Manchester by the Sea

9

nvnickJan 4, 2017

I think some people didn't like this film because of "silence" and I usually am one of those people (for example, True Detective season 2). But, here it adds to the film somehow. The film rarely deals with the normal confrontational way dramaI think some people didn't like this film because of "silence" and I usually am one of those people (for example, True Detective season 2). But, here it adds to the film somehow. The film rarely deals with the normal confrontational way drama is presented. We often see the in between moments of the events, or the aftermath - and when paired with excellent acting this made it seem more genuine. There was something about the way it was written and the screenplay, that make the characters more real than those in most other films I've seen.… Expand

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

8

horizonbtsJan 2, 2017

This movie was well acted and well developed. I loved the way it held off giving you the whole story and background. It fed you tiny bits and pieces along the way, to keep you very interested in the main characters. Life can be tragic andThis movie was well acted and well developed. I loved the way it held off giving you the whole story and background. It fed you tiny bits and pieces along the way, to keep you very interested in the main characters. Life can be tragic and hard and this movie captures on that in a big way, and how like a big pill can be hard to swallow, life is that way too. Great movie and great drama, and again well acted!!… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

2

AxeTJan 1, 2017

Sir Alfred Hitchcock once said, "I don't make slices of life pictures. I prefer slices of cake." This is a prime example of why he expressed that sentiment and why he was the Master, and why so many are students of his to this day. TheSir Alfred Hitchcock once said, "I don't make slices of life pictures. I prefer slices of cake." This is a prime example of why he expressed that sentiment and why he was the Master, and why so many are students of his to this day. The filmmakers of this little indie slice of life film are not. Not that there is anything wrong with that, but it is naive not to realize the tenants of suspense apply to all stories and genres, that any good movie needs some form of imagination.
The writer/director here is trying to pass off a lazy, half baked, self indulgent, contrived excuse for a movie that is very slow, dreadfully boring, poorly edited (in the sense of economy of running time), and unevenly acted (at times it's naturalistic and real, while at others it's painfully forced and phony, with Casey Affleck delivering a suitably competent performance but certainly not outstanding by any sane measure)... and the critics just ate it up! They swallowed the pretentious void of story craft and lack of dynamics hook, line and sinker, as the herd on the scent of pretentious art films does, so often mistaking the pretense of art for actual accomplished audience pleasing work, or even difficult opaque but still highly worthy endeavors that require work on the audience's part. This thing is neither. Moviemakers should always work for the audience, not the other way around. That means even with difficult, challenging or disturbing material the work of story craft in a narrative must be done before it's given to the audience. To just throw up on screen some ramblings and musings (no matter how tragic or melancholic) that a screenwriter jacked off on the page and called it a day is no excuse for the lack of quality entertainment or "art" in any genuine sense of the word when it comes to the cinema.

Of course The Academy flock will also delight full course on this unpalatable slice of s--- too. Meanwhile we, those in and who work for the audience, shake our heads in disgust at the obscene deranged over-praise.… Expand

9 of 17 users found this helpful98

All this user's reviews

1

NWGalDec 30, 2016

I went into the theater to see "Manchester By The Sea" with great expectations because of the Golden Globe nominations it received -- best actor, best drama, best director and best screenplay. I'm surprised it received a nomination for bestI went into the theater to see "Manchester By The Sea" with great expectations because of the Golden Globe nominations it received -- best actor, best drama, best director and best screenplay. I'm surprised it received a nomination for best screenplay because too often there is no meaningful dialogue between characters or very little. Music now plays where words used to be. Can't any one write any more. And because of this lack of dialogue, Casey Affleck has little to work with outside of being depressed due to the deaths in the film. This film also has a lot of foul language, too many slow scenes and unnecessary scenes that I wished I could have fast forwarded through or that the director would have cut. The plot is good, but not ever film needs to be edited with meaningless flash backs. I understand why the director edited it like that, but some scenes were unnecessary. Can't writers and directors tell a story in chronological order any more? At least, sometimes. "Manchester By The Sea" isn't a bad story. It's just a film that you should wait to see on DVD, so that you can fast forward through the slow scenes and mute the offense language if necessary.… Expand

0 of 4 users found this helpful04

All this user's reviews

8

RvwFromUpHereDec 30, 2016

Who: Casey Affleck, Heath Ledger's wife, and the Dad from Super 8 as, Joe Chandler
What: A movie that's tag line is essentially, "it's really sad," that isn't all that sad.
Where: That place where Aerosmith came from When (Can I watch again):Who: Casey Affleck, Heath Ledger's wife, and the Dad from Super 8 as, Joe Chandler
What: A movie that's tag line is essentially, "it's really sad," that isn't all that sad.
Where: That place where Aerosmith came from
When (Can I watch again): Whenever you want to watch an Affleck give a great performance instead of saying stupid dialogue, or ruining Batman for everyone
Why: This is an excellent film with great Oscar potential, but I'd be shocked if it actually won.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

