart from this the movie manages to impress with, for its time, outstanding visuals. The movie may not be a masterpiece, but it held my attention to the end. It does an ok job as a standalone movie, but it excells in universe building.… Expand

2 of 3 users found this helpful21

All this user's reviews

6

DerekReideMar 10, 2019

Now, I'm not saying this is the worst Star Wars movie, but it is better than The Last Jedi. Sorry Rian, but it's true and the fans know it. I'd rather listen to Jar Jar talk than listen to the "jokes" we had to put up with in TLJ. Anyway, theNow, I'm not saying this is the worst Star Wars movie, but it is better than The Last Jedi. Sorry Rian, but it's true and the fans know it. I'd rather listen to Jar Jar talk than listen to the "jokes" we had to put up with in TLJ. Anyway, the movie was good, but not good enough to reboot the Star Wars franchise.… Expand

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

6

MarinadeJul 28, 2019

The first episode in the prequel trilogy came with a lot of high expectations, unfortunately it failed to meet those expectations. The first 3/4 of this movie is not that great, the introduction of Jar Jar Binks is not well received. TheThe first episode in the prequel trilogy came with a lot of high expectations, unfortunately it failed to meet those expectations. The first 3/4 of this movie is not that great, the introduction of Jar Jar Binks is not well received. The gungan city underwater scenes are strange and lets the story get carried away. The pod racing scene is alright, is exciting but it is just okay. What saved this movie for me is the Obi-Wan & Qui-Gon vs Darth Maul battle, this was amazing, so well done. Duel of the Fates music to go along with it was the icing on the cake.… Expand

1 of 1 users found this helpful10

All this user's reviews

6

faustojcsDec 10, 2019

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. É percebivel e é consideravel que o filme é bastante antigo, da década de 90 e por isso não tinha toda a tecnologia que temos hoje. Por isso, na morte do Mestre Jedi, achei muito sem emoção. Mas, o filme possui qualidades é claro, boas lutas e cenas interessantes. Consideravel para a época.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

6

KazRockatanzkyDec 19, 2019

Nice little movie with some really weird decisions, the best about the phantom menace may be the approach at world building expanding the already known far far away galaxy, has excellent soundtrack pieces and a nice pace.
the two big flawsNice little movie with some really weird decisions, the best about the phantom menace may be the approach at world building expanding the already known far far away galaxy, has excellent soundtrack pieces and a nice pace.
the two big flaws that drag this movie down are the really bad dialogue writing and the too much coincidences through the fim.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

6

PooheadAug 27, 2021

Not as bad as I remember jar jar Binks honestly isn't that annoying still quite boring in parts and some shoddy dialogue yoosa in big doo doo

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

6

patron11Apr 24, 2020

I have mixed feelings about this movie. It´s nice to see the young Anakin Skywalker being freed from his slavery and starting his first steps towards his Jedi-Path. On the other hand the movie was way too silly. Jar Jar Binks can be a funnyI have mixed feelings about this movie. It´s nice to see the young Anakin Skywalker being freed from his slavery and starting his first steps towards his Jedi-Path. On the other hand the movie was way too silly. Jar Jar Binks can be a funny character, but the huge part he has in this story was just incredibly bad placed. Overall I also thought that dialogues and the story itself were very dull and too obvious in many situations. There is also no real connection to any of the characters, they feel very boring and without a lively saga. Definitely one of the worse Star Wars movies.

6/10… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

6

Grizzlyfolk818Feb 8, 2020

This isn’t exactly a great Star Wars movie but I’ll admit I did think the humor this movie had in it was pretty funny not to mention a certain gungan everyone hates but me. I feel like lots of people are mean to this movie and i thought theThis isn’t exactly a great Star Wars movie but I’ll admit I did think the humor this movie had in it was pretty funny not to mention a certain gungan everyone hates but me. I feel like lots of people are mean to this movie and i thought the Darth Maul vs Qui Gon and Obi wan scene at the end was great. I feel it’s just too bad this movie is underrated.… Expand

1 of 2 users found this helpful11

All this user's reviews

6

Geek_In_RedJun 8, 2020

I didn't hate this movie. I didn't enjoy the movie, but I don't dislike it. This is my second time recording my thoughts about this movie, but my reactions are way different this time. The difference this time is that the movie has myI didn't hate this movie. I didn't enjoy the movie, but I don't dislike it. This is my second time recording my thoughts about this movie, but my reactions are way different this time. The difference this time is that the movie has my respect. I bashed this movie once, calling it the worst movie ever made. This time, I respect the movie because I realize that it's George Lucas' pure vision. This movie has pretty good fights, the soundtrack is amazing, and the special effects were amazing for their time. My only real problem with this movie is the passing issues.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

6

tellmikeyyJun 20, 2022

This movie isn't bad in the slightest and the hate for certain characters, although understandable, isn't warranted. Re-watching this movie for the first time in years, the CGI isn't as bas as I remember and the action sequences are stillThis movie isn't bad in the slightest and the hate for certain characters, although understandable, isn't warranted. Re-watching this movie for the first time in years, the CGI isn't as bas as I remember and the action sequences are still pretty good. I have to admit, although the movie has direction, the middle of the movie is definitely slow and there are moments you can't help but want to change. The beginning and final act are the best parts of the movie and Qui-Gon & Darth Maul carry this film.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

6

pur__0_0__Jun 24, 2021

As a kid I hated Star Wars because of the prequels, since I liked the battle droids and I didn't like seeing the Jedis kill them (I was such a child back then). I had no idea what the movies were all about so two years ago I decided to sitAs a kid I hated Star Wars because of the prequels, since I liked the battle droids and I didn't like seeing the Jedis kill them (I was such a child back then). I had no idea what the movies were all about so two years ago I decided to sit down and watch every single Star Wars movie just before the release of Episode IX. Until now I used to always think that Star Wars are all about fighting with lightsabers, shooting blasters and something something Luke I'm your father. But now that I have watched them all and learnt everything, I can finally review them. So here goes the first one.

I really like the idea behind the prequels: George Lucas wanted us to see how an innocent boy named Anakin slowly turned into Darth Vader. This is the first movie where he is introduced as a young boy, who has to work for a pingas-nosed fly whom his family owed money. Obi-Wan and Qui-Gon Jinn get him freedom so that they can be Jedis. I have already forgotten why they decided to do so, because that scene has a very boring aura to it. Just remembering that scene makes me feel sleepy.

But what follows next is the very thing that took away all my sleep - The fabled Pod Racing! It was so cool to watch. Out of the 6 stars that I have given this movie, 3 alone are for the pod racing. I really wish there were some even more fun scenes throughout the movie. Sadly what we got was Jar-Jar Binks. I don't know about you but I absolutely hate seeing those annoying humanoid characters who always speak in weird manners and do random things in fight scenes (Gollum, Dobby, Gimli, Hound from Transformers etc).

So anyway, Anakin is brought to Padmé, who decides to keep him like a child (I'm gonna control my laughter since I wanna keep this review spoiler free). But the Jedi council refuses to keep Anakin since he has grown too old to be trained as a Jedi. I strongly object to this. Luke was trained as a Jedi when he was like what, in his late twenties? So where's the problem here? And it's not even like the technology developed by then so now more people could be trained. Everything is still literally the same, if not worse in future. So in all fairness Anakin should have always been allowed to be a Jedi.

The movie has many memorable characters like Mace Windu, Darth Maul, young Yoda, young Palpatine and Gunray. We also get to see the origins of C3PO, which was definitely unexpected. The movie adds a lot to the lore of Star Wars, but there is barely any world building in comparison to what the original trilogy did. Another problem is that it's very boring and campy. At least the boredom was addressed in the future movies, but by then the damage was done. The campiness stayed, however. The CGI is also very bad, with shadows and lighting reacting all wrong.

Star Wars: Episode I is one of those movies I'd put in the same categories as Batman v Superman. The first time you watch it you hate it. The second time you watch it, it gets better. But I just can't get myself to watch it the second time, remembering the Tatooine scene and Jar-Jar Binks. Although I don't think this movie is outright trash like how many haters call it, it's definitely far from being a "definitely not the worst Star Wars" movie. I really hope in future Disney remasters this movie's CGI and brings it back without any other edit from its side. This could definitely make this movie a bit better.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

6

SirSplendidSep 13, 2020

not as bad as people say it is, jar jar is terrible and so is lil ani. the podrace and the politics scenes are boring but hey, it's not that bad, it's enjoyable with an okay plot and characters.

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

6

Morze232Sep 12, 2020

Although the beginning of this excellent series was not a good movie, it would be better if Darth Maoul who started this beautiful series did not die.

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

6

keonbreezDec 16, 2020

Not as bad as I remember it.