10

nutterjrDec 29, 2016

Silence is often the most deafening sound. A loss can trigger the strongest of emotions. And there is nothing louder in this film than the quiet performances of its leads and virtually say everything especially in moments when no words areSilence is often the most deafening sound. A loss can trigger the strongest of emotions. And there is nothing louder in this film than the quiet performances of its leads and virtually say everything especially in moments when no words are exchanged. I watched this one as part of the London Film Festival 2016 and it blew me away for its equal measures of heart, houmor, love, despair and humanity. The casting is superb and deserve to scoop up the awards of the year in a story which even though one can guess from the start what is in its nucleus, we sit and admire the masterful director peel it off to gradually reveal an even richer and more layered core.… Expand

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

3

namelessDec 29, 2016

I so wanted to like this. There is much to like about the story but the editing combined with the director falling in love with the screenplay he wrote, turned it into a cliche of an art film. It is not Gome Baby Gone that Afleck did so well.I so wanted to like this. There is much to like about the story but the editing combined with the director falling in love with the screenplay he wrote, turned it into a cliche of an art film. It is not Gome Baby Gone that Afleck did so well. Definitely watch it, but on cable. It was so excrutiating at times, I so wanted to fast forward. Keeping the camera rolling while nothing happens does not make it deep, it just makes it indulgent. Every scene Michelle Williams is in is incredible. Would she deserve a nomination... YES.… Expand

1 of 7 users found this helpful16

All this user's reviews

10

AquaMorphDec 27, 2016

One of the best written films I have seen in a while. The thing that makes this movie so wonderful is the ambition and range of topics the film covers. It handles several difficult topics in a masterful way. Characters will do odd things thatOne of the best written films I have seen in a while. The thing that makes this movie so wonderful is the ambition and range of topics the film covers. It handles several difficult topics in a masterful way. Characters will do odd things that lead the audience to ask questions then the films answers those questions in a way the enriches the character. The acting is amazing by everyone especially Casey Affleck and the film finds a great balance of humor and somber drama.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

1

traderjoe9Dec 26, 2016

I can't believe viewers rated this movie highly. Although decently acted with adequate cinematography, the story was unredeeming about a man who experienced a significant tragedy but who is given a chance to turn his life around by his olderI can't believe viewers rated this movie highly. Although decently acted with adequate cinematography, the story was unredeeming about a man who experienced a significant tragedy but who is given a chance to turn his life around by his older brother who makes him guardian to his son. The main character is inadequate in dealing with his loss and his opportunity and fails to honor his deceased brother's wishes. We are all familiar with people who are overwhelmed by life's circumstances. We go to the movies to see shining examples of people who surmount these challenges and point the way turning things around. This movie failed.… Expand

1 of 6 users found this helpful15

All this user's reviews

8

BHBarryDec 26, 2016

“Manchester by the Sea” was written and directed by Kenneth Lonergan and stars Casey Affleck, Michelle Williams, Kyle Chandler and newcomer Lucas Hedges. This is a story of sadness and a series of ill-fated events that befall Mr.Affleck’s“Manchester by the Sea” was written and directed by Kenneth Lonergan and stars Casey Affleck, Michelle Williams, Kyle Chandler and newcomer Lucas Hedges. This is a story of sadness and a series of ill-fated events that befall Mr.Affleck’s character, Lee Chandler, who is asked to become the guardian of his young nephew upon the sudden death of Lee’s brother Joe. ‘The performances in this film are noteworthy because they are understated yet immensely powerful as each actor communicates great degrees of emotion without overburdening the scenes with wordy laments. Kudos to the young Mr. Hedges who plays Lee’s nephew as he and his uncle Lee attempt to develop a relationship despite different lifestyles and aspirations. I give the film an 8 rating with a special spotlight on Mr. Affleck whose Oscar nomination seems virtually guaranteed.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

0

jeffreyhDec 26, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. One of the worst movies ever made--boring, stupid, and flatline plot. Who cares about any of these characters? Dull, insipid, tired of limited vocabulary with f---. don't waste time or money on this.… Expand

2 of 7 users found this helpful25

All this user's reviews

9

RobBob99Dec 24, 2016

Once the first twenty minutes passed, I was consistently entranced in the story. In a subdued and nuanced presence, Casey Affleck delivers a master class acting performance which ended up being my favorite male performance of the year.Once the first twenty minutes passed, I was consistently entranced in the story. In a subdued and nuanced presence, Casey Affleck delivers a master class acting performance which ended up being my favorite male performance of the year. Emotionally draining and yet rewarding, Manchester By the Sea is one of the most natural feelings movies of the year along with the best.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

7

Dunlop13Dec 23, 2016

Excellent acting, compelling story, but incredibly dark. Hard to watch tragedy unfold without some part of the story coming back to the light. You will not walk out of this one feeling good. But certainly appreciate the performances.