Pros:
Podrace scene
Multiple Final action sequences
Opening scene

Cons:
Young anakin
jar jar
bad cgi

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

6

geewahJan 8, 2021

The worst of all the Star Wars movies to date.
Was always going to be tough ask, but some wooden dialogue, bad acting and the overuse of CGI takes away from a movie that does have some great scenes.

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

6

MaddoxWhiteApr 25, 2021

This is just so slow, and doesn't even have that many ironically funny moments, unlike the 3rd movie. Darth Maul scene is obviously good tho.

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

6

ChristmasLoverAug 4, 2021

It’s pretty good I know that everyone hates this movie cause of Jar Jar but in my opinion I like him the movie is slow but it’s still pretty good

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

6

Roguejedi92Sep 22, 2021

Menace is not without its merits but does come out of Lucas’ misguided view what makes Star Wars great. Lucas’ vision for Vader’s background unfortunately begins with what feels like more filler than necessary story and character development.Menace is not without its merits but does come out of Lucas’ misguided view what makes Star Wars great. Lucas’ vision for Vader’s background unfortunately begins with what feels like more filler than necessary story and character development. While TPM has a pretty straight forward plot, but it gets bogged down in stilted dialogue and some odd inclusions such as the goofy - and often loathed- Jar Jar Binks. Menace makes up for some of its lackluster writing and robot like dialogue, with spectacular and impressive visuals, , including but not limited to, lightsaber battle with Darth Maul and the Jedi as well as the exciting podracing sequence. Liam Nesson’s Qui Gon Jinn is perhaps the most charismatic out of the cast and Ewan as Obi, while competent here, was a good choice because he really gets to shine in subsequent films. However Ewan is not really given much to here but wait on a ship. The Phantom Menace isn’t without its exciting moments and stellar visuals, but too much of it is bogged down with a less than stellar story and some robotic performances.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

6

TheSikvelSep 28, 2021

Although I don't like the Star Wars setting, the movie is good enough. Pretty cute movie suitable for viewers of all ages (mostly children and adolescents)

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

5

billJul 15, 2009

The problem with this one (for me at least) was that jar jar binks charactor. From start to finish he was so annoying I could not enjoy any of the scenes he was in, its to bad mr. Lucas didn't have the sense to kill him off. However, The problem with this one (for me at least) was that jar jar binks charactor. From start to finish he was so annoying I could not enjoy any of the scenes he was in, its to bad mr. Lucas didn't have the sense to kill him off. However, the pod race scene was well done and this star wars has possibly the best lightsaber fight in the history of star wars.… Expand

1 of 5 users found this helpful

5

crstfrFeb 9, 2011

This was (regrettably) the first Star Wars film I saw. I was seven at the time and naturally I was enthralled by the undeniably good special effects. Several years on and I have fallen in love with the original trilogy as one should!! WhatThis was (regrettably) the first Star Wars film I saw. I was seven at the time and naturally I was enthralled by the undeniably good special effects. Several years on and I have fallen in love with the original trilogy as one should!! What separates the old trilogy from the new one is the distinction between good story telling, and good visual effects; George Lucas relied too much on effects in the prequels and forgot all about character development. Episode I does have some good aspects (Qui-Gon / Darth Maul) but the acting is so bland and the story so dull, not to mention the abomination known as Jar Jar - Lucas' defence is that it's a kid's film too but I think Jar Jar is even an insult to a three year old). The saddest thing about this film is the amount of hype that was created and the subsequent let down which has forever tarnished the Star Wars series. Yes it can be an enjoyable film, but it completely ruins the magic and heart of Star Wars.… Expand

2 of 6 users found this helpful24

All this user's reviews

5

HalfwelshmanOct 9, 2011

Cast your mind back to May 1999. You may remember quite a buzz of excitement in the air. The world was awaiting the release of a new edition to the Star Wars saga, 16 years after it ended. To put it mildly, The Phantom Menace had a lot toCast your mind back to May 1999. You may remember quite a buzz of excitement in the air. The world was awaiting the release of a new edition to the Star Wars saga, 16 years after it ended. To put it mildly, The Phantom Menace had a lot to live up to. It may yet go down in history as the most divisive film of all time. As often parodied, it split Star Wars fans down the middle. No one could deny that the effects were superb, flawless even. But what bothered many was the clunky dialogue, the wooden acting and the fact that it didn't seem to belong in quite the same world as the series which shares its name. My main problem with the Phantom Menace is that I'm relatively indifferent to it. It's not awful by any means, in fact it has many redeeming features (but no where near enough to make it a great film). The visuals were the best in the world at the time of the film's release, and still hold up today. The realisation of Coruscant, the "capital of the galaxy" in the form of a planet-wide city is an interesting idea, as is the Gungan's underwater "bubble city" and both look sensational. The film also has two stand-out action sequences - the pod-race, a creative, heart-thumping Ben-Hur tribute, and the "duel of the fates" which forms the finale of the film. This three-way lightsabre battle between a young Obi-Wan Kenobi (Ewan McGregor) and his master Qui-Gon Jinn (Liam Neeson) against the formidable Darth Maul (Ray Park) wielding an iconic double-bladed lightsabre. This has to be among the finest fight scenes of all time - the choreography is extremely creative and the execution flawless - it's a real testement to the stunt crew working on the film. Brilliant visuals and two memorable scenes cannot save a film, however. The story isn't up to much, and you don't have the high stakes of the original films - you know who's going to survive, it being a prequel to the original series. Lucas has never been great at dialogue, but during his Star Wars prequels, he seems to become worse at it over time. In the Phantom Menace you can look forward to such gems as Obi-Wan's "do not defy the council master, not again", young Anakin's "Are you an Angel?" speech, Yoda's classic "how feel you?" and pretty much everything said by Jar-Jar Binks. Ah Jar-Jar Binks - no other three words send shivers down the spine of a Star Wars fan so effectively (accept maybe a debate into who shot first). He's a truly irradeemable character - narratively unnecessary, insulting, and very, very annoying. The other actors and their characters are either unremarkable (MacGregor, Lloyd and Portman) or look thoroughly embarrassed to be on screen (I'm talking about you, Mr Neason). The Phantom Meanace is a disappointment, but in truth, it could never live up to Star Wars fans' high expectations, but it's good for providing the odd cheap thrill. And John Williams' scoring for the series is still great.… Expand

1 of 6 users found this helpful15

All this user's reviews

5

SnafuFrankNov 17, 2011

This film has no tension, drama, suspense, focus, excitement, development, and most importantly, it has no story to tell. For what it is, it's a joyless ride of random nothingness filled with flat, undeveloped, boring stereotypicalThis film has no tension, drama, suspense, focus, excitement, development, and most importantly, it has no story to tell. For what it is, it's a joyless ride of random nothingness filled with flat, undeveloped, boring stereotypical characters that none of us would care about. Why didn't George Lucas hired others to direct the prequels just like he did in The Empire Strikes Back, and Return of the Jedi? Why didn't he? If he did, the prequels could have ended up way better. But no, he himself had to direct all the prequels, and for that he has destroyed his godlike reputation.… Expand

1 of 5 users found this helpful14

All this user's reviews

5

JawsPapi87Aug 9, 2011

Jar-Jar Binks didn't bother me that much. The attempts at comedy were pretty rough though as was the rest of the script. But this movie had some incredible moments. The bad acting couldn't destroy all the genius battles and other entertainingJar-Jar Binks didn't bother me that much. The attempts at comedy were pretty rough though as was the rest of the script. But this movie had some incredible moments. The bad acting couldn't destroy all the genius battles and other entertaining sequences such as the podrace… Expand

5 of 10 users found this helpful55

All this user's reviews

5

grandpajoe6191Sep 24, 2011

"The Phantom Menace" is a decent movie that I would overall recommend only to those obsessed with the franchise because the film is a explanation film that connects what happened before the age of Luke, not amazing CGI or powerful quotes like"The Phantom Menace" is a decent movie that I would overall recommend only to those obsessed with the franchise because the film is a explanation film that connects what happened before the age of Luke, not amazing CGI or powerful quotes like the other ones did.… Expand

10 of 22 users found this helpful1012

All this user's reviews

5

imthenoobFeb 16, 2015

Phantom Menace could have been so much better. What ruined it was the needless long pod race, the Gungans, and the laughable kid actor who played Anakin. It's one of those films I'd love to see remade because it truly could have been a masterpiece.

4 of 7 users found this helpful43

All this user's reviews

5

ObbiePR18Apr 2, 2012

Soy muy joven, pero puedo decir cuando una pelicula es decepcionante. Despues de ver The Phantom Menace vi la trilogia anterior y tengo que decir que comparada con las viejas es desastrosa. Alguna de las cosas que no debieron serSoy muy joven, pero puedo decir cuando una pelicula es decepcionante. Despues de ver The Phantom Menace vi la trilogia anterior y tengo que decir que comparada con las viejas es desastrosa. Alguna de las cosas que no debieron ser añadidas fueron a un Jar Jar, un master Yoda computadorizado y a un joven Anakin con personalidad de niño aventurero. Hubiese sido mejor un niño con serios problemas de conducta o "raro", pero al final tenemos a un jovencito nada parecido al super-villano que seria...Vader.… Expand

0 of 8 users found this helpful08

All this user's reviews

5

OfficialDec 30, 2013

Not having watched the original "Star Wars" series, I thought that "The Phantom Menace" did not quite turn out as well as I expected. I mean, it has some cool scenes with the sabers and all that, but was quite boring and dull at times. I'mNot having watched the original "Star Wars" series, I thought that "The Phantom Menace" did not quite turn out as well as I expected. I mean, it has some cool scenes with the sabers and all that, but was quite boring and dull at times. I'm not even gonna mention some of the terrible acting.… Expand

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

5

WhiteTalpaDec 6, 2012

Problems: Death mauls death (should have kept him alive.), Jar Jar Binks (awful character), two pointless battles. Bad attempt at trying to funny.

5 of 9 users found this helpful54

All this user's reviews

5

HealthConnectTVDec 4, 2012

A clumsy attempt at creating the impetus for one of the greatest movie franchises of all-time. The film is very basic, but falls short of other titles in the series in every way imaginable. A shameful cash-in attempt that is still beingA clumsy attempt at creating the impetus for one of the greatest movie franchises of all-time. The film is very basic, but falls short of other titles in the series in every way imaginable. A shameful cash-in attempt that is still being milked through merchandise to this day.… Expand

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

5

TrilobiteGNov 7, 2015

An candy shop of visuals and lightsaber fights which is too easily consumed leaving a sick feeling of dry characters and the most tedious dialogue known to man. Jar Jar Binks you worthless excuse for comic relief. But, the visuals of battleAn candy shop of visuals and lightsaber fights which is too easily consumed leaving a sick feeling of dry characters and the most tedious dialogue known to man. Jar Jar Binks you worthless excuse for comic relief. But, the visuals of battle are always nice to see and the pod race was surprisingly intense...and you can appreciate how cheesy it is for that extra burst that doesn't make this movie complete garbage along with some added nostalgia.… Expand

2 of 3 users found this helpful21

All this user's reviews

5

ThatCooperGuyDec 1, 2015

So it all “begins” with The Phantom Menace. OMG THE WORSE SHTER WERSH MUVIE EVERRRRRR…

No. The Phantom Menace is not the worst in the series, I’d watch it without an issue, it’s really “Attack of the Clones” that I’m reluctant to watchSo it all “begins” with The Phantom Menace. OMG THE WORSE SHTER WERSH MUVIE EVERRRRRR…

No. The Phantom Menace is not the worst in the series, I’d watch it without an issue, it’s really “Attack of the Clones” that I’m reluctant to watch again.

I don’t think the movie is all that bad, it’s just boring. I also don’t hate Jar Jar, he’s not that annoying but he’s a really useless character… Doesn’t help that he’s mostly CGI and none of the digital effects in this movie hope up that well…
With some positives: I do appreciate that 20% of this movie uses practical effects, Ewan McGregor is a great Obi-Wan, and I like the light saber duels in this movie. The Phantom Menace is boring and led to a much worst second episode, but it’s far from being the worst movie ever made.

However, I rarely ever go back to watch this movie, the last time I saw it was in theaters in 3D. My dad took me and we showed up about 15 minutes after the movie started… I assume my dad was not eager to watch this movie again…… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

5

marcmyworksDec 27, 2015

When I first saw this I was impressed with the action and CGI but having Jake "Yippee" Lloyd cast as Anakin Skywalker was piss-poor. I also just don't think this film aged well. Overall not bad, but need a lot of tweeking.

0 of 2 users found this helpful02

All this user's reviews

5

oDjentoJan 2, 2015

I hate when people say the prequel films are terrible, they do still have some great scenes! With ep1, there were some definite let-downs, such as Jar Jar Binks and Anakins very average performance (but he is a kid i suppose), but theyI hate when people say the prequel films are terrible, they do still have some great scenes! With ep1, there were some definite let-downs, such as Jar Jar Binks and Anakins very average performance (but he is a kid i suppose), but they provided many other great things. The pod racing is a hella a lot of fun to watch, and The enviroments vary nicely in the film. Then also, they introduce possibly the most badass character in the Star Wars lore: Darth Maul. He is scary, awesome and just great to watch in this movie! And let me say, the end battle is possibly one of the best and well paced fights ever. Qui-gon and Obi against Darth Maul in those red laser barriers, that's how to rack up some brilliant tension. Many scenes in this film do save it from how bad people say it is, and i'd say watch it all the way through even if you do not like it just to see that final battle!… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

5

diogomendesMay 9, 2015

"Star Wars: Episode I - The Phantom Menace" is occasionally cloying, utterly goofy and doesn't have much in terms of plot or characterization, but it's so fun. With that being said, I don't think it's a masterpiece, but it's not a terrible"Star Wars: Episode I - The Phantom Menace" is occasionally cloying, utterly goofy and doesn't have much in terms of plot or characterization, but it's so fun. With that being said, I don't think it's a masterpiece, but it's not a terrible movie by any means. Definitely worth a watch, if you like sci-fi films.

Final Score: 5.5/10.

P.S: Dat race scene though...… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

5

SpiderPlayerMay 22, 2015

Median film, the story is not very engaging or interesting, the special effects are good, but the film at some points gets to be tiring, but it's a film that you can watch quietly most of the time.

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

5

Larry223Aug 24, 2014

La historia es... Muy simple, de echo no explican casi nada, según parece hay un ejercito separatista que quiere... No tengo idea, ¿un nuevo gobierno? por alguna razón quieren acabar con la republica un gobierno que ya estaba desde hace...La historia es... Muy simple, de echo no explican casi nada, según parece hay un ejercito separatista que quiere... No tengo idea, ¿un nuevo gobierno? por alguna razón quieren acabar con la republica un gobierno que ya estaba desde hace... Quien sabe cuanto, hay muy poca información. En fin, al inicio unos embajadores de la republica que son Jedi llegan para negociaciones y las cosas salen mal. Desde hay vemos como intentan salvar un planeta de la colonización separatista mientras encuentran a un nuevo Jedi y un personaje muy tonto que en ves de dar buen humor llega a molestar un poco, hay diálogos tontos y cosas sin sentido. Por ejemplo: según parece se puede medir el poder de la fuerza que alguien tiene por la sangre. Yo pensaba que la fuerza era una manifestación espiritual y sobrenatural que se podía manifestar en formas físicas de ves en cuando, pero no al punto de que tienes que tener células. Entonces ¿todas las especies del universo tienen las células necesarias para usar la fuerza? Y de ser así entonces ¿los humanos de la tierra en ese universo también podrían usar la fuerza? y si no es así entonces ¿solo una galaxia tiene ese poder? y si es así entonces ¿como se obtuvo eso? ¿fue algo especial o?.... Mejor lo dejo así, y algunos actores (tal ves la mayoría) tienen actuaciones malas y mediocres aparte de cosas tontas que decir. Lo que mejor tiene la película son los efectos, las escenas de acción y... Y creo que ya, no es una gran precuela pero tampoco puedo decir que sea del todo mala. Sin embargo esta muy cerca de eso, le doy un 05/10 un poco mejor que lo mediocre.… Expand

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

5

MiracSpectacJan 7, 2018

It's honestly hard to say this film is anything better or worse than "just ok". It doesn't accomplish very much, but it still has a certain level of classic Star Wars drama.