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

6

AxgrinderDec 22, 2016

This is an extremely dark movie. Critics love it because it doesn’t go for the happy ending. Casey Affleck will likely win an Oscar for Best Actor. Affleck plays an average lower-middle working-class guy living in a small coastal fishingThis is an extremely dark movie. Critics love it because it doesn’t go for the happy ending. Casey Affleck will likely win an Oscar for Best Actor. Affleck plays an average lower-middle working-class guy living in a small coastal fishing town. Michelle Williams (who is probably too pretty to be believable for the part) plays his wife, and they have three young kids. Affleck is a happy guy with zero aspirations in life and spends his free time boating, drinking with his buddies and dabbling in recreational drugs. The movie would have you believe that many people live this kind of life, and that most can get away with living a sloppy and ambitionless life without consequences but, in the dice game of life, Affleck takes a stupid gamble and rolls snake eyes. He becomes a haunted and angry individual who moves to Boston and ekes out a living as a janitor. Several years later, his older brother dies and names Affleck the guardian of his high-school age son. This could have been a movie about redemption. (It’s the obvious ending choice, and you will find yourself hoping for it, rooting for it.) Instead, you get a cautionary tale about broken people. Those who like this movie use a lot of adjectives to describe it like: "heartbreaking, genuine and powerful." It is all those things but, it’s also a movie without hope. The ending is sudden and abrupt like a cold slap in the face, a lump of coal in your Christmas stocking, or discovering the Grinch in your living room instead of Santa Claus. If you're looking for holiday cheer, you might want to go see something else.… Expand

1 of 5 users found this helpful14

All this user's reviews

8

BrianMcCriticDec 21, 2016

A film that gives you feeling of true life pain and anguish. Even as the characters try to suppress their pain you can still feel their grief. The performances are all strong and Casey Affleck has never been better. This is a film I reallyA film that gives you feeling of true life pain and anguish. Even as the characters try to suppress their pain you can still feel their grief. The performances are all strong and Casey Affleck has never been better. This is a film I really wanted to love from all the hype, but instead I really really liked it. A-… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

8

SpangleDec 21, 2016

Utterly devastating. Bleak and unrelenting, Manchester by the Sea is akin to being bludgeoned repeatedly by an axe aimed straight at your heart. Once in a while, a film will come along and leave me in a ball of tears. Films can onlyUtterly devastating. Bleak and unrelenting, Manchester by the Sea is akin to being bludgeoned repeatedly by an axe aimed straight at your heart. Once in a while, a film will come along and leave me in a ball of tears. Films can only accomplish this, however, by putting the audience right alongside the characters and making us feel their pain and agony. Their pain becomes our own and it makes the experience feeling entirely personal. Manchester by the Sea is this kind of film. By the end, Lee Chandler's (Casey Affleck) depression became my own and, as a result, the film left me feeling heavy. Elegantly written, score, and directed, Manchester by the Sea is an operatic and thoroughly depressing film. If you are in a tough spot right now, either this film will be oddly therapeutic or just leave you wallowing in tears.

Anchored by an impeccable lead performance by Casey Affleck, Manchester by the Sea tells the story of Lee Chandler returning home to Manchester to care for his nephew, Patrick (Lucas Hedges). Thrown into guardianship following the death of his brother, Joe (Kyle Chandler), Lee is divorced from his wife Randi (Michelle Williams). Returning home brings up various bad memories for Lee, which makes the journey especially difficult. Suffering from a deep depression before and during his return as a result of these memories, Manchester by the Sea is an examination of the grieving process and how we cope with tragedy. For Lee, he has turned into an emotionally remote man who can hardly converse with anybody else. As he blames himself for his issues, his depression compounds upon itself and leaves him incredibly numb. For Patrick, losing his father only has an impact in quiet moments. Small elements - such as the fact that his father needs to be frozen until Spring when the ground is soft enough to bury him - bother him deeply. Otherwise, he continues on with his life and finds things to keep himself busy. For Randi, she is still deeply shaken by her own actions, rather than what actually happened and how she treated Lee as a result. Both Hedges and Williams are tremendous as well. Hedges truly shines when Patrick has a panic attack. Here, your heart truly breaks and Hedges' raw emotion and authenticity make the scene land even harder. For Williams, she absolutely deserves another Academy Award nomination. She gets very little to chew on, but when given the opportunity in a conversation with Lee, my God. Powerful barely scratches the surface of this scene. Williams is a revelation in this scene and, in one moment, steals the entire film. As a whole though, the acting in Manchester by the Sea is a step above the acting of any other film this year.