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

5

Red-Opposom-098Oct 7, 2015

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Star Wars TPM is directed by George Lucas (American Graffiti) and stars Ewan McGregor (Trainspotting) Liam Neeson (Taken) Natalie Portman (Black Swan) Ian McDiarmid (Restoration) and Ray Parks (Xmen)
I remember watching this as a kid and liking it but then time went by and I started to enjoy it less and less and then I didn't like it. The pod race scene is alright I guess. Okay now I realized why Ray Parks' (Darth Maul) voice was dubbed but why was Natalie Portman dubbed I mean was it necessary, no! The very end lightsaber fight kicks ass though, the duel of fates in the back makes it perfect. The acting isn't that great I mean you see some actors are trying to work around Lucas' writing but it just doesn't work, Liam Neeson accepted his role without reading one word of the script. I'm not eve going to anything about Jake Lloyd's performance or jar jar because everything that can be said has been said. It's a shame Maul was killed, he could of made a great prequel villain, now yes I'm aware they brought him back in clone wars. There was actually a pretty good fight somewhere in the middle of the film where Qui Gon gets attacked by Maul. One thing that's always bugged me is when Anakin and Obi Wan meet, it's nothing that kills the movie but it should of been done better. All in all this movie is a very mixed bag for me. This movie can be very boring at times but it still has a few moments that make some parts good.… Expand

1 of 2 users found this helpful11

All this user's reviews

5

homer4presidentMar 11, 2015

It's not a bad movie, just heavily flawed. Its acting and dialogue can be cringe-worthy, but its high points still make it an enjoyable cinematic experience. It is overall a visually-dazzling film with a stunningly complex plot andIt's not a bad movie, just heavily flawed. Its acting and dialogue can be cringe-worthy, but its high points still make it an enjoyable cinematic experience. It is overall a visually-dazzling film with a stunningly complex plot and heart-pounding action sequences.… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

5

EdwardGregoryApr 19, 2015

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Things get off to a cold start with the much parodied credit crawl. Where Episode IV goes for the in media res jugular – “It is a time of civil war!” - problems in Episode I are not quite so pressing. Events are “alarming” perhaps, there’s certainly plenty of “turmoil” and we all know “taxation” is a thorny issue but the context is clear: like Anakin, this conflict still has some growing up to do. The menace is still phantom.

An inexcusably lazy establishing shot - the Jedi shuttle cruises past the camera - and lethargic opening sequence hardly help pick up the pace. In A New Hope’s famous opening salvo the bad guys fire first and ask questions later, in The Phantom Menace the Jedi are ushered into a meeting room while the semi-bad guys go into video conference with Darth Sidious about whether an invasion of Naboo is legal or not.

Critics complained that Lucas had got yet worse at writing for humans in the twenty-two years since Star Wars, in fact it is simply that, beyond Alec Guinness talking about the force, the plot of A New Hope requires no exposition - The Phantom Menace on the other hand is all explanation, much of it, like the midichlorians, unwanted and unnecessary. (To be fair, Lucas waited a generation before spoiling his enigmatic myth with background material, the Wachowski’s jumped that particular shark in film two.)

nd yet there is still much pleasure to be had watching our full-blown Jedi guides in action. Qui-Gon and Obi-Wan quickly discover that things are mercifully worse than the credit crawl predicted, a robot invasion force is being unpacked, Naboo is under actual threat. Sadly, we never actually see any of the massacres that are apparently taking place, instead we land somewhere that looks suspiciously like the woods near Leavesden and meet one of the galaxy’s more annoying comedy sidekicks (although not as annoying as fans frantically searching for a scapegoat would have you believe). After all, this film has at its hero a small boy – it cannot visit the dark 12A places.

Tatooine turns out to be a total bust. They leave Obi-Wan behind, Amidala pretends to be Padme for no good reason, Anakin whines a lot, there’s some mumbo jumbo about a mystical birth and at absolutely no point does Han Solo turn up. Bastard. This is a section so flabby that even the electrifying pod race goes on for one lap too long.

But hell, we meet Vader Jnr. and he says goodbye to his mother, which is the only essential action of the movie, so it’s almost worth the trip.

Despite the unspeakable Yoda puppet, more endless politicking and some iffy CGI, the arrival on Coruscant and the subsequent battle of Naboo provide most of the lasting excuses for forgiving The Phantom Menace. At last there are new worlds to explore, new creatures to encounter and new wrinkles to the Star Wars myth. On Coruscant we are free to marvel at the work of Doug Chiang’s design department - every bit the equal of the original trilogy. And during the saga’s very best lightsaber battle John Williams adds another classic theme (Duel Of The Fates) to his masterpiece. The final act is a mess of conflicting ideas and we are forced to root for a tweenage space pilot but you certainly can’t fault it for pace.

Perhaps best of all, we have the death of Qui-Gon. Liam Neeson has manfully carried the action on his shoulders throughout (the subsequent prequels desperately miss him) and his final words – “Obi-Wan, promise... Promise me you will train the boy” - provide the movie with its only real weight.

Lucas probably imagined that Anakin’s goodbye would be the real heartbreaker but he couldn’t write it and Jake Lloyd couldn’t act it. The irony is, we don’t need it. Given where he is destined to end up, Anakin doesn’t need to be innocence personified when we meet him. Indeed, we are told that the kid is too old to be trained and that the Jedi council fear him, facts that are utterly lost on an audience who see only a bowl-headed brat.

One of the most disappointing film of all time it remains, but with the galaxy of hype now far, far away Menace seems much less of a public menace than it did in the summer of 1999.… Expand

1 of 2 users found this helpful11

All this user's reviews

5

TheDude-Jun 13, 2015

The phantom menace is said to be the most disappointing film of all time which is true poor character development, bad dialogue and jar jar binks made that happen a true fall from grace

1 of 2 users found this helpful11

All this user's reviews

5

therealcritic79Aug 10, 2015

There is so much yet so little happening in this movie. There is a complicated story about the trade federation and politics, but it is so weird that it goes nowhere. It lacks the feel that made the first star wars so great. That and JAR JARThere is so much yet so little happening in this movie. There is a complicated story about the trade federation and politics, but it is so weird that it goes nowhere. It lacks the feel that made the first star wars so great. That and JAR JAR BINKS! Need I say more? Fans will enjoy this, but everyone else should just skip this one.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

5

justinsirkin01Aug 21, 2015

In the 1980s the Star Wars franchise became one of the most beloved film sagas of all time with a striking line of toys, comics, books, costumes, games. Star Wars was huge. it told the story of a man who becomes a villain. After 15 years StarIn the 1980s the Star Wars franchise became one of the most beloved film sagas of all time with a striking line of toys, comics, books, costumes, games. Star Wars was huge. it told the story of a man who becomes a villain. After 15 years Star Wars Episode I: The Phantom Menace was announced and the hype was enormous. We were finally going to see the story we wanted to see. We were finally going to see the origin of Darth Vader one of the most iconic movie characters of all time. Instead we were treated to something extremely different from what we expected. And I honestly have to say this...What was George Lucas thinking when he wrote this? Now before I express anymore i understand that this movie was made for children, and as a child I liked this film. But as an adult, I cannot believe that they screwed up a franchise as much as they did. In a list of Top 10 movies that derailed their own franchise The Phantom Menace would take the top spot. I really do not know why George decided to do this to his own franchise and make something that we all loved and make it into a bizarre childrens movie that barely keeps any of the love of the original Star Wars. Not alot of things that are positive about this film. For instance who is the main character? Shouldn't it be Anakin? But its not! That there is a major problem with this film. Star Wars Episode I: The Phantom Menace is a weak addition to the Star Wars franchise and can probably be skipped in its entirety.… Expand

1 of 2 users found this helpful11

All this user's reviews

5

DanBurritoMar 24, 2016

With unimpressive acting, a poor script and an over-reliance on cgi, The Phantom Menace is a less-than-satisfying start to the infamous prequel trilogy. The pacing was painfully slow, and even Liam Neeson seems bored. Then of course, there'sWith unimpressive acting, a poor script and an over-reliance on cgi, The Phantom Menace is a less-than-satisfying start to the infamous prequel trilogy. The pacing was painfully slow, and even Liam Neeson seems bored. Then of course, there's the character of Jar Jar Binks, one of the most annoying characters in the history of cinema. Seriously, who thought HE was a good idea? Darth Maul was a cool villain, but he's barely even in it! The character development is practically non-existent, and much of the film is just a bunch of Jedi sitting around talking about taxation. The special effects were great, but the filmmakers seem to value them over story and characters. And just so you know, I am a HUGE Star Wars nerd. That's why this movie feels like a punch to the gut. FINAL VERDICT: This is a disappointing addition to a great franchise, and lacks the depth of previous instalments. 4.5/10.… Expand

3 of 4 users found this helpful31

All this user's reviews

5

NestriReviewsDec 30, 2015

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Star Wars Episode I: The Phantom Menace is a total disappointment. It's an annoying movie, seriously. The characters, at least most of them, are totally uninteresting and underdeveloped. I thought that one of the antagonists had no personality at all (the one with a black and red skin) and was just there to look cool with his double lightsaber, fighting against the Jedi. He was so underdeveloped and forgettable. The main character, Anakin, is a little bit annoying because, you know, he's a kid. But, you know what seemed odd? This kid blows up a SPACESHIP in the end of the movie!!! What the hell was the director thinking? Also, Jar Jar gets on my nerves. I'm not a fan of his design. I'm also not a fan of the battle of Jar Jars vs droids, it's just not that good because it is rather anti climatic. None of the characters have impressed me in this movie and they can be so cringe-worthy at times. But, the story however, is not bad, it's just the execution is terrible. The same can't be said about some of the battles in this film, that are mostly appealing IMO. So, basically, Star Wars Episode I: The Phantom Menace has a decent premise, but the execution of the story is poor.… Expand