In examining grief, Manchester by the Sea takes the varied approaches as described above. Lee cannot get over his grief to the point that he can hardly be in Manchester. Patrick wants to continue to live his life. Randi is grieving the dissolution of her marriage because it did not need to happen. Though hardly profound, the film exemplifies that we all "grieve in our own way". Yet, the masterful element in this portrayal is its division between the sexes. When Lee is down, Joe steps up and cares for him. He shows emotion, yes, but he is in control. His emotion is bottled up and he is solely focused on helping his brother through this ordeal. For Lee, when Joe dies and after his own issues, he bottles it up. His only expression of his internal anger and pain is when he gets into bar fights. Part him needing to find out if he can still feel anything and part venting, these bar fights exemplify the way in which men often internalize their pain. Similarly, Patrick is headed down the same path with few scenes where he lets loose. Otherwise, as mentioned above, he simply goes along with his life of hockey, baseball, band, and his two girlfriends. Things do not alter much for him and, outwardly, he is laughing and as charismatic as he was before. His pain only comes in private when things remind him of his pain. Instead, he seeks distractions and constant chaos (depicted by Lee driving him all over God's green earth without end) in order to cope. Randi, however, has hardly internalized her pain. Instead, she vented at Lee in the past and, now, cried openly before him to express her agony of what went on between the two of them. Not to be too stereotypical, but women are certainly better at expressing their emotions and the film underscores this. When Lee and Patrick are together, there is a mutual understanding that they are both in pain, but neither divulge or open up as to how they are feeling. When Lee is with Randi, you can see how uncomfortable he is with this display of emotion, even if it is what he needed to hear.… Expand

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

10

Rebecca31Dec 18, 2016

Starring Casey Affleck, Michelle Williams and Lucas Hedges. This definitely has Oscars written all over it and for good reason. It's an emotional rollercoaster to say the least that will have you laughing one minute and crying another minute.Starring Casey Affleck, Michelle Williams and Lucas Hedges. This definitely has Oscars written all over it and for good reason. It's an emotional rollercoaster to say the least that will have you laughing one minute and crying another minute. Well I didn't cry but half the cinema sure did. Not an easy watch but it's a fabulous movie all round. I loved the story, I loved the acting and the soundtrack was terrific. Strongly recommended.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

0

morgan12345Dec 17, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. A very depressing movie, not for me. Good acting but I go to the movies to end up feeling good and this movie had the opposite effect on me. The young actors were very good.… Expand

2 of 9 users found this helpful27

All this user's reviews

9

Seymour_MoviesDec 16, 2016

A moving movie that showcased outstanding performances from Affleck and crew (special note to Hedges) by allowing the actors to show off their ability in painfully long (in a good way) and tense screens. Multiple times throughout the movie,A moving movie that showcased outstanding performances from Affleck and crew (special note to Hedges) by allowing the actors to show off their ability in painfully long (in a good way) and tense screens. Multiple times throughout the movie, long takes during difficult scenes highlight the amazing acting by everyone involved. Lonergan flawlessly takes you on a journey that keeps you tense and awkward (in a good way) throughout by exploring extremely dark moments that are lighted by sprinkles of witty and often awkward humor.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

9

TVJerryDec 13, 2016

After the death of his brother, Lee (Casey Affleck) learns that he's been named the guardian of his teenage nephew (Lucas Hedges). This means moving back to his small hometown where he left painful memories behind. This is a sensitive storyAfter the death of his brother, Lee (Casey Affleck) learns that he's been named the guardian of his teenage nephew (Lucas Hedges). This means moving back to his small hometown where he left painful memories behind. This is a sensitive story with loveably gruff characters who have a hard time expressing their feelings and often hurt instead. Affleck and Hedges are powerful in their subtlety and restrained emotions. The script by Kenneth Lonergan is intelligently crafted with eloquently mundane observations, while his authoritative direction is detached, yet sensitive (look for him in a cameo as a man on the street who berates Affleck for his lousy parenting). This compelling drama is impressively skillful and quietly affecting.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

6

EnlilDec 12, 2016

I am not sure what to think about this movie. The acting is generally very good. Michelle Williams sticks out as the real star although Casey Affleck seems to be getting all the hype. Affleck is a great fit for the role. However, he plays theI am not sure what to think about this movie. The acting is generally very good. Michelle Williams sticks out as the real star although Casey Affleck seems to be getting all the hype. Affleck is a great fit for the role. However, he plays the exact same role he plays in all of his movies which makes me wonder about his actual acting capabilities. It's perfect for this movie though. I am concerned that Casey Affleck is like Klaus Kinski or Woody Allen who only can play themselves.
The movie is well shot and has a profound story that's well written. The movie would have been better if it had taken itself a little bit less serious and been sped up a little bit at times, especially in the first half.… Expand

7 of 8 users found this helpful71

All this user's reviews

4

fzaltaDec 11, 2016

I walked into this movie with all the hype in the back of my mind and no idea what the story was. I loved the cinematography - the acting was extraordinary but I found the storyline over the top and kind of overblown melodrama. what broughtI walked into this movie with all the hype in the back of my mind and no idea what the story was. I loved the cinematography - the acting was extraordinary but I found the storyline over the top and kind of overblown melodrama. what brought him to get so drunk? how did he survive the unsurvivable? I felt like they just kept adding reasons to not like Lee (Casey Affleck) while feeling sympathetic to the two ex-wives. I feel like they just wanted to create a Job-like character when in fact he is more of a self-destructive character. What brought him to drink and do drugs? Also - although I love the music overall - the placement of the sound on one speaker over whelmed the dialog and the emotions of the scenes. Anyway - great job by the actors - not so thrilled with the director or the writer's job. Sorry - I left the theater feeling as if I was taken advantaged of.… Expand

1 of 6 users found this helpful15

All this user's reviews

9

moviemitch96Dec 10, 2016

Definitely one of the most real and honest-feeling films I've seen all year! And with performances that are as raw and honest as the overall film itself, this makes for one of the most deeply felt character studies for me this year as well.Definitely one of the most real and honest-feeling films I've seen all year! And with performances that are as raw and honest as the overall film itself, this makes for one of the most deeply felt character studies for me this year as well. The Academy might as well just give Casey Affleck the best actor Oscar right now, because as far as I can tell, no one else this year will likely come anywhere close to his compelling and moving performance that I'd easily rate as his best yet! Michelle Williams and her few brief but worthwhile and hearfelt appearances throughout also served the film well. Sophomore actor Lucas Hedges also delivers a memorable breakthrough performance as well. In addition, the whole film form start to finish had just the right blend of subtle charming and lighthearted moments to support its poignant dramatic story. Writer/director Kenneth Lonergan's screenplay might just be among my favorites this year with its straightforward yet often times quite impactful dialogue spoken from the characters in the film. Overall, simply put, this is without a doubt the most emotional-feeling and even human-feeling film I've seen all year!… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

0

skh33Dec 9, 2016

This is one of the most depressing movies I've ever watched. Well acted, but very, very, very slow, and dark and the opposite of uplifting. It's a feel sad movie. The emotional torture of dealing with horrible life tragedy is wellThis is one of the most depressing movies I've ever watched. Well acted, but very, very, very slow, and dark and the opposite of uplifting. It's a feel sad movie. The emotional torture of dealing with horrible life tragedy is well represented, but watching it for two and a half hours is not fun, nor particularly illuminating.… Expand

2 of 9 users found this helpful27

All this user's reviews

9

TrevorsViewDec 9, 2016

A man and a boy, one an uncle, one a nephew, are engaged in an intimate fishing lesson off the lake on Manchester, Connecticut. This melodic view takes us from here through the uncle’s cold spiritual journey of knowing his place amidst theA man and a boy, one an uncle, one a nephew, are engaged in an intimate fishing lesson off the lake on Manchester, Connecticut. This melodic view takes us from here through the uncle’s cold spiritual journey of knowing his place amidst the chaos of death.

Manchester by the Sea is written and directed by Kenneth Lonergan (Gangs of New York), whose hard work shows in how deep he is willing to dive into the darkest corners of everyone we meet throughout his record of memories. The lonely, depressed, recently divorced plumber we are invited to connect with has a lot coming at him; having lost his brother to cardiac arrest, and now left to be the only one left to take in custody of his now fatherless nephew.

From watching the heartbreaking flashbacks that depict the uncertainty of the plumber’s path, to the humbling, somber performance by Casey Affleck (no tears necessary), all audiences suited for the well-earned R-rating will be greatly moved by its rough depiction of an everyday story within an everyday life.

What makes the chilling power of this deceptively simple story so powerful is the consistently cold feel that Lonergan maintains from start to finish. Being set in the northeast, snow appears all over to reflect the plumber’s state of mind, and the cold is felt all the greater depending on the amount of stress tugging between him and his blood relatives. The screen’s empty starkness takes its time to linger on the quietest of moments, screaming the loudest of internal noises without saying a word.

Manchester by the Sea could have easily taken place anywhere in the world, not necessarily in one particular small town in one particular part of the nation. What makes the Boston-Manchester setting work to its advantage is its subtle handling of the culture, right down to the look, feel, and taste of the area. The much-needed emphasis on father and son bonding through the quietness of fishing bookends the film with the one single image that defines everything valued by the people who live there. Also similar to last year’s big Oscar-winner Spotlight, there is a clear presence of Catholicism guiding the lives of all Bostonians, whether or not they consider themselves religious. They claim that all Catholics are Christian, which is not believed to be entirely true by everyone, nor is it said so in the feature, but it works to the advantage of making the sense of hope they seek after touch much closer to home.

There are plenty of independent features out there that tackle the discomforting subject of family death and custody, but none of them handle it with the same level of detail, humanity, and personal application as Manchester by the Sea. It’s not the feel-good holiday treat you may be looking for this time of year, but considering how family and tragedy essentially go hand-in-hand, Lonergan’s scholarly study on the personal crisis will help countless others in what to do about a similar trauma.

Hence, I encourage all to see this masterful, humbling work when they get the chance to, but not just with anyone, with the relatives they are the closest to. That way, you can walk out of the theater together sharing the tears of your worst and best memories. If more movies had the power to do that, then Hollywood would at last be restored to its former glory.… Expand

1 of 2 users found this helpful11

All this user's reviews

10

AvrilDec 8, 2016

A masterpiece, in every sense of the word. A screenplay has never been this beautifully constructed and executed. Powerfully realistic characterization has never been so enthralling, so spellbinding. A dance so subtle, so beautiful, soA masterpiece, in every sense of the word. A screenplay has never been this beautifully constructed and executed. Powerfully realistic characterization has never been so enthralling, so spellbinding. A dance so subtle, so beautiful, so heartbreaking, you'd never want to stop. Hooray for story telling at its best. Hooray for nuances, pain and beautiful storytelling.… Expand

0 of 4 users found this helpful04

All this user's reviews

7

swingDec 8, 2016

I was really looking forward to this movie because of the hype. Well acted. Well photographed. And interesting story. But it wasn't entertaining for me. I really didn't feel the emotion or the empathy. Not sure why not. It lacked something.