1 of 2 users found this helpful11

All this user's reviews

5

UNARMED_JORDFeb 26, 2017

More of a political negotiate movie than a star wars film, the phantom menace is a very disappointing start to the prequels that doesn't deliver in any way other than the bad ass Darth Maul

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

5

TheMovieMan28Jul 12, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. The trailer is better than the movie,better edited and better music the movie is boring with only ONE good fight with darth maul.The movie is filled with bad CGI and cringy acting.It kind of medeokre.The last 40 minutes is the better than the other parts of the movie and the fight with Darth Maul is badass.… Expand

1 of 2 users found this helpful11

All this user's reviews

5

eva3si0nJan 30, 2020

The problem with The Phantom Menace is that many start to get to know Star Wars with it, which can deter the film series. The film itself is quite mediocre, there are few strong characters here and the film 's performance is not so activelyThe problem with The Phantom Menace is that many start to get to know Star Wars with it, which can deter the film series. The film itself is quite mediocre, there are few strong characters here and the film 's performance is not so actively developing to in the main trilogy. Strictly for fans.… Expand

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

5

TiagoGM18Mar 27, 2017

I don't really think that Jar Jar Binks is the worst part of this movie, I really don't, if we were able to connect to some of the characters, Jar Jar would be easily overlooked, however, since Obi-Wan is the only charismatic character, theI don't really think that Jar Jar Binks is the worst part of this movie, I really don't, if we were able to connect to some of the characters, Jar Jar would be easily overlooked, however, since Obi-Wan is the only charismatic character, the movie gets really boring really fast but if you manage to sit through 2/3 of the movie, the last act will certainly pay off. P.S. betting on an 9 year old with little acting experience is always a risk, i'm sure Jake Lloyd performed as well as he could and I can't help but agreeing with Mark Hamill's take on the kid's critics… Expand

0 of 3 users found this helpful03

All this user's reviews

5

SonicHD7Jun 1, 2017

Obi-Wan Kenobi (Ewan McGregor) is a young apprentice Jedi knight under the tutelage of Qui-Gon Jinn (Liam Neeson) ; Anakin Skywalker (Jake Lloyd), who will later father Luke Skywalker and become known as Darth Vader, is just a 9-year-old boy.Obi-Wan Kenobi (Ewan McGregor) is a young apprentice Jedi knight under the tutelage of Qui-Gon Jinn (Liam Neeson) ; Anakin Skywalker (Jake Lloyd), who will later father Luke Skywalker and become known as Darth Vader, is just a 9-year-old boy. When the Trade Federation cuts off all routes to the planet Naboo, Qui-Gon and Obi-Wan are assigned to settle the matter.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

5

Dragonfly44Nov 28, 2017

I completely understand the disappointment from the movie and it could of been much more, but personal I loved it. It was thrilling and nice to get a backstory on Darth Vader.

1 of 2 users found this helpful11

All this user's reviews

5

Jaredc324Jun 28, 2019

Phantom Menace is a solid combo with way too many side orders. Everything involving Anakin and Qui-Gon Jin's characters enliven the truth and splendor of this prequel kickstarter, but is surrounded by an influx of overly-compressed andPhantom Menace is a solid combo with way too many side orders. Everything involving Anakin and Qui-Gon Jin's characters enliven the truth and splendor of this prequel kickstarter, but is surrounded by an influx of overly-compressed and exaggerated imagination, that benefits nothing but its own financial marketing scheme. But aside from all the child-actor whine-cries and Jar Jar binks, holds a decent enough story to revisit from time to time.… Expand

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

5

LoletinAlexisApr 8, 2020

The Phantom Menace, that great project wasted by the direction of a misguided George Lucas.
Less ego and more help, Georgy.

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

5

merijnjFeb 21, 2018

(45/100)
Just not as good. The CGI was too much the humor was too much. The plot was poort and didn't make sense in many places.

1 of 2 users found this helpful11

All this user's reviews

5

AdrenelineboyJun 25, 2018

George Lucas, the once masterful director, has lost his way, and there is no-where that this is more prominent than in Star Wars: Episode I- The Phantom Menace. Coherent storytelling, memorable dialogue and technological brilliance isGeorge Lucas, the once masterful director, has lost his way, and there is no-where that this is more prominent than in Star Wars: Episode I- The Phantom Menace. Coherent storytelling, memorable dialogue and technological brilliance is replaced by a disorientating CGI whirlwind of effects driven action and wooden dialog. Great, snarky, laugh-out-loud humour, is replaced by a computer designed, rabbit eared lump of flesh that steps in a pile of poop.
And an engaging plot is replaced by tedious, boring, Government committees that no adult or child has ever shown the least bit of interest in. The few redeeming factors that stops this film from being absolutely terrible are Liam Neeson and Ewen Mcgregor's characters, Darth Maul (obviously), and the fact that John Williams made the soundtrack. Because who doesn't want to hear another score from Williams?… Expand

2 of 3 users found this helpful21

All this user's reviews

5

benskylerhillMay 20, 2018

Ah, The Phantom Menace: one of the most hated movies of all time. That hate is arguably quite justified--not because it's a bad film, but because it has the structure of a fascinating prelude to a classic saga and wastes its potential-filledAh, The Phantom Menace: one of the most hated movies of all time. That hate is arguably quite justified--not because it's a bad film, but because it has the structure of a fascinating prelude to a classic saga and wastes its potential-filled premise on passive, poor execution.

Star Wars: Episode I does, in fact, have some redeeming qualities. For one thing, this is where the action sequences began to be modernized. The lightsaber fights are elegantly choreographed and the transition into CGI-powered space-battle scenes works very well most of the time. The other primary positive trait of The Phantom Menace is its plot. Many people are bothered by the fact that it focuses on slow-burning political tensions rather than fast-paced attack-and-retreat military action like the original trilogy did. This doesn't bother me at all. There are political drama-thriller films that are very entertaining, and the politics of Episode I's story are quite fascinating when it's considered that they have a massive impact on the fate of the galaxy and eventually pave the way for the rise of the Empire from the original trilogy. The sad thing is that what could have been a thoroughly engaging politically-centered war film crumbles into the pitfalls of poor storytelling. The high-stakes, desperate situation of Naboo is swept under the rug thanks to purely wooden acting and emotionless line delivery. The script doesn't articulate things as well as it should sometimes, but the real problem is the fact that pretty much every actor appears to be reading from a teleprompter. It also doesn't help that nearly all of the exposition is given through dull scenes in which people sit down and discuss things, and the combination of all of this gets old very very quickly. To engage an audience with dialogue, there must be something else happening--moving--in the scene to accompany it, and there is absolutely none of that present for the majority of Episode I.

There are some visually striking scenes (especially by the standards of 1999) but there is certainly an enormous over reliance on special effects. The original trilogy made its universe appear real through the use of tangible makeup and models and physical sets. The Phantom Menace has horrendous set design with visible gaps filled in with unnecessary CGI and some scenes entirely created with computers. This wouldn't normally be a problem, but the effects of 1999 just weren't ready to create entire worlds and the lack of anything physical in many scenes makes the world appear cartoonish and it severely weakens the believability of the galaxy far far away.

The Phantom Menace is not a train wreck, as some believe it to be. Darth Maul remains one of the best villains of the franchise and there are many visual improvements that were kickstarted with this installment. But it certainly ranks among the most disappointing movies ever made because it could have been infinitely more exciting had there been more talent involved in front of and behind the camera.

Story: 7
Acting: 2
Script: 4
Visuals/Sound: 6.5
Entertainment Value: 5.5

OVERALL SCORE: 5/10… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

5

All_ButTrU4May 9, 2022

An uneven stiff start to a lauded franchise I'm only watching to satisfy my curiosity on the dedication it's amassed. I'm rarely ever affected by the anachronism of movies in terms of production, effects and scriptwriting but on this classicAn uneven stiff start to a lauded franchise I'm only watching to satisfy my curiosity on the dedication it's amassed. I'm rarely ever affected by the anachronism of movies in terms of production, effects and scriptwriting but on this classic it alienates investment . Anakin I a void of character whilst Jar jar is an eyesore. The dialogue was a trudge alongside the pacing which seems to relish not getting to the point.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

5

Moviecritic43Mar 2, 2019

The Phantom Menace is a very disappointing movie. It’s not a terrible movie, but it’s a dissapointing movie. There were some good scenes in the film, and Darth Maul is a compelling villain. But there’s a lot of bad acting and bad dialogue,The Phantom Menace is a very disappointing movie. It’s not a terrible movie, but it’s a dissapointing movie. There were some good scenes in the film, and Darth Maul is a compelling villain. But there’s a lot of bad acting and bad dialogue, Jar Jar binks is very annoying, there’s too much dated CGI, and this film has too much senate meetings and politics. But overall this film is a mixed bag.… Expand

1 of 2 users found this helpful11

All this user's reviews

5

mecheng03Mar 9, 2019

Pretty bad but if you watch the fan edited version with Jar Jar having an alien language and no pod racing makes it actually about a 6-7.