1 of 2 users found this helpful11

All this user's reviews

10

cesgreenDec 6, 2016

Beautiful, very moving movie. Excellent performences and a script that wont left you unmoved. One of the best movies of 2016. Hopefully it wont take too long for the next movie to come.

0 of 2 users found this helpful02

All this user's reviews

9

kathytreeceDec 6, 2016

The movie was not what I expected. I enjoyed the characters, the scenery, and the plot. And Casey Affleck looks and sounds a lot like brother Ben. It was a good value for my money. I found it to be a positive and hopeful movie, despite theThe movie was not what I expected. I enjoyed the characters, the scenery, and the plot. And Casey Affleck looks and sounds a lot like brother Ben. It was a good value for my money. I found it to be a positive and hopeful movie, despite the sadness that some of the characters go through.… Expand

0 of 0 users found this helpful00

All this user's reviews

7

GinaKDec 6, 2016

A wonderfully well-acted film, but it may not be for everyone. It’s a realistic “slice of life” about ordinary people. It is more like last year’s Spotlight or Brooklyn and less like movies that I prefer that are about something extraordinaryA wonderfully well-acted film, but it may not be for everyone. It’s a realistic “slice of life” about ordinary people. It is more like last year’s Spotlight or Brooklyn and less like movies that I prefer that are about something extraordinary – last year’s 45 Years, Carol, or this year’s Nocturnal Animals. It also is a long film although I was never bored and didn’t fall asleep. I hope this review helps because if you go to a film for excitement or to see something extraordinary, this film may be too “low key” for you although you may not regret seeing it.… Expand

0 of 4 users found this helpful04

All this user's reviews

0

ckmontDec 5, 2016

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. If you love "feel good" movies, you might want to skip this one. There is no resolve or happy ending. This is the real, raw, and brutal reality of life after horrendous tragedy. Kenneth Longergan, the director and screenwriter, brilliantly articulates the void of life after insufferable and incurable tragedy. It may have been a crowd pleasure to write an ending where his nephew brings back the spark of life, but I found it more authentic to end it the way that Kenneth did. Casey Affleck's character, Lee, mentally imprisons himself for his past mistakes since the law will not do it for him. He deprives himself of every form of human connection or indulgence; going through the motions of life without fully living. This is a story of tragedy without healing. Casey Affleck's incredible ability to convey the long drawn affects of grief is Oscar worthy.… Expand

3 of 10 users found this helpful37

All this user's reviews

6

BeeceeDec 5, 2016

This is a movie about a man with a volatile temper who is haunted by his past (we find out why towards the end of the movie). Since the main character and the teenaged nephew who has the main secondary role are not immediately sympatheticThis is a movie about a man with a volatile temper who is haunted by his past (we find out why towards the end of the movie). Since the main character and the teenaged nephew who has the main secondary role are not immediately sympathetic characters, the film needs to keep the filmgoers interested with the plot and the personal growth of the characters. Unfortunately, Casey Affleck never really experiences any personal growth, and ends the film the same as he started. Matthew Broderick is totally wasted in a cameo role. The scenery is beautiful, but the film is way too slow moving.… Expand

6 of 9 users found this helpful63

All this user's reviews

1

stevenkDec 4, 2016

Superb. Oscar worthy film .acting, dialogue, screenplay, cinematography all superb. A realistic film about dealing with grief and loss and being human.
Uplifting without being saccharin.

0 of 6 users found this helpful06

All this user's reviews

8

ReginthornDec 2, 2016

Manchester by the Sea is objectively one of the best Oscar bait movies I have seen. The acting is grounded and always character consistent. The character consistency is the key to the overall film’s success. Kenneth Lonergan’s directorialManchester by the Sea is objectively one of the best Oscar bait movies I have seen. The acting is grounded and always character consistent. The character consistency is the key to the overall film’s success. Kenneth Lonergan’s directorial accomplishment is utilized to anchor moments that might otherwise be drama cliche. The character consistency would, of course, be an even more impossible task without an excellent cast. Casey Affleck will undoubtedly get the quarterback like attention at the Oscars. What that comment means is I failed to see a single bad performance from the rest of the cast. For narrative, the contemplative structure allows the viewer a chance of gaining character insight without letting moments explicitly define the players. A tragic event will occur and a given scene only allows a character minor fallout before a transition in time. The cinematography is fine with an excellent focus on the little quirks one might find in a small New England town. In addition, the blend of cinematography and location lends to the rare cinematic experience of a story feeling like it came from a genuine place. Manchester is an uncomfortable film when it comes to dishing out any form of conclusion. The result is a narrative more in line with postmodern sensibilities. The ending can easily be dismissed as a typical indie climax. However, the conclusion is anything but a simple artistic gimmick. Seeing the ending as a gimmick robs rewarding the narrative of its logical continuation. In fact, I daresay Manchester by the Sea contains one of the year's best movie endings. To summarize, the butterfly-like effect of grief is the central theme I pinned down. The question, "Do I deserve forgiveness?" is also asked. I can’t say I admired the film as much on a personal level. The film contained a lot of scenes which were a little long for my taste. Additionally, the movie works better as an example of fine filmmaking over anything I can take with me in life. Many people will see the film as a relatable experience but nothing more. I am curious as to how long the movie will stay in the minds of the average viewer. Definitely, see the film for its cinematic accomplishments.… Expand

2 of 4 users found this helpful22

All this user's reviews

4

GreatMartinDec 2, 2016

"Manchester by the Sea" asks how do you survive an unimaginable tragedy?? People handle it in different ways and Lee (Casey Affleck) becomes a totally cold, uncaring person who cuts himself off from all those he loves, leaves his hometown,"Manchester by the Sea" asks how do you survive an unimaginable tragedy?? People handle it in different ways and Lee (Casey Affleck) becomes a totally cold, uncaring person who cuts himself off from all those he loves, leaves his hometown, gets a job as a janitor in Boston, drinks a lot of beer and has fights in bars.

The first hour of the film deals with Lee before and after the tragedy, how he was a happy man, father, husband, brother and friend before he became the loner he is now. After his brother, Joe, (Kyle Chandler) dies, he comes home to find out that Joe has appointed Lee the guardian of his 16 year old nephew Patrick (Lucas Hedges) who in many ways is a typical teenager but is acting out upon the death of his father. At this point the director/screenwriter, Kenneth Lonergan, tells us what the tragedy was and it is almost to painful for the audience to hear and watch. For the next hour and 17 minutes we see how uncle and nephew interact and deal with life, Patrick with humor and sarcasm, Lee without emotions and staying as uninvolved as he can stay. We meet Patrick's mother Elise (Gretchen Mol) who has been out of his life for years, her new husband Jefferey (Matthew Broderick) Lee's ex-business partner and friend George (C. J. Wilson) but most important of all Lee's ex-wife, Randi (Michelle Williams).

While Affleck is getting all the attention in the reviews I was more impressed with 20 year old Lucas Hedges as the 16 year old who can break your heart and a second later having you laugh. Affleck does a strong job especially since most of his scenes have to be done in a monotone, showing no emotion and fighting the pull his nephew on has him as a human being.

Michelle Williams has a very emotional scene, lasting about 5 minutes, with Casey Affleck but as easily as I am moved in a movie's emotionally scenes, this didn't move me.

Gretchen Mol is wasted and Matthew Broderick has a very thankless part. The rest of the supporting players including Patrick's main girlfriend played by Anna Baryshnikov are all above par.

I love heavy, family, movie dramas but the bottom line is that "Manchester by the Sea" is way too long by 15-20 minutes which doesn't make for very much tension and though the scenery of Manchester by the Sea is excellent in all the seasons and there is no fault with the acting I don't recommend it.

Oh, yes, a very distracting soundtrack that more than once takes you out of the story.… Expand

3 of 5 users found this helpful32

All this user's reviews

10

tylerdillNov 30, 2016

I don't think I've ever seen a film nearly as 'human' as this. Every single performance in this movie is astounding, nothing comes across fake, or even acted. Such a fantastic movie, it is a damned shame this movie is not a wide release. IfI don't think I've ever seen a film nearly as 'human' as this. Every single performance in this movie is astounding, nothing comes across fake, or even acted. Such a fantastic movie, it is a damned shame this movie is not a wide release. If you have the chance to see this movie, do.… Expand

6 of 7 users found this helpful61

All this user's reviews

10

netflicNov 27, 2016

Critics love this movie, and I expected something good.
But I was not ready for this. The film surpassed all my expectations.
Directing, acting, cinematography, script, attention to details. Superb! In my opinion, this movie is by far theCritics love this movie, and I expected something good.
But I was not ready for this. The film surpassed all my expectations.
Directing, acting, cinematography, script, attention to details. Superb!
In my opinion, this movie is by far the best this year.
I hope it will win Oscar in February.