1 of 1 users found this helpful10

All this user's reviews

5

TEMP0May 30, 2020

I feel ashamed to say that Phantom Menace is the start of the Skywalker Saga when it's filled with George Lucas' brain farts after the Originals.

Are kids supposed to see a film about an intergalactic trade embargo?

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

5

kiroaramaJun 29, 2020

Not the greatest star wars movie, the special effects have aged really poorly and when the majority of the movie are green screens and many characters (including some of the main characters) are CGI, there is a big disconnection between theNot the greatest star wars movie, the special effects have aged really poorly and when the majority of the movie are green screens and many characters (including some of the main characters) are CGI, there is a big disconnection between the viewer and the world their are trying to create.
The dialog is odd, almost nobody speaks like (normal) people.
Jar Jar is probably my biggest question mark in this film, I just don't understand his purpose.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

5

Nick-ChierJan 21, 2021

The story is bloated, leaving the dialogue to be used as an explanation device then as dialogue, some actors are good, some are bad, the bad ones distract and take me out of the experience. The effects are outstanding at some points, butThe story is bloated, leaving the dialogue to be used as an explanation device then as dialogue, some actors are good, some are bad, the bad ones distract and take me out of the experience. The effects are outstanding at some points, but Lucas took big swings and he missed a few that really throw off the movie. The only emotional connection I found myself having with the movie was with the relationship between Qui-Gon Jinn and Obi-Wan Kenobi. The rest is soured by subpar acting and even more subpar dialogue and pacing.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

5

BobbyAxelrodFeb 2, 2021

In the first half of the movie you are essentially watching a children's Star Wars movie. It was incredibly slow paced and the negatives outweighed the positives. The movie tried to be funny at various points but just came across as flat. TheIn the first half of the movie you are essentially watching a children's Star Wars movie. It was incredibly slow paced and the negatives outweighed the positives. The movie tried to be funny at various points but just came across as flat. The second half of the movie was much better but still nothing to celebrate. I have mixed thoughts on this movie.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

5

Star_Wars_FanApr 28, 2021

The Phantom Menace could have been a decent movie, if it weren’t for issues such as annoying characters, awful dialogue, and *sigh*, a focus on politics.

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

5

MetaMetaXYMay 11, 2021

I don't think, it's a great film, but it's okay. Theres to much politics and to less Star Wars, but overall not the badest.

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

5

M7AMDDec 13, 2022

I always avoided anything related to Star Wars since i didnt understand it, so i decided to give it a chance and after some quick search they recommended this is the first movie to watch in order, i will be honest im quite disappointed iI always avoided anything related to Star Wars since i didnt understand it, so i decided to give it a chance and after some quick search they recommended this is the first movie to watch in order, i will be honest im quite disappointed i expected something much better than this considering all the hype people have for the Star Wars movies, these some nice visuals when you compare it to movies at that time but what i found this movie lacking is a good and strong story to keep you interested. another thing to mention is the movie is a little bit long for this story i was forcing myself to keep watching after maybe 1 hour into it, they should have ended it early and not dragged it for 2 hours!

i might give Star Wars another try but that was a bad start for me.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

5

JJ2FAS4UDec 30, 2021

----------------------------------4.8/10-----------------------------------

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

5

XathiahsFeb 11, 2022

The most boring SW movie. Poor characters and slow plot developing. The lightsaber battles and the depiction of a young Anakin are the only interesting things.

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

5

FionanMurphyAug 14, 2022

This is a bad movie, but its not as terrible as its successor
it is boring though and the only time i watch it is whehn I am showing a friend star wars for the first time

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

5

Fixer84Mar 15, 2023

Basically a film that is almost useless. If most fans consider it non-canon there will be a reason. And the reason is that to watch it or not to watch it, practically nothing of the Star Wars saga is lost.

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

5

DaG4mEJun 1, 2023

The Duel of the Fates is the only reason this is not lower. The story is ok at times.

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

4

JBAug 12, 2006

Great special effects and music. Terrible acting, story, dialogue, characterizations and costumes. Anakin should never have been an enslaved toddler. There is no group cohesion, which is what made the exploits of the original trilogy's Great special effects and music. Terrible acting, story, dialogue, characterizations and costumes. Anakin should never have been an enslaved toddler. There is no group cohesion, which is what made the exploits of the original trilogy's cast so entertaining. Despite what may be said of the original acting in the first trilogy, I've always felt that it shined over poorly written lines ... not the case here. A poor work.… Expand

0 of 2 users found this helpful

4

Syn_againSep 28, 2010

The only reason this movie is not a 3 or lower is simply due to the fact that an interesting character - Darth Maul was introduced. Aside from this there are no good takeaways from this movie.

2 of 7 users found this helpful25

All this user's reviews

4

J42HmusicDec 9, 2011

If you loved the original trilogy, prepare to be shocked by the disaster that is 'Star Wars Episode 1: The Phantom Menace.' Bad acting and an annoying Jar Jar Binks cause excited Star Wars fans to lose the will to live when watching thisIf you loved the original trilogy, prepare to be shocked by the disaster that is 'Star Wars Episode 1: The Phantom Menace.' Bad acting and an annoying Jar Jar Binks cause excited Star Wars fans to lose the will to live when watching this film. Despite the messiness of the film, it is not a bad film as such, and I recommend you watch it before judging it by its lack of originality.… Expand

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

4

kman5473Feb 25, 2019

What happens when you take one of the biggest franchises of all time, its creator and his never-revised first draft script for a prequel, and then surround him by enablers? Nothing good. The aesthetics of the characters is there, certainly,What happens when you take one of the biggest franchises of all time, its creator and his never-revised first draft script for a prequel, and then surround him by enablers? Nothing good. The aesthetics of the characters is there, certainly, but every decision made is lacking precision and second, third, and fourth thoughts in its execution. Jar Jar Binks is supposed to appeal to the younger audiences, but was taken too far and became a caricature that only annoyed most. Darth Maul is a villain with with a ton of potential...but then is killed off without any further character development. These decisions, clearly, were based on merchandising statistics vs great storytelling motivations. A kid-friendly character sells better as a stuffed animal/pillow case than a villain, right? Add to this dialogue that is incredibly difficult to penetrate and understand for an audience member that is supposed to be driving the plot forward. Add to this dialogue that is really cliche and dumb that is supposed to entertain the kids. Total loss of tone in the story.… Expand

2 of 2 users found this helpful20

All this user's reviews

4

MudgetJun 10, 2013

My dad brought me to see the first Star Wars movie (A New Hope) when I was 7 years old, back in 77, and it created a magical memory that will remain through the rest of my life. When this 'prequel' hit in 99, I took my elderly father to seeMy dad brought me to see the first Star Wars movie (A New Hope) when I was 7 years old, back in 77, and it created a magical memory that will remain through the rest of my life. When this 'prequel' hit in 99, I took my elderly father to see it with me. If only there could have been some magic in that experience. Instead, there was only confusion for my dad, and embarrassment for me. With an overemphasis on cartoon-like characters (and voices) and multi-zillion dollar animation and CGI, and an underemphasis on character development and coherent plot storytelling, the whole thing felt like one big mess (although a mess within a fireworks show, if that makes any sense quite nice to look at most of the time). It's amazing to see actors like Liam Neeson, Ewan McGregor and Natalie Portman so absolutely rigid and cardboard-like. There is no equal to any of the characters of the original Star Wars series, no wet-behind-the-ears Luke to cheer on, no Leia to secretly lust for, no Han Solo to crack us up. Instead there is the inclusion of the most annoying characters ever to grace a screen, a character who constantly reminded me that, at 30ish years of age, I had no business being there at that movie, let alone taking my father to it. A far cry from the kind of mass appeal the first set had with all kinds (and ages) of people. I truly feel that these 'prequels' will go down in history as the most unnecessary movies of all time. And yet I own them, I am THAT connected to the franchise, that I own movies I probably won't watch again, purely in honor of the original series and the hope that maybe, just SOMEHOW, some kid somewhere felt the magic like I did when I was a kid. In this age where all action and sci-fi movies look and feel like these 'prequels', I find that unlikely, but I can hope.… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

4

Jedi_JettsonJul 16, 2012

The story is alright, but there are several plot holes, the script is bad and wooden, there isn't enough great action but the duel between Obi-Wan, Qui-Gon, and Darth Maul, and the acting is also bad, and Jar Jar Binks is annoying to the StarThe story is alright, but there are several plot holes, the script is bad and wooden, there isn't enough great action but the duel between Obi-Wan, Qui-Gon, and Darth Maul, and the acting is also bad, and Jar Jar Binks is annoying to the Star Wars Universe.… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

4

ZegilgameshDec 29, 2012

Although it's certainly accomplished from a technical level, the characters, dialogue, and story are certainly lacking, and this is a major fall in quality for a Star Wars movie.

2 of 4 users found this helpful22

All this user's reviews

4

ryflemanJan 7, 2012

The lack of story and horrible characters make this into the worst of the saga (although its sequel was not far behind). Jar Jar, medichlorians, and a general lack of any true plot makes for a terrible movie, and the fact that it is Star WarsThe lack of story and horrible characters make this into the worst of the saga (although its sequel was not far behind). Jar Jar, medichlorians, and a general lack of any true plot makes for a terrible movie, and the fact that it is Star Wars and has Liam Neeson as the closest thing to a lead role makes it into an average, albeit mediocre adventure.… Expand

0 of 2 users found this helpful02

All this user's reviews

4

cowbell31Feb 5, 2012

When people say this movie is good, they can't back themselves up with the story, only with the effects. The movie continuously adds on to the characters character, we always question their decisions, and don't understand why anyone doesn'tWhen people say this movie is good, they can't back themselves up with the story, only with the effects. The movie continuously adds on to the characters character, we always question their decisions, and don't understand why anyone doesn't act like a normal person.… Expand

10 of 16 users found this helpful106

All this user's reviews

4

skyminsterMay 21, 2012

Star wars: episode I: the phantom menace is kind of okay. A lot of it is boring politics, but some of it is exciting action. The good: some good action, good music, okay acting (mostly). The bad: boring politics, jar jar binks (I know it's aStar wars: episode I: the phantom menace is kind of okay. A lot of it is boring politics, but some of it is exciting action. The good: some good action, good music, okay acting (mostly). The bad: boring politics, jar jar binks (I know it's a name and names have capitals at the start of them, but this character doesn't deserve a capital.), not much of Darth maul (he's an alright enemy), it's really cheesy.… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

4

Movie1997Dec 22, 2015

Having not experienced Star Wars as a kid, I thought that I should watch all of them starting with "The Phantom Menace". Unfortunately, this did not kick things off to a good start. Right off the bat you get a lame and pathetic story aboutHaving not experienced Star Wars as a kid, I thought that I should watch all of them starting with "The Phantom Menace". Unfortunately, this did not kick things off to a good start. Right off the bat you get a lame and pathetic story about tax federations, weak characters and even worse performances. The visuals are completely overblown and suck you out of the movie. I don't think I need to say anymore about Jar Jar Binks. While I didn't find him to be the biggest abomination in cinema, he does leave a bad taste in the mouth of viewers. But it's a not a flat out terrible movie. There are some great light saber fights (even if they are too well choreographed), and there are even some (not many) but some moments of promise. However it doesn't fulfill the way that it should be use of George Lucas' direction. The problems this movie has are because George Lucas doesn't know how to write characters let alone get real performances out of his actors. You can tell he's more about style than substance. Overall, while not a terrible movie, it's boring storyline and dull characters make "The Phantom Menace" one to simply skip. I'm going to give it a C-!… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

4

InlikeflynnJun 8, 2014

The problems that comes with this movie is that everything lacks grip...

Why are all the characters so dull and boring? I really can't imagine why made everyone so robotic; is hard to describe the characters because of their lack ofThe problems that comes with this movie is that everything lacks grip...

Why are all the characters so dull and boring? I really can't imagine why made everyone so robotic; is hard to describe the characters because of their lack of personality, I just can't imagine the actors in my head trying to play out the lines in the script without any kind of passion in it or maybe the directing was non-existing. The special effects haven't aged well, I can tell that almost everything in this movie is CG and if I look closely I am sure I can find some texture raptures (Although I am not fully sure of that myself)... The general story is so boring that I can guarantee you that you will not care at all about what it's going on, stiff acting and odd concepts for the expansion of the star wars universe.

I can honestly say however that the soundtrack is great; with memorable tunes like "Duel of the Fates" that you won't get out of your head and the well choreographed fight scenes that are just fun to watch. The Phantom Menace has too many flaws to just be a passable flick but it's at least fun to enjoy thanks to it's few saving graces.… Expand

1 of 5 users found this helpful14

All this user's reviews

4

GamingSoldierNov 23, 2014

Phantom Menace isn't as bad as some people make it out to be and it has some really good ideas. Unfortunetely, it fails to live up to it liscense

Pros -Music by John Williams is at best -Despite a weak script, Liam Neeson and NataliePhantom Menace isn't as bad as some people make it out to be and it has some really good ideas. Unfortunetely, it fails to live up to it liscense

Pros
-Music by John Williams is at best
-Despite a weak script, Liam Neeson and Natalie Portman do well with their material
-The pod race is exciting
-Darth Maul leaves the biggest impact a supporting character has left since Boba Fett
-The fight choreography, especially the duel between Obi-Wan, Qui-Gon, and Darth Maul near the end
-Interesting World
-Special effects are well done for the most part

Cons
-Jar Jar Binks
-Any villains that aren't Darth Maul
-Jar Jar Binks
-The Tatooine section drags on forever
-Jar Jar Binks
-Ewan McGregor as Obi-Wan is wasted
-Jar Jar Binks
-Anakin Skywalker is useless to the plot and shouldn't even be a child. Jake Llyod didn't do very well with the material
-DID I MENTION JAR JAR… Expand

1 of 2 users found this helpful11

All this user's reviews

4

jeff_reviewsJul 5, 2013

"Star Wars: Episode 1 The Phantom Menace" suffers alot from its technology, as it seems to a different level than the first films, and it feels odd in the movie's tone with the original trilogy. The movie suffers the most from its story, as"Star Wars: Episode 1 The Phantom Menace" suffers alot from its technology, as it seems to a different level than the first films, and it feels odd in the movie's tone with the original trilogy. The movie suffers the most from its story, as it's not that fresh and deep from the original trilogy, and the story does lag off at parts. The visuals are great, but they sometimes get in the way as its too different from the original trilogy's technology on so many levels. With putting so many characters onto its pallet, the movie doesn't work as it just feels strange with the branches of characters added onto its belt. Overall, it's average, and does suffer a lot when compared and connected with its original trilogy films.… Expand

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

4

AaronWasserman2May 3, 2014

Pathetic and down right embarressing. it barely gets a 4 just for effects, music, and some cool fights. aside from that this movie is BAD. Most people do not count it as part of the saga

2 of 8 users found this helpful26

All this user's reviews

4

Kai82Feb 2, 2020

Honestly nothing in Episode 1 is really important to the trilogy. You can skip this movie and it would actually improve your experience. I am pointing at Jar-Jar and midichlorians (mainly). For details you can read the very good articleHonestly nothing in Episode 1 is really important to the trilogy. You can skip this movie and it would actually improve your experience. I am pointing at Jar-Jar and midichlorians (mainly). For details you can read the very good article “Absolutely no Machete Juggling” by Rod Hilton. He suggests that to get most out of the movies and to avoid spoilers you should watch the movies in the order 4, 5, 2, 3 and 6. His arguments are rock solid and he asked the question: Name something that happen in Episode 1 that enhance the other movies and can not be told in a single dialogue instead? For the movie itself it is underwhelming. The original trilogy was a team effort. George Lucas was not influential and rich enough to do everything as he wanted. He asked for help, listen for advice and made a lot of changes that improved the original movies (There are lots of articles you can read on this topic). For the prequels he had free reign for everything. No person is good at everything. I wont criticizes him for staying true to his vision. I will admit he has not enough talent at writing dialogues. There are many scenes in the prequels that are impressive / working without the dialogue or better said get drag down with it. This all might sound too negative. I really like many things in the movie. The score by John Williams is as always totally awesome. He is a legend. Then I like the new characters Darth Maul (Ray Parks), Qui Gon Jinn (Liam Neeson) and Padme Amidala (Natalie Portman). Ian Mc Diarmid is a fantastical Palpatine. You can see the glimpse of what will come. Also the choreography of the battles is much better. I was stunned how bad the battles of the original trilogy look in comparison. Not kidding. Just rewatch them (It must be a case of nostalgia that improves the memory). Overall while not a failure it was underwhelming and can be forgotten.… Expand

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

4

Jeebus117Jan 25, 2021

Darth Maul and Liam Neeson can't save this movie. The massive shift in tone, as well as the over-animated visuals are just some of the issues. Anakin and Jar Jar are the worst, though.