Directed by Kenneth Lonergan.
Main character Lee Chandler played by Casey Affleck.
Another stellar performance is of his ex-wife Randi played by Michelle Williams.… Expand

2 of 4 users found this helpful22

All this user's reviews

10

saintsfan1255Nov 25, 2016

I have never cried and laughed at the same time in a film, however, there is a first time for everything. Kenneth Lonergan's Manchester by the Sea is easily the best film this year. I guess I should start with the acting, which is also theI have never cried and laughed at the same time in a film, however, there is a first time for everything. Kenneth Lonergan's Manchester by the Sea is easily the best film this year. I guess I should start with the acting, which is also the best this year. Casey Affleck shines in his role as Lee, a grieving uncle/brother with a dark past. I am not one who can see the future but I can easily say that Affleck will be getting a best actor nomination if not win best actor. Among the other future nominees, Lucas Hedges is a welcome surprise in his role as Patrick, Lee's nephew. Finally, Michelle Williams will probably be getting a best supporting actress nomination in her role as Randie. The acting in this film is impeccable and it definitely helps it destroy you emotionally. Another stand out is the writing, people are probably saying that this is the saddest film this year but they forget the fact that the film has a lot of humor. The humor is very unique in that its a stinging humor, every joke has an insult behind it (which is great). The direction and the cinematography is amazing and really adds to the amazing sense of place that this film has. You can really tell where you are (I don't really know how to explain it but it's good). Overall, this film is unlike many that are made these days. It doesn't spoon feed you exposition, it lets you come to conclusions on your own and it is very rewarding. Also, the film doesn't have a linear storyline yet it all makes sense. And like life, it doesn't have some perfect ending where everyone's happy, it is real and it feels as such. In closing, it would be a disservice to oneself not to see this movie because it is unequivocally the best film this year.… Expand

2 of 4 users found this helpful22

All this user's reviews

7

Brent_MarchantNov 25, 2016

A moderately entertaining character study with relatively profound explorations of issues like redemption, forgiveness and understanding one's limitations. But it's also often an exercise in taking itself way too seriously, with more than aA moderately entertaining character study with relatively profound explorations of issues like redemption, forgiveness and understanding one's limitations. But it's also often an exercise in taking itself way too seriously, with more than a few pregnant pauses, lingering shots of mugging emoting and throwaway slice-of-life sequences. Casey Affleck and Lucas Hedges turn in capable but overrated performances, though Michelle Williams steals the show with what should be an Oscar-winning supporting portrayal. Enjoy this one, but don't get taken in by the hype.… Expand

2 of 4 users found this helpful22

All this user's reviews

0

Gala7777Nov 24, 2016

The film is pathetic. Dragging on, pretending to portray real feelings, this film is neither real nor (good) fiction. It is sentimentality on its lowest level with no real educational sense either. As far as the script, in one instant, theThe film is pathetic. Dragging on, pretending to portray real feelings, this film is neither real nor (good) fiction. It is sentimentality on its lowest level with no real educational sense either. As far as the script, in one instant, the creators didn't know how to get out of the drag, so they just turned the page, changed the music to a happy sound, just to fall right back into near senseless depression, and end the film on meaningless nothingness. How can other film critics not see the worthlessness of this 2.5 hour-waste-of-time? Perhaps, they are afraid not to get free tickets next time around.… Expand

5 of 32 users found this helpful527

All this user's reviews

10

ScarlettMiNov 23, 2016

I left this movie wanting to find an Oscar to immediately hand over to Casey Affleck. His restrained but deeply moving performance has easily been one of my favorites of the year. The movie is filled with impressive acting from everyoneI left this movie wanting to find an Oscar to immediately hand over to Casey Affleck. His restrained but deeply moving performance has easily been one of my favorites of the year. The movie is filled with impressive acting from everyone involved, but I feel like so much of it hinges on his ability to make his character's quietest and stillest moments say so much.

The movie is a powerful exploration of grief that works so well because it remembers that people don't stop making sarcastic comments and stupid jokes when things are awful. It's the humor that makes the sadness more genuine and affecting, because the characters feel more human and real.

It's one of my favorite films of the year.… Expand

16 of 19 users found this helpful163

All this user's reviews

10

adzjonesNov 21, 2016

Film is INCREDIBLE!!! Casey Affleck and Michelle Williams are heartbreakingly moving and stunning! Gonna be a long but fruitful awards season I think for them!! Whole cast and overall picture are a MUST SEE!

5 of 5 users found this helpful50

All this user's reviews

10

kn55544Nov 21, 2016

mindblowing. Lonergan's amazing writing is paired with astounding performances from the actors. Definitely gonna be remembered for many years to come.

4 of 6 users found this helpful42

All this user's reviews

9

nickdrakeNov 20, 2016

Worth seeing twice, in my opinion. I left the theater feeling a bit underwhelmed after first seeing it, but I went back the next night and felt I better understood why it garnered such overwhelming praise. Affleck's performance is trulyWorth seeing twice, in my opinion. I left the theater feeling a bit underwhelmed after first seeing it, but I went back the next night and felt I better understood why it garnered such overwhelming praise. Affleck's performance is truly remarkable; again, I couldn't appreciate it as much the first time I saw it, but after developing a better understanding of the character (don't want to reveal anything), I appreciated how challenging of a performance it was for Casey. The film is raw and visceral, and really offers an interesting perspective on the grieving process and the effects it can have on a person.… Expand

5 of 5 users found this helpful50

All this user's reviews

Manchester by the Sea

User Reviews