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

4

MattBrady99May 4, 2020

"There's always a bigger fish."

May the 4th be with you folks.

Remember, even through this movie is extremely boring and disappointing, at least it's not your son.

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

4

MrMovieBuffDec 27, 2015

(I had to review this movie sooner or later, so here it is)

George Lucas returns in the director's chair for 'Star Wars: The Phantom Menace', the highly anticipated space opera prequel that will tell us the story of how the famous Darth(I had to review this movie sooner or later, so here it is)

George Lucas returns in the director's chair for 'Star Wars: The Phantom Menace', the highly anticipated space opera prequel that will tell us the story of how the famous Darth Vader became...Darth Vader.

The movie stars Liam Neeson as Qui Gon Jinn, a legendary Jedi warrior with his accomplice Obi Wan Kenobi (Ewan McGregor) who travel to find a young boy they believe will bring balance to the force and will one day, become a legendary Jedi fighter.

The movie starts with promise, still giving us the iconic crawl text sequence with the iconic theme composed by the great John Williams. Some of the action sequences here do look impressive, as you would expect from a movie made in the late 1990s. We also meet the female protagonist in the movie named Padme (Natalie Portman) who gets on really well with the young Anakin Skywalker (Jake Lloyd) and they seem to have this strange romantic infatuation with one-another. I use the word "strange" simply because Anakin appears to be an eight-year-old boy, and Padme appears as a teenage girl...somewhere along the lines of 13, 14-years-old.

Director, George Lucas, who hasn't directed a well-known feature since "A New Hope" in 1977 clearly has shown how his skills as a filmmaker has somewhat fallen for the nearly 22 years he has taken between directing features. The story is an interesting story as we (mostly "Star Wars" fans) learn how one of the most iconic villains in motion picture history becomes the person we know them to be. Unfortunately, it's the execution of the movie and how the story is being told that comes off as a disappointment, which led many fans to react with outrage and hate towards this movie.

But we need to discuss the elephant in the room, or maybe the Gungan in the room, that is the ever so hated Jar Jar Binks (Ahmed Best). This character has gained some notorious hate because of his voice and antics on screen. Lucas clearly wanted to make a comic relief character similar to that of the Genie in 'Aladdin' (1992), where the jokes and obnoxious behavior would result in laughter, instead, the jokes result in frustration from the audience as we want to know, when will Jar Jar Binks shut up?

There are many moments where we see Binks constantly falling over, screaming, becoming the victim of slapstick, physical comedy and even just getting himself in danger so we could see him do something funny. Unfortunately, he is neither funny nor helpful, the movie wouldn't be any different without him, although, it would be slightly easier to watch.

Another trouble this movie faces is the dialogue, it is very expository where characters such as the legendary Qui Gon Jinn use very long words relating to "Star Wars" things and speaking like he is reciting poetry, or verses from the Bible. There is never a moment where we see the characters speak realistically, or even times where they are not trying to drill in your heads what the movie's plot is. The story execution is so thinly written, Lucas depends on dialogue to help the audience catch up.

The CGI here is the real deal, it is a very lush looking movie, in fact, that is pretty much the reason why it got made. Throughout the 1990s, with films like 'Terminator 2: Judgement Day' (1991) and 'Jurassic Park' (1993) have broke new ground with their almost realistic looking CGI as technology improves, even four years before "The Phantom Menace", an animated film called 'Toy Story' (1995) was released becoming the first ever CG-animated feature film.

We get many scenes where characters are in certain set-pieces standing before other CGI characters in a CGI hall-like room and we get many establishing shots and wide shots to showcase what a great looking movie this is. It is gorgeous and well-made, but that isn't enough to hide a bad script.

All in all, "The Phantom Menace" is only worth watching for the final fight between Obi Wan Kenobi, Qui Gon Jinn and the main antagonist, Darth Maul...this fight scene may look more like dancing due to the unnecessary flips and twirling of the lightsabers like they are batons...but it is pure eye-candy.… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

4

Termin8terMar 4, 2016

It's finally here! The follow-up to Return of the Jedi! It's here, ready to blow everything else out of the water....... Just kidding, this movie is a massive flop. The acting is bad, there is far too much CGI, and Jar Jar Binks is the mostIt's finally here! The follow-up to Return of the Jedi! It's here, ready to blow everything else out of the water....... Just kidding, this movie is a massive flop. The acting is bad, there is far too much CGI, and Jar Jar Binks is the most annoying character in any movie of all time. The one redeeming quality is the awesome lightsabre battles, but they don't last that long. *sigh* Don't bother forcing yourself through this mess.… Expand

1 of 2 users found this helpful11

All this user's reviews

4

MovieManiac83Apr 24, 2015

Things get off to a cold start with the much parodied credit crawl. Where Episode IV goes for the in media res jugular – “It is a time of civil war!” - problems in Episode I are not quite so pressing. Events are “alarming” perhaps, there’sThings get off to a cold start with the much parodied credit crawl. Where Episode IV goes for the in media res jugular – “It is a time of civil war!” - problems in Episode I are not quite so pressing. Events are “alarming” perhaps, there’s certainly plenty of “turmoil” and we all know “taxation” is a thorny issue but the context is clear: like Anakin, this conflict still has some growing up to do. The menace is still phantom.

An inexcusably lazy establishing shot - the Jedi shuttle cruises past the camera - and lethargic opening sequence hardly help pick up the pace. In A New Hope’s famous opening salvo the bad guys fire first and ask questions later, in The Phantom Menace the Jedi are ushered into a meeting room while the semi-bad guys go into video conference with Darth Sidious about whether an invasion of Naboo is legal or not.

This arse-numbing inactivity recurs throughout The Phantom Menace: because the battles lines are not yet drawn and sides are still being taken there is always much explaining to be done, characters are forever having update meetings or being introduced to one another. The plot machinery lumbers through the gears, hampered further by the strange declarative dialogue and by an apparent disinterest in making these scenes visually interesting.

Critics complained that Lucas had got yet worse at writing for humans in the twenty-two years since Star Wars, in fact it is simply that, beyond Alec Guinness talking about the force, the plot of A New Hope requires no exposition - The Phantom Menace on the other hand is all explanation, much of it, like the midichlorians, unwanted and unnecessary. (To be fair, Lucas waited a generation before spoiling his enigmatic myth with background material, the Wachowski’s jumped that particular shark in film two.)

And yet there is still much pleasure to be had watching our full-blown Jedi guides in action. Qui-Gon and Obi-Wan quickly discover that things are mercifully worse than the credit crawl predicted, a robot invasion force is being unpacked, Naboo is under actual threat. Sadly, we never actually see any of the massacres that are apparently taking place, instead we land somewhere that looks suspiciously like the woods near Leavesden and meet one of the galaxy’s more annoying comedy sidekicks (although not as annoying as fans frantically searching for a scapegoat would have you believe). After all, this film has at its hero a small boy – it cannot visit the dark 12A places.

Tatooine turns out to be a total bust. They leave Obi-Wan behind, Amidala pretends to be Padme for no good reason, Anakin whines a lot, there’s some mumbo jumbo about a mystical birth and at absolutely no point does Han Solo turn up. Bastard. This is a section so flabby that even the electrifying pod race goes on for one lap too long.

But hell, we meet Vader Jnr. and he says goodbye to his mother, which is the only essential action of the movie, so it’s almost worth the trip.

Lucas probably imagined that Anakin’s goodbye would be the real heartbreaker but he couldn’t write it and Jake Lloyd couldn’t act it. The irony is, we don’t need it. Given where he is destined to end up, Anakin doesn’t need to be innocence personified when we meet him. Indeed, we are told that the kid is too old to be trained and that the Jedi council fear him, facts that are utterly lost on an audience who see only a bowl-headed brat.

Perhaps best of all, we have the death of Qui-Gon. Liam Neeson has manfully carried the action on his shoulders throughout (the subsequent prequels desperately miss him) and his final words – “Obi-Wan, promise... Promise me you will train the boy” - provide the movie with its only real weight.

And yet if only Lucas could have stopped thinking like a fearful father and acted more like the fearless myth-maker of old, there’s a quick fix that would change everything. Imagine for a moment a street urchin orphaned by the Clone Wars, a scoundrel scamming to survive, already using the force without even realising it. Imagine a cocky fifteen-year old robbing Qui-Gonn, competing with Obi-Wan and flirting with Padme. Imagine, for a second, an Anakin invested with the spirit of a young Han Solo…

The most disappointing film of all time it remains, but with the galaxy of hype now far, far away Menace seems much less of a public menace than it did in the summer of 1999. Alongside the obvious action highs, the ability to consume the saga in a single sitting has created a veritable feast for those fans still keen to mine for irony, with Palpatine’s Shakespearean scheming particularly delectable here.… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews